From 5921e47f2314fc288c6928422503c737618e6e72 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Fri, 18 Sep 2026 20:43:44 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] README: replace \operatorname with \mathrm in equations GitHub's KaTeX renderer does not allow \operatorname; it rendered as literal text with a warning. \mathrm{logit} and \mathrm{Var} render the same way and are supported. --- README.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index d9e8254..99253dc 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -87,7 +87,7 @@ Two consequences follow directly. each factor gives an i.i.d. Bernoulli(p′) process with $$ -\operatorname{logit} p' \;=\; \operatorname{logit} p \;-\; \lambda, +\mathrm{logit}\, p' \;=\; \mathrm{logit}\, p \;-\; \lambda, \qquad p' \;=\; \frac{p\,e^{-\lambda}}{1-p\,(1-e^{-\lambda})}. $$ @@ -162,7 +162,7 @@ The moments of this compound geometric sum are $$ \langle T'\rangle = \frac{1-p'}{p'}\,\mu_C + \mu_S, \qquad -\operatorname{Var}T' = \frac{1-p'}{p'}\,\sigma_C^2 + \frac{1-p'}{p'^2}\,\mu_C^2 + \sigma_S^2 . +\mathrm{Var}\,T' = \frac{1-p'}{p'}\,\sigma_C^2 + \frac{1-p'}{p'^2}\,\mu_C^2 + \sigma_S^2 . $$ As p′ → 0 the second term dominates, CV → 1, and p′T′/μ_C converges in distribution From a7aa988f772ec427c6fc4d5635d4382e711e1b20 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Fri, 18 Sep 2026 20:48:02 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] README: remove backslash-punctuation spacing macros from equations GitHub's markdown preprocessor applies CommonMark backslash-escaping (any ASCII punctuation may be backslash-escaped) even inside $$ ... $$ blocks, before the math is handed to KaTeX. \; \, and \! are backslash followed by punctuation, so the backslash was silently consumed, leaving literal ';', ',' and '!' characters in the rendered equations (e.g. 'k_UF;=;...'). Word-based commands (\mathrm, \text, \Big, \left, \qquad, ...) are backslash + letters and are unaffected, which is why only the thin-space macros broke. Fix: drop \; \, \! from all equations and rely on KaTeX's default operator spacing (whitespace is otherwise insignificant in math mode, so removing them does not change layout). Two cosmetic leftover spaces inside exponents tidied. --- README.md | 284 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++--------------------------- 1 file changed, 142 insertions(+), 142 deletions(-) diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 99253dc..363bc4d 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -26,7 +26,7 @@ This is the decomposition used in transition interface sampling and forward-flux sampling [2, 3]: $$ -k_{UF} \;=\; \Phi_{U,Q^\ddagger}\;\cdot\;P(Q_f \mid Q^\ddagger), +k_{UF} = \Phi_{U,Q^\ddagger} \cdot P(Q_f \mid Q^\ddagger), $$ the flux of attempts through Q‡ times the probability that an attempt reaches F @@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ before returning to U. Per trajectory we record the number of failed attempts k_ and the folding time T_i. The model success probability per attempt is estimated as $$ -\hat p \;=\; \frac{N_\text{done}}{N_\text{done} + \sum_i k_i}. +\hat p = \frac{N_\text{done}}{N_\text{done} + \sum_i k_i}. $$ --- @@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ $$ variables. The reference path measure factorises as $$ -P(\omega) \;=\; P(\omega \mid Y)\,P(Y),\qquad P(Y)=\prod_j p^{s_j}(1-p)^{1-s_j}, +P(\omega) = P(\omega \mid Y) P(Y),\qquad P(Y)=\prod_j p^{s_j}(1-p)^{1-s_j}, $$ where Y = (s_1, s_2, …) is the sequence of attempt outcomes (s_j = 1 for success). @@ -63,8 +63,8 @@ constraints, the one closest to a reference measure P. "Closest" means minimum relative path entropy (Kullback–Leibler divergence): $$ -\min_{P'}\; \sum_\omega P'(\omega)\ln\frac{P'(\omega)}{P(\omega)} -\quad\text{s.t.