From 81c26e27384f5160c14b87791e4c72ea0ed74998 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: James Kent Date: Wed, 14 Oct 2026 08:11:07 -0500 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] Never open the PubMed abstract page; address no-LinkOut PLoS articles by DOI When an article has no LinkOut record, get_html_by_pmid opened https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov// in the browser. Since 2026-10-14 PubMed answers beast's browser with an Incapsula block page, and the abstract page was only ever useful for a PLoS citation_doi. Now, with no LinkOut, the keyed esummary decides: a PLoS journal (fulljournalname) with a DOI in articleids goes straight to the PLoS manuscript URL; anything else opens nothing and is logged, which process_article and retrieve_articles report as an invalid article. _is_pubmed_landing_page and _extract_citation_doi are removed. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- ace/scrape.py | 84 +- ...or_other_journals[article-with-a-doi].yaml | 147 + ...hing_for_other_journals[book-chapter].yaml | 141 + ...s_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml | 2182 ++++++++++ ...t_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml | 880 ++++ ...without_linkout_opens_the_pubmed_page.yaml | 153 - .../test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml | 3605 +---------------- ...failure_is_logged_without_the_api_key.yaml | 320 ++ ace/tests/test_ace.py | 91 +- 9 files changed, 3957 insertions(+), 3646 deletions(-) create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[article-with-a-doi].yaml create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[book-chapter].yaml create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml delete mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_pubmed_page.yaml create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_plos_summary_failure_is_logged_without_the_api_key.yaml diff --git a/ace/scrape.py b/ace/scrape.py index ecb762f..62c5498 100644 --- a/ace/scrape.py +++ b/ace/scrape.py @@ -278,29 +278,6 @@ def parse_PMID_xml(xml): } -def _is_pubmed_landing_page(url): - """ True for the PubMed abstract page, which is what we open when an - article has no LinkOut record. It is not full text. """ - - return re.match(r'https?://pubmed\.ncbi\.nlm\.nih\.gov/\d+/?$', url or '') is not None - - -def _extract_citation_doi(html): - """ Pull the DOI out of a page's citation_doi meta tag. """ - - if not html: - return None - - for tag in re.findall(r'(?is)]*>', html): - if not re.search(r'''(?i)name\s*=\s*["']?citation_doi["']?''', tag): - continue - match = re.search(r'''(?i)content\s*=\s*["']([^"']+)["']''', tag) - if match: - return match.group(1).strip() - - return None - - def _plos_doi_from_url(url): """ Pull the DOI out of a journals.plos.org article URL, if it is one. """ @@ -308,6 +285,14 @@ def _plos_doi_from_url(url): return match.group(1) if match else None +def _plos_manuscript_url(journal, doi): + """ The NLM XML of a PLoS article. The legacy 'asset?id=.XML' + endpoint still works, but only by redirecting here first. """ + + return 'https://journals.plos.org/%s/article/file?id=%s&type=manuscript' % ( + PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES[journal.lower()], doi) + + def _visible_text(html): """ Rough plain-text rendering of an HTML document, used to tell a real article page apart from an interstitial that carries nothing but a widget. """ @@ -589,17 +574,37 @@ def _providers_from_elink_json(json_content): return [(obj.get('provider', {}).get('nameabbr'), obj['url']['value']) for obj in objurls] @staticmethod - def _prlinks_target(pmid, providers): + def _prlinks_target(providers): """ The page that elink's cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref redirects to: the - first LinkOut provider that isn't PMC, else PMC, else the PubMed - abstract page. """ + first LinkOut provider that isn't PMC, else PMC. """ for name, url in providers: if name != 'PMC': return url - if providers: - return providers[0][1] - return f"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/{pmid}/" + return providers[0][1] + + def _plos_url_without_linkout(self, pmid): + """ The PLoS manuscript URL of an article that has no LinkOut record, + from its keyed esummary, or None if it isn't a PLoS article. """ + + try: + response = self._client.get( + 'esummary', + params={'db': 'pubmed', 'id': pmid, 'retmode': 'json'}, + return_content=False, + ) + summary = response.json()['result'][str(pmid)] + except Exception as e: + logger.error(f"E-utilities summary failed for PMID {pmid}: {self._without_api_key(e)}") + return None + + # The caller's journal can be a label of its own rather than PubMed's + # name for it, so PubMed's record decides whether this is PLoS. + journal = summary.get('fulljournalname', '') + doi = next((a['value'] for a in summary.get('articleids', []) if a['idtype'] == 'doi'), None) + if journal.lower() not in PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES or doi is None: + return None + return _plos_manuscript_url(journal, doi) def _without_api_key(self, text): # requests puts the full query string, key included, in its errors. @@ -645,7 +650,16 @@ def get_html_by_pmid(self, pmid, journal, mode='browser', prefer_pmc_source=True ) return - url = self._prlinks_target(pmid, providers) + if providers: + url = self._prlinks_target(providers) + else: + # Without LinkOut, prlinks lands on the PubMed abstract page. That + # is never full text, and NCBI blocks scripts that browse PubMed, + # so only a PLoS article, addressed by its DOI, is opened. + url = self._plos_url_without_linkout(pmid) + if url is None: + logger.info("\tNo LinkOut record for PMID %s and no PLoS manuscript to open. Skipping...", pmid) + return None logger.info(url) return self.get_html( url, @@ -666,17 +680,9 @@ def check_for_substitute_url(self, url, html, journal): try: if j in PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES: doi = _plos_doi_from_url(url) - if doi is None and _is_pubmed_landing_page(url): - # E-utilities had no LinkOut for this article, so we - # opened the PubMed abstract page. Its citation_doi - # meta tag is enough to address the full text ourselves. - doi = _extract_citation_doi(html) if doi is None: return url - # The legacy 'asset?id=.XML' endpoint still works, but only - # by redirecting here first. - return 'https://journals.plos.org/%s/article/file?id=%s&type=manuscript' % ( - PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES[j], doi) + return _plos_manuscript_url(j, doi) elif j in ['human brain mapping', 'european journal of neuroscience', 'brain and behavior', 'epilepsia', 'journal of neuroimaging']: return url.replace('abstract', 'full').split(';')[0] diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[article-with-a-doi].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[article-with-a-doi].yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..03368dd --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[article-with-a-doi].yaml @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, + like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=42869849&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"42869849","objurls":[],"info":"No + LinkOut links available for UID: 42869849"}]}]} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:05:21 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D33C7E9FE8B2C65000056F4C5D7A4C5.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - DC69A73962DDC2FA_F265SID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=DC69A73962DDC2FA_F265SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:05:21 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '9' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '176' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=DC69A73962DDC2FA_F265SID + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, + like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42869849&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["42869849"],"42869849":{"uid":"42869849","pubdate":"2026 + Oct","epubdate":"","source":"ACR Open Rheumatol","authors":[{"name":"Lerkvaleekul + B","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Sirachainan N","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Songdej + D","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Paisooksantivatana K","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Chinudomwong + P","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Vilaiyuk S","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"lastauthor":"Vilaiyuk + S","title":"The Usefulness of White Blood Cell Inflammatory Parameters in + Children With Systemic Lupus Erythematosus.","sorttitle":"usefulness of white + blood cell inflammatory parameters in children with systemic lupus erythematosus","volume":"8","issue":"10","pages":"e90152","lang":["eng"],"nlmuniqueid":"101740025","issn":"","essn":"2578-5745","pubtype":["Journal + Article"],"recordstatus":"PubMed","pubstatus":"4","articleids":[{"idtype":"pubmed","idtypen":1,"value":"42869849"},{"idtype":"doi","idtypen":3,"value":"10.1002/acr2.90152"}],"history":[{"pubstatus":"revised","date":"2026/08/18 + 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"received","date":"2026/05/15 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"accepted","date":"2026/09/01 + 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"medline","date":"2026/10/13 23:37"},{"pubstatus":"pubmed","date":"2026/10/13 + 23:36"},{"pubstatus":"entrez","date":"2026/10/13 22:53"}],"references":[],"attributes":["Has + Abstract"],"pmcrefcount":"","fulljournalname":"ACR open rheumatology","elocationid":"doi: + 10.1002/acr2.90152","doctype":"citation","srccontriblist":[],"booktitle":"","medium":"","edition":"","publisherlocation":"","publishername":"","srcdate":"","reportnumber":"","availablefromurl":"","locationlabel":"","doccontriblist":[],"docdate":"","bookname":"","chapter":"","sortpubdate":"2026/10/01 + 00:00","sortfirstauthor":"Lerkvaleekul B","vernaculartitle":""}}} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:05:20 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D33C7E9FE8B2C6500002EF4C66B1DAF.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - DC69A73962DDC2FA_F265SID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=DC69A73962DDC2FA_F265SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:05:21 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '8' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '1912' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[book-chapter].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[book-chapter].yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9e59ea0 --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[book-chapter].yaml @@ -0,0 +1,141 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=28520367&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"28520367","objurls":[],"info":"No + LinkOut links available for UID: 28520367"}]}]} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D33C7E9FE8B2C65000038F0E5F052A5.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - C39567E4915B91FC_E4AESID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=C39567E4915B91FC_E4AESID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:57:56 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '7' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '176' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=C39567E4915B91FC_E4AESID + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=28520367&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["28520367"],"28520367":{"uid":"28520367","pubdate":"2012","epubdate":"","source":"","authors":[{"name":"Dean + L","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"lastauthor":"Dean L","title":"Carbamazepine + Therapy and HLA Genotype.","sorttitle":"carbamazepine therapy and hla genotype","volume":"","issue":"","pages":"","lang":["eng"],"nlmuniqueid":"","issn":"","essn":"","pubtype":["Review"],"recordstatus":"PubMed","pubstatus":"ppublish","articleids":[{"idtype":"bookaccession","idtypen":8,"value":"NBK321445"},{"idtype":"pubmed","idtypen":1,"value":"28520367"}],"history":[],"references":[],"attributes":["Has + Abstract"],"pmcrefcount":"","fulljournalname":"","elocationid":"","doctype":"chapter","srccontriblist":[],"booktitle":"Medical + Genetics Summaries","medium":"Internet","edition":"","publisherlocation":"Bethesda + (MD)","publishername":"National Center for Biotechnology Information (US)","srcdate":"2012-","reportnumber":"","availablefromurl":"http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK321445/","locationlabel":"","doccontriblist":[{"name":"Dean + L","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"docdate":"2015 Oct 14 [updated 2026 + Oct 6]","bookname":"gtrbook","chapter":"carbamazepine","sortpubdate":"2026/10/06 + 00:00","sortfirstauthor":"Dean L","vernaculartitle":""}}} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D33C7E9FE8B2C65000050F0E6580C0D.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - C39567E4915B91FC_E4AESID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=C39567E4915B91FC_E4AESID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:57:56 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '6' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '1319' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bcb9ce4 --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml @@ -0,0 +1,2182 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=42868205&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"42868205","objurls":[],"info":"No + LinkOut links available for UID: 42868205"}]}]} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D322F91B7495C35000057E45CD6A5AB.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:57:55 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '7' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '176' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868205&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["42868205"],"42868205":{"uid":"42868205","pubdate":"2026 + Oct 13","epubdate":"2026 Oct 13","source":"PLoS Comput Biol","authors":[{"name":"Yin + Q","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Chen L","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"lastauthor":"Chen + L","title":"Interpretable neural networks prioritize cancer driver genes from + genome-wide dependency landscapes.","sorttitle":"interpretable neural networks + prioritize cancer driver genes from genome wide dependency landscapes","volume":"22","issue":"10","pages":"e1014869","lang":["eng"],"nlmuniqueid":"101238922","issn":"1553-734X","essn":"1553-7358","pubtype":["Journal + Article"],"recordstatus":"PubMed - as supplied by publisher","pubstatus":"10","articleids":[{"idtype":"pubmed","idtypen":1,"value":"42868205"},{"idtype":"doi","idtypen":3,"value":"10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869"},{"idtype":"pii","idtypen":4,"value":"PCOMPBIOL-D-26-01062"}],"history":[{"pubstatus":"received","date":"2026/05/05 + 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"accepted","date":"2026/10/04 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"medline","date":"2026/10/13 + 23:36"},{"pubstatus":"pubmed","date":"2026/10/13 23:36"},{"pubstatus":"entrez","date":"2026/10/13 + 18:14"}],"references":[],"attributes":["Has Abstract"],"pmcrefcount":"","fulljournalname":"PLoS + computational biology","elocationid":"doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869","doctype":"citation","srccontriblist":[],"booktitle":"","medium":"","edition":"","publisherlocation":"","publishername":"","srcdate":"","reportnumber":"","availablefromurl":"","locationlabel":"","doccontriblist":[],"docdate":"","bookname":"","chapter":"","sortpubdate":"2026/10/13 + 00:00","sortfirstauthor":"Yin Q","vernaculartitle":""}}} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D3407F95CD407A5000036EFC3CCE88F.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:57:55 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '7' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '1723' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article/file?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pcbi.1014869&type=manuscript + response: + body: + string: '' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - max-age=3600 + Content-Length: + - '0' + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT + Location: + - https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869/1/pcbi.1014869.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T063435Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host&X-Goog-Signature=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 + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CIfo682BrZK1uQEQAw; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + status: + code: 302 + message: Found +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869/1/pcbi.1014869.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T063435Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-Signature=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&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host + response: + body: + string: "\n\n
\n\n\n\nComposition + Vendor\nNewgen KnowledgeWorks (P) Ltd.\n\n\n\n\n\nPLoS Comput Biol\nplos\nploscomp\n\nPLOS + Computational Biology\n\n1553-734X\n1553-7358\n\nPublic Library + of Science\nSan Francisco, CA USA\n\n\n\n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869\nPCOMPBIOL-D-26-01062\n\n\nResearch Article\n\n\nMedicine and health sciencesPharmacologyBehavioral + pharmacologyDrug dependence\nMedicine and health sciencesOncologyCancers + and neoplasms\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsMutation\nMedicine and health sciencesOncologyCancers + and neoplasmsMalignant tumors\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsGene + typesSuppressor genesTumor + suppressor genes\nResearch and analysis methodsDatabase + and informatics methodsBiological databasesMutation + databases\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsMutationMutation + databases\nBiology and life sciencesCell + biologySignal transductionCell + signalingOncogenic signaling\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsGene + identification and analysisMutation detection\n\nInterpretable + neural networks prioritize cancer driver genes from genome-wide dependency + landscapes\nInterpretable + neural networks for cancer driver genes\n\n\n\nhttps://orcid.org/0009-0004-3643-7981\n\nYin\nQingyang\n\nConceptualization\nData + curation\nFormal + analysis\nInvestigation\nMethodology\nResources\nSoftware\nValidation\nVisualization\nWriting + \u2013 original draft\n\n\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6164-4553\n\nChen\nLiang\n\nConceptualization\nFunding + acquisition\nInvestigation\nMethodology\nProject + administration\nResources\nSupervision\nWriting + \u2013 review & editing\n*\n\n\nDepartment of Quantitative and Computational Biology, + University of + Southern California, Los Angeles, + California, United States of America\n\n\n\nWei\nHang\n\nEditor\n\n\nXidian University, + CHINA\n\n\n

The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

\n
\n* E-mail: liang.chen@usc.edu\n
\n13102026\n102026\n22\n10\ne1014869\n\n552026\n4102026\n\n\n2026\nYin, + Chen\n\nThis is an open access article distributed + under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which + permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided + the original author and source are credited.\n\n\n\n

Identifying + cancer driver genes and their therapeutic impact remains a core challenge + in computational cancer biology. We introduce xNNDriver and xAEDriver, two + interpretable neural network frameworks that connect cancer mutations with + genome-wide DepMap gene dependencies, pathway activity, and drug-response + patterns. xNNDriver is a supervised pathway-guided model that evaluates whether + a gene\u2019s mutation status is encoded in the genome-wide dependency landscape; + we interpret model fitness as a driver potential score, which quantifies the + strength of this mutation-dependency signal and prioritizes genes with broad + functional footprints. Across 3,008 candidate genes, xNNDriver recovers major + established drivers and highlights literature-supported candidates, while + pathway analyses reveal biologically coherent programs related to metabolism, + growth factor signaling, and immune regulation. To capture combinatorial functional + states, xAEDriver uses an unsupervised autoencoder to learn Driver Variant + Representations (DVRs), latent binary features guided by the frequency distribution + of known driver mutations. DVRs capture cell-line-specific dependency patterns + and expression patterns and are associated with drug sensitivity and pathway + activity. Together, these interpretable deep learning models demonstrate that + gene dependency landscapes encode rich, interpretable signals of oncogenic + function and provide a hypothesis-generating framework for prioritizing drivers, + pathways, and therapeutic vulnerabilities for further experimental validation.

\n
\n\nAuthor summary\n

Cancer is often + driven by genetic changes that give tumor cells a growth advantage, but finding + which changes matter and how they affect cell behavior remains difficult. + In this study, we used large-scale gene-editing data from cancer cell lines + to ask whether the pattern of genes a cell depends on can reveal information + about its cancer-driving alterations. We developed interpretable neural-network + models that connect mutation patterns, cell survival dependencies, and biological + pathways. One model prioritizes genes whose mutation status leaves a clear + functional signature across the cell. A second model summarizes broader, combined + driver-like states in each cell line. These summaries were linked to known + cancer biology, tissue type, and differences in drug response, suggesting + that functional dependency data contain useful clues about cancer mechanisms. + By connecting mutation patterns with functional dependencies and pathway activity, + our approach helps identify candidate cancer drivers and interpretable drug-response + patterns that can guide future experimental studies. Making the models interpretable + allows researchers to move from large screening datasets toward biological + explanations of cancer-driving processes.

\n
\n\n\nNIH\nR01NS139485\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6164-4553\nChenLiang\n\nNIH\nR01CA301708\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6164-4553\nChenLiang\nThis + work was supported by the National Institutes of Health (R01NS139485 and R01CA301708 + to L.C.). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, + decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nData Availability\nThe + codes are available at https://github.com/qyyin0516/xNNDriver-and-xAEDriver. + All data from the DepMap database were downloaded from https://depmap.org/portal/download/all/ + (version: 23Q2). The COSMIC database can be downloaded at https://cancer.sanger.ac.uk/cosmic/download/cosmic/v102/mutantcensus, + and categories of clinical significance for SNVs can be found at https://www.ensembl.org/info/genome/variation/prediction/predicted_data.html#consequences/. + The ClinVar database can be downloaded at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/, + and categories of clinical significance for SNVs can be found at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/docs/clinsig/. + Reactome pathway annotations and hierarchy can be downloaded at https://reactome.org/download-data. + The list of 3,008 frequently mutated candidate genes can be found at https://github.com/idekerlab/DrugCell.\n\n\nPLOS + Publication Stage\nuncorrected-proof\n\n\n
\n
\n\n\nIntroduction\n

One of + the most critical and challenging areas in cancer biology is the identification + of driver genes and mutations. Cancer driver mutations fuel tumor progression, + unlike neutral passenger mutations [1]. + In recent years, machine learning and deep learning have shown great potential + in bioinformatics, including applications for detecting cancer driver genes + and mutations [2\u20136]. However, current + deep learning models predominantly utilize sequence data and three-dimensional + protein structures to infer driver mutations [1], + while functional genomics, especially gene editing, remains less explored. + Additionally, the interpretability of these black-box models is often limited.

\n

Conventional + gene perturbation strategies, such as knockout and RNAi-mediated knockdown, + enable researchers to study a gene\u2019s loss-of-function effects on tumor + progression, aiding in identifying cancer-driver genes and mutations [7]. CRISPR-Cas9 has advanced + gene perturbation in terms of precision and scale [8]. The Cancer Dependency Map (DepMap) + at the Broad Institute conducted genome-wide CRISPR-Cas9 knockout screens + across a wide range of cancer cell lines [9,10], providing gene dependency + scores that reflect each gene\u2019s importance for cell proliferation and + survival in a cell-line-specific manner. While DepMap dependency scores provide + valuable insights into the essentiality of genes in cancer cells, they are + not sufficient on their own to conclusively determine whether a gene is a + driver of cancer. Accurate identification of cancer driver genes requires + an integrated analysis of dependency scores with other data types, such as + DNA mutations, pathway involvement, and gene expression.

\n

We hypothesize + that mutations with driver activity can leave detectable signatures in the + genome-wide dependency landscape, whereas passenger mutations are less likely + to produce coherent dependency shifts. To test the hypothesis, we built a + supervised learning model to predict the mutation status (mutated or not) + of each candidate gene, using the dependency scores of all screened genes + in a cell line. The model\u2019s fitness, expressed as the driver potential + score of this candidate gene, prioritizes genes whose mutation status has + a strong functional footprint in dependency data. We name this model xNNDriver + (explainable Neural Network for Driver + gene identification). Because the labels are derived from existing mutation + annotations, xNNDriver is best viewed as a functional prioritization and interpretation + framework rather than an independent de novo mutation-discovery tool. Additionally, + genome-scale CRISPR knockouts measure gene loss-of-function effects on cancer-cell + fitness. Although well suited to detecting oncogene addiction, these screens + may have limited sensitivity for tumor suppressors that are already inactivated. + However, tumor suppressor alterations can still be reflected in DepMap data + when they reshape the dependencies of other genes across the genome. xNNDriver + is designed to capture these broader mutation-associated dependency patterns, + rather than relying only on the dependency score of the candidate gene itself.

\n

Our + approach successfully identified both well-known driver genes and novel candidates. + To discern the pathways through which these drivers contribute to tumorigenesis, + we incorporated the Reactome pathway hierarchy [11] + into the network architecture, designing each neuron to represent a distinct + biological pathway.

\n

To simultaneously infer multi-driver functional + states in a cell line, we designed an interpretable autoencoder model that + integrates both dependency scores and gene expression data. This unsupervised + model is named xAEDriver (explainable AutoEncoder + for hidden overall Driver status identification). The latent + layer of xAEDriver, which captures the key features of the input data in a + compressed form, is guided by the mutation distribution of known driver single + nucleotide variants (SNVs). The latent representations are constrained to + resemble the population-level distribution of driver mutations, but they are + not forced to correspond to specific genes or variants. We refer to these + latent representations as Driver Variant Representations + (DVRs). xAEDriver is also interpretable, so it can reveal biological pathways + that offer a deeper understanding of the driver mutation status. Notably, + cell lines stratified by DVRs exhibited distinct drug responses, supporting + the use of dependency-derived driver states to interpret treatment-relevant + vulnerabilities.

\n
\n\nResults\n\nThe fitness of the supervised xNNDriver quantifies + cancer driver potential from dependency landscapes\n

Our supervised + xNNDriver model links genome-wide gene dependency scores to the mutation status + of a candidate driver gene in each cancer cell line. The mutation status of + a true driver gene, but not passenger mutations, influences the impact of + other genes\u2019 knockout on tumor survival (dependency). In other words, + the distinct genome-wide dependency scores can predict the mutation status + of driver genes (high model fitness), but not those of passenger genes (low + model fitness). We define the resulting model fitness as the driver potential + score, a measure of mutation-dependency association and functional prioritization + rather than direct proof of causality. A schematic overview of the workflow + is shown in Fig 1A.

\n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g001Supervised xNNDriver model for prioritizing individual + candidate driver genes.

(A) Workflow of xNNDriver. + Functional SNVs are aggregated to annotate the gene-level mutation status + for each candidate driver gene. Individual neural network models are trained + using gene dependency scores as input features and candidate gene mutation + status as labels. Data are split into training and test sets, and the model + follows the Reactome pathway hierarchy. Predictions from all layers are integrated + via voting. The model fitness is evaluated using the driver potential score, + where a higher score indicates a stronger mutation-dependency association + and higher priority as a candidate driver. (B) Prediction performance + for the top 15 genes with the highest driver potential scores. Point color + represents the number of cell lines with functional mutations in each candidate + gene. A total of 1,095 cell lines (mutated and non-mutated) are considered + for each model. Gene names are color-coded by driver annotation from DepMap + (purple: driver; black: non-driver). (C) Tissue-level driver + potential scores. The color of each square indicates the driver potential + score within test cell lines from a given tissue, and the number following + the tissue name denotes the count of test cell lines in that tissue.

\n
\n

To construct the training data, we determined + each candidate gene\u2019s mutation status based on the presence of functional + somatic SNVs, as annotated by both the COSMIC [12] + and ClinVar [13] + databases. The model was trained using a biologically informed feedforward + neural network whose architecture mirrors the pathway hierarchy acquired from + the Reactome database. The input layer consists of screened genes with dependency + scores, and the hidden layers represent pathways. The edges between the input + layer and the first hidden layer capture pathway membership for each gene, + while the edges between pathway layers represent the hierarchical relationships + between pathway terms. Each pathway layer is followed by a predictive layer + designed to predict the mutation status of a candidate driver gene. Predictions + from all hidden layers are aggregated using a voting mechanism.

\n

The + model fitness of xNNDriver reflects the strength of association between a + candidate gene\u2019s mutation status and genome-wide dependency patterns. + A high driver potential score therefore suggests that the gene\u2019s mutation + status is linked to a broad functional dependency signature in cancer cells + and prioritizes it for driver-focused interpretation. Important pathways contributing + to predictions are identified by contrasting the activation values of neural + networks between mutated and non-mutated cell lines. We iteratively apply + the xNNDriver model to all candidate genes (3,008 genes) to prioritize cancer + driver genes and their associated important pathways.

\n
\n\nxNNDriver + prioritizes established drivers and literature-supported candidate driver + genes\n

We applied our supervised model, xNNDriver, to the 15% most + frequently mutated genes in human cancers as determined by the CCLE project + [14], totaling + 3,008 candidate genes. Fig + 1B illustrates the driver potential scores of the 15 highest-scoring + genes, with complete results provided in S1 Table. Among the top 15 genes, ten are + well-established cancer driver genes as documented in DepMap, such as KRAS, + NRAS, BRAF, PIK3CA, TP53, + and so on. This strong concordance supports that the dependency landscape + contains functional information that captures core cancer driver biology.

\n

The + remaining genes, although not yet recognized as drivers in DepMap, have been + suggested in the literature to possess driver-like functions. For example, + Murakami et al. and Strazisar et al. [15,16] reported that LATS2 + acts as a tumor suppressor essential for regulating the proliferation and/or + survival of malignant mesothelioma cells. EZH2 exhibits a + dual role, functioning as either a tumor suppressor or an oncogene depending + on the cellular context [17]. + Additionally, Sasaki et al. [18] + identified KEAP1 as an inhibitor of NRF2-induced cytoprotection + and proposed it as a potential tumor suppressor. Collectively, these results + demonstrate that xNNDriver can reprioritize known drivers and nominate literature-supported + candidates for further validation.

\n

To test the robustness of our model, + we redefined mutation status using all somatic SNVs rather than only functional + ones. The top 30 genes under this alternative annotation are shown in S1 Fig, + with complete results in S2 + Table. The recovery of major known drivers (KRAS, + NRAS, BRAF, PIK3CA, TP53) + and consistent identification of EZH2 underscore the robustness + of our approach.

\n

We next examined tissue-specific driver activity. + For the top 15 genes (Fig + 1B), we recalculated driver potential scores within individual tissue + types. As shown in Fig 1C, + higher tissue-level scores indicate a gene\u2019s stronger driver potential + in that tissue. For instance, BRAF is strongly associated + with thyroid cancers, consistent with the BRAF V600E mutation + being the most common alteration in papillary thyroid carcinoma [19]. Similarly, PIK3CA + mutations frequently drive breast cancers [20]. + This tissue-resolved analysis highlights the context-specific roles of cancer + drivers.

\n

Furthermore, we evaluated event-level performance for the + 15 highest-ranked genes by comparing held-out cell line\u2013gene predictions + with curated functional SNV labels (S2 Fig). Precision exceeded 90% for several + established drivers, including KRAS, BRAF, + TP53, and HRAS. Predicted-positive pairs + without matching SNVs may represent false positives or alterations not included + in the current labels, such as indels, copy-number alterations, structural + variants, and other non-SNV mechanisms. Recall was approximately 78% for KRAS + and 60% for BRAF. Missed events may reflect passenger or + context-dependent mutations, incomplete dependency signals, or limited model + sensitivity. Thus, xNNDriver identifies catalogued mutation events associated + with detectable functional dependency footprints, although this cell line-gene-level + analysis does not directly determine the functional effect of an individual + variant.

\n

To assess performance under native class imbalance, we additionally + calculated the area under the precision-recall curve (AUPRC) for the top 15 + xNNDriver genes without upsampling. Established drivers (e.g., KRAS, + TP53, BRAF, NRAS) retained + strong precision-recall performance, whereas several rare or marginal candidates + (e.g., LATS2, ALK, BAP1) + showed low AUPRC despite non-random AUROC (S3 Table). Thus, AUROC-based driver potential + and AUPRC provide complementary information: AUROC reflects overall discrimination, + while AUPRC provides a more conservative estimate of positive-class recovery + in imbalanced mutation settings. Together, these analyses demonstrate both + the benefit of upsampling for detecting mutation-associated dependency signals, + particularly for rare mutations, and the need for further experimental validation + of candidates with limited positive-class precision.

\n

Baseline machine + learning models, including Logistic Regression, Random Forest, and an unconstrained + Multilayer Perceptron, achieved comparable or sometimes higher AUROC for individual + genes (S4 + Table). These results indicate that genome-wide dependency profiles + contain mutation-associated signals that can be detected by multiple modeling + approaches. xNNDriver showed a positive rank correlation with Logistic Regression, + the strongest baseline model (Spearman \u03C1\u2009=\u20090.49; S4 Table), supporting consistency in dependency-based + gene prioritization. However, the main advantage of xNNDriver is not raw classification + accuracy alone, but its pathway-guided interpretability. By embedding the + Reactome hierarchy directly into the network architecture, xNNDriver links + candidate driver mutations to interpretable pathway-level dependency patterns, + providing biological context that is not directly available from standard + baseline models.

\n
\n\nSelf-dependency + contributes biologically meaningful signal but does not fully explain top + driver predictions\n

To address whether xNNDriver relied primarily + on the candidate gene\u2019s own dependency score, we performed a leave-candidate-dependency-out + analysis for the top 15 genes. In this analysis, the dependency score of the + target candidate gene was removed from the input feature matrix, and model + performance was recalculated (S5 + Table). The strongest established drivers retained substantial predictive + performance after this removal. For example, KRAS changed + from 0.873 to 0.896, NRAS from 0.854 to 0.858, BRAF + from 0.814 to 0.790, PIK3CA from 0.684 to 0.738, and TP53 + from 0.640 to 0.638. These results indicate that, for core drivers, mutation + status is also encoded in dependency patterns across other genes, supporting + the presence of distributed functional footprints.

\n

At the same time, + several genes showed stronger dependence on the candidate gene\u2019s own + dependency feature. LATS2 decreased from 0.667 to 0.500, + ALK from 0.598 to 0.498, XPO1 from 0.571 + to 0.500, and MYC from 0.556 to 0.500 after self-dependency + removal. We do not interpret this as a model defect, because self-dependency + is itself an experimentally measured functional phenotype and may reflect + direct vulnerability, oncogene addiction, or altered tolerance to gene loss. + Instead, this analysis separates two biologically meaningful components of + the driver potential score: direct self-dependency and distributed network-level + dependency effects.

\n
\n\nxNNDriver reveals + driver-associated pathway programs from dependency signatures\n

Using + the interpretable xNNDriver model, we discovered important pathways associated + with high-scoring candidate driver genes. Fig + 2A shows the top 20 pathways, ranked by their importance measurements + (Dpvalues), + for the 15 genes with the highest driver potential scores. The complete list + of pathways passing the Dp + cutoff (default: 0.1) for these genes is provided in S6 Table. Metabolic pathways ranked prominently, + including \u201Cmetabolism,\u201D \u201Cmetabolism of proteins,\u201D and + \u201Cmetabolism of lipids.\u201D This aligns with Vander Heiden et al. [21], who demonstrated + that altered cellular metabolism can drive tumor progression and inform cancer + prognosis and therapy.

\n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g002Analysis of important pathways from xNNDriver.

(A) + Top important pathways. The top 20 pathways are ranked by Dp + values, aggregated from models of the 15 highest-scoring driver genes. For + pathways identified in multiple models, the maximumDp + value is reported. (B) Pathway proximity to driver genes. Benjamini-Hochberg + adjusted p-values are from the one-sided Wilcoxon signed-rank test comparing + the shortest path lengths to the corresponding driver gene between identified + and random pathways at the same hierarchy level. The random sampling procedures + were repeated 20 times. Genes are sorted by their driver potential scores. + The number in brackets next to the gene name indicates the number of important + pathways identified from the corresponding gene model. The red dashed line + marks the adjusted p-value cutoff of 0.05. (C) Correlation between + pathway proximity and importance. Pearson correlation coefficients between + relative shortest-path length differences and pathway rankings. The red dashed + line marks the cutoff of 0. (D) Differential pathway expression + variability. Benjamini-Hochberg adjusted p-values from one-sided Wilcoxon + signed-rank tests comparing the expression CV values of all gene members of + an important pathway between cell lines with and without the corresponding + driver gene mutation are shown. The red dashed line marks the adjusted p-value + cutoff of 0.05.

\n
\n

Additionally, + signal transduction pathways, such as \u201Cdiseases of signal transduction + by growth factor receptors and second messengers,\u201D were also highly ranked. + This is consistent with Rho et al. [22], + who highlighted growth factor signaling as a central mechanism in carcinogenesis. + The \u201Csignaling by receptor tyrosine kinases\u201D pathway governs essential + processes in cell growth and survival, with mutations in key members (e.g., + EGFR, HER2, MET) representing + major cancer hallmarks [23,24].

\n

Interestingly, + several immune-related pathways, such as \u201Csignaling by interleukins,\u201D + \u201Ccytokine signaling in the immune system,\u201D and \u201Cinnate immune + system\u201D, were identified as important pathways associated with the top + 15 driver genes. These pathways are known to regulate inflammation, immune + signaling, and tumor-immune interactions that contribute to cancer initiation + and progression. Aberrant interleukin and cytokine signaling can activate + oncogenic pathways such as JAK/STAT3 and PI3K-AKT, while dysregulation of + innate immune signaling promotes chronic inflammation and immune evasion [25\u201327].

\n
\n\nDriver-associated + pathways show Reactome proximity and independent expression variability\n

To + assess the validity of the identified pathways, we measured their proximity + to corresponding driver genes within the Reactome hierarchy. We calculated + the shortest path length between each important pathway node (Dp\u22650.1) + and its corresponding driver gene, comparing against random pathway nodes + at the same level (20 random samplings). As shown in Fig 2B, important pathway nodes are significantly + closer to their corresponding driver genes than random ones (Benjamini-Hochberg + adjusted p-values\u2009<\u20090.05 for all comparisons, paired Wilcoxon + signed-rank tests).

\n

We further evaluated the relationship between + pathway importance and hierarchical proximity. Across nearly all drivers, + the relative difference in shortest-path length between important and random + pathways positively correlated with pathway rank (Fig + 2C). Thus, the more important a pathway is, the closer it is to the + driver gene compared to random pathways at the same layer. Notably, genes + with higher driver potential scores exhibit stronger correlations, as shown + in Fig 2C, where genes + are ordered by their scores. Together, these results support the use of Dp + for interpretable pathway prioritization and reinforce the utility of the + driver potential score as a functional association measure.

\n

To explore + the underlying mechanisms by which the pathways promote tumorigenesis, we + examined pathway expression stochasticity. In our previous study [28], we found that pathways important for + cell type stratification often exhibit differential expression stochasticity, + measured by the coefficient of variation (CV; standard deviation over mean), + rather than differences in mean expression between cell type groups. Here, + for each important pathway, we calculated the expression CV for all genes + within the pathway, comparing cell lines with the corresponding driver gene + mutated versus unmutated, and assessed significance using a Wilcoxon signed-rank + test. As shown in Fig 2D, + of the 357 pathways analyzed (Dp\u22650.1 + across the 15 highest-scoring gene models, S6 Table), 193 display a Benjamini-Hochberg + adjusted p-value below 0.05. These findings emphasize that expression variability + rather than mean differences may characterize driver-associated pathways, + which is an insight often overlooked by traditional gene set enrichment analyses. + Importantly, xNNDriver does not use expression data, so these stochasticity + patterns are independent of model training and reflect intrinsic pathway characteristics.

\n
\n\nThe unsupervised xAEDriver model learns multiple-driver + functional representations\n

The success of xNNDriver suggests that + genome-wide dependency scores for a tumor cell line contain information predictive + of driver-associated functional states. Building on this, and recognizing + that multiple driver mechanisms collectively shape tumorigenesis, we developed + the unsupervised xAEDriver model to infer multiple driver variant representations + (DVRs) that encapsulate cell-line-specific dependency and expression profiles + while being regularized toward the population-level frequency distribution + of known functional driver SNVs (Fig + 3A). xAEDriver integrates gene dependency and expression data using + an autoencoder with a fully connected encoder and a biologically informed + decoder constrained by the Reactome pathway hierarchy. The latent layer captures + lower-dimensional embeddings of the data. Here, to guide xAEDriver in generating + hidden \u201Cdriver mutation\u201D information, we incorporated data from + known functional driver SNVs to steer the autoencoder's training, ensuring + that the lower-dimensional embeddings (referred to as DVRs) have frequency + distributions similar to real driver SNVs (Materials and methods). We then + applied layer-wise relevance propagation (LRP) to identify important pathways + contributing to the reconstruction, enabling us to uncover additional biological + insights related to the latent functional states.

\n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g003Unsupervised xAEDriver model to reconstruct driver + variant representations (DVRs).

(A) Workflow of xAEDriver. + Gene dependency and expression data are jointly used to train an autoencoder + with a fully connected encoder and a biologically constrained decoder aligned + with the Reactome hierarchy. The encoder produces low-dimensional embeddings + (DVRs) representing cell-line-specific driver states. Known driver SNVs are + incorporated into training using a truncated binomial modeling approach. + (B) Illustration of cancer type matching ratio. As an example, among + three cell lines with mutations of the DVR (value\u2009=\u20091), two match + the reported cancer type (melanoma) for the corresponding (the most similar) + known driver SNV, yielding a matching ratio of 23. + Similarly, for the most similar real driver SNV, the matching ratio is 1 (22). + (C) Comparison of cancer-type matching ratios between DVRs (blue) + and their most similar known driver SNVs (red). The data are sorted in descending + order based on the matching ratios of the DVRs.

\n
\n
\n\nDVRs recapitulate + driver-mutation frequency and represent the overall driver mutation status + of a cancer cell line\n

To evaluate the effectiveness of the guided + learning in xAEDriver, we compared the mutation distribution of known driver + SNVs with that of DVRs across all cell lines (S3 Fig). The mutation distribution of DVRs + closely matched that of actual driver mutations, as demonstrated by the Earth + Mover\u2019s Distance (EMD) of 5.4 (on a 0\u20131,000 scale) between their + mutation patterns. EMD, a metric for assessing distribution similarity, represents + the minimum effort required to transform one distribution into another [29]. These results underscore + the effectiveness of the regularization term in mimicking the distribution + of real mutations, guiding xAEDriver to actually learn DVRs in the hidden + layer.

\n

Next, we examined whether each DVR\u2019s artificial mutation + status (coded as 1 in the artificial representation vector) matched the reported + cancer type of its closest real SNV, determined via Euclidean distance. The + cancer type matching ratio was calculated as illustrated in Fig 3B. After excluding 481 DVRs with non-unique + matched real SNVs, 61 out of 440 DVRs achieved a matching ratio\u2009\u2265\u20090.5 + (Fig 3C), suggesting + that many DVRs capture cancer-type-specific mutation patterns. Among the remaining + 379 DVRs with a matching ratio below 0.5, 263 (or 69%) still had a matching + ratio greater than or equal to that of their corresponding real SNV. This + suggests that the associated real mutations are often observed in a cancer + type different from the one reported. This could be due to several factors: + the driver mutation may drive tumorigenesis in another cellular context or + a different cancer type, or the mutation may emerge during cancer progression + as a compensatory mechanism or an accelerating \u201Csecond hit\u201D.

\n
\n\nxAEDriver highlights pathways central to tumor progression\n

Using + layer-wise relevance propagation (LRP) in xAEDriver, we computed pathway relevance + scores (Rp,c) + for each pathway p + and cell line c, + where higher values indicate greater contribution to the reconstruction of + the autoencoder. Averaging across all cell lines yielded overall pathway importance + (Rp). + Fig 4 shows the top + 20 pathways ranked by Rp + values, with the complete list provided in S7 Table. The top pathways, such as \u201Ccomplement + cascade\u201D (rank 1), \u201CTNFR2 non-canonical NF-kB pathway\u201D (rank + 2), and \u201CHuR (ELAVL1) binds and stabilizes mRNA\u201D (rank 6), have + been previously linked to tumor progression. For example, Rutkowski et al. + [30] highlighted + the role of the complement cascade in driving cancer by promoting key hallmarks + of its progression. Albini et al. [31] + demonstrated that RAF2 inactivating mutations increase alternative + NF-kB pathway activation in mantle cell lymphoma, diffuse large B-cell lymphoma, + and multiple myeloma. Cai et al. [32] + revealed that ELAVL1 is an m6A-binding protein highly expressed + in multiple tumors that regulates RNA stability to promote tumor progression. + These results confirm that xAEDriver effectively uncovers biologically meaningful + pathways central to tumor biology.

\n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g004Important pathways identified from xAEDriver.

The + top 20 pathways ordered by Rp + values are shown.

\n
\n
\n\nDVRs link multi-driver functional states to drug response\n

Having + established that xAEDriver captures meaningful driver variant representations + (DVRs), we next investigated whether these DVRs are associated with functional + outcomes in cancer cells, specifically their ability to reflect tissue-specific + drug sensitivity patterns and provide mechanistic insights into differential + drug responses. To address this, we constructed LASSO regression models to + predict drug sensitivity (AUC) for each drug using the DVR binary matrix across + our panel of cancer cell lines (Materials and methods). DVR-based models significantly + outperformed those trained on an equivalent number of random somatic mutations + in the test set. Twelve DVR models achieved a test-set R2>0.05, + whereas none of the 50 random models met this threshold (complete list in + S8 Table).

\n

For + each of the twelve DVR-based models passing this performance threshold, we + identified the ten most influential DVRs based on the absolute values of their + LASSO coefficients, comparing them to a control set of ten randomly selected + DVRs. The biological relevance of these top DVRs was evaluated using a tissue + concordance score (Materials and methods), which quantifies the alignment + between each DVR\u2019s mutation distribution across tissues and the tissue + distribution of the most drug-sensitive cell lines (lowest AUC values). These + top DVRs showed significantly higher tissue concordance scores than random + controls, indicating that they capture tissue-specific drug response patterns + (mean p\u2009=\u20090.0015\xB10.0018 + across 10 independent random samplings, paired Wilcoxon signed-rank test, + Fig 5A). These results + demonstrate that DVRs effectively prioritize biologically meaningful, tissue-specific + features associated with drug sensitivity.

\n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g005DVRs from xAEDriver reveal drug-response patterns + via LASSO regression and distance-based stratification.

(A) + Differential tissue concordance of DVRs. The displayed points correspond to + one representative random-control sampling, in which the top 10 DVRs from + LASSO models for twelve LASSO-explainable drugs show significantly higher + tissue concordance scores than random DVRs (p\u2009=\u20090.0005, paired Wilcoxon + signed-rank test). Across 10 independent random-control samplings, this comparison + remained significant (mean p\u2009=\u20090.0015, SD\u2009=\u20090.0018). (B-E) + Differential drug sensitivity. Cell lines stratified by DVR dissimilarity, + DVR-divergent (high dissimilarity) and DVR-convergent (low dissimilarity), + exhibit distinct drug responses. The DVR-convergent group shows significantly + higher sensitivity (lower AUC) to drugs (B) Velban, (C) + ICL1100013, (D) Mirin, and (E) Alecensa (all Benjamini-Hochberg + adjusted p\u2009=\u20090.02, t-tests). (F) Pathway hierarchy + tree for the top 10 important pathways in the DVR-divergent and DVR-convergent + groups. Highlighted pathways illustrate representative differences in Rp + (pathway importance) between groups. Gray nodes denote parent pathways connecting + these top-ranked nodes, while non-relevant child and sibling nodes are omitted + for clarity.

\n
\n

Next, + we stratified cancer cell lines based on their DVR binary matrix using a distance-based + approach (Materials and methods). This analysis divided the cell lines into + a DVR-divergent (high dissimilarity) group (n\u2009=\u200976) and a DVR-convergent + (low dissimilarity) group (n\u2009=\u2009430). Comparison of drug responses + between these two groups identified seven drugs with significantly different + AUC values (Benjamini-Hochberg adjusted p-value\u2009<\u20090.05, t-test). + Fig 5B\u20135E highlight four representative + drugs, including Velban, ICL1100013, Mirin, and Alecensa. Interestingly, all + four drugs were more effective in the larger DVR-convergent group, suggesting + shared vulnerabilities across a broad spectrum of cancer cell lines. The boxplots + for the other three drugs, SN38, Mps-1-IN-1, and Y-39983, are shown in S4 Fig.

\n

To + further assess the relationship between DVR and drug response, we correlated + the pairwise Euclidean distances between cell lines in the DVR space with + the pairwise Pearson\u2019s correlations of their drug response (AUC) profiles. + This analysis revealed a significant, though modest, negative correlation + (PCC\u2009= \u22120.04, p-value\u2009=\u20095.5\xD710-39), + indicating that cell lines with greater DVR dissimilarity tend to exhibit + less similar drug sensitivity patterns. These results demonstrate that DVR-based + stratification can effectively distinguish cell lines with distinct drug response + profiles.

\n

To explore the biological mechanisms underlying these differences, + we analyzed pathway relevance within each cell line group. All 680 pathways + were ranked by their average relevance scores across cell lines (S9 Table), revealing group-specific enrichment + among the top pathways (Fig + 5F). For example, the \u201CAdaptive immune system\u201D pathway ranked + 7th in the DVR-convergent group but 654th in the DVR-divergent group, consistent + with higher sensitivity to Velban and ICL1100013 in the DVR-convergent group + (Fig 5B\u20135C). Previous findings show + that local low-dose Velban injection enhances adaptive immunity via dendritic + cell maturation [33], + while ICL1100013 targets NMT1, an enzyme critical for T-cell + receptor signaling and immune function [34,35]. Similarly, the \u201CBase + excision repair\u201D (BER) pathway ranked much higher in the DVR-convergent + group (10th vs. 564th in the DVR-divergent group), consistent with increased + sensitivity to Mirin (an MRE11 inhibitor) and Alecensa (an + ALK inhibitor) (Fig + 5D\u20135E). + These associations are mechanistically coherent: MRE11 plays + key roles in BER and single-strand break repair [36], + while Alecensa resistance, characterized by low SFTPD expression, + has been linked to elevated BER pathway activity [37]. Together, these findings suggest that + enhanced immune and DNA repair pathway activities underlie the heightened + drug sensitivity observed in the DVR-convergent group.

\n

Overall, these + results demonstrate that DVR-based representations capture biologically and + therapeutically relevant signals, enabling the identification of tissue-specific + patterns, drug sensitivities, and underlying pathway mechanisms in cancer + cell lines.

\n
\n\nAblation study supports + the importance of frequency-guided regularization\n

To assess whether + the truncated binomial distribution penalty provides a useful inductive bias + or instead introduces circularity by injecting known driver mutation statistics + into the latent representation, we performed an ablation study. We trained + a binomial-penalty-ablated xAEDriver model in which the autoencoder was optimized + using only reconstruction loss and L2 weight regularization, while removing + the frequency-guided penalty from the latent layer.

\n

The binomial penalty + used in xAEDriver is intentionally low-information. It does not encode driver + gene identity, pathway membership, tissue type, drug response, or any one-to-one + correspondence between DVRs and known driver SNVs. Instead, it constrains + only the marginal frequency distribution of DVR presence across cell lines, + encouraging the latent variables to have a sparsity pattern broadly similar + to observed functional driver SNVs. Many different DVR-cell line assignments + could satisfy the same frequency distribution; therefore, the biological and + pharmacological associations of DVRs must still be learned from the dependency + and expression data during autoencoder training.

\n

Removal of the binomial + penalty substantially reduced downstream performance. The number of drugs + with held-out test-set R\xB2\u2009>\u20090.05 decreased from 12 to 2, and + the maximum test-set R\xB2 declined from approximately 0.34 to 0.08 (S10 Table). + Tissue concordance of the top predictive DVRs also became non-significant, + with the paired Wilcoxon signed-rank test p-value changing from 0.0015 to + 0.5. In addition, DVR-based stratification no longer identified any drugs + with significantly different sensitivity between DVR-divergent and DVR-convergent + cell lines, compared with seven drugs identified by the original model using + Benjamini-Hochberg adjusted p-value\u2009<\u20090.05.

\n

These results + indicate that the binomial penalty improves the biological coherence and downstream + utility of the learned latent space. Rather than imposing specific biological + annotations, the frequency-guided penalty acts as a weak population-level + prior that discourages degenerate latent representations and helps xAEDriver + recover DVRs that remain informative for drug response, tissue concordance, + and pathway-level interpretation.

\n
\n
\n\nDiscussion\n

In this study, we + introduce interpretable functional-genomics frameworks for linking cancer + driver alterations to genome-wide dependency landscapes, pathway programs, + and drug-response structure in cancer cell lines. xNNDriver prioritizes candidate + driver genes by quantifying how strongly their mutation status is reflected + in dependency profiles, while xAEDriver learns multi-driver functional representations + that summarize broader oncogenic states. Together, these models show that + DepMap dependency data encode biologically interpretable signals of driver + activity and treatment-relevant vulnerability.

\n

xNNDriver reframes + driver identification from a purely mutation-frequency paradigm to a systems-level + functional consequence paradigm. The fact that known drivers score highly + supports the biological signal embedded in dependency landscapes. Furthermore, + the model is applied uniformly to 3,008 candidate genes and identifies both + established and literature-supported but not yet DepMap-annotated candidates. + Importantly, the driver potential score quantifies the functional footprint + of mutations rather than their recurrence alone.

\n

Given that the dependency + score of the candidate driver gene provides a quantifiable functional signature + of driver activity, it was included as an input feature and could be intrinsically + selected during model training. For example, loss of an oncogene often reduces + cell viability (low dependency score), whereas loss of a tumor suppressor + enhances growth (high dependency score). As shown in S5 Fig, TP53, a tumor suppressor, + exhibits the highest mean dependency score (0.426), while NRAS, + an oncogene, shows a low value (\u22120.654). However, HRAS, + another oncogenic driver, displays a near-neutral score (\u22120.107), underscoring + that single-gene dependency alone provides only partial information about + driver status. Indeed, the self-dependency exclusion experiment showed that + top drivers retained substantial predictive performance after their own dependency + scores were removed, indicating that xNNDriver also captures distributed dependency + signals across other genes. For some candidates, performance decreased after + removal, suggesting a stronger contribution from direct self-dependency. Thus, + we interpret the driver potential score as an integrated mutation-dependency + association measure that can reflect self-dependency, network-level dependency + effects, or both.

\n

xNNDriver-prioritized pathways frequently exhibited + lower expression CV in driver-mutant cell lines, even when differences in + mean expression were modest. Because these estimates were derived from bulk + RNA-seq across cell lines, they reflect inter-cell-line pathway-state variability + rather than single-cell transcriptional noise. Reduced variability may indicate + driver-induced canalization, in which oncogenic alterations lock downstream + pathways into more stable transcriptional states. In non-mutated contexts, + higher pathway variability may reflect dynamic responses to environmental, + genetic, and regulatory cues, whereas driver mutations may restrict this flexibility + by enforcing a constitutive pathway state. This state-locking provides a plausible + mechanistic link to the dependency footprints captured by xNNDriver, because + tumor cells may become more reliant on the altered pathway or its compensatory + networks and less able to adapt to CRISPR perturbations. Because expression + data were not used to train xNNDriver, the observed decrease in pathway expression + variability provides independent biological support for the functional dependency + footprints identified by the model.

\n

To model complex combinatorial + functional states, we developed the unsupervised xAEDriver model. While xNNDriver + excels at evaluating individual driver genes, it is not inherently designed + to capture systemic, multi-driver states. In contrast, xAEDriver represents + a conceptual shift from single-driver evaluation to multi-driver functional + state inference by encoding cell-line-specific patterns that mimic the behavior + of real functional driver variants through guided learning.

\n

DVRs showed + biologically interpretable and drug-associated patterns. Using LASSO regression, + we demonstrated that the DVR-based predictions of drug response also exhibited + strong tissue-type specificity, supporting their biological relevance. Furthermore, + DVR-based stratification of cancer cell lines revealed distinct groups with + significantly different drug sensitivity profiles and pathway activities. + This stratification identified specific vulnerabilities, such as enhanced + response to immune-related or DNA repair-targeting drugs, highlighting the + translational potential of DVRs in predicting therapeutic responses and informing + precision oncology strategies.

\n

The ablation analysis of xAEDriver + supports the importance of frequency-guided regularization in shaping biologically + interpretable DVRs, but the role of the truncated binomial prior should be + interpreted with caution. This prior does not encode specific driver gene + identities, pathway annotations, tissue labels, drug-response information, + or one-to-one mappings between DVRs and known driver SNVs. Instead, it provides + only a coarse prevalence constraint, encouraging DVRs to follow the broad + sparsity pattern observed for functional driver SNVs while leaving the specific + DVR-cell line assignments to be learned from dependency and expression data. + This design helps balance flexibility and biological structure in the latent + space: it discourages overly dense or degenerate representations optimized + only for reconstruction, while still allowing DVRs to capture novel combinations + of functional states. Thus, we view the binomial penalty as a weak inductive + bias that improves latent-space organization, rather than as evidence that + mutation frequency itself determines driver importance. Future work may explore + alternative priors, including cancer-type-specific or context-adaptive priors, + to better capture rare driver states.

\n

To enhance interpretability, + both xNNDriver and xAEDriver incorporated biologically informed neural network + architectures guided by the Reactome pathway hierarchy. Rather than acting + merely as a sparsity constraint, this design embeds the hierarchy directly + into the network to aggregate signals across levels, enabling the mechanistic + attribution of driver effects. We do not view the pathway-constrained architecture + alone as proof of a causal mechanism; instead, pathway attributions are supported + by standalone proximity analysis, expression-stochasticity analyses, and consistency + with external literature. In xNNDriver, the identified important pathways + demonstrate hierarchical coherence and expression variability patterns. In + xAEDriver, a biologically constrained decoder preserves pathway structure + while allowing the encoder to learn flexible representations, since fully + constraining both sides proved too restrictive and often produced trivial + DVRs. Ultimately, the pathways identified by both models confirm the biological + robustness of our framework, providing interpretable and biologically grounded + insights beyond conventional pathway enrichment analyses.

\n

Despite + the utility of DepMap as a comprehensive functional-genomics resource, several + limitations should be acknowledged. Genome-scale CRISPR knockout screens measure + the effect of additional gene loss on cancer-cell fitness. This design is + well suited to detecting direct dependencies on activated oncogenes, but its + interpretation for tumor suppressors is more context-dependent. Some tumor + suppressor alterations can still be captured when they are associated with + direct dependency signals or broader dependency-landscape changes. For example, + TP53 exhibits a high mean dependency score (0.426), is strongly + prioritized by xNNDriver, and remains predictive after TP53\u2019s + own dependency score is removed from the input features (S5 Table). This indicates that tumor suppressor-associated + dependency signals can extend beyond dependency on the candidate gene itself. + However, tumor suppressors that are already functionally inactivated, poorly + represented in relevant tissue contexts, or mainly altered through non-SNV + mechanisms may remain difficult to detect. RB1 illustrates + this limitation: despite its established role in retinoblastoma and other + cancers, it shows no strong eye-specific signal and generally low scores in + Fig 1C. This may reflect + pre-existing RB1 loss, limited tissue representation, and + incomplete capture of non-SNV loss-of-function mechanisms, including indels, + copy-number loss, structural alterations, or epigenetic silencing. Therefore, + low xNNDriver scores should not be interpreted as evidence against the established + roles of canonical tumor suppressors. Future versions of the framework should + integrate multiple alteration types to better capture tumor-suppressor biology.

\n

Second, + DepMap also identifies pan-essential housekeeping genes whose loss broadly + impairs cell fitness. Such dependencies may contribute to driver-associated + functional footprints but are unlikely to provide a favorable therapeutic + window because of potential on-target, off-tumor toxicity. Therefore, xNNDriver + pathway scores indicate functional associations rather than direct therapeutic + tractability, which requires additional evaluation of tumor selectivity and + normal-tissue tolerance.

\n

Looking ahead, expanding the models to include + larger and more diverse datasets will improve the detection of both common + and rare driver mutations across different cancer types. This broader scope + will refine our understanding of gene dependencies and mutation synergies, + leading to more accurate prediction of therapeutic vulnerabilities. Ultimately, + the integration of dependency data with mutational and pharmacological information + will advance precision oncology by enabling more personalized and effective + cancer treatment strategies.

\n
\n\nMaterials + and methods\n\nDatasets\n\nThe + DepMap database.\n

We utilized data from the Cancer Dependency Map + (DepMap) projects (23Q2 version). This release contains data from CRISPR-Cas9 + knockout screens across multiple tumor types, as part of Broad\u2019s Achilles + [38] and Sanger\u2019s + SCORE projects [39]. + It also includes genomic and transcriptomic characterizations from the CCLE + project [40].

\n

The + primary dataset includes CRISPR-Cas9 essentiality screens for 17,931 genes + across 1,095 cell lines [9,10], resulting in a cell-line-by-screened-gene + matrix. Each entry represents the \u201Cdependency score\u201D of a screened + gene, which was processed from the log-fold change in sgRNA read counts before + and after knockout. A lower dependency score indicates a stronger reduction + in cell viability following gene knockout, implying that the gene is essential + for cell survival. Quality control and normalization were performed by DepMap.

\n

Somatic + point mutations for the DepMap cell lines were obtained from the same source + [41]. We specifically + filtered for SNVs, resulting in a final set of 1,290,926 mutations for downstream + analysis. Gene expression data (RNA-seq) were also retrieved as transcripts + per million (TPM) for 19,194 genes across 1,450 cell lines, log-transformed + with a pseudo-count of one. A total of 1,019 cell lines had both dependency + score and gene expression data available.

\n

We also downloaded drug + sensitivity data for the cell lines [42]. + From the raw data, fold-change viability values were calculated using the + R package gdscIC50 [43], + and standard four-parameter monotonic log-logistic dose-response curves were + fitted using the R package dr4pl [44]. + Drug sensitivity was then quantified as the area under the curve (AUC), covering + 320 drugs across 962 cell lines. Among these, 506 cell lines also had dependency + scores and gene expression data available.

\n
\n\nThe + COSMIC database.\n

We obtained mutation data from the Catalogue + of Somatic Mutations in Cancer (COSMIC) Cancer Mutation Census [12], filtering for SNVs. To identify functionally + significant mutations, we retained those annotated as \u201Chigh\u201D or + \u201Cmoderate\u201D impact based on consequence predictions from the Ensembl + Variation database [45].

\n
\n\nThe ClinVar database.\n

ClinVar compiles + relationships between human genetic variants and phenotypic outcomes [13]. Although primarily + focused on germline mutations, it includes somatic variants as well. We downloaded + the ClinVar summary table and filtered for SNVs annotated as: pathogenic, + likely pathogenic, affects, drug response, or confers sensitivity.

\n

We + merged the filtered COSMIC and ClinVar SNVs, yielding 28,459 clinically significant + variants also documented in DepMap. Among these, 340 were located in known + driver genes with mutations observed in at least one cell line, which we designated + as known driver mutations for model training and validation.

\n
\n
\n\nxNNDriver: Supervised model for identifying driver + genes\n\nTraining and test data.\n

Gene + names from the considered datasets were converted to Ensembl IDs using the + DAVID portal [46], + ensuring consistency with the Reactome database. Genes absent from the Reactome + database were excluded. Dependency scores were split into training (75%) and + test (25%) sets, with five-fold cross-validation on the training set for hyperparameter + tuning. Because mutation-positive samples were much fewer than negatives, + we balanced the classes during the training process by random upsampling of + positive samples to achieve a 1:1 ratio.

\n
\n\nPathway + hierarchy.\n

The Reactome database [11] + was used to construct a hierarchical pathway tree using the NetworkX Python + library. Internal nodes represent pathways, and leaves correspond to genes. + To simplify the hierarchy and reduce redundancy, each gene was linked only + to its closest pathway nodes. A hyperparameter l controlled + the number of pathway levels included. Genes or pathways absent from the data + were excluded. The resulting structure was encoded as a binary mask matrix + M, where Mi,j=1denotes + a valid connection. Following our previous work [28], + multi-layer predictive designs were employed to enhance model accuracy.

\n
\n\nNeural network construction.\n

We built a + feedforward neural network based on the mask matrix. The input layer consists + of CRISPR-Cas9 screened genes, with their corresponding dependency scores + as input data. The size of the input layer corresponds to the number of genes + allocated to the lowest level of the pathway hierarchy. For each layer, the + input is denoted as x + and the output as y. + The output of each layer is calculated as: y=f[(MW)x+b], + where f + is the activation function (tanh), M + is the mask matrix, W + is the weight matrix, and b + is the bias vector. Here, MW + is the element-wise multiplication (Hadamard product) of M + and W.

\n

The + tanh activation function was selected to provide bounded and signed hidden + representations. Because xNNDriver pathway importance is based on activation + differences between mutation-positive and mutation-negative cell lines, bounding + activations to [-1, 1] improves comparability across pathway layers and gene-specific + models. In addition, the sign of tanh activations allows the model to preserve + opposing dependency patterns, rather than truncating negative signals as ReLU + would. Although tanh may saturate in deeper networks, the relatively shallow + Reactome-guided architecture used here reduces this concern.

\n

Binary + predictions were generated using a sigmoid function: \u03C3(z)=11+e\u2212z. + A cell line was classified as 1 (mutated) if \u03C3>0.5. + Training used the Adam optimizer, cross-entropy loss, and L2 regularization. + Final predictions were aggregated across all predictive layers via majority + voting, and model performance was quantified by the AUC metric on the test + set, referred to as the driver potential score.

\n
\n\nHyperparameter + tuning.\n

We applied stepwise hyperparameter tuning with five-fold + cross-validation on the training set of the model for the candidate gene KRAS + to optimize hyperparameters. Hyperparameters were tuned sequentially in the + following order: the number of levels in the pathway hierarchy tree (l), + L2 regularization hyperparameter, learning rate, batch size, and + number of epochs. The optimal hyperparameter values based on the highest driver + potential score were l + = 3, regularization\u2009=\u20090.0001, learning rate\u2009=\u20090.01, batch + size\u2009=\u2009128, and epochs\u2009=\u2009100.

\n
\n\nEvent-level + validation.\n

Beyond the aggregate driver potential score, we performed + event-level validation to assess whether xNNDriver can correctly identify + individual mutation events in held-out cell lines. For each of the top 15 + candidate driver genes, precision was calculated as the fraction of cell lines + predicted as mutation-positive that indeed harbored the corresponding functional + mutation in DepMap, and recall was calculated as the fraction of truly mutated + cell lines that the model correctly identified. These per-gene metrics were + evaluated on the same held-out test set (~25% of all cell lines) used for + driver potential scoring.

\n
\n\nBaseline + model comparison.\n

To contextualize xNNDriver\u2019s predictive + performance, we benchmarked it against three conventional classifiers: Logistic + Regression, Random Forest, and a standard Multilayer Perceptron without pathway + constraints (all with default hyperparameters). All baseline models were trained + using the same genome-wide dependency score features, mutation-status labels, + and 75/25 training/test split as xNNDriver, but without embedding the Reactome + pathway hierarchy into the model architecture. For the top 15 candidate genes, + we compared the test-set AUROC of each baseline model with the corresponding + xNNDriver driver potential score. To further assess whether xNNDriver produced + gene rankings consistent with a simpler predictive model, we trained Logistic + Regression across candidate genes with valid xNNDriver driver potential scores + greater than 0.5 (433 genes) and calculated the Spearman rank correlation + between Logistic Regression AUROC and xNNDriver driver potential score.

\n
\n\nIdentification of important pathways in xNNDriver.\n

Pathway + importance was measured as the absolute difference in activation values between + cell lines with and without mutation for a given pathway p: + dp=|Ap,0\u2212Ap,1|. + If a pathway appears in the paths of multiple prediction layers (nested subnetworks), + we chose the maximum value of dp + across all paths as the final importance measure, denoted as Dp. + Pathways with a Dp + value greater than a predefined threshold (default: 0.1) were considered important. + If the pathway node was an artificial node introduced to preserve the pathway + tree structure, the original pathway node was retrieved.

\n
\n\nProximity analysis in the Reactome hierarchy.\n

For + each candidate driver gene, we calculated the shortest path length between + its important pathways and the gene within the Reactome tree using NetworkX. + Random pathways from the same hierarchical level served as controls. Statistical + significance was assessed using paired Wilcoxon signed-rank tests. Correlations + between relative path-length differences (the shortest path length for an + important node minus that for a random pathway node, divided by the former) + and Dpranks + (sorted descendingly) were computed using Pearson correlation coefficients + across 20 randomizations.

\n
\n\nExpression + stochasticity of the pathways.\n

Pathway expression variability + was quantified by the coefficient of variation (CV: standard deviation over + mean) of member genes across cell lines with or without the candidate gene + mutation. Differences in CV distributions were tested using the Wilcoxon signed-rank + test. Here, we use the term \u201Cexpression stochasticity\u201D operationally + to describe inter-cell-line variability in pathway expression measured from + bulk RNA-seq, rather than single-cell transcriptional bursting within individual + cells.

\n
\n
\n\nxAEDriver: Unsupervised + model for multi-driver representation learning\n\nTraining + data preparation.\n

The model xAEDriver utilized both gene dependency + score and gene expression data as input features. Cell lines present in only + one of the two data sources were excluded. For each gene j + in cell line i, + each feature was normalized within genes: normi,\_\_j=xi,\_\_j\u2212mean(x\xB7,j)max(x\xB7,j)\u2212min(x\xB7,j). + This gene-wise normalization step maps both CRISPR dependency scores and RNA-seq + gene expression data onto a comparable numerical scale. After normalization, + the gene dependency and expression data were merged into a unified matrix + by aligning cell lines.

\n
\n\nGuided learning + using known driver SNVs.\n

Known driver SNV frequencies across cell + lines were modeled using a truncated binomial distribution to exclude both + endpoints. Let X + represent the number of cell lines in which a known driver SNV is present + as the mutated allele. The truncated binomial distribution for X + is:

\nP(Xi=k)={@lr(nk)pk(1\u2212p)k1\u2212(1\u2212p)n\u2212pn,k=1,2,\u2026,n\u22121~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0,k=0orn,\n

where + n + (= (1,019) is the number of cell lines, and p + is the unknown probability of SNV being present in the population. Note that + for all known driver SNVs, k + is neither 0 nor n. + Parameter p + was estimated via maximum likelihood from the 340 known driver SNVs.

\n
\n\nAutoencoder construction.\n

The autoencoder + consists of a fully connected encoder and a biologically informed decoder. + The encoder and decoder share a symmetric structure in terms of node numbers + at each layer, and both use the tanh activation function. However, in the + decoder, certain neuron connections are masked according to the pathway-gene + mask matrix, while the encoder remains fully connected.

\n

The pathway-gene + mask matrix was constructed following the approach outlined in the description + for xNNDriver. The key distinction was in how we handled genes that appeared + in both the dependency score and expression datasets. Before integrating dependency + and expression data, each feature was normalized across cell lines by subtracting + its mean and dividing by its range, placing the two modalities on comparable + numerical scales. Then, the pathway was linked to both the \u201Cdependency\u201D + node and the \u201Cexpression\u201D node, and both entries in the mask matrix + were set to one. The binary mask matrix M + specifies only the allowed topology and does not impose equal weights across + modalities. Dependency and expression edges are assigned independently learned + weights during training, allowing the autoencoder to balance modality-specific + information and noise. For genes present in only one dataset, connections + were handled as described before.

\n

The lower-dimensional representation, + referred to as driver variant representations (DVRs), is produced in the latent + layer, which consists of 1024 neurons. Each DVR is represented by a neuron + in the latent layer with values constrained to 0 or 1, indicating the mutation + presence or absence of the DVR. The sigmoid activation function is used in + the latent layer, ensuring the binary nature of the DVRs (rounded to 0 or + 1). The autoencoder was trained by the Adam optimizer, and the cost function + includes both reconstruction loss (measured as the mean squared error between + the output layer and the input layer) and regularization terms, which include + an L2 regularization term and a binomial distribution penalty.

\n

Specifically, + the binomial distribution penalty term encourages the DVRs to resemble real + driver SNVs. In each epoch, after obtaining the lower-dimensional representations, + we computed the sum for each DVR neuron across all cell lines and denoted + it as xi. + The binomial distribution penalty term is defined as the negative logarithmic + likelihood across all DVRs (q\u2009=\u20091,024), calculated as:

\nbinomial_penalty=\u22121q\u2211i=1qlogP(X=xi).\n

If + P(X=xi) + is equal to 0, the training process will be terminated, and the rounded DVRs + from the previous epoch will be used as the final output.

\n
\n\nHyperparameter tuning.\n

Grid search was + used to tune the model\u2019s hyperparameters. For each hyperparameter combination, + we recorded the average loss over five repeats and selected the combination + yielding the lowest loss as the default. The default values for the L2 + regularization hyperparameter and binomial distribution penalty hyperparameters + were set to 0.1 and 0.001, respectively. The default learning rate was 0.01. + The default number of epochs was 1,000. The batch size was fixed at 1,019, + corresponding to the total number of cell lines, as it is required to remain + constant to compute the binomial distribution penalty.

\n
\n\nMeasuring + pathway importance by layer-wise relevance propagation.\n

To assess + the contribution of pathways in generating DVRs, we employed layer-wise relevance + propagation (LRP) with the epsilon rule [47]. + LRP decomposes the prediction by propagating relevance scores backward through + the autoencoder\u2019s layers. For a given cell line c, the + relevance score rj,c + for neuron j is calculated as:

\nrj,c=\u2211kaj,cwj,k\u03B5+\u2211iai,cwi,krk,c,\n

where + k denotes a neuron in the subsequent layer (closer to the + output), and i iterates over all neurons in the same layer + as j that connect to k. Given the pathway-constrained + hierarchy of our architecture, these connections are sparse, meaning wi,k + is non-zero only for biologically established links. Here, aj,c + and ai,c + represent the forward-pass activation values, wj,k + and wi,k + are the corresponding connection weights, and \u03B5 + is a small positive constant. The relevance scores are propagated from the + output layer to the input layer. We compute normalized relevance scores for + each layer using z-scores, and the pathway importance is quantified by examining + the decoder layer. The final normalized relevance score for pathway j + and cell line c + is denoted as Rj,c.

\n
\n\nLASSO regression model for DVR-drug association.\n

For + each drug, a LASSO regression model was built with DVRs as predictors and + drug AUC values as responses. Data were split into training (80%) and test + (20%) sets. Models were trained using a LASSO regularization parameter (\u03B1) + of 0.001 and a maximum of 2,000 iterations. Predictive models (R\xB2\u2009>\u20090.05) + were analyzed for their top 10 DVRs based on coefficient magnitude. LASSO + models were also built on 50 sets of random mutation controls for comparison.

\n

To + evaluate the biological relevance of the top DVRs, we calculated a tissue + concordance score for each DVR. For a given drug, we defined two groups of + cell lines: (1) the DVR-positive group, consisting of all cell lines in which + the DVR was present (value\u2009=\u20091), and (2) the drug-sensitive group, + consisting of an equal number of cell lines showing the strongest response + to the drug (i.e., the lowest AUC values). The tissue concordance score was + defined as the degree of overlap in tissue-type composition between these + two groups, normalized by group size. This score reflects the degree of tissue-specific + association between DVR presence and drug response.

\n

As a control, + for each drug, we randomly selected ten DVRs that were not among the top ten + and repeated the concordance analysis. We then compared the tissue concordance + scores between the top DVRs and the random controls using a paired Wilcoxon + signed-rank test to assess statistical significance.

\n

The regularization + parameter \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.001 was empirically selected to balance feature + sparsity and model capacity in high-dimensional functional genomics data: + excessively large \u03B1 values force most coefficients to zero, while excessively + small values lead to overfitting. To verify the robustness of this choice, + we retrained the LASSO models across different \u03B1 values and evaluated + the number of predictive models (test R2 + > 0.05) and resulting tissue concordance p-values + (S11 Table). + Extreme settings reduced predictive performance, whereas \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.001 + and \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.0005 both produced 12 predictive drug models and + significant tissue concordance. We therefore retained \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.001 + as the primary setting within a robust effective range.

\n
\n\nDistance-based DVR stratification for drug sensitivity + patterns.\n

We calculated the total Euclidean distance of each cell + line to all others in DVR space and stratified lines into DVR-divergent (large + total distance) and DVR-convergent (small total distance) groups using the + 85th percentile cutoff. The 85th percentile was chosen as a data-driven threshold + that balances signal purity and statistical power, as confirmed by a sensitivity + analysis across adjacent percentiles (75th\u201390th). Drug sensitivity (AUC) + differences were assessed with Welch\u2019s t-test, omitting cell lines lacking + drug data.

\n
\n
\n
\n\nSupporting + information\n\n\n\nPrediction + performance of xNNDriver for the top 30 genes with the highest driver potential + scores using all SNVs.\n

All somatic SNVs, no matter whether annotated + as functional or not, are used. Data point color indicates the number of cell + lines with mutations in that gene. Gene name color distinguishes whether a + gene is a known driver or not (purple: driver, black: non-driver), as documented + by DepMap.

\n

(TIF)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nEvent-level + validation of xNNDriver predictions for the top 15 candidate driver genes.\n

Blue + bars indicate precision, defined as the fraction of cell lines predicted as + mutation-positive that carried the corresponding catalogued functional mutation + in DepMap. Green bars indicate recall, defined as the fraction of cell lines + with a catalogued functional mutation that were predicted as mutation-positive + by xNNDriver. Predictions were evaluated on the held-out test set (~275 cell + lines) for each gene.

\n

(TIF)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nComparison + of mutation frequency distributions between DVRs from xAEDriver and known + functional driver SNVs.\n

The histograms display the frequency of + mutation occurrences across cell lines for (A) DVRs and (B) known driver SNVs.

\n

(TIF)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nDifferential + drug sensitivity for additional significant drugs.\n

DVR-divergent + and DVR-convergent cell lines show distinct drug responses for (A) SN38 (Benjamini-Hochberg + adjusted p + = 0.04), (B) Mps-1-IN-1 (adjusted p + = 0.03), and (C) Y-39983 (adjusted p + = 0.02), based on t-tests followed by Benjamini-Hochberg p value adjustments.

\n

(TIF)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nDistribution + of mean dependency scores of all genes.\n

The histogram illustrates + the distribution of mean dependency scores across all cell lines for all genes + in the DepMap gene dependency dataset.

