Summary
The developers.sap.com site now hosts its own Streamable-HTTP MCP server (/mcp/search, /mcp/homepage, /mcp/graph, plus /mcp-auth and /mcp-pat), backed by the CAP/HANA platform that owns the tutorial, mission, news, video, KG, and per-user progress data.
Several tools in this CLI's local sap-devs mcp serve duplicate that functionality by reading a synced content index or by scraping external APIs (YouTube RSS, Community RSS, GitHub raw markdown). In each case the hosted server is the authoritative, always-fresh source. We should convert these local tools to delegate to the hosted developers.sap.com MCP (proxy/forward) rather than maintain a divergent local implementation, or deprecate them where the hosted tool fully supersedes them.
Tier 1 tools to migrate
| Local tool(s) |
Hosted equivalent |
Why hosted wins |
search_tutorials |
search_tutorials (/mcp/search) |
Local searches a ~1,200-entry synced index that goes stale between syncs; hosted is authoritative full-text over published HANA content. |
get_tutorial_step, get_tutorial_image |
get_tutorial_step + tutorial:// resource (/mcp/search) |
Local re-fetches raw GitHub markdown and parses client-side → drifts from the published render; hosted serves canonical rendered HTML/images from HANA. |
update_tutorial_progress, get_tutorial_progress, list_active_tutorials |
complete_step, reset_tutorial_progress, get_my_tutorials, get_my_completed_steps (/mcp-auth, /mcp-pat) |
Local progress is a per-machine DataDir file, not cross-device; the platform keys progress to the SAP universal ID server-side. |
recommend_tutorials |
get_my_recommended_tutorials / get_my_recommended_missions |
Hosted has the persona ranker + KG PageRank; local matches pack refs against the stale index. |
get_recent_news |
get_recent_news (/mcp/homepage) |
Local scrapes YouTube + Community RSS (fragile); hosted's HomepageService aggregates this authoritatively. |
search_videos |
get_recent_videos (/mcp/homepage) |
Same scrape-vs-owned-data argument (partial — hosted currently surfaces only homepage videos). |
Design notes
- Progress/recommendation tools require auth — delegate via OAuth (
mcp-remote pre-registered client_id) or a PAT (/mcp-pat/api), per the hosted MCP quickstart.
- Read-only tools (
search_tutorials, get_tutorial_step, news, videos) hit the anonymous /mcp/* namespace — no credentials needed.
- Keep the tools structurally local:
check_tools, check_project, cf_*, btp_* inspect the workstation and cannot move.
- Consider a config flag to fall back to the local implementation when offline / when the hosted endpoint is unreachable.
Out of scope
Tier 2 (add search_events public catalog + get_news_detail to the hosted server) is tracked on the developers.sap.com/tutorials-ims side, not here.
Summary
The developers.sap.com site now hosts its own Streamable-HTTP MCP server (
/mcp/search,/mcp/homepage,/mcp/graph, plus/mcp-authand/mcp-pat), backed by the CAP/HANA platform that owns the tutorial, mission, news, video, KG, and per-user progress data.Several tools in this CLI's local
sap-devs mcp serveduplicate that functionality by reading asynced content index or by scraping external APIs (YouTube RSS, Community RSS, GitHub raw markdown). In each case the hosted server is the authoritative, always-fresh source. We should convert these local tools to delegate to the hosted developers.sap.com MCP (proxy/forward) rather than maintain a divergent local implementation, or deprecate them where the hosted tool fully supersedes them.Tier 1 tools to migrate
search_tutorialssearch_tutorials(/mcp/search)get_tutorial_step,get_tutorial_imageget_tutorial_step+tutorial://resource (/mcp/search)update_tutorial_progress,get_tutorial_progress,list_active_tutorialscomplete_step,reset_tutorial_progress,get_my_tutorials,get_my_completed_steps(/mcp-auth,/mcp-pat)DataDirfile, not cross-device; the platform keys progress to the SAP universal ID server-side.recommend_tutorialsget_my_recommended_tutorials/get_my_recommended_missionsget_recent_newsget_recent_news(/mcp/homepage)search_videosget_recent_videos(/mcp/homepage)Design notes
mcp-remotepre-registeredclient_id) or a PAT (/mcp-pat/api), per the hosted MCP quickstart.search_tutorials,get_tutorial_step, news, videos) hit the anonymous/mcp/*namespace — no credentials needed.check_tools,check_project,cf_*,btp_*inspect the workstation and cannot move.Out of scope
Tier 2 (add
search_eventspublic catalog +get_news_detailto the hosted server) is tracked on the developers.sap.com/tutorials-ims side, not here.