}\quad \langle g(Y)\rangle_{P'} = G,\;\; \sum_\omega P'(\omega)=1 . +\min_{P'} \sum_\omega P'(\omega)\ln\frac{P'(\omega)}{P(\omega)} +\quad\text{s.t.}\quad \langle g(Y)\rangle_{P'} = G, \sum_\omega P'(\omega)=1 . $$ Take as constraint the mean number of successful crossings in a fixed number of @@ -72,27 +72,27 @@ attempts, g(Y) = Σ_j s_j. This fixes the crossing flux, i.e. the barrier. The Lagrangian solution is the exponential tilt $$ -P'(\omega) \;=\; \frac{1}{Z}\,P(\omega)\,e^{-\lambda\, g(Y)} . +P'(\omega) = \frac{1}{Z} P(\omega) e^{-\lambda g(Y)} . $$ Two consequences follow directly. 1. **Conditionals are untouched.** Because the tilt depends on ω only through Y, - P'(ω | Y) = P(ω | Y). Given the outcome of each attempt, the dwell times, excursion - shapes and structures are exactly those of the model. This is assumption (A2) - derived as the least-biased choice rather than postulated. + P'(ω | Y) = P(ω | Y). Given the outcome of each attempt, the dwell times, excursion + shapes and structures are exactly those of the model. This is assumption (A2) + derived as the least-biased choice rather than postulated. 2. **The outcome process stays Bernoulli, with shifted log-odds.** For an i.i.d. - Bernoulli reference, the tilt e^{-λ Σ s_j} factorises over attempts. Normalising - each factor gives an i.i.d. Bernoulli(p′) process with + Bernoulli reference, the tilt e^{-λ Σ s_j} factorises over attempts. Normalising + each factor gives an i.i.d. Bernoulli(p′) process with $$ -\mathrm{logit}\, p' \;=\; \mathrm{logit}\, p \;-\; \lambda, +\mathrm{logit} p' = \mathrm{logit} p - \lambda, \qquad -p' \;=\; \frac{p\,e^{-\lambda}}{1-p\,(1-e^{-\lambda})}. +p' = \frac{p e^{-\lambda}}{1-p (1-e^{-\lambda})}. $$ - The Lagrange multiplier λ is therefore the shift in log-odds per attempt. + The Lagrange multiplier λ is therefore the shift in log-odds per attempt. **Detailed balance and ΔG.** Counting crossings in both directions tilts U→F and F→U attempts by the same factor. In the rare-event limit both rates scale by the same @@ -105,16 +105,16 @@ probability (1−p)^k p. Under the tilt it has (1−p′)^k p′. The likelihood therefore $$ -w_\text{done}(k) \;\propto\; \Big(\tfrac{1-p'}{1-p}\Big)^{k}\,\frac{p'}{p} -\;=\; c^{\,k+1}\,e^{-\lambda}, +w_\text{done}(k) \propto \Big(\tfrac{1-p'}{1-p}\Big)^{k} \frac{p'}{p} += c^{k+1} e^{-\lambda}, $$ and for a censored trajectory with k failures and no success $$ -w_\text{cens}(k) \;\propto\; c^{\,k}, +w_\text{cens}(k) \propto c^{k}, \qquad -c \;=\; \frac{1}{1-p\,(1-e^{-\lambda})}. +c = \frac{1}{1-p (1-e^{-\lambda})}. $$ These are the weights computed by `log_weights`. The unit test @@ -148,8 +148,8 @@ Under (A1) and the conditional invariance of §2.2, a tilted first-passage time sampled directly. Draw $$ -K \sim \text{Geom}(p') \;\;(\text{failures}),\qquad -T' \;=\; \sum_{j=1}^{K} C_j \;+\; S, +K \sim \text{Geom}(p') (\text{failures}),\qquad +T' = \sum_{j=1}^{K} C_j + S, $$ where each C_j is resampled from the pool of observed cycles ("return to U → end of @@ -160,9 +160,9 @@ it contains the relaxation from the starting structures. The moments of this compound geometric sum are $$ -\langle T'\rangle = \frac{1-p'}{p'}\,\mu_C + \mu_S, +\langle T'\rangle = \frac{1-p'}{p'} \mu_C + \mu_S, \qquad -\mathrm{Var}\,T' = \frac{1-p'}{p'}\,\sigma_C^2 + \frac{1-p'}{p'^2}\,\mu_C^2 + \sigma_S^2 . +\mathrm{Var} T' = \frac{1-p'}{p'} \sigma_C^2 + \frac{1-p'}{p'^2} \mu_C^2 + \sigma_S^2 . $$ As p′ → 0 the second term dominates, CV → 1, and p′T′/μ_C converges in distribution @@ -185,11 +185,11 @@ Evidence for two-state behaviour must come from quantities that thinning cannot manufacture: - **Attempt independence.