\n

(TIF)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nComprehensive + results of all xNNDriver models using functional SNVs.\n

Each model + corresponds to a frequently mutated candidate gene (3,008 in total). Information + includes the following metrics: driver potential score, the number of cell + lines with mutation presence, the number of cell lines without mutation presence, + and whether the gene is annotated as a driver based on DepMap.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nComprehensive + results of all xNNDriver models using all SNVs.\n

Each model corresponds + to a frequently mutated candidate gene (3,008 in total). Information includes + the following metrics: driver potential score, the number of cell lines with + mutation presence, the number of cell lines without mutation presence, and + whether the gene is a driver based on DepMap.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nAUPRC evaluation + of xNNDriver for the top 15 genes.\n

Each entry reports the test-set + AUPRC for an xNNDriver model evaluated without upsampling, preserving the + native mutation-class imbalance.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nBaseline + model comparison.\n

Prediction performance (driver potential score) + of xNNDriver, Logistic Regression, Random Forest, and an unconstrained Multilayer + Perceptron is shown for the top 15 candidate genes using the same genome-wide + dependency features and mutation-status labels. The table also reports the + broader comparison between xNNDriver and Logistic Regression for the 433 genes + with xNNDriver driver potential score\u2009>\u20090.5.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nSelf-dependency + exclusion analysis for the top 15 genes.\n

Each entry reports the + driver potential score after removing the candidate gene\u2019s own dependency + score from the input features.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nImportant + pathways identified from xNNDriver for candidate driver genes.\n

This + table includes a comprehensive summary combining results for all 15 genes, + as well as 15 individual sheets detailing results for each gene. The overall + table also provides the adjusted p-values from the Wilcoxon tests on the comparison + of coefficients of variation of pathway expression between cell lines with + and without mutations.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nPathway + importance from xAEDriver.\n

This table includes the average Rp + values across all cell lines. Pathways marked with \u201C_copy1\u201D indicate + artificial nodes created to preserve the pathway tree structure.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nTest set + <inline-formula id=\"pcbi.1014869.e073\"><alternatives><graphic id=\"pcbi.1014869.e073g\" + mimetype=\"image\" position=\"anchor\" xlink:href=\"info:doi/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.e073\" + xlink:type=\"simple\"/><mml:math display=\"inline\" id=\"M73\"><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:msup><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi + mathvariant=\"bold-italic\">R</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mn + mathvariant=\"bold\">2</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:msup></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:math></alternatives></inline-formula> + values of LASSO regression models based on DVRs and random somatic mutations.\n

Random + control results are averaged over 50 runs.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nAverage + pathway importance (<inline-formula id=\"pcbi.1014869.e074\"><alternatives><graphic + id=\"pcbi.1014869.e074g\" mimetype=\"image\" position=\"anchor\" xlink:href=\"info:doi/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.e074\" + xlink:type=\"simple\"/><mml:math display=\"inline\" id=\"M74\"><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi + mathvariant=\"bold-italic\">R</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi + mathvariant=\"bold-italic\">p</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:math></alternatives></inline-formula> + values) and rankings for the DVR-divergent and DVR-convergent groups.\n

Reported + metrics include average Rp + and rank for each group.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nDrug-response + prediction using DVRs learned without the binomial penalty.\n

Test-set + R\xB2 values are shown for LASSO regression models trained on DVRs from the + binomial-penalty-ablated xAEDriver model.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n\n\n\nSensitivity + analysis of LASSO regularization parameter (\u03B1).\n

The number + of predictive drug models (test-set R2 + > 0.05) and the corresponding tissue-concordance p-values are shown across + a range of \u03B1 values.

\n

(XLSX)

\n\n
\n
\n\n\n\n

We + thank Dr. Sika Zheng at the University of California, Riverside, Yingtong + Liu, and all members of the Chen lab for their discussions and suggestions + throughout this study.

\n
\n\nReferences\nPorta-Pardo + E, Valencia + A, Godzik + A. Understanding oncogenicity + of cancer driver genes and mutations in the cancer genomics era. + FEBS Lett. 2020;594(24):4233\u201346. + doi: 10.1002/1873-3468.13781 32239503\nSong + Q, Li + M, Li + Q, Lu + X, Song + K, Zhang + Z, et al. DeepAlloDriver: + a deep learning-based strategy to predict cancer driver mutations. + Nucleic Acids Res. 2023;51(W1):W129\u201333. + doi: 10.1093/nar/gkad295 37078611\nZeng + Z, Mao + C, Vo + A, Li + X, Nugent + JO, Khan + SA, et al. Deep + learning for cancer type classification and driver gene identification. + BMC Bioinformatics. 2021;22(Suppl + 4):491. doi: 10.1186/s12859-021-04400-4 34689757\nPeng + W, Tang + Q, Dai + W, Chen + T. Improving cancer driver + gene identification using multi-task learning on graph convolutional network. + Brief Bioinform. 2022;23(1):bbab432. + doi: 10.1093/bib/bbab432 34643232\nLiu + Y, Baugh + AG, Roussos + Torres ET, MacLean + AL. Inference of marker genes + of subtle cell state changes via iLR: iterative logistic regression. + Bioinformatics. 2026;42(2):btag051. + doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btag051 + 41627891\nYin + Q, Wang + Y, Guan + J, Ji + G. scIAE: an integrative + autoencoder-based ensemble classification framework for single-cell RNA-seq + data. Brief Bioinform. 2022;23(1):bbab508. + doi: 10.1093/bib/bbab508 34913057\nvan + der Weyden L, Jonkers + J, Adams + DJ. The use of CRISPR/Cas9-based + gene editing strategies to explore cancer gene function in mice. + Curr Opin Genet Dev. 2021;66:57\u201362. + doi: 10.1016/j.gde.2020.12.005 33429291\nChiu + Y-C, Zheng + S, Wang + L-J, Iskra + BS, Rao + MK, Houghton + PJ, et al. Predicting + and characterizing a cancer dependency map of tumors with deep learning. + Sci Adv. 2021;7(34):eabh1275. + doi: 10.1126/sciadv.abh1275 34417181\nDempster + JM, Rossen + J, Kazachkova + M, Pan + J, Kugener + G, Root + DE. Extracting biological + insights from the project achilles genome-scale CRISPR screens in cancer cell + lines. BioRxiv. 2019. doi: + 10.1101/720243\nMeyers + RM, Bryan + JG, McFarland + JM, Weir + BA, Sizemore + AE, Xu + H, et al. Computational + correction of copy number effect improves specificity of CRISPR-Cas9 essentiality + screens in cancer cells. Nat Genet. 2017;49(12):1779\u201384. + doi: 10.1038/ng.3984 29083409\nJoshi-Tope + G, Gillespie + M, Vastrik + I, D\u2019Eustachio + P, Schmidt + E, de + Bono B, et al. Reactome: + a knowledgebase of biological pathways. Nucleic Acids + Res. 2005;33(Database issue):D428-32. + doi: 10.1093/nar/gki072 15608231\nForbes + SA, Bindal + N, Bamford + S, Cole + C, Kok + CY, Beare + D, et al. COSMIC: + mining complete cancer genomes in the Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer. + Nucleic Acids Res. 2011;39(Database + issue):D945-50. doi: 10.1093/nar/gkq929 20952405\nLandrum + MJ, Lee + JM, Riley + GR, Jang + W, Rubinstein + WS, Church + DM, et al. ClinVar: + public archive of relationships among sequence variation and human phenotype. + Nucleic Acids Res. 2014;42(Database + issue):D980-5. doi: 10.1093/nar/gkt1113 24234437\nKuenzi + BM, Park + J, Fong + SH, Sanchez + KS, Lee + J, Kreisberg + JF, et al. Predicting + Drug Response and Synergy Using a Deep Learning Model of Human Cancer Cells. + Cancer Cell. 2020;38(5):672-684.e6. + doi: 10.1016/j.ccell.2020.09.014 33096023\nMurakami + H, Mizuno + T, Taniguchi + T, Fujii + M, Ishiguro + F, Fukui + T, et al. LATS2 + is a tumor suppressor gene of malignant mesothelioma. Cancer + Res. 2011;71(3):873\u201383. + doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-10-2164 21245096\nStrazisar + M, Mlakar + V, Glavac + D. LATS2 tumour specific + mutations and down-regulation of the gene in non-small cell carcinoma. + Lung Cancer. 2009;64(3):257\u201362. + doi: 10.1016/j.lungcan.2008.09.011 19008013\nZimmerman + SM, Lin + PN, Souroullas + GP. Non-canonical functions + of EZH2 in cancer. Front Oncol. 2023;13:1233953. + doi: 10.3389/fonc.2023.1233953 37664059\nSasaki + H, Suzuki + A, Shitara + M, Okuda + K, Hikosaka + Y, Moriyama + S, et al. Keap1 + mutations in lung cancer patients. Oncol Lett. + 2013;6(3):719\u201321. + doi: 10.3892/ol.2013.1427 24137397\nAl-Masri + M, Al-Shobaki + T, Al-Najjar + H, Iskanderian + R, Younis + E, Abdallah + N, et al. BRAF + V600E mutation in papillary thyroid carcinoma: it\u2019s relation to clinical + features and oncologic outcomes in a single cancer centre experience. + Endocr Connect. 2021;10(12):1531\u20137. + doi: 10.1530/EC-21-0410 34734568\nLee + K-H, Hwang + H-J, Noh + HJ, Shin + T-J, Cho + J-Y. Somatic Mutation of + PIK3CA (H1047R) Is a Common Driver Mutation Hotspot in Canine Mammary Tumors + as Well as Human Breast Cancers. Cancers (Basel). + 2019;11(12):2006. + doi: 10.3390/cancers11122006 31842489\nVander + Heiden MG, DeBerardinis + RJ. Understanding the Intersections + between Metabolism and Cancer Biology. Cell. + 2017;168(4):657\u201369. + doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2016.12.039 28187287\nRho + O, Kim + DJ, Kiguchi + K, Digiovanni + J. Growth factor signaling + pathways as targets for prevention of epithelial carcinogenesis. + Mol Carcinog. 2011;50(4):264\u201379. + doi: 10.1002/mc.20665 20648549\nLemmon + MA, Schlessinger + J. Cell signaling by receptor + tyrosine kinases. Cell. 2010;141(7):1117\u201334. + doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2010.06.011 20602996\nYarden + Y, Pines + G. The ERBB network: at last, + cancer therapy meets systems biology. Nat Rev Cancer. + 2012;12(8):553\u201363. + doi: 10.1038/nrc3309 22785351\nGrivennikov + SI, Greten + FR, Karin + M. Immunity, inflammation, + and cancer. Cell. 2010;140(6):883\u201399. + doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2010.01.025 20303878\nMantovani + A, Allavena + P, Sica + A, Balkwill + F. Cancer-related inflammation. + Nature. 2008;454(7203):436\u201344. + doi: 10.1038/nature07205 18650914\nKumari + N, Dwarakanath + BS, Das + A, Bhatt + AN. Role of interleukin-6 + in cancer progression and therapeutic resistance. Tumour + Biol. 2016;37(9):11553\u201372. + doi: 10.1007/s13277-016-5098-7 27260630\nYin + Q, Chen + L. CellTICS: an explainable + neural network for cell-type identification and interpretation based on single-cell + RNA-seq data. Brief Bioinform. 2023;25(1):bbad449. + doi: 10.1093/bib/bbad449 38061196\nRubner Y, Tomasi C, Guibas + LJ. A metric for distributions with applications to image databases. In: Sixth + International Conference on Computer Vision (IEEE Cat. No.98CH36271). 59\u201366. + https://doi.org/10.1109/iccv.1998.710701\nRutkowski + MJ, Sughrue + ME, Kane + AJ, Mills + SA, Parsa + AT. Cancer and the complement + cascade. Mol Cancer Res. 2010;8(11):1453\u201365. + doi: 10.1158/1541-7786.MCR-10-0225 20870736\nAlbini + A, Di + Paola L, Mei + G, Baci + D, Fusco + N, Corso + G, et al. Inflammation + and cancer cell survival: TRAF2 as a key player. Cell + Death Dis. 2025;16(1):292. + doi: 10.1038/s41419-025-07609-w 40229245\nCai + Z, Zhai + X, Xu + J, Hong + T, Yang + K, Min + S, et al. ELAVL1 + regulates PD-L1 mRNA stability to disrupt the infiltration of CD4-positive + T cells in prostate cancer. Neoplasia. 2024;57:101049. + doi: 10.1016/j.neo.2024.101049 39265220\nTanaka + H, Matsushima + H, Nishibu + A, Clausen + BE, Takashima + A. Dual therapeutic efficacy + of vinblastine as a unique chemotherapeutic agent capable of inducing dendritic + cell maturation. Cancer Res. 2009;69(17):6987\u201394. + doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-09-1106 19706755\nLi + Y, Umbach + DM, Krahn + JM, Shats + I, Li + X, Li + L. Predicting tumor response + to drugs based on gene-expression biomarkers of sensitivity learned from cancer + cell lines. BMC Genomics. 2021;22(1):272. + doi: 10.1186/s12864-021-07581-7 33858332\nRampoldi + F, Bonrouhi + M, Boehm + ME, Lehmann + WD, Popovic + ZV, Kaden + S, et al. Immunosuppression + and Aberrant T Cell Development in the Absence of N-Myristoylation. + J Immunol. 2015;195(9):4228\u201343. + doi: 10.4049/jimmunol.1500622 26423150\nAlblihy + A, Ali + R, Algethami + M, Shoqafi + A, Toss + MS, Brownlie + J, et al. Targeting + Mre11 overcomes platinum resistance and induces synthetic lethality in XRCC1 + deficient epithelial ovarian cancers. NPJ Precis Oncol. + 2022;6(1):51. + doi: 10.1038/s41698-022-00298-0 35853939\nLi + Z, Fan + Y, Ma + Y, Meng + N, Li + D, Wang + D, et al. Identification + of Crucial Genes and Signaling Pathways in Alectinib-Resistant Lung Adenocarcinoma + Using Bioinformatic Analysis. Mol Biotechnol. + 2024;66(12):3655\u201373. + doi: 10.1007/s12033-023-00973-y 38142454\nTsherniak + A, Vazquez + F, Montgomery + PG, Weir + BA, Kryukov + G, Cowley + GS, et al. Defining + a Cancer Dependency Map. Cell. 2017;170(3):564-576.e16. + doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2017.06.010 28753430\nBehan + FM, Iorio + F, Picco + G, Gon\xE7alves + E, Beaver + CM, Migliardi + G, et al. Prioritization + of cancer therapeutic targets using CRISPR-Cas9 screens. Nature. + 2019;568(7753):511\u20136. + doi: 10.1038/s41586-019-1103-9 30971826\nBarretina + J, Caponigro + G, Stransky + N, Venkatesan + K, Margolin + AA, Kim + S, et al. The + Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia enables predictive modelling of anticancer drug + sensitivity. Nature. 2012;483(7391):603\u20137. + doi: 10.1038/nature11003 22460905\nGhandi + M, Huang + FW, Jan\xE9-Valbuena + J, Kryukov + GV, Lo + CC, McDonald + ER 3rd, et al. Next-generation + characterization of the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia. Nature. + 2019;569(7757):503\u20138. + doi: 10.1038/s41586-019-1186-3 31068700\nIorio + F, Knijnenburg + TA, Vis + DJ, Bignell + GR, Menden + MP, Schubert + M, et al. A + Landscape of Pharmacogenomic Interactions in Cancer. Cell. + 2016;166(3):740\u201354. + doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2016.06.017 27397505\nVis + DJ, Bombardelli + L, Lightfoot + H, Iorio + F, Garnett + MJ, Wessels + LF. Multilevel models improve + precision and speed of IC50 estimates. Pharmacogenomics. + 2016;17(7):691\u2013700. + doi: 10.2217/pgs.16.15 27180993\nRitz + C, Baty + F, Streibig + JC, Gerhard + D. Dose-Response Analysis + Using R. PLoS One. 2015;10(12):e0146021. + doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0146021\nHarrison + PW, Amode + MR, Austine-Orimoloye + O, Azov + AG, Barba + M, Barnes + I, et al. Ensembl + 2024. Nucleic Acids Res. 2024;52(D1):D891\u20139. + doi: 10.1093/nar/gkac1000\nDennis + G, Sherman + BT, Hosack + DA, Yang + J, Gao + W, Lane + HC. DAVID: Database for Annotation, + Visualization, and Integrated Discovery. Genome Biol. + 2003;4(5):P3.\nBinder A, Montavon G, Lapuschkin S, M\xFCller KR, Samek + W. Layer-wise relevance propagation for neural networks with local renormalization + layers. In: 2016.\n\n
\n
" + headers: + Accept-Ranges: + - bytes + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - private, max-age=0 + Content-Disposition: + - attachment; filename=journal.pcbi.1014869.xml + Content-Length: + - '184995' + Content-Type: + - application/xml + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + ETag: + - '"588c4afdf870c42bc95bce71802ac441"' + Expires: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Last-Modified: + - Tue, 13 Oct 2026 17:45:49 GMT + Server: + - UploadServer + X-GUploader-UploadID: + - AP6rU83EzS1I3zHTG8frXB_JV94Fp09XGDqfbGbw72Bu83UlLJ_hQ5u-kepw82b_T1J0AZKinTs8UYvh46YecA + x-goog-generation: + - '1791913549093855' + x-goog-hash: + - crc32c=LQNGlA== + - md5=WIxK/fhwxCvJW85xgCrEQQ== + x-goog-metageneration: + - '1' + x-goog-storage-class: + - STANDARD + x-goog-stored-content-encoding: + - identity + x-goog-stored-content-length: + - '184995' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..10c8ec3 --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml @@ -0,0 +1,880 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"42868208","objurls":[],"info":"No + LinkOut links available for UID: 42868208"}]}]} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:54 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D3407F95CD407A500002BEFC1B73A6C.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:57:54 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '8' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '176' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: "{\"header\":{\"type\":\"esummary\",\"version\":\"0.3\"},\"result\":{\"uids\":[\"42868208\"],\"42868208\":{\"uid\":\"42868208\",\"pubdate\":\"2026\",\"epubdate\":\"2026 + Oct 13\",\"source\":\"PLoS One\",\"authors\":[{\"name\":\"Urra-Barra G\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Acevedo + G\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Leighton-Vallejos + E\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Ruiz-Gonz\xE1lez + V\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez + C\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"}],\"lastauthor\":\"D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez + C\",\"title\":\"Practice-based initial teacher education in alternative teaching + certification programs: A scoping review protocol.\",\"sorttitle\":\"practice + based initial teacher education in alternative teaching certification programs + a scoping review protocol\",\"volume\":\"21\",\"issue\":\"10\",\"pages\":\"e0360047\",\"lang\":[\"eng\"],\"nlmuniqueid\":\"101285081\",\"issn\":\"\",\"essn\":\"1932-6203\",\"pubtype\":[\"Journal + Article\"],\"recordstatus\":\"PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE\",\"pubstatus\":\"258\",\"articleids\":[{\"idtype\":\"pubmed\",\"idtypen\":1,\"value\":\"42868208\"},{\"idtype\":\"doi\",\"idtypen\":3,\"value\":\"10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\"},{\"idtype\":\"pii\",\"idtypen\":4,\"value\":\"PONE-D-26-12708\"},{\"idtype\":\"pmc\",\"idtypen\":8,\"value\":\"PMC13660980\"},{\"idtype\":\"pmcid\",\"idtypen\":5,\"value\":\"pmc-id: + PMC13660980;\"}],\"history\":[{\"pubstatus\":\"received\",\"date\":\"2026/04/29 + 00:00\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"accepted\",\"date\":\"2026/09/21 00:00\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"medline\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 + 23:37\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"pubmed\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 23:36\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"entrez\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 + 18:14\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"pmc-release\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 00:00\"}],\"references\":[],\"attributes\":[\"Has + Abstract\"],\"pmcrefcount\":20,\"fulljournalname\":\"PloS one\",\"elocationid\":\"doi: + 10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\",\"doctype\":\"citation\",\"srccontriblist\":[],\"booktitle\":\"\",\"medium\":\"\",\"edition\":\"\",\"publisherlocation\":\"\",\"publishername\":\"\",\"srcdate\":\"\",\"reportnumber\":\"\",\"availablefromurl\":\"\",\"locationlabel\":\"\",\"doccontriblist\":[],\"docdate\":\"\",\"bookname\":\"\",\"chapter\":\"\",\"sortpubdate\":\"2026/10/13 + 00:00\",\"sortfirstauthor\":\"Urra-Barra G\",\"vernaculartitle\":\"\"}}}\n" + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:54 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D322F91B7495C35000038E45B96D6E8.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:57:55 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '7' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '2087' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0360047&type=manuscript + response: + body: + string: '' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - max-age=3600 + Content-Length: + - '0' + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT + Location: + - https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047/1/pone.0360047.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T065306Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host&X-Goog-Signature=4e17444ef0c430a33abad3ac0210332144f05c9e715bbdadbac1c4fbae7db1254b823054dafdee078e991739d067803b6e20735c2a16f686b3b5f6c8a931f3bb69193d3b66d3eeaa7328686638c6f757b764c824573d52fd7629c8fa99c78df9aec1c8c25dea19865986e7421962b08d900ae2f6d4d282b8f928562a13eeec39d721bcef07b943139ef4e14361b85b1791e29d260bf7ac38b769ca7451482775842aea6e206d772c1edbb6a224f07ca2f5f032bc05f808cdd4faaff80dc024cb8e63714c3fec49218e86d28df11f50ed70dfe3795a3ecb9c3830dd7a85aeb7b6a87da7ab5cc953f96d7905a4f9f40056d462af846bf641cda9a19a41720b8c95 + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CPvL-qzrgcfdexAD; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + status: + code: 302 + message: Found +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047/1/pone.0360047.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T065306Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-Signature=4e17444ef0c430a33abad3ac0210332144f05c9e715bbdadbac1c4fbae7db1254b823054dafdee078e991739d067803b6e20735c2a16f686b3b5f6c8a931f3bb69193d3b66d3eeaa7328686638c6f757b764c824573d52fd7629c8fa99c78df9aec1c8c25dea19865986e7421962b08d900ae2f6d4d282b8f928562a13eeec39d721bcef07b943139ef4e14361b85b1791e29d260bf7ac38b769ca7451482775842aea6e206d772c1edbb6a224f07ca2f5f032bc05f808cdd4faaff80dc024cb8e63714c3fec49218e86d28df11f50ed70dfe3795a3ecb9c3830dd7a85aeb7b6a87da7ab5cc953f96d7905a4f9f40056d462af846bf641cda9a19a41720b8c95&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host + response: + body: + string: "\n\n
\n\n\n\nComposition + Vendor\nNewgen KnowledgeWorks (P) Ltd.\n\n\n\n\n\nPLoS One\nplos\nplosone\n\nPLOS + One\n\n1932-6203\n\nPublic + Library of Science\nSan Francisco, CA USA\n\n\n\n10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\nPONE-D-26-12708\n\n\nStudy Protocol\n\n\nPeople and placesPopulation + groupingsProfessionsTeachers\nResearch and analysis methodsDatabase + and informatics methodsDatabase searching\nBiology and life sciencesNeuroscienceCognitive + scienceCognitive psychologyLearningHuman + learning\nBiology and life sciencesPsychologyCognitive + psychologyLearningHuman + learning\nSocial sciencesPsychologyCognitive + psychologyLearningHuman + learning\nBiology and life sciencesNeuroscienceLearning + and memoryLearningHuman + learning\nResearch and analysis methodsResearch + design\nSocial + sciencesSociologyEducation\nBiology and life sciencesNeuroscienceCognitive + scienceCognitive psychologyLanguage\nBiology and life sciencesPsychologyCognitive + psychologyLanguage\nSocial sciencesPsychologyCognitive + psychologyLanguage\nSocial sciencesPolitical + scienceUnited Nations\nResearch and analysis methodsResearch + assessmentSystematic reviews\n\nPractice-based + initial teacher education in alternative teaching certification programs: + A scoping review protocol\nPractice-based + teacher education in alternative certification programs: Scoping review protoco\n\n\n\n\nUrra-Barra\nGerardo\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting + \u2013 original draft\nWriting + \u2013 review & editing\n\n\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-8100-6663\n\nAcevedo\nGraciela\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting + \u2013 original draft\nWriting + \u2013 review & editing\n*\n\n\n\nLeighton-Vallejos\nErich\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting + \u2013 original draft\nWriting + \u2013 review & editing\n\n\n\nRuiz-Gonz\xE1lez\nV\xEDctor\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting + \u2013 original draft\nWriting + \u2013 review & editing\n\n\n\nD\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez\nCamila\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting + \u2013 original draft\nWriting + \u2013 review & editing\n\n\nFacultad + de Educaci\xF3n, Universidad San Sebasti\xE1n, + Chile\n\n\n\nBaker\nRogis\n\nEditor\n\n\nUniversiti Pertahanan Nasional Malaysia, + MALAYSIA\n\n* E-mail: Graciela.acevedo@uss.cl\n\n

The authors have declared that no + competing interests exist.

\n
\n
\n13102026\n2026\n21\n10\ne0360047\n\n2942026\n2192026\n\n\n2026\nUrra-Barra + et al\n\nThis is an open access article distributed + under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which + permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided + the original author and source are credited.\n\n\n\n

Given + the shortage of specialized teachers, Initial Teacher Education requires alternative + teacher preparation routes, such as Alternative Teaching Certification Programs, + that allow the incorporation of professionals who already possess prior work + experience into the educational system. However, this situation raises new + challenges regarding the design and implementation of the teacher preparation + model within these programs. Consequently, this study aims to map and synthesize + the existing evidence on the characteristics of practice-based teacher education + (PBTE) programs, understood as an approach in which professional learning + is constructed through authentic, situated teaching experiences rather than + primarily theoretical instruction, designed for individuals who already hold + technical, bachelor\u2019s, or professional degrees. The review will be conducted + following the JBI (Joanna Briggs Institute) methodology for scoping reviews, + and will be reported in accordance with PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Data extraction + and synthesis will be structured around the JBI Participants, Concept, and + Context (PCC) analytical framework. Database searches will be conducted in + Web of Science (WoS) and Scopus, including studies published between 2009 + and 2025 in English, Spanish, and Portuguese. The review will specifically + examine program duration, mentoring structures, practicum design, institutional + type, teaching strategies, and reported outcomes. This protocol has been registered + in the Open Science Framework (OSF) and will be publicly available once approved.

\n
\n\nThis + study was supported by Vicerrector\xEDa Acad\xE9mica and Centro de Investigaci\xF3n + para la Educaci\xF3n Superior \u2013 Fondo USS-FIN-2026_APC_VRA-013.\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nData Availability\nNo + datasets were generated or analysed during the current study. All relevant + data from this study will be made available upon study completion.\n\n\n
\n
\n\n\nIntroduction\n

Initial + Teacher Education (ITE; in Spanish, Formaci\xF3n Inicial Docente, + FID) is understood as a systematic and structured process aimed at developing + the professional competencies required for teaching across the different levels + of the educational system [1,2].

\n

At a global + level, the United Nations estimate that approximately 44 million new teachers + will be needed by 2030 in order to respond to the growing educational demand + [3]. This shortage + poses concrete demands on teacher preparation systems, which must not only + increase enrollment, but also guarantee training that is both high in quality + and relevant to current teaching practice.

\n

In this context, alternative + teaching certification programs have emerged as a relevant alternative within + the Chilean tertiary education system. For the purposes of this review, Alternative + Teaching Certification Programs (ATCPs) are defined as initial teacher education + pathways designed for individuals who already hold a prior technical, professional, + or academic qualification, offering an abbreviated or alternative route to + a teaching credential that recognizes prior learning and work experience [4]. These programs connect + prior learning experiences with the completion of a bachelor\u2019s degree + in education and a specific disciplinary teaching certification. The National + Accreditation Commission (CNA; in Spanish: [5] + defines these programs as designed, formalized, and implemented with the purpose + of offering study continuity to individuals who already hold a prior professional + or technical degree or an academic qualification, recognizing work experience + and knowledge acquired within the school system. Notwithstanding, their growth + also raises challenges regarding the program\u2019s quality assurance, particularly + under current regulations, in which accreditation is required to enroll new + students.

\n

In response to these challenges, it becomes necessary to + reconsider the teacher preparation models offered to pre-service teachers. + Within this scenario, the international approach of Practice-Based Teacher + Education (PBTE) has gained relevance. PBTE argues that professional learning + should be constructed through authentic teaching experiences that integrate + pedagogical theory, disciplinary knowledge, and situated action in the classroom + [6,7]. This approach implies a substantial + transformation in the design of ITE (FID) programs, particularly in relation + to mentoring practices and the articulation between universities and schools. + Unlike models focused primarily on theoretical or didactic preparation, PBTE + promotes the active participation of pre-service teachers in simulated teaching, + analysis of real classroom practices, guided mentorship, and systematic processes + of critical reflection [8,9]. Its implementation + becomes especially relevant in alternative teaching certification programs, + where candidates bring prior educational and/or work experiences that require + pedagogical proposals capable of recognizing and articulating those forms + of knowledge with concrete opportunities for situated and contextualized professional + development. While PBTE is associated with stronger practical readiness and + greater coherence between theory and classroom action, the literature also + identifies persistent tensions regarding the risk of reducing the theoretical + and disciplinary foundations of teacher preparation, the resource demands + of high-quality mentorship, and the variability in how authentic practice + is operationalized across programs and institutional contexts.

\n

Despite + its expansion, the ways in which this approach is implemented to guide pedagogical + processes in teacher education programs vary significantly across countries, + institutions, and levels of development of teacher preparation systems [10\u201313]. These experiences illustrate that + PBTE is being adopted and adapted through diverse methodological approaches, + without yet converging on shared definitions, common program structures, or + agreed criteria for what constitutes a practice-based component in teacher + preparation. This conceptual and empirical heterogeneity signals a field that + is still under development, for which a scoping review is the most appropriate + first synthesis step rather than a systematic effectiveness review.

\n

Given + the diversity of frameworks, designs, and contexts involved, a scoping review + was considered the most appropriate methodological approach. Unlike systematic + reviews focused on effectiveness, scoping reviews allow researchers to explore + the range, nature, and characteristics of a broad body of literature, map + emergent categories, and synthesize key concepts [14,15]. + This approach is particularly pertinent when the field of study is under development, + as is the case of PBTE, and when a structured overview of the available knowledge + is required.

\n

For this reason, the purpose of this scoping review is + to map the available literature on PBTE, identifying its main characteristics + in terms of program duration, mentoring structures, practicum design, and + institutional type, as well as pedagogical strategies and reported outcomes, + in the context of alternative teaching certification programs that enable + professionals with prior educational experiences and certifications to obtain + a teaching degree.

\n\nResearch question\n

What + evidence does the literature report regarding the design, implementation, + and outcomes of practice-based initial teacher education programs for individuals + with existing degrees, including post-baccalaureate, alternative, and consecutive + routes?

\n
\n
\n\nMethods\n

The + proposed scoping review will be conducted in accordance with the Joanna Briggs + Institute (JBI) methodology for scoping reviews, as outlined in the JBI Manual + for Evidence Synthesis [14], + and following the PRISMA-ScR recommendations [16]. + The protocol has been registered in the Open Science Framework (OSF) under + the registration number 10.17605/OSF.IO/UTR6V, ensuring transparency + and traceability throughout the process.

\n\nInclusion + criteria\n

Participants: Studies involving both teacher candidates + and teacher educators participating in programs explicitly defined by their + authors as alternative teaching certification programs, and that are directed + at students or professionals who hold a prior academic or professional qualification + (e.g., bachelor\u2019s degree, tertiary technical degree, or professional + title) will be included. Studies reporting only on traditional initial teacher + education programs (i.e., those involving teacher candidates without such + prior qualifications) will be excluded.

\n

Concept: Studies examining + initial teacher education programs that implement a practice-based teacher + education (PBTE) approach will be considered. PBTE is characterized by the + structured and systematic integration of authentic teaching experiences as + the core element of teacher professional learning. Such experiences include, + among others, simulated lessons, analysis of real classroom practice, reflective + practice, and guided mentorship provided by experienced educators [6,17]. + For the purposes of this review, a program will be considered PBTE-aligned + if it explicitly incorporates at least one of the three processes described + by Grossman et al. [8]: + representation of practice, decomposition of practice, or approximation to + practice, implemented in a structured and recurring manner within the program + design. No restrictions will be placed regarding the length of the program, + disciplinary area, intended education level, or any other characteristics + of the program or its participants. The language of program implementation + is not a restriction; however, publications reporting on the program must + be written in English, Spanish, or Portuguese, as these are the languages + the research team can assess.

\n

Context: Studies conducted in practice-based + initial teacher education programs directed at individuals with prior academic + or professional qualifications (post-baccalaureate/alternative/consecutive + routes) and delivered by higher education institutions worldwide will be included.

\n
\n\nTypes of sources\n

This scoping review will + consider studies adopting experimental and quasi-experimental designs. Likewise, + analytical observational studies including prospective and retrospective cohort + studies, case-control studies, and analytical cross-sectional studies will + be included. Descriptive observational designs such as case series, single + case reports, and descriptive cross-sectional studies will be considered.

\n

Additionally, + qualitative studies informed by approaches such as phenomenology, grounded + theory, ethnography, qualitative description, and action research will be + included. Opinion pieces and reflective articles relevant to the object of + study and meeting the inclusion criteria will also be considered. Opinion + and reflective articles are included because PBTE within alternative teaching + certification programs is an emerging area in which much of the available + knowledge is still expressed through expert commentary and practitioner reflection + rather than empirical studies. During data charting, these sources will be + flagged by type and synthesized separately from empirical studies in the narrative + synthesis.

\n
\n\nSearch strategy\n

Systematic + database searches will be conducted in Web of Science Core Collection and + Scopus. These two databases were selected because they offer the broadest + interdisciplinary coverage of peer-reviewed literature in education and social + sciences, support advanced Boolean search logic, and together index the large + majority of high-impact journals in teacher education research [18,19]. + The search strings were structured in three thematic blocks: Block A covers + PBTE terminology, Block B covers initial teacher education, and Block C covers + alternative certification programs. The three blocks are crossed using the + AND operator. No language restriction is applied at the level of program implementation; + studies are limited to those published in English, Spanish, or Portuguese, + reflecting the linguistic competencies of the research team. Studies published + between 2009 and 2025 will be included, as this period corresponds to the + emergence and consolidation of practice-based approaches in teacher education, + particularly with the development of models such as practice-based teacher + education and the consolidation of concepts such as core practices and high-leverage + practices [7,8]. The complete Boolean + search strategies for both databases are presented in Table 1 (Web of Science) and Table 2 (Scopus).

\n10.1371/journal.pone.0360047.t001Web of Science Core Collection search strategy (TS\u2009=\u2009Topic + field).\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
#Search query
1TS=(\u201Cpractice-based teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cpractice-based + teacher preparation\u201D)
2TS=(\u201Ccore practices\u201D OR \u201Chigh-leverage practices\u201D + OR \u201Chigh leverage practices\u201D)
3TS=(\u201Cpedagogies of enactment\u201D OR \u201Capproximations + of practice\u201D OR \u201Cdecompositions of practice\u201D)
4TS=(practicum OR \u201Cfield experience\u201D + OR \u201Cclinical experience\u201D OR \u201Cmentored teaching\u201D OR \u201Cguided + mentorship\u201D)
5#1 + OR #2 OR #3 OR #4 [Block A \u2014 PBTE]
6TS=(\u201Cinitial teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cteacher + preparation\u201D OR \u201Cteacher training\u201D OR \u201Cpreservice teacher\u201D + OR \u201Cpre-service teacher\u201D)
7TS=(\u201Cstudent teacher\u201D OR \u201Cteacher candidate\u201D + OR \u201Cprospective teacher\u201D OR \u201Cteacher educator\u201D)
8#6 OR #7 [Block B \u2014 ITE]
9TS=(\u201Calternative certification\u201D + OR \u201Calternative licensure\u201D OR \u201Calternative route\u201D OR \u201Calternative + teacher certification\u201D)
10TS=(\u201Cpost-baccalaureate\u201D OR postbaccalaureate OR + \u201Cconsecutive teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cconsecutive route\u201D)
11TS=(\u201Ccareer changer\u201D + OR \u201Csecond-career teacher\u201D OR \u201Ctransition-to-teaching\u201D)
12#9 OR #10 OR #11 [Block C \u2014 + ATCP]
13#5 + AND #8 AND #12 [Final intersection]
14#13 AND Publication Years: 2009\u20132025
\n
\n

Source: Prepared by the authors.

\n
\n
\n10.1371/journal.pone.0360047.t002Scopus search strategy (TITLE-ABS-KEY field).\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
#Search query
1TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cpractice-based teacher education\u201D + OR \u201Cpractice-based teacher preparation\u201D)
2TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Ccore practices\u201D + OR \u201Chigh-leverage practices\u201D OR \u201Chigh leverage practices\u201D)
3TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cpedagogies of + enactment\u201D OR \u201Capproximations of practice\u201D OR \u201Cdecompositions + of practice\u201D)
4TITLE-ABS-KEY(practicum + OR \u201Cfield experience\u201D OR \u201Cclinical experience\u201D OR \u201Cmentored + teaching\u201D OR \u201Cguided mentorship\u201D)
5#1 OR #2 OR #3 OR #4 [Block A \u2014 PBTE]
6TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cinitial teacher + education\u201D OR \u201Cteacher preparation\u201D OR \u201Cteacher training\u201D + OR \u201Cpreservice teacher\u201D OR \u201Cpre-service teacher\u201D)
7TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cstudent teacher\u201D + OR \u201Cteacher candidate\u201D OR \u201Cprospective teacher\u201D OR \u201Cteacher + educator\u201D)
8#6 + OR #7 [Block B \u2014 ITE]
9TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Calternative certification\u201D OR \u201Calternative + licensure\u201D OR \u201Calternative route\u201D OR \u201Calternative teacher + certification\u201D)
10TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cpost-baccalaureate\u201D + OR postbaccalaureate OR \u201Cconsecutive teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cconsecutive + route\u201D)
11TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Ccareer + changer\u201D OR \u201Csecond-career teacher\u201D OR \u201Ctransition-to-teaching\u201D)
12#9 OR #10 OR #11 [Block C \u2014 + ATCP]
13#5 + AND #8 AND #12 [Final intersection]
14#13 AND PUBYEAR\u2009>\u20092008 AND PUBYEAR\u2009<\u20092026
\n
\n

Source: Prepared by the authors.

\n
\n
\n
\n\nSelection of studies and sources of evidence\n

All + citations will be imported into Rayyan, a systematic screening tool, and duplicates + will be removed automatically. Prior to full-scale screening, a pilot test + will be conducted with four articles selected purposively from the initial + search results to represent a range of study designs and geographic contexts. + The pilot aims to confirm inter-rater agreement on the application of the + eligibility criteria and to identify any ambiguity in their wording. An agreement + rate below 75% on the pilot set will trigger a joint discussion between reviewers + and, if necessary, a revision of the inclusion and exclusion criteria before + full screening proceeds. It is acknowledged that four articles constitute + a limited pilot sample given the conceptual complexity of PBTE; the research + team will therefore remain attentive to recurring disagreements during the + early stages of full screening as an informal extension of the pilot phase. + After the pilot, titles and abstracts will be assessed independently by at + least two reviewers. References that meet the inclusion criteria will proceed + to full-text assessment, which will also be conducted independently by two + reviewers. Any discrepancies will be resolved by consensus or by involving + a third reviewer.

\n

The complete study selection process will be reported + in the final review using a PRISMA-ScR flow diagram for scoping reviews [20].

\n
\n\nData extraction\n

Data will be extracted + independently by two or more reviewers using a data extraction tool specifically + designed by the research team for this review. This tool will include structured + fields aligned with the PCC framework (Participants, Concept, and Context). + Furthermore, this tool will also include additional variables concerning methodological + designs, program implementation characteristics, and the main findings reported + in each study. This strategy will ensure a systematic, rigorous, and coherent + data collection process aligned with the objectives of the scoping review.

\n

The + data extraction form will be piloted with an initial sample of included studies + to assess its relevance, clarity, and alignment with the review objectives. + Based on the pilot, the research team will refine the form as necessary before + proceeding with full data extraction. Any modifications made to the extraction + tool during the review process will be documented and justified in the final + review to ensure transparency and reproducibility.

\n

In cases where + relevant information is not available in the full text of a study, corresponding + authors will be contacted to request missing data or necessary clarifications. + If no response is received within two weeks, a reminder will be sent. If the + information remains unavailable after a further two weeks, the missing data + will be coded as not reported. If the search yields fewer studies than anticipated, + the research team will broaden the search terms and extend manual reference + list screening before concluding that the evidence base is genuinely limited. + If a database becomes temporarily inaccessible during the search window, the + search for that database will be repeated when access is restored and the + execution date will be documented in the PRISMA-ScR flow diagram.

\n
\n\nData analysis and presentation\n

The results + will be presented descriptively and narratively, organized around the components + of the PCC framework and directly addressing the objectives and central research + question of the review. Accordingly, different formats will be used to enhance + the visualization and understanding of the findings.

\n

First, the results + will be organized into tables that will map key characteristics of the included + studies, such as country of origin, type of program, participant population, + type of institution, methodological approach, implemented practice-based components, + and main findings. These tables will provide an overview of how practice-based + teacher education has been addressed in programs aimed at individuals with + prior technical, academic, or professional qualifications.

\n

Second, + graphical representations and thematic maps will be used to identify patterns, + knowledge gaps, and geographical or institutional concentrations within the + available evidence. These visualizations will support the identification of + emerging areas, recurrent practices, and potential gaps in the implementation + of the PBTE approach across specific contexts.

\n

In addition, a narrative + synthesis will be conducted to interpret the findings in relation to the PCC + framework. Themes will be identified using a primarily deductive approach + structured around the dimensions stated in the research objective, specifically + program duration, mentoring structures, practicum design, and institutional + type, while remaining open to inductively coding patterns that emerge from + the data and do not fit these predefined categories. Two reviewers will independently + group the extracted data into preliminary themes. Discrepancies in theme labeling + or grouping will be resolved by discussion and, where necessary, by a third + reviewer.

\n

Finally, in accordance with the purposes of a scoping review, + no critical appraisal of methodological quality will be conducted for the + included studies. However, when appropriate, comments will be made regarding + the diversity of designs and methodologies used, with the aim of informing + future systematic or empirical research.

\n
\n\nSignificance\n

At + the national level, this review responds directly to the expansion of alternative + teaching certification programs in Chile under accreditation requirements + that currently lack an evidence base on how practice-based components should + be designed and implemented. Mapping international evidence on PBTE can therefore + inform program design and quality assurance criteria in this specific context. + At the global level, given the United Nations projection of approximately + 44 million additional teachers needed by 2030 [3], + alternative certification routes are expanding as a workforce strategy across + multiple countries. This review contributes by synthesizing, for the first + time, evidence on how practice-based approaches have been conceptualized and + implemented specifically within this type of program, supporting future systematic + reviews and informing policy decisions in national systems facing comparable + teacher shortage pressures.

\n
\n\nLimitations\n

This + protocol presents several anticipated limitations. First, restricting the + systematic database search to Web of Science and Scopus, while justified by + their interdisciplinary coverage and advanced Boolean search capabilities, + means that studies indexed exclusively in discipline-specific or regional + databases may not be captured. Second, the pilot test involves only four articles, + which is a modest sample given the conceptual complexity of PBTE; this is + acknowledged and partially mitigated by the informal extension of the pilot + phase during early full-text screening. Third, the inclusion of opinion and + reflective articles alongside empirical studies introduces heterogeneity in + the strength of evidence synthesized; this is addressed by analyzing and reporting + these source types separately in the narrative synthesis. Fourth, consistent + with standard scoping review methodology, no formal quality appraisal of included + studies will be conducted; the review will therefore map the breadth of available + evidence rather than evaluate its methodological robustness. Fifth, while + the regulatory context of Chilean alternative teaching certification programs + motivates this study, the global scope of the review means that findings will + need to be interpreted in light of each country\u2019s specific institutional + and regulatory conditions.

\n
\n
\n\n\n\n

This + study was supported by Vicerrector\xEDa Acad\xE9mica and Centro de Investigaci\xF3n + para la Educaci\xF3n Superior \u2013 Fondo USS-FIN-2026_APC_VRA-013.

\n
\n\nReferences\nCornejo + J, Fuentealba + R. Pr\xE1cticas reflexivas para + la formaci\xF3n profesional docente: \xBFqu\xE9 las hace eficaces? + Santiago: Ediciones Universidad + Cat\xF3lica Silva Henr\xEDquez; 2008.\n\xC1valos + B. La formaci\xF3n de profesores + y su desarrollo profesional. Pr\xE1cticas innovadoras en busca de pol\xEDticas. + In: Cox C, + editor. Pol\xEDticas educacionales en el cambio de siglo. La reforma + del sistema escolar de Chile. Santiago: + Editorial Universitaria; 2003. + p. 559\u201394.\nUNESCO, International Task Force on Teachers + for Education 2030. Global report on teachers: addressing teacher + shortages and transforming the profession. Paris: + UNESCO; 2024. Available from: + https://teachertaskforce.org/sites/default/files/2024-04/2349-23_GlobalReportonTeacher_WEB.pdf\nBast\xEDas-Bast\xEDas + LS, Iturra-Herrera + C. La formaci\xF3n inicial + docente en Chile: Una revisi\xF3n bibliogr\xE1fica sobre su implementaci\xF3n + y logros. Rev Electr Educare. 2022;26(1):1\u201322. + doi: 10.15359/ree.26-1.13\nComisi\xF3n Nacional de Acreditaci\xF3n (CNA). + T\xEDtulo exacto del documento. Falta completarla. Probablemente corresponde + a los Criterios y est\xE1ndares de calidad para la acreditaci\xF3n de carreras + y programas de pedagog\xEDa; confirmen cu\xE1l documento citaron. + Santiago: CNA; + 2023.\nZeichner + K. The turn once again toward + practice-based teacher education. J Teach Educ. + 2012;63(5):376\u201382. + doi: 10.1177/0022487112445789\nBall + DL, Forzani + FM. The work of teaching + and the challenge for teacher education. J Teach Educ. + 2009;60(5):497\u2013511. + doi: 10.1177/0022487109348479\nGrossman + P, Compton + C, Igra + D, Ronfeldt + M, Shahan + E, Williamson + P. Teaching practice: a cross-professional + perspective. Teach Coll Rec. 2009;111(9):2055\u2013100.\nMatsumoto-Royo + K, Ram\xEDrez-Montoya + MS. Core practices in practice-based + teacher education: a systematic literature review of its teaching and assessment + process. Stud Educ Eval. 2021;70:101047. + doi: 10.1016/j.stueduc.2021.101047\nLim + JM, Choi + HJ, Hwang + H. Supporting preservice + teachers\u2019 reflection with an AI chatbot: The mediating role of cognitive + and emotional engagement. Teach Teach Educ. + 2025;137:104447. doi: + 10.1016/j.tate.2023.104447\nFlamand + L, Vanderlinde + R, Tuytens + M. Promoting epistemic agency + in teacher education: A learning path for student teachers and teacher educators. + Teach Teach Educ. 2025;138:104456. + doi: 10.1016/j.tate.2023.104456\nDeJarnette + NK, Hord + C. Building teacher candidates\u2019 + interdisciplinary capacity through design challenges. J + STEM Educ Res. 2025. doi: 10.1007/s41979-024-00157-2\nWaychunas + W. Scaffolding novices toward + ambitious social studies teaching: a learning progression for enactment of + core practices. Proceedings of the 2025 AERA Annual + Meeting. 2025. doi: 10.3102/2197149\nPeters + MDJ, Godfrey + C, McInerney + P, Munn + Z, Tricco + AC, Khalil + H. Chapter 11: Scoping reviews + (2020 version). In: Aromataris + E, Munn + Z, editors. JBI Manual for Evidence + Synthesis. JBI; 2020.\nArksey + H, O\u2019Malley + L. Scoping studies: towards + a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol. + 2005;8(1):19\u201332. + doi: 10.1080/1364557032000119616\nTricco + AC, Lillie + E, Zarin + W, O\u2019Brien + KK, Colquhoun + H, Levac + D, et al. PRISMA + Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist and Explanation. + Ann Intern Med. 2018;169(7):467\u201373. + doi: 10.7326/M18-0850 30178033\nBall + DL, Sleep + L, Boerst + TA, Bass + H. Combining the Development + of Practice and the Practice of Development in Teacher Education. + Elem Sch J. 2009;109(5):458\u201374. + doi: 10.1086/596996\nHarzing + A-W, Alakangas + S. Google Scholar, Scopus + and the Web of Science: a longitudinal and cross-disciplinary comparison. + Scientometrics. 2016;106(2):787\u2013804. + doi: 10.1007/s11192-015-1798-9\nMongeon + P, Paul-Hus + A. The journal coverage of + Web of Science and Scopus: a comparative analysis. Scientometrics. + 2016;106(1):213\u201328. + doi: 10.1007/s11192-015-1765-5\nPage + MJ, McKenzie + JE, Bossuyt + PM, Boutron + I, Hoffmann + TC, Mulrow + CD, et al. The + PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. + BMJ. 2021;372:n71. doi: + 10.1136/bmj.n71 33782057\n\n
\n
" + headers: + Accept-Ranges: + - bytes + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - private, max-age=0 + Content-Disposition: + - attachment; filename=journal.pone.0360047.xml + Content-Length: + - '54783' + Content-Type: + - application/xml + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT + ETag: + - '"2f0d55f8a9c67c6e52306ec0572825b7"' + Expires: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT + Last-Modified: + - Tue, 13 Oct 2026 17:48:14 GMT + Server: + - UploadServer + X-GUploader-UploadID: + - AP6rU81xzxa_Qg7j7DKGHokGBW_hXpPJJnOBQIFw0_nRprLhu-9DitMlUxs8imRoHzC_aP3IRF_vHOsFaC-PPA + x-goog-generation: + - '1791913694195892' + x-goog-hash: + - crc32c=LvdmRw== + - md5=Lw1V+KnGfG5SMG7AVygltw== + x-goog-metageneration: + - '1' + x-goog-storage-class: + - STANDARD + x-goog-stored-content-encoding: + - identity + x-goog-stored-content-length: + - '54783' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_pubmed_page.yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_pubmed_page.yaml deleted file mode 100644 index 8244081..0000000 --- a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_pubmed_page.yaml +++ /dev/null @@ -1,153 +0,0 @@ -interactions: -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=28520367&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAADzMPQvCMBAG4N1fEW4uUlr8ILOLUHRykg4JueJpmpR8FCT0v3vtILe9z3tvgRcq - gwFkgfSdECSgJfeBCmYMkbzjpN63sFSw5hFTBPksYPQQ/Mg4ZT2i4T6ZHKylmDYnw9acD03dHk+s - Xr+Z19+eq27wzDcvOt685yS2baFmRVZpi2LwQTyuFyn+E0vPt/sBAAD//wMAUT1EubAAAAA= - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Alt-Svc: - - clear - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Encoding: - - gzip - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Tue, 13 Oct 2026 22:46:46 GMT - Ncbi-Phid: - - 1D34B517D8E41095000038197EDCD3CF.1.1.m_1 - Ncbi-Sid: - - DFDB05183F487CB5_78C8SID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=DFDB05183F487CB5_78C8SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Wed, 13 - Oct 2027 22:46:47 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Ratelimit-Limit: - - '10' - X-Ratelimit-Remaining: - - '9' - X-Ua-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-Xss-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/125.0.6422.60 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28520367/ - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAA51YeZPTOBb/n08hDEvZRewcQ88y6SRTXFOwwzFLw2wVLNMothILHMkryUmHnnz3 - ebps5Wh2a5uiO5Heffzesye3C56rbU1QqVbV7NZE/0EVZstpRFikDwguZrcQmqyIwigvsZBETaNG - LdKHUXfB8IpMozUlm5oLFaGcM0UYEG5oocppQdY0J6n50kOUUUVxlcocV2Q6tGIUVRWZ1c18RYqM - 5XOasWqVMVpmS76e9O21JpRqaz8hY3QPzXmxRdfmAKEVZWlJ6LJUYzQcDP527s+xWFI2RgN/MMf5 - 16XgDSvGSCznOB6dnfVQ92uQeMqcV1yMkRKYyRoLcMve7Mxvqx2tqaRzWlG1HaOSFgVh5wFBlnP+ - lRKZCvKfhgpStPaGfOZzRbzegsq6wnC+qMiVP8QVXbKUKrKSY5SDLUT4qy+NVHSxTV3sD68PIrMu - /UWNi4Ky5RiNHtRXp8JzZ7FYHATjzmgwGo4e+NMFqEwXeEUrMFduJZiXNrSHUlzXFUntSQ9dkCUn - 6P2LHpIQy1QSQRdhLF2Y2iilKyIlXpIuu/jKFtEYnY0GnbUVZaRzLntw5i8UuVKpidl+OP6LvnIY - qHSFA/+GgUrjsqTfCMRtdKMlo/9JXX2s7TDeZ2dnJzQPz7xmrWHSd70x6du2nejagz8FXSNaTKMD - /dCmFZby6NzbFblKNm1XDmdPbBGjFRQamhNEGIZyLUDb0JDUs2fmBLlqB0sF9GuNWai94CtMAVtu - bHXNMEOYFUiQiuMCqZJKqFIIlOIGWShrSDbp19pT8A3+yFzQWs1uwS3YBjBVVYQtyYsCTVH0nr2+ - +ueXB8unb1j9+N0PH3568Wv+bhOdH1I/NZZpjhtsa1nmVEmgG478ARTmK33yYAA//rCgeMk4NGX+ - ihcEbhe4ktDetxYNyxXlDDEuVlCd30jxHOg0iMZrXDUkMQUhiGoEQxdKQHvaC/TnnyiKkgyOVnGS - CQIIkZO4/8e/s/v9nr3iL/mGiCdYkhgwbBeosxmwbv7CxZNGaDTTqmObFavXWl/CMdh8wsQNZQXf - ZBXPsRable7CIKZlVlDH5AZ2p0oT0wWKbzta8Oy2lpR4v1lTVeddGKw90ynq6PVRRlgh/0VVGX/O - 7l7bu93nBP3s6cZO0HEgXGC1UT1kwtvTiXy0JGEcCl8V34neQQm1vnlesFob0boWRV2oYKSYYvpo - +vjz3WvCciiX929fPOGrmjPQYUxMdtOTd7Zgdp97lv8VQCR4ALTWFX8R/YZhEPcj9+0CJF7AGJm+ - xFcRHH3SBhlTsrqREEzrCYixPkBIvVOH6a8FVxxwyrgZlUrVchwlobDoguSNIFESpNNef+GUxdE5 - ik5W6nMsf9fehSkKU0OuapIropv8/49bYBMsQ80K7hxQZzB/qQLzoKskh8rVNqPpzNjuWtA47e04 - cGIu+AZm3KM8J7WSDj1j64AOJMNrusSKC6fPomdhRBqoaOvFAYf3WzaLBb0Cr10FB3gXYMLHPx6l - H3D6bZD+9Km/tOAgK9jD4kEP/TBKDJZA8uYkqEYdMR3Oy0sKyA9b1/ay5ptLa+BlXpL86+Xda2uA - jZ3ls+jUWvQUK5IxvomTABRgc7RBaJvpVAf+OAhY8opg8T2mKPKrmsGSToWGk4D7OJRK+K3xIO2g - qBVjh6u1BZs8mmr7Tnme3yAysMWSOHu8VH24Q9BSeYniSyIEF4mz79Dy3V6VyZJvXG29dQM8DpvE - LxnTziiAxWcV0R8fb18U8dFe0MbT8SZeSGYXgm6UBZ7aPVcvFC8pwDIslV6w3JMc2g4x0avnByL4 - Yxip8XyriLTGVwDdiisMsGK3Ib1MxG78AhniCxSQW3vNhW6fQdKuVFbI/Sl62O1UdoUIdzMjXeuE - 0Q4a/35uPsy0bv0pTTuBWpHVdA/FQzSZaIIk8XpbfUOvj0CofBLNbad414GPu4HwYLllOQoSjEdn - Pz7WvsZ6n91bDhjZoPeUqYePhMDbGG8wmJ2Lba14Jps5PDRlBV0SmFHRxfNHKQiChtFM70DSM4OK - AhYJi49WfJKctAJWIqoueLWGeucs3wNiSC2kN1fvhU7X/t5jfP1ZA/TR3iDIwmPsHTBrmHwcfNrd - AbyBZ5gVPDgo8tlwj9Ep1vNAvQRQl7rGbQAWBNoojvoau/pS2wzibf7gcbXk8FAT/fbm4p2bhjkG - YIMjxlMJcEz8MbilMRBKHS4lNHnKBYX93N3rJZsIuLuOnthnrvQdPEtHQKyfe6i1tf9Fchbteu3D - 4Bj94+LN60waGIMHttgXVgvjgL3jcIntOQIT97HHWJsFf+dTcNmIahwmxNZaoost2QtZU6k2YD6C - mTY2bvvfUkEhAUjJvU472G0BbR1td2GXNeFHtv45SiOWpdm3g5RHrjts23jOBWVUlq/txARWb1ro - trbiVKEkYaP7bhONw9JDfA3x6Uir3Skhqtanboa4cWV3Qr336r58+/J4V+7sOdyUHUerQrvjBBq2 - 3t43J0TnwnJktjZN1D2hO7p3z6nJalgC7YgPqNrDjk7CsIJBFFLZo30YdNQmjR2z+Xo7YNUHHeON - ZRCwe+jc3VA49skwbt/R2BSGeT7msGuRV+JDeMPM/Z7C3Ql4FA0LNrvbN6x+XvrJmR2uBb403eIE - RtvFo9ur2pGoh5aBAjMoAwqUtowT+4B6bgnv30/2qtYOiBYLwnkDqB3g0G5899pIcE8D1tnDIW7F - JXp46ufk/YpxKo6GSbKXQgBKQfDX/Tl5DDsh080Jg2SZ7GQm0bHe2Wddpg4lfkcO/J/0/ZuGyYJz - RcRsUs8mGOlymrpnn35/s9lkZSn1K4P+uqkYEdi+40sLKvOKS3gYSmsOE2LbB3XkKtNvMiPzlmRd - 1NHs+fML9HvIiJ62jJM+nul3H5O+swCMcu95+vYt7l/V6Cpr1hUAAA== - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - clear - CAF: - - 2.0.1 - Cache-Control: - - no-store, no-cache, must-revalidate - Content-Encoding: - - gzip - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Date: - - Tue, 13 Oct 2026 22:46:47 GMT - Server: - - Microsoft-IIS/10.0 - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Vary: - - X-NCBI-CAPTCHA,X-GCP-Client-IP,User-Agent,Cookie,Accept-Encoding - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - status: - code: 203 - message: Non-Authoritative Information -version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml index ed6ffec..8b95a73 100644 --- a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml @@ -519,2767 +519,13 @@ interactions: - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 Safari/537.36 method: GET - uri: http://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: ' - - - - 301 Moved Permanently - - - -

Moved Permanently

- -

The document has moved here.

- - - - ' - headers: - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Length: - - '327' - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:39 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Apache - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAADzMPwvCMBAF8N1PcdxcRK1gzexSEJ2cpENCrhhNk5I/BQn97l47yG3v9+4VfJHU - FFAUTN+RUCBZ4z5Y4UQhGu842W1rnCtc8kgpongW1KoPfmAcsxpIc9/oHKw1Ma1uNFvdNPvj+XRg - 9erNvPx2XHW9Z755uPLmPSdYt0FO0lipLEHvAzzai4D/xNzxbX4AAAD//wMAp4IJxLAAAAA= - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Cache-Control: - - private - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:39 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - NCBI-PHID: - - 322C94F129AFBF0500007E11593212B4.1.1.m_1 - NCBI-SID: - - 636C4BC40E3B70FE_AEAASID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=636C4BC40E3B70FE_AEAASID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Fri, 30 - May 2025 23:51:39 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - X-RateLimit-Limit: - - '3' - X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '2' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: http://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - response: - body: - string: ' - - - - 301 Moved Permanently - - - -

Moved Permanently

- -

The document has moved here.