** Test whether the observed k_i follow a geometric - distribution (χ² test) and whether successive cycle durations are uncorrelated - (lag-1 Spearman correlation). + distribution (χ² test) and whether successive cycle durations are uncorrelated + (lag-1 Spearman correlation). - **Timescale separation.** Compare the relaxation time within U with the cycle time. - **Committor.** Check that committor values on the transition-state surface are - peaked around 1/2 [10, 11]. + peaked around 1/2 [10, 11]. ### 2.7 Interpretation of λ @@ -226,18 +226,18 @@ of exponential statistics follows Salvalaglio *et al.* [16]. ## 3. Statistics used - **Survival function.** Weighted Kaplan–Meier estimator [17], handling censored - trajectories. Weights act as frequency weights: a weight of 2 is equivalent to - duplicating a trajectory, which is unit-tested. + trajectories. Weights act as frequency weights: a weight of 2 is equivalent to + duplicating a trajectory, which is unit-tested. - **Exponential fit.** Maximum-likelihood time constant with censoring, - τ̂ = Σ w_i T_i / Σ w_i δ_i, where δ_i = 1 for completed trajectories. + τ̂ = Σ w_i T_i / Σ w_i δ_i, where δ_i = 1 for completed trajectories. - **Exponentiality test.** Kolmogorov–Smirnov statistic against an exponential with - a fitted scale. Because the scale is estimated, standard KS p-values are - anti-conservative. The null distribution is simulated once per sample size - (Lilliefors [18]); it is scale-free. + a fitted scale. Because the scale is estimated, standard KS p-values are + anti-conservative. The null distribution is simulated once per sample size + (Lilliefors [18]); it is scale-free. - **Uncertainty.** Nonparametric bootstrap over trajectories [19] gives confidence - intervals on λ*. + intervals on λ*. - **Stitching test power.** The stitched sample is subsampled to the original N - before testing, so the test has the same power as on the original data. + before testing, so the test has the same power as on the original data. --- @@ -246,8 +246,8 @@ of exponential statistics follows Salvalaglio *et al.* [16]. ```bash git clone git@github.com:multi-ego/MaxCal.git cd MaxCal -pip install -e ".[test]" # installs the maxcal-poisson and maxcal-joint commands -pytest -q # fast tests; add --runslow for the validation tests +pip install -e ".[test]" # installs the maxcal-poisson and maxcal-joint commands +pytest -q # fast tests; add --runslow for the validation tests ``` The scripts can also be run directly with `python maxcal_poisson.py ...`. @@ -258,7 +258,7 @@ using the test datasets: - the reweighting weights, their saturation, and the resulting CV and N_eff; - stitching and the emergence of Poisson statistics; - validation against a simulated higher barrier, including what goes wrong with Q‡ - on the barrier top; + on the barrier top; - the joint-mode checks (kinetic ΔG, transition-path symmetry across temperatures). ```bash @@ -273,7 +273,7 @@ committed outputs: ```bash python maxcal_poisson.py "runs/q_*.xvg" --qu 0.3 --qf 0.8 \ - --qts 0.40 --qtse 0.55 --out results + --qts 0.40 --qtse 0.55 --out results ``` Input files contain either one column (Q; give `--dt`) or two columns (time, Q). @@ -293,8 +293,8 @@ Lines starting with `#` or `@` are ignored, so GROMACS `.xvg` files work directl **Outputs** - `summary.csv`: one row per Q‡, with p̂, geometric-test p, lag-1 correlation, CV, - KS p-values, λ* with bootstrap CI, N_eff, stitching threshold, and - `cv_stitch0`/`ksp_stitch0` (stitching at λ = 0). + KS p-values, λ* with bootstrap CI, N_eff, stitching threshold, and + `cv_stitch0`/`ksp_stitch0` (stitching at λ = 0). - `tse_frames_*.csv`: TSE frame per completed trajectory, with its weight. **Status columns.