- - - - ' - headers: - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Length: - - '326' - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:39 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Apache - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Cache-Control: - - private - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - text/html - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:38 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814972 - NCBI-PHID: - - 939B5B3F7502167500005DDF4B8C347A.1.1.m_2 - NCBI-SID: - - 9A8895FB22208AE7_BAFESID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=9A8895FB22208AE7_BAFESID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Fri, 30 - May 2025 23:51:39 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - X-RateLimit-Limit: - - '3' - X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '1' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 302 - message: Found -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=9A8895FB22208AE7_BAFESID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814972 - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:39 GMT - Location: - - /38814972/ - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=9A8895FB22208AE7_BAFESID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Fri, 30 May 2025 - 23:51:39 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Vary: - - Cookie,origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=9A8895FB22208AE7_BAFESID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814972/ - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAOx963bbRpLw7+gpephNnEwMUqTujsSsLNuxJ5ajiZzJZGZneUCgSSICAQYAJTO/ - 9jX2Bb4H2yf5qvoC9A0gqIvtzImOLZFAV3V3dXV1VXV19fGfnn1/9vbni+dkVszj4Rb+HONHEvvJ - 9KRDkw4ZwhPqh4REBZ3nQbqg7FOxWtCTzqwoFk96vTyY0bnfTbNp7yc6vvCntEPIIqOT6N1JJ50+ - IaJcOl1057SX5J8iXgI/x3Na+CSY+VlOi5POj29feIcd9RVCevTXZXR90vm79+Opd5bOF34RjWOo - I0iTgiYA9+r5CQ2hVugCA/2T55HzdBzFFJoBTc6KiObE81TMiT+HHrz0k3BG4/BFFtEkjFcK0rfZ - knZsCI73+0URzaPfaKgA7Ay2HeWvI3qzSLNCKXgThcXsJKTXUUA99uUxiZKoiPzYywM/pif97jbv - DP93HEfJFclofNIBsgKehAaAcAYk5oOQA3WDMOkmwTjqJvG8m0Sz7jS9Zu1pBX1zc3NH6GmaTmPq - +Ykfr4ooyLtBOlc7oaHKi1VM8xmlrbrRWyzHcxr2/P3+5GB7L/B2xkHg7R7t7nuH4d6R5092d4Jx - GO7sh0Hv7PTs5fNekOe9dFkslkV3jwaT/cHY97cnfheedwjn3oK+K7Ac6+bW1gdr3+7eIDjYDuj+ - /uSgpn2SgqKhH5KaRwfBzva23987CvuN1Nz6gCTdHk/8vaP+4W5wUDfksoXQxiIqYjp8mvlRQkB4 - kXmapEWaREFUrAgICDJZJkERpcDZREyA6BrfhdFkQjOaBCBd0gkBQRkXsxXJl+NfoAxIHHKxHJ/T - 8LjHq6iZDDCv4tQHUeLnJ50JSIl7J9AyvwnzXhjlRQ/x5705zbLohvrFjGbeOI1D74aO8VX3Jp1M - BpJe+KQnngRZmudpFk2BSr1hxYlM2r7wQZiliRSy6rDPQPgFy4Lge4k3mgOde/CkVU+DNKPLIorz - XoLdiObT3kTUJz90Ga6eUbdd5SKZ3luVDFePDSqjQf9o8A7+P4ZhJCgp53NYUihwT5qR0yTM0iiE - omItXC5Cv6B5F5fbvSwNrpi87A22+7u9fr93uVzgouEBrAdjNKdekMbwOUq8s1mWwvedI/ayQmxR - vqb3OSxbwGeitfdFDQ9wWRTZO3i3d0C+YOvGfJHmNPySUSO6mKUJJTvfXj5GPcGDXvfhYRqSt+ky - mLE5BzxJS7oRvlg62MtfLGDRKRDMY+1QKru3vu0dsK4NZb8OBu8OBo5+9fOCTGlCMx+lBfTIDx+z - 32TA+sQ+zmGp37QfYsxYvffWq4OB3qt+f/cd/K8fr93HZBdGbI/1BV4X1sDdrlui4vtjxf6u0bNd - qGDX3TMYkZ0sZF3aLWbq8N2yM7yu++vMruxMOa1eQMMvomQK8+Mr8i1Tu4hUSEGRLOhU9OCLN5fe - 4WD7S9kVRS3Ftozy6SgVcKNIVWU71RwWevQ4S29yqNAPw4zmORn7GWEiyYFbEVgKzk8H23t7h76C - +gIw0eyaEgAgP1BYSjOo4WZGEzJNoX9kApKOvHz79uKSFCn74KgtE4BKVXyV8hCTx5Ytjz8RdZtk - WDBajqbFfFRkfnClYCrQCACJxtr7Op1OsVkLP/Pn+RM5BiGd+Mu44MKpXN7NSoB5FLx88e5oC6kD - KBw3wtTCLWbacO4P9kBn2+4fnPZ39w5f7MHn7Z3+88HRwe5Bf/vZ026/Ox/trW2NoFNe+MVomcVK - BU1WRA/LN+GO0+kogMVwmmaq/RWDnQl8vMzo2oYFIItGAUBpXGDQq2S7mmEMlnkB7MYZrIYAoUZW - f5wjv5Sdc3UsVUc9owXYmde0DmCpod85POzvHqHAd5dmTdoMBFsEWuAi9lc0BNB8Q9g8XWYBbWTL - ksyXaQAGLWEYCn+aM3m7TCbAOUh9+COX8y21mpDmQRYtUH4plZzGhRDLOUg4JjDGqK9//um7wcHX - ua6WQz1YACUhDg8D8kGpn3IYEOZT9mzmg+wZUxA3ebEMI1DVbiJYAhDWB50DNHoQUAU2FlmYki+y - /MvJ+Q+vCKhuPvGLApChfodSKvYzsByS5XxMM7cxAM+u/SxKlzlIjHkKMhpmKZjJ5O0swrbkvClR - Aky1BNWxAOJBYxdZeh2F2Ah4E01nBfYrJbP0hvhkARIuRQ0PdU6wUkJfAPrk//7n/3WGKmGv6Oom - zbQhX8yj8Ikc98ckTKMn/e1uf+eg3/sFRhrsne4CFv7uNkiPg8H2Y3IZ+XP/inwHg5ulaT5bQYce - k9MwBcsO5x9+BlEIf6Y0lL8Pt7lCd00zfARd+TPpQdNXeQRLxHT1mHDT6xxEJPazhzwzS8NcvMDS - YeRPE5jlUUBQlYViyksV1RlnBNCQH5MXdO7H8PelGIq/pfESeg4DBM+Wcz+Bv+d+MINRJK+pnyUM - 7TnURLGiH2gOJh8Yd+QVr/LPatPOGerzKAxhdeQd/TldQvMFBbjlR06FjHhM3rx6Cb9en8Ovs6ev - 4LcvTMpXMOJRsSy4Eckbq7w+Y3KNzZ6nUVrQYJawvgIcPJuzYkrx1xEwebZCVFA/2LAJNvP5s9ev - 3jzXGSJLx2mhskME5sq7x0k6SeM4vYEPfgbEAXElwIQvbcWcesyiVYAf0Hx21u9egLgwstcgyeQ9 - J64/ZM69yxyNvsz6dIxWk18DoPMox/LiiYd4PYbKux50f1lM6+t6ktMAFIcaLeUhqkWCqC5eOs5B - f3EWxRcjnIJKeZ3RhRoNnAHc9CRM5zDo1orrcNe6oAM/UzWEfDmfg3gYMd4Z8YFxwn2A+a034I4T - 3KDhHzP8YbQKSeAHm+KVQvn9giaXFNck8vfz1w5PI3snPV5orEcBG9weTL6Ev1X44Kt383gTR6vS - 2gpflyFhc0VOYiLaUdm5z6LcH4OGBG9AB6LxCq3pKxgVGlOkbM5t3iQlf7mU3QJlhzV02OTrN5za - 9+01RvdEL0k93pKudO4f96rGMZVf5QcQCozmo4eXHx23tV22wF+CqpapCo6itZLL774WWxWNSNBL - q2DY3uvtbPcG24PdCtgJB3SOIxgm1SC9eJ1eku8Ttk/pBBJKt0W7ixgAUwbormzutgJriku7dYTO - 55o1soWcbSbcNSjb2hLXP+oM1f0PF1CU50sVZq8EqSU0GC1qJQ3mi5QlNRUnWlt3Bt7+YHunw3fF - 7T2bwE+QhX1LhKwnXGkpH/dwax0GaZyGK6LvDqnz/ziMrkkQ+3kORr+cjt7Yh6kC7BWFjqdCbCiA - N9y+ARGb52zRZyUay3goWcqChC8pqL2QhNIwJ3/xr/1LVi2658C4vBKKTrzqkouY+jklNEHRRyJW - pPCvYE0Jr31YTUAQwJzGVRFdqDEFrDkt8NmEMq9P/ifZwh40UXRIfhQfDFFkkwo6AsNr0cp4PAMr - jiYmqd0Ua02vszhajMGEAsNQrFovYflIMzBSUeixtQAkXopbcJwoAS77ovPEzygp6HyRgjUXwZKx - TIDaUYzU7G6ZZBkvC5CosllBnOZUdM7jrzrlIOKPWK/OsFzVTtYsvamwJhWkrJeI/hJBNw0nmwQ4 - P/IsOGEtGCXpSFB65IKAfvkeTrksjZ3DZZeGZuDku9eGM8T03cLHzTrh8ZXcxomnMRz7IwMGfEny - Ze57+VW0gEGSAuFTPyuiIKZeCPIminOB9BJK4VxAnZ4scBoIqcMq8SvXG2oOJ+UPefr821dvyMvn - p8+e/6A+R33hOKdsAVVbowgClWXxlR/Ayh6iKiz6iWIIPaAmtMdfOGUFlppmoNAqxSNF9rDy0Ry0 - XOCHZgdxtQ3C96mb9uAI6AAnnR+7l10yif2pEKaiusXwNAEJMomY51HYYFLM/JjAF+ATVLpzMkV3 - VILa13FvoaDgI64wiItuYlKpXbenmcFXEz/OqfW+Yn9okMRVpIuq4FABOc4Bm2OYeOVC/LwElelR - zlT5VbokV0l6c9xDQKWXCmPz74qE5WNeCbstiw6iVsG3ROOEikbitewJil5XH+t4S5SbLqMQJaMH - sKwCFi/lwbLuzfx4YjCbe9wkdwZiyGB9jvzROE6DKzA2puqg3I5ZGYOGaYGN7ObXGkbGr89AGqGF - Xj5XudbouNo6VAw6Ggcs1G/IEcA+yXT4Fhgcm0fm1Edjtvi///nfvJwKXWAAXk4HHmdqQ/DnBQ3Z - qlRNDzmNEFuBNgvuYye8MjCJu/Mo7pKndAJk0TDlM2BwNHLBVIpAoUfLWfFXzlEVyGGlQyaFxsIH - GB0f1j/WAA2V0hhsSVelhzZ5KzY2v6xhrjyPP27mYlBO1nqJbx6WsZgURdWPOdXaMxPCSjyy2yUw - MFLOFJ1i5hdMUqHGI+0/YBzUF2c6T1miHRd+Bu8nK5W/GD7u42AtBxsyWy1A/OsrP0JnMF/m6MMI - Rf9Aed2UwWy1VCzI8NEYBGTl2Afay6L62oscIVddAgsDaGlSSUX3kCfwwrDLlXnrE9eqDC8+sV5U - 3H0zA9QyXNbFL0o7RqM4naYdfWhZeb9FDCmYOwIlw6KpcbgPgruxqejcFJcP3r0gjoIr4Z4sX0qw - Vy9xH4VD2s26hdpRRl9gG/Pe6RT4ZYXo2Yzj80yr1eR0zgS+MSOErviJPhIaaXG5XCYFGy4o5rNl - UjxEuqPfVyeyeGl7fzWhxPUTXovUTQhzHZ10xAbwkwQ9Chbl0bc1Alm7tOgum8VeDoEOMONYp1nT - RZVq+3FCls1q0RaG6JNPDMVIYluki+VCEOoTTROawLLhe8scZwkD5vac1OWl9mMDIgg6AkhI8yvQ - SGBuYAi4jYN1a4lFRyyesQlpnnE0w0vmTeWtZ8JJhalUMPalnlNYtz1YpaBeySbOMrIq/q2jjYR4 - 5CCO6IC7VhwzWeQTw8hkxYSlKcbUnsRoBbbgJcdoFhEY1SWZLcW3JDIzBWUplabY4tnu8JRXBGrt - ruwrJ7bVb0k+ZAqPsa7EgwEjlGk9fv4E1rleRRKzZZyfVH6JUwzekm+qlrZsDbOoqzFYxioVlgmb - RiGUyouy0CfHcTQ0RMl8heMlZUmPf61kc07RcwRDyZyBbmGMQzXCsx/1g8krGT7z8xkzzFE6HPeg - NQ0tWyzHudmuII1jvtDlvXE0jiO+r7G67wazuocX6KrlOwV5mxZD3aigVK0WL3ryxX03s6xQcjOR - T9o0F9e0ZWE3Npom8Py+2ypqY8sDfDAbeNxbxjbnVx8rSSiflSqVtEvZLOGqUeJfR1Ofb+qpigU0 - BmMUr+gKp46gR3KTj8Syy9/D69F2m3MwPbQTaE+EQOa9T3lAn0SSd1ySiZTvTzpQS+GPWXjFScfr - s3GUDWQraFMT+62O6qxrQt9sAlO+XqZzij6otY0YtBIdpK72gVn7+Wqz+ndKrxr6zaRrYV2nd6xq - 0el2xqHX1lnG8H66tqJdZ0VvSvbkdQlOls46XaE/jWnG9rTsxdhnrzxQlAI6Y3HxlfmgWBqGw/D5 - m2c17kLhKudd1+ipTqJz00FJ4HF607Hn3rBUfUUE4HGULJaF2J7k+kZH7rjk2WTOgqZuwN4rcBu0 - Q679eAnvnv99Z/Xdz7O/vo0Gf9m/eLX96iB53j94dpOn81//Vjz99Zcf/fO/xhfPf/zHb3/97oeL - V1dvv1/0i8vfpsnPz+Nvf/wJ5zqagEQKLeBSHq910pnifqm/LFK52wCa7mSiDyz3IFcfvXE0Fbu5 - HsMrCOEhVYBMKyZXkYhKIUmfchdYN6yYi9S7geVMOl9LH7LYA2d2kjQk1AG5YO+5ASLfi0lZfpdS - WcbTgjrFNxTCEWoSVjlJKV63bunpf1xm1f3sMDMrL+8p3ffGwA+K7cVfkVg3vbZKq0sS0pyuYlgY - N3pFFoEaJw1pwOuJbZCX6CQQgz/2s3I7n+nv6nN1MMyXQ7M11Sol4xIcjaporTkKkI+8SUTjkJTb - rMesYqcgguLAWOGooNlc7jKwSp4wlwQDHMpdTD43RbV8hooGimcirgNx6RzA5dVVtPAiituNoKR5 - RYqe3JNORy2TUSaqPMThYfCLR98Boxml2DPv1yVFLpVvFBlXPRR9Zug42cSLDE8GZ+hdl59Ub7Ok - SG/oYI0ghk5748LQHM7wsRxXXle1W2a/Eh4a1f7hQfIealcZZZJRGk6C2MDLUWFyg9WQS8E0IY8d - CZ3ILauII+NViO0AjsiykLQjpdWulubWqvahzjKKoUpsIWJuM/Hgh8tL5rbjWIUvL07TKxJHV5Qw - 46U6d42YntJCRrPiMRH08lXlJRr4i9Ew0OSAVuDKBBEdZfiZMF2gC80hnV0OYBVYdfH6pYosNmN7 - 2kahS6aweAAo7ik4NaC28tglkwHvSK4ip6JJmpPJ/lD1IZCboy07UZbnX8WifV9dKbFr/rpqA1fj - ZH/OLN8o8RQwewvLd3r6qwKaT8bqL7PymV7PB22NRfEjnn1ixXWveUnvGY0XOqk3o5hNM2zhyK6S - ENaWb/GF5qf2VeKoxHK6qPm0x4VGRMXgBGFmo9i1ZrNI2/+1iqDHTERCemyBlANY8941GS19yCwg - EeDsxsjITB8ApSSok8sswSVJ0b1M8WaDzZdxEeHBvozmeIxLNplInuCBnTo/5P41fUwoKM/xY9zi - CkGQcV1P8YNioRIrDAiNSyVEG1C+MLgCNST7KohIW6zr9p+tHWiGmHee49VL29yMACPc56PukpKT - sZy7hKAm+pzLYb2E0oJlxWKl0pSR/F6IqmEirfFuTFaO+SHoyjC3J+xzLG5QVp0HoFKUvB9m6SJM - bxKPbRd2tCFQC7pp1ET9Sp3jkKQNOi24KAfVe4RQAmiEypMBoKtSfHq6ilTDpDVDdh/VJwasU8yi - Qlledk4+qAhZyS8ZbqYSX1rgQ8XDq9UgtBXh3yuVWLloawxrjB5f8Mzusx+pFbveabqtq0B7xjUA - bK2gqbSUuDAQzt2+Uotw7sgx56Ogmq6tGyOl0kr1OUuiegXG4lupOeq243rfjP3gCoNrT1jRz3ZO - Pxu8gH818aHwRkaIsnI7OHU9rSFcdgzPV+Sp8vjWnVSc7B+0j2o7RBfPqketuifDeL25n/jYj/XT - wQJxk+BTaIwoSUTJqkXoy+a6hfrboW7o1r3Y8/RSdgwhF3Yjj13wmDuRfxazgr0VZ8xlKeEwKw8g - KyWDZZahFVRTUtdpFI2FoTBEc7WVzGuQlvDMBzOUqK20ZYHo5Uj2UismJYBRaBRGfpxOpb6pavAi - xI0Jg87wGYcjAq7SdxUDV9fyKgldBfvqJXjQvZQwRg2qDm1BlsLbskEMnw6MR40aq3aVVym7qkm1 - FwyJpvbrZhGiojh3hBtHjBEnvMwxZvGEulrKjktIVeGXnCveMYLz1hIT51AefD3u8RJ8RPTS4uj4 - UGZJaiiJJxyGF+evniml0PmNfa0J0HHaPVoJVuCD+aqdjbajity2F5NwqlVkGl9WAc36Ks0TTS/V - 7A31DdGLueII1rm5ZwPdohMyGi3MKJlq2n8pnNE7NIliaQ7MBgIXc8Y7u8Bd8MrwuuqU+xnioQlS - 7h5IawC0fczFFIW5ZuGzOTVeSd9PHZh4jaWd4IC2FtasUu5mYPKdhqasK4ZVamXK1erDzQY5aR0+ - AmvwYA2zXAbcPc5c4SpXSDHmQmVLWC5fnyhTUzjPywdCuprMJ6uRKWn4KDZVzhGlxjqgSz1xWFd6 - cvk38gV+/bKSg7XgYkeFQ5syth7KIWprC9vyvn3zgvwatKvLv9lFTcGua1S1rCFsJZUr9JglfQC4 - I96yGjQ3vfWWTSHM1ofnfqSB6V/Dt263W1O8tY203nGillJcUbpblfvmS8HJKahH/DeTJkBfc2zX - bJ/BeaTJ61wK7EfE4ejAH8cpIUaQmuKbeahKiEb3zHsaFkFDbWDYo9ox0ZZ+7pl1nDvCny1hUFQO - MQdRNDdX/WK+VZFNW9EVkyKjgb8ogpkvDxmixaeFo5QlugkteuW3HktdssiinHZ/yb/JMB9idgKj - E+Ph38/TBCfSCf9zxkHO/DhGq9JdPz9NGN630sE8YyUX12obNinvVd1AD4fH6riNmsEbV5Vrp2+0 - q3NjfaKFylJy/QfWv2+rb2g7Vs1axSU/sK6qFcZmloqMD6Q45N5RGK98pIphzrry1bBP+MqJ4aoF - nT8h0uGi5KI16q6nv1GtoHxtFZ3e5li9mZ/PStT7h0d72+F4ZzDeP9g92h7s+4fhEZ0Ek92jcTjY - 3T/0j4JgMt4f9OnR/iQ8DA77BzvhhNLDncODvf2jqgUtNYYWyiRvbpE2qJBlHAKP2fD8HKRelF9p - TPA2bVIrVXJxt742yj/QIFpEKET4eJ/yLIwdI2CCQf4nfedjiBPLv62wj9KF6sHCx+14kAT//U/f - ++3U+8e2dzTqfuX966v/rB7At//qKl+7//rqPzpk7r+LaTItZnjqfrtTEuGhhgATorTW46HsHch9 - yRaqO9Baa6v66H7oPdjb77jJfH/kLh2kD2hB1dSk52ZoZUURNyqX9SGlF24p8E8dw94qTa0WRswd - TbQmf9laIFFpC8trnWVlM02UBPEypCCnMektz//jdF5qcymY0eBqnL7r6LbCK46MnNPLlzwXIEt6 - gOqDHG1XfeqMcr/XZpizSBOL3xKn5HpHbwxuN+ZmORo1sX6lnkuqJPrmuEwrbbgjotzUJzxGD9Zl - to+w/3qS//TyPDzFn7P4u3Hx/eKXvw4W579M82/fXV8fvAn/8dPR8lUZTqzklZWGh7QzShU8y9Ks - zImhRp/x6BrtPZFQwLlRKDZcJCjfiWAxZWUD2oqxD2bqw8rwMLa+YzNfLVa3C8r2p2m5s8+57oFs - fd1Myjcx8lkLW1r56wImSpAHNvPbjcid7Pw2irIw50QSEbkGKHHQG6LQVe5tujvY39/x94OdcXi4 - t3t0OAnGh4cHR4dH8JGGB+NJGOzuhbt7B6CY7w0O+3S3709ofycItvcGu2U71rgsKjmibPfWey3q - Smm+CxJhCvZ0iuoZpl/I27s0VPxsF5pPhtK/oDJUE8Ayixk9Tzqf1m1mr3dS7LRyUoAeiu41ZW9c - Oip2RLjuVuWqqKOf5n1YQ2tPOUtR78rQC+RzH5BlpV5WZiYQId8Ry3yokYk5k3p4gtH5vqdh8MMQ - A/wcBQWe+gI6ooA5ST2QHxJnQm9sdOuK6UintPDk/hv6RCoPCsdW+15Hw49YeaDwqw3CGe2pFpeD - LkpxhOaRtKy0Xlylf5amDo+eFevhOJopUhx+yC0jc5s/mKV4qdY0S/G8s4h1gHmU8idixlUxVuwd - L+6xG84quwoPLZYiXO0jg7HWhcZZB0xjAThmn6uYoGRVyiohCOoC3mgBtMKzGuo0F8Gq6IiRZ4St - cevejUQaypMGBL4pIUqWYl2Nzr0OlJQbbUartmzrIauvDe2o0s/98Yxq2eANh7aCE6uYnxD5rM0o - 82PDqkFlxt+g6ihPgjgy9dX6QIguz/NSD1UEQYsOVovD3fyEbzAbxSpdZgpVnlTk0KijHuQiSi7Y - alg5IzoXrqpQ43xQ+lUC1KsNrtKlx+uf//35r8u0+Ppzf774+uTzGD5Ni6//q/evP5dHrDBhEE8+ - z/gC+BkQY+ZjPGPEMvrhO56KAVO6MWoxWj4hLuTKnobhrSyft5tL1iRiUmrkIqcxh5I0GU3865Rd - QakCuJwuxlrAl/wiTT1MIkHqbGyuayH9HVa2wVrzZY7neEmMx8+LGUxDoIZCadtEUT+2mlBOJe9O - s6qUHq18kGezFK1Vv8UMUlyRrdtgyMxGp2T9FKlDt4lot7alWbVOpnSy5hf/8cWjT9c38dGXXeCr - L77EU+Tk0QvkZUwH9+hL8o36lTwhj0pmxydKQx4p3mrD/1jD/XhTzoo5XzxoEeP3u/L/jzwTLTtw - 6IemkCXhksqFCbEfjzNljavOjw5FXltoHvGnvsiAVD9r3CtWgy9rUz9WvQ/L5b+C5dflvrIPl9qv - b3VEpVbbMNOHhKFq6Aoaqn6TTX1YDv+VbUE7XVgO95WqCTkgDAfWGheHCtTownp4shvOK8Vx5cx9 - 287Dox1aqHfx1Ba7Lx+PVkErJ08dhOnlcR3LuGc3j3HKw3D1VI6eWirWhaY0A9yXu6ckqVhMtFoN - 10QrmLFf4Mn26DeMQLBBtLIhtGaKWX5V35K7hB314qpccy3pCalM8Lu7gEpU8xVUdQf3DINXmvo7 - DfJVT2OBDm2rkg0eIG0TtfL6GBgrvYfU+4MEEtXZoFGT00+lON+fm688/aE83Wc+V30W0gFgpZlU - 1WYTg30yzNh65zJE74G0rOU3+yiCY6wM+r0nZa2ctPeoq61jxA+1z1ijp5XF9UQgShmpPPE+PtBG - oFijVO7bZDNQhWu5J7hOpzAhH3hrkInWjyYEGFse6vGhjgM9zhK6ruU62aOoRxqWVgpVHYSpUGnl - WitU7YJ7f0bZwSoQyXukLjWQZ6u040ROMtUpU80Aa5Upa8kX200aWm0jSn1jawwohgUUZj6S+o/x - 2IbT6ttM4eBANP+Y1Iu7nh0qSSEu6av151qFN4gHZe64dKJx5vqQRTUIUNec2Y/LCSx++ADY3TPL - WfPAWcrF/86CMlzBfC5JZD7/sO7i+49d1SjE0pHdMY5Y3HPD5ncTvyATAB1818DzdlgjrTXP8aaM - 8D3uSexr4whBXStULBat7NRshrjqDN8CDpl4jfW7LvlTnR2gC2JoegbWlZ/hHfF4D0n7qH5GMzY4 - mPbUjn79KV3GTFvl+cxY+A1ZLkJfXO6Lm5qiI+L4xjfKEBqB+bIex9LEYub4Ys1vNBzTcLxqbNox - KM8YK+ZIIDi8ZDJIcBZLREp+QDuEPOUJ2YC7GHCNOXV7o0mzedzd9FY0r9FjqtcOHhc0EvKHI+FG - VZNNtaZ+18bDzzRvZWk10UG7FSHlVmiZfrAFjZK0iUT4di2FEvsuhTWESZrORHSGb9JbGaCShVuI - YtaKHEY1XMZ0fQ6xZqFNjAyba+LcxaGxJ1pPrO5yeWKf1/HlmQJrPMVphIZGrJFR3jiNq3x55Isq - W5AIK5KZ5c005o3anp3ifBiwLCAoir+0k/NpSRbauXnayugGvpzgCoV3d7Q9rYAnRQTI2pHUD343 - 1JmkMAZZWKahKbcDa+CM+aHH+s+BRDOU0ef8gyu63wK6ofQKYX5if1uBhMB2K0zdH7kB1uTaaDvI - GglE39DxFiGAb65YNcMs4aCK0N9grH+aRbC+Acg3txzrmorrBrx5ZC/xYmUgOdNiowxUHP6k1XAB - NxjA/Ekr4LdLmhvQ4lEr8J9omFgIyoftWjBbZlYTxLNWCF5kkQHOn7QCvsQknCbtxbOWk0WDbQuG - 09IAFY/e14zjgmHjCSfA3vt8c9fbTr7qsK1m4i3m361m3e3m2u1n2C3m1a1mU9Mcuh9ubseuGcUT - 8e359AdWXmS8uq0eYFTajkkFUCN9n6XB5XLeeCaxBuZtyzOJFvhpq1OJtWBv2x5LtKfV82evX715 - 3pit5j0yEt+kbs9I7DCWX5B5mt+aj4w62/GRAGqkbR+zA6B53mok9jrlQdnhHgPLW8H1t6Ga7Q0A - 8F72wSYAewCwtwkAhhgMMcxxk0axVjWAtGJDDcB9TtYaf5aRI5qAdS2yEbste0cxh4lvl2rF9/Vt - cDnBRQxI2SfHnKDXNCE3M8r8sBlFB23yiN/aiS4x4QtrmjG30n1EJkWUP5hOnp+Gaz/9RZoElGat - RcD3C65YEQRDxzNt4yZoctYqrTCd5ezH7UJoAHCxkwLj8O5a5N/MTf7BDus+VF4u7jmrLVaXmKvM - bM5p90Cb89Z+56bJuEJx68QGSbncu89uyAfemm83Ng+5NV8ddTVzDDv35htLvb/Em+XBK8zfxu5n - ASGAl1ZWJ75FBmR+EXc6KXAPVxDETpbV2K0/0nT+u6TpVIPfzLSXevP0nL+9j3jZeLAcD3JOjMSc - 2HwJeb+5Hdl+oZrb0ZAE2SZLi9n5lstLsxD9IEvMxsP4vgLBsjx3rzHmi/VhX/cbfoX3hL2gVJ7r - cIRemS2sWyGc5W4daIXYJtAuPchKfeoIlqrueuQRDTLE5eORzncJWMHOr4t72iS+SQ79nWObtOxr - b1yxRmujn8q+ma8lBzbFOtW+58P36JH5/Pca4oQdjSO8QfA2W+q33MctK21var9Zzsc0Qx5jXhoi - bidQWW2t682uttbhVhVd4zgb7m3gKWtXVPHGKWnrhv12NXEX2wbOtY3carfwjn3kfgOmZH1UnoPq - us335D+AmjbR7WButFTnLBXl39FJsMkyLORKcgVPF6t1KzO/q9IVw4fr7Gt4W7e6asunppQxsI66 - eirLJa+wEpVK9dUDsVjJJtgTVqFg3c1w8qJbt8pXEUgwuSxuH8BbzxMmN0AFrtdlFpSFvn98Bg/u - rLivOyCu3MKp38HDn/CjivLRHAuUaZhF7X6O91oLfOw2T3wg7+Fs1O23xG/XPZzyjt4SmXKwVVyh - dMqLsuOqdfUYwqq08uRj+Z3fCFV3L6Aqvr5fUGQLLE7w0mnlFhnhig+jyYRmzHtVrGJq5b+5S/IF - qKy2jHoZo6sI6HBl5lp5ZkOOZq98Yd4uKwwZSSjWJVBf4rmznLgLRNxChdNJrYT7sXpGcKF+59YZ - 9NC8RvqY3aVWSY5ekJfxhCzYML2mGd4YxW5e68GC0dOedLG8cRFidXZe1K/ccaSxvcb0+qtwXF0u - ZXKaVYGWpqOe37QE0XjrhagMOet89ebs6SsVUbdZMKkJBRyy0L4oMbhqFFFrsVn5C0VHnWe31oNp - 54Pe3/2A4n44s5WRVkr2pZGZ1RsGDZ5WuFEwq8wkJ6+na0pmaTRRIBJyqaEvDheM43Y6O4WFuHqw - ZgrV7yUMG5NFimH+I1vkA2aLvEWax/vK2/jBPFSb5GpsPmHC7gO9dbY/wd8fT17GZhGuAdWuClqp - 5syMa9JvKeRZl5Gxupz1roPxO829+P5Grsqi2G74Nsy6aF1q25hi8a7ZFdt14X3mVXzghIp2j0qI - f/OMik0z5CEyK37EKRXtmVU/d9YkUtxoAt17CsU1uRNrajdE3oMnT1wvm+8jiWL3fSVRLN3qH3Xa - xHUZeOwr09fvAPw+siKuY7cWesAmeRH/SIn4IDRvkRRRMi9z8Dr4mf/Wh2cO/CMZWnqetGfNrk6x - oFteTkQhrGoWolP4V5bWqg0fAox8SbEC10uX60Pe9c4393LhYBP+Q3a7kAjz2qpoGNKJv4wLWcq8 - 40opGSwzdMTWlZTWIJ3yBV3ZRSiTRDAqMemmDrsg0xk7nEzUJtqsI7o4kl3Uikl+MQqNSh9QvXPp - GQcR4eeNDqYwSxdhegMmNrfCXT4fMZgGVmUXwVTUKR4FMe+YAior13dprRdh8s7j0QxSeSQ7I5Z/ - rhDLgD/hjIsKoJE9pqr4kZ2RkCyIne8oKPOBc6C8y6391WnOe7CtQ0Xr772u1tu6Ka78Fvs6Ctnz - NEBC4P6BjIiyN0sY1OWMh9LKDJ+K60NHwjz3OeP6ZcJc/qGHzrBy40bkmCjXYPQNPen1CpAVoIzi - PYW9iHEIPKK0+Abtm5OnGbDFZ4NtWPnh9zwFwyBN8IreFT5MQvg9WSZsWPwYvgAjJShzr3kJua8S - 0By+pRP4NaN+XMzwpbjoE99IJ3CvV+MArjYkhKyQNEDysK6T6qMn+iSKZtwmgE6DIgKCIUnRe1y+ - LvxsSouTzgXfB7nkVAV2AJ5k1Pcu0sVyIUtzKcJelH5+YJW3WpUt9oss9ZLVa7wUc0L2Z8jS2/A8 - GTXDiZ6+iR/QcZpesTFldWbiT3cxW3yzPLlncsv63ie9X+h13jPBJ2ON1nz+KheLqFOZNXlBQRLF - zh1uY11yhKHILqY3ZQ8rfFZxbcnOAWhUFuaLdu0OtN5wa4FRZXntWsN/LmSNmvw3z7W5Fh8NDQgl - 1TVoxOfJDWpZl3lwSUhn6eNuy8r4oy44pxbJe6aCVjVBDTSoFAxvkUXselCld1LdAIDmUb1tbEId - HiU4YcQ50qWQiFHF5playFb9oLpitfhHIY1Yyh5t1Uv8kglYqAF8j6Y+5sAQqpx4gOqcNi4XaIoq - L83YhMkyBlUiKm8TqllAgVl1RKLBZcLsakFl+wfqosmOs5X3XorvDCiOJJCIauYXc1YGrgx23rL4 - TbSEGcdvsaGEOdKIvyxmaZaD9a16F2zuQCqOAEmNWNOjrB0VsGHSRdv6XkqVyuymocHX9bM88X3H - zlWaHXsv0bbrUkP3QDxNwPorvHTioRKUYV45o6uuMmu6fSZAWCSqRJsX8JaflLobMZwN4oRprngN - uer+u0k3p7nIKWoSrHqzhkzsulyO4o4kUarkhKhQ37LTQlpol0xVgcKlDoBnvZgswlmWgt61iGkB - wi2dTEqPu9plGalbdlhP9KaUXHCPXFDKwPrpqlstpSBwyAA9MrcdvnUXUreZcTpGNwM38259nW3Y - 1sigpXBLxSib17ClhjUf92CcedSejO1j8XZyPZyDQWXG8pVXuKrhfPLhkHdi6/hPnkc6L6KY79Is - FnGEF5SjBpgTjPTkx+gZv0Q5qIlhlHEewwvmZXJJzxtyTGMa+MucyueTdIn3VSdUHLlnBa2Oit/H - yFug2etLIG++uv5otHcu3TxtpvxqHRFSrsZ2R0HKIDdLsdS+OW7LlgjydJkFla6gBTb+Au/ArJVu - ByI1Zh6hVrme9T5IKKe+78YsyxInjKbwC0jNTaeVFsLmIk4vcTiNl/44SkL67qRjnKIxnLJWbzb1 - xqrS7G06nYIAktQjMI2X7BixwE3cba3PZn/xGsp/n8gTxqrzzDkUtk1h0r9sm/VBcY1VWLjBVH3X - /Ffru+kM36qP2ZJuu0pRNZvPmEMEvpRJHcVpNLwlh1vazGzXedhzmph8/e59g+Lw5LPBAOn9FdAb - Pn629xQr/2zvGVtPclj3TjCHbfltxE7InGDuWXcYw0Mh181inqYgSka87yM5bdAryawihrOcTONx - Rq9PJF+1CO3gFawN55AVOMlsGGxl7UOjoMi+C8sGd1Nqr/m2mQy0cQw+mMLYbraB0JoDgJjERU1A - NhLI3H0yv5M2KUThs0BawxVMg/nqlI1SxOQ98MjauutGTfbgfY/em9fn5IxX3WYIxT6xGMlbDh0g - GRWpTNvhBmBWeFN8kpJy++RR1dN/In3+ZR1uvPVk0dq6ht7rm1FuNBsvxL7mZXXhgz0OSqST+lt1 - oyxoFqVhZ9it9j2UtwGeBRxsD3bJub8iO9tf94++2PvyCd3e2d4+GGx3ZVpcsYIJq8LUmAyM4thD - Gil9gm9PSH+729856PcEv3YXsMh0ZVUSmZKI1/hl1AS2BqYuzFaY8ULlZ1rtBRPsWw3qrQb/EXP5 - zfqG4uhV/hpX+6RqRgjbjSCo4Ko7EQTUEFLtQhB1D4IoOxBoUIjdByL3HrYqS/C4N+trvi+tH9ph - FZhH1BOmFG/2Vnk0xi6vFpSYt5xFVN+TnsxZec/CXMHWriQFU3isA8jaQnuZZmmaz1agqXx1+R1b - /AKOdAQqU3lWQoXXFlRRtlw+tZKtZrw12znGWmTyPEXkz/0r8h1RetAZup6y6ZsvFyXNJpMo5qtF - qSDZNPUAAgTcws+YT3L4eTLOF1/LOe3XISuN+mcIWjB3DrDXJU7SHCyL/DF+TkD9C8mPSXQNJhtw - Y/XwMTk7fYxv0D5DKM6ep3MQK4HflSdlPq10WbUF/Y5zdKCIJe4I6RtPuJiDbg+riSs9tuWMLmft - lv2bzRX1NKOy9NZMGe4gcVq2ctKfVv3L1ef6OUE1YkKiEa9Q9S+YqVFOzS2FpWDesw0EdMnHsb+o - LBbD9pF2jYmlyeipjQfioRG0KG/rKXcjMMpQVqFH/0eht4Dhjd6xzBGCmCrnmjsyz1mjHNJY3QDa - MkTxuiHDHE+cDC4nhUWkmkQh1c9WNaJaLSYe3YKz3peGetu/rr4pc0m/kaJ2D4H/KDyqrXFyL0F8 - 13cU9A0Fi+YMIo4EkyqTXCeEPv1tNZtsUFwTk1d01Rn2uUAgDyPN7PsuNOrVXjPoHMtKW2rQM9QP - W+aYAIcW0SSiNrepr4YWAxm3U6gzsgIkMqRkyyqihdEITBhU8kQ+ULRCoQKASMLgbKECisioKCxX - H24QklfPOkMpWAAJgyqFq6ZrclpVPdm0d1L7bNG1Z9+/qu+Zr8KqKoCMDhiNY195LGIKtEACU0Xh - cgr0mcrAr56dNCnJrCzAsW1oaHdZgW68Que7aTbtNaEqQW2lCPlspO1hmzpRWbUciqaaxGzwNxho - Ode2HCu3ruF6QRwtxqmfiaElapTAK1RAQRE/k2W26vaFXVpA5fetvrscv8qn34nJsOUkJu+l5qiu - 1e31GVSha7YF0PkvFkhDx60sgxqV2Wm6imPjlVLcLUME1NtczMndxnqVHtlqnKUd37oRDj2njlSG - AQtvi2hOrUpWYK2wEEWKrzErzmCXm+/HPXzSnkDK1HNRql5vVhmGh/7qWpcndgBZZG8Z/1he1KP1 - 0RVcbOhwNfqDVJ/XlzZU6peYUKKhuCaoeS0jKZsbwFy7Ei0a1y5PzMbKuQXqUtTFGDjUdRbfJVpt - sosrVsvQEvWcGx9TDPaWbqR9LGHYW9ZAtInF3lKHYqtNxNxt4rLtiGAzQM4pGexo7TqV7RaB2xqq - +4/hnqfjCKetEbq9tVGcgV26JoJbL/n/AQAA///sXdtu3DYQffdXEAaKJrW9G9sNYAftg+EiQAvv - S1CgD0VhyCtZYqpbpJXt7R/1N/plnRlSF1LX9Ur2aq0ASaSVKA5nhjxDznBYF8V9cNCSjkydcajJ - eir6aUMq+ubpdOXI1jKlVgec7r7xl/GHF2y7fXCIl5szJo94I/WTS3xyiU8u8cklPrnE8wKTS1yX - w+QS78slXukUL1y3XW7mSilAf70vJSOs0Wvd7h6hIsrMQvWMTH7vye/dze9dUNuXdHy3OaDq/s9K - j9HJWMvrsuWiDylvzc2oXh7ogtA9iwVOTa7FttZNrsU9cy326VPUvYqFACXhh6MNKXLHSlNyahG8 - dzhln97v7NNTgp0pwc6UYKezcyYNaR5vfp18f6Iy+mccoJ2V6u7xFEvy48p0c7ywv1z8yeAnPdWy - Oo5Sne1X0JMlwM5O7Cnb2hRmiW5oleqaWuiH3AgKNfKucNeoPK1PJvS8w8iY72M19iWI6Bntu01H - NsNDS5FeZ2JYiJmDae7vLBgQ41VicjAUaUTEsgY30SrHbbuYF4F27rJ3Ufz+fvHlV9JTZqyoM8id - qS7aZcynM5sqI27wtwdQ4SCJmWl5gQ1I7cB0YcZ+dzjSEgtSuA+cSnBaYbjYyjAKHjglZ4An3HYQ - bGGYpjwrLHQsP0CrjEHx+8Q3DVkQbjFcCKY2VHfGqhky0QkSGwZ+Y+kA/cyF6b6P33+3uHkPcL50 - fP4tsSR7DDcCq2QtaDOt0A3WIp1qnCwdyTeY8vjBA9hCWEyyO0L+P+At7gGXCVihnY9B9PeM/WFR - Udrti0dmY97FVDzIHvhYEGLTQ4vyn2Li0RXe2yCRGCZV7hplY3mUu9HBXH/AXmixKb9xTMFR/F4I - 08bmmWsYbIDh+CadE5NWJziM9IqhAju1cRdgRpesMCjvV8rbucaWCGpTyaIEMXAEaBNk4BfjkNSx - ELGFNrpQXoeHoGmui2lVvyWGmDuYgmRnHQZQbSxmhXcy8EshAfmRFofZI3L3gRtscTNjn5MI2YkQ - fUzU51TVBYoZSyA2lk0FsSDdoH9YZOVgWVT22FrldWJiAJCvCT0A2xqEiWgXaBIqAbZCfjS2nizJ - nntOp47Cb8sogT7F/4G6uMeh33CSMBYrBq2JDotkeQYImWLdLLrMehTUb1M+3UiGpIj8tCF6E6Cb - gY6A+qBMLXMm4S7MN7o0DUT13vGqaba+vaCwHpPW9FOYA2y4jrAfH8rksumtqO46vf/E/vuXlmNZ - ul42Ky6YyWGDI+MYGr/A8yWm6E3T9AD8gY0DJgMICgYGS4yJIkFFIPqFOAgMdPQ68DzstVcrUQSF - ecOXlh+DGj3CKOVQ1h8OPE98HBMjTnvyE3yeVQSlhA5HFnQAMxEryqi//pqBDHjiHaedzSQCQJdB - tXG4oiUwKix89zSALHH7/0oIj0SnchIqhivu4ckpyMrCPU3B0xwe8/zB/FCfQDPbuM0tOpcTwiRg - 4UIziZJ0IgPvFUw6+T2xAorPpF1CnL7N0U4uQPySlZDpO0LpF9BMr3ImCakktUlSaoG/NXtKagEc - 6PievVRe46myE0AgT57rx5+exMSnkMPt8VysB1xeXs6fBKvEq57n1rx4MV8YK4f+Wdykr4en2dsy - QRa6F+HyhNzuOL6kiYcItEwLmhKRksEY4Qc0ZFkrAaKCFbHIPz2TolA7tzIE6L25+Lf4Y9GbQbFC - eWKOijQzMAMCKDSzmMh8k0y9JafkgdEEqKzhZR8XC6rkfywIWD5uDYGpfl0Pa0mbUuG27BQuIouz - KxPmbPES9U75SNfoFp3MnNknVQXb8/BWBqnkVEot0cNUOpJRw9tBA1YqOL11yIregIFDVnLSRQQB - dokeg1b6+3xz2IrkWr4Qi1rysziRIKdB3P+JRPzVX+wKVnWLDW4LfSiqifbqdqEr1CU6q0AtL6kh - NUU6RKdgcSH4upGnkc9UfcP7JXbXkdqd60W+o1Joj3uPNxkw3OTwZXR9k9CTzUgaIAwlE90IoDpx - +0fp0z5RGgjcHKBPdwagkb/jw2ageiBY7uHL2yAyVP/qYEwqsec4XBpWGrk7HARX8Xof0XcwvX4W - 8LZR87Yx19YdLD1A7lmPkGtb+vk9HRD3bFcQ16azlEcGuED0MHjbw4e3gFuo/bXR1rbMfQfb0njS - yNvBsLaK03sItYPp9HOQto2YNw+0x+ziA3mj8IT03lH3vF/UVYjdHILPdwiCVb6PE4+vjy4+HEEb - jrANA8Jzr/Vsh9aK2HYAujU12nsc15RhR2C9WQr7ifEv0BOeCfjdKRs/+jPP+BpEW9kAALY/sDkL - nXXMAzew171bAUTjyY992gIloje3BspUva5NUJbD+KwCaMN3Z5/zJkiwvvrtS69GQd/VbGMTAC3z - nJJ0uAFSXsckqNCiPTcKKs6Pb+D1cGZAO+f30RB4CfV/lh2wAWHjNwO2MABExs2FESLSgv561soJ - zLh3I+Bjf/BfQ/LmJsDHHQH/OhmMzQCgdhzJdgBCy3YMsjQwUF3PNwUUIc4lOa+8RFCrWI02wf8A - AAD//+xda3faSNL+PPkVCnP2JNkgofvF63jXcZLBu3bGEyfZd7Jnj48QApQIxEiA49kz//19qls3 - QGDA4NjOeCbQ6q7urq6urqf6oua++wRTqnEHfINVe+Hh+Qe3OCY2cBLW5+7+ewo3XjBgQiNHtx24 - QGW6CEQI+u68G761hQNzy55DNfObLiCYd8mHWNAv99KPAKYXTXmeNmUnCwq7q+6G3kRjvi+/8QLD - Ui17+E7FXXEmVuyBB+pQ3Nqw2NSnWJfBP92KAr52vg9h7cCduPk+hHXX3Ih7vA+R4fmO9yG2X81N - 3YU7sw9RqUV/uge36R58V/sQt6P+G7sDf+5DXO8AHPGrWqL+hj/5sARh7e0hfsHl+kBv3xGIL0n6 - viF7wfpO9hS2V/zmSF7w8I33Dspq8qChe5HlWSrnXeH3Eqk/PNjeta5vANgrsvRdQ/UbdjvZ1mHa - 2R5Mcw7Xh2jnjkB0KuH7Bs+c7Z1A83aK3hyWef3fGJIztXjQcFxlXZbKd1dQvEDaDw+Gd6nbG0Dw - Cux81/DbTO/b/RiFY5h8+omKbUOxssV75ObZXR+XlbtyoVyF7O8bSKdNeF40YSeAvf1qNgfv+V77 - xkBepUYPGtTnteEOAPwKvfDwwP62xsIGwL8ma9+3EzDuu4MdAP8Wr6bjLG4A9nflcrpUxvcO4Bnb - uwH1rRR9AyBn9X9r8E7V4mEDdoV9WSrfnYF0tbQfIDDvULc3AePr2fmuAfg0/VGZE5//qMz2oXiL - V9bNMrsBKN+V++vm5H7f4DltwPOsATsB6m1Xsjlkz/bXNwbvefV50DA+qwd3ANCv7YGHB+23MwY2 - APm1GLv/cH/jU+qnbnfg06n+d34SDdyB5wvH/Hz/X3f46jw/Ia5s8TK9ldqxvpNQwei3dRVW6a37 - 5z/wVj3PW/X8OHtbbeYt+O2ed7+Nim/iZyzq7Nk3e7/RmfgVtfGBuyOLVOhOOCabdNBD9Fa+zUja - yH+5Eav336O5kS+zgzN8yhZv+Tvd6Aifcldu9Du9jyf4Tnd1fm8bBd/EOfjmZ/dOH/7JvXmLslS2 - u8Px7+LU3u50eiMg/vPE3hKoBYCAYCc/bKNs8WK9Ep8bAO9duU2vLO17h7+M9+c7+72bLZZ/AzQu - Ouhbg3JZVR42NhcdfxcgeoncHyBS71rfNwHsFXn6rnH712g86O7qN2C3eK1dic8NcPuu3GBXlvZ9 - w23G+/Pd/S7sFsvfHLdLHfSNcXtKVR40bpc6/g7g9jK5Pzzc3rm+b4Dbq/K0K9ymtBRjKBLBR4/Y - R/kf+8wDj/YbfSDEwSOWj3+WzTf9TE/oXtXSTmoHbhh1a1OgcRSMXBKZ8IonUr3lIngewUvJxHZB - BsJp38ELo8QX80oLKFdqB//5+t8cO+f4TGEIvPh546cp8vpH/tdR5ro8WkJTO8hLqqRJ0Wu6IWmv - 5eA3vBLTFvJmi53IG+enECqU0534F0nPjf1ZmkwvUf9cWtoTVF2WVIhOzfXsCOnTPkja4UD6frqJ - 9qI2jJLCgOwHg+F4JIyuhuh97jrUhIHbx5OXxJ0+81Qvwe4o+kJJEzccI+31/2lX//q198v7QP2n - eXYsH1uD14r16jKJ+r99HL387fMH9/SX8Oz1h0+///Kvd2fHX97/PFRG5793B7++Dn/68O+i/lR6 - nIEEOBjM2dpU2PDPgK5itR1ZRdKztFUSn6VJJU8mMYzcuekbU0v4VWmy4AqdAF4teVbQMD8euGE+ - MIS+O3C7PlyvkZBEndFlBWtFr2ol67GfwDPNh1tal5gOibxuadAKWvsNol0pq9iPWgGVUJFxZiA2 - SIFyG/KocrgkoyuUmfgh3eARi5exOxymP8i2z6RY4H1KwmJrB29Qtjvag4mjZ0bPSaasEKeqXVNt - 2aToqQSzJkVD1gsccFiucRyKXNfdvjvbFammH54ezqYU0kViLjBe/BpVDhdWebasyrPNq+yHi6o8 - PVlSJRI3rhKO1YIq356czqbwXqQZWBYqDQLQL+ICusvoDx6lFv1RDpFLItYGwlPM+oR0IjQHhjTR - 64OgmLalJUyjZBVJOsgSzFvhXkwD3rk/aAvvI7SQpaakxVRrqrx0npWKqbAB3OkjDr0wGLYiF3Oz - dLZem/bO8jHKDLGYg/dMrvkYceTGXX80hYIC8SPCuPaFWuETHWVZc59nmt9pF9WH9xLm1eYFzrKd - l/6a6GdLnplvABjWKPEc5AtYnS35msKyWYfreXAkR/Mzj7+3XO/LBQbPC0b6F+3wL+obuuSUTQ/n - 6JGi2baiO5bK6LRo6MNxD1phEHVhfntXIkw6mdjTK+FlKXq2OXeyHV4U0phmip0246iIWkl5cpDg - yBuv0eu503vKs07XV/LEl/m3sy7tIpuUuuuFTaKhSlLCOIpGpV81LRusEPzH7miM8Z9SpW3xov4w - ZG6GG5OPzV2UE7INNPt4e/TyWDjJM7PTO+PY85M5b3mcwAWKg8wI7w8XVp360wuL3m8MVy0ja6m7 - mJBNMis8voLyIs4bVT3t5kWsuBjQwADCPI9UYOfcDfve6syBGLydnR7dCmutKPqS9PywszqDLEvt - 4GWW81b4bAcJSg76fjzFaKOIh9Be5Q85TysrqeCOYEgwrLn/Cfb6bAX0fc9Pl70EWsbru/EX9lO4 - aRxwMYI/4Qux3w0SFIa4Uey2fSJMhKgjjFDAB+lcEl75QzcesZkCovmr+awo9mKgcO7HkwBtF542 - m+fPJOHDwB1jbhcHv6PIceKnZSHAiw4SAe5D4I3CK2EYR72ghXa1pbTB01YpA4THoii8yP+El69/ - On4rvPn55/ev35XjRRFZ9rlw8q5NuJHOpBh4JCceV57VZJaunC72fEgkrlXlvUjTMGMIw+iSWbJp - rqfMF5muYoVcKNbKy8sy5QxTdVWTl/U21QjKVWPt4BEXo8tgxMzx9ABJoyWY5wYNlGnf8n2aaX5h - bz+ZdIXLoD3qYUojo1Q/6PZGPDwJ/MuXEe2ECLKgy4Jm1WgCivIG0cCvCV/74SDhLKRD9FKTorjb - UGVZbqDgivpYnQw0DlKm9hv8sZq0y9qetu6rIsv2gkL50HKhyZSBAox4IS39gfDUlGTT0kzBOlFM - ybYsW1BlyXYc5QQp+FMETZXUpiJL6oliS6agapJyohqSado8SdNPVFWyBcWSjBNNkRzBaqq2hFhZ - sgTFQEjRJR0lWU2qzXbsZlrrp1MH5ViGJtiSpemq1lRUydFU60R1EKFagiZLumnYTdWUDNOxTmbo - Py1vIO+tH42XpmK+rDUWyLjRrdAL6r8Z3SzMaxpxrbJ2XM8nK11lzrO0XGXJtk+r7Zss+wGp6RyP - zDTzieCJe4VBqKyik9NqrcnsX9XI4GqZ8bBQTbnS5R7a/EUbKbPQNRVaZNQVqIQCjbIUydI/OpZk - q54s2pKi1w1Jc0RFrjuSQt891ULsR0MNRc2RNFVEPk/USPfqsqirkq7WoRimnYZ1TbKsieJIut10 - HEl2JpqJbFSMqk8U2enp0EZlIlJQMz5VtbpBzZmN59qwgQIQRPrt+evz59Uho2TqQE6mO7hialEx - xy/ryAnLdzzgOnI7OpHVuQ2dUGRFMvW6ir7TrKZhSZaD/lH0HiJs41NfVFVRgVUx9J4oqaaHB0k1 - 0P2qAsVBT0qamYbxaZFiKCjRqNuSrVOUYtRhnjSNh8+pPqtuwX6odUVW6w4KsI8oxFKsuqNJOnQU - JWp1C+ZGSx8+9WFQYZzqhiqZyiFZO9CxT5n9pxCprU5MBVrcVKCGip1IhgIeDUnVGGN6E1QTRXMN - HSzV+SfLXNd0FCXC/pmmp6IZdR2JDkqU7DRooBhnYtiSZjQVBwPmI6qrYsTGMDPBD6yufgtK3g1G - vXFr1sbx2AWA/FMwaiLLN7Frbb+TVCHBPltdq8YIiStxfUmiKvxvARYRCu0JP1oa/fe3SqI/Hi2r - dmnJYjwO/T3Bn/iDqN1eVPx8HC16VbYXTl+lhNLBz7tuK0PfwEgx6zqss+3SIMHoTb+YIosahqJW - V2VTUjzovo1RAloMdEnjAQM2nkyBZAAbZIIM2AygBMYRRq4jwosALJiSzkBDo9Gl21NhXbIVCpKV - ITwSyV+xpsKOZDgiuR9wOfBNIMO/wSwsgWQB0kxJVejRKQcdRgPmLZg3ZIIhkXSnDpcGZgYGCMQo - B2ZGI16RaIBVC+zoaAFMki0ZVl0BQCp1G8YQzce/NAShGYqroxrAHvvkVoQqFuF9aQ4spaSIZE7Q - SIuMKMkCMTYjhVmxkWrD9BJSUkZbd8nEqdQL7IsXacBCHcHe1G0Uy3oDTVMIrkthj/eeToZHZWnA - clRXR9eCP9uq88+cS9upczZlSjHRqeBSr+uQNhi2YenI0Co2hANBadT7FkkSfqHCQ+hig9pC4qJO - V6lOmFAWglqADxscgEN0AdMcEw6GbB1WqFq9rIurm8wqdVcXqbvN/BYFjgl5MUAE0loFjjA5MEAY - MKAiv8QjRckxEDDQM+zJpABAjgBDYSqGpkgOLL9kAiWRWVR2w7cDScrQOmgUdI6NDqgxQBjqo4Az - 3XHBAzGEDyZLMEmapzgeG5g6+oqyEW4j1kKOhHeNRSOZCKkF1Oyq2c02mqAzpVBkNMHEoDZRF9SI - LIcGvhwlQTy8BYg0NSfEHFMheJC2Q/4EEm0WY+if+mgmbXDfnDGHxr8KQ2NbJF6b2KB+JnmpNGzh - r5JSKDRYmR5QNKmChiQaaxZQnoSvEocWDQnEpRzuQpYKKoHsVAw/lVQCDjj5YZJuEBNkcGBTjUSk - OI0aY5FgFaYD9KhSj5sYsDZkWleYlSDjSDS7ZBuGGAOc2HYw36hD4CKJDbYd1p8NIwgaQUek8ajS - eGKOFR+ESCClgYYjhF6y2Dfl13fJNIwizXHgBBqGJ5GaQHCEJKQazLiRpJkSaxwGyRgTQDFcIhpK - JWuKVMqnmEu1d2MnsMW246ZdQPL7gkFCKyrJ/PLltEf4stirK1VLUxqqhPmBF0ptK76hTv/TOUxy - c1Kvj3ta/2OuWuap/ZG5SKlHNN9xNd5LOjDdBXZxbBN1kcJ6inUIYeoA//5QgQl3UryxJBnjxXBB - nzo7CE204rlOUw1MM6CBWUmqXIdHBBNVEKk0b+iVs0FfP/VRyyG0M4V61FY3S5nMujVVE0KHNCqz - mQiURZtJ74H7/FlDe7VPtcbB9YskswuI5UfaV/b4TvOCpc18lVDshOOgLbS64jAO+rTxUr0oWaxH - DkeisXApMo4uhf5I1GYXH6dKCsWwK2oCBRR1XjOHpZ0wdibqskcHXarW7Us6n0Re4IZ9TPTdBjtI - IfVGfbb3xn6bRbjEpIn24vmG2HCu1mJrOgySkRgMQrrjhpd6wYqtMkRhUJGL79BRKxavpIKTi7fH - zerF1MqZBt+oflGDPXBpdyD22XIp7TmiV+hkd8eP48qlWK4BxXKsZhTLsRSent/ZAsVtYzmW1bv6 - kiwjn1uWdWps114kE/GiNo7Dpz/Ss3xhGqplXmiObj5bUj8rNF+9/ZietmHGBZAuy6ag6QBN0zgC - 3DqWqWTP/NsyBBZvKPkzc7Mc8yh7tiVZ1RVTyPLLAGfVsjQhqyCLOCJKQ9ELCgpopSKy56yK7Dlj - ISsgY3GmCZ+ybvtRlQ3d0Wq0fRJ9gUVPhxB/FFM1gMeQR/VpxygM8IX4JR5YtVjTRXGHCxaQqtsK - cWvQ0rdqOrYAnEWTnRObGJYVapHRpInZCbVBUGVa6UY2k6eolFeVkaKYJ6pFRTWB2KB2BIV961QQ - T6D6HNVqpvV+gkeCaYljCbTSbVtakyZohuLQ2jp9C/hWTUVr0oK7o5onM/S5GLnUrpVF5TJ3nrho - UaREQvp8lslyVrmv0W1WQMwtHB/cdmlw23NNidl5o6WlNTJ+ljV5cbMWODo8qXx4I49dy4rOr/Cz - Aw9uGAatGAAWdchaeyih2o5WbgMstqazdneJdZ34ccJ2cqFOK/lOjGTvKy1QVxFiQus0vvK9YDLO - w6+L9mSueOq0IVd1h/7REL+ikxT+wG2FvkhnXLpxNB609wb+pVCi/BvjaC8ZQioY07Gf+PGk6q34 - rM1UbnoCloC64SVVV91kf1IyUuSFC270ly7nvWF/1ett9LdgSS+rY6VKCNgW1yCkZnEFZoQpo7on - 2CuQFsZ2T1DkZQ2tjl+4wJgmc4w9PxWv3WJKMyyzX0vSZmZc1L8ptGJeR6sxPVHVP9ow/Z4sGnVN - otU9tW5IFn33aFv0oymHtECli7KkeCJAgC0eEBmSDR6izaqJgqSmI08IJyirc61ZrP6bmBZBj2ZM - RAr1aG/jJGP49xtZ+2VJXhB7GC2FqEhWHr1BABQyEbziQUByTBBsIwReeLZlhrZyAXr2nFyesrap - vYrGo3HLZ5Z2DINAnuuc4/orJ7qp47qRFV0g8PVt63IruqCaXdnWfAinor1uBK9vi/WHYyWXNdPY - DuJUx19niGcHvZ4NeZ3GeTbk9dWHPJsgjWJ3kNCbDehqCobuyH8q10XHoEVVVbGXzYdmLLax7JgH - c+Zt2rSVNcxIPNoF0mlBxZZom0XjAfqY6GS+5TojoM2MPIV99CwYb4/nZhFiRsOKWMuST0ReF2NG - zLgoPprE8e/CKR2GoK1nw5bskLaraCdXD8U8+JGnXWvyF1r1wtGtMrbFWdsiZmrJhkWttTBSev8R - BiS54AuEQmmR5OBt6gwLJ9wbpiN1p6k/vN+KKxChyuh3o6gbcpvfd4dJYxjCbDVsU5afv4u8LxOM - Gv/5WfDFrz9/6dOJvbZbf3766rkq247e+IdmS45jOIZs10UL2C0rMm2rWL83aJHxxWOtrzzWW/jX - NxDWHyuJ/NV2WpbnGL5qWKbRbrf25K+Koxhmx7ZbmAppRst+bPfVx1q7KP2x3qbyZce2NVWr0uSK - ZaTV4YjaK+TtFai9lSIUhFwIwukrgQmhcplpPQUQPH/ATlsicsEq2fIlsUu/dTGMQvS9n/DVsAp5 - HPzbbwlnKRXjemUtyeoJBgnAaTzyExFRDfwTo04n8HyxHcRswaWRPkOh+uNB4Lnp8fhxC/WKYeAG - STRodGLfb0d9OCUd9tJU+jJjWthq3Xvw5ufjw/Wa0eslrBmTcQgNcFtBGIyuRHbqNkroCC2T4VV5 - VbFKr2juPmkPawfN5rnwsVyW8Cov63bUIn8ZZkhvHtKZImHxQmpKNb2BcND0w+Ga2lDK73oe7FPA - m79Y9Q7LZJvX5rkx/e5X9r24viNOsFonzEdMr3Nfv8R9XV8N3DxHKxqNoPnTL0KVSEsvTs2vrqc0 - Vf5+Kr+Fq+nzwgSE8EXyynlFdR3rVV1Budi2gJ3j5k7ZWWIR2FjeXuWr4dM8O+PETdn5cH5IobVY - mvdDKA66t57+L9pg4o/5QfrZ8/ev375adPqe0352J27ixcFwRC/5BIPPtJT59t+vzum9bxdo3U0k - 4S1K3+MvYJJDM7hsJxfpPJFeEhgP6SKTttC6EmqDYT+bQsIGAG/o9QNWH9WY1VTMk4r601E1cePp - Cl4ItFIuabW/PcoJiLeLjAoU7cgb02sPkhf7YOU1f4/p6ROie/KMTyym8ki004qMT2jzNo99UkWZ - 3lQD4jJbnDKvFy5NWmny8uq9232L4p8+oRcPnjz7j/xfiV5qHrSPekHYfjpV/LOqVq3bovnWzLak - 1IonV36WfDP2ifUfiG839ONR8iEOqa8aHly4Bo9Kv6TPCTrvh6AjPKWeJw0Cny/dxKc8j6GQTzBl - 9zvwkVEfJow//FAuskz8vKgMJdK8EGOBqU/2bu7Uq3HZlRb8O1P5X8Y+PHO2IzkMx134T0xDH6Wv - A2ZaSteU5IbAaw8qXqRiLyY2XFPpWLLhiVrL80Td0U3RbhuO6HZ0zWu125rZ9hpHh0fN143PSSMa - j4bjkaQ6WqfVsUzXxazpM11zlDekuJaD8XsWR2xUtiADgdMk6RC+RX5N3fJ1VWkZcluv5He/eBRY - n0nupZ9EfV8ixs/cri8Fg2D0NFsPoNWsY7iae6UVgiA5ibpdOoG9J7DbtIpzqUROar4n1GpFbBih - +6AMiN3t66XTdUIm05VWvsaWctJI6Oav8aiCgUZjQeWNrOpGhtd/ZAy0+FDYE54sq/xJRj6IzsnJ - iwZHUfQl8N9yEQ774iDJ28Qvszluz5IkQTuncduf37qT8wWUSAWkTWXghdL9C+fsrXAgxFz5nYKH - IPl5wEsnVZmlDKJkWCsk4H15H3HiWcLWKAlzQg8OHWY74bnvH4bhLKmXuDnl54Snvoro2htKr+6X - PAOp4zndEvLO/23sJ6M3bhD67bJyQvCU3j73R6Ng0E2Q1r/iBjriF4y0L5I0bS7TIVedqjypVnG9 - +INBwZQNnAbZftQe51crB32aagiYW/WDJKElU3oX7pAsqtCJo76wPfPBUKBUkcjeS2bGm8MBY4ib - YoKfc8b00+UDqhpa6kJnPODHa54+y41JlxE8/c+TVtS+Eg6Ev+7B1xuJHmHYk/8+yxYbq2TxNE39 - 45nUQbc+zYrPS6+QeknwbVrBWODjrGCkWSP5lYHpFzO35epKuHY7xt/wLd1r6YbW7swa/4yXZQDg - xqPACyswgGzZ+RgWP2ErEtymYkqcxzTykdF3R71/ul+nze6NG0qlfna/NsaDIYwKcp3yatDIv8Nl - 6gTdF6enJxdHzfenJ2Wzwq+iODw7fgfPm3h2qZQ8oTFP+xaaQAJI21jchDGgyccQKY217PGa5nVl - m7m2JQyjQfe9H/fPMHEKviIDRfxG43oGOz68O6FTDdT6HN2QIgI4GpvDTEm3UtEW0FnoTvzln+db - V534C9SEjByGOGuwlMblFdPNdM2g2wvpPMhRFEZxGSF6WYrffk/XZCXlRLpdil9edMaWRP2BN4eK - XmcBCuw3yOrRy9m0GHPw/wAAAP//AwAXlVl8bPQBAA== - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:40 GMT - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - pm-csrf=P7hogxIYbRHhOchSMWBVawpdY9MoAntG; expires=Thu, 29 May 2025 23:51:40 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31449600; Path=/; SameSite=Lax; Secure - - pm-sessionid=vopa4ve86pjx7a6byxo2xjc59qp19m04; expires=Fri, 31 May 2024 07:51:40 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=28800; Path=/; Secure - - ncbi_sid=9A8895FB22208AE7_BAFESID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Fri, 30 May 2025 - 23:51:40 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Vary: - - origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.78 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: http://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: ' - - - - 301 Moved Permanently - - - -

Moved Permanently

- -

The document has moved here.

- - - - ' - headers: - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Length: - - '327' - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:41 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Apache - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.78 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAADzMMQvCMBAF4N1fcdxcpKUONbOLIHVykg4JuWA0TUqSFiT0v3vtILe9790r+CKp - KaIomL8ToUBy1n+wwoVissFzUh9bXCvc8kQ5oXgW1MrEMDJOsxpJc9/qOTpnU97dara265rTuW5Y - g3ozb78DV70JzH2AG2/e5wz7NshFWieVIzAhwuN6EfCfWAe+ww8AAP//AwBTvVrssAAAAA== - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Cache-Control: - - private - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:41 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - NCBI-PHID: - - 322C94F129AFBF0500007511672A29FD.1.1.m_1 - NCBI-SID: - - 391DE0148DF53292_507CSID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=391DE0148DF53292_507CSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Fri, 30 - May 2025 23:51:42 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - X-RateLimit-Limit: - - '3' - X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '2' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: http://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - response: - body: - string: ' - - - - 301 Moved Permanently - - - -

Moved Permanently

- -

The document has moved here.

- - - - ' - headers: - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Length: - - '326' - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:42 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Apache - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Cache-Control: - - private - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - text/html - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:41 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814901 - NCBI-PHID: - - 939B5B3F7502167500004CDF532F729C.1.1.m_2 - NCBI-SID: - - 065BB74121959273_D8A2SID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=065BB74121959273_D8A2SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Fri, 30 - May 2025 23:51:42 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - X-RateLimit-Limit: - - '3' - X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '1' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 302 - message: Found -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=065BB74121959273_D8A2SID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814901 - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:42 GMT - Location: - - /38814901/ - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=065BB74121959273_D8A2SID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Fri, 30 May 2025 - 23:51:42 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Vary: - - Cookie,origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=065BB74121959273_D8A2SID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814901/ - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAOw963rbuLG/k6dAlXaz2zUl6+JbYqt1bCdOG2fdOHvrTR9EQhJjklB58WV/9TXO - C5wH65OcGVxIgARlOXFO9kf97doSMRgMZgZzA8Ds/+b4u6P3P5+fkEUeR+PH+LOPH0lEk/lBhyUd - MoYnjAaEhDmLM58vmfiU3y7ZQWeR58tnvV7mL1hMuzyd935k03M6Zx1ClimbhTcHHT5/RhQcny+7 - Mesl2RPES+BnP2Y5Jf6CphnLDzrfv3/p7XbMJuzpsX8V4dVB5yfv+0PviMdLmofTCMbweZKzBPq9 - PjlgAYwKUxBdf+N55IxPw4gBGUBymocsI55nYk5oDDM4pUmwYFHwMg1ZEkS3BtL3acE6zR4S73fL - PIzDX1hgdBgONh3wVyG7XvI0NwCvwyBfHATsKvSZJ75skDAJ85BGXubTiB30u5tyMvK//ShMLknK - ooMOsBXwJMwHhAtgsRRCBtz1g6Sb+NOwm0RxNwkX3Tm/EvSs1fv6+voTe885n0fMowmNbvPQz7o+ - j81JWKiy/DZi2YKxtabRWxbTmAU9ut2f7Wxu+d5w6vveaG+07e0GW3senY2G/jQIhtuB3zs6PDo9 - 6flZ1uNFvizy7hbzZ9uDKaWbM9qF5x0itTdnNznCiWk+fvzF6BttDfydTZ9tb892WujTHFSEfklu - 7u34w81N2t/aC/orufn4C7J0czqjW3v93ZG/0yZyTSHQmId5xMavkyycL/IMlmLOSb5ghM1moOsZ - 4TOC9iFIWegvCM3pTUgJTwRMxGY5uYJlnYY+mJsiC5M5ed8nMV0u8SPYF7CmOSNzGnBgRljEhCUL - mvgshl7EI+fF9IwF+z1JRct6gaUXcQrWhmYHnRkYkgfnYZFdB1kvCLO8h/izXszSNLxmFGaZelMe - Bd41m2JT95rPZgPNUnzSU0/8lGcZT8N5mJDeuFJWYZBfUrB3PNF22NSMBdhHv8gJtmu8YQx+pAdP - 1pqpz1NW5GGU9RKcRhjPezM1nv7QFbh6tbGbQy6T+YMNKXD1hFAFD/p7gxv4fwPESNCYxqADAQvI - jKfkMAlSHgYAqtxlsQxAcbIueuStlPuXwqT2Bpv9Ua/f710US/QrHvT1QEYx83wewecw8Y4WKYfv - wz3RWCFucL5l9hl4NtAzRe1DccMDXA2ObO3cbO2Qr4VriZc8Y8E3ghvh+YInjAxfXWxgKOHBrPvw - kAfkPS9wFcK6Ap1kJd+I9KcO9YKVCH4px26eoMMY7MHmtrUjpjbW89oZ3OwMHPPqZzmZs4SlEMSA - CQnPabAhfpOBmJP4GIOduO88lMzEuA82q52BPat+f3QD/7fLa7RBRiCxLTEXaM4bgvu4aamBH04V - +6PazEYwwMg9M5DIMA3ElEb5whTfR05GjvVwkxnpyZTL6iUQfg7+B9bHt+SViMyIjlnRwbG5msHX - by+83cHmN3oqRuSKtEyy+YSrfpPQjHY71RpWofY05dcZDEgD8JRZRqY0JcIkOXAbBsvA+WSwubW1 - Sw3U54CJpVdM+Np3bAY+CUa4XrCEzDn61xlYOnL6/v35BQGvjR8co6WqozGU9FIeYvKE2/LkEzV2 - nQ1LwcvJPI8neUr9SwNTjnkCWDRB7xs+nyNZS5rSOHumZRCwGS2iXBqn0r3XBwHlMfBK592xHKmj - UzBd2ae133JhiXN4tL0JP/3jnf5xf3S0hV8GL4Z7R8P+YDB4Oer2u/Fk605qFJ+ynOaTIo2MAVYl - Gj2EX4U74vOJD85wzlMzRYsgFQU9LlJ2J2E+2KKJD70sLajxq1S7FjH6RZaDukkFa2FAYLGVTjPU - l3JyrolxU+opg0iSXbG2DoUttd3d/mhvs98GLUi6XxekCKLAZURvWQBds3v2zXiR+mylWpZsvuA+ - 5LxEYMjpPBP2tkhmoDnIffij3fljc5iAZX4aLtF+GYMcJhBVZYhRGLYpy68ZmIkgnM2KTBq9NMtF - lk3e/EDiW+7TNMBvsxBMVxZmwsKjdYf0lWQghDTMb6Ejefnu+JBcQ8y2RHMEUXsIUdsSQ7ckj25F - fgAQHngA0NEAsYPUCx8UE7D7EOzPIYwDpYLcPgRHAK4C2KsSgHJwxD/jBcYAMBOMAbgYH7BnxfSD - yESuQ/A/ghokFXskPC+nDZgFgGt8ApwVHcX8yH/+/b+dscnTS3Z7zVNL2ss4DJ5pkW+QgIfP+pvd - /nCn3/sAQoY8v7sEn9/dHG4O97b3Nsg7jovkhJwL1kXRBvlzGE9ZCiz6mbwJkw1yRtMcZveCHCOr - bv3LcIMcQl4EAoUh8TNYyQ1ytAgjCIuOgJKUQsAE+VFIN8hLFtOIwV/FMviUimws2TATtEORoP2e - 9Ah63ij0hUJkLTCAeZ6AcQCRYwQMetcCqBSjDc8SEiVwZ/PbDfKqTPV+v0FOGcyZ/KAzxKxtTBec - gdPZvLjNQm4CFTHFiZ4BeqHE71jGE8w1yWs5DnYDqS94IMCQm2dhEID3PpwzYPlFnvJLRn7gURFD - 28+gj3MtFZmokkNl0jbI29en8OvNGfw6evEafgtGg8pBKg0LrYDkBbUXSI+wxFU2HwkzLBb7i5Dn - zF8kYgLQD57FAswAfwPipqlYCKgIfpgg1SfHb16/PbGVOOVTnpsqjOv0ZiPhMx5F/Bo+0NRfhGBd - VTdVHbwVZUqRgJtVxS9aEHCS6Hap0rw2vapeuz0nrv9a0Ye0ohZrRSrtENSqIg30BvoRXj3xEK8n - UHlXg+6H5bx9rGcZ8yEKagm5PsewWDMwS9psmkEw5gTFhgkuUAPe1nGVEwDbQbueBTymYdIIHxzl - aVdvVEejb1bEMRiPSUTTOWQwQjDOfr/O1W/T+InLv8bm/67/B4+iNG8/mwGoYufvgHMXDP0Z+ens - jaOoKtp0cQ/rEioQ6sHSTGSroQLf3sTRfWrKBrUVvq5AIlaSXuJE0VGl9MdhRqcQwUjdYCD5KcYc - CWGRkGUm0/uEkz9d6GlBsCQIHa/a+aiV+B+6QI6VmF7CPUlJV2917Pcq4kR2Y+qDH+aC55NfhXXp - uGsPJZG0gMAwNeMnHcmTdyfPIYAnf/75+UsI8iNydvj8aMEwODw7O31+xsOU/Hjx/IinUxDdG2ik - Cw5Ev3peBvrk7MVztTe0kgiseRsUbG71hpu9weZgVHV29gNRgllYWOn9+Rt+Qb5LxMaws5PKYxri - OY+gIxcd3YPF7py6BVxXASZYym9x0mtY8dWMuxIxu4G5v9cZm7tJrk5hlhVmn62ySyujIQ80B1mR - EWpz1TJwYtE6HHjbg81hRx5DaO6A+TThCZiwhpW6m3Fl3WG/h2cZQEhTHtwSe6/NNDH7QXhF/Ag8 - wkGnXPHelCYJqlcYOJ4qy2R0vKZpAosSrHiWiahDQKyE8dB4lYCEvF+AR8PwiSSMBRn5E72iF2JY - LHZCvn6pIq3otkvOI0bBQ7MErSsJBUhOIZmjwRVNcoreaybMiEiLGWDNwIfBsxkTNbTsN5rCHpCo - JqQ/qg81a9dkFUwExNvgVe3xAnJOltRZ7ebY2vw6isLlFDI8TGOlYzwFD8VTSIzRMAp3A56c44am - ZIqPW29q8oSmjOQsXnJINkPwSkUC3A4j5Gb3cZ0t0yLPwb4psvyIZ0xNzpNNnVKI+KNc4hHCVXQK - smxSZSSixyVqvkTxzcIpFgGujyz1DwQFk4RPFKcnrh4wL+rhkkt55BRXExrIwMX3oIQLxOxmSXHr - U9XPtbZJ5lkKJ/7oExpUs7zIqJddhksQkjYIT7C4BH7RC8DehFGmkF4AFK4FTCrIEpeBsjpiEFoV - MjE4OSh/yIuTV6/fktOTw+OTd+ZzDEn2Id8S8bFBjWEITJXFJupD8BBgoK3miWYI68n13p5scNoK - hJqnYUAM8NCwPQI+jOcE9WF1ub3aVJK7/qt2NAmN8GRW96JLZhGdK2OqhluOIV/gs1ko6rgqCdRm - 5vskxGD6IsddbALjsjTBMGS/tzRQSIkbCuLim1pU5tSby6ymVzMaZazRXqk/EKRx5XxZAY6NLvsZ - YHOISQ6uzM8pRLFPM7Lg1+SWF+Qy4df7PexozNJQbPndsLBS5pWxe9zggxpV6S2xNKHikWrWM0HT - 65pjm24puHkRBmgZPegrBhAH1Dxw696CRrOasrnlprXTVyKLsX47mUbcv4R8Zm4K5eOUVShowHMk - sptdWRiFvh6DNcISQfnc1NraxE3qMDDoWBqwNL+hRoD6JPPxe1BwJI/EjCYQxuf/+ff/ZOVS6IIC - SDi78zQ1CcGflywQXqlaHnoZIbYc0yKZy4rBIP3sxmHUJS/YDNhiYcoWoOBgciG1hu7hFSbrRjk1 - xlAgA0+HSgrEwgeOGfJMEmChMohBSromP6zFW6lx/csdypVl0a9buUQvp2qdYsvnVSxhRTH0E1W9 - 9ZUJ+2o8etplZ1CkTAQ6+YLmwlJhxKMOdKLiyETUQtgw7ej4RX+a3Jr6JfBBLHoVBoJylvjp7RLM - v+35sXcK6yXGMkmg5gfB630VrBmWKocMH2tCQFWOKPBeg9q+FzVCe10CjgGiNB2kQiYKMYbEC2LX - nvnxI5dXhoZHjYZKu68XgFqfT3bpi0HHZBLxOe/YohXwdI1Du5DuKJQCixXG4TYN7m1zNbk5ug85 - PT8K/UtVHy0bdbfXp7jNI3s2yfqIsKM8y4I0Zr3DOejLLaIXK06uM2vUuqZLJaC1FaFixUe2JCzW - orssRCnkEYJR4SbVQ+Q7Fp5tJqvGZvnZMkoyPpGj6NiEiOrUQUdtpz9LsKLQ4DyWzyZga4sG3zVZ - onEMfIAVJyYtSFdDmvTjgizJWoMWgejRo1pgpLEt+bJYKkY9siKhGbgN6hUZrhLRWeZzOpbX0U+z - I3bBQgAJWHYJEQmsDTxz38QhplUg6EScDl2FNEslmvEFhmCKemGczD5VCCa+tGuKmLYHXgrG1Wri - hNFDyW8dSxLqkYM5agLuUVFmGuRRLckUYCrTVDJtLmLMAtfQJYc08xCS6pLNjcC3ZLJIBTWUyVOk - eDEaH8qBIKwd6blKZjfmrdmHSuEJ1dV48PgNkxX87Bn4uV7FkjplUp9MfYk4HoXTLRWla1IjMupK - BkVkcqFIxDIKACrLS6BH+1E4rpmS+BblpW1JT36tbHPGsHIEohTFQLcxRlFN8LJNuzDlIONjmi1E - Yo7WYb8H1KygbFlMszpdPo8i6eiy3jScRiGfp3S5uH1ogsXY43Ms1apTGetQDGNjgFJRrRp6uuGh - ySwH1NpM9JN1yEWfVuRNYsN5As8fmlY1mnAP8KFO4H6viJqaX32sLKF+VoZUOi8Vq0SGRgm9CudU - bhmagQUQgyc+L9ktLh3Fj+Q6myi3K9uhebK5zsWjHuYJrKcOlGa9J/J4pEaSdVyWiZTtBx0YJadT - cfrjoOP1hRw1gcKDriKxv9bdqLtI6NdJEMHXKY8Z1qDuJGKwlukgbaMP6qOf3d5v/GFZVcO6mS4t - 3DXpYWNYLLodyd53jlmeiH5y50Aj50BvS/WUYylN1sU6O6A/jFiaC0vfcMZUNHlie3khbhlU6YOR - adQKhidvj1vKhapULqdu8dNcRGf1AiWBx/y601x74zL0Vecp98NkWeRqB1TGGx2945Kls1gc8bqG - fC/HndYOuaJRgbcfP+yezMPhL78csZPd77bjs/fvfvhpNBq+P04y/4e/+P7Pl6Mg2z56cfwu3D1c - 5h8+/BS/vrx6F7xcnrw5jU5xrWMKSLTRAi2Vp8sOOnPckqVFzvVuA0S6s5ktWFlBrj5603CuNow9 - gVcxwkOuAJtuhV1FJhpAmj/lRrOdWIkSqXcN7kwXX8sastpmF3mSTiRMgZyLdpmA6Ha1KMvv2irr - 08kQTskNhWCCkUQDTnNKjm1nevYfV1r1MJvYIsvLesb0vSnog5F7ySYS2anX4zLr0oysL1clFqGN - Xp6GEMbpRBrwemob5BSLBEr4U5qWJwZE/G4+N4VRbxzXqam8lD764CCq4rVVKEA98mYhiwJSbrPu - i4GdhgjAQbGCSc7SWO8yiEGeiZKE6DjWu5hybaph5QpVBKpn6ugI4rI1QNqry3DphQy3GyFI83KO - ldyDTseEUSdhPMTh4eEVj92AotWgxDPvXwVDLdUtho2rHqo5C3SSbaohxavYKVbX9Sez2qw50hs7 - VMOPYNLeNK9FDkf4WMtVjlXtljWbVIXGzH/klQMPo6uUCcuoEyfFbNDlMK9rQ4OQC6U0gTyeEjiR - N7IiiUwOobYDJKJGhmTd4a12tayyVrUPdZQyPMchHJEom6kH7y4uRNlOYlW1vIjzSxKFl4yI5KW6 - 6I6YXrBcH7bFSzdY5avgNRr4iwdugGSfVd2NBaImKvALY7rEEprDOrsKwGZns8RLyxBZbcb2rI1C - l00R5wEA3DNwWp3Wtccumwx4J9qLHCqSrCJT80M1B19vjq45iRJeflVO+6GmUmK36nXVBq6lyTQW - mW+YeEa35hYWdVb6KwCrJtOYr8jyRVwvhXZHRvE93iQT4HbVvOT3gkVLm9X341iTZ0jhpDkkIYKW - V9hg1ampyRyTWc4StVz26GjUqRhcICJtVLvWYhVZ+78NEKyYSWozTzhILcCWdtdibMRDdQCNAFc3 - RKTW/rINCeFkkSbokozYq27emt3iIspDvCaZsgwvxWmSidaJlM0b+pDRK7ZBGATP0QZucQVgyGSs - Z9RBEajECgJhURmEWAKVjsF1UEOrr4GIrIv1rv3nxg60QCwnL/Ha0E1txg4T3OdjbkityQjnhlDc - xJpzKdYLgFYqq5yVyVPB8gdhqoWJrI333myVmD8HXwXm9Rl7guA1zprrAEKKUveDlC8Dfp14Yruw - Y4nABHTzaBX3q3BO9iTroLMOF2UQek+wl+o0weCp1sEOpeTydIFUYrLI0NPH8El0tjnW4EIJryen - H1SMrOyXPm5mMl9n4GOjwmuNoKIVVd8rg1jttC2FrUlPOrz69MWPjopdbVZs6wJYX3FrHZpRwSpo - bXFBEM7dvjKKcO7IieKj4podrdckZfLKrDlrpno5XtlovOikbTuu94cp9S/xcO2BAP3d8PB3g5fw - X8v5UGjRJ0QF3BCXrmcRIm3H+OyWvDAef/QkjSL7F52jSYea4lH1aK3p6WO8XkwTivO4ezk0urhZ - 8ASIUZBEQVYUYS1bxhbmb0e4YWf3as/T4+KmQ6byRnl2wRPlRPlZrQrRqm7sayhVMCuvcxuQfpGm - mAW1QNoxjRGxCBQ101xtJcsRdCYsL5+YVDZtgZrlRM/SAtMWoAY0wZs7fK7jTTOCV0fchDHojI9l - P6L6VfGukeDaUV5loavDvjaEPHSvLUxtBDOGbvQsjXcjB6nVdEAeLWGsOVU5pJ6qZdVeCiRW2G+n - RYiK4dpRZRwlI8l4/VK3hk6Y3lJPXPc0A36tuapNMFxSS+o4x/pe7n5PQkiJ2NDqIv5Yv3NqBSTe - cBifn70+NqCw+I1zbTmg48x7LAgB8MVq1U6im6eK3LmXsHBmVlRPvhoAVvZVpidWXGrlG2YLscFc - 5wjuKnMvBnZGp2w0ZphhMrei/9I4Y3VoFkY6HVgMFC5RjHdOQZbgDfG6xtT7GephvUu5e6CzAYj2 - 8c1WYZBZGb5YU9NbXftp66aaEdrZHdC29q0PqXcz8FVGK0i5CwyHtGBKb/XlVoNetI4aQUN44MMa - JQNZHhelcFMrtBlzoWpaWGlfnxlLUxXPywfKutaVTw+jX/AjpbhqcImI1/yAbfXUbWFdyZXfyNf4 - 9ZvKDrZ2Vzsqsnfdxrb3cpjaVuCmvV+fPD+7gujq4ocmaN2w2xFVq2qoXMnUCvvMki0AWYhvZA1W - mb7RKpYQvvsQ7/3oBJNewbdut9sCvnaOdHfhxIQySlF2WVXW5kvDKTlon/hfzRofa81Rc+TmHZyn - lr3OtMF+ShyFDvxx3BISDGkBv1+Fquyxsjzz/yQWxUNLMOJRq0ws1y8rs457R/jzWCUUVUHMwRSr - zNXuzB9XbLM8upFSpMyny9xfUH3JEDM+6zhKCdFNWN4rv/XEm1WWaZix7ofsDylerk8PQDpRCCrz - FU9wIR3IP0eyyxGNIswq3ePL24TBQwcdojJWanFrtNFk5YOGG1jh8MQYHxNmSOIquPXijfXGvHc8 - sUbIUmr9F46/PzbesHasVkcVF/JND2ZYUdvMMpFJQaq3Q3QMxSsfmWZYqq5uGveJ9Jx4XDVn8TOi - Cy7Gm31rY7fzvzas4nzrEJ3e/bF6C5otStSb1N/c2R3sbc3YzmB7Z7YzDPZ2/N0+3QL0w70Ro9Ot - 0eYgYEO2u7s33Nue0dnedNgP6HCP0mlQUbBmxLBGMCnJzfmKELI8hyDPbHg0A6sXZpeWErznq8JK - k12yrG9J+R3zw2WIRkTK+1C+07JTOzAhev6R3VA84iReeG6ojzGF6sGS4nY8WIJ//o16vxx6f930 - 9ibdb71/fPvH6gF8+3vX+Nr9x7e/7ZCY3kQsmecLvHW/2SmZ8LlEgK/WXDuOB9hPYPeFcFSfwGuL - VvPRw/B7sLXdcbP54dhdFkg/YwbVMpL9boa1sijiRuXKPrT1wi0F+alTy7fKVGuNJOYTU7RV9bI7 - O6lB18i87sqsmkoTJn5UBAzsNL5CGO9e0shZvLTWkr9g/uWU33TsXOG1REbO2MWpfFW2eOkBhg9a - 2q7xzBXlbrdWmBNklYp/JE6t9Y7Z1LS9tjZLabSc9SvjXFL9qwV1ucyraLijTrmZT+QZPfDLYh9h - +80s+/H0LDjEn6Poz9P8u+WHvwyWZx/m2aubq6udt8Fff9wrXpfHiY239OrEQ+cZZQiepjwt34lh - nj6Tp2usdqJ7geaGgdpw0V3lToQ4U1YSsK4Z+2KpPniGz5PrOzbzTbC2XVCxP83KnX2pdZ8p17fT - pOw+Sb6gcM0s/64DE2WXz5zmryeRT8rz1wmUVTqnXiKifYBxDvqeKGohNxsNtreHdNsfToPdrdHe - 7syf7u7u7O3uwUcW7ExngT/aCkZbO8F0uDXY7bNRn85Yf+j7m1uDUUnHHSWLyo4Y273tVYs2KKt2 - QUJ8oT2fY3iGr1/I1i9pmPjFLrRcDGV9wVSoVR2KNBL8POg8advMvrtIMVyrSAFxKJbXjL1xXagY - quO6j6tSRRv/rOrDHbz2jLsU7aUMGyCLKSBLy7isfDOBOvIdZnhvzWKTKCb18Aajs71nYaBBgAf8 - HIAKTzuAjcgXRVIP7IfGmbDrJrq7wGykc5Z7ev8NayJVBUVia2230cgrVh4E/CZBuKI9M+Ny8MUA - x97yJK2AtsFN/qecOyp6jbMejquZ6i2KX3LLqL7N7y84/itm85TjfWd11gHWEZdP1IqrzliJNgnu - iX9Srsqr8NJiacLNOYo+Db+wctWB0jQ6OFafC0xxsoJqQCiGujrfywE2jmetGLPuBCvQiWDPBKlx - x94rmTTWNw0IfDOOKDUC60o6DyoobTfWkVYr7Noiax8N86iyzv3rkWpJ8D1FW/VTXowmRD9bR8ry - 2rCZUNXP32DoqG+CON7U11oDIbY9z8o41DAEa0ywcg6fVid8i2+juOVFanDlWcUOizvmRS5ivG62 - EqtURKfjqoBWrgdjXmWH9rDBBV1WvP72z6/+VfD8+Vc0Xj4/+CqCT/P8+d97//h9ecUKXxgk340v - 9AL0GRCzVL4MUbzRD9vkqxjwlW6CW4KXz4gLubGnUatWls/XW0uNRSSs1MTFztoaSngymdErLv7N - T7ODq+hS8wXS5eece/gSCdKWY8tYC/nvyLJrqhUXGd7jJRFeP88XsAyBGwanmymK+XGtBeUM8j5p - VZXWY60a5NGCY7ZK11hBRilybRpqNnNlUbJ9ibShu49pb2xLi2GdSulUza9/+/XTJ3eT+PSbLujV - 19/gLXLy9CXqMr4O7uk35A/mV/KMPC2VHZ8YhDw1qtW1+mOL9uO/O3Qrii8eUCT0/VP1/3v5Jlpx - 4ZAGdSNLgoJpx4TY96ep4eOq+6Nj9V5bII/QOVVvQGpfNW6PtaKWdd86VnsNy1W/AvfrKl81L5c2 - mz/qikprtFF/fUgQmImu4qFZN7lvDctRv2pm0M4SlqN8ZUZCjh61AtYdJQ6z08oS1udne614ZRSu - nO++Xa/CY11aaC/xtII9VI3HGmCtIk9bj3qVx3Uto1Hm+T8AAAD//+w9aXMTSbLf9SvqeYMZCCwb - 2xgGBjRhDMwQixkC85Y3sbHhaEstq4dWt7ZbMmj/0fsb75e9zKyj6+pLh6+RIzDu7jqzsjKzsvJY - Ts1jeXlYqp5C0VMKxTLTlOoKq1L3KJAKZmL0aqkmGtU5D6bo2R79By0Q3CpG2QGM5gKj/Oq6JX8J - 1+rF17mhWjIDUtnVl1cBqabGc+hqCfUM1deGekuNfHVvLJChXVGyQgNkXKIWWh+rxULuYeX6INGI - rmwwoMnhp0Oc38+N513zpfTus9/rOgupAHDCTOpis92C6xlmXb1zGmLOQJ6s5ZPriuBZKwt+VySs - qU27QlmtDhGv656xRE5Txc1AIFoZKTzxOa7pIlDwKB372lwG6vUa3gnWyRR2zTVfDRJpvTEmwDjy - gWkf6nHo8ZYwZS2fZ48mHhmtNBKoymrYApVRrrFA1cy49w+kHdSBCN4jZal96VtluBN5wVQmTFVX - qBWmHJYvrpuMZo2LKP2LKzEgGRa1MPKRlH+s1249o792AgevFOY3SbxY1ndIgUJkCSzV5zqFW9iD - kjoO08BpmFlvsqgbAZqSM/34lMDihy+AOz27nLMPvKV8+O8tKM0V7PcSRPb761UXr9521YAQhSNb - 0o5Y5Lmh/V2FL4gEAIfAt/B8HM5KG8PzfFEWvi92Zeu1doQgrk31VhxYuaHZLHK11fsMbcjAazTv - suBPZecAkxDD0DM4XQXZRZRQHpLmVv0EM1ocDHvqWr9+SWcxSas8nhmZ37DZZBCI3MN4qSkmItw3 - ftGW0DLMl/14WBPZzHFmzZMmnoeD83nl0F6A8Iy2Yp4Agr1TokECsygQKfuE5xD2igdkA+yiyiXH - qcUPTcaZxz/N7jzMS+SY4rMHxwWMBP3hjfBDVdWZqqZ/38XDH2He6KRVBQcjK0LKT6Eq/GADGCVp - FYjway2EEjeXQg1gkiqfiK3eh3ShA6hE4QakmEaRw6oOZnFYH0OsmmgzK8JmjZ27cBp7bszEmS6n - J66/TiB9Cpz1FN4IFYOooVHd8zQu4uWx+0W0IGFWJCPL22HMK6U9N8R5j6egRVL8wA3OZwRZaKbm - aUqjK/ByiBwKc3c09VZATxFRpXYlTcfvij6TFNYgG6gwNOo6sKSetT9MW/8xgGiENPqE/+Gz7ncq - fQvDr1jnC/3fqMoA0G6Oofsjf4WaWBtNF9kAgZgbKt4irBDYHKtkmWU96GIQtFjrLyPMYQtVfllw - rUs6Llvw6pU9nSXYCGVYGkYZiDj8TaPlAmywKvM3jSp/noW5VVu8alT9SzhInAbUy2YjGM0yZwji - XaMG3maRVZ2/aVT5FINw2rAX7xpuFqNu02q4La2q4tVV7ThOGFpvOFHtyvebv99m9NWs22gnLrD/ - Ftp1i+21xXfYAvtqod1UtYdWg83N0DUL0SO+OZ5+ovIi4tWicoDVaTMkFZUq4fs67Z/OxpU+iSV1 - Pjf0SXSqHzXySiyt9rmpW6K7rd68fv/uw5vKaDVXiEj8kro5IpEzVjBl4zRfGI+sPpvhkahUCds9 - jA6Ax/NGK3G4pRxle4dULW9Ub+8RdPOoRYV9qLDfpsIhVDhsUwFNDHpo5thmUDSqiiqN0NCo4PeT - ddafInJEQzhdi2jE/pO9p5jniO+WaoT35WPwKcGFDYiak2dPhJdhwr6NQtLDZiEqaJMfedZOVIkJ - XVjVjllI9hGRFJH+YDh57g3XfPuLMAlIzRqTgN8nXLBiWA0Vz2ETNUGVslYbha0spx+/CqGigg+d - tDoe7a4D/nZq8mtz1l1XXC6uOSstVhaYS0U257Bb0+W8c9/ZNhjXQGSdaBGUy3/77K+55qv5Zmuz - zqv5wtXVjjHsvZuvLHV1gTeV4xXGb6P8LEAEMGll4fEtIiDzRNzpcIp3uAIgbrCsymltwnTelTCd - uvGbHfbSHJ4Z83f3BrONtcV4kHviTOyJ9izkamM70n2hHtvRogRZG9ZiT74he6kmotfCYlov41UZ - gmV57ucx9od6s6/Vml9hnrC3YSj9OjymV/YIyziEt9zChlbY2hDGZRpZ6W89xlJFrkdu0SBNXG4O - dV7GYAUnX2f31Ma+SS790rZNRvS1Dz5bo1rrJzU3+7PEwCpbp9LvfPl+/NF+f1tNnHCicYQZBBe5 - Ul/wHld12vyo/WE2Pg8zxDHS0jCRnUBHtVrVm9ttqcKtKFqjOOsdttCUNSuqaeO0sHW9vWY9cRVb - C+VaK7XaAtqxG643ICHrRmkOinSbV6Q/gJ7ayHawNxqKc46IcheVBG3YsKAryVd4O5nXcWaeq9Jn - w4d89j18LeOuBvs0hDKqtqVzT41d8g4LUql1X7wQzEoOwd2wGgTLMsPJRLd+ka8AkEByWdx1wKvH - CRsboAPfZxUFZWLeHx/Di6UF9zoHcS0Lp5mDh7/hrory1RgLqDDMovcgx7zWoj3K5okvZB7OStm+ - I3778nDKHL2qMc2xVaRQOuJFyV21rB+LWKlTnnwtn3lGqLK8gDr5+n0SIlpgcYZJp7UsMkIVP4iG - wzAj7dV0HodO/Jtlgi9AZ6Vl9GSMviIgw6nItdJnQ67mrvpgZ5cVBxkJKJoSiC/x2FtO5AIRWahw - O+mdcD3WrmVcaObcOoYZ2mmkX1AutYJy7PZzZU9IxobpZZhhxijKvLYLDGPXeLOD5a1EiIXvvOhf - y3FkoL2B9OanwXmRXMrGNKcDI0xHOb4ZAaIx64XoDDHrZP7h+NU7vaGdasKkBxTw0EI3UWL/ayWJ - qm3NiV8oJur13aqvZvgHXV1+QJEfzh5lZJSSc6lEZj3DoIXTGjYKZJWR5GR6uqpgltYQRUOCLlXM - xaOC8WSnc0NYiNSDJVuo/C6hVxksUizzJlrkGqNFLhDmcVVxG69NQ9UmVmO1hwnlA1042p/A75sT - l7GahBuVSrmCUao6MmNN+C0NPHURGYvkrMsuxi2NvXh1K1dEUWy2fC2jLjpJbStDLC4bXbHZFK4y - ruKaAyq6M1I17nhExaodso7Iijc4pKK7s8r3Tk0gxVYbaOUhFGtiJ5b0bpG8tQdPrKfNqwiiuHNV - QRSVWv1Gh02si8DjpkyvvwG4HVER69CtgRzQJi7iJiTiWmDeICiiRF5S8Hrwmf82l2cM+CMRWmqe - jHfVqk7B0B0tJzYhTtVkojMNvjpSq7F8WOEskBCbIr/0qT5krnd+uZcLBZvQH1J2IWHm1SlgOAiH - wSyeylJ2jiutZH+WoSK2rKQ8DYYXnKFrtwgqSARBiaibvuwCTMfknMz0IbqoI6Z4JqdoFJP4YhU6 - UzqgcuXSa15FmJ9XKpgGWToZpN/giM1P4T6dj1hMq1XtFsEW1EN0BbFzTAGUtfRdxuiFmbzXPZpq - aq/kZAT75wKxNPgTyrhoCjBy11QnP3IysiYZsfMbBW0/cAyUudyap07z5sF2nIrq814X/LZsi2u/ - xb2OBvY87SMg8P5AWkS5lyVU63TETWllhE9N9WE2Qpr7nLB+lpDKf9BFZZi6uBExJhQPRt3Q893d - KdAKEEYxT+FuRBgCr8Jw+gueb16+S/LoYjTN7+0/go8p/AdnAfgdDocwe3ydDuHX2ywKB1kY9Ufw - AEv9PQrwU6LKx+FwCv9dQvMZqsbh71kOo4b/P+/BrzGcHfkjUHgsD1sR/rsIBinMK5qNsc9khAR3 - HN57s3/vp0f3jp7AS6k+3t0tUR0XVxmCykjoIWAJaKz4syugIYpm/DQB4AIRBkhKkqLeWX2eBtlF - OH259ZHfoJzy9QBEAmymdet+TCeziSzN6Q99UDcEgGSfjS4b3DQ5gin1a30Uu0nOp0eBcXiEjRJE - QB3hMOiH52n6lbCB+szEfzuT0eSX2csVg1v2d5Xwfmv2uWKAD88NWPOdr6Uk0YkADXkSAg2LvXfj - FkfzGLDIKabf1AyL9pziBrPPodKZKszZfendtTlwhzXpXKCUS/Gfj7JHg3PYHnE+tmU0A+RMVypa - ln3yalv2Zbs8CbouteNNURl/dFZ15IB81xbtiiHoJgqFaNKdZBElFtVmJwUVqFC9qotaNZS1o5k1 - nHGM9IkyYlVxeLb80ilfVJ+VF/9TUCMK9mPwyyRQSEBGCvAcXQQYPUMIgeIFCoLGunzEQ6z20bZq - GM5iEEIilYeohPUCspoNiQGrUNsFK6abB53dkiOcypgpnqlSHMlKwh6ap/QsjsbSTLrj4JsYCR2r - P+NAGangWDCbjtIsh3O7rpdwsQOheAaNlJA10z7b0wEtk0na6mcphTF7mpbsXzZP5Su+5OQKmZC+ - y2abTaliekCehnBunHbTYRfFpwwj0llT9ZWpmfaxqEI2rLLZfApfuY/VcsDwDogDprrjGnCV/fOD - bhzmIhqpDbDiSw2YKNEub2JJkGhdckAUTVdM2j+xfAbYhaKqM7HiS83ETosmlpyY1qU4UagXi62m - pNW6pZo48ynBBl3fiMAi6UhBmJzE4RQodjocqgsIfbrScFlN1ox7p5WccAVlXxH2chpkHuIUdfMQ - NtNQuVl7dfm5m5ARs0X/rqzekOV9NtmLVkAxbQsU2O/vobwVHd8KVGs9zsJO/MUuYAo3g5TGkmTA - KMWEcRAVik5p5SVz4ur2kfJlj0+g8+K/ul229TaK+bXXZBJHmPEdBeOcoeksj0tAGBflID0Pooxj - 6TBLxzJaZ7fb4y2dh/1glofy/TCdYQLwJBQxDKigM1Hx+wViJxx4TMmAD19nywbcvRINj0MqHx2f - Ky3XuN+sVFoNOvK28eRJPy4byNNZ1i9EKMNS9E/4lgRKec/kQYKb/BW6fHMOspb3GORvWZZl3jrG - OUjUNPSeRmlBrj7G6Skup/UxOI+SQfj95ZbllmRpuZ3ZtFVv6/Twc3pxASRMQo8BIZiRX7Zom/nH - Wp4e4ON7KP97Il22dW2kdynco5YNfzU25w9N11i0ws+RxbOhEKyfptcertwITupBC/ndHj4hh7Ak - UlEyhXsfph3iCgjSZpg43PWevDn33/0FCerLe/v7CO+HAG/4897hK+z83uFr4kg5cM6XGBRYPZ2R - y9FLDObrtwtZV+OmtoDHfYiSMz73M7ltUM1Lh0VqU22m8/MsvHwp8aqBrQzvoNY+RnbgBbN1jlW9 - 96yCIpwxsA2u9zU+83tIabnkWfwkHuO46UamMQYAMJkPmtDYmWjMPyf7mTWJyQp/i0ZLsIJkoIdH - tEoR0XvAkdq+y1ZNzuCqV+/D+xN2zLtusoTi4l2s5IJLB42cTVMZB8VfgZQTVQZfWgzzlz8WM/0n - wudfjrfowpvFGGsNvOuHoW7urQ/iovi0yKDhroNmOqb/1rVLkzCL0sFWb6e4SNK+9tG5cv/R/mN2 - EszZwaOf957dP3zwPHx08Ojg2ZNnOzLOsOBg4lxiS0xWi8KPJI20OcHTc7b3aGfv4OnersDXnQkw - mR3ZlWxMi2xs/bJ6gtMKxoLM5hhCRMfnsLhcZzi3kqY7FWo10oSO9izBsVuosXzjk6IZY/J6B08W - KZl5iYsdPG0UlzqMX+mg9hzL4GUOU1c5jC5y2Oc9Ji5xGEgxDC9wWHF9w9TlTTLtFEfNF7ujPUNr - aEzVcBCCdsKuOK/xmXWUO5JbXi8oW+54i+haOzOAtvadTIvhMF8QE5KJHKdvgxd/DC8Bp+P44ac3 - xBz7vMUzEKmUc4pe2WC4oqxir0bJRhTBoQa8xdLGBN39lKLc/IbJ0W/17De0rfPZRAFqOIxizkWU - 4OQCsgs1gPBNgoxUuL0fkvN88rPc60FZY0pdcJImQT4Cep8NovQyyPuzOMjYp1Act44RHcNtxov9 - Bi+nhIevsccpKc0ApfGuqA+IxO6f9kdpGuO7Y8TQPoiTp/0oJI1LMBXNMGgnno4eyGbZfycRwCCP - pnNq3Ci1DS0Fc6D52+wfEdqpRcE2O5qhbgAmtCOdn/5WSNP6XPe2vOsPRRyCy9ie9YYTWgCwRTTT - 8TjY6m2boPZQ16VR/X2UPPz7H7cIy/8eYYQAOOL/gX6pWz3z+Xow/HV0GeXICxApCc1BsJkDWo2i - GOhw8sPfvu8//Tlnv6X5BJgXIe9H+BYMwngyQmyznsIkyefxZZDgE6Auqi5OpzLjyNEYdnO/FjH3 - 2yDm/k1DzLdAu+KHJ0e3CDVPguwrO2I08q2e/rRBy7uClsejcJZcPDw5+e02ISZIgkEYsxP2G+MT - APR03l0TkhpsXkfTT+kccLIMWQEdYYNdglQTLsS2D9qg4YEPDdcNi48B2segqJ5v6/ILSUPxOZ5w - wmWh8LgNFB5fDRS4CKjkw1/RQxDkuFk2SFFctPBBlYMTETQwmy4Nk8M2MDm8aQTqJI2yh19ObxF1 - +gI8ZIZLjkPf6hmPmxPL5sRic+A0Ow+Th+9vk2T4Pp1FeQjSIB/8Vs96cT1o/iqb9UP2Phxm6Vwg - Nd3S/Bom4TTqC1xTeH+VNPhJGxR9cuNQNIANnzz89RZh6K8xCPeMD3yrpz9txMJ2YuF1It7rMA6m - 8/7X6OHJq1uEfCdogpCwV0yNn47P1rsNkVw5kVw9uOQ0kkLWEZDK2WmYXUYg9Cw776dt5v20fI+q - yxppvKxucdRNTcf9TZcfekhA7bq15A6Em9V5rZnkRc9RMb9cf28G29PdDmUz4hOae0zJvETdtXS0 - zQZISrb0aJ0ex8GksFKx7F2kLYvdSpWhS6lTLfcvDKcq5b0yzEdXfdmFGUInGnQnsLzRdwq/LICp - I6rtnPCGBuW5gdN9ITrW9VvdkmGiBA4Gn2GaA6SSaNvFT6dYUaMXux3Tasf5royzmv7vm5u2l8y0 - zqXm9PzHwlFVS9nVi2fTut40rneATjXiSGCptstNSJjnF2eXM9aiuMFFvobzrd4epwjsth/83PzU - y0F6vx2kneIupPcFpK9JN71qAB20A5BT3AXQgQTQugTgVYPgcTsQOMVdEDz2gmAl6tBVT/6w3eSd - 4u7kD8Xk164FXTUonrQDhVPcBcUTAYrrFMFXDaWn7aDkFHeh9FRAaSWSd+V0pfeIfNIEKq/cUVhz - VdhB6X/wWpr4ANLUNBpGoSsZ6Z96HaupF+YkDOmxqMhkDIGOU8SImyBawigCz+ULzWqNDxoAiMGn - 5IlfhMKIBupgxA1W2bvXQOKFEAyNUC11EDBs4Tisipm0nZ20jmswtde/vyufWaDX1Q/y0qn77DwO - tNfCFdzw/7YVDVymPosGhQFy8e5llREflYV65D0M41YdmMa1MPmdNLvYrWpKVXVVG4hnZ4brsa3Z - UF3LpajqSeyGoMVCy73W8ZwyTfO6bj+OJucpCAgicp7u3P0OlUgRkQReplPmzus7sRZ+KcWzzzFF - ++vumDR2vPDmgDB8bUpVeOYmK5qrVfnpBQqtn8ecz2tuK2KH2zqcEAMD7pjaR31o2t5vYnwrHUoK - NJBmyLXj2TF794zF6dayv4Wv02gcOp3Mgb1TyJoQP2OWlP3H3Pr4xS6+qYeVNTbv6DpVKiAdWXgo - KFOB0BUukBTpScXDycMphpSzjuO+YFOWOqJEmpCaoPrSlnboN0wwUFHcoOO8lzNJuiuq+ZyqGgyu - Wd6Q1nomp6pP5yTWwKN5oqgdYtQ2uvgicFgyo5mD4SbF5OqY+kY56+sOy9VxFqJJbK6OvhSdJnFQ - FonT5UaIssOeeCmDG72rTKJbIJCX0dTqY3qN0/MIt60VyqvTytHaLV0S0ctX0o3q1enUpKcyDyRm - 8hbPPq1ITV6tGfZSthrtsElwmrv2Xo07ryb63QV/Xnc6t8mht3L0G4/ejUfvxqN349G78egtKmw8 - eu112Hj0rsqj1+vTq/1d92c7qwCN9ZebBaiBVXrU1t/0q7BxxUzNS/6NU+7GKfdGmLhr2+Lu2Lhv - vHLvgPtjCWbebv/HjVvuBi9vIl5u/HJvnQNGCR7+1RxzS8Dw1/bMLQHKxjV345q7Obeonxt3btn4 - 5t4pt7MSHN04526cc2+rbLjxzt14594aMnnT3XNLJr5u/9w634Oy/1XtW+kLWSowutfS9n3Rxhty - NbAudYdsWv4O+UOWcuh2ILrdHpGlupt2QLitPpGlWpp2078bXpGlUkA7YNx5v8hSoaEdnO6gZ6T5 - Jy9Y4QypAWbjDVk3u4035B3zhlylG6TtCKnF/+F+gZTjSyQBM04PwkaZGxii5yKsoGUDHSWw8t1v - WTDZsnPMKrs3+VrZwZHni9/O3rTI/h0Qi/Hi5FGm2mC4YDjnQTQchhnlnsTc4o6fVdNctL51h85K - y4gBIuZ7iwRxrBwbctttS31wfLa4W5Py3MMpwQaLx95ywjhceNvg7tI7Cb9PgILu+pPlCsJwDDO0 - k+V6/fIMTGDGu+rVFBTRWUhsgkkHDXSIDb46sDboCFYwnCd6pv/ADXQ4u4neZq0dzfxQtj3MFnEu - 87tKVLqRLes7tg6HMZkCRm0H03GsuddYM4+xem8x5SvmsYN2fpspHw3qryBAySrNPMWSl4z2y9RI - WiZj/qPYz2jfEXP8YqJ/PF2BKyo5q0e0pihm6BprjrqkF3pRCEETj7O2IfHls/OuqzV7FfS/XmSY - XfO5xngLqU9r8bPl2U+ap/vv//GA9YkA5OzbCGMBpH0gOMjl3PgA999+en30AJAzhO8ykW08Z9A9 - iMnTNB3siK026RVLvHYgnITTUTrIayFA+o2gz8bBBT/NZWGeJhi2gN0/Pvn0gEXwBQMcfAtyTDKP - uwkkah7/IGB7O4efWd4PUPhA+MBg/qRYCsRbEDQAwZSgM0rH6X/mF+ksp9MjkA+yL5faKHiO0Hku - YXvs16MjGMckDEiywPALb//nA7sA2XYHlUtoWT9g4zDIZxlFV4DuQPTQhgftvf8HzCnPcTVPHmzj - Y5gMkEfCmsQwz8s0no1D/PzmNaw3Kv2wzJ/COH+YcTpCBd4+2GEfQBK4DDHkA8jawXch/GB0AKxK - YSS+I4qHcUxYJNov2nlzDN3QOGdTOF7mMEwA6RiOg5hdFkbsR0SUqzBr7Hie9mmtYjaMzrM0j/K6 - oBPQwK9vHtDK6V0GolMBJQB0HIgKsuUdvnQX4oSfkw35dE5NAVDDPFc4gDOnIyI0iKukrV0MOx+w - 4D682ntwLbvgE2XWrd8FQAdgXWhxnh34kPj+kwMWDLCtbXbwCKgD12xss8PH9wCcIO8Cjj1DiAK6 - j9koAEhjQuBZP0S8evOW3f8hnv58eHgPUOmIEdIx4GTpNwJggjwqZhkJHbTTYBviggD6Hzy7tw2N - ARqz4DwFFHQqQKH9fSwE6EDbqJ/B3qCOT3Z5VxniKxb86dk9Nb8d9i4Rs+JTDWS7OOJt7Cjjw6FW - B7CqCR512QRwhHZDP81wN0zFHsYxUkO44mI8LAkvAqcw7+4i3GYg1ECvLI/GEeK8LJGPoonY1nkY - YvcK6DvUPAeTGAjQW9k6TJsaT9R+pU0K9c9T7JNPF4dWLCI+USXYo1hSrjScHRAIsPsAx9K+uIcx - QCFmzckHQHqHwZ6zl3B/7x4WlHDfxiWKZxi1pmZQJibKYaYAMhO7gDxhImnog0MehwQ0lq89p42Y - nRrVTURqYIzXsh+PU5w4kvzaLXmU6ECHvTL9FoaJIoeU6Ry1iBGhayl5dEgYMnFiS8YSqQWNSauN - JboSnaB1GOGsP51l0LoQDGCdoUNOU30UlNrnKb4Rodg4gq0ldOYe+kJLCzWSdKqmLTHZ1z+urp9E - O0zY2NQtV708coFcLH3R7CjG2n2q7OnFpDhoTOYZBmLiYm3xyLs7ls/P2f/9L7nKKU8mxkMMAdEG - MNMyMzz9wyG2D4yJCZ0WYApALQLygqwKhTEinJSyHhcBH46BThKVOE7HY9zZR1NeBTHufdQPkxwo - FBcBQbgYRwDTWQJIgyya2sXvqqMoFdsWECJLYXdSO7j8yRzElQGw523AufQyGoRcZACUAOEK1obf - XfM9TwEVSGTq46aFfnY6Ys1MEELH8BdQt4zDUHsmHWQg7UKKD7tbtgYRZIez4kgbQ3fAK0CuOkNB - EEciNTlQTjvTiva4VQd+EwczgvRZIe4LDexrVYM0chIBnZAmQxDNpt102KX9DYCW2OH5Irz/yk4+ - x6IOLrasAxsJpkoBuTh64xGI/6kH35KFXCW376AEC/J9HCf58+9c84PqUOGm/e2AK0SfPXu2+52D - ihcdj+OSgj/tngTTEf06eS+LT/ZUaX4aJZ9v+LNLsRDwGCPMhkD0uMTISjCVjJAsIPaKB5MQQz8p - UOQgrwLi7oilMHe1sfftbaz/01/qLqYUwCXMucNzvqV0WOoV+xrOv6XZQAWqKoJwlx9lT8LT3/gO - Ns6w8qG4xFCNc0MIcgrXFlh8ro1L4i9uxxqRU/H4kjeK4SGqsyOQ4cO8j3hnNNI05Ig9zALYXV/F - yuAj5ZFDilEKLLFjhzQcRgls1xpFxAPppeOI2BNYcxyRYug8rANuiRVGElld89WxRATUipsoxJKX - P/x7lk5/LsbAn/+Jg/jX6gKKYFdnOOG6eBQ6mlhFl4snQluiMQqUwpImUlKlQcgQrM4XvozyVMKZ - uq8o74C7bKjNoa7DHZHC+rzyICBrjAGydTW43iYeSLshrSE2iFq6W8Cq4cC+ci69t0ouDQNsz6D3 - bgyDRvjePt4Mo14TW15By8twZOj+2pkxocQd58MOWamE7vpYsA/Wd5H7rg2vF2K8daP5S/NcsiZd - Oc/dXx3PpQG257n7N4TncvjeNp5Lo14Lz11Jy4vzXOr+mnmuQIk7zXM9ZKUSuuviuX5Y3z2eu0a8 - XoDn1o/mr81zkYUG+ZTc64KVM9+DFTJfY6TtufDBTeHCJsRvHTsWw39Iw18PX15pF0swaGOlVkrR - /h8AAP//7F1rc9u41f68+RWMdjpJapHi/eI67us4ySodO5vG2bRNp+OhKEpiTIkqScnxdva/v+cA - 4FWULMmkLStxYovE9eDg4DwPABLaAqlLZrPfkF2wgF3A7tXa30MQvwfb3wbN1xfru4b1ty4+slg7 - nKv1wTmVcHMYV3cExpmGHxt8U7Ebge16it4ermn9DwzTiVnsNTxXeZeV+m0Klpdoe//guEnb3gKG - 1xDn+4Zf9oxw7QCs1QjATMbNIVjbFQhOtPzoQJgJ3gwM11T4HYCYSfDQUJyax36DcaWvWanjxuB4 - mcb3EJAbtfFtIHkdgb5vUA7JC73l74K8OyjrNYIyk3FzUNZ3BZQTLT86UGaCNwPKNRV+B1BmEjw0 - KKfmsd+gXOlrVuq4MVBepvE9BOVGbXwbUF5HoMcPytzY/hqEd4Lm9NCNE3Loxp+5DnmjzfccO3f0 - TvJTA2gTkcuH/90Num9rw+agvijkw0L7rb30+EA/adIBbdKf5LeFFjHAPvnbx1rZQMO13oUmlPq4 - UxAscWQg2cOwh9stcM95RclydoJgbNwp+0g9HmDcbMVItpfzB1GphsC+ZwMTiPCQDnaWVkNsxWyY - rSw2ZFvKYu4yZanor33gLVmzDliz7o281F91nQxmsb93kcZUWeUPLrMLXGaNnvkeCM19DaNaWM2G - wv6gNtVQyQ4fa2r5xWqY0CTib0tjrF2mMWnf7AN5SRpzb5SlrgrrJCqJTLtITzJr+0FKdoGULO2P - 74GKNDtQaiEga4n4g3ZUQ9vUjkfkK9ka4h1SjcflrW7AtsxD2pWT9G7pn33gHmlr7o181FZjnewj - FWoX6UfO4n7wj13gH8s75HsgIA2PlVoYyHoy/qAg3C/pd2v8uSm+UePBfzlptyYXu3IKYF7zj41J - ZLI3QhvqK357jpDJ8MCUoGAne43/WUt3APhXqX3/UL5pa98C1NcU6QeGs+/z/ky/W8t3o3t9LkOq - 8YzB9RqyNfLvylmEa/bXYyMFpFkHWbPu77GMe6l5eypR7u/deyhjXYvca/pRtqIdICFb9sv+8ZMH - G0JbEJe7yvqD0VQiZOP7IjWe17hS/q35y66c4ri6d/aAtjS7KdJkhTWSlF3ZErnF2n5QkoenJN/T - fsh9j5M6CMiP3ZC78I7RTeQFjbOPGo+XXKMVW3OQXTmCcp2e2gcmUmzSvfGRequtk5UUJdtFblK2 - wh8MZQcYyi2d8j3wlPsYObWwlQ0Effyc5S5sZTa2GzgdRKrxoE0q4uZsQ9qVczaZjh8dlSBiN3Kc - Vz1F34ESkPof+CivxCz2G9sr/MtK/TaG6NXa3kPQbtC2t4Hm28V5/AB850WDc3tIXnfhPrpRMLEn - jsu9o9s8yDzHLvCYflMvkUo1nr+5Vju2XjjYlTM61+utx4b3SasO0lYdvEsee3jLGtXI4sF9VLw9 - V1je2R0m2wMvIKxpjXtNM5ab0A5Qj+06aP+YyUONpC1Yyx1FffyM5k5cpoFvzpJqPGn0fKsvzpJ2 - 5RjR88f4vVnnTX1rVh0F34UcPPg3Zp3v//dlLXqUlbptDse/i+/Kas6mtwLiH9+TtQJqAUAgwcnQ - 7dePuDWelpmTcwvg3ZXDMPPafnT4S2Q/QNmbgeH6yr8DGmcd9NCgnDeV/cbmrON3AaJX6H0Pkbpp - e98GsNeU6bvG7QuA3yuX+xz4s3EDc+Uaj4UsSLoFdu/KCZBFjT829KbSH1DpG8HvWmvYHsEL3fTA - GF4ymb1G8UL37wCOr9b9/iH5Pdj9Fli+vlTfNZr/K5hNhtDUmR/XjuVyjSct5uTcHMnlXTlQMa/t - x4bjRPYDInsjKF5j+dtjeK6DHhjBC6ay1/id6/gdQO9Vet8/7G7c3rdA7nVlagq3MY5hDAbC5ZMn - +If8h9AEcKJZL4pxez1qpYMsDUpcfgRaJ6pIxTwaySWvn8p4kWZP0nZG8vGT5GbB9aPPj+LWI6Ea - y44325ZpZMrmayQamZRr8owlYuzG0YqPjmWUjz6cjBs8V3HbwjfkFyxg2cGKk3GN/ja1xtt8bd5G - 9ppelPu9AY6RKn3jsxW/A4rRrL3XcbBilUDf9aLAKWKuHcVggf3yKeQ1oHWNByIXJd0csXflMOSS - xh8baifiHxDxG0DuOiu4E3oXO+pBEbxsM/uO4gs2sANIfksf7B+aN2//WyD62kJ916j+NrTxyyEm - teN5jScgJzJujuS7crhxquXHhuGJ4A2gdz1F3wm3ExEeFLEz29h3rM71+A6g9FK97x8+N2nnW30z - 0a3i3PcyfvqbLOqz4KPOGBCArbY/yZb6WacHczf07ZsW6xbgGX4wbBVA4dSLbdQU95pGYp35Imge - zmHJ+H6WDBIWOYHjB5HLp5VmKC21jv/97T8pNC7IyZAGZHHThhdTpPXH7rc4oSRPVqRpHaclVaZh - AFVsCOuxFN+mNzxrIW02PwicWXosQIVN2nP3MhrZoVtOk5gj1L8Qx3oCq0uiMtXJrWzZYFo6ApB1 - OCD5mL3V+rI1DaJsD/DIm0xnMRffTKH3KTVocRN7DHdOFA7G5NHRaxA3Dq4wam77M4jrfjXfDD3l - 999P3Tfmr/r4/NPHz/9UVeXT60nkfP674/zrSu1H+umr1x8982Qaf/36z/G7q/nH/tvpm7Ou383q - Z9qjAoAHHHsL26VM2cC9AEr5as+xjqbLaas0Xk7DNI9O0A/sheepiVkCb2LRnM0NPGCryJzAwtxw - YvvpwODG9sQeukCtYi4KBvF1hWhZryo5z3EUAetMhxuri2dDIq1bmPS83lEH066VlR8HPQ9LqMhY - GogdNKDUhzypHC5RfANlRq7vOnEQ8tehPZ0C8STDi2gxQ3iWhIS2jt9C2XZ8CO4N70l6mqTghWiq - 1i3V5l2KyjSYNCmYkl6gEENyzUKfp7Zujxe+lZBZ+sn5STkm0y5EpgqjxW9Q5XRplR9WVflh+yrH - /rIqz89WVAmRW1cJVGpJle/PzssxtBdxdpVc5QYBpF8mBdguSX/8hHn0Jyk8rgjYGAjPYUbHsbnO - AhjiPG4MCbJpGSuhiJJVSdggi2BKOhmWAO/CnfS5TwG0kMSypNlsqlAem0oxNWU+gNI8lNDxvWkv - sGH6xWbhrSIfy+34gyPmU/Au5VoM4WM7HLpxAQU5lIcH5zrmWhkfOk2ypnynKG+RlLrAXvy02rTA - sthp6W8wfbnk0gwDgGGDEi8g+RJRyyXfUlgyz7AdJ5hN4sW5xl97tnN1CYPnJUn6J+XkT/JbPLeV - zAUX0kOMYpqSaokSSacEUxeoutfzvWAI7nd0w4NLRxd7fsO9ygWXm7OT7XAC33eZYbNmnGZBaxlP - ChIUecMNej0lvec0a7G+HAtfxW/LlHaZT2J0PfNJOFRRSzCOgpiBaNlh+SA/TENmMP5ZKtYWJxhP - fUIz7BA5NqUoZ+gbcObx/vTVO+4szUyO05iF+LhPmQnPIqBAoZc44aPp0qoZn15a9FFnum4ZSUvt - 5QnJtLKC8WUpL8O0UdVPztEi1pz+d2AAwSwaTaBx6aZjZ33hIDHI9uH89F5E6wXBVTRy/cH6ApIs - reNXSc57kbPvRVCyN3bDgqCdLByU9jq9SWVa20g5OwZHAsOa8k8Qb0wWOT+NXLbQxeES3dgOrzgb - 4JuFAS4GwCdcLnSHXgSFQVgc2n0XE0ZcMOBiKOA34ULgXrtTO4zJTAGCu67txyNSFDm6j7tww7mH - T+M973YvXgjcbxN7BnO70PsdipxFLisLLmjRXsRFeAxv7N9w0zAYeT1oV19gDS56pQQQnvI89zL9 - 4V69+eXde+7tr79+evMxH87zkOWIKiftWvZsYKJFz0E9lZ4XzHm6fDw/ckEjYasq7yWLgxmD7wfX - xJMVpS64L3Rd2Qo4l62F55dk8hkKdVUnz9stswjM1SLtoAGX8bUXE3dcHCAsWAD33MGBUuSWn1im - xaW8o2g+5K69fjyCKY0IpbrecBTT67nnXr8KcJODEzlV5BSjhRNQKG8STNwW923sTyIqAhui14oQ - hMOOLIpiBwquqI/USUDjmAl11KG31UmHpO2sdd8kUTSXFEqHlg2WjBnwgiRemhZ/IOG5Loi6oeic - cSbpgmkYJieLgmlZ0hnEwI/EKbIgdyVRkM8kU9A5WRGkM1kTdN2kUYp6JsuCyUmGoJ0pkmBxRlc2 - BQgVBYOTNLiSVEGFkowu1mZaZpfV+uXcgnIMTeFMwVBUWelKsmApsnEmWxAgG5wiCqqumV1ZFzTd - Ms5K6b+sbiDtrZ+1V7qkv2p1lui4M6ywC+y/km1m7pUF3GqsA9tx0UtXufMkLjVZ9O1Fs32bZD9G - M12QkbhmOhE8s29gEErr2GTRrBWR/FaNDGqWiQxLzZQaXcrQooXvLmfCgq3JYEVaWwKTkMCiDEkw - 1M+WIZiyI/KmIKltTVAsXhLbliDh50g2IPSzJvu8YgmKzEM+h1fQ9toir8qCKrfBMHSTXauKYBhz - yRJUs2tZgmjNFR2yYTGyOpdEa6SCNUpzHi8V7UtVq8n3vpTDqTVsYQAIkW6/vH1atTWSpCTmgCTT - ntwQs6iY4+dt5IzkezehNnI/NpHUWYdNSKIk6Gpbhr5TjK5mCIYF/SOpIwgwtS9jXpZ5CbyKpo54 - QdYduBFkDbpflsBwoCcFRWfX8NdAw5CgRK1tCqaKQZLWBvekKPT6Ausz2gb4D7ktiXLbggLMU7wi - MUbbUgQVbBRKVNoGuBuF3XwZg0MF59TWZEGXTtDbQTryVyT/JExqynNdAivuSmCGkhkJmgQyaoKs - EMHULqSaS4qtqSBSm/4lmduKCkXx4P903ZGhGW0VIi0oUTDZpQbFWHPNFBStK1kwYD5DdVWCmDDM - dJAHvK56D0Y+9OLRrFf2cTR0CSD/4sVdyPIgfq3vDqIqJDgiq2vVGCFQI26viJS5/y3BIkShQ+5n - Q8F/f6lM9MeTVdWuLJkPZ757yLlzdxL0+8uKXwzDRa/K9gLpq9QQG/y062oZ+hqMFL2tgnc2bRwk - MHrZBzFkXoGhqLRlURckB2zfhFECaWGgCwq90MDHoysQNMAGESEDfAagBIwjGLkWDywCYEEXVAIa - Co4u1Sxcq4Ip4SV6GcQjHvmKUbi2BM3ikX4A5YBPBBn6CcKCJxAMgDRdkCW8tfKXFkkDwhvg3iAT - OBJBtdpAacDNgAOCxFAOuBkFZYVIDUQ1QBwVWgAuyRQ0oy0BQEptE5whNB9+2RUoTZNsFaoB2CN/ - qRfBinlgX4oFnlKQeHQn0EgDnSjqAkJMkhTcigmxJrheRErMaKo2ujgZe4F80CI18FCn4G/aJhRL - egOaJiFc564d2nsqOh6ZxAGWQ3Vt6FqQzzTa9G8qpWm1qZgixujQqSCl2lZB2yCwCZ4OHa1kgnJA - UQr2voGaBF4o0SvoYg3bgurCTpexTnCh5ArMAuQwQQKQELqAWI4OBEM0TipMrZ23xfVdZpW5Vz27 - QMzdJLxFAmKCLAYQAa1WAiKMBAYQBgSQIb9AA3nB0uBCg54hdzpeAMghYEjExKApggWeX9ABJSEz - LzUjtwWaFMHqwKLA5sjoADMGEAbzkUAy1bJBBhQI/hBdgpBoeZLlkIGpQl9hNsRtCDUgR0S7xsCR - jAmxBdjsqtlNHU1QiVFIIjRBh0GtQ11gRug5FJDLkiIIB7YAKmXuBIUjJgQM0rSQT0CkSUI09csY - mokb3HcXzMLxL4OjMQ1Ur4liYD+jvmQctsBX0SgkHKzEDjAYTUGBKBxrBqA8Kl9GCQ0cEhDGJGxC - lxJUArqTYfjJaBJAwJGHCaqGQqDDAZ+qRTyGKdgYAxUrERvAWxl7XIcBa4JO2xLxEugcMU2TYoMj - hgGOYlsw32iDwnlUG/h28P5kGIGi4dLicTzKOJ4IsaKDECLQaMDC4Qp6ySCfmF9tUmhwijjHARKo - aY6AZgKKQyRB0yDODTVNjFihMIjOGAGK4BKmwVj0phCL+SR9pfVuTQJ7ZDuuSAGR93mTCFdUosXl - yyIjfJXt1eWqxSkNVkJ44KXUqoUbqvgfH7VEmsNYH2Va/yNULWFqfyQUiTGixY5r0V5SAdNtwC6K - bbzK47XKsA6uYOoA/P5EAhduMbwxBBHGi2ZDekZ24GquZPdtnGrANAMsMClJFtvAiMBFZYlknDeM - 8tnAXr+MoZYTsE4G9VBbW89l0ttGoSa4OsFRmcxEwFiUUvwIpE/vFWiv8qXVOb59kaS8gJi/xX1l - h+40L1naTFcJ+YE/8/pcb8hPQ2+MGy/Vi5LZeuQ05rWlS5FhcM2NY14pLz4WSvJ5f8grHF5I8qJl - TnM7YeSZqOsRPuhStW6fs/kocDzbH+MT5x3yIIUwisdk720ywWcyrmHShHvxdENsulBrtjWNL3Hz - 3sSH1nK01MvxktcJjnyvIhfdocNWLF9JBUku37/rVi+mVs406Eb1yxb4Axt3B0KXLJfiniP0Cj61 - PXDDsHIpllpAthyraNlyLF4X53cmh2F1LMeSetdfkiXJF5ZlrRbZtefRRbxszUL/+c94L17qmmzo - l4ql6i9W1E8KTVdvP7OnbYhzAUgXRZ1TVABNXTsFuLUMXUru6aehcSRck9J7QrMs/TS5NwVRViWd - S/KLAM6yYShcUkEScIopNUnNUuCFkisiuU+qSO4TEZICEhFLTfiSdNvPsqipltLC7ZPgCjw6G0L0 - lmdmAIwhDRrjjpHvwQeEr2Bg1Wpli+IWVSxAqmpKKK2GS9+ybpkc4Cw02TozUWBRwhZpXZyYnWEb - OFnElW7IptMYGfPKIsRI+plsYFFdQGxIbXES+VSxIBqB9Vmy0WX1fgFGAtMSy+Bwpds0lC5O0DTJ - wrV1/OTgU9YlpYsL7pasn5XSp2qkWrtVF5XL3GnkskWRXBK05w+JLsvGfYttkwJC6uHo4DZzg9tc - aEpInjdaWVonkWdVk5c3awnRoVH5hzfS0I286OIKP3ngwfZ9rxcCgAUD9NYOlFDtRyu3AZZ707Lf - XeFd524YkZ1cMKe1uBNJcvgNF6irEsKE1up8o3vB6Jyn35btydzQ2KIjl1ULf3GI3+CTFO7E7vku - j8+4DMNgNukfTtxrLpfyL0Siw2gKWoExHbqRG86rjsxL2ozlsidgEag7TlT13TPJjxDFkrh0wQ1/ - 2HLeW/JTvd6GP0uW9JI61qoEgW15DRxzi2sIwxWc6iFnrpE0c7aHnCSuamh1+NIFRhZNMfbinL91 - i4llWOW/VsSVZlzYvwxaYV6HqzEjXlY/m+D6HZHX2oqAq3tyWxMM/BzhtuhnXfRxgUrlRUFyeAAB - sniAySBao1e4WTWXIKpriXPECcxq3eoWq3/muoHQo2hzHq9GuLdxlgj8+528/aooxwsdGC2ZqlBX - Dr5BACikw+UNvQRIDhGCTbgCWWi2VY62cgG6/JxcGrOxq70JZvGs5xJPOwOHgMx1gbj+iya6K3Hd - yosuUfjmvnW1F11STVO+NR3CTLW3jeDNfbG6P15yVTO1ehCnOvw2R1we9Goy5FUc58mQV9cf8mSC - FIf2JMI3G6Cr8dK3Y/e52OYtDRdVZclcNR8qeWxt1WMehMybuGkrKjAjcXAXSMUFFVPAbRaFXuCf - uYruW2yTBLiZkcaQPyMDnLdDc5MAPklDitjIk895WhcRhk+kyP50UeLfuXN8GAK3njVTMH3crsKd - XNXn08vPNO5Wl7/Uq2dEt8rZZs/aZiGFJRsStNHCSO6NR3Ag0SVdIORyiyTH7xkZ5s4oG8ZH6s4Z - Hz7qhRWIUOX0h0Ew9KnPH9vTqDP1wW11TF0UDz4GztUcRo178MG7ctsHr1x8Yq9vtw/OXx/Iommp - nf9TTMGyNEsTzTZvAHaLkojbKsbvHVxkfPlUGUtP1R78jjW4Vp9KkfjNtHqGY2murBm61u/3DsVv - kiVp+sA0ezAVUrSe+dQcy0+Vflb6U7WP5YuWaSqyUmXJFctI68MRtpdL28theytVyHGpErjz1xxR - QuUy02YGwDnuhDxtCYFLVslWL4ldu73LaeBD37sRXQ2r0MfxP9we94GlIlKvbSVJPd4kAnCaxW7E - Q1AHfvlgMPAcl+97IVlw6bB7MKjxbOI5Nns8ftaDennfs70omHQGoev2gzGQkgF5aYq9zMgKW697 - j9/++u5ks2aMRhFpxnzmgwXYPc/34huePHUbRPgILdHhTX5VscqucO4+709bx93uBfc5Xxb3Oi3r - fswifRlmim8e4jNF3PKFVJaquIFw3HX96YbWkMtvOw74J482f7npneSTbV+bY4PhhFHyuby+U5pg - vU5YDCiuc9++xH1bX03sNEcviGOw/OKLULmkuRenFlfXWZoqvs/0t3Q1fVGZACF0kbxyXlFdx2ZV - V6Rc7ltAnHfdRsVZ4RHIWK6v8vXwaVGcWWQzcX67OMGrjURa5CEYBra3mf0v22Cit+mD9OXn79+8 - f73s6Xua9qs9tyMn9KYxvuTjTb7iUub7f7y+wPe+bUDrYSRw76H0Q/oCJhKayXU/umTzRHxJYDbF - U0v6XO+Ga02m42QKCT4A8AZfPyD1YY1JTdk8Kaufjaq5HRYreMnhSrmgtP7yJE2Asl0mqSBFP3Bm - +NqD4IQuiPKGvsf0/Bmme/aCTiwKeQTcaYWMz3DzNg19VpWSHUYDifNi0ZRpvUBpWKXRq5tP9vA9 - FP/8Gb548OzFv8X/CPhS86R/OvL8/vNC8S+qWrVpixZbU25JrhXPbtwk+m7io+g/ody274Zx9Fvo - Y191HKBwHRrEPoSvEXTeT96Ae449jxYEcr6yIxfzPAWDfAZTdncAHBnqgwnjTz/li8wnPsgqgxJx - XghjgZhP8m5u4dW45EiL5LxqavJ/n7nAzMmO5NSfDYE/EQt9khxpzawUDyZJHYHTn1S8SEVeTOzY - ujQwRM3hlZ7j8Kql6rzZ1yzeHqiK0+v3Fb3vdE5PTrtvOl+jTjCLp7NYkC1l0BsYum3DrOkrnmSU - NiQ7loPI+yEMyKjsgQ44miZiQ/ge5dVVw1VlqaeJfbVS3qPsliN9JtjXbhSMXQEF/2APXcGbePHz - ZD0AV7PeAdU8zK0QeNFZMBziE9iHHDkpK3suFZOjmR9yrVYW6gfQfWAMENrs66XFOkEnxUorX2Nj - knQiPNVrFlcI0OksqbyTVN1J8PqPRIAeHQqH3LNVlT9Lkk+CCyR5weQ0CK489z1V4XTMT6K0TfQM - m3f9cpLI66dp7P7X9/b8YklKiAVIK2SgheL5CxfkrXBAiIXyB5kMXvTrhJaOplJO6QXRtJVpwLn6 - FNDE5YS9OPLThA4ebOvY/oXrnvh+OakT2WnKrxGNfR3gsTcYX90vaQY0xws8JeSj+9+ZG8Vvbc93 - +3njBMVjfP/CjWNvMowgbnxDHXRADxjpX0YsbiHTCTWdqjzMqqhd/EGgoOADiyA7Dvqz9FR9b4xT - DQ7mVmMvinDJFN+FO0GPyg3CYMzV5z4ICuQq4sl7ycR5UzggAlFXjPBzQYR+vnpAVUNLmxvMJvTx - mucvUmcyJAme//tZL+jfcMfcnw+B68W8gxj27D8vksXGKl08Z7F/vBAG0K3Pk+LT0iu0nlN8H1cw - lnCcNZw0aSQ9DpB9EHebry6Ha/fj/DXXUJ2eqin9Qdn5J7KsAgA7jD3Hr8AA9GUXM/D4EVmRoD4V - psRpSCcdGWM7Hv3N/lZ0u3duKJb61f7WmU2m4FQg1zmtBhr5V6BMA2/48vz87PK0++n8LO9W6FEU - Jx/efQTmjTLbWEoa0VlM+x4sARXA2pidhDHByccUYjob+eMN3evaPnNjT+gHk+EnNxx/gImT9w0y - YMB/cVyXsOO3j2f4VAO2PkU3iOEBODrbw0zOtphqM+jMbCe8+ttF7aYTXoGZoJODIU4aLLCwtGI8 - i67rDUc+Pg9yGvhBmEeIURLj9j/hMVlRPhJPl6KHF30gS6LuxFlARWewBAWOOuj18OVsXIw5/n8A - AAD//wMAdl2sfTNwAgA= - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:42 GMT - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - pm-csrf=FPmA7kddcbNOaWthHAgBVqBYuccmJWFF; expires=Thu, 29 May 2025 23:51:42 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31449600; Path=/; SameSite=Lax; Secure - - pm-sessionid=o8fn6rge7eqbyamp05v38g0a9ows6089; expires=Fri, 31 May 2024 07:51:42 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=28800; Path=/; Secure - - ncbi_sid=065BB74121959273_D8A2SID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Fri, 30 May 2025 - 23:51:42 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Vary: - - origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esearch.fcgi?db=pubmed&term=%28PLoS%2BONE%5BJournal%5D%2Bjournal%2Barticle%5Bpt%5D%2Bfmri%29&retmax=10000 - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAALKxr8jNUShLLSrOzM+zVTLUM1BSSM1Lzk/JzEu3VQoNcdO1UFKwt+MCAAAA//+y - UXTxdw6JDHBVSA1OTSxKzghKLS7NKVEICHXy8XRWUNLV1/fz8dXXdwlxUUgtBqtQMDIwMDMwM7LQ - 13f1U1JQyigpKSi20tdPLS3JzCnWy0tOytTLy8nVy8vM0EvPL4OK66eUpOjDdUKN0gMKKtlxAQAA - AP//ZNK9SgRBDADgWl/m8jP5GRi2sRLORp/gQAsbBV3hHt94d4VJ2CbzMZuEZFaqHeeHz5+PfVPz - uQ7XeD2/7U+n881uhz982U9f+wYXu8b36/H1+P4dwV1EG7vjmEbrEIf/BJgJ5iRIZPENasSFTFmg - EXonq0RWc6HzrGTMmdTRvRGVW+LOUMm0U60orCKNhmYarLUJnkpUSSwP2sjbcIhhjEI0tVTE2FFJ - j9FEmSrEsksuwHh1iXSqAFeKZjPFtjE3oTrJS64R+aVSPKdMLKZWSazdGu1HiDfXiEtFUoxB/wIA - AP//bJZBdgAhCEOvJAgi979YM+2Kb7f/qTOQBCWKftC+RAvOOWsfNDplfJz1izZQrDag3agxz20E - JuUueCLzrgqgz+ZECQNkWtt+0MJPRBlMnnvdPdVO8877oP2gyxrtc/lA0SpzdjXuY6ZQ/tFVIeXo - QYnj6/vCixJoXfjrF82y4xwOBaHT60E3HgQXhhzAVenLcLwUQqNjl/WUNrwO8hiuRRN9IYUc++yq - elAA7bVqPQi+/5Bjo3ejqx/iRs0ETAC5a8Emnn64KiwQUSHHeHSNQhjAtxuuOVcLX5TcaGnwqvUn - 5UQnL0QzqR2zhSaAbJuVwv2iDbSdSGpAWvXUkccPocZ1IjBNPoQal7SFjh+yBPLGzJGdb28gWzNW - 9T0w5hdLWb9zMlXvwCVdrfvl5IOmHHUl/9TxD9lEFXr9ABmuAA2OgHN0B9mZw6pkw+xNFP+gwhet - ew6YKmVjTrnS7ztqrNTdl0Q+Z46QaXq8iBsVq1mQXlqUo7wtsWpdx0+oMw1pTzmeGHVSc3V24ngo - bRMpeoGNayf6lc1X7Yd+AAAA//9sl0sWAyEIBK8EKKj3v1jaZEWZbT2HUb7NyQKyQBamLl89TbJU - ybB15YQTYQSs1OCm+Yu6cyRpfPuDFk8ZVMdK6ePEh9og+Ech2NIkPF25q9dv2wYkMYQP02avbWmc - ZUiTqQ6AOE5JgAnkmtMFJOHWLzGOMRwXZbelgseuIAEYwx8UiJCQIxxjSB91rw6XEDkPgleHp2VP - zLhCwR8EfwnFxodSgTAfEmCxgeL0Wau9YGNXWHEHcrely3tXHcvrPuBB6HJCrG2vwZYm6Vj1oglb - s6zPxy/Cg76oHuQ85YEmegdrAYXWmh5HNy1q3ZZmXM5+LxUQfa+sNLhQr0k4Rwiy84f+nBpAY8zf - qQ8AAAD//2SZQRZEEQwErySIz/0vNh2r6bKthzFIp5P/h/hWVYls6KpSFQO5UPrfbq1txFCh+Y7y - RLHOWc2dlQrD2CscZfk0orm+B3nuWGe09WGiaoAkktMZQO0MjhLCqBjD38RFLqLyiZ/KXUdbZV9z - pI36K6y7+LhWNTEetPwxrapYXDqUMaUTQQQZWmVFcarK0HNiq63PNoHaOONB87zIb0jWKrC8HFLH - WoU8UQjRkq1qDfmLXsq/zUO0RKh7frxoYaI8P39RtvPDxFZZGkjFqK+1dGleW13kYSVT0Gf3tZTb - B6JDCMp0kWcYqeUOzwprKYzxmC7CJtqH2uqiPV/E5aucMyQVCs9DhZpr4UWtAynn+BHmp/ibQOXm - Hc2+Jn6x5wxMrEAOoo2zV0kWH/YlwQ8giRwnCnma0wUpYnzU1NEj0gqF/6GpSECITumc90TXlL+D - PArt7xkFz6SSLL7vPAjCV4j7kmB612dNGUUEzFBRjrAqhJMY0m2ElVDgagsFJkrkIHwlC9yEVI6b - EIIM9a3MtB8EES2E2xbqH0bpvhEdyjgLOa0Q3upFmDhb5ygpx8Io1UwHy6v2Pf1BnqRXnJmIbV0/ - WilCdHwXIRlGubL5INzQRetF/UF4cqHcyk30A78qpIeDX4yuUs1R2/D3QiqJA2gkUH218CLjIghy - IUSaNIHPt2TCu2RC43iXX0orYfWtytIEQrQp+vAAVOccCLJiNt1/pZR9uyCn6tzjfbk80hwvAy/i - WtpsB8rA+7oosHy1YNKRHmFgrR6ItIv8hlKF7vDgu6jhP8ZAU/yijrWUHb3ZlVslvz+Ai7yfk+Xl - XL+EOqyP3H31XF40XvROdOuT1U5vmKiy4GD5+vCDUXI+3GqjoUzZFxjdrI9n7ifqi0u6Yl7kfd8s - lxZYXq/CH3mh6ZnvosRE/UcPhULjw8RqImFfElE8XxV9bWFiO7G+B7lzF5pQciGFmm9Vdc30Fs9F - WEt+eMSD+iZSytwv8hhaVfNhlCzNag9CdEjAmou7UDaEqEQH3c7MXXsFmtB7Ve4tcF6ZjUeozaON - ldk7vovK5VTTypEckru0QtuLDCGpnC8/JQBQk9kfNSnkei8UEdhEDDRvsvpMGFXIq5Osz2drPIhr - 7Wh4JgVxEtXQd9MslRg/AAAA//9kmkGSxSAIRK+Eiom5/8Wmm7+Y4lnZvYomMQKNgMPnQtiYEp27 - V36MEisxv6CPnlV47egdKDZKkn+jJxl7LnkYDPQW6984h8N5R9ZHQbR6urWH/mw/ByjUkwxrzonp - h5Lynj4YBYxv2BtiYPo7O5qBfEiSdqFIVQjrVagPDDv8TTQxV5yB0/RCcMhSIRseQChh25XpfhfC - 3w792340IBSIVvnJa/ccRorZ+pQIKXhKFJye4Rfqv0PJ0IcDvUI9BKTPYPsH6ZO/3X2OUL59AwgF - aidyhAeeSSiQGaZThS50jZ4uAtOl/+6GCvUT8DwSi7xLzvY8F3owvewjiFjVlSiUHZ8Lrfuuibni - hSZPhbSNz/bhTTe+tFLAExXSsAuVwR4IynTTCxa6Uph9oZd3bRzfGkF1FEqgKRWAV5U/5l1GeaHu - thWrPviJfFzCnxeCwSi6D+ycJ93acaEeWAthM1VxHmjyuDuVEEXv2ZIcm4nfsSU6e+xIh/eNu/JF - mTq1DKN7udyueb8XeuNCD+YKVsrSahjmXmgAzeg1nUJdWRXCE43wh9J1pHUhbJNCeOLz4Wy7EKd/ - eMCeeouDVTUKoPVyCTU3GmgKceA8ExsgbaF5ocCrSh/BHo3yvdDCE5X+cgnDj7gQHIybDmHublXp - mrzQutHAXK/sJYHYJSZPeHBS80OY63a1RoiP8hQv7FEXNNOvLLovNM+FBgfKcHGXXBWsdrmNr7+E - JDO66n5oXgjbRO8Qg3MxYxXSUCD3F2GgVBrikOtwnMt1pQshIc65nV13lJp9E6GsX2gCacl6/ig0 - v425lGViR2tHoHVBaDAEGOE/Du/WIHqhAWRTaLU14qoabTxR6ePCE7UOXXbKaLXL54W6HC7Ebxwb - VZFCh3MNdN+m9iW6PwohpinUouPsh/p7hfYq1JDQg6hgOQx7jFxoCjV64BTCTXr9VUPWvjG9pANC - gBHWPnweeaP+a5db454b9ScW6ja0PlctMPCsr3+ju0tXN1Gh+Poxw/IhWWLgHui909za+M+Fephb - 9hyxiOK5UcaFui5Uur3RVSc05ooL9T1hc9ndrIRmHN41USsv1I8ZCnU/4UZ3SEV5PcUvoP2iQ89o - fONCC9MrMfy3jj8AAAD//2SbSZLEIAwEvySx+/8fmyr6MEHqmoExtkEqLf5HuLCzNVkoIXS74pX1 - mseLOi5MOZ1F1L5Z0Gt9LZgW9qrRa3NuTximF0p8R6PMgvAKFc2fLwpqmF6OIjCXT9EoCBvALUF8 - xs5A/Yc4/WxchIIHTi+Ek7a1ybkuoVevylPFelVtX+4bahVlQZOooWdLKL+BUZL8r+y8iHMJYWO6 - qv+mBowOl9p1HDFKHv/DqNwou7qecmDlXGL5yihkMX6oFxS4YzDn7rpFwEYbvUrholeA95s3A9ps - 0nYmG60efa51cGrnSuS2b2YW1mS6mfQUBPM4FVyPglAxuAhfW8IaattpRVQphVwFfZG7lTcRFPJF - uxXEN1FSFkJM37opjY5CMTgClosCo8ZHL2oE16RADd7d4gu/Clj8Lt4xFu29EfbERVhEyDO9jy0v - Pd4Q3NYdStQIjQTd/cp490ZQCkadqKOj8SI4ViMYKzerTc4VqOraBKB2chHXNRNdwRcFHmi4hfVF - /VB1dO0SLuI2BAAVp2OEjdlzIrg2Qo7vIhxkB1uY3sl6eL7m9u4GFJRkRqMibDmhhePuVhzs6Itm - QXAURjiPzWXjJEKKR8httC+SfIB4UFDWoYaM4GsvwoW5ThaEBhqh3PBWFzWiBTXkv3QwKr+F7HBP - GQDoCSPYVTdBwOkYdc4lnVNHwenIYx54q7Tge1efs1GIGHHU2DTuOdjueRGOVd7G4ILgO1I7AKdD - Un7gc6QC7hgVBREa5IUaz2O6i+NF8TGn8EPv9O6zW0QzcNJCcghGISb/iLsIZjtcLMO69F5xHi9q - BbVTURSEd+/YGh/thttYV2xGmU4qQ2wZYTMZdc7V0EXdvi8RKzRF8yg1GOFXAac1UDRWsLJQRrzo - 4I72+IMIb1VILxqLcLKgA+Xg9DJzDdO7pSYLei15O87Cv894TqKDygju5KI319HO9t8VFWEua36M - mi70EO0Pd5yytK2gV95JhcyPiwjXCAt63a9bb+Ot6fxQFPQ6MKFAf85FeCAhZH0U7zHmc7Pv5h2F - OkbtxQcyWq2ggbkWZbokmjVyQdH+AAAA//9snEmWxSAIRbcE+DVx/xsrHhlxqek9aowNjYIdpR+A - VSiEFV3IBzIiw8lpoe4YKBpzPT4Qm0/flyORGpP90s0yUSrpRcQll+oYsRihyNFu1Ci1BjamTjpw - +KwoAuSdfGiWwnSc3EVdI3+o/1DOBdxTebXQMLHTU+iOeqFRig8xCCFitlC3hj7U+5UDHywl1P9x - nwtLQQhpU7EVybcmQlf3fthWohilDjaMAr7/QdsG6icPkbLE8cW6DfwN1BXrh85AXYvq6pRTWygm - mhUdX3wuAu0KYW8LQYimMw/nupDhi+fiqrQQdofQD23pOhhoPbhRT7SQ7RqKoPoHPXcgbJifxOod - 6LwDcbaNscOxbhoPBhQIoSuEsV/KmdhEuA6OypPsndDxJyZNKQWQX0IQohXIhYq/i2dKPhRAL1LW - PnQGwoYRggJbNbcDsZQinIDS4MN0CBna8lzQFyg3MkpZ4OQh4r54FqEQhjARQrkjlIv0AgXOrJTS - f7C+Ul1xiwrZInreUQqPJ3wIFVO0Q+lE2qHsRKJ+EJQLdcELKIRFrgO3xYpGGa0dw66mWwY7J5y5 - bokUazkQjAchzHZ4ekhoS57uGgiOgRAUfvp3exEx+eVDa6D4B/Ufcjnlz0AYCVc2KivKIepopzcX - A2ExFTIiHICGsoohrFzBcCgl7xel7ASmw9VTVDRmEBaCvDedgPfNpznDdAhBNWkasb6EsJFTQ+Pm - pxDGS3fGbkQBOZGq3fDbttfDtvai/SUEt6bQLIVlUmg2D78jEWKj5DP/4MMIwTFIqUobQIIWqkkI - stDSzbh7IEhf88BJTS7KH+1ooa4fPQ0MBL0U6lLuQ7Nib94VOspSDyOCCtlLhMOIQrOi9alN5Ijk - /dDpSCmw+Medw4VSihsAStXn+KFgUk6ihS1aKFBRSX8oJT2B3ufm9ncilMpx6AZ4ob75/L2O8Fih - 3UVHmgQOF6lQN5pdT7RtNC9/OIighwo96MThIxiFMPavciQeIK1zIMf7TC6Vs9EJGWBnIpYyY+8X - H64o1FV5oR9Q7Nu21R8AAAD//2ycSRaEMAgFrwQZ9f4Xaz6uKHpbL2pMGDIAQoqjryhswrGGIJhC - nFrbVt2J4hY2Bvq2YOgP1SG8iu7Fu/aBm/MsJMNWIb/WEGRCMTwN6YK2IejQVV1AfHHagWW6sUuu - NlroXnwxlAqSowy/alf9yBTWL57nRTJHaKw7jOhREbo69io2g+k4sZt/OoJMCFXfkQjW5KyFmoOJ - 6p1hooneK/QRnQh3j3k8klaMhDL12IpJEx/qD1prhQptoQbx+t2Q91b8ohAfNJxsJbLWCgn8iVon - bPC3A8Ga6NSnLk51XPzWgKNEm618QJiEZkeDXwyPj1b3IgAw0KKvzfqFs6EH6PDI9UOLiJZcR0Nn - Ezm0Qwjmce+JkmCJIABh2alWe20cIX7o6QhfjGUhlE9ozY5GQ3z9ZOi7q3oKFFmm/ayG6nHkh6wh - GNEd1gu2cL0PgkKFbj32c/k9eAWVWoThE4Lcr/M+/GKMVl2JBjKK7wqXU5fpiTCPQhjoNZklKYS9 - lfaruFBNBMlZ7VA8kaP3Y2P/GD5OV1IN+WzInAilT3V9hx1Y+MtQ0dqJ+cb/EE1Ek8qqTizvelVI - V7nCumFRSv+BAKiMDyyANkgQXyULQDsyWaC14tpEQa2wE7r8W97QIJq4kkwEhdGK9UEnQoBhHhPN - hqBWuix/vSH47YzSx7vs4KxDdVWRcJcIs61bZMhEIBxtqtTqhcIkwoPaGL4NwWUKQa3GUVppRcq5 - xA8t3pTJL3HPF/6SS1ihekgihLC3RA96HwsWyITiOrB4CKXasJgK2YOxEoIix6YPFWiELkQuK3HM - hnor1HJNBLWK/0Etngzlx45Cx0WwTELGBw0J/EKorfyh0xAflAFDq8Giua56HaMjyL0rv3o0BIcv - hL2VqajDAgpxtYbqWUci7PlU5xi7ObuO+gAfug2N3sobQhnVD+Fd57auKpL3D0JXFXp1O8LgbKO9 - V3kATG0gpO8mgsUUWni9FtujIdgcZYZBTBJZQ9DtWFgPjv0Yzgf9Iskk0MT1QCKYRxVMxGI+0SDC - kWtM64MQTRUTHJPIcGeYaKCV6sRptn8AAAD//2ydS7btIAhEp0RUROc/sUdxOs/N7e4VjX/AaOU/ - FLyfVoh56YLtBjLsif7Q19DAU/vihleihQFgkoh5R6HlUgg79EP9KZZLiAl3bD418VEvIxPt/ANN - XCEtdHZDgTeWBQP6FttryEdq6LV8plG/T0MDRZUagDf0WUOGolp/Y6LXwuRqrEs/L9Its0mEE9km - Ta0ACscR4ETpa73tdfThMhr6iBxHiQqtr6E5GxrtKWz7FdpMaBBHE9psHInQHCDDalKIFRqUDbKT - htxvQ388NfDGNK0LCS0ca87RxsNbocgZg4msPT4UIs6Fln4iv8wrUX/qvIqJFnEPWjVRvM6phbQv - vaPR0OuuJOJ58kJoHKHXeyyEmRY6o72I4D0mmlyshFhU6RdGR7MjtITubnTETtOCggqNDQNWyKMh - FlUIb5QaF/L6Nn7WYZE9+e5Z5WzhCap0x+7G+CoUQAOiuYXW7sgbQtfuLNYbGAhBDKDQ6QjmZO8D - HZEMCwJRkyIFyDUUYuO4weMrZMh++Wa1E2GBkUgjFoVE2AA1TQ6s0Vu/h9kNYQAIsahCA8hx8/+H - UFQFAci+zE5Di8hxRKAQB1OGQ2gJvxt3Hwq9EcUPGRFnrd9BF6MQE9IJzGlwcQ65EIx0IvwCJRGD - fpPS2hvzFYqO0NAl0baAPmxGmGTsMb6kX8k67jHZEhJkmw1h6RAyZO/ScnxR3c1uCD6A14n1hmBr - C6H0dbSjIbb9+KDbWYh5dS9NiL2tY2+oUBPXLvTG7oqs8X3oh6wh6wkxvtblVzeTaAxMphC6Vsh7 - QhidlZ7IwRv1/6w/kDeEiSzE7MPxia0Q65jhELpWCKucnEfMISH0tlRW7BK1Ci2Dhp6t2eKhNYJO - 4JJYITptjAvTtDJehXMq6T1W2w49d6EYDW0mnNiEK+T9KayFWcUPYyIDSnwhNgm2YNYKIZoT+pDX - oTSSEBcFIZRef4iBc6pn0Nszg0xYBf2vjQkTwcUQYrnS9YXREWKFnJerCn0N0U2X8h2Gb6kzIOE/ - AAAA//9snVeS4DAIBa8EWMn3v9jy5KmppZnfLkcFBBLhoWfXRe1G5RhtiG+UKzJ6SKF6uDEcniQp - jOPhsxLxtz1HOT5VA/NtCBJA9gkHUw66TZTTaBIhavkiDgClsa+iI7pclX70tqsQjnoRlpNQ5A7Q - PtRqYz8oRyAED5dsGEegg6kWCHQmobqhJ4QQeIvBqoe3DgAEnxyRoVoLQVUM5Yo8DUGaXPQ0xB9q - sW6m6BFsywhtXhXw69BxOpzHL+KNOhTB49O8ZktI1NZ/VOEXLGBCaNWbFmN2FA1BRrs2YVZHoyHv - N+LrXUL0NIR+9GNcyhXYitkhhB5K9Yj2o5AFUX98UwJdJ/2rIUjfXIRo6gpByqlIFSwwIX7XSCWw - ziHXwfVuiK2qbAZOBOfLiyCsFOeweZXBg/0iiA7FxNoiQgROmpiD26QXoXGUeak2oTx5IYaE0F6m - jUBcJRfN1RBW0YsGEAPl7dbTsYaqC8pF0Ia0d4eJLHse/SgEMZQK/voDYadGyi9/6IbzAOnAoyHM - IelkWFjtFjyoKHIsoSUU/YRn3SJLDcGauwifmtoXhokQe1sIb9QB0dsRHp8Ti51mSpHb0OaznIuO - 3YOY/5CqRsKi+EEDCDPtQw/QmTVdfKJcMMua9qG5G/KGqikiNOtu54eK3fEhH0Q1TW+i9db8Ez/I - G2LjTMSK/KBV0ZAzd0OON8qrcjW08cbUMdZpyPDbkXMNv63MdIeoHjbKYlrB3k4tYLwNxWrITkdP - R1bQUbmT+vVHDr+joVHHxEkrED0khH8Uij/QAhqBMXHRBLLqSxZKalwtsA9h3KvE8FoNxUO0d0d8 - /PRq1yrv+K651z408PX+OKZ72nc1cYUQysZdNN92VTUDP7TqG/dp3yW0XqCop27Kjuk1ZO1DTx0m - O7X0PRpyotQUrKH5NDRq1yrltw2ijYG5x5qQX0KDV4XzhxJBYgph5AgZWlXZ7kdDGNH7JkStKPU9 - fpcQ3ujn5TBRtQNcZadW8BFCoeCUN++hEBXa0dC0hvwBGsN4FUJkJOHeelASKuMaWE6EjCh+3Vn+ - AQAA//9snVmOAyEMBa9kg9nuf7HxI5FGlPNbIjQBb3Rj84/GrmhVFKWvwSfm1gpLq1vJZhQEozAn - agU3ffZ5aw0Itff49QfZrAh9qWiXEzUYK7045zomgsJI0WAepzLngqhBMHV6ER7molGQYRA6pMlW - 4ZQcD4MFmLYHHEVOasDXCg0ie+/c+CIrCGZ7bCQyJ1JhjAAyiokQLEDa2QPBHNPpysc91Q4Ub9mz - L8IPc+c+e0GNqG+owkVeUDsF+SuFQ0VgF1GH75D0Iv4auRiwX0JQ5FupDN17X3yinQ2FSbQQFghh - tUNRkwPFhFEQgkzoUgSEirq1AEKuCpDtna+Yk9FQ5J/EagvtUxCsb6jg1CyoV4RYLpFDYSKQaPpB - EHIhuEyhwBNV4j+IOnRIlboRmwjBwAjBp4UKTOKJPgxqJYQASYWHEfrcS2remVDODMT3IrZSphaQ - r8ZWvpx9+bJT0Ts5t9zfLgh2VchKq/cLnmoxxYG9F4If0hWNh8jeZI5E+ryJVkNn8ok6FEY3xGCF - VNeef7tvLpoQ50vdYSa0t2oFDf4w3jJxF61dEdTqIow+92mwJkKrtuoclzHi63XPJ4SYSekvsPc6 - 3Me+DBeTfhCF/F6qVxCnUOnUGIQZIwUhOAotEGLMu2ZvXy1dDhy+EIaayBDUNGnarqgR0ZLrSML5 - gaKg/QNhqHMFNhktAx2YDqFWWs3Dvnxi7vVmE3urNI4bm5+mlLKKZBT+AAAA//9knUsWxCAIBK9E - 40Ti/S82NrOaYlsvJiZRQOVDhKvWLqgTIwiFdDapgWjLOTAbQsGZSTFhjCDJjTgAEoWVL7Iz/yJK - CGSjNRF2aozYe6k2b6//2tTZNVHwRJ0P16Kyt3IMhK8q5l77oRwNNwamEYS7EYRVo9Gv/YxOJEah - c1VidujNDZ3WCPeyG2INBN1xhziXgT4VgVmgLrQ3EMwCh9dBWzlKDvsTRpATjdhQgSmqrgEMFAcm - WYcZJlHwtS+C2NZ6DjYt72LohXgUPW8aBQSMEWy5RmjI2og/xJFjxIZJ48GhKPgdduaHXRjHjlwD - 1bwK7+jjFHzCTnmDJ1ZRSV/FlF8AAAD//2SdSRbEIAgFr4SoxNz/Ys03vaHY1otGEXEGtHYi7ipe - VCWhu2pobbkMiYY4dlhXJstkLKrPzYQ+ub0mhEYTYh19coMq0Qr+0QxDgI0I/lEP6vtX2IS7qMhL - t/iqs0I55MyFzgs06lFpogf+74Wi+l4TmtXj/h9ZQ0bkNcKwy3HgYrmEAmjUKN3aXH/q/cIPrdXQ - RPZ7YiNI6FQFOFp5vm9Dwa/2GR3ZJML+xIesoec0FEio2Tay110iolVvDXwooiG2kJy884+rPn75 - IyiAnjYxr2HUQo8a9vJDVF/3SUG7Y0WRayGrd04vmq819MyGqOTmhwkTPVVe2pat5lHXGzaa45yw - OiInMizdLkJXOCGPEA1BfXPJNCAcoYWi3kixDU2US2eg1tBAXiseNNpFoyG0Y6LqFuFDh9nnbPs0 - dJjXqBFDEmmbaTS0T0PLGvKG9ovsddIziOrVGKHnUKp6L1r1Po0Elg8X7SDa1K8BH7OJ7mOBhuI0 - REkkQq9NW1If8KfO6/zBgSY2shVpedeh/KK663MUhCGQvUKMG9CoTwUuwmmg0GK5hFAuPa47DT3W - UJ0NnXtutTtiQh6VntSb6kHrQ/XEQGgHE8JDmyvQ6gvNEXqIYkILhaBM9wyM2Xv1wCx/vwf7q4nc - YKwUr5yS0I0wlMvny0YbcLEglPOj0RCLaogR9yEWwtaGsUq0YnfE7Nfy/hUrJMQ/5sT9IYqHhVBX - 64iFMKpJmssHLRTax6hSVTQd2NVcy+Go4SJ7ibDuOHI8DbsqhN4hBOFkbQyyFzImHC9mVhFhmN6l - bRysUDgVU7ejWSHFuCRatKvyYItuFbozP4maJPRiiV8ZjmY+1L+CnUgjwaEp5IYdRVVpO0K3ipwN - TWQ/1qQk9PzYGtqQqnHL9UO1Qrkcxno70XkxSCsoijMhrpd9aLeElNdF/CPcPyVK2WDuuxmj5EOb - XzmNuxD/eHxiFbCfPbD40c10Ckf+/IHCgwkTwQLsXD1gKBfyjtDTLoKgt7/oyDubH4ZPiIVQCONo - aJ2OIEI9DmVepdo/AAAA//9snVG26yAIRackiNHOf2KPY+776D5d/dsrWqNEERH+o8FG5OIIadtR - RHDjugg6wCrakM9SuJRJFFDAl9yop6FhaFPkGlHkFPPVn4LqI8ThYADLiwJ6oRBGSFGvoE8osefg - Uy3QjiBfQpCvRjjevAhKTR0EDnsRG3GU6t4QdAAhSLTOfTAXCmEdqp0BKbxbGBSUsfMHCqBJ84cQ - FPBa015byJ/CVFu8cttIsyNeW0nMwxAUEcU9hO4rtIni+5bki4p1BXxELkoviD2f7A4Q8v7aaSQR - gp5TSnhxDFEw86GC1OihRCsKO/9RFyeA5MzpiK3PD9S70rYDSEcBqGtMnOGf+aHDkRBNT8r3in8U - Qq8KJQvWLEP5bXMXCvvHis3qKzAhy/L0bY48sjxhfewdH3xEzlTqlEM00PdC7K/WfbAznAuXTP7Q - IqIGo4AEmAGErPqV7Og1ONpKtAizjDIaLtQ1cenrRbDUKFkSlhMhVt+rHDsnJxUkIXxDQpB7hVI+ - 29D+gR5HZWj5UxSTEYsiN5SgjQgejUd+iN9nTUfnW9MRZEIIg9Y/+K8Kfd+3+kPHEBuxT7KpjbAY - XrQMLa8L61BuhQUzhKlD+Y0wjqm7Iij41MBqJcQuXLt+IIxQ6nJdGSpH0wtiskrefnoRdF95ILFz - 6nBFblXehqMRX7tw3eZFHCGFodyGoMIKYb+tO6XYDwnxHRuxC2dRJXszpQDFxAqTPaHBkJ0KHIbW - R9Jc1Fond6w5kNLjReUFofILQWe62rDVtf0fcYZ/dE1rO8JnFZ8H3t1K5V0PC2Zh8xOKZ4aC/RVh - HC9KogfGwV4vC3sYeYiwEdpA4qleOzZRUHMXwgwQk95FR0e/UNNDLnOO2IVCjyEsYBeFIQhA7yc3 - 3zEXnCWEqNRcZAUXVFihTZQ8YbmRNdn64GFjaOlATygZDGSid26OJtZtZQvA1CG0/CnMhQqih0FT - EiEYgi4qQ/hEhdATrawsSGGjhHonBL1wMLj2i9Cr8pX5WF1UdIUeR/09/gMAAP//ZJ1JFsQgCAWv - hKKY3P9izSe9sdjWU2OMihiGC52gRFaMK4iA1JB54yaEvVAIe6HJYeUQOX4iVBSfjjj2iQ7bMjge - fcg7Yr8MdtuPKX5SEPEC1Ha7mbeNhHDKQRkUc4VQUanRrCFOTCHvaHaEtjyV5N0QP5pyijuRc3AU - j4kVbXN+5bCyouU7onlrl0pC97w/lfjFGrp1mEQTSn8h7+gWFEJ3cFrl/zzwyxTC39NEfsdgT7Rf - mHqc3Npx2VXIgmi8reJ4W8XRK2JiFmqd2K/jhRSt7GkoMDgpC188cYw76PcfWUMOpBBwsyFfDY2X - yDg4hthrHwrv6C71lG9jR/cLyR4AH+1R5p+noVthkdPfPnji4c50cg+K2RH7Fcrg0NC93POciIT1 - iRSiEZ1wSvdC7FcFlwFCRuY/YsVp7YkTV+fS0trnkOGTN9RKrZf9mrypKcUtWMpwlivkfCKC5iZS - SH+MvQwMraF1OkJb2jBHQ5jkEkRYj0LBtiZ8dQthoHOiwha20H3EKHRfKhVylppQYqVODGy11Qs8 - 8QRcKwrdh9MPofl47vgmH9qomKeVYEW62xRiv4KuYYmQTqUQ7mAKYcFkp3AVXAiiSVYDmHLKmD03 - Eey2hWC3/aHZkKNffuAFkii40oTm6Wh3NInw96EQB0eZjjGqEyk0/whfSLdkLIVsGn80GoLcPpV+ - taFAqRHcARSNb7HUGP501EthbRfCO+bKHpuIAv9UwJkLKUAqdl8h7ABCmHIhV02UUlL2u1/9t76M - c16Maurf0CiOvKbQ+0KTCGffRLz/ktbBs1w4f0kWwkeTzR4Ea9Q+SnSwdUT7BSIEQ6hEk8tdCMs9 - hkQ+UXBwUiZwJHSMeokevnbqd9gUElH86qCIhRzGW8WjTEk4+oQh1tOHbBHxqJhoopSMErBqE21v - pSYkzJY36t1VuRXjayeC0Usih8tHod3QWqshnPi2UhrvhhbbMoOg2Kmc3JqhYrNQSAtBpglxCGPt - g36F8TAvNFkRyQsL3Ykj5w8AAP//bJ1btuQgCAC3FESD2f/GhnK+ury/dZJu4wMQQUAK3AcpfhWb - 1hYMZu7WB60RUmC9WnQ4y75N9xY0qk+2CbeJ7rrQXEb7vVC5v249BMrrKUWSHCTRsYZuTDxoeRxb - 0GrVkobtz27kjg6feBbVVEpPkXMfRooBJwrmc7uexz1BsnZcSGn+B2kcQfrHuVWF4aDfq7dA79ba - noSh+bfsCj5IcrUnziOBPImOey80PqOltQ2S9dhIxwNFxLTb1TtkLYVJvJR6Yi3b96Cp1q/pbTNB - A3Wh3+pJB4WfosPSSOfIRXL7ViNyvhKPMx2uDtI5TM3hU7fiClvPiRE2wDHlJdxn6DLfg2b+geJC - bhf1zNRf8dwvPnK5FkUcNbT5Ocz5IEmmRsp9ANlMb6SEzsqtuvOg2vog0uk1TZL4jzLK8FNp4d72 - sZyDbcsPRYqD3F+N5HOnzkBKlXOGL8uKaw8lTZKoN7Vrbl3Z1MjJCQe5Xa3I83rKijXbpln6x7Zp - pKQ5YX394mvjIfGvjgvJjj5o3UjfmGn9yGmtpwkWnka7tZzsnIP0jT1mw7817Hs8pSM/IztvqNoo - 7wqzy0MbYS8GdbDiQtM9weLIG+lFSqeovx6f6pL8Zr8JN5xIUYD081xBIiHKlRoS7idAtoxSmo9g - Ne0COBjbfvEpKXyc+m4qySmf0Stj/nSPUVg/omlluI21PSdAGiGqHMtDCXJP9Cbz9c+nVTmuencO - 8Vkajl56UnPjVO000rk79xFYzQ0cxGlkk2ycTavQTLd+OC0PZM88mXTyA1DTR/J+EHupf+z9o1sf - LeaM2h7OC0kFUO1E49iiV3eScC3dkpyIb+h6MZDSk4qWqqlBOsRvrwalcj6j0kaqtcR0I+ryiFA4 - QXMVJGMLJFOx0SOjBqShDe7D1lO3QRmtOiSjgxtZ9UHr8ojg45ecIPBKgxZT9U5A0z6rRq9kIVV7 - td+OdKAKxSjsYOf+ZalMjnTcE/3ddaPwi84qxSOmpK+iaKPnxDM/KTDsNjeCzY+fCqVqMrCKVCrq - 2Wl+UZZOcwI0LvRqmlC8TgsZlP7Hd2gCPJ/T1kE2kFrOKkLvoLhQaFtD6paWO9dp/NfI/wAAAP// - bJ1BloQgDAWvBAJB73+xSdErKrOtpzTSUQIkPxfSYpFIIlkOhbc8XolauUrB9olm0z8E8uCkQ/y5 - rXSj3a8mFYGNWkczKudDjZ1GNU8Y6jKSyk6i8qYlsq2m0zH92Lks13ooDXrLaebAXh5fc6nwg+zB - 5MfLfmGiZcsZFtbcDREH2QQh0hocTmd0Ix98jUSvltMd7ccmwOi+sUn3DuRVQKN4pdpqKuMIGoqE - A225w1Sl1HY3aPuq5y6W9iC5IJcsUMKb/6BlpI1ZqpXr2DVR1zYWSNu3gaLsPZ2ASld5RV8j7W0H - +q73ZJhoKooHNGcraKhfsZVcBbqLDYGsoJUoJ50w0ul8oqbZPZCrfNU8at5qa9nb/iHf6KM/Ugdm - 10gMaysnytX1MLrrGICmtrECmbDPbTUpaMVPOexGJ/zuRmyvfkYSpz2oFTRtTPluD3Wiv9N/bTon - 5ap56/KDmlxrkOYhkg6Uc03SwecH4gvTC/L7SBE3t9XD/WreGgBJOhDUSr+aNJVAynSJF8nPaaTt - 20C65CnorvxyapYoGQ207okCpBRSdLfk3h30qF8EJ2+hbosmi/wNI78widpSVxFX3kZlvILFjlDY - AA56jSRhG6T0lqvGGv7FoeR20F2h4CDFdVBKVCLDcXJuH6P5LaMyhPn+6wODgK3s68X11Ui4GjZo - 6SwTpAxVivy8NszHOdcgnfOBlCgPKmP/lFkhkbZlQIq+pfTm5/Ei3qhcpX25U7OzaXC6CqYe9Cw9 - UJHzBi0/drPgehAMa4tu1qsF6TwtOMnUAxG/qH87kWeF/TmVDrTkdWx0nKaR1gogVQLgmETOfKI1 - tq9aWrsnmkoOBW0Z5o6QxgYyH8M3BhWVhFTG8aDVNaqkyKj361Hoe6L+atJJpKA9kJReQIraPCmr - 7heoXtUKUjQpyFMmZzOfb5yedPbsn+1rrM/NU0VIxpRfNPdrlJmPzdrSVtchaLCpGL6RudyoPDYn - nNNoeOyf/YSvCiVgoG7x2nJ66PQUNDWVg6ZvnBKCB0kEI5ETrEH++gZyyEsoF7GvkPVXA1dBU3kQ - unD/Im+yzOS83Gp+q6oTyHnlif4AAAD//2SdQRLEIAgEv6QiaP7/sZ2xai/NtWvjGoMKiBAwT4UW - 0jaWU7BjCI2wnQhFBRFV2PIUOg0Fm78BkROarRMHFzq94uyPzReyhJUTkGAt1GO4CSo0L/YO34/I - IFr8aJtJJ8u1k2CBVSxEGAuNyRd69YYawm4lS5ETxpFk2GulHW1+2ikBw6/sSymixY82so3XYNyj - 0MCx2EM3iQbWwtRb34YQAWqE+PuHsCgYjfYg9yHH7UPkemCPJG4iy7TRxC4qrQ15RB6CAAjRyszi - bTEjZBISKlqZLo8NiXblhGJbvqDQEAe6FhJ01SsvyhfSysdfDRpl6ZAz/KMrZKMtl/7BC2XGJtqH - nfANrEsUhVHNidwMQoPTSk0t6BO5m+0uREtaKD8+OFagq1HUo51wDBqfEOKjjQY/rYs6JFFgY02n - XsEQzoOc4g9BxXio/WpxVF3B+naETrjGIUZiLsQhP+ctJUfqBEdCyxCcXT6RpkQPppsRmlQoZW1R - mGyAwam0PY8XUOKav/3M9PEZQbOS5YaQaaOFBfmh9iA8lEJJr89DRVTFrg7EWvvMYrNfJ1B1R2gg - 53Pt+lCezSjZL3vAFtG8RBdnrL6AF3whryeDiJNv10wsj56zm70fOKSSnnhxCdOIu4J0eeQ5rael - byIkNbXOyTVH6PIL7XMaSlwYdvwJzh+NcNhoxB3Z/tzJTtjlRlTJFxoLU3THx83Ql3cp0dIAsiEa - GVq0UdTHCBnafJg2OZFlZMDFsxcDe2o/bwrQPBQTKXxQ71wbAnuHYyOxfjndDNeJwbgho+C0smaF - 1x4L5dkqvovktEYce2kOVMniY1ZII2S9shP+w+DEq1IC1JYOO8AhhSEtHfIlhIMlGfwfkn47Rxyd - EU5dgwU52pUioXac4jLtmEPhE6MFxDgY33XGPZ2H2C/7TtG8TLBDVEi1+FIOQnx9eRPKqRAlJ5KB - dvXKXKP5bAZL7ItMtEYI4hAaBypGqBeYfC5WTPnSGkdhchJFPrioKYTP4TYRvQXxIrAbwg4TL2yr - o/bgwnbiCyU4VzCi+Mq8a20lDtnLaQU+trXoaDSiABjxH9eh3EvqOWEmM4Q8hE1HKPjR7Hj49+sH - AAD//2ydS5YlIQgFtwSoaO5/Y82lalJBT+OoL58fVBD4RYrluomCE9OUxo1oc2LaMfaXMcdlI8ov - GXA+IriiZCe0S6CDd49CcNNotFjRP+gnOuFFDMS2ZCnJidBWrT3MCYVOwOpQ1EFcAxVPEJuOouix - J55R66P0MPxD12l21ZMQaId/XlAQwUFRiBtro79DKyU1zCk/yuCJRim4hjXCkUyqs/GLQzkohPt2 - tG/YX6TshWirjvcPfX+CitlGPtAdFe9oPmjJKBT8ep0eHxHenEon89g5yh6+iO5/EHtiM15tIUaF - FKJRT+jwu2pnwjRZNzhXF7NgCcF5T4j2DiH217KFy2JIK/aIxqoNhkVoDz/oMYXOKLW5RAthayo5 - uykUIoz9pXBDToSHY0LOGV0Sh6LDxnlVDzQpAQpxDdmD+0gjrlp7FO4Kv/pYaiM9mxA1lI3YFhOv - pUJYP5YyPEtSGqYFVUohOL80guArxHcwQlgKrjSBrLjgOy+ER9rSHsAxRI6gVHd7x+Um4t5RCHHT - G53RPBdyI3ROh/sCcipmXemEnYgX4kb4rps0UnXKKxsI+7byMhgrDlN8I34E4w4LBVEqhCGRsflU - bnWgYXVz5a5bA422nI9xCh0OWjrfKfh51CEX2tg7vE4+EFZyfuLEVHZUVNzPuRT2M86vPR7jFLqc - X/viyaHkLI1UheDOlb4S7/ik/aSKWoHWIL9cthOWCkRqF6I23ZXxapRyLtHh9pny1OVcDeX6IjKO - Y4lMLj6Nmg+EjUIIGkrXvsqKG5FohcZ/dIMHYbZPDr+LHnGN+B+F7kRoXkG5PyKe0qq3kDG3UBxK - AAsaqWxqRBrdgTBXTVFQfKBgW/pLQLX1oXllpAig5NFawWagsmh0BsI00b6KDayRDYQtU3HcPlYs - YfIRUaNr9/CgW4jXeVOEb1Y0Z0+UAICwEsIaUgSqxYp0rfhBh4i2zE6ns4iMo51Dq9iIFZMapLog - fc5SJz9+lz+OttAlQnBtIZrFpKD+WGrYrepSfthWIQ7tSZotTKnI/wEAAP//ZJ1RGkQRCEa3FOli - /xub/ubJ6fV8w7iEKHWJeIeciNfwytALvTCPikhxqEsspO39tHCwqX4RY0MosIsKcT764QlMiGLi - QY9sU5ReawjrfaJJAZjeBCC3L5x0bNplIyqYKxHP20JYMU2x12ZDm2hvilzqUbgt0MUADL1yNsC+ - rfhGlAmle2Vdg/baRHTjssHcrkK0npr2DlbPODWfaSlHu4wPhgvhPGRyv2+oTVG5Wj8jFFfPgC4R - DITyI4hW0BH4MNFEigoh6IVysoHNMK4i/npDjoKbQeVDx6HJgg5dTui06h36V+iE9HZ0oVa94VF0 - Frq4AJXpf/IbP7qNCCFlshAOeIkmjAh/xH+cUDGEjH2vBTkaGqgrAnGHC/khwjv80Oq1jGhQmBZf - 6hWyjwiPAITwCrcQm7ritoKxKJipyVFMZPFCI/wganKhbxCtNRtyfLZCseyGOIeUxWkTweNMCBEc - QtHr+Nm5bHM4puPRVyJm8v0j1DUubnSF8KY/UVx2oVxOG0IA3kRm7FWj87gQbPj6O2PrLeDOIrQu - mmo8xIby0GIFEMJM06uGd6PQkxzcFwohJKvQWh+RvapiSJV/t0wh2CgSDUSEUnbsy3/MNQ7T/Sh8 - FVqf6nCrKxDERwghdQrZJYrXeiqEZDBCyBNbqLU+uCgc+TlPIuT7leslpfB86gogakNCuF0JpSDr - CGerP0Ij5L62iXD6FTL2l1yoUJeyMe6GOEIplxQTufEMIuc4rov7wkIc2nUuP3udJqvrICxVIWxN - ZzHwTiH/iMJRfSqityOs5Mdjs/U+jALgNCyVOy4WmERIDiAE5yV51DinVVmzGoIGc6a3iSw0G+LQ - yuza0OFwKOQJfjV4TVrInAgpDgthAys0iQaFfNB7rdC2htg5ChWMzhkTvndCrb9SZ94sOPB8VwhW - 3UIUk6E4Ai+yDZdDIcRBEpqUHNtIRa9HFIfTKhHF15yaVaLJmabj3ItyU0DIciHcfwkhZJMQNQX5 - dU0WpEv+HxkR3iwKIfNx6CbtsC6/raDD9Ce0P7ben9fnPwAAAP//ZJ1BloQgDAWvBEJA73+xSWVm - M5VtPbWRRgyY/P+HtltPckxH7VraCCqkfwi34t4u+cMU+r97R66BR3Qi5cIWGuqJ95O6AUh1FEjS - PIoeQXqsLu85XyvefpTSWQot/2LI4xIf+s+dg/OerzWXQtjLY9uOkuQJaPQTh3uVmEntypjZrSee - UFMznrhfQ6uh111IFsTpaBp5lZlI9R2BrK2mjks57TCaox3VbrulcWW4d4ebGufz8CWoMZqPXpn0 - jaJa7lqTaEbf+gYWiA4qzmHN73vcj6r+QNKPLhcpz1/MtNco/HSsN/ykra1sLPKSlZQAuh73c28P - 8unE/US2egNdj0I0YvSL48po8xepVwcZzEYqYSjkGRMz92V0PO7HWVrhn8+G4lR8aGe+0GnIe0Oo - AeivBWmWQ7hGex35cEwNOerDQ+16rcRRSP112tcH0GpH5bJmNbSNpiTBQEeTVSIPTIrwtK4lIUgb - GyAtkdjrVHB6al3eUTSkXYxTS3UjJUsU0ox5alFpJLOhQv1EzyaF2rVk/xek/LtXt7+dBMnWeh7P - itd9T7XgZ6R0FtByIx47FUalUKmjH3sQxplxPHKmPakSkV9kpDxRCpYcF4KGOmcsFVclevynMbtr - +yNwS/x/Im4B2qqjPEkvikTKQgSpdj7Yu1N4B9Jfm8jRNns+CihJ43x91FFRTqJnqO9B0+2ajplA - xyfaMgbpUH0gDBSYtZDKpa9EYEHSQwYpK6UMRzXB4O2ssUr10+xIr5NCy8i7dzEtngBqred+OtJa - NLC03R2thnxD5bLVkU/c8tNJtKQulcgiGCBlY4EcPYJmO0rijommY7lA/8mNGLKDipKn3kJL9Y8M - eykmgqRxhvWbdMBLnlx/bSK/MjfCS6+R36IoVs+OFJtUamd0tIT29m3fLf0Jyia907yR+1IX4rnw - NKRpO5Fq50GrnTjfduLwunaf9glk8ylOR1FS0pDE5H6ROmedqzAqkSz7gk9n2gou9BhJXizK+trX - smofQtQyoi60fC1bOdccqsdqzwgPkxlK9yRpKPQM7WGH4UT5ostr/QAAAP//bN1JtuQgDETRLdEY - N/vfWCmoUV7+9B3biUnAAkkhECv5Vf8Z9upGx1WvMy3yeLx2G7oaglgLr1Z72F80PzVm/6MX9DhF - M//504KGz0odIdAkYiMIuYagdTx+knu60eMvTmrzrMhDfDaiuaWcWax47bK+mNtlfevoLUR+R2I/ - GpvFmQLfC9RIig4i+SWIqocrNXe86vn8nAQ1rzpGYWT8MLaCbFfUY1+R8zFoeGOt2kNE/lDUsD2M - SAAwk69QxxDZ5fkOtDCag3zHRNXQE7UHmwcieKnQYU+k8DHGfNB1IHL6g9ARqX2btYODbgd5GTC4 - SgvpMdjIx7djmFxGy6w5c2QMejxynadXJIi9VZBLx5yfE3mayV5IAcsgzfRCftM2ovW1cPhCqStC - I/rloVKZvreTL+cm3tiImA2iFFdQw8QIYkdRb62dsxE90cb9B2IqjHjrJugmdTqo0au1fdTOSdlA - Omej8yq8bgktYLNYiKjg7E2JMN6IKZoCppwDpFAo/RWEURPEp2lE7etAjonU1zjQQos6iBDzIBLb - 1k64HAfqPt5CiBvxhdlC4zaiv5eN6DpwtvzegZZduEXnDjT/QD7LHM/1XyLiF63PeJMdObREi0G+ - 0R9XMQqzs6WptRlxTGS36I3KeAXNz0b05rRaze/j2IoavyiHz7Sr1nH/7Z3B/4umaiPxILx2dC2i - ztqsHLQrUTZL5HlhkF04jlOMoO7j7+46sUNFQUM3dUa9YzWC7tyYuoE0NREVPKs9nytTO/xpI+7N - 46rp3K6FHHMliFPrMkxIuQ3S+1AICcgkj2ghF5oYpz3KJceNw198LwNoeuQql4hc3SDkB1YylrrP - qs/VA2rkXAdpnBZa33Gjg2kjXigC+x+oIaEWZCBUIUrsrH6nyumBMNy24P4lIlkoyNOVvoXcDmTn - 3ErFFhr6flNlkYnct5f1QEyFvn14IircFZqvI6fMB1t/nQPzenWU9BQMOZCf8h6xlEdknFW/VIUM - Ilo5K7TbmkJIGaT4G1qbWyyJjWeQ/ZXaDN+J6K/oWPOs0RErXP8AAAD//2ydWa5sIQhFpwSK3fwn - 9thUcpOzeL8ranksxYbOJcAWEdwYlZqJxhLKuAGR5iUCiJBZW4hPYu4LyR4LYZurhBFGtDbbYoS2 - 3AoXba1dNvnf3ueaRcC8RBMOikIHhxqlH8LR2h7j5/wQK7a7gl4BcCY3WXuh+Tth1L6s8kJ/UWU/ - B2KIGL0EB1aHHoexHiX2sJVbru3BUgu+lKvsS4MIvuAKRR8c6Jz52Pnk9t2aZ2r1ypaIyWRxqWM1 - RcK6HaGrcWj1lMhxBjDJF5TKCzgOlEq6gz3NdM0kGlSUyJwJe1p2nY+DhdCv0nASeS+FtDiVXZKd - SMTP9qYOlhsFDuCKAIkHBF2HOaMTWUOwcAlpz7/vmEJwywu5VnxnTqHJtrxV1KHmAeVIjIYWmj/K - ndAQmz+86obuhYMVD7wHfgi9zyX63cCEYC6lGHcQokJtJHK05iOC5WAi2t4JIVxDXmDe5Tfq0BFE - 57tbKdK5v9vRAjLEElOCabzUCEHtGvJ9OIsIgk9KJFhtCvlkW4bY3YVYah7s20KIJBQVVwCdmBtH - slLzBpufUFIJGSeAXCvY/FitrbE4v/JmdTCqSra6iaBFKsSBVsQTdGIEIpiGUk80pMMIESzhQrea - 7Q0tlrq7VdRdisg2vlEO76zobTI5ragLtV+kc4Ls8dv8MuofEy3o04QGm9fWx4r+uIbM4fsghLNv - oV4K73JKsATTKyHkuJR5PLTNhb5P54p9jjd3mQ2+VnEgioAQjFXj3hM2iIZtIviBhRxDsB4Txffo - Uwiy8B4mZgjlfYBw1yMWBjpl45lE0zc+O2QWCtRmTvbgcXCE0PsUexAwN+j/+EOtIt59Qxqjh1Jy - uXWiwYGefI0Swmt6IU65lDgcnESLpRZuJ4nicq5qDhjRab84EZhOaG6M13CYlxUKdpW5LQpB5ui0 - ioOI7kychQpBc4lwtxJCYLpE+3AIfbcJIFfgVjHYe4WWIGLOszxYv+Bfq/iYkwgGWqHYLP9B/NOs - r6FEnPcWGwdKocN+DZhBFBrsxEB8zFDoNQoFpRHCEBq1biFVAP7ac+VX3NDoCPujgmhCwCg3gLH5 - v7gY/wAAAP//ZJ1HloUwDASv5Gy4/8VGpb8ZStt6xiRh5NT9H+mG8AhUA4NH4OPqH3XBQeqxgjSJ - sDAz85OIYPVt3yMpg0hC3ucYTTfbpLmK6IucnEs1mTMl0k8n0aioF9R1YOS++hQCXSW6ILUmd1tB - PtCWfnSi5TPaNB2k8UKQ4x7kN0SrXdAudY3pN8S4XDeafva4079GzUHOV2TkUQyQVoqzDuppvoi5 - HZjpa2/UHYU4VTYjLVZN5Pc4X43ooq19/AgZ9nOpuX0R0bVWMg9Sm3PjZfhTGI+GUkBD3dP0mHap - qyWHiZTeBdIQdSKl1oEkaLbSDdmlcEMuaPoihjOrW6QyQP4/JloFOVaZRdA99vu6Leze68bI0FMO - tHt4ovNW5LqmdsUvzIrLPSJ5YaTRKGwTnHWg6aBOBqLZTzeSUlUif3xtS2cLNEpd0f/5nhF9iO8c - GEhTDSBJZiIzL1t7kFaSpBh9d/UlvcOXUPkEGk4KXxyoFIXn7uOrx2J6F6Q8GucBvcdzbGWTO358 - 4CkhF0gL5BN9p59A05d6vDwWpJ16IOmTg7S3hqXjsuQGaXIjUS0lOW9Q88Nhg6VLeeLyh5qR5mF+ - aBptR07OP3xRBI4a5EDuqGNkoN/cWVOSFAuF+lKXl8asHHDTgaikt4L0kwap+3BYCDULUrcZefVR - qvdAEKrfywdO2ZaASphEoz18Eezg/CLkXHtBftCpOie0pQkHuo6J3IVVkLJatGKXS40S5CwR8BnH - cAAg+VqQe/go1yiPDrRL9d4rsiJP1ObjRE2NVdTuYEJ21KVqG83MzDXSngxQK3XN1y1mToIJPRLg - BWkH4Q+VUl2/TJAjp9m/Y6WYmEtND8sEum4x25TPIsh5NNuFFV9YS+mlMUyudjWQ9EQTHdf1uO++ - 3+20E3Wh6euyJ+jCqlSfeyCPDQXyTEYi39ByDwxbt7ciJZR0atSH2RjFllJ9lbqk0fhD3cjZEGi1 - grpLHS19B8kHL9GoqFzE0TLURNs3FGlOqcujPoF2eV5W2gOtt9Tl4bVAfwAAAP//bJ1LkuQgDAWv - BAZD1f0vNnqqRUdkzjYDY/6SQCA4Cgc96qHDnebYnWzVQlDJGulDqrBvXAmYl8Rvoym0lQoPajS6 - RjCkXgWyaMQRXTINmkIZv7jv3giiPAcN7NpCEE1xvYGiGwRtuxEqlFP2LcS8osxfITah9ftGQ4gL - zGDo60aP0OJaOPjCUaNHRUWAs0bQ5XI6C9230RZ6hR50RxAUpIRtdvZwxgmiCht0jR6VnqI8aPLD - S/MhCGOiTADuPARhDgXB3MoJzscI3RE0ldeBIRV0VAg4JTR6nQrTascPeQkNpeKRZNA1wpZFENv+ - vriz+ENKRdEUBKWmkUrPjdlCuNfU6Bq9/0Eq6uAgz51V/DFR1j5EPNMJwuIexAp10FEhmA9BR9nD - ey1ocNYmwqjRUunxREx8/SjKgzgwD0M5758VKzT4xzJhlD1efG10nQr6atwSOd1rbqgJ+WRm0Iaq - uDsypdBS4yyuE4ev0CWOHDyCGnE1yd3Zj5FTTWV/WcdC7KGX4Tj3VuynRpwwiSf9NbpGqOM83NkK - 4oeFODuCHqHtD7l+zcONsyAOzHkkrSaDY/6QCkEXlK13yUrYfxfnYyGO+/Hl/v0ee3LcF+J0L8TG - GXtSGOY1X/5xaMXMA78sxMAbGwlBSIkcBK02aDoVFPCgwewnfZCWnO2DeIDTaAodlmtSbgeh05Yd - 2grdY/ToQ1y422UoUL9fCSKyhaAWFKITRxDGRBCGbxAOvBo5r6FyIZZkEO4273WPGrrQY4SVaeVJ - qCHElgh6hJYR61gIO5R5su2j7GkZBmElz8NubPtCWNIaqUK0KIKWGodGRl+wX0IQJ0FsnEJYrIKw - U1MIkciDVIiS0RzkQY8QRGYQe+hl9KQfGkR0EwxyKno0BmHfN4j9GITs4wz5FYI4CYJ8LER1OOjP - KPsHAAD//2ydW67rIAxFp2RsIOn8J3a9XelKXfv8LqUUEjAGv/4jaLWNkEzui6xfvIQT4teWS1sZ - okhrRIEsjx0+9X4orFRsmQOKgOKmgF7KaDnfpKEw9FCayOpdhri209SVQdY876OFuIElA1aEeDus - NEX8HCtp3BDiZFJ5G3uKN0hCx/6RFxvyS/VOLAqFRrh66rM8guS2Munzo1ms2843eUU9qAzhXi7l - APY77FYdEXAnxDEKYdNplBjQoEOE/ACDytpCwqmtwEbs2xPr+BriGHUUCUPX2qKPm1Dwh3HsH2MX - 22I1oEHBAQVN8UIQfELL2qKiK+RP0cKiFF1YooqbwRJVkMxrTyF+e38PSYb4JvbmnqZTDM5WQhAK - qWLehwgpuAdx2Jtl9naWqVFCUKNUYQkKZe8SyMH+Rf4UtKHMQg4qIV6dDwpD2NMG8R8L+SeE1sc6 - wfARIYghIc7oRsFhF+0KqUvLMATlQQhbUyM6yAtdayv5JnrtQZ9QJUlOzGDp2C9iJxhqPojLPTaN - VEKcTIqIYic2lUChw375GorN6w/VkryOoDws1R5wtB3BBiYEwSeECTA1Ho4httUqLNbjOocvetDv - gJYsbPih/FKOozIUbOvSM0IuSI899Ww2X7zbHvQrv3qrosf/UvXox9EhonlTiB9NRWF/5+oaqzfR - gdl1ze2mIeg5a5nga7SwYIQgtpcSrqchzC8VKcL0bYTiTIOuIYbICGHmNDqv/RDJJgbdP9A2hMkU - E+zmyNqiI+egMMROuMVTqBxBDCnC82NP0WND6HHEYct6am3xqNuIN6dCZW3R+bIR/ayE+LWFrPny - l4PCa0LImz7Ih40cQQrloAlECMdmIXjxCHGa3A+jEQcFUbFf1+IVhNYfyH6YaZ3gebsRykE1ujxv - CwV7b0aEkEPAJUK+7UHlCDrmoDTEmdPLmG/VLepCUERasS5KgB20sQpxjPJprn8AAAD//2ydSRbE - IAgFrySKmtz/Yu0nK+v3tp4DIkbjAIa8eJ6UCU1Phb3HQlY8X6cUaoa8QdyMEFpeFo0pm/V2MqBS - IZeeN6gKQdRxfkXTUTeE3ZWDeN4hhAlfAQdpcloOdyJOmYqXyqFwEE76hTjcO8M3ZD0gDEM0poNo - TELNEHY7D3o4p50xS03E7LScg7Yjzsih2xhEgd0CeYXlQG4vt86F+I0WSkO4PyFEIQ5ipzU6+/rQ - JUSZ0q2JQvcv5YeaoT9l3YuaQumpbq0K4ZpNoWUZsZ8jTwAIzvQhT3UbkxAuvhbakP4sc98w9Dii - vg5aj6G70wqF1QjPEoW8LFwR+NAwFJsIB/aFGgxAJw3NEEVdPN4sNDxVJFFQhUJWo5mcfPU7oiaE - piE2+6xWm6H+DkNrGppBhC1qIcRYUsRZxBYrRJuQyxYW74Z5FmXd0GaNSRcxhUYQTfbjQRxD8kQa - hpqlwmL+Q81QTCIbCnJe9jqyGoP9eOYcKnoweqWc7SJSTqHtqSaFmHDvWoiGqRMc6oubqYqp2vjF - PIjGdNBYhjqkl5c7Ft/NvuSEzlGweD3eItpUoVAzlIYWx3anG4kP3TU+b8LFlVBOS4VrqIWWp7pX - aYWmZ7yPjArdqw4hzgpC9//2ULhEZqx4PUTPy4yJkDFCuGz/oeGoGwrLiAOcQmllzfsQoZA3KB+r - MZfViEuhHzJNJHv7oO6omaiDKlxvp/SLgdd00I9oU4Uo/YonWXzgPUwhKlrRLqajYQgrGMW4pXIy - g1170PZUVOFRF76FhZohiqorNJ6xEQ24AynEkZZ8uSFn4Y81u+Gxo9B+WGPb1qC2+VGQz+c/iHKd - ScGEQDTZD1GrDVs8QsnxmIxEXsjbOKxrGwI9DYW9ZCp9Qx9DWDQrEuYehrCCOShyGQoWP3GTpND1 - F/ADAAD//2ydy5XEIAwEUxJgAc4/sVFr9jLVe61nMMigjwHxh/jGRA6ERpONyLQ+JlJcNeLw1Rly - SHUyR6PQgjG8vfxLhKMChdamGpoLa79LG7kRBQjBPl4Nr2kI0cnVas0mQpTZiLMjkqGb7pL8XQxq - hD4KQYRCw1EQXaRjW7qW8DqCXi2ErZDraPPSJsKG70aYfELwhpTnIR35U8+1RtA0CcFdOXvilm6h - BTMnBIPfaBoKq4shZTlftGmFBoUjNA1BDTXygoMFAyuLutcz4yUySWihxxHfqIys+Bzr4bgXYl2F - MGuPfqe9hhDzCcGDOTLIkwhHIoUeuBhCULVCUDBCEx2qht5/UBiCUmg0HLFgPDcNHb4xcJCmEeZ2 - +Zw4JdkIQYYQPsdWosALNDh8hSbfOLBx7IuCCH90G21H8NL2yzu8CsULpaBD8Rj3QogVGoUhTGRd - OGgFx6YIz8Dmy0YUjvY9DkPjdbSJ0gviujEh5GZoxOor+MXAFGJdySXJRlAwW0sgVpCRoRA7lJHw - MYXgBDYKQ1Z9JGX/MFFkI/zYEOLsKJN/HMHHFILro6P5cGqE2HoloLHqg59DNnkaYh8LTdbF7J79 - N4eSkOW2gkiuLYQ9zY2oAVa5JmxqJAU994VeFeLsKPSrOj4AAAD//2ydURbEEAxFt0Trhe5/Y9OX - +Zr75vceUkUQIYw2+9eLOJpcVQ+Keo3o5I6vT/GDppvvqPO3540o5o1geDbagahD88adn0asHKPf - VHrtLyy2jJRo/kFFBLf+F92BKmTBj9wI+thoBkKjGY1AOLPV6ERROXcYYTmsowfrex1Gg2iEFpJj - YKxAmFhfNFiFjrMUKGQV3U9G3DpX8VqL0YAZKFtbg4jqbqTIiLN3jVbKwgAj8ehoox1fpFoZYfyS - I45FuWqHeJoPRspUWRNia3dOIhwLb5SyBnXI19+YcXHo6NdX+Y8LL+Y6mj9CzjWibns/B6ns1BXR - Zsc0ylTUISP3iQ8AAAD//2ydSZYEIQgFr4Rj6v0v1nxy0xU/t/FMylJwQIX/aOwPRDUZjPkstGi1 - CgzcHTVD7KFEcGMpQ5CXajT3rjzdhoKV2JdqkmhT1r4c5YRYL6YdL/RQVtADXs/8ryFsfoSw/lpa - iJos3EES4ka91lqTCOERxywHmCFMTTPndrh4hLAGEMLsLhQmi4dnU0esDxHe8xXCiYF86RjlhFj7 - rZeARFwXCrUPZOKphbqOCaud+3D/WIj1Ohdea6HGqh7OaULLxB+c/AgN1t4O2d9gPIasoeMM/qLy - G/2i9dAJJ8RfzKnjWikeb+rG/Kb41tlp8pFcIkS2L9QN4f6Xci5xBZOIs7sQRvI5nkmdGIy9Vog9 - JDQNsaqJmn3YWS+lrzyGwj5sNGQ5QAwFRpM5Gt3dcgNh1SGEuUNvg2kKibDkF6LmZMtznFDWqGuI - fzsRbUhqH0Q81RWiPSai3ifiaBLnsr3CzV3ZoIYhNmEs7kULNSKEFikEg6mT8W4I4+pQQxwipO1V - kEAqZiK86C2ESScRneKFvBSsQwhLMqHgh/1eluq8xCHUWNXOeUjo+UD+YfdSmPnS9pBK8EUotS6v - GwxFAd5ECGVQqy+oibY6bELlyRhEvBkhBEejdqLUnMmwLkPJGzAWCsGGhGB8cg5bJRgGWghxFV+E - D8dGNo3K2cp6dYZZKoRNbKIJqxXC+l75NWhDuhjBXwy80ylEZQqpoaPtaBhiS4Qi4DuyUryzJbRN - fFBzonHpk4gn10LUwkTDUVB8cMQUMvFxaaJh9wuFmiG8pSzU7BcfDlZhd7YU5LJZKURzLkSzCp39 - /aB+FhVACF0rhDFaKAwh9XUhTGCFTHwcK4UQRC8KoHk/EMYJoeWlMFEIWb2YSEwIwQoLhYnnHlkI - NiRk7aUw7IaGid/Wabn0sXrxupRQ9w+xyeiKdb2IeECoVLvstESYYd40lL/oDwAA//9snVG6riAI - RaekiGbzn9hl85+X1r6v6wsjUxQi2az2KXQ45FRN8jUEGy1E7TerCzai9oWGtZV8aUKmarJXN8tC - N4ItVGo1PrsKsaNXbScguFiOYHVi/UOEI+d+aDkKQ9SrXiRiQxGWYdzIr+IbKgR/SOVxTfBsDpMu - kEyE8wEaXRNcyGYQChNctIVxmNwrdBxt08tsoVaTJGKwSwgrjBC8EyHEC4XgZDSaRPu1qzaHyWCN - uEZYTublr06N/nMV4jlCmHyNHqB9MMgbTUOTSmzUAmmUJsgveEJwpOQYBh9oczAJLb9qmfYo5PpD - Loi1Q9V3Ee1stA254POYIFcYIUzkRkFEgywEozC3fd8Wwk60EH7obHRNcFGvMtqHgpaaLMTxpUIA - JsidlZA9kGUrz9wotSs0OO5zMxQshPk4M5kK2SgNPVQimaQtxDmU+fKxM62/hKgq6801wjpUZpyf - SoU4rcoh4nxU/fVNhFM9GsGITtWRWoZgv4TgDwlxik7WKm0UFLwvjcK8l50zA4ej/RCbD5Sga8S5 - XU4NlgChzZ6Qq+PI2xrUa/Ank0bftoZqy33vqJ9HsEEqxLiJEBy8Rl8lykljCt14JnN0C+FUokZY - RYWWX4UpWghnGDdC56hGM5aTocRUQ0lVCy1HMMj6Zwa+qJAL4kBGIfrbQsPaYm6nvg7BaxLi60j+ - JSl0sYA1CiIcntBo2x0fv+OB4RO6dsdD7eNlMo4QOzpepiUJsaPjZQhRCMGuQpHWPP2hRnZHhp4K - MZAt5HoxyNuIzV9+RlRlRM5HoSCicW9kgtwpCJle93AAxLUpGjp+0ZHphYOKfmgR4ehAIdQ+Vw1a - 1z4xCuNV+D4NDUMoEvhDgwgZLlFLoQk+A0m0NXjLH34MfTdbjc4x9N3yNxpsPpBr3eg7rRoFmw8k - OQqhVGWjpBKB05KEsKGMrhfxd8d/AAAA//9knUmWBCEIBa+EOOb9L9Z+atPG38YzKUsBZ/iHejOU - w1Cz/4hlTSrN8eyGMomwOVhoNEPNPwyUyoOn+anQtGcQHVZV0TKA2sIVJ6G2rBTG2kLdS1En7qyD - en/R8VLsjrtKm/bh7t0QNaclwqek7uOOZSgMbVrHRWycmMkeskMqoaApBDfFC83tiOIDG8YyDRzE - XX/JzZtC7yI2lUwFGn0UmvQABXJvCiFtyQ+FoTRZ2J+Qo8WpiBACFhd6p4qFxjAE69Au6XI0P0PD - Ud+G0NsXLVZ1cBwSwtlvIZeFuMOFpqFu4u+oAFnX+U60aps4RCgEUyjUDbHTlJvpc2S/iN0CIbwz - LASDOTqH+QzBIZ/gpeNCPQ1hhCnEUhrDDLGhNU17a7+/RASaQlAmISjm1ntnQzhGTIVphp8otA1t - Q9glK5QmHmlehIJ/6CIYjNAwWdFZqh2raqOabD00payGILA/xD/UFht6zM320g2aaQgeU89toKsK - gQGrFWIlFIHAEXv7agnrlYGMDoXgoxVhA1q4FTVmGWJLNOYx+CGIj4ZAa4W6l4KPFsIksJB9iAvy - hWBphYYhdodi17yyFFMLKieE2dDSdYBXlm6JvieeQuO9onnRnO/O1g+FoXftnoq8tsMQxiEhaOFa - vL5YCNZRiOKTE5GL8LyyEOYTt/eD9dJFYZRSxEyUys9qr+npNNQdwecsvYhDEyoQyjIEN6RkKlC5 - OzXF1mYh+BwhGLIQ1URj2jK0HUUSbbZ9LOT7LTQ2ERLLFMI06o7HuIcshNh+hWAdhYajMJT+IYZM - vYeCbV9Hi3OYH2qGppcaXiqJAlHCCmGRoby0WEnP287oRyHWXigMLUfNEM4VCrEl5un8UK8OhqF5 - DHVH7I6LsIa5CJfHUxmNYWnTQrvlVRuuH2dfOE4pBNsWgi+cctH2IUI2XZQHti0EN6QjqknxgWdm - qY0Hdkc9YzH0BwAA//9snVG2pCAMBbeEgNLuf2OTSv9M132/dTBKxBAiJP46LkrYGnmFTxokD7nx - 2PUBRauwTEQjZUSJRj7RSkdRGv3+5mm0LIuzzEZPPIR/lEwWJ5qkG81Asky7JlbLOjF3gGT4qGov - RYM+IV5J+BvNEO9PtJAyVjfSG6JMtywAhWLlR+NiWjxnhV6jeGmF9LmDFI0CyZI3Uh9JwJxITjNo - /4HuQFrhUw9K89Aup1bz9l7+lUVlBi+3dq2b3G0yNp1AMmkgWROqA7yWdbzIAHmYgCz+OM5ECmZZ - k5qFXg9y0Ax0RSsdFSCrlk7Yf9FM9KtV9Cx3mFSY+qxAevpCqjHeaISscUKW9oB/0Qq0spXmofVZ - KmHeB2wVzwFd0Uq/xTprpwwMaIes289VyMphdp+BUpaKYjRyH+9X+xT6/Fu0upURCrQUBwBZE7eL - PX6R7ri9WbWRIjWgx62O9rk3ks8Ekp2o53zGSbSNvAJbI/yvSWrCN5D6OCk39gcaRg4zTOYhiT+P - alw2GoH0Y7yR/GiQliKFxutWnMswUgGEdsBkJwp9tEYGyf8qdKycQrIAIA1ykJyHso9KttpIvglI - PhN5whRBAsnAgFZeKI+vkZSzXPh29hHFE8h9nE63TCF6O+AgTRQgv+0oOAjS5vG64a0sh7OrMCTS - IO+SC08geR2FtHVhUgXPiER+I5AGeaNopTMGIO28qV5v5exqdBmtpVm00RNIr/ba47YKaxrShwyS - vb/W9HqokI7TN1KUv1FeaH31xspfRJYwocvlQQoNe+4gRaNAHhOXE6Q2molkREEyyBe/51ei3zuS - gFmjECTx5HuVvqhsIZNGLn25K51x/wTSNNdoG6kYTCN1CKSRQ6p+fdvkv9erbSRZFNHVc9VaUY4b - xaD0HgvpVMMcnW/XSEl8vmgF0vhqpAvrftYqB7z+QCOQhlxv4liBNHwbbSOH4UGPH3U6YDymq5k1 - sgpBIctO4OhQgNH/Wv0HAAD//2ydQbIkIQgFryQiZdX9LzY8OmZB8pedoYZlK6AC/kdjJDZPYYX4 - D0nHoJQewcFILGYbKdQHJ82XF+nPCx0iwzlTod6JugnY70A2S/VllYjR+oVWEDm7+vBxzEJ3lBqf - rYNsVrTV75HTdrzYlUtjIgNNoe7wXajrISEEMdmXu4fXiZwf5DTTTclZnKUMZ1ZC8BootC8RhPsP - jbaQDsQqHQw+yMI5c4Qeos2ZI4Tm5T9xBnpZkVmTC/GDEnkQBZtfTI4mf1kkbNG1Iq5ACmG8hLoE - EEKgvEmgbbR1eZam6G1jW/EikEZe9PBmKMf6LpkKsfmdi+EdyEYpaORCd1TEi0eFzmxrduJwcHQJ - PpHjg3Las1+J7ix1Z6mYpbpWEMIryj+EgbaDRGuJDG5cQvGNUsGxF2LzhnNMu4oqPgN1R84fciI8 - Vy10Mb+u1DYq6hwTFVNz9E2sad+5nOh90fsIPPOSaF0shUTwcNEm4HsmYu8TQXekIEQunkKYJkJ7 - lELIR6GDD3K6cv/QKMU5cXNlQ6TpMrtvFvM3A4YThfVjUiG8v10IsjAl6IP5JdTt6LQmLjxmC0GB - SVQRRcCNqxDUr1Lh9Utjoct+JYJZUAgfVHHxHe0PWei0tQ4oaSGfCOaK0BqlEIMn5C9GwgyHN4Ui - BoJ+FNpoXu4/fSRCvtBAlznhCsEkU760ZyJjxTRhe78iPqSxL8S2Ep2B4KlUCGIoN9sOKack0DCQ - hGApJEJMRiHIQvnQQliVD60PhLkqBDWXNieOXAth+gr5LNWPBoSw7zC9gwkteqS/vokuEcJHTNIR - Rs0Zh7w/9EcpfNDhy2iFYFnVZRB6f8JZUbsajKpt7DILLXRVUTmHaLFiovUH6p1QoDHml38LV95K - E4mUOkKIDDKFI2PKJcLrSYUg7wuNUng5NJfGhzxI5rmhxHJXhi4oCiEYW0JQc3q5HcvdZWwPhFDz - QhyJ/XBjkKsRjq9CwebXhStkooBfrf1idxpKjQO33UJYyEKYmEJYtULoxK79aUdafM9AZyLYJrqZ - S5nzDwAA//9snVuWxSAIBLeE72T/GxvazE8X97dOYowPBBUgegpaGBMK0godM1GUpyZtK6FRUccX - F2+v3UT0mGmJ4LXcerwviw+6TV3ElkhrHiqGEJaArtOaWRAbWhsbXlZaUth8zjFYrBMhGBlCEB2J - Zn1xQmdq5T6AssHBKbrdzHiNiIqbEMS28udhkCdakKvZkYiimWgeFq/NKP/tnHsIxSKE05qL0Kqp - tyOyqnZ9EZyjKZoVxr0QxHZMpQiqCMXPDu8nZQ3Evu/NGug9FDfLWkURRAiXpVAA2B0WgodqKKe1 - 93a85bcvmrugQFn9wBf8orkqioJ8PqYc5GngRaiqrCEXCh/qRPAx+FB9yoeJEC5CCWFahYx5Fj/o - N5dI3oGOir0dOn7eo6AVBc3yFCKOCeF4Uy4AWLdzJizcClYyHSRAuMg15LjpCPxFrbQu0lIgHFiZ - iToSnIVuyw0gBRNbRIhhHLvTrg1ZOuhHIdcUYqdu5cI91j7LZaGyAyF1bEjujR9oEUHRDaXc8I0N - uerCdleGB5hukeowoggIwaMk5k2B4Kg3WAEx5ZqPL7YymJQ6wfc6cpHrMEWE4Pug3XukXfoQykqd - Fu0l5It03KuKju41NO/aprtx3h25pkFN/5BXQhsWbhl+CMVv7keHBg7LUvrVtyDX5RSoDKneEmVv - eCVCd5CiIHRHTluE+1MDInHkjSTGFxcdabKnaeGnXn1wYJ+d0XC0/KEoCBNZ8d9MpKVKkEvfAFrb - o+x8yFYF5RLeHijyQ1ZVaRyz2yBv76NkkhsoPPKSTnnm+oFsSyyRQjQ60nXM5i8eCfIBdNwt70OT - T02PE/iPvHHOwXZ3uzlhF1DKko4vzu06QKKBs8xETVm8gJBOJVEct5o+tL34HPQvWmLnKoQXt3z8 - Aig80VOT5uPZnXUq9njyr0RpBbyjIHSa0OpAbeMfdebW8cUx/J5Coo4wS7rWNQKdth5cZ2lS7l+U - pXRNw4evQq/1WVDjU9tPKROlLG9eiayCnxnqYkzOhQH0vOihuXtgmCgY/SrI45I1GR2Hxbe+0Nvj - 3XzxIm8vJVh5n4rw4nWScrQXq6pb7s9bEZ6a0fmU4jSPgjbRGKzqgM3X5N3T+Y+BEFftlSczBN9F - /sWeQuFpQKdB8AnFAxQH073zkmP7AwAA//9snUtyxCAMRPc5DbLBMJucIBfJOrl/RS1cqbx2NrN4 - ZSiN+BiMaBUaVn0/+HbfyMajsuo1TkO6nO9PSejDjMhNX6e/avHzD6JdOmGzCVlHxn6gqlsArEub - UfNX7U9pvUKQlqPOewFaaV3TjNDXok5Tc9V82Rzdhm1YhBqDJUKq02HDvZWOKlFYnHuiivX4iyRE - zXwnidZgfnch2+FXYsRHwWH3kW8UD8T30EbockvClwdNXRrJrGspzp2mrjhPjo6lLwOc0lZdbKQR - OuRpVjBX24PVz8sEbiQwnA+eDzQcjZd5dYaJtkV6dDFjbiGbYApxltPZPL/eJcr9FntOoaALr75s - 1BZq9lSORzciDkZ/bLTYjiPXAJ1/aMxBTfEb8Q/p4hHHdhr1YiC6JN9Pag5uFA/EA5yQuKsNmHR8 - UKioEKO7pRXfKYwSSnbRrZsUYl3KSmYtpISj1gGETqu+z2ktJOk1fyqrMrukj8fV0EbHA5nvQ5d1 - WbApePz1QOacNnuz7qsLXtZo+fbipizR2ThHb8TpcWp1yrVcIS47N2JBRXHhwF4o5z4WnGExbkok - OZcZcR0Wmx4KaadMrw4Q7Ar8RmbqKGOJ8m3FV3nFF7ObzK59FFGu5fkdINEcwQ4w06XMGHIj/m1p - zrG1p5QyzF9HH51jW9kifk/n9fvx+fX9/vYDAAD//9Sc30/CMBDH3/0rLnuCYBy8qWmWkCgxRhiy - JTwshNTuHCVdS/rDhP/edigpIr7bp/buc/e9Xts9jpSaSiOo5UoWaLN4nUEYZKJVm81fVDHIZ4/V - s3JaUrEiaWc/IKXKkkBALjH5Ru7X6y2vR8Pud363Ix/hsQ5PY5FLioP3VvMzlZY2Ei1noNEoSSVD - 4N7GZZNUUyyeoETdmhXkC+gd4aQaCwETjqL2rvHsAZJj+C++Y8LI0w8Z/1SP0wQ2lH9ivbT/9OcR - vDrU+xjpJTuhDKiouV+lbg8roNpXJbx77t4EZ10YlPsd+sID2PvPjeuT9KwlZEm19OHdLSa5sztn - p2gMbTBboLGas8AZoGzD8QPrGzDWdwmorIEpJ/2s3jpjsQarYHgNd91H9DQTSWOZK/9usECq2cZL - OOEtnwAAAP//AwBu9WWWLfwBAA== - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Cache-Control: - - private - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - text/xml; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:12 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - NCBI-PHID: - - 322CC39D15567C2500005FF61B903162.1.1.m_1 - NCBI-SID: - - A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Sat, 31 - May 2025 19:29:12 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - X-RateLimit-Limit: - - '3' - X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '2' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&retmode=json&cmd=prlinks - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAADzMPwvCMBAF8N1PcdxcRK1gzexSEJ2cpENCrhhNk5I/BQn97l47yG3v9+4VfJHU - FFAUTN+RUCBZ4z5Y4UQhGu842W1rnCtc8kgpongW1KoPfmAcsxpIc9/oHKw1Ma1uNFvdNPvj+XRg - 9erNvPx2XHW9Z755uPLmPSdYt0FO0lipLEHvAzzai4D/xNzxbX4AAAD//wMAp4IJxLAAAAA= - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Cache-Control: - - private - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:12 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=39 - NCBI-PHID: - - 322CC39D15567C25000060F6213852A8.1.1.m_1 - NCBI-SID: - - A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Sat, 31 - May 2025 19:29:13 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - X-RateLimit-Limit: - - '3' - X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '2' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: http://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - response: - body: - string: ' - - - - 301 Moved Permanently - - - -