** Every NaN in `summary.csv` comes with a reason code, so it can be @@ -311,11 +311,11 @@ told apart from a failure of the code. **Reading the results** 1. If `geom_p` < α, attempts have memory. Poisson statistics after tilting are then - imposed, not recovered. + imposed, not recovered. 2. If stitching at λ = 0 already passes, the original deviation from Poisson was the - initial relaxation, not the barrier. + initial relaxation, not the barrier. 3. If CV ≥ 1 at λ = 0, a missing barrier does not explain the deviation; look for - intermediates or parallel pathways. + intermediates or parallel pathways. 4. Only Q‡ values on the U side of the barrier region are meaningful (§2.8). --- @@ -323,38 +323,38 @@ told apart from a failure of the code. ## 5. Tests ```bash -pytest -q tests/ # 46 fast tests (~8 s) -pytest -q tests/ --runslow # + 13 validation tests and the demo notebook (~25 s) -MAXCAL_UPDATE_REF=1 pytest tests/test_regtest.py # regenerate the reference +pytest -q tests/ # 46 fast tests (~8 s) +pytest -q tests/ --runslow # + 13 validation tests and the demo notebook (~25 s) +MAXCAL_UPDATE_REF=1 pytest tests/test_regtest.py # regenerate the reference ``` - **`test_unit.py`**: parsing, attempt counting, tilt identities (§2.2–2.4), - Kaplan–Meier, KS/Lilliefors size and power, geometric test, stitching moments - (§2.5), and I/O. + Kaplan–Meier, KS/Lilliefors size and power, geometric test, stitching moments + (§2.5), and I/O. - **`test_regtest.py`**: full command-line run on 100 seeded overdamped Langevin - trajectories, compared with `tests/regtest/reference_summary.csv`. Deterministic - columns use rtol 1e-5; RNG-dependent stitching columns use loose absolute - tolerances. + trajectories, compared with `tests/regtest/reference_summary.csv`. Deterministic + columns use rtol 1e-5; RNG-dependent stitching columns use loose absolute + tolerances. - **`test_reweight_path.py`**: end-to-end test of the path where reweighting - succeeds, which the Langevin data never reach. It uses hand-built trajectories - (`tests/synthetic.py`) in which the weighted CV crosses 1 at λ* ≈ 1.1 with - N_eff ≈ 115. It checks that: - - λ* is finite and bracketed by its bootstrap confidence interval; - - N_eff and the KS p-value at λ* are finite; - - the weighted CV equals 1 at λ*; - - the TSE weight ratio between trajectories with 3 and 0 failures is exactly c³; - - every NaN has the right reason code. + succeeds, which the Langevin data never reach. It uses hand-built trajectories + (`tests/synthetic.py`) in which the weighted CV crosses 1 at λ* ≈ 1.1 with + N_eff ≈ 115. It checks that: + - λ* is finite and bracketed by its bootstrap confidence interval; + - N_eff and the KS p-value at λ* are finite; + - the weighted CV equals 1 at λ*; + - the TSE weight ratio between trajectories with 3 and 0 failures is exactly c³; + - every NaN has the right reason code. - The regression test also checks that every NaN in the summary has a non-`ok` - reason code, and it compares the reason codes with the reference. + reason code, and it compares the reason codes with the reference. - **`test_validation.py`**: low-barrier and high-barrier Langevin runs; the high - barrier is the low one plus a Gaussian bump of 2 or 3 kT on the