Moved Permanently

- -

The document has moved here.

- - - - ' - headers: - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Length: - - '326' - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:13 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Apache - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Cache-Control: - - private - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - text/html - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:13 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814972 - NCBI-PHID: - - 322CC39D15567C25000072F622F24208.1.1.m_2 - NCBI-SID: - - FC2329054D888048_9129SID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=FC2329054D888048_9129SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Sat, 31 - May 2025 19:29:13 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - X-RateLimit-Limit: - - '3' - X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '1' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 302 - message: Found -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=FC2329054D888048_9129SID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814972 - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:14 GMT - Location: - - /38814972/ - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=FC2329054D888048_9129SID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Sat, 31 May 2025 - 19:29:14 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Vary: - - Cookie,origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=FC2329054D888048_9129SID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814972/ - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAOx965bbNpLw7/RTYJRNnExMqaW+O93Kttt27I3b7nE7k52ZndWBSEhimiIVkuq2 - 5te+xr7A92D7JF8VLiQAghTVF9uZM30SWcKlABQKhapCoXD8h2dvz97/5eI5meXzaLiFf8f4lUQ0 - np50WNwhQ0hhNCAkzNk885MF49/y1YKddGZ5vnjS62X+jM1pN0mnvV/Y+IJOWYeQRcom4YeTTjJ9 - QmS5ZLrozlkvzr5EuAT+jucsp8Sf0TRj+Unn5/cvvMOOnoU1PfbbMrw+6fyn9/Opd5bMFzQPxxG0 - 4SdxzmKo9+r5CQugVRgCr/oHzyPnyTiMGHQDupzmIcuI5+mQYzqHEbykcTBjUfAiDVkcRCsN6Pt0 - yTrVGgLu20UezsN/sECrsDPYdpS/DtnNIklzreBNGOSzk4Bdhz7z+I/HJIzDPKSRl/k0Yif97rYY - jPjvOArjK5Ky6KQDaAU4MfMB4AxQLCYhA+z6QdyN/XHYjaN5Nw5n3WlyzfvTqvbNzc0da0+TZBox - j8Y0WuWhn3X9ZK4PwgCV5auIZTPGWg2jt1iO5yzo0f3+5GB7z/d2xr7v7R7t7nuHwd6RRye7O/44 - CHb2A793dnr28nnPz7JesswXy7y7x/zJ/mBM6faEdiG9QwT15uxDjuX4MLe2Pln/dvcG/sG2z/b3 - Jwc1/VMYlB39lNg8OvB3trdpf+8o6Ddic+sTonR7PKF7R/3DXf+gbso/MRrHewf7B7uDycTfYQ1o - FF3Mwzxiw6cpDWMC3JXMkzjJkzj0w3xFgIORyTL28zCBpUfkCg2vMS8IJxOWstgH9pdMCHDyKJ+t - SLYc/wplgCWSi+X4nAXHPdFEzWqFhR8lFHgdzU46E2Bj946fZXYTZL0gzPIews96c5am4Q2j+Yyl - 3jiJAu+GjTGre5NMJgOFLkzpyRQ/TbIsScMpYKk3LJcK3w5eUOC2Sax2AX3WZ8Cd/WVOMF/BDeeA - 5x6ktBqpn6RsmYdR1otxGOF82pvI9tSXLofVs9quNrmIp/fWJIfV45PKcdA/GnyA/x/DNBJk5fM5 - 7HkMqCdJyWkcpEkYQFG5WS8XAc1Z1kV5YC9N/CvO0HuD7f5ur9/vXS4XuKt5UNeDOZozz08i+B7G - 3tksTeD3zhHPLAFXMF8z+gz2VaAz2dv7woYHsCoY2Tv4sHdAvuEb23yRZCz4lmMjvJglMSM7P14+ - RkHGg1H3ITEJyPtk6c/4mgOaZAXeiNjNHeRFFwvYFXOs5vF+aI3d29j2DvjQhmpcB4MPBwPHuPpZ - TqYsZilFbgEjosFj/kkGfEz86xxkkU3HIeeMt3tvozoYmKPq93c/wP/187X7mOzCjO3xsUB2Xpm4 - 2w1LNnx/pNjftUa2Cw3sukcGM7KTBnxIu/lMn75bDka0dX+D2VWDKZbVC+j4RRhPYX18R37kciFR - EjNIujmbyhF88+bSOxxsf6uGosnN2JdRNh0lst4o1GXtTrmGpaA/TpObDBqkQZCyLCNjmhLOkhyw - NYalwfxysL23d0g10BcAiaXXjEAF8o7BVppCCzczFpNpAuMjE+B05OX79xeXJE/4F0drqayoNSV2 - KQ8heXzb8kSKbNtGw4LjcjTN56M8pf6VBilHLQU4Gu/v62Q6xW4taErn2RM1BwGb0GWUC+ZUbO92 - I0A8GlyxeXeMjdRRKRg31qmtt5gZ0/l88PRwe3u7f7D9YvD8YH8Pvm8Pjg52n56ene08PT3s9rvz - 0d7a3kg8ZTnNR8s00hpoUnN6WL4JdpRMRz5shtMk1RXECBRhoONlytZ2zAdeNPKhlkEFFr4KsquZ - Rn+Z5UBugsBqEBAYaKXjDOmlGJxrYIk+6ynLQRG+ZnUVlgb4ncPD/u4RMnx3ad6lzapgj0AKXER0 - xQKomm1YN0uWqc9cZPl4MferqL5MfNC6CYeS02nGee4yngD14AzAP2pL39KbCljmp+ECeZjW0GmU - S9acAZfjTGOMMvvXX34YHHyfmaI5tIMFkBviFPFKFAT7qagDDH3K02YU+M+YAcvJ8mUQgrh2E8I2 - gHUpyB0g1QOTyrGzSMaMfJNm307O370iIL5RQvMcgKGMh5wqoiloD/FyPmapWyGAtGuahskyA64x - T4BPw0oFXZ68n4XYl0x0JYyBsJYgPuaAPOjsIk2uwwA7ATnhdJbjuBIyS24IJQvgcglKeSh3gqYS - UFmRkv/7n//XGeqIvWKrmyQ1pn0xD4Mnau4fk4vzs36/v3M02O8/JkESPulvd/s7B/3erzD1oAB1 - FyAJdLdBRz0YbD8mlyGd0yvyE8x0miTZbAWje0xOgwQ0PVyQ+B14I/wzBRqRn4fbQsK7Zikmwbj+ - SHowjlUWwp4xXT0mQhc7B56Jg+4hAc2SIJMZWDoI6TSGZR/6BGVbKKZl6qDOBFWAyPyYvGBzGsG/ - L+W8/DmJloAGmC1IW85pDP+eU38GU0peM5rGHOw5tMSwoXcsAx0QtD3ySjT5R71r5xz0eRgEsF2K - gf4lWUL3JQaEKkhOJdN4TN68egkfr8/h4+zpK/ikUsd8BdMf5stcaJWis1r2GWd0fCk9DZOc+bOY - jxXqQdqcF9OKvw6B4tMVgoL2QamNsZvPn71+9ea5SR1pMk5ynTZC0F8+PI6TSRJFyQ18oSkgB/iX - rCatfytuhuQqrlb5AfVpZ/vuHUlwp+qmpCi+54T1LwZ07wzIwC9XRx2z1WTogNpZmGF5meIhXI+D - 8q4H3V8X0/q2nmTMB0miRmx5iGYRIbpRmo0zEGicRTFjhEtQK28SupSrgTKAmp4EyRwmvbIFOwzM - rto+TXWRIVvO58AeRpx2RmJinPU+wfo2O3DHBW7h8F8r/GFEDIXgB1vipXT5dsHiS4Z7EvnP89cO - 0yPPUyYw1N5Dn09uDxZfLHI1OvjuwzzaxPKq9baE1+VA+FpRi5jIfpSK77Mwo2OQkCAHZCAWrVC9 - voJZYRFDzGZCCY4T8h+Xalgg7PCODpvM6paR+77NyGiv6MWJJ3rSVXb0417ZOS7/6/QATIHjfPTw - /KPjVr+LHtAliGqpLuBoUiu5/On78lSgHgiabTUI23u9ne3eYHuwW1Z21gM8RyFMk66hXrxOLsnb - mJ+sOitJobuCu4sIKia8oruxuVstrCmuFNkRWqNr9sgWfLYZcdcgbBtbXP+oM9QPRFyVwixb6nX2 - iiq1iAalRW+kQX1RvKSm4djo687A2x9s73TEOX71EMenMZIwrbCQ9Ygr1ObjHjoDwCSNk2BFzOMi - ff0fB+E18SOaZSedYjl6YwpLBcgrDBypkm1oFW+EfgMsNsv4ps9LNJbxkLMUBYnYUlB6ITFjQUb+ - g17TS94s2utA07ySgk606pKLiNGMERYj6yMhL5LTK9hTgmsKuwkwAljTuCuiTTViADVjOaZNGDcD - ZX9QPexBF+WA1Ff5xWJFVVTBQGB6K7iykmegxbHYRrUbY63xdRaFizGoUKAYyl3rJWwfSQpKKjI9 - vhcAx0vwTE4gxcdtXw6e0JSRnM0XCWhzIWwZyxiwHUaIze6WjZbxMgeOqrrlR0nG5OA8kdUpJhH/ - 5H51huXKfvJumV2FPSknRbtEjpdIvBkw+SLA9ZGl/gnvwShORhLTI1cNGBf1cMmlSeScrmpp6AYu - vnvtOAfMPiwont5JE7CiNoE8g+D4P8rFgSqULzPqZVfhAiZJMYQvaZqHfsS8APhNGGUS6CWUwrWA - Mj1Z4DKQXIc3QktbHEoOJ8Ufefr8x1dvyMvnp8+ev9PTUV44zhjfQPXeaIxAJ1nMoj7s7AGKwnKc - yIbQJGrX9kSGk1dgqWkKAq1WPNR4Dy8fzkHKBXpothiX5yLi4LrpUI6ADHDS+bl72SWTiE4lM5XN - LYanMXCQScjNkFIHU2zm5xh+AJ2g0J2RKZqjYpS+jnsLDYSYcY1AXHiTi0ofenWZWXQ1oVHGKvkl - +UOHFKw8WZQFh1qV4wygOaZJNC7Zz0sQmR5lXJRfJUtyFSc3xz2sqI1SI2zxW+OwYs5LZrdVwYNs - VdItMSihxJHMViNB1usaYx1tyXLTZRggZ/SgLm+Ae3h5sK17MxpNLGJzz5uiTl9OGezPIR2No8S/ - AmVjqk/K7YiVE2iQ5NjJbnZtQOT0+gy4EWroRbpOtdbA9d6hYNAxKGCh/0KKAPKJp8P3QODYPTJn - FJXZ/P/+53+zYil0gQBEObPyONU7gn8vWMB3pXJ5qGWE0HLUWfBgOxaNgUrcnYdRlzxlE0CLASmb - AYGjkguqUggCPWrOmr1yjqJABjsdEil0Fr7A7FDY/3gHDFBaZ7AnXR0fxuItydj+sYa4siz6vImL - 13KS1kvMeVjC4lwURT9uVGtPTFhXwVHDLioDIWVc0MlnNOecCiUepf8B4aC8ODNpqsLacePn9Wm8 - 0umLwxM2Dt5z0CHT1QLYv7nzY+0U1sscbRiBHB8Ir5sSWFUslRsyfLUmAUk5ooB7VdTce5Ei1K5L - YGMAKU0JqWge8iRcmHa1M2994dqVIeOLSkZJ3TczAK0cfF30ovVjNIqSadIxp5aXpy28XkHdkSA5 - FEOMw3MQPJ5N5OCmuH2I4flR6F9J82SRqaq9eonnKKJmtVu3EDsKdwzsY9Y7nQK9rBA8X3FinRmt - 2pQuiIBaK0LKil+YM2GgFrfLZZzz6YJilG+TMhHxjnZfE8kys2r9NZiSkE9EK0o2Idx0dNKRJ8JP - YrQoVDCPtq0R8NplBe+qWzxzCHiAFccHzbsum9T7jwuy6FaLvnBAX3xhCUYK2iJZLBcSUV8YktAE - tg3qLTNcJbyy0OeULK+kn2pFrIKGABKw7AokElgb6LRehcGHtcSiI+7g2AQ0SwWY4SW3porec+ak - 1ylFMP6jnlL4sD3YpaBdRSbOMqop8atjzIRMciBHDsDdKs6ZKvKFpWTyYlLTlHNaXcSoBbagJcds - 5iEo1QWaK4JvgWSuCqpSOk6xx7Pd4aloCMTaXTVWgezKuBX6kCg8TroKDnqQMC710OwJ7HO9EiV2 - zwQ96fQSJejNpXLKnrbsDdeoyzlYRjoWljFfRgGUyvKi0BfHUTi0WMl8hfOleElP/Cx5c8bQcgRT - yY2BbmaMUzXC2yr1kykaGT6j2Ywr5sgdjnvQm4aeLZbjzO6Xn0SR2Oiy3jgcR6E411jdd4d528ML - NNWKk4KsTY+hbRRQyl7LjJ7KuO9uFg0qaiYqpU13cU9b5tXOhtMY0u+7r7I1vj3AF7uDx71lVKX8 - 8mvJCVVaIVIpvZSvEiEaxfQ6nFJxqKcLFtAZdFq8YitcOhIf8U02ktuuyIfs0Xabmzs91BNYT/pE - Zr0vhYefApJ1XJyJFPknHWglp2PuXnHS8fp8HlUH+Q7a1MV+q8tF67rQt7vAha+XyZyhDWptJwat - WAepa31gt36+2qz9ncKqhnYzZVpYN+idSrNodDsTtde2WTj1frm2oV1nQ28K8hRtSUpWxjpToD+N - WMrPtKqbMeVZHghKPptxR/lSfdA0Dctg+PzNsxpzoTSVi6Eb+NQX0bltoCSQnNx0qmtvWIi+0h3w - OIwXy1weTwp5o6NOXLJ0MudOUzeg7+V4DNoh1zRaQt6f53PY0a6Xv82evlqx90d/ehn1L37807vf - 9v7606uzi9OL7M/v/nr+9Ojp+O158jTY9fOXry5/Y3S2Q9Od9NUzXOuoAhLFtIBKhb/WSWeK56V0 - mSfqtAEk3cnEnFhhQS6/euNwKk9zPQ5XIsJDrACaVpyvIhK1Qgo/xSmwqVhxE6l3A9uZMr4WNmR5 - Bs71JKVI6BNywfOFAqLy5aIsfiuurBxsQZwSBwrBCCWJSjmFKdG2qemZ/7jUqvs5YeZaXtbThu+N - gR403UtkkchUvbYKrUsh0l6uclo4NXp5GoIYpxRpgOvJY5CXaCSQkz+maXGcz+V3PV2fDDtzaPem - 3KWUX4KjUyWuDUMB0pE3CVkUkOKY9Zg37GREUBwIKxjlLJ2rUwbeyBNukuAVh+oUU6xN2axYobKD - Mk36dSAskwIEv7oKF17I8LgRhDQvT9CSe9Lp6GVSxlmVhzA8dH7x2AcgNKsUT/N+WzKkUpWj8bgy - UY6ZgxNokxkp3mVO0bquvunWZoWR3tBBGn4Eg/bGuSU5nGGymlfRVnlaVs2SFhpd/xFe8x5KVynj - nFEpThLZQMthblNDpSOXkmgC4TsSOIFXtCIBTDQhjwMEoIqGZFyCLU+1DLNWeQ51ljJ0VeIbETeb - yYR3l5fcbCegSltelCRXJAqvGOHKS3lTHCE9ZbnyZsV7I2jlK8srMPAvesNAl31WVtcWiBwoh8+Z - 6QJNaA7u7DIA65V1Ey8tRGR5GNszDgpdPIX7A0BxT4NpVGrLj108GeCO1C5yKrtkGJmqX8ox+Opw - tOUgivLip9y072soBXTDXlce4BqUTOdc8w1jT6tWPcKiTkt/WcCwyVTGy7V8LteLSVujUfyMl6F4 - cdNqXuB7xqKFierNMFbFGfZwVG2SEN6XHzHDsFNTHTk6spwmarHscaORXjG4QLjaKE+t+Soyzn8r - RdBiJj0hPb5BqgmsyXctxoo8ZBdQAHB1o2dkak6AVhLEyWUa45akyV42e6tWmy+jPMSbfinL8F6X - 6jJRNCEcO016yOg1e0wYCM/RYzziCoCRCVlPs4NioQIqTAiLCiHEmFCxMbgcNRT5aoBIW6jrzp8r - J9AcsBi8gGuWrlIzVhjhOR9zl1SUjOXcJSQ20eZcTOsllJYkKzcrHacc5feCVAMSaQ13Y7QKyA+B - Vw65PWKfY3ELs/o6AJGioP0gTRZBchN7/LiwY0yBXtCNoybsl+KcqEnagDOcizIQvUdYS1YaofBk - VTBFKbE8XUXKaTK6oYaP4hOvbGKsgoWivBqcSigRWfIv5W6mI19p4EPNwmu0IKUVad8rhFi1aRsE - a82e2PDs4fM/JRW78gzZ1lWgPeFaFapSQVNpxXFhIpynfYUU4TyR48ZHiTVTWrdmSseVbnNWSPVy - 9MWvxOqoO47r/TCm/hU6157wol/tnH41eAH/1fiHQo7yEOXldnDpekZHBO8Ynq/IUy351oPUjOyf - dIx6P+QQz8qkVsNTbrzenMYUx7F+OVSquFHwJXRGliSyZNkjtGUL2UL/dIgbpnYvzzy9hF9DyKTe - KHwXPG5OFN/lquC58tK5KiUNZsWNZK2kv0xT1IJqSpoyjSaxcBAWay6PkkULShOeUVBDid7LKi+Q - oxypURrFFAewCo2CkEbJVMmbugQvXdw4M+gMn4l6RNYr5V1NwTWlvJJDl86+ZgnhdK84jNWCLkNX - ahbMu6KDWDYdmI8aMVYfqmhSDdXgai84EEPsN9UiBMVw7UgzjpwjgXgVFa1CE/puqQauauoCv6Jc - mccRLnpLbJhDdfH1uCdKiBkxS8sr+0MVNqmhJN5wGF6cv3qmlULjN461xkHHqfcYJXiBT2ardna6 - 6lXk1r04h9O1Ilv5qhQwtK9CPTHkUkPf0HOIWczlR7DOzD0bmBqd5NGoYYbx1JD+C+aM1qFJGCl1 - YDaQsLgx3jkEYYLXptfVpjrPkIl2leL0QGkDIO1jcKYwyAwNn6+p8UrZfuqqyWws7awOYGvr2k2q - 0wyMxtPQlXXFsEmjTLFbfbrVoBatw0ZQmTzYwyomA2Ee56ZwnSoUG3OBqnJYwV+faEtTGs+LBMld - beJTzagYNWIWmxoXgBJrHzC5nrysqyy54hf5Bn9+W/LB2uryREXUtnlsfS0Hq60tXOX37bvnZ9cg - XV3+uVrUZuymRFVLGlJX0qnC9FkyJ0AY4itag2Gmr+TyJYTh+/Dej1Iw6TX86na7NcVb60jrDSd6 - Kc0UZZpVhW2+YJwCg6bHfzNqfLQ1R9WWq3dwHhn8OlMM+xFxGDrwz3FLiCOkpvhmFqqiRqN55iNN - i8ShMTE8qXZOjK1fWGYd947wb0sqFKVBzIEUw8xVv5lvlWgzdnRNpUiZTxe5P6PqkiFqfIY7SlGi - G7O8V/zq8dAlizTMWPfX7IcUAySmJzA7EV7+/TqJcSGdiH/ORJUzGkWoVbrbF7cJg/sWOrhlrKDi - Wmmjisp7FTfQwuHxNm4jZojOleXayRvt2txYnmghshRU/4nl79vKG8aJVbNUcSkurOtihXWYpQMT - EykvuXc0wiuSdDYsSFdlDftE7Jzorpqz+ROiDC5acFqr7Xr8W81KzNc20eltDtWb0WxWgN4/PNrb - DsY7g/H+we7R9mCfHgZHbOJPdo/GwWB3/5Ae+f5kvD/os6P9SXDoH/YPdoIJY4c7hwd7+0dlD1pK - DC2ESdHdPGkQIQs/BOGz4dEMuF6YXRlE8D5pEit1dAmzvjHL75gfLkJkImK+T0VYxo7lMMFr/jv7 - QNHFiUcM18hHG0KZsKB4HA+c4L//Rr1/nHp/3faORt3vvL9/9+9lAvz6r672s/v37/6tQ+b0Q8Ti - aT7DW/fbnQIJDzUFGBCltRwPZe+A7ku+Ud0B10Zf9aT7wfdgb7/jRvP9obswkD6gBlXTkhmboZUW - RdygXNqH4l54pCC+dSx9q1C1Wigxd1TRmuxlayvJRltoXus0qyrRhLEfLQMGfBqj4Ir4P07jpbGW - /Bnzr8bJh46pK7wSwMg5u3wpYgHyoAcoPqjZdrWnryh3vrHCnEWaSPyWMBXVO0ZjUbu1NovZqPH1 - K+RcUob9t+dlWkrDHenlpqcIHz3Yl/k5wv7rSfbLy/PgFP/Oop/G+dvFr38aLM5/nWY/fri+PngT - /PWXo+Wrwp1YCzSrFA+lZxQieJomaRETQ/c+E941Rj5RtYByw0AeuKiq4iSC+5QVHWjLxj6Zqg87 - w8Po+o7DfL1Y3SkoP59mxcm+oLoH0vVNNSnbRMnnPWyp5a9zmCiqPLCa325G7qTntxGUpTong4io - PUDzg94QhClyb7Pdwf7+Dt33d8bB4d7u0eHEHx8eHhwdHsFXFhyMJ4G/uxfs7h2AYL43OOyz3T6d - sP6O72/vDXaLfqwxWZR8RDvurbda1JUybBckxJjsyRTFMwy/kLU3aejw+Sm0WAyFfUEnqKYKyzTi - +DzpfFl3mL3eSLHTykgBciia17SzcWWo2JHuululqaIOf4b1YQ2uPe0uRb0pwyyQzSkASwu5rIhM - IF2+Qx750EATNyb18AajM79nQKBBgA5+joISTn0BE5DPjaQe8A8FM2Y3VXDriplApyz31Pkb2kRK - C4qAVptvghFXrDwQ+PUO4Yr2dI3LgRetONYWnrS8tFlcx3+aJA6LXsXXw3E1U4Y4/JRHRvYxvz9L - 8BmwaZrgfWfp6wDrKBEpcsWVPlY8TxT3+JtspV6FlxYLFq6Pkdep7AuNqw6IplLBsfpcxSQmy1KV - EhKhrsobbYAV96yGNu1NsCw64ugZYW/csncjkobqpgGBX5qLUkWwLmfnXidK8Y02s1VbtvWU1beG - elRh5/58ZrXo8IZTW9aTuxiNiUprM8vi2rCuUNn+Nyg6qpsgjkh9tTYQYvLzrJBDNUbQYoDl5nA3 - O+EbjEaxSpaphpUnJToM7OgXuYgWC7acVkGIzo2rLNS4HrRxFRXqxQZX6cLi9bf//vq3ZZJ//zWd - L74/+TqCb9P8+//q/f2PxRUrDBgkgs9zugB6BsAY+RjvGPGIfpgnQjFgSDeOLY7LJ8QFXDvTsKyV - RXq7tVRZRJxLjVzotNZQnMSjCb1O+KOZegWX0cXaC8SWnyeJh0EkSJ2OLWQtxL9Dy7ZIa77M8B4v - ifD6eT6DZQjY0DBdVVH0r60WlFPIu9OqKrhHKxvk2SxBbZW2WEGaKbJ1Hyye2WiUrF8ideA2Ye2V - Y2nerJMonaT5zb998+jL9V189G0X6Oqbb/EWOXn0AmkZw8E9+pb8oP8kT8ijgtgxRevII81abdkf - a6gfn85ZceOLBz3i9H5X+v9ZRKLlFw5pYDNZEiyZ2pgQ+vE41fa48v7oUMa1he4ROqUyAlL9qnHv - WA22rE3tWPU2LJf9CrZfl/mqerm0mn2rKyq10oYdPiQIdEVX4lC3m2xqw3LYr6oatNOE5TBf6ZKQ - o4ZlwFpj4tArNZqwHh7tlvFKM1w5Y9+2s/AYlxbqTTy1xe7LxmM00MrIU1fDtvK4rmXcs5nHuuVh - mXpKQ08tFutcU5or3Je5p0Cp3EyMVi3TRKs6Y5rjzfbwH+iBUK1ilA2gN1OM8qvbltwlql4vrsYN - 05IZkMqufncTUAFqvoKm7mCe4fW1rv5OnXz121ggQ1dFyQYLkHGIWlp9LIil3EPq7UESiG5sMLAp - 8KdjXJzPzVeemahu99npus1CGQAqYSZ1sdmGUL0ZZh29Cx5ijkBp1upX9SqCY64s/H0kYa1YtPco - q60jxE91zlgjpxXFzUAgWhklPIkxPtBBoNyjdOrb5DBQr9fyTHCdTGHXfOCjQc5aPxsXYOx5YPqH - Oi70OEuYspbrZo8mHhlQWglUdTVsgcoo11qgaufc+xfkHbwBGbxHyVIDdbfKuE7kRFOdMNVcYa0w - Vdny5XGTAdY4iNJzqhIDsmFZCyMfKfnHSq7WM9rbTOAQlVj2OYkXd707VKBCPtJXa8+tFN7AH5Sb - 45KJQZnrXRZ1J0BTcuZ/LiOw/BMTUB2eXa6yDpylXPTvLKjcFex0hSI7/dOai+/fd9XAEA9Hdkc/ - YvnODV/fTfSCRAB4oK6JF/2ozLTRPUdO4eF73FPQ1/oRgriW61AquKqGZrPYVWf4HmCowGt83HXB - n+r0AJMRQ9dT0K5oio/G4zsk7b36Oc745GDY06r36y/JMuLSqohnxt1vyHIRUPm4Lx5qyoHI6xs/ - aFNoOeardhxbE/eZE5u1eNFwzILxqrFrxyA8o6+YI4Dg8JLzIElZPBApeYd6CHkqArIBdfHKNerU - 7ZUmQ+dxD9NbsaxGjimzHTQucST5jwAilKomnWpN+66Dh7+wrJWm1YQH41WERGihRfjBFjiKkyYU - Ye5aDMXVtxTWICZuuhPRGb5JbqWAKhJuwYp5LzKY1WAZsfUxxJqZNrEibK7xc5eXxp4YI6kMV/CT - 6n0dqu4UVOZT3kZo6MQaHuWNk6iMl0e+KaMFSbciFVneDmPeKO1VQ5wPfR4FBFnxt9XgfEaQhXZm - nrY8uoEuJ7hD4dsdbW8r4E0RWWXtTJoXvxvajBOYgzQowtAUx4E19az1Yfr6zwFFM+TR5+KLy7u/ - UumGsSus8wv/t1WVAMhuhaH7Q3eFNbE22k6ygQI5NjS8hViB2jtWzTSretBEQDeY619mIexvUOWH - W851TcN1E948s5f4sDKgnEuxYQoijkhpNV1ADVZlkdKq8vsly6zaMqlV9V9YEFcAFIntejBbppUu - yLRWAF6koVVdpLSqfIlBOG3cy7SWi8Wo27YaLkurqkz6WCtOMIaNF5ys9tHXm7vddvzVrNtqJd5i - /d1q1d1urd1+hd1iXd1qNTWtofuh5nbkmjK8Ed+eTt/x8jLi1W3lAKvRdkQqKzXi91niXy7njXcS - a+q8b3knsVL9tNWtxNpq79teS6wuq+fPXr9687wxWs1HJCRxSN2ekPhlLJqTeZLdmo6sNtvRkazU - iNs+RgdA9bzVTOx1iouywz1eLWtVr78NzWxvUAHfZR9sUmEPKuxtUgFdDIbo5rhJp3ivGqq0IkOj - gvuebGX+eUSOcALatYxG7NbsHcUcKn61VCu6r++DywgufUCKMTnWBLtmMbmZMW6HTRkaaONH4tVO - NIlJW1jTirmV7CMjKSL/wXDy4jZc++UvwyQgN2vNAt4uhGBFsBoanlkbM0GTsVbrhW0s539uE0JD - BRc5aXUc1t0K+jczk3+yy7oPFZdLWM5qi9UF5ioimwvcPdDhfOW8c9NgXIF8dWKDoFzu02d3zQc+ - mm83Nw95NF9edbVjDDvP5htLfbzAm8XFK4zfxt9nASaAj1aWN75lBGTxEHcyyfEMVyKkGiyrcVj/ - CtP5zxKmU3d+s8Nemt0zY/72PuNt48FiPKg1MZJrYvMt5OPGduTnhXpsR4sTpJtsLfbgW24vzUz0 - k2wxG0/jx3IES7PMvcfYGevdvu7X/QrfCXvBmLrX4XC9sntYt0M4y93a0QqhTaBfppOVnupwlirf - ehQeDcrF5fPhzndxWMHBr/N72sS/SU39nX2bjOhrb1y+Rmu9n4qx2dmKApt8nWrzxfQ9emSn/15d - nHCgUYgvCN7mSP2W57hFo+1V7TfL+ZilSGPcSkPk6wQ6qa01vVWbrTW4lUXXGM6GextYytoV1axx - Wti6Yb9dS8LEtoFxbSOz2i2sY5+53YALWZ+V5aB8bvMj2Q+gpU1kO1gbLcW5iojyz2gk2GQblnwl - voLUxWrdzizeqnT58OE++xpy63ZXY/s0hDJeraPvntp2KRosWaXWfJkgNyvVheqC1TBY9zKceujW - LfKVCJJEropXL+CtpwmbGqABV3YRBWVhnh+fQcKdBfd1F8S1VzjNN3hEiriqqJLmWKAIwyxbpxm+ - ay3h8dc8MUG9w9ko22/JT9c7nOqN3gKYdrFVPqF0Kory66p17VjMqtDyVLL6LV6EqnsXUGdfbxcM - yQKLE3x0WntFRprig3AyYSm3XuWriFXi39wl+AI0VltGf4zRVQRkuCJyrbqzoWazV2TYr8tKRUYh - ig8JxJdo7iwn3wKRr1DhctIbEXasnuVcaL65dQYjtJ+RPuZvqZWco+dnhT8hdzZMrlmKL0bxl9d6 - sGH0jJQulrceQizvzsv2tTeODLI3iN7MCsbl41I2pVUaMMJ01NObESAaX72QjSFlna/enD19pQPq - NjMmPaCAgxdWH0r0rxpZ1FpolfiFcqDOu1vrqxn3gz7e+4DyfTi7l6FRSo2lkZj1FwYtmtaoURKr - iiSnnqdrCmZpdVECknypYSwOE4zjdbpqCAv59GDNEqo/Sxg2BouU0/yvaJEPGC3yFmEe7ytu4yez - UG0Sq7H5hgl/D/TW0f4kfX8+cRmbWbhRqXZXMEo1R2ZcE35LQ8+6iIzl46x3nYzfaezFjzdzZRTF - dtO3YdTFyqO2jSEW7xpdsd0QPmZcxQcOqFgdUVHjnzyiYtMKeYjIip9xSMXqyqpfO2sCKW60gO49 - hOKa2Ik1rVss78GDJ67nzfcRRLH7sYIoFmb1zzps4roIPNUn09efAPw+oiKuI7cWcsAmcRH/FRLx - QXDeIiiiIl5u4HXQs/g0p2cO9KMIWlmejLRmU6fc0CtWTgQhtWruopPTq4rUakwfVhhRhbEc90uX - 6UO99S4O9zJpYJP2Q/66kHTz2ipxGLAJXUa5KmW/caWV9JcpGmLrSiptkE3Fhq6dIhRBIjiWOHfT - p12i6YxfTiZ6F6ukI4c4UkM0iil6sQqNChtQvXHpmagi3c8bDUxBmiyC5AZUbKGFu2w+cjItqNop - gi2oM7wKYr8xBVjWnu8yei/d5J3Xo3lNLUkNRm7/QiBWDn/SGBfmgKPqnOrsRw1G1eRO7OJEQVsP - ggLVW27tn05zvoNduVS0/t3rcr+tW+LapzzX0dCeJT4iAs8PlEdU9bCE17qcCVdaFeFTM32YQLjl - PuNUv4y5yT/w0BhWHNzIGBPFHoy2oSe9Xg68AoRRfKewF3IKgSTG8h9Qvzl5mgJZfDXYhp0fPucJ - KAZJjE/0rjAxDuBzsoz5tNAIfgAhxchzr0UJda7iswx+JRP4mDEa5TPMlA99Yo4yAvd6NQbg8kBC - 8gqFA0QPHzopv3pyTLJoKnQCGDQIIsAY4gStx0V2TtMpy086F+Ic5FJgFcgBaJJj37tIFsuFKi24 - CM8o7PxAKu+NJlucF1XES96ulSnXhBrPkIe3EXEyaqYTLX0T6rNxklzxOeVtpvKf7mK2+GF5cs/o - Vu19THy/MNu8Z4RPxgauxfrVHhbRlzLv8oIBJ4qcJ9zWvuRwQ1FDTG6KEZbwKsWNLTuDSqOisNi0 - a0+gzY5XNhidl9fuNeLvQrVo8H/7Xptr8zHAAFPSTYOWf546oFZt2ReXJHdWNu62pIx/+oZzWkF5 - zxbQyi7ojgalgOEt0pA/D6qNTokbUKF5Vm/rm1AHR3NOGAmKdAkkclaxe7YUslU/qS5fLfFVciMe - ssfY9WJaEAF3NYDf4ZRiDAwpyskEFOeMeblAVVTLtH0TJssIRImweE2oZgMFYjUByQ4XAbPLDZWf - H+ibJr/OVrx7KX/zSlGoKkmvZvEwZ6ngKmfnrQq9yZ5w5fg9dpRwQxqhy3yWpBlo37p1oUodiMUR - AKlha6aXtaMBPk0ma1s/SiVS2cO0JPi6cRY3vu84uFKy4/kKbLshNQwP2NMEtL/cSyYeCkEpxpWz - huoqs2bYZ7IK90RVYLMccsVNqbshw9khgZjmhm9FAZNwugQwNlZk8hpEvJCV7zhi1ZgYpAS6ZjTN - o+JCCpdP7YGVOWvG9q4EccfhaU2KEZagbzVlc5bJcK/24MqcNYPjLxkLEHccnNakGFwJuuUMNg92 - mtI4rwxUpK4Z5I+iKj7YDMoM5+Z3HKxsVgy0Cn79gNVWqrsDSsW6kDvxfiHf/5CzJyDrLyKWw4aa - TCbFKY8+TOUdXgzODC6olVwIK7Bf7Lv11GZqysXm49h3TG/wdvDWPYLehsubEN1Ms5lf3qbnBauS - XKoexnpYOl8oWcJteqUvwnL9re/besiK4qvE3gi9vA5w3ANaFd6uyieW+6kqOXJOw9KerZz51NPH - uhusShyKDm8d/8HzSOdFGInTzcUiClnQIag5ZQQ9pEX4CU7zYQbqVRCmYp1M0mSugrJ63lBAGjOf - LjOm0ifJEt95j5kMVcELVlAnP49xfYBGbIqOovu63Gbg2SnyinCz6mflap32pLzbe1g5h1YUMuOX - 45V5BSBLlqlfytiGQ/CvkBfT4oyGKE1TeHaWRzbmGFQtp57shqzKEmcdQ1GWNQ3ztlFaMsyLKLnE - 6bQy6TiMA/bhpGPdPrMOMyqj2fQUQ+fI75PpFJiowh4BVrTk1+8lbOLua/0rEBevofzbWN3M143O - zqmo6uI2/ou+Vb5oJuUSijA0lL8Nu+/6YTrdHut9HZW5u1Tw7O5z4pAOY0UwVHmLE1+XEhYqbu4y - adhzmmaEzNH7AZnqyVeDAeL7O8A3fP1q7yk2/tXeM74nZrB3n2Ds5+LXiN8sO8GYzW73n4cCbpqT - RHiPMB6JsY/UskFrPrcmcJjFYhqPU3Z9ouiqhUuUaGCtG5RqwIlmy9BRtD60Csqo1bBtCPO+kS2O - m5WDmmPy42iO/eYHb60pAJBJXNgEYCMJzD0m+zdpE3oXvkugNVTBpbDvTvkshZzfA42sbbtu1tQI - PvbsvXl9Ts5E022mUPpXyJm85dQBkFGeqHA37grcetXk16eFqj95VI70b4ifv1cuBd96sRh9XYPv - 9d0oHDSsDOkPcFk+lFKdB81DUP/UzY8LloZJ0Bl2y/NCLdfHO7SD7cEuOacrsrP9ff/om71vn7Dt - ne3tg8F2V4WTljuY1IxsicmCKK8LJaE2Jvj1hPS3u/2dg35P0mt3AZtMVzWlgGkBrK0PqyXQlzDk - Z7rCSDE6PbPSh4Lg2GpAbzXYXbmpfNa3BEevtHO6+qdEM0L4KR5BAVc/wVNCujy9I/rZHdFO7lAp - kqd2RJ3ZbZVa63Fv1jdsxsY4jEtesI6YJ9VB0e0tVdwh7eoFFeQtZxHdZmsGQdfyuXs46Wicggs8 - lYv7xkZ7maRJks1WIKl8d/kT3/x8AXQEIlNxx0ivb2yosmyxfRolW634ymoXEGuBqXtIIZ3TK/IT - 0UbQGbpS+fLNlosCZ5NJGIndohCQqjj1oAYwuAVNuS1/+HU8zhbfqzVN64AVholnWDXnZlAgr0tc - pBloFtlj/B6D+BeQn+PwGlQ2oMYy8TE5O32MOaifYS1BnqdzYCs+7XYKs2Qhy+o96HecswNFKuyO - kL6VItgcDHtYLlx10lGs6GLVblU/+VrRbwFrW2/NkhFGHqdmqxb9aTm+TE8379fqnkYKjMxC0T/n - qkaxNLc0koJ1zw/e8Cgriuii1Fgs3UfpNTaUJqWn1o9OuBSxvHjlqjjFQ+9c1YR5ayYMvAVMb/iB - R1yRyNQp1z7JfM475eDG+sHplsWK100ZxkYTaHAZKSpIqgmwU/5tlTNqtGLDMTW4Sn6hqLf91zU2 - bS2ZL7nUnr2JP41GjT1OncHJ3+ZJnHkQV8E5rxGFkki1RW4iwlz+VTGbbFDcYJNXbNUZ9gVDIA/D - zarvxBjYq32e0zmXpbTUIGfoX7bsOQEKzcNJyKrUpmcNKwRkveqir8iyIlGuWFuVIob7mYSEzlhP - VIImFUoRAFgSXmqQIqD0KAyDYvcRCiHBe2eKsQAQXqtgroasKXBVjmTj0c399kM7axob1WvrQoDy - qxmNI6olS28cwwXHFlIEpwKJplTxy7QT6FC/3985Guz3eRYU4/4akF7Aq/ggVZRVwEBPAs3whwJZ - umVUxSGksJHh9WFLQxxZIndY4k/BloRPH2ZOlUbRYk6fvX31Oc1ok+JjTDH02zHFaJCAwXeTdNpr - AnWnmS2aVlPR1NItJlrxzy2HNGZqLZ4fhYtxQlM5tUT3mHqFSgUoV2eqzFadj4xLsitt+eVvlzFf - +/Y7UQO3nMgUozQOH2r1NXMFleCa9Ts80JFCj6W3lNpejRrkNEfIEBqlotMt3KX0l63sxd3GIqGs - 7OU8K9tM6044ZNc6VFlGCcjNwzmrNLICDZS7azPMxghhg11hkjnuYQog6P8DAAD//+xd73LjRnL/ - rqeYKOXzKhYp/hXJvV1fabWxvXeWvbXy5aqSSqlAEiLhxT8D4Grpug/OY1xV8jVV+ZpHyAMk7+An - SXfPDDAABiQoAVqKhsq1JsHBoKe7Md2/6Z6e3WjTUne0CQupCsO3QaQ96ZaITNMuhzgXPD60LDVG - 3UaLjF9e4BNKSLS9dQYmfYPFdTY0T03U/Ck3cm7ecJsu0lSCuHI1s3YGXLlbdeBLyEADwSjXVVCd - VRdd3mrG80/XH9qn/ShHaeC9L1tSjnKCKLMv5UgVxVGZ7OH77FHJ747IJgtrZ4b8zpUil+0em1hS - XVW/n8Xxpha+tpltLEc75b/kWxfsZtG1zO9oOTraUprxKHUlXbhM855uOJZj8xKJdmbbskySnnDK - 5zs8To6D4tsdQpJDfjhPKcthI/VNmkOT5tCkOTRpDk2aQ3JDk+aQlUOT5lBVmoM20UH5vO3jbuEx - xfQXx8diwjZmImwPedEtKWSRjnY1uQxNLkO5XAZFbR8zmWFbULHo//HdTzFwXMjrvOeSnVJ+a6Hj - 9MejrCCy0WKFU024eOvomnBxEy7eG4k24WJtuLjKOHE2UqwkEvLYKm0cEzvLNh2+wJNsj5vTFQ77 - dIWmgFxTQK4pIFc64Ca3Hjzd+nHJPuLU7B9zgHZAp6ujSFuSHMeZhVhK/RT+F5sfeWpzOiVU81FP - T3zAQ3wiXR4/UTo0phakqS54Cl1InCA/Q94F7u4Wp9GKgtVTzHb6PEznM3kB/UZ7/OXMZjjo/VNz - xqeFkC3xGJepCRNiGK3mFjj/NCPivYY1R6SFJQKoUgRiL/YsCE9ur969IT1lRkQvg9hBbqNfxlw6 - k1CbRYXXPoAKe6uQzU3HW4ClXgIEbLMflhbSEnJSLBc4tUKoaNg4Sj/wPlhUrgJ+sRZLNLYwTVMd - MeYvTddDr4zB7bgV3xA3wldMAQO4Ss+OWdVGJi691QImfmO2BPqZbRqBi/0/u/r2BMz5bOlaP61M - wR7DDsArWXPa5qZve2teLjxczZaCbwBjXe8D+EJ4m2B3gPz/gF+x3oQoMA7jvPOC9232F5NupV35 - QFuAdYWleJA90Jnn49B9k+p7Y2HtCL8vQCIhAGV7jbIxHapNvMRatsBeGPFc9HFKCW/WLRfmAoc3 - X8NkAwzHlnQOmnwc5zDSy6cKfKmNqYcVy+KbQXl/pLrUaxwJp1ZKFiWIyUBAGycDewx9UkclCw99 - dK68S8sHTbNtLBv+08rg2GHOSV6ufQ8eG3KkPxXJfCkSkB/y9gg4DIP+YBns6ts2+2oVIDvRRJ8S - 9QlVRcl/xgyIDcVQQSxIN+gf3hIt8V5U9tCMkmdiERKQ7xzeAByr56/4uECTUAlwFKLT0PxoCvbc - WlQnAq7NghW8U9bP8CzLseC9sUjCeJuaiMhfWCTLMUDIlL9o0sf4jYLnL6hefCDSjHj9dR8jRPCa - gY6A+qBMzXlbmDv/y2Sa3TARFWc86JZOstuAlDU2+aQXfmJg/XWA7/GxKJ4uv/LHXcrvz9n//Bct - sTO5BtpWF0HFtGEh4xg6v8DzGZagl2XowPyBjwMuAwgKJgaTz4m8yo/H3wt+0CXo6KXnOPjWXkT8 - FhTmt9bMdENQozuYpZZU1c4Cnq9cnBMDi2pnrPD3+EFwF9fhwIQXYL7iUQLUX3fNQAbWyjmVL9uc - CABdBtXG6YqWNelmno9BE8gMy3REXHgkujQn4cHwyXLwZDBkpfKdILisD3SW/HB2nAXQbGHcJB6d - bZGFWYGHC8MkSiSQgXaKSyf646va+JvwS4jTN4m1E4tKr+M7REkgX8R6Mq5XvmqNUJLCImCFhn9r - dTDpARxl7XvcKL9up/MTQCAfHdsNn3/kwEdZ8Lnr8/WAyWRy9pGzijd1HLug4fjsyoiW9M/Vt7K5 - 341biwKQtHq0mrYolQLnF1lYj4zW3IShBKRkMEe4Hk1ZZsSNKGdFyM9XaAtRpF/u1BSQeZszUTPV - SxbVgHiCU6qK2UZJ4V9S5kxOQLFoCh7DF8D5qqsNb1SozVLBP6p4CPOMSZ/EoU+cm+FsCXMq8f6N - A9P/13QgV/q8y/TEyJ+epkUEqvLe324P/56m9eJu0B0A7zOkmq4wLVA1WX1zHrJGtrT02U6phvTu - QvPVgkbU6ua8VCUEx0esr9paJtEhteaJzh7Wlz+LVz6nlnuWit0uOp1u+0c/n6mgMkV44n8ONAfq - ctyE+TIwS5vz6ToexMzgwE3Hm40ZATIdGKXWurPmeAjMeSaqmGu3NNGs4RnT55sbgt/88hheCKYL - yPD1FmdGgRxlWbeoqdRQaJ1jqyaE9sJyFhlRR0tw6o8VZtMFF9wNvUql6lTxERUoH8PllBq0ZWHd - FjxQYS07yyk5mqbsNQccK2XsJOzj0u8yE4rJ1SP3wEznXEPu0zvqVI72vHBzs6h8BVjmjeDHIJem - Q3kReQfbd/wWkJjxCAQ5mVOhUz0cFYW45EyVWpUBTM1I/ug/oncfgpeHqDSkNEW4EfEVdCKA2a+/ - /CeLTWQuHJZzonmrjO+curyDUFrcZ9TL5t78rZlhKciG3rmKWjleB9fKc9sb2LqFLULrMc0BiHvj - MhOQvBSUGsYtLwN4gnwTEudFsQ8FlGDEprJXh1soX5vAXY0sa5HjA0UoxMdmBp24JRdl4IlRwJeX - cDVCrDgQtMZFjpmHgXb+PXxvUjYbPcm6XbPLt4TwYphMi1pwm1hFsSJabMLT3xSkDKAbD/EF33je - xlVbTpVkEoJMQP8rhDWkJcLXDAH+w0NxFUZZuHj2zQkxlQBnsnAiUKePqI7go2SxGS/nAX/lugk5 - 6h8Mu80uTlDJ5XfWxRFY6L/7vIIjjYp6NgGvAV0LM147CSVbcHWPL4rNxYl4yG25NgNuLy7s4Olz - YWa5J1mHmC1BxJ7tLbA9LZYEFCSIFw3XHJzNTB9PhMN+kkPhhp3P2uzVCa2F8KUvictwTD11sSyM - dZBA+ltsmVof27xgxW9Q1sLa7BI5KB7VR97RGSBzrjfKk+MHQx/5tRilS1BXF5eCVqHsA9pq1tmI - 7Hilrb1lckpmodwq8VGu5SrZDJCbHZ4sStGmIBWgFI0/9UlRSq9mlKLjzc4oRc1A0LaTKGUwLotS - CmFPNSglL+a6UEqB8tWDUnplUErvsVEKqkd9KAV1qkEpOzjdPTD+Lrv6lvmWb2JwF22NiQFXmFkb - aFKGS2l/lkcF0elS4lK3Rri0KkQk4OLUiUa6B4RGqhLdA6VGTimG+C4IUrxiVIyesoGWZhZ7LAJv - 5ccxJCXtKwZU5JBTAMdzsbo7rsRT+fVIhNM9NxUWT1z7U9bjIaQ+Meb6n64ySKjn8OC778FNGOXN - oZ/3CCIsPJdWachj9KYVe9U0Ek/GnWlI/MFxPzIgmoTYxYhjyi03Szl02G+c3PRf3snVOUyswMnt - 75mT26/ZydXx5h5L8cNyTi6MdFDSy+3X6+Xm5VyXl1ugffV4uf0yXm7/8dfihzV6uaRUjZu7gwPX - 5yky/GyR2LKS1W+c3O080hU7M+x1aPGl3cRGV+nhsqUVRpjE54R1Oru9A3J2KxFhBZ5uIjk6H4io - 4ImbqWXz9MJxxgkGB9f8YAZr1cWFH8BrZUMqr8bQ5aF4Ang98JA7Iz6WiPfC0N2HdoHJowpY6gyT - OK1I+t2SUbS+nKws/+9/vwAav+zg1sLplzxnykavTvzQ5T8gKTKagB0rTnTs1GNKEN6P6ZBhJD17 - vOJjdqUbxSmx+DP509Jdx7kBPL8WcSPJhMTIQbfT6Xx1+ZbdmTwbJ0PwS9bvtofj0wy9cL3Tngx7 - XEmufeCNgynmXiDzJvHZnfaIknkorS1Zmk9W/sMNMuSSc+fSt0cXfm7NaMkdUdUcc7/UnMmURk5N - PDKbcy+680TmJuYuttlfkEnX796+uj7ND3fU7o2HmuH22ueT81OhDcUDngzGlDDsUvCFSF2Cbb4P - mRexusb9zwzn8uI7TAKe0/aPHPUdIlBDfK8/2CaryfichdbCRQmE5clEJfruT29a766VIJaJESud - Mk3ao4FWmcaj0Wks7mIizztjxLs2PUalsUFy6b88ktOBAlaA5AZ7huQGNSM5HW92R3KTkuGKHZBc - YbtqkFxeznUhuQLtqwfJDcogucGjI7lJnfGKBsnRnTuglEGD5B7Co7IwoPcEkVz/gJBcJSJskFw1 - SA695xjNJcGZZJcU94BdTayEb4MLTPCJaXNWDr/xPY4aSNNtD/S4oNVpdwcjCawoB8qK8JjoGd9R - LRK9pEhmsSOeZF/Z6/T+PIHcMrvbiiETkNAb9BOf3gDkAFOgdh+egG6EEBC+JWzLjXnca3eHE/2o - YdBw54JEUN14N4Or7mBSbowKTibQKyGRki6Xx8lcFQQ63KQJo/ZAj+X7vYmCW6vVhC1LBAOVMRLX - Q2db+SOl/+svf9uJV0hPDlpnIWw64a8YcZ8Pi1g6GPa3rxcMuiO5OTBZ3XDV7MbU4AGNSME04HcX - 8KvDUawA/GriLZ8U/A5rBr863tQaxiybrFfYYzXgNy/nusBvgfbVA36HZcDv8ODCmE223k7AbtiA - 34fwqCxy6j9B8Ds4IPBbiQgb8Fsd+BXRS+S9EsEEVGtaH6Cl3IMiOKLAXWRIHNlUkKAEwKLyCa+k - QmWeNLCwN2j3tM46hji3R59Gk2HspwM3QZ7zFRX+IW+d1z2JI5MpB50AWlHMsd/udrVUjcalyBoP - ++mgY0qrBXTbqm2kY0LuMfog/SJec3S5mb39Xnuo4y+C/M5w+1Cg3WAw1rF4biosDh3DtgtCqvx9 - 34Tm+vGWrBz9g2G72yteKhmd42si0GpCHGBVQV4Wr23GvtjleTcN/IxpiLu4cqNqAF7qLw/wdFiB - FQC88z0DeOc1Azwdb3bfjDUsHd3sbYGCMQopBILVALy8nOsCeAXaVw/AOy8D8M4ffTfWsN7oZm/Y - ALxdwMt5VcDjItkCzTdW44JwKfxxqLiwXtaiw/bVJWGQJCzES/SBm2HARM83yET17twaHhAKPH+g - rB4qJ6yKIHDKKdYVEEDg8iT2qtHnfH1CbYXvGiMfhrEMM+C+pGMa9FREV3Fq5RSgKwBDvqNfVnOU - JKV9fzwwOEyKMLwFzzQE+V9eKsSmKk46RhRYH5n5cWaaWIPAoEKTgGFtqrn61//7t78SVDnn9E2t - 21WQRIewO6AWK6N6oUWlInCkrrngtQyfWW3AF5hMqPjG4QmbW4EpasFiOQ879Ag2u/CQO68VGo6P - pURbEdWGw81rsrYBLw3Cw0M8l3FmCH86J7mkFEScXitRKRXWdglyEigWxRUQ3/q81jFHXp0hbXlD - bBtzhRRCHhoCeCNFhwBjvmEFd1Yoy3NaIY5UZllKVp3GfBLIycNisUA4h1+c4WF73pajS8SsqR8q - eBkXBuH84nodF+BtSdyNxW+NqWVvKDq6D5gkKnTS9gWX6FxcVoBLRnuGS0Y14xIdb3bHJZ2SuGQ4 - LNwWl4Elo3phSV7MdcGSAuWrB5aMysCS0aPDkk6dsAR1qkElO7jOI9oqzq20PGFL3Zk+M8Mm/FSe - V8KTkZ5DYfHtewT17gkbzg8INlQqgNhLTIq0VxFYIkBAi+JaR1D1/tBP9m0vQtdPnK2IeVay+Fsh - 7TEwyIRaqkUkNYAR4KEVPgSJNEDkoUDkq0tiHPGsLN64jQsamh9l9JNzo4Ec+b885NC5r6wAcoz3 - DHKMa4YcOt7UCTm2NIz94nG9kCMv5rogR4Hy1QM5xmUgx/jQIEengRy7uNFjMJZbXLgGcpTn1Q7u - 7mNhjtEBYY5qJfDEAQff5dPAjQZuNHAj97cvcEPnurICuDHZM7gxqRlu6HhTJ9wojFxk4MakXriR - F3NdcKNA+eqBG5MycGNyaHBj1MCNXVzoSQM3quTVHsKN8QHBjWol8IThBk/EajBGgzEajJH87QvG - 0PmrrABjdDXu0KcEGd1OzSBDx5x9SKPqFvZYCcrQyLkulFGgfrWgDFCXMkeCdg4NZjSJVLsdcdlp - cEalzNpDoDE5IKBRsQieMNJ4tD0eDfxo4MdewI/s9Ke0Ud/O0ETn0QbtJvVoTY0gMyG94A5thhJ5 - O3CkheUGs74TWRt818EpxnYILMKWOBTXDLLNye1cwB3wUi+8IPa3i9pxcvnzb4D+3CR6EU/WIXvW - 7ZxkGMfHpN6UMcIJ4178XavF3nlexEzblPPo26UXedd3lg86fLUKI17Hn5jC/PDOb7NW68sjldF4 - VVLUAhRme4tjxf4k1yJQIA7A8CA3jinkb3kbfpSwhbvNC+CGGaxbK9WjFs8QHZChIJeW2POad45j - p7G+MmbvUU/deWakkiVvos+xbKCchGO+YD0L13J4KUPPN3gljBDPYIvoVDGYYoPF1Hh2wtmT1kRk - 0M3NFAhJVJfouSbdYejO+dANTTMeTMu3tnf3nDOjuD8ws55tq74g9XkpFZFvy8OJJmRcSduJUiRj - Z+9NE6uGumBx+mJ+cOTs8/r7K5oUUAUcE96GtdLHa8/9PMICJeLINJik+ozTRusAgnnhKT89Aqfn - ORoFmLpx7omHphtc8jrFzleuDT7k+MuUdlfVSJ1iiKuvzVtjZUfsWcK4P7+5EVdP+Fx5a6D5wFnU - p7ooonoOGB2jzS75ocncrMw3DX1lMfmhJd6IDUyAh2VmNqKX1AAnKLJ5oWnftsyPvm24Bh5s3Wbf - B1hac1ZAVJFM6JDwDDfjaTSj7fya+qXVmtleaMI8YEX46l/iN/bsH8PZCfaZnbjKdxsuYZBxt9f0 - 7UEd3oZxbz94iwV4EOgiwwtnoiwe0vPPnufEff8zfAHVOfNWkdprWpJvwdfxDJQW1uRhwg+feXPT - h9nB8kAWTogvGi4PmO7Zev3qL967tCixHzmV3VlgPxZmpEzpNze+fEiL7M8Hk5/ZGF/GlzdYuS7q - 82YliW9J2a0N7eDtm2WRwsbmM+RWduVg0w1zz+UMzmHR3KWsZqemjZTboZmPUe/AY5iD65W7It9k - +QsWuDVbUQrGF3UZeZ4dWX52FkuTU1oDjSAAx6Zlm7dRrIigYx8sbwX+BP3K8MeTZNLJaubODwv4 - Oo542ncALeWT6JdNj8rPQkYWWxa2gQ+mZsbKz/PxB8lUDcrjjkpLffwGLIgrwq2sEcutG6utj8Vy - 8d8ff3ltIkrA3dXo9/CjST1/TbyC+QLcb4dviQcr/fbqktbp1LFsgKicH5J15FyBXYAntIRwZrY1 - e082H+vK0cqAHHLqrhn4HoYfmrn7llgKK3Vfmri07mRXHWi2bU2j1Cqz6toVk5UdD2hZmebJQOgG - PfnSC1i7hmPNGDaVflmssZkXMlEyjobkco6y3KEKKkaOIfedle+CgGVPtiWWxy/Au7ilUOllT3Et - oK/P0UdI+gNtC6PP88+l62FGaXM+CrTnLfn6arwuIoft2US+5pHK4c2ZX5R3+Ygz54VtiTFAf/mb - UL54IlTm9mRGsC1FzBLQvbf8Fge+MPum4BfB5JfH3ZRdSVmKP1kO+2P7lIHdNOw2fPj1l3+/mLr4 - JmLBvgi6DEExeCVIpVyCC0jdC96zOdccWm96awTvobnn/vrL30I2B3BvhObpr7/8B3uFt5+yXgfL - eM896zmuc3U7k/4ZdXxm3H3s9fspwrIwmrEtFxhraa69MDQXWY71RZEulg12AfG0SKijX38/3Y7d - YxQkkfUNXvqd4fi/p6Utw/a98KUuvMN0UDvuZ/MNEnOXpVa/9P76+zc6zvLZOf23SWp7KNFS4Sj4 - MhwPur1O7+zhEt50TvRDJAzmUhBZXq5wzwHK9aw36Qz74/6wAmltOgvuIdKSJO4gq9X0ypxXLC4F - D0i7JC3jmWdzLwB/2EfD9Q24TSG7ypguXA8mY8MuAWLQut8FhgKesytebxfwgREQ3KMqxhGaLgAJ - pmGHjJQiXoOWxY+h7SmgRgtL1RoRrvBIy8YMZ2171pxNVwFAoFPh0C5cSzqxtNx8/cPF12+++5rK - EXswqawcJKvbOe11zxlQ6Xiu9bM5Z1fvWDgz3JAs5oX989K0HDMgW0p6yV4T0LUMNKS9rmpIYWoy - 7J/b3V53NN7nd1NrRVXi99yEbiO1sZ96+zmagMMxqWJGrtF+CiJ/8/az35v0OpPxeI/tpySxsZ/3 - tp9XYMsw5n3VJrN1Eayc1cJw2A9gSI+/MWzbATRHFcEVQ/icGXNcPRAxbN+Ilp7tLSjIS/ESeeLV - dM0w52nq2QAeMRRshqfH7NK0bXYlrocOAcKxase652c/tmdwZ5t+6QzbnW53n18WrUHTjmLPLVtp - mhsTpzdx553+ZNw7328TJ4j8zZu43mQ8GgzPq5BWfRCRk9iYuHubuEvPNh9hcfMKHjNb2UbA3oZr - AJlGFKyFaTtErr72QtOdYpbUdxnWvg3MuTWTNY3xvI4PFp1KwhkM6HkVYH7Jig4Aub1694b4dz2z - cCzEso7iDXRhNg35b/BlMugOBvs8qehcAc0Q9tsPKElw4wTonYB+tz/sj/bcCRBENk5AZ9ybDMaT - fXYCBIlPxQk4ks341dS9SSdK1DWbw8o7TaWvqmmrmDYqLqfEI3NKbzJyko0zqa36IG6aYBKFa36M - Wj7maK4CG5dGxuPuYDLqnSV3x9pTQtjaVNgkFVey7Bpj+5jhOxgmidcyCJ6kaOF/6dj8kfhHDV4f - KW2OsmkhSdujWDIY5XbMcNmKzMAJ49B2com9N9fgHs3DVsgz1JMsl6JQPgPUf/0No9tjHcFwvvyy - in2buHPuz6D7oyqM+FmwEByxwPPn3p3bmtre7D20T6dhZJq3wOVb4Ll58v/y9/xkoeZmiFw5+Szm - mO6KksXF7exiDj5giEko6U6SxOCOpvdEIbNkJsxu6W7kmSAmZiIbdpiZS/jOQQuPB2xZC3B242Tz - hMq0LsViL0lGAW9j9uQ+aJPIed5Y8l1l+OsynE7phdC3C04LV+/UDjO+hwVuyqlaPACaTYTKxRlN - 4OcHs2XLclv+auqYXFUyaqe3NcLM/AEZ+PKzXi8hHb58NnyFr8Rnw9dkSzAw9BIkZ8bfbjzMZH2J - u45yPZOI6+s+PbXS+G8s94aP/0ZwLbGDqCUvf/fTyot+n9DAv/8LEvGvevpTUyV/SmFDOWHio25w - wIUthQKpapJpek2PIkiXt5VoJcmWFSkBvRKlVaCQlzSQ+++uxtu54Itmno18psdvaJ9jdxGp5bmu - 8h2VIvNzAd+N+bwVeS3B/tJsTzEd+riJvBsxcn37TbvA+S57TgGx/PhxdD1F9zZ934mkOB8z88PF - nDaQcUEVvBZnK1sknab/laJ7AqZ6ZVdvpbtVWmkgcHcD3d0bA438fXq2GaiuySxX0PNDLDI8/pMb - Y1KJA7fDuWllI3frM8E6Xh+i9a1Nr+9leLdR89u2uQtzXrnJ7VVochdi+tnJ4vb2xeIid5+cwQWi - 67G3FXT8AHMLT//U1pbU4bCNbW4+2cjb2mytjtMHaGpr0+n7WNptxPzmDe0pG3coOw8LLlRudfvV - Wt0Usbub4P4emeA035+mPb78Ytz5AsbwBY6hRvNc6XMeZq1TYtsD051Ro4O34xll2BOzvlkKh2nj - H+FNuKfBL0/Z07f+zDF+9IIH+QBgbP+BnTF/uQ4tTM9fV+4FEI2tQZW+QI7o3b2BPFWf1ifIy+Hp - eQUwhs96XyVDEMb64o/vKnUKqn7MQ3wCoOUsoURON0DKp3EJNFp04E5BNid5M6/rcwO2c/4QHYHH - UP97+QE7EFbgBvw/AAAA///sXW132kiy/jz5FQpz7omzRkLvL17He21nMnivyXjjTPZs9uzxEUKA - EoEYCXA8e+a/36e6JSFAYMDgt4xnAlJ3dXd1dXU91dUt8YTcgDs4APz594Y7IKSF/vb8YTdqJVt3 - Aoztwf8Cltd3AYxHAv6LxuCpOQCsH/tpP4DQaT92EhrYUVubuwJTg1hL2XngEMFCxXrWPsGUajwC - 32DVUXh+/sE9zokNnIT1uXv6nsKdAwZMaOTotgIXqEzvbGcvaJybalsLHJhb9hzKmd80gGA+Jh9i - wbg8ST8CmD7pyn7alZ0EFHbX3B29idr8WD5wgGGplj1/p+KxOBMrjsAzdSjubVps6lOsy+CfbsUE - vna+D2HtwJ24+z6E9djciCe8D5Hh+Y73IbbfzF3dhUezD1GqRX+6B/fpHnxX+xD3o/4buwN/7kPc - 7gCc8h/Qi3r+1nHf3h7iT7hcH+jtRwLxBUk/NWSfsL6TPYXtVb85kk94eOC9g6KaPGvoXmR5lsp5 - V/i9ROrPD7Z3resbAPaKLH3XUP2O/QDv1mHa2R5Mcw7Xh2jnkUB0KuGnBs+c7Z1A83aq3hyWefsP - DMmZWjxrOC6zLkvluysoXiDt5wfDu9TtDSB4BXa+a/it+2447N4In6KQfonWj7d/WE/Z4nvk5tld - H5eVx/JCuRLZPzWQTruwP+nCTgB7+81sDt7zo/bAQF6mRs8a1Oe14REA/Aqj8PzA/r7mwgbAvyZr - 37cTMOq5/R0A/xZfTcdZ3ADsH8vL6VIZPzmAZ2zvBtS3UvUdgJy1/9DgnarF8wbsEvuyVL47A+ly - aT9DYN6hbm8Cxrez810DcPoLscK5z38hdvtQvMVX1s0yuwEoP5b3183J/anBc9qB/awDOwHqbTey - OWTPjtcDg/e8+jxrGJ/Vg0cA6LeOwPOD9vuZAxuA/FqMPX24v/Mp9Ybb6ft0qv+Dn0R9t+/5whk/ - 3/+XHT46z0+IK1t8md5K/VjfSShh9GFdhVVG6+n5D7xX+3mv9s+yp9VmnoLf7nn3+2j4Ln7GosGe - fbL3gc7Er6iNz9wdWaRCj8Ix2WSAnqO38jAzaSP/5U6sPn2P5k6+zA7O8ClbfMtfY6MjfMpjeaNf - 4yme4Gvs6vzeNiq+i3Pw4Gf3Gs//5N68RVkq293h+Hdxam93Or0REP95Ym8J1AJAQLCTH7ZRtvhi - vQKfGwDvY3mbXlHaTw5/Ge/7O/u9my3Wfwc0ngzQQ4NyUVWeNzZPBv4xQPQSuT9DpN61vm8C2Cvy - 9F3j9r+iUb+zq9+A3eJr7Qp8boDbj+UNdkVpPzXcZrzv7+53YbdY/+a4XRigB8btKVV51rhdGPhH - gNvL5P78cHvn+r4Bbq/K065wm/JSjKFEXL54wT6K/9hnlsOIMxzqxG5/mFSy0U9vMyYPu+qMzc85 - /JlRsp/1aY/6rewMG/HRVfPyBVDgVUN7EgKGOcxIKxGTIQatx9DjY9cX3NGwG8V7yWtomOcHY78l - 9CMhGfhe0A68rGkGW8NukAiwlV+lXBTzUjms9QCORy9Y5osXs0zSLxSF7k0l1c9W4IZRpzKFl6cB - OIS2CG95JlVerIKXEbyUTGxNyEA47TZ5YZT4Yt7oxItRKkf//vaf3G2Y4zMdDfDiFztbxOCs/aH/ - bZh5bS+W0GSDsogmBe7pjqTjnOP+4EZMe8i7LbYjb5QfwCiZl+7Yv0q6buzP0mRTEu3P5aUjQc1l - WRPRqbmSniJ/2v1KBxza0kv3D99UBlEysZ2HQX8wGgrDmwFGn3tNFaHv9nDnJXG7x5z0a7A7jL5S - 1tgNR8j71OuN+sl49Fv35OzG/+j8ox4qFz//48Nvxuf/Ozu9OL5IPn343DhxTpq/NKKTlu4N62eX - v/luV3NjLT57O2k/lR5nIIELEMzBTCpsuKZwLMRyE7qKpGdpyyQ+S5NKntAgjNy5lStTS7iUabbg - Cu0ADj3NTmiYH/fdMJ8YQs/tux021YUkag+vS1ibjKpWMD2HCZzyfLqlbYnplMjblvrNoHlYI9qV - ioq9qBlQDSUFZyZijRQotyEvSqdLMrxBnYkf0stLYvE6dgeD9LfoDpkUJ65OSsJSK0fvULc7PIB1 - p3tGz0mmrBCnqtzSbNGk6KkEsy5FAzYKHGtZqVEcilzX3Z47OxSpph83jmdzJtJFZi4wXv0aTQ4W - NnmxrMmLzZvshYuabJwvaRKZGzcJn3JBk+/PG7M5fBRp8ZldFSYB6BdxAd1l9EcvUov+IsfBJQlr - A2EDC14hXQPOgSH5Fj0QTFasaQ3TKFlGkk6yBEt2IPs04F368Dc+Rughy01JJ6vMqfrSJWYqpokN - 4P4uceiFwaAZuViWpoGKyrRjms9RZojFHLxnSs2niEM37vjDKRQUiB8RxrUnVCbu4GlWNHf3pvmd - 9s59eC9h3mxe4Szbee0/Ef1szTNLLQDDGjVegnwBq7M131JZtuByPQ8+9HB+0fW3put9vcLkecNI - /0c7/h/1Hb3fla2M5+iRo9m2ojuWyui0aOBjzRI0wyCC8zno3ogw6WRiGzfCSSF5tjuPsh9eFNKc - ZoqdduN0krSS8uQgwZE3XmPUc6e3wYtOt1dYhCzzb2dd2kU2KV2yTC9USEqYR9Gw8IOuRYMVgv/Y - HY4w/1OqtC9e1BuEzM1wY/KxuYtyTraBFl7vT0/OhPO8MDu4NIo9P5nzlkcJXKA4yIzw4WBh06k/ - vbDqw9pg1TqynrqLCdn6usTjm1BexXmnyiMOvIoV4yA1TCAscUkFds7doOetzhyIwdtF4/ReWGtG - 0dek64ft1RlkRSpHJ1nJe+GzFSSoOej58RSjtUk6hPY2v8l5WllJBXcIQ4Jpzf3PqeU7j/jRqrzV - c+OvLFyQpgEXI/gTPhb2nSBBZUgbxm7LJ8JEiNpY0PvCr9KlJLz1B248ZCsFJPO3ErCq2DORwqUf - jwP0Xdir1y9fS8KvfR41CH5HlaPET+vCBa86SAS4D4E3DG+EQRx1gyb61ZLSDk9bpQwQXoqi8Cb/ - E05++vnsvfDul18+/vShmC6KKHLIhZMPbcKNdCbFwCM58bTiqiazdMV8setDInGlrOxVmocVQxhG - 18ySTXM9E38JWpPNAWGyTVCMSBULTLVVTl7U21QjqFSF9YMnXA2vgyEzx9MTJE2WYJ5rNFGmfcuP - aaH5mOZhMu4I10Fr2MWSRkatftDpDvn1OPCvTyLaBBJkQZcFzarQAhT19aO+XxG+9cJ+wllIp+i1 - JkVxp6bKslxDxSXtsTYZaBylTB3W+G05aYf1Pe3dN0WW7QWV8qnlQpOpAF0w4oW09AfChinJpqWZ - gnWumJJtWbagypLtOMo5cvCnCJoqqXVFltRzxZZMQdUk5Vw1JNO0eZamn6uqZAuKJRnnmiI5glVX - bQmpsmQJioErRZd01GTVqTXbsetpq58bDuqxDE2wJUvTVa2uqJKjqda56iBBtQRNlnTTsOuqKRmm - Y53P0H9e3kE+Wj8aJ6ZinlRqC2Rc65ToBY3fjG5OzGuacKuytl3PJytdZs6zvFxlybZPq+27rPgR - qekcj8w084XguXuDSaisopPTaq3J7F/ZzOBqmfGwUE250uUe2vw7RlJmoWsqtMioKlAJBRplKZKl - f3IsyVY9WbQlRa8akuaIilx1JIW+u6qF1E+GGoqaI2mqiHKeqJHuVWVRVyVdrUIxTDu91jXJssaK - I+l23XEk2RlrJopRNao+VmSnq0MblbFIl5rxuazXNerObDrXhg0UgCDSb83/csC8OmSUTB3IyXT7 - N0wtStb4RR05Z+XO+lxH7kcnsja3oROKrEimXlUxdppVNyzJcjA+it5Fgm187omqKiqwKobeFSXV - 9HAjqQaGX1WgOBhJSTPTa3xapBgKajSqtmTrlKQYVZgnTePXl9SeVbVgP9SqIqtVBxXYp3TFcqyq - o0k6dBQ1alUL5kZLbz73YFBhnKqGKpnKMVk70LFPmf2nEKmtjk0FWlxXoIaKnUiGAh4NSdUYY3od - VGNFcw0dLFX5Jytc1XRUJcL+maanohtVHZkOapTs9NJANc7YsCXNqCsOJswnNFfGiI1pZoIfWF39 - HpS8Ewy7o+asjeOpCwD552BYR5EHsWstv52UIcEhi66VY4TElbi6JFMV/rsAiwiFDoQfLY3++2sp - 0R8vljW7tGYxHoX+geCP/X7Uai2qfj6Ngl6l/YXTVyqhdPLzodvK1DcwU8yqDutsuzRJMHvTL6bI - ooapqFVV2ZQUD7pvY5aAFhNd0viFARtPpkAygA0yQQZsBlAC8wgz1xHhRQAWTElnoKHR7NLtqWtd - shW6JCtDeCSSv2JNXTuS4YjkfsDlwDeBDP8Gs7AEkgVIMyVVoVuneOkwGjBvwbyhEAyJpDtVuDQw - MzBAIEY9MDMa8YpMA6xaYEdHD2CSbMmwqgoAUqnaMIboPv6lVxCaobg6mgHssU9uRahhEd6X5sBS - SopI5gSdtMiIkiyQYjNSmBUbuTZMLyElFbR1l0ycSqPAvniVBizUKexN1Ua1bDTQNYXgunDt8dHT - yfCoLA9YjuaqGFrwZ1tV/plzaTtVzqZMOSYGFVzqVR3SBsM2LB0ZWsWGcCAojUbfIknCL1T4FYbY - oL6QuGjQVWoTJpRdQS3Ahw0OwCGGgGmOCQdDto5LVK1a1MXVTWaZuquL1N1mfosCx4S8GCACaa0C - R5gcGCAMGFBRXuKJouQYuDAwMuzOpAuAHAGGwlQMXZEcWH7JBEqisKjshm8HkpShddAo6BybHVBj - gDDURwFnuuOCB2IIH0yWYJI0T3E8NjF1jBUVI9xGqoUSCR8ai2YyEVIPqNtlq5ttdEFnSqHI6IKJ - SW2iLagRWQ4NfDlKgnR4CxBpak6IOaZC8CBth/wJZNosxdA/99BN2uC+O2MOzX8Vhsa2SLw2sUHj - TPJSadrCXyWlUGiyMj2gZFIFDVk01yygPAlfJQ4tmhJISznchSwVNALZqZh+KqkEHHDywyTdICbI - 4MCmGolIaRp1xiLBKkwH6FalETcxYW3ItKowK0HGkWh2yTYMMSY4se1gvVGFwEUSG2w7rD+bRhA0 - Lh2R5qNK84k5VnwSIoOUBhqOK4ySxb6pvL5LpmEUaY0DJ9AwPInUBIIjJCHVYMaNJM2UWOMwSMaY - AIrhEtFQLllT5FI5xVyqvRs7gU22HTftApLfF/QTiqgk8+HLaY/wZLJXV2iWljTUCPMDr5TKVnxD - nf6nI6jk5qReH/e0/stctcxT+yNzkVKPaH7gKnyUdGC6C+zi2CbqIl3rKdbhCksH+PfHCky4k+KN - JcmYL4YL+tTZwdVYm9xXaamBZQY0MKtJlavwiGCiJkQqrRu6xWLQ1889tHIM7UyhHq1VzUIhs2pN - tYSrY5qV2UoEyqLN5HfBfX6vob/a50rt6PYgyWwAsXhL+8oe32leENrMo4RiOxwFLaHZEQdx0KON - l/Kg5CQeORiKxsJQZBxdC72hqM0GH6dqCsWwI2oCXSjqvGYOCjth7EzUdZcOupTF7Qs6n0Re4IY9 - LPTdGjtIIXWHPbb3xn6WRrjGoon24vmG2GCu1cnWNB18E4N+SK/34bVesWrLDFEYlJTiO3TUi8WR - VHBy9f6sXh5MLV1p8I3qNxXYA5d2B2KfhUtpzxGjQofa234cl4ZiuQZMwrGaMQnH0vX0+s4WKG0b - 4VjW7uohWUY+F5Z1KmzXXiQT8aYyisO9H+levjIN1TKvNEc3Xy9pn1WaR28/padtmHEBpMuyKWg6 - QNM0TgG3jmUq2T3/tgyBpRtKfs/cLMc8ze5tSVZ1xRSy8jLAWbUsTcgayBJOidJQ9AkFXWiFKrL7 - rInsPmMhqyBjcaYLn7Nh+1GVDd3RKrR9En2FRU+nEL8VUzWAx5An9WjHKAzwhfQlHli5WNOguMMF - C0jVbYW4NSj0rZqOLQBn0WXn3CaGZYV6ZNRpYXZOfRBUmSLdKGbyHJXKqjJyFPNctaiqOhAb1I6g - sG+dKuIZ1J6jWvW03c/wSLAscSyBIt22pdVpgWYoDsXW6VvAt2oqWp0C7o5qns/Q52LkUrtVFqVh - 7jxzUVCkQEL6fJHJcla5b9FtVkHMLRyf3HZhcttzXYnZeaOltdUyfpZ1eXG3Fjg6PKt4eCNPXcuK - zkf42YEHNwyDZgwAi9pkrT3UUG5HS7cBFlvTWbu7xLqO/ThhO7lQp5V8J0Zy8I0C1GWEWNA6tW98 - L5iM8+Dboj2ZG547bchV3aF/NMVv6CSF33eboS/SGZdOHI36rYO+fy0UKP/KODpIBpAK5nTsJ348 - LnshQNZnqjc9AUtAXfOSsrf8ZH9SMlTkhQE3+kvDee/YX3m8jf4WhPSyNlZqhIBtcQtCahZXYEaY - MqoHgr0C6cTYHgiKvKyj5ekLA4xpNsfYy4Z46xZTWmCZ/VqSN7PiovFNoRXrOorGdEVV/2TD9Huy - aFQ1iaJ7atWQLPru0rboJ1MOKUCli7KkeCJAgAUPiAzZBr+izaqxgqy6I48JJ6ioc6tZLP8bmxZB - j2aMRbrq0t7Gecbw73ey9suyvCD2MFsmoiJZefQEAVDIxOUNvwQkxwTBNq7ACy+2zNCWBqBnz8nl - OWub2ptoNBw1fWZpRzAI5LnOOa7/4kR3dVw3sqILBL6+bV1uRRc0syvbmk/hVLS3zeD1bbH+fKzk - sm4a20Gc8vTbDPHspNezKa/TPM+mvL76lGcLpGHs9hN6sgFDTZehO/T35KroGBRUVRV72XpoxmIb - y455MGfepk1bWcOKxKNdIJ0CKrZE2ywav6CPsU7mW64yAtrMyHPYR9eC8fZ4aZYgZjSsirUs+Vjk - bTFmxIyLyUedOP5daNBhCNp6NmzJDmm7inZy9VDMLz/xvFtN/kKrPnF0y4zt5KztJGUqZMOS1gqM - FB79hAFJrniAUCgESY7ep86wcM69YTpS10j94cNmXIIIZUa/E0WdkNv8njtIaoMQZqtmm7K8/yHy - vo4xa/z9i+CrX90/8enEXsut7jfe7quy7ei1/9VsyXEMx5DtqmgBu2VFpm0V6/caBRnfvNR6yku9 - iX89A9f6SyWRv9lO0/Icw1cNyzRareaB/E1xFMNs23YTSyHNaNov7Z76UmtNan+pt6h+2bFtTdXK - NLkkjLQ6HFF/hby/AvW3VISCkAtBaLwVmBBKw0zrKYDg+X122hKJC6Jky0Ni137zahCFGHs/4dGw - Enkc/dNvChcpFeN6ZS3J2gn6CcBpNPQTEUk1/BOjdjvwfLEVxCzgUkvvoVC9UT/w3PR4/KiJdsUw - cIMk6tfase+3oh6ckjZ7aCp9mDGtbLXhPXr3y9nxet3odhPWjfEohAa4zSAMhjciO3UbJXSElsnw - phhVLNMrWruPW4PKUb1+KXwq1iW8zeu6H7XIH4YZ0JOHdKZIWBxITammNxCO6n44WFMbCuVdz4N9 - Cnj3F6vecZFs89Y8N6afPMu+F7d3yglWG4T5hOk49+0h7tvGqu/mJZrRcAjNn34QqkBaeHBqPrqe - 0pT5+6n8FkbT54UJCOFB8tJ1RXkb6zVdQrnYtoCds/pO2VliEdhc3l7jq+HTPDujxE3Z+fXymK7W - YmneD6E06N56+r9og4nf5gfpZ8/f//T+7aLT95z2izt2Ey8OBkN6yCfof6FQ5vt/vr2k575doHUn - kYT3qP2AP4BJDk3/upVcpetEekhgNKB3uLSE5o1Q6Q962RISNgB4Q48fsPaoxaylyTpp0n46q8Zu - PN3AG4Ei5ZJW+euLnIB4u8qoQNGKvBE99iB5sQ9WfuLPMe29IrpXr/nCYqqMRDutKPiKNm/z1Fdl - lOlLekBcZItT5u3CpUkbTU5uPrqd96h+7xU9ePDq9b/l/0j0UHO/ddoNwtbeVPWvy3q1bo/mezPb - k0IvXt34Wfbd2CfWfyC+3dCPh8mvcUhjVfPgwtV4UvolfUkweD8EbWGPRp40CHyeuIlPZV5CIV9h - ye634SOjPSwYf/ihWGWReH/SGGqkdSHmAlOf7NncqUfjpt7mkav8P0Y+PHO2IzkIRx34T0xDX2Tv - /Ei1lN7QkhsCr9UveZCKPZhYc02lbcmGJ2pNzxN1RzdFu2U4otvWNa/Zamlmy6udHp/Wf6p9SWrR - aDgYDSXV0drNtmW6LlZNX+gNT3lHJm8kYfxexBGblU3IQOA0STqF75FfU7d8XVWahtzSS/k9nNwK - bMwk99pPop4vEeMXbseXgn4w3MviARTNOoOreVCIEATJedTp0AnsA4G9SGxyLpXISc0PhEplkhpG - GD4oA1J3+3jpdJuQyXSjpY+xpZzUEnrp2WhYwkCttqDxWtZ0LcPrPzIGmnwqHAivljX+KiPvR5fk - 5EX90yj6GvjvuQgHPbGf5H3i7/E5a82SJEErp3FbX96748sFlMgFpE0V4JXS+xcu2VPhQIi5+tsT - HoLklz6vnVRlljKIkkFlIgHv68eIE88SNodJmBN6cOiw2gkvff84DGdJvcTNKb8kPPdtRK+9ofzy - cckLkDpe0ltCPvi/jfxk+M4NQr9VVE4InvJbl/5wGPQ7CfJ6N9xAR/wFI62rJM2bK3TMVaesTKpV - XC/+YFAwZQOnQbYXtUb5+4iCHi01BKytekGSUMiUnoU7JosqtOOoJ2zPfDAUKDQksueSmfHmcMAY - 4qaY4OeSMb23fEKVQ0uV3m7Ej9fsvc6NSYcR7P37VTNq3QhHwl8O4OsNRY8w7NV/XmfBxjJZ7KW5 - f7yW2hjWvaz6vPYSqRcE36IIxgIfZwUjzTrJ35aYfjFzW2yugGv3Y/wN39K9pm5orfas8c94WQYA - bjwMvLAEA8iWXY5g8RMWkeA2FUviPKWWz4yeO+z+3f02bXbv3FGq9Yv7rTbqD2BUUKrBm0En/waX - qR103jQa51en9Y+N86JZ4a+iOL44+wDPm3h2qZY8ozZP+x6aQAJI+zh5E0afFh8D5NTWssdrmteV - bebaljCM+p2Pfty7wMIp+IYClPAbzesZ7Pj1wzmdaqDe5+iGHBHAUdscZgq6lYp2Ap0T3Ym//v1y - 66oTf4WakJHDFGcdltK0vGF6KV896HRDOg9yGoVRXESIbpbjtz7Sa7KSYia9XYq/vOiChUT9vjeH - il57AQoc1sjq0cPZFIw5+n8AAAD//wMA29Vk8OCqAgA= - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:14 GMT - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - pm-csrf=4gJxMugPl4ne0xu5wWwRdUyt18lRvZ3d; expires=Fri, 30 May 2025 19:29:14 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31449600; Path=/; SameSite=Lax; Secure - - pm-sessionid=fp9j321mzrdjbljdqlxu51xuwnm4f7da; expires=Sat, 01 Jun 2024 03:29:14 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=28800; Path=/; Secure - - ncbi_sid=FC2329054D888048_9129SID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Sat, 31 May 2025 - 19:29:14 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Vary: - - origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, - like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&retmode=json&cmd=prlinks + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814972&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json response: body: string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAADzMMQvCMBAF4N1fcdxcpKUONbOLIHVykg4JuWA0TUqSFiT0v3vtILe9790r+CKp - KaIomL8ToUBy1n+wwoVissFzUh9bXCvc8kQ5oXgW1MrEMDJOsxpJc9/qOTpnU97dara265rTuW5Y - g3ozb78DV70JzH2AG2/e5wz7NshFWieVIzAhwuN6EfCfWAe+ww8AAP//AwBTvVrssAAAAA== + H4sIAAAAAAAAADzMPwvCMBAF8N1PcdxcRK1gzexSEJ2cpENCrhhNk5I/BQn97l47yG3v9+4VfJHU + FFAUTN+RUCBZ4z5Y4UQhGu842W1rnCtc8kgpongW1KoPfmAcsxpIc9/oHKw1Ma1uNFvdNPvj+XRg + 9erNvPx2XHW9Z755uPLmPSdYt0FO0lipLEHvAzzai4D/xNzxbX4AAAD//wMAp4IJxLAAAAA= headers: Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - '*' @@ -3294,24 +540,22 @@ interactions: Content-Type: - application/json; charset=UTF-8 Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:21 GMT + - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:39 GMT Keep-Alive: - timeout=4, max=40 NCBI-PHID: - - 939BBA21E3AAD485000034CDDFF20ED5.1.1.m_1 + - 322C94F129AFBF0500007E11593212B4.1.1.m_1 NCBI-SID: - - A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID + - 636C4BC40E3B70FE_AEAASID Referrer-Policy: - origin-when-cross-origin Server: - Finatra Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A5FA6087D91486E2_FE4ESID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Sat, 31 - May 2025 19:29:21 GMT + - ncbi_sid=636C4BC40E3B70FE_AEAASID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Fri, 30 + May 2025 23:51:39 GMT Strict-Transport-Security: - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked X-RateLimit-Limit: - '3' X-RateLimit-Remaining: @@ -3335,65 +579,16 @@ interactions: Connection: - keep-alive User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: http://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - response: - body: - string: ' - - - - 301 Moved Permanently - - - -

Moved Permanently

- -

The document has moved here.

- - - - ' - headers: - Connection: - - Keep-Alive - Content-Length: - - '326' - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:22 GMT - Keep-Alive: - - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Apache - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 - Safari/537.36 + - Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, + like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.78 Safari/537.36 method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=ref + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&id=38814901&cmd=prlinks&retmode=json response: body: string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= + H4sIAAAAAAAAADzMMQvCMBAF4N1fcdxcpKUONbOLIHVykg4JuWA0TUqSFiT0v3vtILe9790r+CKp + KaIomL8ToUBy1n+wwoVissFzUh9bXCvc8kQ5oXgW1MrEMDJOsxpJc9/qOTpnU97dara265rTuW5Y + g3ozb78DV70JzH2AG2/e5wz7NshFWieVIzAhwuN6EfCfWAe+ww8AAP//AwBTvVrssAAAAA== headers: Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - '*' @@ -3406,626 +601,28 @@ interactions: Content-Security-Policy: - upgrade-insecure-requests Content-Type: - - text/html + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:21 GMT + - Thu, 30 May 2024 23:51:41 GMT Keep-Alive: - timeout=4, max=40 - Location: - - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814901 NCBI-PHID: - - 939BBA21E3AAD485000041CDE21828BA.1.1.m_2 + - 322C94F129AFBF0500007511672A29FD.1.1.m_1 NCBI-SID: - - 28DF727C32ECC374_9478SID + - 391DE0148DF53292_507CSID Referrer-Policy: - origin-when-cross-origin Server: - Finatra Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=28DF727C32ECC374_9478SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Sat, 31 - May 2025 19:29:22 GMT + - ncbi_sid=391DE0148DF53292_507CSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Fri, 30 + May 2025 23:51:42 GMT Strict-Transport-Security: - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked X-RateLimit-Limit: - '3' X-RateLimit-Remaining: - - '1' - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 302 - message: Found -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=28DF727C32ECC374_9478SID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814901 - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA= - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:22 GMT - Location: - - /38814901/ - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=28DF727C32ECC374_9478SID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Sat, 31 May 2025 - 19:29:22 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Vary: - - Cookie,origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-UA-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-encoding: - - gzip - status: - code: 301 - message: Moved Permanently -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=28DF727C32ECC374_9478SID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38814901/ - response: - body: - string: !!binary | - H4sIAAAAAAAAAOw723bbuLXP8VdglIfeTFFXK3ZsreX4EqdjJ27szCR90QJJkMKYJFiCtKw+9Tf6 - A+fD+iVnbxCgQIlynKlnZR7qNeNIBPZ9Y99AH/5w+uHk9sv1GZkXSTzdwZ9D/EhimkZHHZZ2yBSe - MBoQwguWSF9kTH0qlhk76syLIjtwXenPWUK7Io/cn5l3TSPWISTLWcgfjjoiOiB6n4iybsLcVL5E - vAR+DhNWUOLPaS5ZcdT5dHvuvOrYSwjpsH+U/P6o89n5dOyciCSjBfdioOGLtGApwL07O2IBUAUR - FOgPjkOuhMdjBmwAy3nBmSSOY2NOaQISXNA0mLM4OM85S4N4aSG9zUvW2YSo8H7ICp7wf7LAAhgO - ei377zlbZCIvrI0LHhTzo4Ddc5856ssu4SkvOI0d6dOYHfW7vUqY6r/DmKd3JGfxUQfUCnhS5gPC - Oai4MoIE7fpB2k19j3fTOOmmfN6NxL3i50nQi8Xiv4SOhIhi5tCUxsuC+7Lri8QWooFKFsuYyTlj - TxLDzUovYYFL9/rhpDf2naHn+85of7TnvArG+w4NR0PfC4LhXuC7J8cnF2euL6UryiIri+6Y+eHe - wKO0F9IuPO+QynsL9lDgPiXmzs534280HviTns/29sLJFv6MBjWj31Ob+xN/2OvR/ng/6D+qzZ3v - qNKeF9Lxfv/VyJ9sM/l3VqM3nuxNRoMw9IfsETVWLBa8iNn0XSp5NC8kxIpCkGLOCAtDOIySiJBg - AAtyxv05oQV94JSIVO2JWViQe4g7OfchHpaSpxG57ZOEZhl+hAAI4b5gJKKBAF3wMiEsndPUZwlA - EYdcl94VCw7diostBxpiQywohEMqjzohRLpnV2EpF4F0Ay4LF/FLN2F5zheMgpS544k4cBbMw6Xu - QoThwGgUn7j6iZ8LKUXOI54Sd7o6TSpjnFMIyCI1icJ2jDkEcL8sCK4bvDyBROfCkydJ6ouclQWP - pZuiGDyJ3FDTMx+6Cpe7RnuTZJZGz0ZS4XKVUZUO+vuDB/h/F8xIMNon4AMBC0gocnKcBrngAWzV - +bzMAnAc2cWSYZwL/07FfHfQ64/cft+9KTNMfA7AOmCjhDm+iOEzT52TeS7g+3BfLa4Qb2h+i/QS - Ui/4meb2ubThAK4NjYwnD+MJ+aPKfUkmJAv+pLTBr+ciZWT49mYXax0HpO7DQxGQW1HiKYRzBT7J - ar2RKuG3uBecREicBYI5ig+L2LPJNp4o0aZGrsngYTJokasvCxKxlOVQZUEI4dc02FW/yUDJpD4m - ECe+VQ5tM0X32aSaDJpS9fujB/h/u71Gu2QEFhsrWWC52DDcrxNLE34+V+yP1iQbAYFRu2RgkWEe - KJFGxdw2368UpqL1fMKMjDD1sToHxq8h/8D5+At5q0pHYopqTHAs0hL88f2N82rQ+5MRxSqtkZeZ - jGZCw824XY53VmdY9wJeLhYSCNIAMqWUxKM5USGpBbcVsCycLwe98fgVtVBfAyaW3zOVaz+yEHIS - UFjMWUoigfk1hEhHLm5vr28IZG380EIt14AWqSpLOYjJUWnLqZ5o2utqyJQuZ1GRzIqc+ncWpgIb - GYhoit9LEUXIVkZzmsgDY4OAhbSMiyo41el9nQg4j4W3St6dRiJtAQq8R2G2wmXzhjnPBm9e9Xq9 - /qR3Pjib7I17+OV4Mjp59WY8nJxOuv1uMht/lRutJ1nQYlbmsUXgsU7Ixf2P4Y5FNPMhGUYit3vI - GHpl8OMyZ19lzIdYNPMBquEFa/qq3W6LGf1SFuBulYNtUUDQUCv1JPpLLVybYMK2es6gkmT3bBtA - 2UA/fPWqP9rv9bftVix9GwhyBFVgFtMlCwBUfiOsFGXusza33M0Sf1PVN8KHxpwoLAWNpIq5ZRqC - 96AF4B+T0ndsUgGTfs4zjGEWoeMUKiuJGFVw81ixYBAqAh6GpawCXy4LNQoglz+RZCl8mgf4LeQQ - viSXKspjhIcem0gwRM6LJQCS84+nx2QBdVuGIQkqdw6VW4blW1rES9UjwA4HsgD4aYDYwfKlD84J - 2H0o+CMo5cCxfBpzSAaQLkDFugmoiSP+UJRYB4AkWAcIRR+wy9L7RXUjCw45SHGDrCJEKopabMCs - NrTRJ6BZBajkI//51/91prZO79hyIfKGxbOEBwfG7Lvk+uqk3+8P94f9/V0SCH7Q73X7w0nf/QWs - ntK4m0ER0O0Ne8P9PdjxUeCpOSPXSo9xvEt+5InHctDXF3LJ011yRfMCRH1DTlFvS/+O75JjaJTA - ukAfP0PY3CUncx5DnXQCbOUUKihomDjdJecsoTGDf7X+4FOu2rN01+7YjlXH9mfiEkzFMfeVd8gt - ewBzlEK0APtjSQxOuGWj9pJteDLonCC/Rctd8rbu/f68Sy4YyEx+Mi2j3EazbZ+Fs3V5vpRc2JvK - hKKgV4BeefRHJkWKzSd5V9FBMHCBuQjUNtTmFQ8CSOfHERxZclPk4o6Rn0RcJrD2BZwzMlapOldy - rGPcLnn/7gJ+XV7Br5M37+C3UjT4H/TWcOpK6GbQlYH1GIdy9fKJisvq5L/homD+PFUCABw8S9Q2 - a/slmJvm6lSgI/g8Ra7PTi/fvT9renQuPFHY/oyH9mE3FaGIY7GADzT35xzCrQbT88ylGqyqjtye - g37XCUEri+05toq3m2nWHGS3Fdf/QupzhtSGalVv3WKox6Y2AA384379xEG8jkLl3A+6v2TRdloH - kvlQFm2pwX4LsjhEsIfwzJNQnbVuxYUZHlBrf9PHdZMAagfvOghEQnm6UU+0DNTboNEdLVhZJgkE - j1lM8whaGmWYVrjf5+lv8vhfHv81Nf/v/D97SWV0+5sFgFUh/QE0d8Mwn5HPV5ctU1a1ZqZ9OKjQ - hZALRzOtVi0X+MtDEn/LkNnidoWvq5Cok2SOONF8rHr8Uy6pBxVM5RsMLO9hzZESFitbyqrfTwX5 - 640RC4olxej0sUuGtZH/c0/McTTjpsKpOOmaW4VDd8WcanVsf/B5oXQ++11El077MKJmkpZQGOZ2 - /WQqefLx7DUU8OTHL6/PociPydXx65M5w+Lw6uri9ZXgOfn55vWJyD0w3SUs0rkApt++rgt9cvXm - 9eoaZjsTOAS3OOiN3WHPHfQGoxVwKxyYEsLCvNHvX1+KG/IhVVfZrUC6j9kwz3UMgEIBthNL2pvs - LdvNWGCGs/0tSfoJUfxxxd2rmt3C3N/vTO3rpTYgLmVpw4xrkK2Khj7QJvJIR2jC1RbCaYPX4cDZ - G/SGnerFic0rMZ+mIoUQthGlvq64eghx6OLbF2AkTwRL0rx8s0PMYcDviR9DRjjq1Cfe8Wiaonvx - oOWpjkwW4ILmKRxKiOJSqqpD7Xh0j4PBq95IyO0cMhqWTyRlLJDkr/Se3iiyOP2E5v1OV1rxskuu - Y0YhQ7MUoyvhaktBoZmjwT1NC4rZK1RhRLXFDLBKyGHwLGRqqCZ/MBy6wKIWyHzUH9ai3aaqQBAw - 74au1h7Poedk6bqq2zX2ZH2dxDzzoMPDNrZKjBeQoUQOjTEGRpVuIJMLvOGslOLjXZwWntCckYIl - mYBmk0NWKlPQNo9Rm92ddbV4ZVFAfNNs+bGQTAvnVEud2oj4o1PiCe5b8anYarJaVSKGLtHyEq23 - Bk51CPB8yNw/UhzMUjHTmp61QYBc1MEjl4u41Vybu4ENPHzPyrhCzB4yineheqBuvK1SXsPh1D/m - nRJqVF5K6sg7noGRTEB4icMlyItOAPGGx1IjvYFdeBawqSAZHgMddRQRuppsYnFyVP+QN2dv370n - F2fHp2cf7edYkhxCv6XqY4sbKxDYLotL1IfiIcBCW8uJYQgHzOvQTrXQGitwV5TzgFjbuRV71H6e - RAT94fH5++qWqXoN4LErTkJjfJese9MlYUwjHUw1uWwK/YIIQ66GuroJNGHmU8qxmL4p8FqbAF2W - p1iGHLqZhaKyuOUgbXrTh8oWffOYrflVSGPJNtZX7g8MGVyFyFYbpxbIoQRsLWaqiOvwcwFV7B8k - mYsFWYqS3KVicegioCWl5djVdyvCVjZfBbudDT1oqtpvScMTVjrSy0YSDL1tMm7zLb0vKnmAkdEB - WEVAvVLnQFp35jQO15yt3W7GO31tsgTntzMvFv4d9DORbZRf56zKQQNRIJNded/AqPz1FKIRjgjq - 57bXrgluc4eFQafhAZn9DT0C3CeNprfg4MgeSRhNoYwv/vOvf8v6KHTBAap9TWAvtxnBn3MWqKy0 - Oh7mGCG2AtuiqpdVxKD97CY87pI3LAS1NDDJOTg4hFxorQGc32Ozbo1TEywFJGQ6dFJgFj4I7JDD - ioEGKosZ5KRr66NxeFduvP7lK84lZfz7di4F1epaF7jy2zqWiqJY+qmp3tOdCWENHiN2DQyOJFWh - U8xpoSIVVjz6FVR0nKoRbSDcCO2Y+BU8TZe2fyl8UIve80BxzlI/X2YQ/puZH6FzOC8JjkkCLR8U - r9/qYJtlqU7I8HHNCOjKMQXdm63N3IseYbIugcQAVZopUqEThRqjwgtmN5l550VbVoaFFxsLK+9e - zAG1eaO6zV8sPmazWESi0zSt2k+f8JoxtDsapcLSKOPwmgYvu4UWLsL0UYnnx9y/0/PRetGAvbvA - a54KcpOtX1F21C+3II/SPY7AX5aIXp246pw1qK57euUEdO1E6FrxRdMSDdViuizVKOQFbqMqTeqH - qHccPDeVrBc3x8+NoFTVJxUVU5sQNZ066uj79YMUJwobmsfx2Qxibbmhd8OWWpyCHuDEKaEV65qk - zT8eyJqtJ/CiEL14sVYYGWyZyMpMK+pFoxIKIW1Qp5R4ShRw1c+ZWt5UP5uACIKDABIweQcVCZwN - /CuBTRxKrBK3ztTroo8hlXmFZnqDJZjmXgUnG2ZVgqkv2z1Fie1AlgK6xk1a9xhS1bdOwxL6UYty - tADtVNFmZsuLtSZTbdOdprbp5iHGLvAJvtRizYJDU12reaPwrZWsWkGzy9YpcjwfTY8rQlDWjoys - lbI35DbqQ6dwlOsaPPg+Dqsm+PIA8py7Usk6Z5U/2f4SC3w3zqysOH0iN6qjXtmgjG0tlKk6RgHs - kkW96cVhzKdroSRZor1MLHGrr6vYLBlOjsCUahjYHozRVDP886DtxqyITE+pnKvGHKPDoQvcPMJZ - VnpynS9fxHGV6KTrcS/mIsppNl8+N8OK9vQaR7X6rYyncAy0sUBZca0XXLPw3GzWBI03E/PkKexi - TiuLTWZ5lMLz5+ZVU1PpAT6sM3jolvGm568+riKheVaXVKYvVaekKo1Ses8jWl0Z2oUFMIOvgN6x - JR4drY90IWc67VbrsDzrPeVPpVzsE5ir3zCV7svqfUmDRHbaIhOp1486QKWgnnr746jj9JUdDYMq - gz7GYv9Jf831NRb66yyo4utCJAxnUF9lYvCk0EG2UR+sU79afhv9YT1Vw7mZGS18TejhBlkcup1U - 0F+lWb8i/fKrhEathN7X7lnR0p5shnXNgv44ZnmhIv1GMqZqyVHXy3P1Zwer9sHqNNYGhmfvT7eM - C/WovBK9oU/7EF2tDygJPBaLzubZm9alr3658pCnWVnoG9Cq3uiYGxeZh4l6xWsB/V6BN60dck/j - EtY+fV6Wn9necc8bX16+fXt2f/5pIf8+uPx7Nvzl7ZeTUfTz34oi9u+CyY+xvJ7888PFp8/Xp+/3 - hrfDiT+KP+BZxxaQmKAFXlq9XXbUifBKlpaFMLcNUOmGYdOw1QR59dHxeKQvjB2FVyvCQa2AmpYq - rqISrU1GP/VFc7OxUiNSZwHpzAxf6xmyvmZXfZJpJGyDXKv1qgEx6/pQ1t9NVDavK0M5VV0oBDOs - JDb2GU1VtJudXvOftrbqeS6xVZcnXUt8xwN/sHqvaonEzdZrp+66jCLXj6s2i/JGp8g5lHGmkQa8 - jr4GucAhgTa+R/P6jQFVv9vPbWOsL07XuVllKfPqQwtTK103BgXoR07IWRyQ+pr1UBFuDUSwHRwr - mBUsT8wtgyJyoEYSCnBqbjGrs6nJVidUM6if6VdHEFfTA6p4dcczhzO8boQizSkETnKPOh17j34T - xkEcDr684rAHcLS1XeqZ84+SoZeaFSvGrR6izP8PAAD//6xbzQ6CMAx+FV6A+AYmysG7xDNBWCIR - f4K8f1x/Rlu6RE08iWzr2rJ169f2RSyx2rhhguLxCdD19KTR5qSRzTazNLoxCl2e59XNoYLX6bvS - XBIt802M0Gj/h2oQSrhdTQEtY3KcWNlxLQ/zejU4RmpeND2lp/RZ4s4rImI0BYcDiJDzkEzVsUS1 - DKwlcahqCpDHgQcRwmb84ljXCNsRVcbyxsfjWozDNRTovEhpPlDahzkl20IVDqB80j+Rib+QcBNZ - 7oIMVxuEBUX6aEyfAKFlrHMOANaDNcTbLldkDsZuTKAwZ1MwHyB2LxVNM+hbe5yzyZFuk06RHbNk - QCb/IDJ0KTj6pRBLf/rLh/a/RFmoG7xOArhmJbc39HyHe6mG+RBWm0X6pYPBZJy86OXjvZ4+2geP - 4gSlZdjdouaLvi9hfFpV/6YxrzPgsPFTFgXycoAGg1O3WjlaWVmImrY9HDScFQMbBN1GjlrjLpL4 - 7xsAAP//7B1rcxs37nt+xY7axsm1svyM7TRRmjrNNXNNelfnLtOnZ6Vd2WokrW9XcuL++iP4WoCv - 5UqW7d7U02lsLsAHCIIgCICJAwQsZqK3VZdvkGoCPd9di9HSh0wAVQGsbqaRkvtlCsnUyUU5gy0J - 6V6meLPRpovJfAxxk2VeQZSc6nKieKLMzyx+qNLL/IskZ8rz5Au44sqYIBO6HrKDApCulU1IPtFK - CJlQsTG4HDUU+6KKktham+6frRtoXrEYvKiXQtvcDAincM+XuyEVJwOcG0JSE2zOelpPGLRkWblZ - YZpykl8LUUlNSXS9rckqal4HXXnN8YT9BsANyuJ1wFQKzftZWVxkxYdZl18XdsgUYEA3jULUr9U5 - gZnEVEeciyqmep8ClkQ6BeXJQKCqlFieLpB6mkg31PBBfeLIlGIWFTS8GpwqqAlZyy/lboaJr07g - fWThJS1IbUXa97QSqzZtwrDG7IkNzxw+/1Fasesb0W1dAPGMayDYWkEIWklcNhHO2z6tRThv5Ljx - UVKNauvGTGFaYZuzImp3DiEbVuYT33Vc79kgHb4H59qnHPSz3eef7bxk/3n8Q9kX5SHK4XZh6XZJ - R4Ts6L++Sr5GxUsPEhnZb3WMuB9yiMd1UdTwlBtvd5rOUhhH83KwUNwk+IR1RkImErLuEdiyhW6B - /+9QN+jpXt55dgse6VDJc6PwXehyc6L4Xa4K/lWG8CsoaTDT8d0IcrgoSzgFeSCpToM0Fl6FIZrr - q2TRgjoJi+AT3EtbFshRnqpREjAlAQygU4jcKc6Uvok1eOnixoVBp/9C4CUSr9Z30QGXanm1hK6d - fSmEcLpXEsZoAevQFqYW3tYZxLDpsPnwqLF4qKJJNVQi1V7ySojaT49FUFUOa0eaceQcCcKrNHQW - T+DdUg1cYWKFX3Gu/MYJLnqbmHX2VVzuk56AEDNCoWUChL5KQhWAhAiH/j9fv3qBoMD4DWP1OOg4 - zz0EggPcmq3a2Wnbq8h99uISDp+KzMOXBUBOX/p4QvRSct7AXxIK5vIjaDJzn+/QE52U0XDCHM/O - iPavhTNYh0bjiToOnO/Iurgx3jkEYYJH0+tqU91nyEITRd8eqNMA0/Yh1dU4q8gJn6+pwZWy/fjQ - 5GeAdqKzar24ZpPqNgNyGwW60gQGTRIYvVvd3mpQi9ZhI7Amj+1hlslAmMe5KRxzhRJjrqpsCSvk - 62O0NKXxXBdI6Woyn2pGZfwRsxhqXFRUGPsAlXoyWlhZcsVfyQP482EtB73o8kZFYJsy1o/lELVe - YFvex3dvWF0y7erkPzaoKdipRuVlDXlWwlxBfZboBAhDvHVqIGZ66ytfQpAMEeJ+1AEzvWR/bW5u - esCjz0jNhhMMhUxR1KwqbPNacAoKUo//MGmGYGue2C3bMTgbRF5XSmBvJA5DB/w4ooQ4QTzg7SxU - GiNonrmhaZE0JBPDi7xzQrZ+YZl1xB3Bzz15oKgNYg6iEDOXfzO/V5ON7OjoSFHmw/RiPjxPVZAh - nPiIO4qG2Jzl857+q8czq1yU4yrf/L16VkJwffmUzc5kzFjmfjGDhfRU/HMsUI7TyQROle72RTRh - dt1KB7eMaS72ahs2Ka9V3QALR5e3sYyaITpXw8XpG3FtttYnIlQWzfW3rH8vq2+QG6uwVnEiMj1g - tcK4zMKViYmU2SE6iPF0ERbDgnXVp/52InZOcFed59PHiTK4oFS/Rtt++hvNSsp7m+j02tfaPU+r - c131VjrcOjjcOdof5Qc7jw5GB7vZ0cHwcDvdZ9XvHu3l6WB/b2sny3fzw8Oj3aNHo3R0NNjdztLd - ozQdZHUPIjWGCGVSdHdeBFRI7YcgfDa6acWk3rh6T5jgbRFSKzG5hFmfzPIP+XB8MQYhIub7uUhy - 2TEcJjjmV/nHFFyceIp2xD5oCHXBRQrX8UwS/PZz2v3jefenre7R6ebn3V8//6ouYH/9son+3Pz1 - 8087yTT9OMlnZ/NziLrf6mgirGsKINdmtB7PYFcg9wnfqFagNekrLroeeu/sP+q4yXx95NYG0jWe - oDwt0dwMUaeoxF2V6/ShpBdcKYjfOsZ5Sx+1Ig4xKx7RQvayRiTZaMTJq+lkZTPNeDacLLKcyWnI - KQyxl+nEabwka2l4ng/fD4qPHXpWeCUqS17nJ9+K3Nk86QGoD2q2Xe3hFeX+TlaYEyTE4kvWqbje - MRqD2421qWfD4+un9dykfmfBnJezWhvuSC83XCJ89Ni+zO8RHn03qt59+zp7Dj/Hk38M5t9f/P6v - nYvXv59Vf/94eXnwJvvp3dHilXYnRml71cFDnTO0Cl6WRalzYmDvM+FdQ74nCotx7jiTFy4KVdxE - cJ8y3YFYMXZrR322M6znrO+4zMdgvltQfj+d65t9wXVrOuvTY1LV5pDPexh5ym9ymNAoaz7mx83I - Suf8GEVZHudkEhG1ByA/6JZVGCp3vrfz6NFu+mi4O8gO9/eODkfDweHhwdHhEfs1zw4Go2y4t5/t - 7R9kg939ncPtfG87HeXbu8Ph1v7Onu5Hg8miliPoutdvtfBBEdtFMoYM98UZqGeQfqGKN2ng+vkt - tFgM2r6AGSqEsCgnnJ5PO5/4LrObjRS7UUYKpoeCeQ3djStDxa50171Xmyp89CPWhwZad1Eshd+U - QQGqacoqK7VepjMTSJfvcQVxa4RM3JjUgwhG5/ceqSHNMnDwcwDKevwAtKIhN5J2mfxQdc7yD3Z1 - TWC00rN83lX3b2ATqS0oojbvd1qNCLHqMoUfdwhWdBefuBx0QeCALTxpOTQFx/Qvi8Jh0bN8PRyh - mTKL4m1eGZnX/MPzAt5dOysLiHeWvg5sHRWiRK642seKfxPgXf4IXn2ugqBFLcLxGDmOtS8EVx1j - GgvBsfpcYJKSNZQFIQnqQm61AVruWYE2zU2wBj3l5DmF3rh17yCR+irSIGF/IRclS7GuZ+daJ0rJ - jZjZ8sJGT5m/NThHaTv33ZlV3eGWU1vjyV0snSWqLGaWRdgwPlCZ/jegOqpIEEemPq8NJKHyvNJ6 - KBIEEQOsN4fV7IRvIBvFVbEoEVUe1+Qg1MGBXAlKN1tPq2BE58ZVAwXXAxqXRvCrDS5obfH6+bf7 - /10U8y/vp9OLL5/en7DfzuZf/tL79W86xAoSBonc+JwvGD+zivNSJEPkGf3gm0jFACndOLU4LR8n - rsrRnYZhrdTlcWvJWkRcSp26yGmsoVkxOx2llwV/pRQjuIwuxl4gtvx5UXQhiUTiO2MLXQvo7zhl - G6w1XVQQx5tMIPx8fs6WIaMGorR9RMG/Ri0op5K30qrS0iPKBnl8XsBpNY1YQcgUGd0HQ2YGjZL+ - JeKrro1ot66lebNOpnSy5oNPH2x80tzFjYebjK8ePIQo8mTjJfAypIPbeJg8w38mj5MNzexQgjqy - gazVhv3Rw/3wENEVN750WY84v6/K//8WmWh5wGGamUI2yRa52pig9ieDEu1xdfxoX+a1Zd1L0rNU - ZkDyrxr3jhWwZbW1Y/ltWC77Fdt+XeYrO7jU/rxUiIpX2zDTh2QZPuhKGmK7SVsblsN+ZZ+gnSYs - h/kKa0IODMOA1WDiwEhBE9b6yW4Yr5Dhypn7Ns7CQ4IW/CYeL9h12XhIA1FGHh+GaeVxhWVcs5nH - iPIwTD21ocdLRZ9rShjhusw9mqRyMyGtGqaJKJxBOofI9vEf4IFgoxDYjPXmDLL8YtuSG8L2enE1 - TkxLNCGVib66CUhXNb1iTa1gnuH4qKt/UidfHI3FdGhblQxYgMglam31MWqs9Z7Ebw+SlWBjA6Gm - oB+muLifm151aaGK7jPLsc1CGQCsNJNYbTZrsCPDjKt3IUPoCNTJWv1lhyI45sqg3w0pa3rRXqOu - 1sSIt3XP6NHTNDhNBIJglPIkxrimi0C5R2Hua3MZiPEi7wSbdAoTc81Xg1y03hkXYOh5Rv1DHQE9 - Tgiqa7kie5B6RGqJUqh8GKZCReCiFao4594fQXbwBmTyHqVL7ajYKhJO5CSTT5kKIzQqU9aWL6+b - SLXkIgp/sTUGEMMSCzIfKf3HKLbxSHvtFA6BlFd3Sb1YNXZIk0K+Eui151rALfxBuTkOnoFDnNns - soidAKnmzH9cRmD5IybAHp4JZ60DJ5SL/52Ayl3BLFckMstv11x8/b6rhEI8HdmKfsTynRu+vkP8 - AkzA6JC6Jl70w5pp0j3HF+3h+6Snam/0I2Tq2hzXYtHKTs1miKtO/y2rQyVe4+P2JX/ynQOoIGZd - L9npKi3PxjP+Dkm8Vz+nGZ8cSHtqe7++KxYTrq2KfGbc/SZZXGSpfHsYLjXlQGT4xjM0hYZjvmrH - sTVxnzmxWYtHEwd5NrgKdu0JU57BV8yRQLB/wmWQ5CyeiDT5Ac4hydciIRvjLo7sOU4tf2giZx73 - MLtXeeXRY+rPDh6XNJLyR1QiDlWhM1VD+66Lhx/zKuqkFaIDeRWhEKdQnX4wgkazIkQi+NpIoZn9 - lkIDYWahmIhO/02x1AFUsXCEKOa9qNisZotJ3pxDLCy0EyPDZoOfuwwae0xGYg1XyBM7XidVMQXW - fMpohEAnGmRUd1BM6nx5yYM6W5B0K1KZ5c005kFtz05x3hdP0IIofmgn5yNJFuLMPLEyOsCXI9ih - 4O2O2GgFiBSRKI0zSQO/A23OCjYHZabT0OjrQA+esT6or/+UkegcZPRr8YvLu99C+pDn7wHnHf83 - CiVjbHcFqfvHboSGXBuxk0xIIMcGhrcxIKTmjuWZZoXHmsjSFnP97hzesGUoz5aca0/DvgkPz+zJ - YgaV8BeWRuOSqTiiJGq6GDcYyKIkCvntIq8MbFkUhf4uz2ZWBbowrgfni9LqgiyLquBlOTbQRUkU - 8gkk4TRpL8siFwvBjUWDZWmgyqKbWnFCMLRecBLtxtebu904+Upxo1biEutvqVW33FpbfoUtsa6W - Wk2hNXQ93BzHrmUOEfHxfPoDh5cZr5bVA4xG45hUIgXp+6IYniymwZhED87byJhEC/15VFSiF+1t - bFiivay+efHdqzffBLPV3CAjiUvqeEbiwVjpPJkW1dJ8ZLQZx0cSKUjbbcgOAMfzqJnY7+hA2f4+ - R6ui8La3WDNbLRB2GMJOG4R9hrDfBgFcDPrg5timU7xXAZQoNiQI7jhZa/55Ro7xiJ2uZTZi98ne - AeY44ttQUXzv74PLCC59QPSYHGsiv8xnyYfznNthyxwMtLMN8WonmMSkLSy0YpbSfWQmRZA/kE5e - RMPFL3+ZJgGkWbQI+P5CKFYJoIHhOY8xE4SMtagXprGc/7hNCAEEFzshHId11yJ/OzP5rQXrrisv - l7CcecF8ibl0ZnNBuzVdzlv3nW2TcWXy1YkWSbnct89uzDVfzcfNzTqv5utQVzPHsPNuPgh1c4k3 - deAV5G/j77MwIQCPVtYR3zIDsniIuxjN4Q5XEsROlhUc1l9pOv9f0nRi5zcz7SXtHs3527vD28ba - cjyoNXEq10T7LeRmczvy+0Kc29GQBGWbrcUcfOT2Ehait7LFtJ7Gm3IEK6vKvceYH5rdvq7X/Qre - CXuZ5yquw+F6ZfbQt0M44ZZ2tILaRqxf1MkKlzqcpeq3HoVHg3JxuTvSeRWHFRh8k99TG/8mNfUr - +zaR7GtvXL5Gjd5PemzmZ8WBIV8n73cxfRsbZvmf1cUJBjoZwwuCy1ypL3mPqxuNP2q/WUwHeQk8 - xq00iXydALNao+nNbtZrcKtBGwxn/f0WlrI4UGSNQ2nr+ttxLQkTWwvjWiuz2hLWsTtuN+BK1p2y - HNTPbd6Q/YC11Ea3Y2sjUp2zVJT/RyNBm21YypXZe1Z6cdW0M4u3Kl0+fLDPfse++nZXsn0SpYyj - dfDuibZL0WAtKlHzdYHcrFQX7AWLKOh7GU49dOtW+WoCSSZX4HYAXjNPmNzAGnB91llQLuj98TEr - WFlxbwoQR69w0jd4RIkIVVRFUwDQaZhl62kF71rL+vhrnlCg3uEM6vb35P9d73CqN3p1ZSiwVT6h - 9FyA8nBVXzuGsNKnPFWs/hYvQvneBcTi6/uLHNgCwBN4dBq9IiNN8dl4NMpLbr2aX01yK//NKskX - WGNeGPwYowuE6XA6c62K2VCz2dMfzNdl5UFGEYoPiakvk6kTTr4FIl+hguWEGxF2rJ7hXEjf3Dpm - IzSfkX7C31KrJUdvWGl/Qu5sWFzmJbwYxV9e67ENo0dKNgHeeAixjp2X7aM3jgjbE6ann7JB/biU - yWlWAyRNh5/fSIJoePVCNgac9frqzfHXr3BFm2HBhBMKOGSh/VDi8H1QRDXWZuUvlAN1xm41o5H4 - oJt7H1C+D2f2ckyg1FiCzIxfGDR4GnGjZFaVSU49TxdKZml0UVYk5VJgLA4TjON1OjuFhXx60LOE - /HcJ/WCySDnNf2WLXGO2yCXSPF5X3sZbs1C1ydUYjjDh74Eune1P8vfdycsYFuEEybsrEKhwZsaG - 9FuIPE0ZGevHWVedjD9p7sWbm7k6i2Lc9LXMumg9aovX6v8AAAD//+w921IbyZLv+oo6bHgGwkgg - iYuxDScw+DYDYwd4zuzsiROKRipJbbe6tN0tsObp/MM+7Q9sxP7Gfsr5ks2sW1d1VesCwhaMHA6g - u+uamZWZlZWZ5aRYvGt2xdmm8C3zKt5zQkV3RrrGI8+oOGmF3EdmxSVOqeiurPK1MyWR4lwLaOEp - FKfkTizpvcDy7j154nTevIgkirVvlURRm9WXOm3itAw87pXp008AHkZWxGnkNoMeME9exFVKxHuB - +QxJERXxcgOvh57FTxs9A6AfRdDK8mS9m2zqlALdsXJiE3JXzV10suCLo7Va6MMKrUBBLEN56TN9 - qLvexeFeKg1s0n7IbxeSbl6VHIYd2g1GUaZKFe+4Mkq2RwkaYstKqt0g7QmBbpwi6CQRHEqcu5lo - l2A64cHJxByiSzpyii01RauYopdCoZa2AZUbl05FFel+PtHA1EnYsMNuYIstduE+m49EZqFV4xSh - qKhTDAUp3jEFUDau77JGL93kveHRvKbxSk1Gin+hECuHP2mMCzOAkYtTk/2oyaia3IldnCgY60FQ - oLrLbfar07z3YDtBRdPvvc7lbdkSN37Kcx0D7ClrIyDw/EB5RLmHJbzWZV+40qoMn4bpw26EW+5T - TvWjmJv8O1U0humDG5ljQstgtA0939rKgFeAMor3FG6FnELgFaXZX3F/c/g+TsNeP0ufNLbhI4Nf - sBeAn7Tbhdnja9aFH2+SkHYSGrb78ACo/hoG+CnW5SPazeDXNTSfoGkc/h6lMGr4/akOPwawdxSP - wOGxPCxF+NULOgzmFY4G2GfcR4Y7oE9eN548235yvAcvlfl4a6vEdJwfZUguo6CHgOVAI/mfVQkN - WTQRuwkAF6gwwFJihnZn/TkLkh7NDtc+ihOUS4EPICSgZo636kc2HA1VacF/+Ad9QgBE9snqcoaT - Jkcx5f0WPsrVpOZzxBPjiAwbJYSANsJu0KZXjH3h1MD7TOSv2rA//OvocMHgVv19S3i/sftcMMC7 - Vxasxco3riQxmQAf8pACD4u8Z+MFieZxYFFTZDd6hnl7TnFL2KdQqaULC3FfenZtD9wRTaYUKJVS - 4t9H1aMlOYoRcT6xZTUD7Mw0KhY8+9TRtuqrGPIk+bqyjs9KyvjPFFXHDsi3iqpdPgTTRSFXTarD - JOQXixqzU4oKVJiM1dt6NZS1Y7g1tARF+lQZiVUcXlF/qZQj1eflJf6U3Ign+7HkZRxoIuBOCvAc - 9gLMniGVQPkCFUELLx9xE2t8LHo1dEcRKCGhvoeoRPQCsdoNyQHrVNu5KOYnD6a45YFw+sZM+cwr - RaGqJP2hxZWe+dZYuUlXHHqTI+Hb6k84UMJNcCQYZX2WpLBvN+0SLnUgFFvQSAlbs/2zPR1wNNms - bfoslTJWnGZB9y+bp44Vv+Pkcp2Qf1fNzjalCdMD9tSFfWNWZd0qqk8JZqQrTNVXZsq0T2QV7sOq - mk0z+CpirO4GDO+ABGAmd3wrCuiGvRE0U4SKfD0FEG9k5TvOWHUmJikbnTKbybPiSgoFfdSZWP5l - ytwu8ibuOD2jSzHDvOlboWxAU5kotji5/MuUyfE7kEUTd5yc0aWYXN70hMn5J5aOYOEHPqzlX6ZM - 7DJv4o4TM7qUmz394o6kidunjtwROtRpfJxKoLwsMAKx0w75Jel3pFSze0WsTjdzI7aXBHHmTFa8 - nTLLt6Iq3tfdHfEAv7tOUnYrZuc2P/fkEFhs5MgV+XrK9NDv9gNUrgqDIPA9NkoWQL2qdzHLsl4m - E7LS+0yvV2k/0pskDKPlyhqqIQw2psOIZqD9sW5XH2aa81VBEHp+dg5No+RQHHa0tZJYzhptg5DW - lDxKkh30MFt7EwxWM6skdot+CT9ZuN9m5FquSpFa3sb0tkwhlsuv24zKlBi5sPC3VN6KyZ5zzny3 - GVrMz8P35h2j4jQuk5m3Jb2cy1Zy6cTzkJ6XW7AQhce68mvnvuZqRzcIwvxMSjnkquvLTVd29fJI - jLny8i/VKll7E0bCQ2E4jELaWSNow0gJRjmIFDJ8QYcpjLkTJoIJdBM2UImVq9Uj0dIVbQejlKr3 - XQYgg2aoTDfDCzqYlT9f4uKnSWETJ4Zv7qAsUHs3nyJltHp0wmN17WILCkjKwdsxjVhPshlfAwKx - +Y7VLPMZvsWBPmclyuYjvLPzY1d7DqqW12Llb1mVJd46lslK1rSOqKzSUhp8jNglorPwMbgK4w79 - erhWiCAtHEg6s5n3JNIUN59YrwcSQkGPAJ8d8RQasm3iH2v5TS4fz6D8h1hl1zAPjryocK1iRfjr - sTl/GMdCeSvC5Jc/W2c306fpdV0u91dWR1a5qaU4fMlLuZ+hTmgsI7HxhjhhK+aGZ5uGq14jqVCt - tv6KEuPwSaOB8H4K8IY/n+y+ws6f7J5ygZ+CYnKI+dv1U4tHhx5i3nW/C999NW4bdkWKnjBuibm3 - 1LLBEzlu1+Nt6sV0dZXQ60NFVzO4NYoOproyqg68YC6YHHXvR4WCMvM8iA1xRGd9Fi4jysnUg/w4 - GuC4+eH5zBQAwCQ+aEJjLdmYf07FZzJL+mz4WzZaQhVcxXx6zLEUcn4PNDK17zKsqRl8a+z9cnZO - TkTXs6BQ+khJTN4SddBIK2MqZZW/ArcjT/LNNa6bOPwxn+nfET7/cAL7b71YrLFOgff0YWgnq8IH - 6dNzmV925OLB8PI1f5oHAUOahKyzdlTLz/yNr22Mg29sN3bIeTAmze0X9YP13Y3ndLu53TzYO6ip - lPBSgsltX1FjKrQoQ/5YaMwJnp6T+nat3tyvb0l6rQ1ByNRUV6oxIwl94UehJ9gMYtreZIzZnkx6 - prkfFMG5lTRdmXACgl9f9usFxbGanzj4xqdUM0LUSTxu3Bj3yJVn8LiZy8/fiTh9x4NOLIPn7kSf - uhN+5k4+1Yk8b+cbBtyEkPyknehz9jir5Dv2l1v9unXAY03ViuWEdmhVbofFzCqquEchNguqlive - IuYBi33XgfGdR4GQNYOZcJ3Iyc9hyeKP9BpoOoqeXrzmwrEtWmyBSqXjCM3KlsCVZbV4tUrOxBEc - biBaLG1M8t0Lhnrza6JGDzvKwhu+rNPRUAOq2w0jIUW04uQCsgo1gPENg4Sfth39EF+lwxdqrQdl - jWlrzDmLg7QP/D7phOw6SNujKEjIBZXbrRMkR7pJRLF38DLjdHiKPWb8fANIGo/120BIZP2y3Wcs - wncnSKFtUCcv26GwmweZbIZAO1HW31DNkl/jEGCQhtmYN26V2oSWgjHw/E3ytxBdisNgkxyP0PQC - E6qt6SMKrU2bc62vefEPRRyGS0i98EYwWgBwgWmywSBYO9q0Qe3hrncmddjeP/359wdE5T+HmMwF - tvi/o5Fx7ch+/j4UfhpehynKAiRKTuag2IyBrPphBHw4/uHfvjb2X6TkHUuHILw48X6Eb0GHRsM+ - UlvhicZxOo6ugxifgHTRdHGZqcuhjgewmttTCbMxD2E2lo0w3wDvip6eHz8g0jwPki/kmPCRrx2Z - TyuyfCxkedKno7j39Pz83UMiTNAEAxqRc/KOiAkAeTrvvhORWmLeJNMLNgaaLCNWIEdYYNeg1dBb - ie3mPGTY9JHhfcPiY4CujKiqp5um/sK1oegKdzj0rlDYmQcKO98GCkIF1PrhWwzmBj1ulHQYqosF - etDlYEcEDYyyO8Nkdx6Y7C4bgzpnYfL0t8sHxJ1+AxkyQpTj0NeOrMfVjmW1YylKYJZc0fjp2UPS - DM/YKEwpaINi8GtHhRffh8xfJaM2JWe0m7CxJGp+SvOWxjQL25LWNN1/Sx68Nw+J7i0diQaw4OOn - bx8Qhb6NQLknYuBrR+bTSi2cTy38noR3ii4k4/aX8On5qwdEfOfoghCTV0SPn2+fC+9WTHLhTHLx - 4FLTiHNdR0IqJZc0uQ5B6bnrvPfnmfd++RrVhzUqzkSf4uiTmor7kx9+mNlbjePWkjMQ4bXo9WZS - Bz3H+fxS872dF9WMEFfNyE/o7pFx9xJ91lIxFhsQKQ97wkCiKAqGuZdKwd9F+bIUW5nk6FKa/0CE - gtOs3S9mq8SsKqoLO9tZ2KkOAb3hV54pXwLTJNRiHNlrPijPCZwZtlYpHL9NQxneaSPA4HNMc4BU - cjFC/q+SY9TqpdiO7bXjfNfOWbP+9s3NWEupNczSyCfxr0CjupYOgZLPdiCUHQflAJ3XiEJJpcYq - tyFh71+cVU7IHMUtKfKFjteO6oIjkIe+8VPhc4uCdGM+SDvFXUg3JKS/k2160QBqzgcgp7gLoKYC - 0H0pwIsGwc58IHCKuyDY8YJgIebQRU9+d77JO8Xdye/Kyd+7FXTRoNibDxROcRcUexIU31MFXzSU - 9ueDklPchdK+hNJCNO+J01XBOerJUKi8ekfuzTXBD8r8Q9Qy1AfQprKwG1JXMzI/HVUKTb20J2Fp - j3lFotK9VJwiVoob2RImfHmuXhhea2LQAEDME6h2/DJrUdjRGyPhsErenwKLl0owNMJr6Y2A5Qsn - YJXPZO7ZDdqzT+1k0twCs7a5lVcZOFpXUWC8lnk7rGQdRVOD0KpbYSd3Qc7fHcKA6vV686BZP+Cf - oBjP7ADvdXtOthLHmRYgsCUbTfFBNZkncHCNGkhhLSs/RNGmwYElvh7l8FNtS8IP7genyuNxBpye - fni/TBid5JhpoRjG7UExOkzD5Gss6W1NaupOmNVdK1RM6ukWiFb8s+KxHNguk9V2FA6vGCh9MnGt - mVvlPRoGQ87mRZlKWTYNnxUijzXKn33BRsZfj8dNteKFtwCEFT9Vapa1F1ne3FQzrlkgt+R6XDS9 - LtTy6o6iXY5iXt6abVE2h2as/VkcqlWQUE4GyrV86nhqdu+esTjdFnyq4WsWDqjTyRhUNp4xjuJn - vKSssSM8yl9u4ZvpsCqMzTu6yiSznkksIhOjbRSqyqhhnmhRp6NLaYYZXQsmFl+ux4KJqURDVNa9 - 6aULFr93eL/PhOIWHxe9tBTrnlDNFyg3w+Bmu7ZrbtuhU9VnR5Q48FgTedIsOeoiudiWRPXP1pIr - y5oSs2LbkNWsv3dWzIqDiFlSY1ZMVFTIDGnIbpMm003QWMw65uUMbvLMMo3uFnk0raYWn1JzwK5C - XLaFTJqVuXITuKVLEmr6SrpJNSuVKbdDVqw39t1pnnVaTEE2s7Xfy9mmWPxthjN7uPa3CdE2VL/H - EKPtTuchBWlPHP0qSnsVpb2K0l5Faa+itPMKqyjtIh5WUdqLitL2xmkbf0/7cz5PD0P0l7t66IFN - jJKe7r2hs7bmM7UdN1aB1qtA66UIWzCWxeOJW1hFWj+CkNYSynzYMa2rUOsVXS4jXa5irR9cUE0J - Hf7Zgq1LwPDnjrYuAcoq3HoVbr3at+h/S7dvWcVbP6pQwhIaXQVcrwKuH6puuIq4XkVcPxg2uewh - 1yUTv++Y62nxJGW/de0HGd9aqjC6x9LF86JVhOtiYF0a4jpr+UcU41oqoecD0cOOci213cwHhIca - 51pqpZlv+o8j0rVUC5gPGI8+1rVUaZgPTo8w2tX+UxScEOBqAGYV4Tp1dqsI11WE69JgdBXh6o1w - XWRoazG41cjTJWI9+V188rI+a0co/c6F0yhGowIGC37tYQyYr94kwTCPlSj6MqrX2reRRzP5Yyds - L/sPQFhEFOdRgroNggjDOXfCLr/kEq/gHEfUiZ3zmIOCa9pK+0HiOIAX8Q6dlZaRA0TK9xYJokgH - q6TFUDz9wYnDE6FqOhoTpwQLLBp4y0mHfxlBhavL7IR+HYJU3CoYm+x4sROYobbzqQgLX6ylRQnE - ejcZm1LKOYjk12KqoBsMcg6+OLC2+AhWsAJijuyYkCUMIlzGCMK5gwf9UC5GDd4mYNAf/jIxNPCu - 8YD3EQSormrSy8EOBpw9EnC2KMDpEYA6/s/j2+78tK9mtbi/hgC/VFaP21QmXvYbZaZBNT39Qouf - fsNRc/yqv388VUkr+o5qz3aJZxvEcGd71CW98Be5EjT0BOBbWnw6uqq6ltBXQftLL8FbcJ8bgjfX - 5I0WPxWyNXBr4vrZ3zZImzOAlNz0Mb8DawPDQSnn5nxYf3NxerwBxEnhu7rPOxoT6B62PhljnZpc - asOjHMX3DoRzmvVZJ50KAW6zCtpkEPTEDh1vSI4xFQVZPzm/2CAhfMGkFTdBSoY0wdUEuySR0yIg - 9druJ5K2A1Q+ED4wmM88PwaXLQgagCDj0OmzAftj3GOjlFsEgH3wmAFlYYTnEAMiY1Inb4+PYRxD - GnDNAlNqvPn3X0gPdNsaGgwxWqJDBjRIRwnPmAHdgephDA/aO/sbzClNEZvnG5v4SOMOykjASQTz - vGbRaEDx8+tTwDcacrHMZxlw0U0EH+EF3mzUyC+gCVxTTOOB915/lcoPZnzAqjw1yFckcRpFnIpk - +3k7r0+gGz7OURZGYQrDBJAOYIuPt0DDiP2EiHoV3u48GLM2x1VEuuFVwtIwnZZIBBp4+3qDY87s - MpCdSigBoKNAVlAt1wTqetJqk/K4gGzMmwKg0jTVNIAz59t+aBCxZOAugpUPVLAOr+ob32UVXPAb - sKevAuADgBeOnIOmj4jX95ok6GBbm6S5DdxBWKs2ye7OEwAn6LtAYwcIUSD3AekHAGm8uHvUpkhX - r9+Q9R+i7MXu7hMgpWPCiY6AJGM3HIAxyqiIJFzp4CsNliEiBMi/efBkExoDMibBFQMSdCpAoUYD - CwE58GXUTmBt8I7Pt0RXCdIrFnx28ETPr0bex3JWYqqBahdHvIkdJWI4vNUOYDXGrS4ZAo3w1dBm - Cb8FXq5hHCNvCDEux0Ni2gucwqK7Ht0koNRAryQNByHSvCqR9sOhXNYppdi9BnqNNy/AJAcC/Fa1 - DtPmjcd6vfJFCvWvGPYppotDy5GIT7wSrFEsqTANewcEAqw+oDHWlmdrFijkrAX7AEjXCKy5Igob - 9SdYUMF9E1EUjTAT0ZRB2ZSohskAZDZ1AXvCC9+hDwF5HBLwWIF7wRvxFnk0IXJWA2P8LuvxhOHE - keVPXZLHsQl0WCvZDaWxZocgK1C8clWR8/oS9uiwMBTiXCxZKNIIjfhJBZaoKnKC1mGEo3Y2SqB1 - qRgAnqFDwVN9HJS330UlhBMUGYSwtOQ5iIe/cNRCjZhletqKkn39I3b9LNoRwtainhPr5dkoFLJM - pBWzjRtn5Kqnl8N8ozEcJ5hcS6i1+aPo7kQ9Pyf/9788/FFHpxGRNgqYNoCZo5ng7h82sW0QTETa - tIBSAGohsBcUVaiMccaJXi98CeDDCfBJziVO2GCAK/s4E1WQ4s7CNo1T4FBCBQTlYhACTEcxEA2K - aN4uftcdhUwuWyCIhMHq5O0g+uMxqCsdEM+bQHPsOuxQoTIASYByBbgR/ghizfMkGVxlauOihX5q - FYkzG4TQMfwF3C0RMDSeuQ0yUL4++YettaIFEXSHVr6ljaA7kBWgV7VQEcSRKEsOlDP2tLI94amD - 3+TGjEO6lav70qp+qmtwi5wiQCdNTRdUs6zKulW+vgHQijo8X2REZ9nO50TWQWSrOrCQYKo8yZog - b9wCiT/NhGqqkHtw4dsoAUK+DqI4ff5VWH4Mi/dNUxhEDw4Otr4KUImig0FUUvDZ1nmQ9fmP8zNV - fFjXpcVuVJjPgcfy/Ba4jZGuYKB6XGO2LJhKwoks4OIVNyYU03lpUKSgrwLh1iQq7FVtrf3CMi6E - MptmgrAHhKOyzsgHw/hZvkcl5I0obkgFjZqSboTjijh2imBFpd7UIfgP3VxSYDCU/8WN2AqaabtP - BwGH/XvY6NC3IPJpMp6QC0f0bo9Fut6529/5Ov/A2XZ5M8A6hrD91uIB/VgCf3GRRwDBUvWnoLEK - 8rULxUc9PqNq3dmmG06FYsbe1AYzZZ+wDn3CGBYbbFe29NHPVRhvWQH1ve3teu3z0E0fYQJFmiJ+ - TSJPMW44wiQmwKVp52qsJ9EOhOXKB5uJaRpUjjbEWvUm7GT9w7X9/WeTy/UpyrPDtb3dKQWDCErB - giA+RyphcB60+cG1ca5VVlRRKJR2wOrxfXsZDnoFVGf90eBqzQA2fxEHoQ/W+I+bqWTKJzGjEuIj - aE++B2rphd2SDg3Qki2HyFE0Fd8NaBYYc+fIXpt5LRNJmII8nA4LjQsKuU3rSFPO2F3kOlxULQFS - WBH8GG72cRgLUTQw/UaRkiEWNAI5HHGs5UVpxdiV2FsQxaksszTsXAjHP27D2+XGL063//rn/xAt - Hx1nAEd1FqUKGrP1eg6MVIXC6EfMrYF7n9BCM9CNMAvKG4NAwSAqt6hUue3cuJtzQ7gUkDB+Rcu5 - +mFw+BIo46HzwohfyJihNy/eYhByr8gQ+0X8gKpjkCTsJtXtDMKOucmeZHaUNturIIWCKe0p10B8 - GcZdCqI1wG1GBFveKKrNgfscyc45QsUpOcpT2DnAf7BqnNe3ukSNayyZGte4ZzXOB5v7U+P2mz6n - Up8a5/PRXqAa56L5vtS4EuK7HzWuMYsa13hcahzS1EqNm0MxaazUuEVDa5nVuPojUuPuDRleNc68 - muL2Kl1Kh5lU2/Sxt9GJvCOD2+3Fmb40vcc0kEPKr8VQo6DDcI4RBGi+1PpjwI9Xihpl+s1VSufq - hfzLX6pVcsFYRmhEdYxMn2Xs8iYc0ho5H6WZMNpygiHD9GZYI9XqkeUBim+JMnxKFzLTzKrf5Tmn - ed4Grv2oby67EcM0dJaesH9WR6bw13Zd0wNLGmzJaZ4Rn881974pzFSB5H32I/ogyIhRquHCj5lh - FNxKzYZBm59mpaQbpBk/vAlikvSugvUNAR6b6yKAWq0rdKzTuODjueS2YYKiZwjN8LXBrmnSjdjN - cwGM8vaAD7AoMuUWb/NEGZqFfb3Pog4sSt5RLSePfO7kC6VDXIPRmDTlqh0oij79cI4LB71hyYAO - WDI22jhl8Y8ZGbBO2B3Lo+gmEWPjmxUJvHSTI5GfhnXwcIkvB+hQTc03OTfTv1sGO9EgXWwh67IC - hOqp8P4k6zngfn3fkm83xMFFNwDOiLyMDflJKsCcc8eEBjVyEuA5sTwh7Uya+igk6o+qXBETgACd - Va8C80IEPl5OBpjBnZ/VpTTqYhbUKIgxDnpcIx8weTZweP+gynAywmkWoEmK965IahfvzIdqtR2x - lOqglhN8Iuuv0/aG4ad7i2aFn7Zq9pI/3anBbqpbkxnrUYbDgqM0vlvLfzA20G3/BzwA6WyxUWa2 - amPyY0Ijhr73pAMLkEhFoc24V0AtZICLQYoLDXcyNN4aj1/9xi5sVGI7ipXd4Cl1j2YGS2+1hqqT - KndRhdV+06cx0a9x8SajOEZ6nkwkuoodHV5eDlZfu6jKTCzeHrmemhMrdFgsAOyozc6rGUIiSlci - p8IqsEOQ9M4btZLVFwAkCK/M2nKUNZkxFmXhsMjF7OHMTIFcHapWUdnKw8swlzo6P67zr1wT28iZ - TpEy5+5M+lLI3n7BqAzZE/8yqSuXCwVF5be0DPxBPRzL5fP6DwVUz55JRjCY3U/YWaHtyrmuxrFw - maXX8izllxQd6dCBhKvZ3PVKuZygSsmdxqX7xsfzExlHlM+lfFgSHgp0XLkS2bGrEjntKGx/4TIf - b23iWxc1ZatWW15179Tr441YVj17cDbtFLdF4h6uwlUmpmpXPqzifPj9XNOL5xPhFfzDV1rAOA4G - sBHicUVSL9MUW1iQdgBV7kFv7MdMRAHuMUKprVwUjOcpviQXuqQkaeU6r25B+RF1hLw97pvwo9sv - f58WiNbRUaC8Tlqu5iMnyYuySF6o5nRpbJALX6y7EYUfkQp+w/bcSojfmGXF6jlHiEIDzcpz5ks4 - rMYjTLSM9zGagkCGSdhnzpak0Hl7yPmrTZnpjJwd1/IQ6S7lrkn+2xdr5CcRRU5+oSNQy2qksV1v - vGjsrx9sPK/Xm81//fO/9mt5Bv/6/v7W9rNnze395rN6Y2fnWaO5bY1nmhnOYwao+kxJgdfgVYR4 - mSmeTIqy9M3B34YVwpWjOQ8FZbAFj4NoyNLDSWcMVgCUbmdyBeU2Ns+I/VbC0w/vvca6wC0+CXtL - iNlZQ6Sbe/s7Owd1772B82HZmzlmAVgGaSkHOTteoc4jxOtWo7G/29g5aC4AW94kNgvAlhriHLhy - L0US/+6CLmM74MRks0goAfhhGeXWO3oDu7eLM4xNGnW4h3cXrx0C7SYtyqp//fO/Uy2vXiVhFqZ9 - kY8Kyv8ko9hJ/WDv2Yvm+u5eHUTX3s4BSK7dhim6mntbV4PPtWYNi9SgxDIvA6/gcmaw5GJrpvGu - hFZJXo+DZ3u7je3lFlpykH96obW7t99s1HeWWGbJEa5E1q1F1qeUjcjx75hhahSlsM16/fMmOQt6 - IKVYmpHLnzBbXxINgphcnm0SDEagNyn5+XST/BZGA5aRtxebMg6nRs5ZAuJOBVf59mViR4a5Ffmu - rP4C9P/1Ooi1xsbznT34fWBIt+363tbn2uc4rWHR2vZubbvRXOYl4xNw3kkst4ybech/JjG31aij - VNjeX2LhpYa4Yoi3Zogf2ShNgZ+9ATZIewkP5+X5XoGjncNfr29gZH+Mv5ATzH8aJKDYkI+b5Gc2 - CD53AnKeM8Nj0mhUf6dBQt6wKGI31dEw3xecsbjH7/XUeRc+jLI2k0kEPloxupej5DqEkReY6rFi - qsfnx6ala/c58tNnJh/drm99DoCHi0JYplZ/tru7zMvNy0pL5rHk3HSOUf+5GOreTn2nvnuwzAxV - DnHFUG/NUH+jYYcC9cfIUi9GgwEdI+98FX6OaZySV5vAFFnyhVxukp+CNADlMaMEdMrTPmM9Sn7K - GSoGt/Z5jl2fdvkc3UZ4yijhD8ddydhgzIags455cDbmwtDx8ZvyqK+QikKsUtbjdph0PBhmbJDW - yEmYYCoWLCePE+oNYLR7DdRZmzumSWavvnXy/uLk17PjT+8//HL87hjeoRJ1sLO/v8zr0Wud2cPU - eHrqQT8wJrPcbHciHla8t9HcP6jXG8vMe+UQHwrvrahiLHLYat6IL5lnYB7/GhkKcwbcB/UxiHR8 - hoUe/NiCj60CnlRhfqDflh5qZYfF9oA5KmL6NasO0Re0kCszr62pZwZkF9HLh40pJO1ErpfoQ4Be - xTsNknck4Z27guF/2wegIn+Yh+QVo0yl6H6Sl61ozOBp+oCmfa6ap/oIPX9FvtDxDRB/WpWu17k3 - TXlSg3N6+U7kG9E0YuQ0MNJo68aFcEZZbhKM/KwSGxKV87F6FbH2Fyfba6G4ygdK1G/13WUWpg+I - 9MlTfZEBjUc8b5usTo47DDZB6OxiN5I7IG97Ws8JsjjMHNjFaHFeUd0vf7jWDaK0wEtEMBUoKTSp - hr2Y5V7a+ShtWtJon3EYJbDV4HH+8CajEP5p+bOV0XIWSPvSex63ZZbQ8lSeDqnpCahrkJDktOeU - yLxfDWOV2BZLFcjOL2usu6WeNBr50OHhye4rXBJPdk+5LElZkh0C5qh+ajH0mD3E8AunZY7i+2ve - Zq18/q0wbon5tyTUcjmIVHL4w3+OWPYiH4N4/jsO4h/+8U+7DcssqBgmdtXCCZeWlARkkkmh6KW4 - SgFd2VxZKW43QgIoIQK+JGYmgVJY8oncPt4UqwvEl3GeiXDm3U8o74C7bKizQ92EOxJF4XMJ3INO - p5qxqgT/zGC3U713Oq2MteTM/eUnxcWKsGMxAg7ytW9D69a4p9H7XEPSfp+FD8edDjpUCkSVLAtM - Cu/L2qtQ9wBE9ShavJSuL1JKwwDnF9D1pRHQCN+HJ5th1PcklhfQ8l0kMnT/3YUxJ4lHLocdtjIR - uvcngn2wfozS997o+laCd9po/tQyl3uiL1zmNhYnc/kA55e5jSWRuQK+D03m8lHfi8xdSMu3l7m8 - ++8scyVJPGqZ62ErE6F7XzLXD+vHJ3Pvka5vIXOnj+bPLXNRhAZpRjwZ1WYVvv8PAAD//+zdzW7C - MAwH8FfhssuqCWl8XnfhwHFvgGAHJmASe39ptHGYkqZpk9jEcXmB9h/H5OcLjYe+GSK+RtJwhWdc - FDYrXhzHEL9q4tO4jPqKBKCNncottdU2ssk2OoCD3f7qC0T8Ab0fo/nwWKNmffNVX7CEzvkcj3OV - MJzxORPGocKl8a1ik7CN8+h4rtX7MzOt20I0z67TxVtfKpY7qi2PY8rejmB4QJxx8ws3mqEDvEAE - GDKGE7zgQrCucnEIQ3AahpEengAxJMhN8b09ZGPsPGu8NSbjuKviAkEm7fEYkocEGjfK1+bvTxd0 - lJeIKEPGcJSXXFDWVS4OZQhOgzLSwxNQhgS5Ub63h2yUnWeNt8ZkKHdVXCDKpD0eg/KQQOWjPDnv - vn+uSTRb32p4nUyb+3dPx726QB4d7Sby2wqT7r41hKPeDpmX9t5dKg99vaRKLenlfWOsCMD+2H6i - TgPEb00ZE6w9nhrB9EF2S5ZneujvQOFzhdU5LAaM4E2ROHpk+N1ETSTxOZ+DipvAw3F3mwR+66vI - 6psR7A+/4E0ra+Jppb2Q2JFlzXlkceyXhLnlf1kVLOthwwv+qzEnmPZ+cxxjXF35nGU4zDJ9O/MH - AAD//+xda3fbuNH+vPkVjPbtxmlEiveLa7t1nIvc2l43TtI2PT0+FElJTChRJSk52p797+8MAF5F - yZIsObITJ7ZIYAAMgJl5BgMSqszNY3Vo7kuNNuLVrMjsD9emHip7HvmK1W2FX6wtOzQp++u6MdYu - uzHZ3DwG5yXtzL25LJtqcJOOSsrTLronubT9cEp2wSmZOx/fgyuyXUXZiAOyFIs/3I56aMODaPFo - 2emW/A5pg8flLe7Aup6HtCsn6d0yP4/B98h6c2/Ox8Za3KT3kTG1i+5HQeJ++B+74H/Mn5DvwQHZ - sq5sxANZjscfLgj31nZDqMgfD/64LX9jgwf/Fbhd27nYlVMAiyP/0DyJnPetuA2bq359HyHn4Ru7 - BCU5edT4n/d0B4B/0bA/PpTftrSvAepLsvQDw7m2h9928xEwISJfoXqvz2VUv3njLvC+XEfWRv5d - OYtwyfl6aE4B6daLvFv391jGvbS8vitRne/deyhjWYl81O5HVYp2wAlZc14en3/yzVRoDcflrrz+ - 8GhqEXLr+yIbPK9xIf9r+y+7corj4tl5BG7LdjdFttngBp2UXdkSuUXafrgk394l+Z72Q+5bTzbh - gPzYDbmL39Gfxn64de9jg8dLLtGLtX2QXTmCcpmZegyeSLlL9+aPbLbZTXolZc520TepSuEPD2UH - PJRbJuV78FPuQ3M24q2swOjD91nu4q2MB/YWTgeRNnjQJmVxdW9D2pVzNtkYPzhXgrC9leO8NlP1 - HVwC0v43PsorFYvHje019mXh+G4N0etH+xGC9hZlex1ovp2dhw/Adw4anNs98roL986Lw6E9dDzu - lG7zoOc58MCPcbf1Eqm0wfM3l+rH2oGDXTmjc7nZemh4n/bqRdarF6fpYw9vWKe2Ejy4j4bX9xXm - T3aL8faNAwhLSuOjdjPmi9AOuB7rTdDj80y+lSat4bXckdWH79HcyZfZwjdnSRs8afR8rS/Oknbl - GNHzh/i9Wefb+tasTVR8F+fgm39j1vnj/76sWYuycGy3h+PfxXdlbU+m1wLiH9+TtQBqAUCA4Ljn - uZtH3A2ellngcw3g3ZXDMIuj/eDwl/D+AnnfDgxvrv47oHE+Qd8alIui8rixOZ/4XYDoBeP+CJF6 - 2/K+DmAvydN3jdtXAL9fPO5jGIwHW1grb/BYyBKna2D3rpwAWR7xh4belPsXlPut4PdGW1gfwUvT - 9I0xvCIyjxrFS9O/Azi+eOwfH5Lfg9yvgeXLc/Vdo/m/wvGwB10dB8nGsVze4EmLBT5XR3J5Vw5U - LI72Q8NxwvsLwvtWUHyD9a+P4YUJ+sYIXhKVR43fhYnfAfReNO6PD7u3Lu9rIPeyPG0LtzGPYQwm - wuWTJ/iH/IfUFHDicSdOcHs9bmRKliWlJj+GUSdDkbF50JcrVj/j8SorntK2+vLRk/RmxvSjzY+T - xgNxNeYdb7aup5EPNr9BRyPnckk/Yw4bu3G04oPzMqpHHw4HWzxXcd3KV/QvWMK8gxWHgw3a20wa - b7O1RRl51O5Fdd634GNkg77y2YrfgYuxXXnfxMGKdQx910GBE8RcO05AAt3qKeQbQOsNHohc5nR1 - xN6Vw5ArI/7QUDtl/wVhfwvIvckG7oTe5Yn6pghelZnHjuIzMrADSH7LHDw+NN++/K+B6Esz9V2j - +pvIxi+HGG4czzd4AnLK4+pIviuHG2ej/NAwPGV8C+i9marvhNspC98UsXPZeOxYXZjxHUDpueP+ - +PB5m3K+1jcT3crOfYfxs18W1M/AJfICGBGX2dl0ssuprMZ5Ifx3lBjECSBhYOOwMRayOH7BwJeq - LobybY5Ue9ioqY+KqvvWGzaW00q35w3/jE0M7YF3yKwlTSZ2shuFg+sxDIBimpJqidIcwQ17/3cY - eQ6YVMLvL5DgdrAwq/MXbLtU0S9A6w/tYBTGh9IvWIpczcw07c6CKX6STWJhM6Ywc73IHib5lLHb - JTZc3hJKDjwVrjseuumXK6QTxq4LOE2rTudqBsZZJTxYp8QbEEB/3/djLk7G7pS7sWPSDExoZ8ol - fW/2CxbxnU1qkY6DwCfvbu69OX53/Jx7GYXDqc39lfubZwPLp+AvREMiEXaQlzoJA9C/MKKicnxj - g0ey54xhBm0hjHrPBe49NEuYiGKub7vQd852Jz6A75RYHJQvyi6AMDhnZHBQtzkH6qZ7WU0OrBI3 - DLMCJN8GTqaxHzehpOPHyADoLwgHjFafAxdpFHkjm7EWdskADOzhOHYif5QImZrWbLxlM41CFI6T - bKrT+1v08gzIfgWWeW4AziYIdByOo3SbrV45Wc1Ftewr1czUhDaOcOXh2AHUpRzV1JISlp24WeDi - 6qDW9WF2Yw+NAJ1mnMoWdGIcJC1d0WsAkEPHPup5yWHjuhPYtSBJNBss9TAMR17Z9Z1RfoZarDvU - ybqMTt1DXZXkX0pK73ZSg+AnYRgcHgNWRwAhvxALwmogFYCdgoKSKMmmJpqzdof8zKIVlr3GSV9I - n4IWm5jFxGlcnn5vb6Z7dYVmXQj8qZasIaqiVupWLJQqP3Y80OihF47jjcsW1GJPY8FBhiOCFieX - 749PeFmW1W8pU6apabstU8VpWUqyLk5OOTK43DEOOncJa516oayXr/ryS0pZBUKfHLQGsNZlJu9J - DqVMrsKJFwX2tMEcUNe3YZQbpeXviZ9QM/6KZh49KVdBy3AOI+PdnAwIy9EPJwCrxmeN5vEIcBT+ - /fU/WRBghk9m4oEXr4gdxVV12n7ifU3S4MuTBTQpps+jYUvxckfYLGQr+dGUZz2k3ea7oZOLSY33 - bU+867hvR16VJpU3aH8mj80ENpdm5UMnN/INklHlsGM24ehQsvM7Dhvgl+VPOx34wxFgZTIdwezT - IEiDI85jw4mj7oC8JAOehZeEXzBrYgdjyPvwz+n4n55+LHa0s7O3b19P3ny4iT/JZ59Gyue3/zpR - e//4e5IEzhfX+FsQXxq//dr+8M/LVxe68l4xHDX4NW+fjR5lANZ6A39GL9lge19HoAh8/RppmZGu - 0taNeJWGjTwu94LQnnlzjLnur1g2Z3NdH7wkjBGBhKHTFmSKgf6P3SOeIheH3eSmhrV8VpWC53oQ - j+xMhVJWeKYSWdvCsON3DlpIu1RRfhB2fKyhpmBFEVsoQJkNeVKrLnEyhTpjD93GMOJvIns0Akwg - 6kVGMY9lMBKS2jh6Q1Y7+2C+8J7QU5KSFaJUjVuaLZoUlY1g2qVwRGaBLqZJqXEU8FTW7cHM9y8z - ST8+P67m5KMLmdmA0epXaHI0t8nLRU1ert/kIJjX5PnZgiYhc+0mAaLnNHlxdl7NobOIceT0qqAE - QD+PC5BdQn/0JF85sqsFCSsD4TkuJ1hUdwYMccGC6408AM1qKKNkHQlTMvBywmGvAnhXHqzI3ofQ - Q5J7VF25lOorhi2y6UH1I2EG5NAJ/FEnhIViuu/QKEeeCs82giHmM/CulJpN4am3WEJBDvnhwbgO - uEYe+TlJi2beS5nfcvjNA+8lyJrNKqyyndX+GumrNVdiqQAMK9R4BeRzWK3WfEtlmSvuOOF4mMzG - b/7csZ0v16A8h4T0D8rxH+Q3eEI9cYdn6CEndZoJnYJuOA+2PPDDHpjf/pQHk44m9nzKvSwkV7uz - k/3IIxBx2o2TPGkp4clAgiJvtMKsZ07vOS1abq8Qb1zk31Zd2nk2iUUoy3EuHCXQozBhIFo1WAHw - H9nJGPSfUbG+OOFgFBA3w47Qx6YuCkZFYozRXJy8POXOssLk4DASH5nxlscxuECRnxrhg9Hcppk/ - Pbfqg9Zo2TrSntrzCUkAvXZdl1JeZ0Gfxoy3l+98LLvR0cKIz1UbRWDr3I0GzvLMATHwdnl+ci+s - dcLwS9z3gu7yDJIijaOXacl74dOFBXtg+wMvKjHaytNh0F5lNxlPSwspZydgSECtqf9ZiP56bEuP - w83IgR19IQFVlga4GII/gRHJnh9DZZCWRLbrIWGcBkk/CFcC9wpjpwlZKUBy27ODpE+qIocUc1de - NPHxvYO9dvvqucB9GNpjWNtF/m9Q5Tj2WF0xhlyxahKUjnwnCabcKAr7fgf65Qqsw2WrlALCU57n - DrMf7uXrt6cX3Jtff33/+l0xneehyAEdnGxq2VsQ6Sj6Do5T5c2IgqUr5vN9D0YkatSVvWZ5sGII - gvCGWLIy15Xwve/me/1cvutfjLoUC5Taqicvyi2TCCzVIP2gCdfJjZ8Qc1xWEJYsgHluoaKUfcv3 - rNBsROggnvS4G99N+rCkEaFWz+/1E3o98b2blyE+zsGJnCpyitHABSiJyQ29Bvd1EAxjygJT0RuF - xJNlURRbUHFNe6RNAhpHjKmDFr2tJ+2RvrPefZVE0ZxTKVUtGyQZC+AFIZ5Liz9AeK4Lom4oOmec - SbpgGobJyaJgWpZ0BjnwI3GKLMhtSRTkM8kUdE5WBOlM1gRdN2mWop7JsmBykiFoZ4okWJzRlk0B - UkXB4CQNriRVUKEmo42tmZbZZq1+OregHkNTOFMwFFVW2pIsWIpsnMkWJMgGp4iCqmtmW9YFTbeM - swr9p8UdpLP1s/ZSl/SXjdacMW71auQC568im7l5ZQm3CmvXdjy00nXmPM3LRBZte1ls36TFj1BM - Z3gkppkuBM/sKSihtIxMlsVaEclvnWZQsUx5mCumVOgyDy3mpdpQMcqaDFKkNSUQCQkkypAEQ/1o - GYIpOyJvCpLa1ATF4iWxaQkSfvZlA1I/anLAK5agyDyUc3gFZa8p8qosqHITBEM32bWqCIYxkSxB - NduWJYjWRNGhGFYjqxNJtPoqSKM04fFS0T7V9Zp8w101nUrDGgKAEOm51QfF6namUkoiDuhk2sMp - EYuaNX5RRs5IudMhlZH7kYm0zU3IhCRKgq42ZZg7xWhrhmBYMD+S2ocEU/s04GWZl8CqaGqfF2Td - gRtB1mD6ZQkEB2ZSUHR2DX8NFAwJatSapmCqmCRpTTBPikKvr7A9o2mA/ZCbkig3LajAPMErkmM0 - LUVQQUahRqVpgLlR2M2nARhUME5NTRZ06RitHdCRvyL5JyGpKU90CaS4LYEYSmYsaBLwqAmyQhhT - 20A1kRRbU4GlJv1LCjcVFariwf7puiNDN5oqZFpQo2CySw2qsSaaKShaW7JAYT5Cc3WMmKBmOvAD - Vle9ByHv+Ul/3KnaOJo6B5Df+kkbinwTu+Z63bgOCQ5IdK0eIwQqxM0FmTL3vzlYhCi0z/1sKPjv - T7VEvz9Z1OzCmvloHHj7nDfxhqHrzqt+Ng2DXrX9BaevdoSY8tOp24jqa6ApelMF62zaqCSgveyD - CDKvgCoqTVnUBckB2TdBS4AWFF1Q6IUGNh5NgaABNogIGWAzACVAj0BzLR68CIAFXVAJaCioXapZ - ulYFU8JLtDKIRzz6K0bp2hI0i0f3A1wO+ESQoZ/ALFgCwQBI0wVZwlureGkRGmDeAPMGhcCQCKrV - BJcGzAwYICCGesDMKMgrZGrAqgHsqNADMEmmoBlNCQBSappgDKH78MuuYNA0yVahGYA98pdaEWyY - B+9LscBSChKP5gQ6aaARxbGAFJOQglkxIdcE04tIiQVN1UYTJ+MskA9apQYW6gTsTdOEaslsQNck - hOvCtUNnT0XDI5M8wHJorglTC/yZRpP+zbg0rSZlU8QcHSYVuFSbKow2MGyCpUNDK5kwODBQCs6+ - gSMJfqFEr2CKNewLDhdOuoxtggklVyAWwIcJHACHMAVEcnRwMETjuEbUmkVZXN5k1ol73VOaRNxN - 4rdI4JigFwOIgFIrgSOMDgwgDDAgQ3mBJvKCpcGFBjND7nS8AJBDwJCIiEFXBAssv6ADSkJhfvZx - sI3wbcFIiiB1IFEgc0Q7QIwBhEF8JOBMtWzgARmCP2QsgUmUPMlyiGKqMFdYDHEbUg0oEdOpMVCT - kRB7gN2uW91sogsqEQpJhC7ooNQ6tAVihJZDAb4sKYZ08BZgSJk5QeaICIEHaVroT0CmSVI09dMA - uokb3HdnzEL9l8HQmAYOr4ls4DzjeMmotuCvolBIqKxEDjAZRUGBLNQ1A1AeB19GDg1UCUhjHG5j - LCVoBMZOBvWTUSTAAUc/TFA1ZAINDthULeYxTcHOGDiwEpEBvJVxxnVQWBPGtCkRK4HGEWm2yTYY - YlBwZNuC9UYTBpzHYQPbDtafqBEMNFxaPOqjjPpEHCuqhJCBQgMSDlcwSwb5xPLqNpkGo4hrHHAC - Nc0RUExg4BBJUDSIccORJkKsUBhEY4wARXAJaTAXrSnkYjlJXyi9azuBHbIdV3YB0e/zhzFGVOLZ - 8GXZI3yZ79UVmsUlDTZC/MBrqbER31DF//hSCbo5zOujntb/iKuWemq/py4S84hmJ65BZ0kFTLcB - uyi28SqP1yrDOriCpQP498cSmHCL4Y0hiKAvmg30zNmBq4mS3zdxqQHLDJDAtCZZbIJHBCYqJ5Jx - 3dAvFgN5/TSAVo5BOhnUQ2tNvVBIbxqlluDqGLUyXYmAsCiV/D5wn90r0F/lU6N1dHuQpBpALN7i - vrJDd5rnhDazKCHfDca+y3V6/CjyB7jxUh+UzOORo4TX5oYio/CGGyS8Ug0+lmoK+KDHK/ioLiro - jGSOCjth5Jmomz4+6FIXty/IfBw6vh0M8N26FnmQQugnA7L3NhziMxk3sGjCvXi6ITaaabX4yGKc - 8P4wgN5ytNbrwZwXJw8Cv6YU3aHDXsyPpAIn1xen7fpgau1Ko/JYY/kRRg7fT+t6UVQbiqUSkIdj - FS0Px+J1eX1ncpi2iXAsaXf5kCwhnwnLWg2ya8+jiThsjKNg72e8F691TTb0a8VS9ecL2ieVZtHb - j+xpG2JcANJFUecUFUBT104Abi1Dl9J7+mloHEnXpOyeuFmWfpLem4Ioq5LOpeVFAGfZMBQubSBN - OEFKTVJzCrxQClWk92kT6X3KQlpBymKlC5/SaftZFjXVUhq4fRJ+AYvOVIje8kwMwGPIkga4YxT4 - 8AHpCzyw+mFlQXGLDixAqmpKyK2GoW9Zt0wOcBa6bJ2ZyLAoYY+0Ni7MzrAPnCxipBuK6TRHxrKy - CDmSfiYbWFUbEBuoLU4inypWRDOwPUs22qzdT+CRwLLEMjiMdJuG0sYFmiZZGFvHTw4+ZV1S2hhw - t2T9rEKfDSMdtVvHojbMnWXOC4oUSFCeL9OxrAr3LbJNKoiohaPKbRaU25zpSkSeN1pYWyvlZ1GX - 53drjqNDs4oPb2SpK1nR2Qg/e8Ek8DsRAFjYRWvtQA31drR2G2C+Na3a3QXWdeJFMdnJBXFaynci - JPtfMUBdRwgLWqv1le4Fo3EefZ23JzOluWVDLqsW/qKKT/FJCm9odwKPx2dcelE4Hrr7Q++GK1D+ - iXC0H49gVECnIy/2oknd4cBpn7Fe9gQsAnXLieu+ZS/9EeJEEucG3PCHhfPekJ/6eBv+zAnppW0s - 1QgC2/wWOGYWl2CGKxnVfc5cgjQ3tvucJC7qaH363AAjy6YYe3XO37rFxAossl8L8iorLpxfBq2w - rsNoTJ+X1Y8mmH5H5LWmImB0T25qgoGffdwW/aiLAQaoVF4UJIcHECDBAySDbI1e4WbVRIKstiVO - ECewqHWrWaz/megGQo+iTXi86uPexlnK8G93svaLshw/ckBb8qHCsXLwDQJAIR0up/QSIDlCCDbh - CnihxRYZ2toAdPU5uSxnZVM7DcfJuOMRSzsGg4Ce64zj+i9KdFfHdS0rOmfAV7eti63onGa2ZVsz - FWZDe5sGr26L1cdjJRd1U9sM4tSn32aIq0qvpiqvop6nKq8ur/JkgZRE9jDGNxtgqvESX7/eE5u8 - pWFQVZbMReuhisXWFj3mQZx5EzdtRQVWJA7uAqkYUDEF3GZR6AX+mahovsUmIcDNjCyH/OkbYLwd - Wpok8CkNqWIlSz7haVuEGT7lIv/TRo5/487xYQjcetZMwQxwuwp3ctWAzy4/0rxbTf5cq547unXG - Nn/WNk8phWxI0kqBkcLZDmBA4msaIOQKQZKji/Rt6zPqDeMjdefMHz7oRDWIUGf0e2HYC6jNH9ij - uDUKwGy1TF0UX7wLnS8T0BrvxaX/xWu+eOnhE3uu3Xxx/uqFLJqW2vqLYgqWpVmaaDZ5A7BblETc - VjF+a2GQ8fCpMpCeqh34HWhwrT6VYvGraXUMx9I8WTN0zXU7++JXyZI0vWuaHVgKKVrHfGoO5KeK - m9f+VHWxftEyTUVW6iS5Joy0PBxhf7msvxz2t3YIOS4bBO78FUcGoTbMtJoAcI43JE9bQuKcKNni - kNiN17kehQHMvRfTaFjNeBz9w+twl4yKcL20lKTt+MMYwGmceDEPSS345cNu13c83vUjEnBpsXsQ - qMF46Ds2ezweX7t3+MC3/TgctrqR57nhgC8cJIEPx7LKlpveoze/nh6v1o1+PybdmIwDkAC74wd+ - MuXJU7dhjI/QkjGcFqOKdXKFa/eJO2octdtX3MdiXdyrrK77EYvsZZgRvnmIzxRx8wOpjKq8gXDU - 9oLRitJQKG87Dtgnn3Z/vugdF8nWb82xQXCiOP2c394JJVhuEmYTynHu20Pct83V0M5KdMIkAckv - vwhVIC28ODUbXWc0df4+G7+50fTZwQQIoUHy2nVFfRurNV1DOd+2ADun7a2ys8AiEF3eXOPL4dMs - O+PYZux8uDrGq5VYmvVDMA1kbzX5n7fBRG+zB+mrz9+/vng17+l7SvvZntj0cBV8yccffsZQ5sU/ - Xl3he982oHUvFrgLqH2fvoCJDs3wxo2v2ToRXxIYj1xyAlFnyjWGo0G6hAQbAHiDrx+Q9rDFtKV8 - nZS3z7RqYkflBg45jJQLSuNPTzIC5O06pQIKN3TG+NqD4EQesPKavse09wzpnj2nC4tSGQF3WqHg - M3IgUZr6rI6SHbsHxEW2KGXWLrg0rNH45fS93buA6vee4YsHz57/W/yPgC81D92Tvh+4e6Xqn9f1 - atUezfam2pNCL55NvTT7buwj6z8h33bgRUn8IQpwrloOuHAtmsQ+hM8xTN5Pfpfbw5lHCQI+X9qx - h2WegkA+w8OGuuAjQ3uwYPzpp2KVReIXeWNQI64LQReI+KTv5pZejaPfyJF/MwcV+b+PPfDMyY7k - KBj3wH8iEvokPTKKSSkePJIZAscd1rxIRV5MbNm61DVEzeGVjuPwqqXqvOlqFm93VcXpuK6iu07r - 5Pik/br1OW6F42Q0TgTZUrqdrqHbNqyaPuORLFlH8gPICL+XUUi0sgNjwFGamKnwPfKrq4anylJH - E121lt+D/JYjcybYN14cDjwBGb+0e57gD/1kL40HYDTrFFzN/UKEwI/Pwl4Pn8De58iZoPlzqUiO - Yr7PNRp5ahDC9IEwQOp2Xy8ttwljUm609jU2xkkLj8iCEjUMtFpzGm+lTbdSvP49ZaBDVWGfe7ao - 8Wcp+TC8QicvHJ6E4Rffu6BDOBrwwzjrEz0x6tStksS+m9HY7ucLe3I1hxJyAdJKBWileP7CFXkr - HBBipv5uzoMf/zqktaOoVCn9MB418hFwvrwPKXGVsJPEQUbo4BH+jh1ced5xEFRJndjOKD/HNPdV - iMfeYH79vGQFUByv8JSQd95/x16cvLH9wHOLwgkDj/nulZck/rAXQ95gSg10SA8Yca9jljdT6JiK - Tl0ZJlVULn4nUFCygWWQHYTuODvkzB/gUoODtdXAj2MMmeK7cMdoUTk8pY/bnPkgKFBoiCfvJRPj - TeGAMERNMcLPFWF6b7FC1UNLE8+qo4/X7D3PjEmPEOz9+1kndKfcEffHffD1Et5BDHv2n+dpsLFu - LPZY7u/PhS5M615afVZ7zagXBt7FCMYcH2cJI006SQ8+Zh/E3BabK+Da/Rh/zTNUp6NqitutGv+U - l0UAYEeJ7wQ1GIC27GoMFj8mEQlqU2FJnKW0Ms0Y2En/r/bXstm9c0ex1s/219Z4OAKjAqXOaTPQ - yT+Dy9T1e4fn52fXJ+3352dFs0KPoji+PH0HnjfybGMtWUZrlvYCJAEHgPUxPwljiIuPEeS0VrLH - K5rXpW3mypYwCIe99140uISFk/8VCmDCf1GvK9jx4d0ZPtWAvc/QDXJ4AI7W+jBTkC02tDl05rIT - ffnr1cZFJ/oCYoJGDlScdFhgaVnDeOpu2+/1A3we5CQMwqiIEP00x3Pf4zFZcTETT5eihxddkpCo - N3RmUNHpzkGBgxZaPXw5G4MxR/8PAAD//wMAsQk7B9DDAgA= - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Type: - - text/html; charset=utf-8 - Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: - - same-origin - Date: - - Fri, 31 May 2024 19:29:22 GMT - Referrer-Policy: - - same-origin - Server: - - nginx - Set-Cookie: - - pm-csrf=w9s9GhgUn6PKRjB5tcaBxOVveEaYGgTU; expires=Fri, 30 May 2025 19:29:22 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31449600; Path=/; SameSite=Lax; Secure - - pm-sessionid=iod0hv0e48bm55s6unxd354zd6pelo4q; expires=Sat, 01 Jun 2024 03:29:22 - GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=28800; Path=/; Secure - - ncbi_sid=28DF727C32ECC374_9478SID; Domain=.nih.gov; expires=Sat, 31 May 2025 - 19:29:22 GMT; HttpOnly; Max-Age=31536000; Path=/; Secure - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Vary: - - origin - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY + - '2' X-UA-Compatible: - IE=Edge X-XSS-Protection: @@ -7632,4 +4229,162 @@ interactions: status: code: 200 message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.207 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=38814972&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["38814972"],"38814972":{"uid":"38814972","pubdate":"2024","epubdate":"2024 + May 30","source":"PLoS One","authors":[{"name":"Sorooshyari SK","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"lastauthor":"Sorooshyari + SK","title":"Brain age monotonicity and functional connectivity differences + of healthy subjects.","sorttitle":"brain age monotonicity and functional connectivity + differences of healthy subjects","volume":"19","issue":"5","pages":"e0300720","lang":["eng"],"nlmuniqueid":"101285081","issn":"","essn":"1932-6203","pubtype":["Journal + Article"],"recordstatus":"PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE","pubstatus":"258","articleids":[{"idtype":"pubmed","idtypen":1,"value":"38814972"},{"idtype":"pmc","idtypen":8,"value":"PMC11139261"},{"idtype":"pmcid","idtypen":5,"value":"pmc-id: + PMC11139261;"},{"idtype":"doi","idtypen":3,"value":"10.1371/journal.pone.0300720"},{"idtype":"pii","idtypen":4,"value":"PONE-D-23-39384"}],"history":[{"pubstatus":"received","date":"2023/11/27 + 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"accepted","date":"2024/03/04 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"medline","date":"2024/05/30 + 18:44"},{"pubstatus":"pubmed","date":"2024/05/30 18:43"},{"pubstatus":"entrez","date":"2024/05/30 + 13:44"},{"pubstatus":"pmc-release","date":"2024/05/30 00:00"}],"references":[],"attributes":["Has + Abstract"],"pmcrefcount":45,"fulljournalname":"PloS one","elocationid":"doi: + 10.1371/journal.pone.0300720","doctype":"citation","srccontriblist":[],"booktitle":"","medium":"","edition":"","publisherlocation":"","publishername":"","srcdate":"","reportnumber":"","availablefromurl":"","locationlabel":"","doccontriblist":[],"docdate":"","bookname":"","chapter":"","sortpubdate":"2024/05/30 + 00:00","sortfirstauthor":"Sorooshyari SK","vernaculartitle":""}}} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:58:56 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D3407F95CD407A5000034F02ADB65A6.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 0A64D23EA7A0F0C4_7F9ASID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=0A64D23EA7A0F0C4_7F9ASID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:58:56 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '9' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '1777' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.207 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=38814901&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["38814901"],"38814901":{"uid":"38814901","pubdate":"2024","epubdate":"2024 + May 30","source":"PLoS One","authors":[{"name":"Peverill RE","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Lin + KY","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Fogel MA","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Cheung + MMH","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Moir WS","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Corben + LA","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Cahoon G","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Delatycki + MB","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"lastauthor":"Delatycki MB","title":"Insights + into the effects of Friedreich ataxia on the left ventricle using T1 mapping + and late gadolinium enhancement.","sorttitle":"insights into the effects of + friedreich ataxia on the left ventricle using t1 mapping and late gadolinium + enhancement","volume":"19","issue":"5","pages":"e0303969","lang":["eng"],"nlmuniqueid":"101285081","issn":"","essn":"1932-6203","pubtype":["Journal + Article","Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov''t"],"recordstatus":"PubMed - indexed + for MEDLINE","pubstatus":"258","articleids":[{"idtype":"pubmed","idtypen":1,"value":"38814901"},{"idtype":"pmc","idtypen":8,"value":"PMC11139319"},{"idtype":"pmcid","idtypen":5,"value":"pmc-id: + PMC11139319;"},{"idtype":"doi","idtypen":3,"value":"10.1371/journal.pone.0303969"},{"idtype":"pii","idtypen":4,"value":"PONE-D-22-29235"}],"history":[{"pubstatus":"received","date":"2022/10/23 + 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"accepted","date":"2024/05/04 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"medline","date":"2024/05/30 + 18:44"},{"pubstatus":"pubmed","date":"2024/05/30 18:43"},{"pubstatus":"entrez","date":"2024/05/30 + 13:33"},{"pubstatus":"pmc-release","date":"2024/05/30 00:00"}],"references":[],"attributes":["Has + Abstract"],"pmcrefcount":42,"fulljournalname":"PloS one","elocationid":"doi: + 10.1371/journal.pone.0303969","doctype":"citation","srccontriblist":[],"booktitle":"","medium":"","edition":"","publisherlocation":"","publishername":"","srcdate":"","reportnumber":"","availablefromurl":"","locationlabel":"","doccontriblist":[],"docdate":"","bookname":"","chapter":"","sortpubdate":"2024/05/30 + 00:00","sortfirstauthor":"Peverill RE","vernaculartitle":""}}} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:59:00 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D3407F95CD407A500002EF038E483F1.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - BB2438E5CA321CA4_F7E1SID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=BB2438E5CA321CA4_F7E1SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 12:59:00 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '8' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '2263' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_plos_summary_failure_is_logged_without_the_api_key.yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_plos_summary_failure_is_logged_without_the_api_key.yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d559a37 --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_plos_summary_failure_is_logged_without_the_api_key.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,320 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"error":"API key invalid","api-key":"","type":"invalid", + + "status":"unknown"}' + headers: + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '3' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '3' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '91' + status: + code: 400 + message: Bad Request +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"error":"API key invalid","api-key":"","type":"invalid", + + "status":"unknown"}' + headers: + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '3' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '3' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '91' + status: + code: 400 + message: Bad Request +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"error":"API key invalid","api-key":"","type":"invalid", + + "status":"unknown"}' + headers: + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '3' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '3' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '91' + status: + code: 400 + message: Bad Request +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"error":"API key invalid","api-key":"","type":"invalid", + + "status":"unknown"}' + headers: + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '3' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '3' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '91' + status: + code: 400 + message: Bad Request +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"error":"API key invalid","api-key":"","type":"invalid", + + "status":"unknown"}' + headers: + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:57 GMT + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '3' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '3' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '91' + status: + code: 400 + message: Bad Request +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"error":"API key invalid","api-key":"","type":"invalid", + + "status":"unknown"}' + headers: + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '3' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '3' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '91' + status: + code: 400 + message: Bad Request +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/test_ace.py b/ace/tests/test_ace.py index ff66fbc..ddebd36 100644 --- a/ace/tests/test_ace.py +++ b/ace/tests/test_ace.py @@ -220,8 +220,8 @@ def test_journal_scraping(test_data_path, source_manager): shutil.rmtree(scrape_path, ignore_errors=True) assert len(names) == 2 - # Each file must be the PLoS NLM XML, not the PubMed abstract page we get - # bounced to when E-utilities has no LinkOut record for an article. + # Each file must be the PLoS NLM XML. Neither article had a LinkOut record + # when this was recorded, so both are addressed by their esummary DOI. for name, doc in zip(names, docs): assert '' in caplog.text + assert FAKE_API_KEY not in caplog.text @pytest.mark.vcr(record_mode="once") From 55ef07fe0e3feb510ff5d9a42d0e1f8f2b1b4ffc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: James Kent Date: Wed, 14 Oct 2026 08:58:32 -0500 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] Open no-LinkOut PLoS articles at doi.org; decide PLoS by DOI prefix Review of #69: in browser mode the PLoS manuscript URL is a download (content-disposition: attachment), so Chrome saved the XML to downloaded_files/ and ACE kept Chrome's "New Tab" page as the article. https://doi.org/ lands on the journals.plos.org article page, the same page LinkOut gives, and loads in both modes. PLoS is now decided by the 10.1371/journal. DOI prefix, so titles missing from PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES (PLOS Mental Health, Global Public Health, ...) are found. An esummary error reply (HTTP 200, per-UID "error") and a malformed record are logged once as a failed lookup, not as "not PLoS". Tests record every request a cassette is asked for, so a PubMed request swallowed by a broad except still fails them. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- ace/scrape.py | 36 +- ...ummary_error_reply_as_a_failed_lookup.yaml | 134 + ...os_article_by_doi[plos-mental-health].yaml | 2844 ++++++++ ...ens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-one].yaml | 1880 +++++ ...s_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml | 2182 ------ ...t_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml | 880 --- .../test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml | 6095 +++++++++++++++++ ace/tests/conftest.py | 18 + ace/tests/test_ace.py | 60 +- 9 files changed, 11032 insertions(+), 3097 deletions(-) create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_logs_an_esummary_error_reply_as_a_failed_lookup.yaml create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-mental-health].yaml create mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-one].yaml delete mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml delete mode 100644 ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml diff --git a/ace/scrape.py b/ace/scrape.py index 62c5498..ee22388 100644 --- a/ace/scrape.py +++ b/ace/scrape.py @@ -285,14 +285,6 @@ def _plos_doi_from_url(url): return match.group(1) if match else None -def _plos_manuscript_url(journal, doi): - """ The NLM XML of a PLoS article. The legacy 'asset?id=.XML' - endpoint still works, but only by redirecting here first. """ - - return 'https://journals.plos.org/%s/article/file?id=%s&type=manuscript' % ( - PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES[journal.lower()], doi) - - def _visible_text(html): """ Rough plain-text rendering of an HTML document, used to tell a real article page apart from an interstitial that carries nothing but a widget. """ @@ -584,8 +576,8 @@ def _prlinks_target(providers): return providers[0][1] def _plos_url_without_linkout(self, pmid): - """ The PLoS manuscript URL of an article that has no LinkOut record, - from its keyed esummary, or None if it isn't a PLoS article. """ + """ The doi.org URL of a PLoS article that has no LinkOut record, from + its keyed esummary, or None (logged) for any other article. """ try: response = self._client.get( @@ -594,17 +586,23 @@ def _plos_url_without_linkout(self, pmid): return_content=False, ) summary = response.json()['result'][str(pmid)] + # An unknown PMID comes back as HTTP 200 with only an error. + if 'error' in summary: + raise ValueError(summary['error']) + doi = next((a['value'] for a in summary['articleids'] if a['idtype'] == 'doi'), None) except Exception as e: logger.error(f"E-utilities summary failed for PMID {pmid}: {self._without_api_key(e)}") return None - # The caller's journal can be a label of its own rather than PubMed's - # name for it, so PubMed's record decides whether this is PLoS. - journal = summary.get('fulljournalname', '') - doi = next((a['value'] for a in summary.get('articleids', []) if a['idtype'] == 'doi'), None) - if journal.lower() not in PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES or doi is None: + # The caller's journal can be a label of its own, and PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES + # doesn't list every PLOS title. Every PLOS journal DOI has this prefix. + if doi is None or not doi.startswith('10.1371/journal.'): + logger.info("\tNo LinkOut record for PMID %s and not a PLoS article. Skipping...", pmid) return None - return _plos_manuscript_url(journal, doi) + # doi.org lands on the journals.plos.org article page, as LinkOut does. + # The manuscript URL is a download, which the browser saves to disk + # instead of loading. + return f"https://doi.org/{doi}" def _without_api_key(self, text): # requests puts the full query string, key included, in its errors. @@ -658,7 +656,6 @@ def get_html_by_pmid(self, pmid, journal, mode='browser', prefer_pmc_source=True # so only a PLoS article, addressed by its DOI, is opened. url = self._plos_url_without_linkout(pmid) if url is None: - logger.info("\tNo LinkOut record for PMID %s and no PLoS manuscript to open. Skipping...", pmid) return None logger.info(url) return self.get_html( @@ -682,7 +679,10 @@ def check_for_substitute_url(self, url, html, journal): doi = _plos_doi_from_url(url) if doi is None: return url - return _plos_manuscript_url(j, doi) + # The legacy 'asset?id=.XML' endpoint still works, but only + # by redirecting here first. + return 'https://journals.plos.org/%s/article/file?id=%s&type=manuscript' % ( + PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES[j], doi) elif j in ['human brain mapping', 'european journal of neuroscience', 'brain and behavior', 'epilepsia', 'journal of neuroimaging']: return url.replace('abstract', 'full').split(';')[0] diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_logs_an_esummary_error_reply_as_a_failed_lookup.yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_logs_an_esummary_error_reply_as_a_failed_lookup.yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..47778d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_logs_an_esummary_error_reply_as_a_failed_lookup.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,134 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=99999999&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"99999999","objurls":[],"info":"No + LinkOut links available for UID: 99999999"}]}]} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:10 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D322F91B7495C35000028FBE97CA40D.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 6C918CFA1EBE24E1_28C1SID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=6C918CFA1EBE24E1_28C1SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:44:10 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '9' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '176' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=6C918CFA1EBE24E1_28C1SID + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=99999999&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["99999999"],"99999999":{"uid":"99999999","error":"cannot + get document summary"}}} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:10 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D3407F95CD407A500003D0661614ABB.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 6C918CFA1EBE24E1_28C1SID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=6C918CFA1EBE24E1_28C1SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:44:10 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '8' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '146' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-mental-health].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-mental-health].yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..70b774e --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-mental-health].yaml @@ -0,0 +1,2844 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=42868163&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"42868163","objurls":[],"info":"No + LinkOut links available for UID: 42868163"}]}]} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:08 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D322F91B7495C35000029FBE358EB48.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 555AF0BB1E9031C7_060ASID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=555AF0BB1E9031C7_060ASID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:44:09 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '6' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '176' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=555AF0BB1E9031C7_060ASID + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868163&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["42868163"],"42868163":{"uid":"42868163","pubdate":"2026","epubdate":"2026 + Oct 13","source":"PLOS Ment Health","authors":[{"name":"Dalisay F","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Liu + W","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Yamamoto M","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Chu + H","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Hmielowski J","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Hong + YR","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Liu J","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Johnson + BK","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"lastauthor":"Johnson BK","title":"Associations + between hurricane stressors, social capital, and climate anxiety among individuals + who experienced Hurricanes Helene and Milton.","sorttitle":"associations between + hurricane stressors social capital and climate anxiety among individuals who + experienced hurricanes helene and milton","volume":"3","issue":"10","pages":"e0000749","lang":["eng"],"nlmuniqueid":"9918844789006676","issn":"","essn":"2837-8156","pubtype":["Journal + Article"],"recordstatus":"PubMed","pubstatus":"258","articleids":[{"idtype":"pubmed","idtypen":1,"value":"42868163"},{"idtype":"doi","idtypen":3,"value":"10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749"},{"idtype":"pii","idtypen":4,"value":"PMEN-D-25-00562"},{"idtype":"pmc","idtypen":8,"value":"PMC13660876"},{"idtype":"pmcid","idtypen":5,"value":"pmc-id: + PMC13660876;"}],"history":[{"pubstatus":"received","date":"2025/12/15 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"accepted","date":"2026/09/22 + 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"medline","date":"2026/10/13 23:37"},{"pubstatus":"pubmed","date":"2026/10/13 + 23:36"},{"pubstatus":"entrez","date":"2026/10/13 18:10"},{"pubstatus":"pmc-release","date":"2026/10/13 + 00:00"}],"references":[],"attributes":["Has Abstract"],"pmcrefcount":49,"fulljournalname":"PLOS + mental health","elocationid":"doi: 10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749","doctype":"citation","srccontriblist":[],"booktitle":"","medium":"","edition":"","publisherlocation":"","publishername":"","srcdate":"","reportnumber":"","availablefromurl":"","locationlabel":"","doccontriblist":[],"docdate":"","bookname":"","chapter":"","sortpubdate":"2026/10/13 + 00:00","sortfirstauthor":"Dalisay F","vernaculartitle":""}}} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:09 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D322F91B7495C35000049FBE443BA00.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 555AF0BB1E9031C7_060ASID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=555AF0BB1E9031C7_060ASID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:44:09 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '6' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '2263' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749 + response: + body: + string: 'Handle Redirect + + https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749' + headers: + CF-RAY: + - a4a70463cbe529cd-DFW + Connection: + - keep-alive + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=utf-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:09 GMT + Nel: + - '{"report_to":"cf-nel","success_fraction":0.0,"max_age":604800}' + Report-To: + - '{"group":"cf-nel","max_age":604800,"endpoints":[{"url":"https://a.nel.cloudflare.com/report/v4?s=oZknTDMoT7rJ66c7GUhMMTwfR41ZK5NUHJIG6%2Fxys3VJF7ouDdMVgnCpqTQNc%2ByZ7RPKGmAeC4shKjt4Z0k6KDa8m9mLX7VRVyrtm3zVOntQmmpCFX5BvbY%3D"}]}' + Server: + - cloudflare + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + alt-svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=86400 + cf-cache-status: + - DYNAMIC + expires: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 14:11:13 GMT + location: + - https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749 + permissions-policy: + - interest-cohort=(),browsing-topics=() + vary: + - Origin + - Accept + status: + code: 302 + message: Found +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749 + response: + body: + string: ' + + + + 301 Moved Permanently + + + +