barrier top. It - checks four things. - - The high-barrier ground truth is Poissonian. - - Stitching the low-barrier cycles with the true p′ reproduces the high-barrier - folding-time distribution: mean within 15% (1–7% observed across seeds), and a - two-sample KS test passes. - - The blind Poisson threshold is a lower bound on the true λ. - - The construction fails, as it should, with Q‡ on the barrier top (§2.8). + barrier is the low one plus a Gaussian bump of 2 or 3 kT on the barrier top. It + checks four things. + - The high-barrier ground truth is Poissonian. + - Stitching the low-barrier cycles with the true p′ reproduces the high-barrier + folding-time distribution: mean within 15% (1–7% observed across seeds), and a + two-sample KS test passes. + - The blind Poisson threshold is a lower bound on the true λ. + - The construction fails, as it should, with Q‡ on the barrier top (§2.8). --- @@ -369,9 +369,9 @@ relations between the two directions hold. The script uses one collective variable (CV) with basins A and B. - **If `--qa < --qb`:** A is Q < qa and B is Q ≥ qb, as for native or intermolecular - contacts. + contacts. - **If `--qa > --qb`:** the orientation is reversed automatically, as for a - distance: A (unbound) is d > qa, B (bound) is d ≤ qb. + distance: A (unbound) is d > qa, B (bound) is d ≤ qb. All thresholds are given in the original units. Backward runs are analysed in the mirrored coordinate −Q, so all of §2 applies unchanged. Each direction has its own @@ -384,14 +384,14 @@ sits in between, at the barrier top. **Detailed balance.** At equilibrium, the rates between core sets satisfy [23, 24] $$ -\frac{k_{AB}}{k_{BA}} \;=\; \frac{\pi_B}{\pi_A} \;=\; e^{-\beta\Delta G_{AB}}, +\frac{k_{AB}}{k_{BA}} = \frac{\pi_B}{\pi_A} = e^{-\beta\Delta G_{AB}}, $$ where π_A and π_B are the committor-split populations. The script estimates each rate as the inverse of the renewal mean first-passage time of §2.5, k = 1/M, with $$ -M(p) \;=\; \mu_C\,\frac{1-p}{p} + \mu_S . +M(p) = \mu_C \frac{1-p}{p} + \mu_S . $$ This excludes the initial relaxation. The rates are ratios on the same clock, so the @@ -400,7 +400,7 @@ scaled time of the model cancels. **Kinetic ΔG.** The quantity $$ -\Delta G_\text{kin} = -kT\ln\!\left(\frac{M_{BA}}{M_{AB}}\right) +\Delta G_\text{kin} = -kT\ln\left(\frac{M_{BA}}{M_{AB}}\right) $$ must equal the equilibrium ΔG for two-state behaviour [25]. It is reported @@ -413,8 +413,8 @@ removes one of the two multipliers. The script scans the forward tilt λ_f (p′_f = tilted p_f) and fixes the backward success probability through $$ -M'_{BA} = R\,M'_{AB},\qquad -p'_b = \frac{\mu_{C,B}}{R\,M'_{AB} - \mu_{S,B} + \mu_{C,B}}, +M'_{BA} = R M'_{AB},\qquad +p'_b = \frac{\mu_{C,B}}{R M'_{AB} - \mu_{S,B} + \mu_{C,B}}, $$ where R = exp(−βΔG_target). By default ΔG_target is the model's own kinetic value, @@ -432,7 +432,7 @@ ensemble is the time reverse of the A→B one [11, 26]. Transition paths run fro last frame in the starting basin to the first frame in the target. Two consequences can be tested using the CV alone: - the distributions of transition-path durations must be identical (two-sample KS - test); + test); - the numbers of Q_tse recrossings per path must be identical too. Under the MaxCal tilt, transition paths are unchanged (§2.2, conditional @@ -474,7 +474,7 @@ box equilibrium constant is K_box = P_bound/P_unbound = k′_on/k_off, where k the pseudo-first-order rate at [L] = 1/V. The standard binding free energy is [30] $$ -\Delta G^\circ = \Delta G_\text{box} - kT\ln\!\left(V\,C^\circ\right), +\Delta G^\circ = \Delta G_\text{box} - kT\ln\left(V C^\circ\right), \qquad C^\circ = 1\ \text{M} = 0.6022\ \text{nm}^{-3}. $$ @@ -489,129 +489,129 @@ missing barrier may be desolvation or induced fit. ```bash # folding / unfolding at the same temperature, experimental DeltaG imposed python maxcal_joint.py --fwd "fold/*.xvg" --bwd "unfold/*.xvg" \ - --qa 0.3 --qb 0.8 --qts-fwd 0.4 --qts-bwd 0.7 --qtse 0.55 \ - --temperature-relation same --dG -2.5 --out joint + --qa 0.3 --qb 0.8 --qts-fwd 0.4 --qts-bwd 0.7 --qtse 0.55 \ + --temperature-relation same --dG -2.5 --out joint # unfolding simulated at a higher temperature python maxcal_joint.py --fwd "fold/*.xvg" --bwd "unfold_hot/*.xvg" \ - --qa 0.3 --qb 0.8 --qts-fwd 0.4 --qts-bwd 0.7 --qtse 0.55 \ - --temperature-relation different --out joint_hot + --qa 0.3 --qb 0.8 --qts-fwd 0.4 --qts-bwd 0.7 --qtse 0.55 \ + --temperature-relation different --out joint_hot # binding / unbinding on a distance CV (A = unbound at d > 2.0 nm) python maxcal_joint.py --fwd "on/*.xvg" --bwd "off/*.xvg" --system binding \ - --qa 2.0 --qb 0.6 --qts-fwd 1.4 --qts-bwd 0.8 --qtse 1.0 \ - --temperature-relation same --dG -8.0 --box-volume 343 --out joint_bind + --qa 2.0 --qb 0.6 --qts-fwd 1.4 --qts-bwd 0.8 --qtse 1.0 \ + --temperature-relation same --dG -8.0 --box-volume 343 --out joint_bind ``` **Outputs** - `joint_summary.json`: per-direction statistics (p, geometric test, CV, KS, - renewal mean, mean TP duration and crossings); TP symmetry p-values; kinetic ΔG - (box and, for binding, standard); joint or independent λ with the tilted p′ in - both directions; the scan; TSE feature comparison; notes. + renewal mean, mean TP duration and crossings); TP symmetry p-values; kinetic ΔG + (box and, for binding, standard); joint or independent λ with the tilted p′ in + both directions; the scan; TSE feature comparison; notes. - `tse_forward.csv`, `tse_backward.csv` (frames with weights), and `tse_features.csv` - if features are present. + if features are present. - `survival_joint.png`, `tp_durations.png`, `tse_features.png`. ### 6.6 Joint-mode tests - **`test_joint.py`** (fast, 13 tests): - - orientation and mirroring; - - transition-path extraction and exact time-reversal symmetry of the TSE frame - rule; - - renewal mean and its inverse; - - standard-state conversion; - - the detailed-balance constraint holding along the whole scan; - - TSE path weighting; - - required `--temperature-relation`; - - end-to-end runs at the same and at different temperatures; - - invariance under reversing the CV (Q vs d = 1.5 − Q); - - binding requiring a volume. + - orientation and mirroring; + - transition-path extraction and exact time-reversal symmetry of the TSE frame + rule; + - renewal mean and its inverse; + - standard-state conversion; + - the detailed-balance constraint holding along the whole scan; + - TSE path weighting; + - required `--temperature-relation`; + - end-to-end runs at the same and at different temperatures; + - invariance under reversing the CV (Q vs d = 1.5 − Q); + - binding requiring a volume. - **`test_joint_validation.py`** (slow, 5 tests), on an asymmetric double well - (ΔG ≈ −0.6 kT) with a low-barrier model, a 2 kT-bump truth, and a hot backward set: - - kinetic ΔG equals the equilibrium committor-split ΔG within 0.3 kT (observed - ≤ 0.1 kT); - - the detailed-balance coupling predicts the true backward success probability - within 25% (observed ≤ 11%) and the backward mean folding time within 20% - (observed ≤ 8%); - - transition paths are time-reversal symmetric at the same temperature; - - a different temperature is detected, and misuse of "same" is flagged. + (ΔG ≈ −0.6 kT) with a low-barrier model, a 2 kT-bump truth, and a hot backward set: + - kinetic ΔG equals the equilibrium committor-split ΔG within 0.3 kT (observed + ≤ 0.1 kT); + - the detailed-balance coupling predicts the true backward success probability + within 25% (observed ≤ 11%) and the backward mean folding time within 20% + (observed ≤ 8%); + - transition paths are time-reversal symmetric at the same temperature; + - a different temperature is detected, and misuse of "same" is flagged. --- ## References 1. Scalone E., Broggini L., Visentin C., Erba D., Bačić Toplek F., Peqini K., - Pellegrino S., Ricagno S., Paissoni C., Camilloni C. "Multi-eGO: An in silico lens - to look into protein aggregation kinetics at atomic resolution." *PNAS* **119**, - e2203181119 (2022). + Pellegrino S., Ricagno S., Paissoni C., Camilloni C. "Multi-eGO: An in silico lens + to look into protein aggregation kinetics at atomic resolution." *PNAS* **119**, + e2203181119 (2022). 2. van Erp T. S., Moroni D., Bolhuis P. G. "A novel path sampling method for the - calculation of rate constants." *J. Chem. Phys.* **118**, 7762 (2003). + calculation of rate constants." *J. Chem. Phys.* **118**, 7762 (2003). 3. Allen R. J., Warren P. B., ten Wolde P. R. "Sampling rare switching events in - biochemical networks." *Phys. Rev. Lett.* **94**, 018104 (2005). + biochemical networks." *Phys. Rev. Lett.* **94**, 018104 (2005). 4. Jaynes E. T. "The minimum entropy production principle." *Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.* - **31**, 579–601 (1980). + **31**, 579–601 (1980). 5. Pressé S., Ghosh K., Lee J., Dill K. A. "Principles of maximum entropy and maximum - caliber in statistical physics." *Rev. Mod. Phys.* **85**, 1115–1141 (2013). + caliber in statistical physics." *Rev. Mod. Phys.* **85**, 1115–1141 (2013). 6. Ghosh K., Dixit P. D., Agozzino L., Dill K. A. "The maximum caliber variational - principle for nonequilibria." *Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.* **71**, 213–238 (2020). + principle for nonequilibria." *Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.* **71**, 213–238 (2020). 7. Kish L. *Survey Sampling*. Wiley, New York (1965). 8. Rényi A. "A characterization of Poisson processes." *Magyar Tud. Akad. Mat. Kutató - Int. Közl.* **1**, 519–527 (1956). + Int. Közl.* **1**, 519–527 (1956). 9. Kalashnikov V. *Geometric Sums: Bounds for Rare Events with Applications*. Kluwer, - Dordrecht (1997). + Dordrecht (1997). 10. Du R., Pande V. S., Grosberg A. Yu., Tanaka T., Shakhnovich E. I. "On the - transition coordinate for protein folding." *J. Chem. Phys.* **108**, 334 (1998). + transition coordinate for protein folding." *J. Chem. Phys.* **108**, 334 (1998). 11. Bolhuis P. G., Chandler D., Dellago C., Geissler P. L. "Transition path sampling: - throwing ropes over rough mountain passes, in the dark." *Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.* - **53**, 291–318 (2002). + throwing ropes over rough mountain passes, in the dark." *Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.* + **53**, 291–318 (2002). 12. Kramers H. A. "Brownian motion in a field of force and the diffusion model of - chemical reactions." *Physica* **7**, 284–304 (1940). + chemical reactions." *Physica* **7**, 284–304 (1940). 13. Hänggi P., Talkner P., Borkovec M. "Reaction-rate theory: fifty years after - Kramers." *Rev. Mod. Phys.* **62**, 251–341 (1990). + Kramers." *Rev. Mod. Phys.* **62**, 251–341 (1990). 14. Voter A. F. "Hyperdynamics: accelerated molecular dynamics of infrequent events." - *Phys. Rev. Lett.* **78**, 3908 (1997). + *Phys. Rev. Lett.* **78**, 3908 (1997). 15. Tiwary P., Parrinello M. "From metadynamics to dynamics." *Phys. Rev. Lett.* - **111**, 230602 (2013). + **111**, 230602 (2013). 16. Salvalaglio M., Tiwary P., Parrinello M. "Assessing the reliability of the - dynamics reconstructed from metadynamics." *J. Chem. Theory Comput.* **10**, - 1420–1425 (2014). + dynamics reconstructed from metadynamics." *J. Chem. Theory Comput.* **10**, + 1420–1425 (2014). 17. Kaplan E. L., Meier P. "Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations." - *J. Am. Stat. Assoc.* **53**, 457–481 (1958). + *J. Am. Stat. Assoc.* **53**, 457–481 (1958). 18. Lilliefors H. W. "On the Kolmogorov–Smirnov test for the exponential - distribution with mean unknown." *J. Am. Stat. Assoc.* **64**, 387–389 (1969). + distribution with mean unknown." *J. Am. Stat. Assoc.* **64**, 387–389 (1969). 19. Efron B. "Bootstrap methods: another look at the jackknife." *Ann. Stat.* **7**, - 1–26 (1979). + 1–26 (1979). **Related MaxCal approaches to kinetics** (alternatives to the attempt-level tilt used here): 20. Dixit P. D., Dill K. A. "Caliber corrected Markov modeling (C2M2): correcting - equilibrium Markov models." *J. Chem. Theory Comput.* **14**, 1111–1119 (2018). + equilibrium Markov models." *J. Chem. Theory Comput.* **14**, 1111–1119 (2018). 21. Brotzakis Z. F., Vendruscolo M., Bolhuis P. G. "A method of incorporating rate - constants as kinetic constraints in molecular dynamics simulations." *PNAS* - **118**, e2012423118 (2021). + constants as kinetic constraints in molecular dynamics simulations." *PNAS* + **118**, e2012423118 (2021). 22. Fersht A. R., Matouschek A., Serrano L. "The folding of an enzyme. I. Theory of - protein engineering analysis of stability and pathway of protein folding." - *J. Mol. Biol.* **224**, 771–782 (1992). (Φ-value analysis, for comparing the TSE - with experiment.) + protein engineering analysis of stability and pathway of protein folding." + *J. Mol. Biol.* **224**, 771–782 (1992). (Φ-value analysis, for comparing the TSE + with experiment.) **Joint mode** 23. Hummer G. "From transition paths to transition states and rate coefficients." - *J. Chem. Phys.* **120**, 516–523 (2004). + *J. Chem. Phys.* **120**, 516–523 (2004). 24. E W., Vanden-Eijnden E. "Towards a theory of transition paths." - *J. Stat. Phys.* **123**, 503–523 (2006). + *J. Stat. Phys.* **123**, 503–523 (2006). 25. Jackson S. E., Fersht A. R. "Folding of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2. 1. Evidence for - a two-state transition." *Biochemistry* **30**, 10428–10435 (1991). + a two-state transition." *Biochemistry* **30**, 10428–10435 (1991). 26. Best R. B., Hummer G. "Reaction coordinates and rates from transition paths." - *PNAS* **102**, 6732–6737 (2005). + *PNAS* **102**, 6732–6737 (2005). 27. Hammond G. S. "A correlation of reaction rates." *J. Am. Chem. Soc.* **77**, - 334–338 (1955). + 334–338 (1955). 28. Leffler J. E. "Parameters for the description of transition states." - *Science* **117**, 340–341 (1953). + *Science* **117**, 340–341 (1953). 29. Donati L., Hartmann C., Keller B. G. "Girsanov reweighting for path ensembles and - Markov state models." *J. Chem. Phys.* **146**, 244112 (2017). + Markov state models." *J. Chem. Phys.* **146**, 244112 (2017). 30. Gilson M. K., Given J. A., Bush B. L., McCammon J. A. "The statistical-thermodynamic - basis for computation of binding affinities: a critical review." - *Biophys. J.* **72**, 1047–1069 (1997). + basis for computation of binding affinities: a critical review." + *Biophys. J.* **72**, 1047–1069 (1997).