Moved Permanently

+ +

The document has moved here.

+ +
+ +
Apache Server at dx.plos.org Port 80
+ + + + ' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Content-Length: + - '338' + Content-Type: + - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:09 GMT + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749 + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CK2LgLeBibLjsAEQAw; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + Via: + - 1.1 google + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pmen.0000749 + response: + body: + string: '' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Length: + - '0' + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:09 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/mentalhealth/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749 + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CPzHiY6LhcGFahAD; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - GCLB=CPzHiY6LhcGFahAD + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.155 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/mentalhealth/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pmen.0000749 + response: + body: + string: "\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n + \ \n\n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n\n \n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n\n\n\n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n Associations between + hurricane stressors, social capital, and climate anxiety among individuals + who experienced Hurricanes Helene and Milton | PLOS Mental Health\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
\n
\n \n Skip to main + content\n \n\n
\n
Advertisement
\n\n \n
\n
\n\n
\n
\n
\n\n \n
\n\n
\n
\n\n
\n\n\n\n\n\n
    \n + \
  • \n

    Loading metrics

    \n
  • \n
\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
\n\n
\n + \

Open Access

\n

Peer-reviewed

\n\n
\n

Research Article

\n
\n\n\n
\n + \
\n
\n\n\n\n
\n + \

Associations + between hurricane stressors, social capital, and climate anxiety among individuals + who experienced Hurricanes Helene and Milton

\n\n
    \n\n\n\n\n \nFrancis Dalisay , + \
    \n\n + \ \n

    \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Formal analysis,\n\n Investigation,\n\n Methodology,\n\n + \ Project administration,\n\n Visualization,\n\n Writing \u2013 original + draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

    \n

    + * E-mail: f.dalisay@ufl.edu

    \n + \

    Affiliation\n College + of Journalism and Communications, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, + United States of America\n

    \n \n\n ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n\n \nWenlin Liu, + \
    \n\n + \ \n

    \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Formal analysis,\n\n Methodology,\n\n Writing + \u2013 original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

    \n \n + \

    Affiliation\n College + of Journalism and Communications, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, + United States of America\n

    \n\n ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n\n \nMasahiro Yamamoto,
    \n\n \n

    \n Roles\n Conceptualization,\n\n + \ Writing \u2013 original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n + \

    \n \n

    Affiliation\n + \ Department of Communication, University at Albany, State University of + New York, Albany, New York, United States of America\n

    \n\n ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n\n \nHaoran Chu,
    \n\n \n

    \n + \ Roles\n Writing \u2013 original draft,\n\n + \ Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

    \n \n

    Affiliation\n College of Journalism and Communications, + University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, United States of America\n

    \n\n + \ + ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n\n \nJay Hmielowski, + \
    \n\n + \ \n

    \n Roles\n + \ Writing \u2013 original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n + \

    \n \n

    Affiliation\n + \ College of Journalism and Communications, University of Florida, Gainesville, + Florida, United States of America\n

    \n\n ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n\n \nYoung-Rock Hong,
    \n\n \n

    \n Roles\n Writing \u2013 + original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

    \n \n

    Affiliation\n School of Medicine, Department of Family + and Preventive Medicine, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia, United States + of America\n

    \n \n\n ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n\n \nJiawei Liu, + \
    \n\n + \ \n

    \n Roles\n + \ Writing \u2013 original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n + \

    \n \n

    Affiliation\n + \ College of Journalism and Communications, University of Florida, Gainesville, + Florida, United States of America\n

    \n \n\n ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n\n \nBenjamin K. Johnson + \
    \n\n + \ \n

    \n Roles\n + \ Writing \u2013 original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n + \

    \n \n

    Affiliation\n + \ College of Journalism and Communications, University of Florida, Gainesville, + Florida, United States of America\n

    \n\n ⨯ \n
    \n\n\n
\n\n\n
\n\n\n
\n
\n
\n + \

Associations between hurricane + stressors, social capital, and climate anxiety among individuals who experienced + Hurricanes Helene and Milton

\n\n
    \n\n + \
  • Francis Dalisay, \n\n
  • \n
  • Wenlin + Liu, \n\n
  • \n
  • Masahiro Yamamoto, \n\n + \
  • \n
  • Haoran Chu, \n\n
  • \n
  • Jay Hmielowski, \n\n
  • \n
  • Young-Rock + Hong, \n\n
  • \n
  • Jiawei Liu, \n\n + \
  • \n
  • Benjamin K. Johnson\n\n
  • \n\n
\n\n\n\n + \
\n
\n \"PLOS\"\n
x
\n
\n + \
\n
\n\n \n\n
\n + \
\n\n
\n
\n
\n\n\n\n\n\n
\n\n\n
\n \n
\n + \
\n
\n\n\n\n\n
\n\n\n\n\n
\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
\n \n\n\n\n

Abstract

This study examined how hurricane stressors and + three forms of social capital\u2014bonding, bridging, and linking\u2014are + associated with climate anxiety, and whether the three forms of social capital + would moderate the relationship between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety. + We analyzed data from a cross-sectional survey (N\u2009=\u20091,342) + administered in Georgia, North Carolina, and South Carolina following Hurricane + Helene and in Florida following Hurricane Milton in 2024. Results showed that + hurricane stressors were positively associated with climate anxiety, and these + associations held after controlling for symptoms of generalized anxiety. Findings + also revealed a nuanced role of social capital. Bonding social capital had + a direct negative association with climate anxiety. However, our results suggested + that bonding social capital\u2019s protective role is conditional and reverses + under high stress. That is, bonding social capital weakened the relationship + between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety only when hurricane stressors + were low. As stressors accumulated, bonding social capital strengthened the + association between stressors and climate anxiety. In contrast, both bridging + and linking social capital were positively associated with climate anxiety + and strengthened the positive relationship between hurricane stressors and + climate anxiety. We discussed theoretical insights and practical implications.

\n
\n\n\n

Citation: + Dalisay F, Liu W, Yamamoto M, Chu H, Hmielowski J, Hong Y-R, et al. + \ (2026) Associations between hurricane stressors, social capital, and climate + anxiety among individuals who experienced Hurricanes Helene and Milton. PLOS + Ment Health 3(10):\n e0000749.\n \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749

Editor: + Marc Eric Santos Reyes, University of Santo Tomas College of Science, + PHILIPPINES

Received: December 15, 2025; Accepted: + September 22, 2026; Published: October 13, 2026

Copyright: + \xA9 2026 Dalisay et al. This is an open access article distributed + under the terms of the Creative + Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, + and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are + credited.

Data Availability: The data analyzed in this + study can be accessed on the following Open Society Foundations (OSF) page: + https://osf.io/adg8f/overview.

Funding: + The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.

Competing + interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests + exist.

\n\n\n\n\n\n

1. Introduction

The + Southeastern region of the United States experienced the compounded destructive + effects of Hurricanes Helene and Milton during the fall of 2024 [1,2]. + The intensities of both hurricanes have been linked to climate change [3]. In the aftermath of + these storms, news media reported that, beyond physical destruction, Hurricanes + Helene and Milton had significant negative impacts on survivors\u2019 mental + health [4,5]. These accounts are consistent with past studies + providing compelling evidence that extreme weather events, including hurricanes, + impose significant psychological strain, including heightened anxiety [6,7]. Prior research particularly demonstrates that individuals + who experience hurricane stressors\u2014such as personal losses, injuries, + or other disruptions\u2014may face an increased risk of developing climate + anxiety [8], a form + of distress distinct from generalized anxiety and defined as emotional or + psychological distress marked by heightened fear and constant worrying about + the climate crisis [9].

\n

Against + the backdrop of studies examining climate anxiety, another line of research + has highlighted the protective role of social capital, or social connections + [10], in mitigating + distress associated with natural disasters [11]. Indeed, a long-established area of disaster research + suggests that social capital could shape how communities respond to climate-related + hazards and influence their capacity for recovery [12,13]. + Despite this evidence, little is known about how social capital relates to + climate anxiety, or whether social capital may moderate the psychological + effects of hurricane stressors.

\n

To bridge the above-noted research gaps, the + present study seeks to accomplish three goals. First, within the context of + the recovery from Hurricanes Helene and Milton, we assess the relationship + between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety. Second, we examine the relationship + between social capital and climate anxiety. Third, we explore whether social + capital moderates the relationship between hurricane stressors and climate + anxiety. We analyze data from online surveys conducted in late 2024 with residents + of U.S. Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)-declared disaster counties + in Georgia, North Carolina, and South Carolina, following Hurricane Helene, + and in Florida following Hurricane Helene/Milton.

\n
\n\n

2. + Literature review

\n
\n

2.1 Hurricane stressors and climate + anxiety

\n

The present study is guided by three theoretical + frameworks to explain the relationship between hurricane stressors and climate + anxiety: the stress process model, the environmental identity framework, and + the concept of eco-grief.

\n

This stress process model provides a framework + that explains the relationships between stressors, resources, and mental health + outcomes [14]. According + to this model, stressors, which are acute or chronic disruptive events (e.g., + adversities due to a hurricane), trigger mental health responses, such as + increased anxiety. The model also views resources as central in explaining + how a stressor affects mental health outcomes. That is, the extent to which + a stressor impacts one\u2019s mental health could be conditioned by the resources + one has available to cope with the stressor. As we will discuss below, resources + facilitated by social ties could play a role in moderating the relationship + between hurricane stressors and climate-induced anxiety.

\n

Based on + the stress process model, we first predict that hurricane stressors would + be positively associated with climate anxiety. As mentioned, hurricane stressors + refer to the adversities and critical losses of resources that one experiences + due to a hurricane [15]. + Such stressors can range from losing access to resources such as food, water, + shelter, or electricity to experiencing injuries. Climate anxiety is a form + of environment-related distress specifically tied to the perceived threat + of climate change [16], + manifesting as extreme and persistent concern and rumination about climate + change [9]. A recent + study conducted by Asgarizadeh et al. showed that personal past experiences + with climate-related events was associated with heightened levels of anxiety + [17].

\n

Yet we note + that direct experiences with hurricane stressors could plausibly produce generalized + anxiety. As stated, research has specifically established a positive relationship + between experiencing stressful hurricane events and increased levels of psychological + distress [8,18], including anxiety [19,20]. + For instance, in their study of individuals who experienced Hurricane Katrina, + Galea et al. found that hurricane-related stressors, namely, experiencing + property loss, physical injury, and physical adversity, were positively associated + with symptoms of anxiety [6].

\n

However, + climate anxiety represents a theoretically and empirically distinct outcome. + Generalized anxiety is characterized by diffuse, object-independent excessive + worry about a number of events, disproportionate to the actual likelihood + or impact of those events [21]. + Climate anxiety, on the other hand, is object-specific and ecologically grounded + and reflects an appraisal of systemic environmental threat rather than a pathological + response to personal danger. Indeed, Clayton and Karazsia\u2019s [9] work has demonstrated empirically that climate anxiety + is distinct from general psychological distress, establishing it as a separate + construct warranting independent investigation. In a 5-year cohort survey + of Texas and Florida residents who directly experienced category 3 or higher + hurricanes, Garfin and Wong-Parodi found that having previous direct exposure + to hurricanes, measured with items such as having a home destroyed, losing + property or a pet, and knowing someone who was injured, was positively associated + with climate anxiety [8].

\n

Complementing + the stress process model, the framework of environmental identity [22] and the concept of ecological grief [23] provide the psychological mechanism for why directly + experiencing hurricane stressors activates this climate-specific form of anxiety + rather than generalized distress. First, on a cognitive level, environmental + identity (EID) represents a sense of connection to the non-human natural environment + influencing how individuals perceive and act toward the environment [22,24]. + For people with strong EID, the natural environment plays an important role + in their self-concept and who they are. Having a strong EID is positively + linked with pro-environmental attitudes and behaviors [22], as well as climate change risk perception and climate + anxiety [25]. While + EID varies across individuals, the EID framework suggests that in processing + the destruction resulting from a major hurricane, people may interpret such + an event through an ecological framework. That is, through an ecological lens, + hurricane-related stressors such as losses, damages, and adversities may not + be perceived solely as personal misfortune. Rather, experiencing such stressors + may serve as evidence of a larger, systemic environmental threat posed by + climate change, thereby activating climate-specific anxiety rather than generalized + anxiety. Furthermore, through an ecological lens, the losses and damages experienced + because of an extreme weather event or natural disaster, such as a major hurricane, + may manifest affectively as ecological grief, which refers to grief felt in + response to experienced or anticipated ecological losses [23]. As grief itself has been known to associate with + anxiety, researchers have found that ecological grief is associated with eco-related + anxiety [23,26]. In sum, environmental identity and ecological grief + provide the psychological mechanism explaining why hurricane stressor experience + produces climate anxiety as a distinct outcome rather than undifferentiated + psychological distress.

\n

Based on the literature above, we propose the + following hypothesis:

\n

H1: Hurricane stressors will + be positively associated with climate anxiety.

\n
\n\n
\n

2.2 Social capital

\n

Our study + also examines the potential relationship between social capital and climate + anxiety. Social capital refers to social ties and informal or formal connections + that enable individuals to develop norms of trust, reciprocity, and honesty + [10]. People with higher + social capital tend to be more likely to engage in collective action, ranging + from joining or volunteering for community organizations to watching over + their neighbors\u2019 properties [10,27]. Scholars have identified + three forms of social capital: bonding, bridging, and linking. Bonding, or + homophilous social capital, refers to the strong ties one has with kin and + close friends [28]. + Such ties offer emotional support and build shared identity, although they + tend to form among those who already share similar values and goals. In contrast + to bonding social capital, bridging and linking social capital are both considered + heterophilous, as they involve ties among individuals of diverse groups [28]. Bridging and linking + social capital are typically facilitated through participation in political, + civic, religious, and work-related activities. Such activities lean toward + being goal-oriented and offer networking opportunities and access to external + resources via extra-community ties [28]. + However, bridging and linking social capital are conceptually distinct. Bridging + social capital involves horizontal connections between people from different + groups and social levels, while linking social capital represents vertical + connections between people of varying levels of power (e.g., being connected + to public officials).

\n

Social capital may serve a protective role against + distress experienced because of disasters. For instance, a study conducted + in Japan during the recovery from the 2011 Fukushima nuclear power plant disaster + showed that higher levels of social capital were associated with experiencing + less anxiety [11]. + The central mechanism underlying social capital\u2019s protective role against + distress is its capacity to facilitate the support that enables individuals + to cope with a disaster. For example, Hawkins and Maurer [29] analyzed social capital during the recovery period + following Hurricane Katrina. They found that bonding social capital effectively + fostered immediate support after the hurricane. That is, during the period + immediately after Hurricane Katrina, most individuals who experienced the + storm first received or lent help to their families or others in their immediate + networks. Moreover, bridging and linking social capital, which connect individuals + from different backgrounds, could facilitate access to resources needed to + recover from a natural disaster [29]. + Bridging and linking social capital could serve as sources for instrumental + support, or tangible resources, after a disaster such as a hurricane [29]. Examples of instrumental support in the context + of hurricane recovery include receiving water, food, shelter, or financial + assistance. Linking social capital, in particular, which encompasses connections + between people of varying levels of power or authority (e.g., knowing a government + official), could open access to resources that one would not otherwise have + available [28]. Having + access to resources is important when navigating through or coping with stressful + experiences. After a hurricane, those with connections to government officials + or institutions may be the first to know where to look for governmental aid + or how to apply for disaster relief. In this case, as Hawkins and Maurer\u2019s + work suggests, bridging and linking social capital may be more important than + bonding social capital for sustaining the long-term post-hurricane recovery + and revitalization of a community [29].

\n

However, + it is important to acknowledge that a line of work informed by Portes indicates + that social capital may have a \u201Cdark side\u201D [30]. That is, it may result in negative consequences + in relation to disaster resilience and mental health [31\u201333]. + For instance, disaster literature points to the \u201Ccontagion of stress\u201D + effect of social capital among close-knit communities [31]. Specifically, in cohesive communities, the stress + experienced by one individual can easily spread through a well-connected social + network, creating a contagion that then amplifies the entire community\u2019s + anxiety levels [33]. + Bonding social capital, which is based on strong ties shared among homogenous + group members, may potentially heighten anxiety about climate change if such + ties include individuals who already feel extremely anxious about the climate + crisis. Thus, individuals within bonding social networks may also face similar + challenges and experience similar levels of climate anxiety due to the homogeneity + of such networks. Additionally, higher bridging and linking social capital + increases the potential of being exposed to a wide range of information regarding + climate change, particularly, those pertaining to climate threats. As previous + research has found, exposure to information about the impacts of climate change + is associated with heightened levels of climate anxiety [16].

\n

In sum, the research to date indicates that social + capital can serve a protective role against distress [11,28,29]. However, a specific + line of research suggests social capital may function as a double-edged sword, + exerting both positive and negative effects on disaster resilience [32] and health outcomes [33]. In acknowledging the positive and negative aspects + of social capital, we propose the following:

\n

RQ1: + How are (a) bonding, (b) bridging, and (c) linking social capital differentially + associated with climate anxiety?

\n

We also + examine the possibility that social capital would moderate the proposed relationship + between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety. As previously stated, the + stress process model views resources as central in explaining how a stressor + affects mental health outcomes [14]. + This model suggests that resources, such as those facilitated through social + capital, would condition the effects that stressors have on mental health + outcomes [15]. First, + on the one hand, extant research supports a \u201Cbuffering\u201D potential + of social capital. That is, it could help mitigate various forms of psychological + distress and enhance mental health [34,35]. Such research specifically + suggests that social capital markedly buffers the distress associated with + experiencing a disaster [11,36]. An explanation for + social capital\u2019s \u201Cbuffering\u201D potential is that it fosters the + support and resources necessary to cope with a natural disaster.

\n

On the other + hand, we also noted the \u201Cdark side\u201D potential of social capital + [30]. That is, it is + possible that the stresses experienced because of a hurricane may be amplified + by social capital, which would then result in heightened climate anxiety. + Disaster literature points to the \u201Ccontagion of stress\u201D effect of + social capital among close-knit communities [31]. For instance, in cohesive communities, the stress + experienced by one individual can easily spread through a well-connected social + network, creating a contagion that then amplifies the entire community\u2019s + anxiety levels [33].

\n

In + sum, the above literature suggests that social capital can both buffer and + amplify the relationship between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety. + However, the empirical evidence on how different types of social capital\u2014bonding, + bridging, or linking\u2014can differently shape climate anxiety or moderate + the psychological impact of hurricane stressors on anxiety, remains significantly + under-explored. Instead of hypothesizing a uniform buffering effect, we propose + the following research question:

\n

RQ2: + How will (a) bonding, (b) bridging, and (c) linking social capital moderate + the proposed positive association between hurricane stressors and climate + anxiety?

\n
\n
\n\n

3. Materials + and methods

\n
\n

3.1 + Ethics statement

\n

The survey and study were approved by the Institutional + Review Board (IRB) for human subjects research based at the University of + Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA [IRB Protocol # ET00043626, Approval date: October + 10, 2024] prior to data collection. Electronic informed consent, specifically, + active consent via a click-through process, was ensured before participants + were allowed to complete the survey. That is, prior to completing the online + survey, participants read a cover page that informed them about the survey + and study\u2019s purpose, the voluntary nature of the study, and that their + responses would remain anonymous. The bottom of the informed consent page + contained instructions stating that if participants agreed to participate, + they could click on the \u201CI agree to participate\u201D button to continue; + however, if they did not consent to participate, they could click on the \u201CI + do not wish to participate\u201D button or just close the browser window.

\n
\n\n
\n

3.2 + Procedure and participants

\n

This cross-sectional study utilized online surveys + targeting residents of counties with FEMA disaster declarations in Georgia, + North Carolina, and South Carolina following Hurricane Helene and in Florida + following both Helene and Milton. We contracted Qualtrics to collect the data + and administer the survey. Quota sampling was used to ensure representation + across demographic characteristics, including age and sex. In Georgia, North + Carolina, and South Carolina, surveys were administered in late October 2024, + roughly one month after Hurricane Helene made landfall, through the end of + November 2024 (recruitment of participants commenced on October 30, 2024, + and ended on November 28, 2024). In Florida, the survey was administered through + November 2024, about a month after Hurricane Milton made landfall (recruitment + of participants commenced on November 9, 2024, and ended on November 21, 2024). + In total, there were 3,329 completion attempts. Participants who did not consent + to taking the survey, sped through the survey, or indicated that they did + not live in a county impacted by either of the hurricanes, were excluded. + This left a final sample size of N\u2009=\u20091,342. The completion + rate was 40%.

\n
\n\n
\n

3.3 + Measures

\n\n

3.3.1 + Hurricane stressors.

We asked participants whether, in the past month, + they had indirectly or directly experienced hurricane-related stressors from + Hurricane Helene/Milton. We listed the following six stressors: (a) lack of + any resource (food, water, shelter, electricity) for over a week, (b) loss + of sentimental possessions or pets, (c) self or household member had health + problems, (d) financial loss, (e) housing situation changed as a result of + the hurricane, and (f) experienced any issues with mold, contamination, or + structural damage in your home due to the hurricane. The first four items + were adapted from Lowe et al. [15] + and we created the two remaining items. Responses to all the items for hurricane-related + stressors were scored with 1\u2009=\u2009yes, 0\u2009=\u2009no. We summed + and combined the items to form a single measure (M\u2009=\u20092.32, + SD\u2009=\u20091.91, \u03B1\u2009=\u2009.77).

\n
\n\n

3.3.2 + Climate change anxiety.

Three items from Clayton and Karazsia\u2019s + climate anxiety scale were used [9]: + (a) thinking about climate change makes it difficult for me to concentrate, + (b) I have nightmares about climate change, and (c) my friends say I think + about climate change too much [9]. + Responses were measured along a 5-point scale (1\u2009=\u2009strongly disagree, + 5\u2009=\u2009strongly agree), then we averaged and combined the items to + form a single measure (M\u2009=\u20092.47, SD\u2009=\u20091.07, + a\u2009=\u2009.85).

\n
\n\n

3.3.3 + Social capital.

Drawing on prior work on personal social capital, + online/social-media-enabled social capital, bonding and bridging social capital, + and linking social capital in disaster recovery, we adapted items to assess + three forms of social capital relevant to post-disaster coping and resource + access [29,37\u201339]. + Bonding social capital captured access to close interpersonal support, bridging + social capital captured access to resources and information beyond one\u2019s + immediate family or close friends, and linking social capital captured perceived + access to government-related contacts, information, and disaster-relief resources.

\n

Bonding social capital was measured + with the following items: (a) I have people I can turn to and ask for help, + (b) there is someone I can talk about my problems with, and (c) there is someone + who can give me emotional support (1\u2009=\u2009strongly disagree, 5\u2009=\u2009strongly + agree). The items were averaged and combined to form a single measure (M\u2009=\u20093.79, + SD\u2009=\u2009.98, \u03B1\u2009=\u2009.88).

\n

Bridging + social capital was measured with three items: (a) I know someone with resources + that my family or friends do not have, (b) there are people I can turn to + for new job opportunities, and (c) I know someone who can help me learn about + things that happen outside my community (1\u2009=\u2009strongly disagree, + 5\u2009=\u2009strongly agree). We averaged and combined these items to form + a single measure (M\u2009=\u20093.29, SD\u2009=\u2009.94, + \u03B1 =\u2009.74).

\n

Linking social capital was measured + with the following three items: (a) I know someone who works in the government, + (b) I know how to apply for disaster relief from the government, and (c) I + know where to look for governmental aid during disasters (1\u2009=\u2009strongly + disagree, 5\u2009=\u2009strongly agree). We averaged and combined the items + to form a single measure (M\u2009=\u20093.08, SD\u2009=\u2009.95, + \u03B1\u2009=\u2009.66).

\n
\n\n

3.3.4 Covariates.

We + measured and controlled for age, biological sex, state (Florida, Georgia, + North Carolina, South Carolina), educational attainment (continuous), income + (continuous), race and ethnicity, and political orientation (1\u2009=\u2009very + conservative, 5\u2009=\u2009very liberal). For state, Florida was treated + as the reference group in all the regression models as discussed in our analytical + strategy below. We thus included only Georgia, North Carolina, and South Carolina + as covariates in the regression models. For race, White was treated as the + reference group, and only Non-White Hispanic or Latino, Black, Asian and other + ethnicities as covariates in our regression models. We also included a measure + for generalized anxiety as a covariate [40], + which included the following four items adapted from the GAD-7 that asked + respondents whether in the last 2 weeks, how often they had experienced the + following: (a) been bothered by feeling nervous, anxious, or on edge, (b) + been bothered by not being able to stop or control worrying, (c) been bothered + by worrying too much about different things, and (d) been bothered by having + trouble relaxing. Responses were averaged and combined to form a single measure + (M\u2009=\u20092.17, SD\u2009=\u2009.96; \u03B1\u2009=\u2009.93). + Finally, the bonding, bridging, and linking social capital were included as + covariates when they were not respectively entered as moderators.

\n
\n
\n\n
\n

3.4 Data + analysis strategy

\n

All analyses were performed using SPSS version + 30 and the regression analyses were performed using the PROCESS macro [41]. Listwise deletion + was used to deal with missing data, and as such, all analyses were performed + on complete data (n\u2009=\u20091,327). To test H1 and investigate + RQ, we used PROCESS Model 1 to estimate three separate moderation analyses, + each respectively examining one form of social capital (bonding, bridging, + and linking social capital) as a moderator of the hurricane stressor-climate + anxiety relationship. This approach allowed us to isolate the unique moderating + effect of each social capital type while controlling for the others. Ninety-five + percent bootstrap confidence intervals (CIs) with 5,000 resamples were generated + for inference tests. The hypothesized moderation effects were assessed at + the analytical mean and one standard deviation below and above the mean of + each social capital variable. All predictors (hurricane stressors and the + three social capital variables) were mean-centered prior to analysis for the + purpose of interpreting the correlation when the interaction term was added + in the model. The covariates previously identified were included in all regression + analyses. We note that prior to analyzing the data, we also inspected the + zero-order correlation between the measure of generalized anxiety and climate + change anxiety, which was r\u2009=\u2009.24 (p\u2009<\u2009.05). + This level of correlation does not raise concerns about multicollinearity. + Lastly, all regression coefficients reported below are unstandardized (b).

\n
\n
\n\n

4. Results

\n
\n

4.1 + Sample characteristics

\n

Participant characteristics are reported in Table 1. The mean age of participants was + 46.03 years (SD\u2009=\u200917.33). There were also slightly more + males (55.1%) than females (44.9%), a majority of the sample resided in Florida + (53.5%), and most identified as White (63%) and politically moderate (39.3%). + Finally, the median education level reported was \u201Cone or more years of + college,\u201D and the median annual income reported was between \u201C$40,000-$59,999.\u201D

\n
\"thumbnail\"
Table 1. + Means, standard deviations, and descriptive statistics of key variables among + participants (N\u2009=\u20091,342).

\n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749.t001

\n\n
\n

4.2 + Hypothesis and research questions

\n

H1 expected + that experiencing hurricane stressors would be positively associated with + climate anxiety. This hypothesis was supported. Our results indicate that + with all other variables simultaneously taken into account, hurricane stressors + were positively associated with climate anxiety in all three regression models + reported in Table 1 (b\u2009=\u2009.073, + se\u2009=\u2009.031, p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009.065, + se\u2009=\u2009.016, p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009.065, + se\u2009=\u2009.016, p\u2009<\u2009.001).

\n

RQ1 investigated + how the three forms of social capital\u2014bonding, bridging, and linking\u2014are + associated with climate anxiety. As shown in Table + 2, there was a negative association between bonding social capital and + climate anxiety across all three regression models (b\u2009=\u2009-.178, + se\u2009=\u2009.032, p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009-.179, + se\u2009=\u2009.032, p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009-.180, + se\u2009=\u2009.032, p\u2009<\u2009.01). However, in + all three regression models, bridging (b\u2009=\u2009.220, se\u2009=\u2009.036, + p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009.217, se\u2009=\u2009.036, + p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009.212, se\u2009=\u2009.036, + p\u2009<\u2009.01) and linking social capital (b\u2009=\u2009.229, + se\u2009=\u2009.031, p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009.230, + se\u2009=\u2009.032, p\u2009<\u2009.001; b\u2009=\u2009.237, + se\u2009=\u2009.031, p\u2009<\u2009.01) were found to + be both positively associated with climate anxiety.

\n
\"thumbnail\"
Table 2. + Associations between hurricane stressors and social capital (bonding, bridging, + and linking) with climate anxiety.

\n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749.t002

RQ2 + investigated whether the association between experiencing hurricane stressors + and climate anxiety was moderated by the three forms of social capital. First, + as shown in Table 2, an interaction term + between hurricane stressors and bonding social capital was significant (b\u2009=\u2009.047, + se\u2009=\u2009.013, p\u2009<\u2009.001), indicating + that the association between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety varied + at different levels of bonding social capital. As shown in Table + 3, the relationship between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety was + significant when bonding social capital was at its mean (b\u2009=\u2009.073, + se\u2009=\u2009.016, p\u2009<\u2009.001) and 1SD above + the mean (b\u2009=\u2009.119, se\u2009=\u2009.021, p\u2009<\u2009.001), + but not at 1SD below the mean (b\u2009=\u2009.027, se\u2009=\u2009.020, + p\u2009=\u2009.176). Fig 1 shows + the plot of this interaction effect. At low levels of hurricane stressors, + participants with high bonding social capital reported a relatively low level + of climate anxiety. However, as hurricane stressors increased, the slope for + those with high bonding social capital became much steeper than those with + lower bonding social capital.

\n
\"thumbnail\"
Table 3. + A moderation model of bonding, bridging, and linking social capital on climate + change anxiety.

\n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749.t003

\"thumbnail\"
Fig 1. + Bonding social capital as a moderator of the relationship between hurricane + stressors and climate change anxiety.

\n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749.g001

Second, + as Table 2 shows, the interaction between + hurricane stressors and bridging social capital was significant (b\u2009=\u2009.053, + se\u2009=\u2009.013, p\u2009<\u2009.001). Similar to what was + found for bonding social capital, the relationship between hurricane stressors + and climate anxiety was not significant when bridging social capital was at + 1SD below the mean (b\u2009=\u2009.015, se\u2009=\u2009.021, + p\u2009=\u2009.464). Yet, as Table + 3 indicates, this relationship became progressively stronger as levels + of bridging social capital increased from its mean (b\u2009=\u2009.065, + se\u2009=\u2009.016, p\u2009<\u2009.001) to 1SD above + the mean (b\u2009=\u2009.114, se\u2009=\u2009.020, p\u2009<\u2009.001). + The plot for this interaction is illustrated in Fig + 2. In contrast to the results for bonding social capital, Fig + 2 indicates that at lower levels of hurricane stressors, climate anxiety + was slightly higher for participants with higher bridging social capital. + As hurricane stressors increased, the slope of the stress-anxiety relationship + became steeper for participants with higher levels of bridging social capital. + In contrast, the slope was relatively flat for those with low bridging social + capital.

\n
\"thumbnail\"
Fig 2. + Bridging social capital as a moderator of the relationship between hurricane + stressors and climate change anxiety.

\n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749.g002

Third, + the interaction between hurricane stressors and linking social capital was + also significant (b\u2009=\u2009.062, se\u2009=\u2009.014, + p\u2009<\u2009.001), and similar to the pattern found for both + bonding and bridging social capital, the relationship between hurricane stressors + and climate anxiety was not significant when linking social capital was at + 1SD below the mean (b\u2009=\u2009.007, se\u2009=\u2009.021, + p\u2009=\u2009.752). Yet, the relationship became stronger as levels + of linking social capital increased from its mean (b\u2009=\u2009.065, + se\u2009=\u2009.016, p\u2009<\u2009.001) to 1SD above + the mean (b\u2009=\u2009.123, se\u2009=\u2009.020, p\u2009<\u2009.001) + (see Table 3 and Fig + 3). As shown in Fig 3, the pattern + of the plot for linking social capital is similar to that for bridging social + capital. That is, at lower levels of hurricane stressors, climate anxiety + was slightly higher for participants with higher linking social capital, and + the slope for the relationship between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety + was steeper for participants with higher linking social capital.

\n
\"thumbnail\"
Fig 3. + Linking social capital as a moderator of the relationship between hurricane + stressors and climate change anxiety.

\n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749.g003

\n\n
\n

4.3 Ancillary analyses: Association of covariates + with climate anxiety

\n

As Table 2 + shows, income (b = between\u2009.054 to.056) and black race/ethnicity (b = + between\u2009.221 to\u2009.222) were both positively associated with climate + anxiety, and South Carolina residence (relative to the Florida reference group) + was negatively associated (b = between -.251 to\u2009.228). Also, generalized + anxiety as a covariate was positively associated with climate change anxiety + (b = between -.182 to -.178).

\n
\n
\n\n

5. + Discussion

Hurricanes Helene and Milton caused widespread + devastation across several Southeastern states in the U.S. [1,2]. + The first purpose of the present study was to test whether stressful experiences + or stressors associated with Hurricanes Helene and Milton would be positively + related with climate anxiety. We analyzed data from surveys conducted in the + counties of four U.S. states impacted by the two hurricanes. Our finding confirms + that hurricane stressors were positively associated with climate anxiety, + supporting previous research conducted by Garfin and Wong-Parodi [8] and more broadly expanding past research linking + personal experiences with hurricanes to psychological distress. This finding + is also consistent with the stress process model [14], which explains why stressors such as hurricane-related + losses and damages are associated with adverse psychological outcomes. Moreover, + the positive association between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety aligns + with the psychological mechanisms proffered by the environmental identity + [22] framework and + the concept of ecological grief [23], + which both suggest that experiences with hurricane stressors could be interpreted + through an ecological lens connecting immediate loss to the broader systemic + threat of climate change. However, we note that our surveys did not include + measures for environmental identity and ecological grief. Thus, future studies + could examine these variables as potential mechanisms that may explain the + association between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety. In addition, + climate change risk perceptions or climate change attributions are also constructs + that reflect cognitive appraisals of climate change as a threatening phenomenon + [42], and as such are + conceptually similar to climate anxiety. As our study did not assess these + constructs, future research could investigate how hurricane stressors may + be linked to such variables.

\n

The second purpose of our study was to explore + the relationship between social capital and climate anxiety. We examined three + forms of social capital: bonding, bridging, and linking. Our findings, on + the one hand, indicated that bonding social capital was inversely associated + with climate anxiety. This finding could be reflective of the \u201Cbuffering\u201D + or protective potential of bonding social capital and may align with the findings + of a previous study by Hawkins and Maurer [29], which suggested that bonding social capital, compared + with bridging and linking social capital, may more effectively foster immediate + support after a hurricane. As such, in our study, bonding social capital was + negatively associated with anxieties about climate change for our participants + who were recovering from Hurricane Helene/Milton. On the other hand, we found + that both bridging and linking social capital were associated with heightened + climate anxiety. We proffer one possible explanation for these results. Specifically, + it could be that participants\u2019 heterogenous social ties, facilitated + by bridging and linking social capital, may have comprised a large proportion + of people expressing worries about the climate crisis. As such, this may have + increased the likelihood of developing similar climate concerns. However, + our surveys did not contain measures assessing the proportions of people expressing + worries about the climate crisis within one\u2019s heterogenous networks. + We thus recommend future studies be conducted to measure this variable and + examine its potential role in explaining how bridging and linking social capital + could be both positively associated with climate anxiety.

\n

The third purpose + of our study was to explore the possibility that social capital would moderate + the positive relationship between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety. + To this end, our findings indicated that social capital did moderate the relationship + between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety. However, the specific moderation + pattern differed across bonding versus bridging and linking social capital. + Specifically, our results suggested that bonding social capital\u2019s protective + role is conditional and reverses under high stress, rather than following + a classic buffering pattern [43]. + As Fig 1 shows, participants with high + bonding social capital reported lower climate anxiety at low stressor levels. + A classic buffering pattern would reveal a flattening hurricane stressor-anxiety + slope for the high-bonding social capital group and steeper slopes for the + low and moderate groups. Yet, our data showed the opposite. The slope was + steeper for the high bonding social capital group. That is, bonding social + capital weakens the relationship between hurricane stressors and climate anxiety + only when hurricane stressors were low. As stressors accumulated, bonding + social capital strengthens the association between stressors and climate anxiety, + possibly because stress was transmitted within dense social networks [31]. Resources that are typically protective become + less effective under high stress conditions [43]. In the context of hurricane coping and recovery, + close-knit networks of family and friends often provide critical support in + the early stages of a disaster [23]. + However, when stressors accumulate, such as when hurricanes bring prolonged, + repeated disruptions, the same networks may shift from being a source of support + to a source of strain. For example, anxiety and worry may spread more easily + within tightly knit groups, creating collective stress as shared resources + become depleted. In addition, individuals embedded in strong bonding networks + may feel the pressure to reciprocate by caring for others, which can amplify + their own feelings of anxiety and emotional fatigue.

\n

Yet our pattern + of findings for bridging and linking social capital suggested that they amplified + the positive association between hurricanes stressors and climate anxiety. + This finding is in contrast with previous research that indicated social capital + to serve as a buffer or play a protective role against anxiety following disasters + [11]. It is possible + that higher bridging and linking social capital increases the potential of + being exposed to a wider span of information regarding climate change, namely, + those pertaining to climate threats. As we noted, past research has found + that exposure to information about the impacts of climate change is positively + associated with climate anxiety [16]. + One practical implication of these findings is that risk communication delivered + through bridging and linking networks is better designed to pair disaster + information with concrete efficacy and coping resources, so that heightened + awareness does not only translate into distress. As the association between + hurricane stressors and climate anxiety was strongest among individuals with + high linking social capital, governmental and institutional risk communicators, + in particular, may wish to attend to the social or emotional\u2014not only + the informational\u2014consequences of their messages following disaster events.

\n

Nevertheless, + these findings collectively contribute to the literature by suggesting that + the relationship between social capital and climate anxiety is more nuanced + and there may be different theoretical mechanisms at play when assessing the + role of social capital in one\u2019s disaster experience. It further underscores + the complexity of social capital\u2019s role in different disaster scenarios. + Furthermore, the just mentioned findings regarding social capital may also + be reflective of the cognitive and structural dimensions of social capital. + Its cognitive aspect focuses on trust and support perceptions, and they have + been consistently linked to lowered anxiety and improved mental health state. + However, studies have found that the structural dimension of social capital, + indicated by one\u2019s participation or connection to social networks, are + related to mental health outcomes in more ambiguous ways. For example, Wind + and colleagues [44] + found that cognitive social capital was negatively related to mental health + issues following a disaster, whereas structural social capital exacerbated + feelings of anxiety. As the current operationalizations of social capital + did not distinguish the cognitive and structural dimensions, the observed + moderation relationship may be explained by the mixed effects of cognitive + versus structural aspects of social capital.

\n

Finally, although + they were included as covariates in our models, we again note the following + findings. First, the measure for generalized anxiety had a stronger association + with climate anxiety than hurricane stressors did. The simple explanation + for this is that generalized anxiety and climate anxiety are both anxiety + constructs and likely share underlying features, even though they remain both + conceptually distinct in their specific focus or content. On the other hand, + hurricane stressors are an external, event-based exposure variable, and as + such, are less proximate to an internalizing symptom measure like climate + anxiety. Second, income and black race/ethnicity (b around.22) were both positively + associated with climate anxiety. These findings respectively imply that individuals + with higher household incomes and those who identify as black may experience + greater climate anxiety. We speculate that higher-income individuals may be + disproportionately exposed to climate-related information, which may heighten + their climate anxiety. Additionally, the well-documented vulnerability of + black communities to the adverse effects of climate-related disasters such + as hurricanes [45] + may similarly heighten their awareness of and anxiety about climate change. + This warrants further investigation about potential racial and ethnic differences + in climate anxiety. Finally, living in South Carolina was negatively associated + with climate anxiety. One plausible explanation for this finding is the differential + impact of Hurricanes Helene and Milton across states. While South Carolina + was affected by Hurricane Helene, the storm\u2019s most severe impacts were + concentrated elsewhere. Thus, it could be that the South Carolina residents + sampled in our study may have experienced comparatively less devastation, + which may in turn have produced lower levels of climate anxiety. Future research + could examine this explanation by including state-level measures that account + for differential hurricane impacts.

\n\n
\n

5.1 Limitations and future directions

\n

Although + our study provides interesting results regarding experiencing an environmental + disaster on people\u2019s information behavior strategies, it has weaknesses + that must be acknowledged. First, our study utilizes cross-sectional data. + As a result, the cross-sectional design limits causal inference about whether + social capital patterns preceded or resulted from hurricane exposure. Thus, + we recommend future research, such as experimental studies be conducted to + test whether in fact hurricane stressors are positively predictive of climate + anxiety.

\n

Second, potential discrepancies in our measures + may have influenced our findings. Specifically, while our primary independent + variable focuses on hurricane-related stressors, the corresponding measure + of anxiety focuses on the issue of climate change more broadly. The issue + here is that people may not directly associate hurricane experiences with + climate change-specific anxiety. To address this issue, future studies should + examine general anxiety tied to the specific event, to ensure a more precise + match between the disaster experienced and the anxiety measured.

\n

Third, regarding + the measure used for climate change anxiety, we acknowledge that two of the + three items drawn from Clayton and Karazsia\u2019s climate anxiety scale [9] were taken from the + scale\u2019s functional impairment subscale, while one was drawn from the + cognitive-emotional subscale. It could be argued, therefore, that these items + more precisely captured climate change-related preoccupation or functional + impairment, constructs that are related to but distinct from core climate + symptomology. We note, however, that this limitation does not invalidate our + findings, but rather contextualizes the interpretation of our outcome variable. + Specifically, the climate change anxiety measure used in our study should + be understood as reflecting climate change-related cognitive preoccupation + and functional impairment rather than climate anxiety in its fullest sense. + Ultimately, we recommend that future research use the full measure of climate + change anxiety, which can adequately capture both dimensions of climate anxiety + conceptualized by Clayton and Karazsia (i.e., functional impairment and cognitive-emotional + dimensions) [9].

\n

Fourth, + while the Cronbach\u2019s alpha for linking social capital in our study (\u03B1\u2009=\u2009.66) + fell slightly below the conventional.70 threshold, this likely reflects the + inherent multi-dimensionality of linking social capital as a construct rather + than poor reliability per se. Cronbach\u2019s alpha assumes unidimensionality + [46]. This is a condition + that works against linking social capital, which captures structurally distinct + ties between individuals and institutional actors [22]. Yet we should note that the mean inter-item correlation + for the linking social items in our present study was.41. This falls within + the acceptable range recommended for multidimensional constructs [47], thus providing supplementary evidence of adequate + reliability.

\n

Finally, the data analyzed for this study were + not representative of the population of interest. Nevertheless, we believe + the use of a non-probability sample is appropriate given the context. Identifying + a representative sample of individuals affected by hurricanes poses significant + challenges, particularly when many potential participants are engaged in recovery + efforts or may lack the time or resources to participate in the current research. + Thus, even though these are not representative data, we believe it would be + difficult to obtain this type of sample given the situation after the hurricanes.

\n
\n\n
\n

5.2 Conclusion

\n

Our + findings help extend the stress process model and social capital research + by showing the more nuanced role of social capital. Specifically, we extended + understanding of the link between hurricane-related stressors among those + who have experienced major hurricanes and their levels of climate change anxiety, + and the role of social capital in conditioning this link. We also found some + evidence suggesting that bonding social capital\u2019s protective role is + conditional and reverses under high stress. That is, bonding social capital + may serve a protective role only when hurricane stressors are low, but not + when they are high. Furthermore, rather than acting as a protective buffer, + our study suggested higher levels of bridging and linking social capital were + associated with more climate anxiety. While these findings for social capital + may be viewed as more reflective of its \u201Cdark side\u201D potential [16], it is worth noting + that research suggests climate anxiety is also associated with adaptive coping + strategies, such as increased engagement in pro-environmental behaviors and + other actions to address or mitigate climate change [48,49]. + As such, in cases where social capital strengthens the relationship between + hurricane stressors and climate anxiety, higher levels of climate anxiety + may result in adaptive climate-related actions, including greater engagement + in pro-environmental and climate advocacy behaviors. Since our study did not + assess climate anxiety\u2019s impact on behaviors, it is important for research + to further analyze this possibility. Practically, we should consider strengthening + close social support and basic coping skills before disasters occur and stress + escalates. Post-disaster efforts should manage information flows with clear + updates, specific resources, and tips to help those in need, and counter misinformation + to limit unnecessary anxiety.

\n
\n
\n\n\n\n

References

  1. 1.\n Cohen L. Here\u2019s + how Hurricane Helene brought \u201Cbiblical devastation\u201D to Western North + Carolina in a near \u201Cworst-case scenario; 2024 [cited 2024 Oct 10]. Available + from: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hurricane-helene-biblical-devastation-north-carolina-near-worst-case-scenario/ +
    • 2.\n + \ Wilcox C, Jacobs P. Hurricane-battered researchers + assess damage. Science. 2024;386(6720):367. pmid:39446958
    • 3.\n + \ Kearbey R. The Gulf of Mexico has reached alarmingly + high temperatures. Climate Adaption Center; 2024. Available from: https://www.theclimateadaptationcenter.org/2024/08/23/the-gulf-of-mexico-has-reached-alarmingly-high-temperatures/ +
      • 4.\n + \ Schmall E. How back-to-back hurricanes harm mental + health. The New York Times; 2024. Available from: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/10/well/hurricane-milton-helene-mental-health.html +
        • 5.\n + \ Sanchez R. Milton and Helene are taking a toll on + the mental health of Floridians, leaving a trail of anxiety and frayed nerves; + 2024. Available from: https://www.cnn.com/2024/10/13/us/hurricane-milton-helene-florida-mental-health +
          • 6.\n + \ Galea S, Brewin CR, Gruber M, Jones RT, King DW, + King LA, et al. Exposure to hurricane-related stressors and mental illness + after Hurricane Katrina. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2007;64(12):1427\u201334. pmid:18056551 +
          • 7.\n + \ Kessler RC, Galea S, Gruber MJ, Sampson NA, Ursano + RJ, Wessely S. Trends in mental illness and suicidality after Hurricane Katrina. + Mol Psychiatry. 2008;13(4):374\u201384. pmid:18180768
          • 8.\n + \ Garfin DR, Wong-Parodi G. Climate change anxiety, + hurricane exposure, and climate change actions and attitudes: Results from + a representative, probability-based survey of US Gulf Coast residents. Lancet + Planet Health. 2024;8(6):e378\u201390. pmid:38849180
          • 9.\n + \ Clayton S, Karazsia BT. Development and validation + of a measure of climate change anxiety. J Environ Psychol. 2020;69:101434. + \
          • 10.\n + \ Putnam R. Bowling alone: The collapse and revival + of American community. New York (NY): Simon and Schuster; 2000.
            • 11.\n Iwasaki K, Sawada Y, + Aldrich DP. Social capital as a shield against anxiety among displaced residents + from Fukushima. Nat Hazards. 2017;89(1):405\u201321.
            • 12.\n + \ Adger WN. Social capital, collective action, and + adaptation to climate change. Econ Geogr. 2003;79:387\u2013404.
            • 13.\n + \ Aldrich DP. Building resilience: Social capital + in post-disaster recovery. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 2012.
              • 14.\n + \ Pearlin LI. The sociological study of stress. J + Health Soc Behav. 1989;30(3):241\u201356. pmid:2674272
              • 15.\n + \ Lowe SR, Joshi S, Pietrzak RH, Galea S, Cerd\xE1 + M. Mental health and general wellness in the aftermath of Hurricane Ike. Soc + Sci Med. 2015;124:162\u201370. pmid:25461873
              • 16.\n + \ Ogunbode CA, Doran R, Hanss D, Ojala M, Salmela-Aro + K, van den Broek KL, et al. Climate anxiety, wellbeing and pro-environmental + action: Correlates of negative emotional responses to climate change in 32 + countries. J Environ Psychol. 2022;84:101887.
              • 17.\n + \ Asgarizadeh Z, Gifford R, Colborne L. Predicting + climate change anxiety. J Environ Psychol. 2023;90:1\u201310.
              • 18.\n + \ Wang Z, Wu X, Dai W, Kaminga AC, Wu X, Pan X, et + al. The prevalence of posttraumatic stress disorder among survivors after + a typhoon or hurricane: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Disaster Med + Public Health Prep. 2019;13(5\u20136):1065\u201373. pmid:31204633
              • 19.\n + \ Herbst K, Malmin NP, Paul S, Williamson T, Sugg + MM, Schreck CJ, et al. Examining recurrent hurricane exposure and psychiatric + morbidity in Medicaid-insured pregnant populations. PLOS Ment Health. 2024;1(1):e0000040. + \ pmid:41661697
              • 20.\n + \ Pietrzak RH, Tracy M, Galea S, Kilpatrick DG, Ruggiero + KJ, Hamblen JL, et al. Resilience in the face of disaster: Prevalence and + longitudinal course of mental disorders following hurricane Ike. PLoS One. + 2012;7(6):e38964. pmid:22761716
              • 21.\n + \ American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and + statistical manual of mental disorders. 5th ed., text rev. ed. Washington, + DC: American Psychiatric Association Publishing; 2022.
                • 22.\n Clayton S. Environmental + identity: A conceptual and an operational definition. In: Identity and the + natural environment: The psychological significance of nature; 2003. p. 45\u201365. +
                  • 23.\n + \ Cunsolo A, Ellis NR. Ecological grief as a mental + health response to climate change-related loss. Nat Clim Change. 2018;8(4):275\u201381. + \
                  • 24.\n + \ Clayton S. Environment and identity. In: Clayton + S, editor. Oxford handbook of conservation and environmental psychology. New + York: Oxford University Press; 2012. p. 164\u201380.
                    • 25.\n Pinho M. The role of + parental identity in experiencing climate change anxiety and pro-environmental + behaviors. Front Psychol. 2025;16:1579893. pmid:40201753
                    • 26.\n + \ Pihkala P. Eco-anxiety and environmental education. + Sustainability. 2020;12(23):10149.
                    • 27.\n + \ Beaudoin CE, Thorson E. Social capital in rural + and urban communities: Testing differences in media effects and models. J + Mass Commun Q. 2004;81(2):378\u201399.
                    • 28.\n + \ Poortinga W. Community resilience and health: The + role of bonding, bridging, and linking aspects of social capital. Health Place. + 2012;18(2):286\u201395. pmid:22037322
                    • 29.\n + \ Hawkins RL, Maurer K. Bonding, bridging and linking: + How social capital operated in New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina. Br + J Soc Work. 2009;40(6):1777\u201393.
                    • 30.\n + \ Portes A. Social capital: Its origins and applications + in modern society. Annu Rev Sociol. 1998;24:1\u201324.
                    • 31.\n + \ Kawachi I, Berkman LF. Social ties and mental health. + J Urban Health. 2001;78(3):458\u201367. pmid:11564849
                    • 32.\n + \ MacGillivray BH. Beyond social capital: The norms, + belief systems, and agency embedded in social networks shape resilience to + climatic and geophysical hazards. Environ Sci Policy. 2018;89:116\u201325. + \
                    • 33.\n + \ Villalonga-Olives E, Kawachi I. The dark side of + social capital: A systematic review of the negative health effects of social + capital. Soc Sci Med. 2017;194:105\u201327. pmid:29100136
                    • 34.\n + \ Flores EC, Fuhr DC, Bayer AM, Lescano AG, Thorogood + N, Simms V. Mental health impact of social capital interventions: A systematic + review. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2018;53(2):107\u201319. pmid:29234826 +
                    • 35.\n + \ Song L. Social capital and psychological distress. + J Health Soc Behav. 2011;52(4):478\u201392. pmid:22021655
                    • 36.\n + \ Wang D. Effects of social capital on mental health + of disaster victims: Evidence from the Wenchuan earthquake. Int J Disaster + Risk Reduct. 2022;83:103386.
                    • 37.\n + \ Chen X, Stanton B, Gong J, Fang X, Li X. Personal + Social Capital Scale: An instrument for health and behavioral research. Health + Educ Res. 2009;24(2):306\u201317. pmid:18469318
                    • 38.\n + \ Williams D. On and off the \u2018Net: Scales for + social capital in an online era. J Comput Mediat Commun. 2006;11(2):593\u2013628. +
                    • 39.\n + \ Cotten SR, Schuster AM, Seifert A. Social media + use and well-being among older adults. Curr Opin Psychol. 2022;45:101293. + \ pmid:35065352
                    • 40.\n + \ Spitzer RL, Kroenke K, Williams JBW, L\xF6we B. + A brief measure for assessing generalized anxiety disorder: The GAD-7. Arch + Intern Med. 2006;166(10):1092\u20137. pmid:16717171
                    • 41.\n + \ Hayes AF. Introduction to mediation, moderation, + and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach. Guilford Press; + 2013.
                      • 42.\n + \ Ogunbode CA, Demski C, Capstick SB, Sposato RG. + Attribution matters: Revisiting the link between extreme weather experience + and climate change mitigation responses. Glob Environ Change. 2019;54:31\u20139. + \
                      • 43.\n + \ Salzinger S, Rosario M, Feldman RS, Ng-Mak DS. Role + of parent and peer relationships and individual characteristics in middle + school children\u2019s behavioral outcomes in the face of community violence. + J Res Adolesc. 2011;21(2):395\u2013407. pmid:21643493
                      • 44.\n + \ Wind TR, Fordham M, Komproe IH. Social capital and + post-disaster mental health. Glob Health Action. 2011;4:10.3402/gha.v4i0.6351. + \ pmid:21695072
                      • 45.\n + \ Berberian AG, Gonzalez DJX, Cushing LJ. Racial disparities + in climate change-related health effects in the United States. Curr Environ + Health Rep. 2022;9(3):451\u201364. pmid:35633370
                      • 46.\n + \ Cortina JM. What is coefficient alpha? An examination + of theory and applications. J Appl Psychol. 1993;78(1):98\u2013104.
                      • 47.\n + \ Briggs SR, Cheek JM. The role of factor analysis + in the development and evaluation of personality scales. J Pers. 1986;54(1):106\u201348. +
                      • 48.\n + \ Crandon TJ, Scott JG, Charlson FJ, Thomas HJ. A + theoretical model of climate change anxiety and coping. Discov Psychol. 2024;4. + \
                      • 49.\n + \ Kricorian K, Kricorian C, Turner K. Predictors and + correlates of self-reported climate anxiety in the United States. PLOS Clim. + 2025;4(7):e0000534.
                      \n\n\n\n
                      \n
                      \n\n + \
                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n\n + \
                      \n \n
                      \n\n\n\n\n
                      \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n \n \n \n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                      \n\n\n" + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:10 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Vary: + - Accept-Encoding + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '222922' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-one].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-one].yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..03c45f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi[plos-one].yaml @@ -0,0 +1,1880 @@ +interactions: +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.207 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"42868208","objurls":[],"info":"No + LinkOut links available for UID: 42868208"}]}]} + + ' + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:07 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D322F91B7495C3500004DFBDEFFADEF.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 5A4B80A627C69E87_861FSID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=5A4B80A627C69E87_861FSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:44:08 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '9' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '176' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=5A4B80A627C69E87_861FSID + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.207 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json + response: + body: + string: "{\"header\":{\"type\":\"esummary\",\"version\":\"0.3\"},\"result\":{\"uids\":[\"42868208\"],\"42868208\":{\"uid\":\"42868208\",\"pubdate\":\"2026\",\"epubdate\":\"2026 + Oct 13\",\"source\":\"PLoS One\",\"authors\":[{\"name\":\"Urra-Barra G\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Acevedo + G\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Leighton-Vallejos + E\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Ruiz-Gonz\xE1lez + V\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez + C\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"}],\"lastauthor\":\"D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez + C\",\"title\":\"Practice-based initial teacher education in alternative teaching + certification programs: A scoping review protocol.\",\"sorttitle\":\"practice + based initial teacher education in alternative teaching certification programs + a scoping review protocol\",\"volume\":\"21\",\"issue\":\"10\",\"pages\":\"e0360047\",\"lang\":[\"eng\"],\"nlmuniqueid\":\"101285081\",\"issn\":\"\",\"essn\":\"1932-6203\",\"pubtype\":[\"Journal + Article\"],\"recordstatus\":\"PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE\",\"pubstatus\":\"258\",\"articleids\":[{\"idtype\":\"pubmed\",\"idtypen\":1,\"value\":\"42868208\"},{\"idtype\":\"doi\",\"idtypen\":3,\"value\":\"10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\"},{\"idtype\":\"pii\",\"idtypen\":4,\"value\":\"PONE-D-26-12708\"},{\"idtype\":\"pmc\",\"idtypen\":8,\"value\":\"PMC13660980\"},{\"idtype\":\"pmcid\",\"idtypen\":5,\"value\":\"pmc-id: + PMC13660980;\"}],\"history\":[{\"pubstatus\":\"received\",\"date\":\"2026/04/29 + 00:00\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"accepted\",\"date\":\"2026/09/21 00:00\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"medline\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 + 23:37\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"pubmed\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 23:36\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"entrez\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 + 18:14\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"pmc-release\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 00:00\"}],\"references\":[],\"attributes\":[\"Has + Abstract\"],\"pmcrefcount\":20,\"fulljournalname\":\"PloS one\",\"elocationid\":\"doi: + 10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\",\"doctype\":\"citation\",\"srccontriblist\":[],\"booktitle\":\"\",\"medium\":\"\",\"edition\":\"\",\"publisherlocation\":\"\",\"publishername\":\"\",\"srcdate\":\"\",\"reportnumber\":\"\",\"availablefromurl\":\"\",\"locationlabel\":\"\",\"doccontriblist\":[],\"docdate\":\"\",\"bookname\":\"\",\"chapter\":\"\",\"sortpubdate\":\"2026/10/13 + 00:00\",\"sortfirstauthor\":\"Urra-Barra G\",\"vernaculartitle\":\"\"}}}\n" + headers: + Access-Control-Allow-Origin: + - '*' + Access-Control-Expose-Headers: + - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining + Alt-Svc: + - clear + Cache-Control: + - private + Content-Security-Policy: + - upgrade-insecure-requests + Content-Type: + - application/json; charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:07 GMT + Ncbi-Phid: + - 1D3407F95CD407A5000055065A9482EC.1.1.m_1 + Ncbi-Sid: + - 5A4B80A627C69E87_861FSID + Referrer-Policy: + - origin-when-cross-origin + Server: + - Finatra + Set-Cookie: + - ncbi_sid=5A4B80A627C69E87_861FSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 + Oct 2027 13:44:08 GMT + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Ratelimit-Limit: + - '10' + X-Ratelimit-Remaining: + - '8' + X-Ua-Compatible: + - IE=Edge + X-Xss-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '2087' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.91 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047 + response: + body: + string: 'Handle Redirect + + https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047' + headers: + CF-RAY: + - a4a7045c1d009abe-DFW + Connection: + - keep-alive + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=utf-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:08 GMT + Nel: + - '{"report_to":"cf-nel","success_fraction":0.0,"max_age":604800}' + Report-To: + - '{"group":"cf-nel","max_age":604800,"endpoints":[{"url":"https://a.nel.cloudflare.com/report/v4?s=pVjaSklfxCpUwOP6jLxoIX56mfXCpedk2TzEhBeZqmWdDm2HfhgkU4zPvh3QdOcmx6sbqH2E%2FHETDFqMGH0WLH%2FC66zxDETn4ZyKvpkGX4ANSZf6ggw5klE%3D"}]}' + Server: + - cloudflare + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + alt-svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=86400 + cf-cache-status: + - DYNAMIC + expires: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 14:11:13 GMT + location: + - https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047 + permissions-policy: + - interest-cohort=(),browsing-topics=() + vary: + - Origin + - Accept + status: + code: 302 + message: Found +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.91 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047 + response: + body: + string: ' + + + + 301 Moved Permanently + + + +

                      Moved Permanently

                      + +

                      The document has moved here.

                      + +
                      + +
                      Apache Server at dx.plos.org Port 80
                      + + + + ' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Content-Length: + - '338' + Content-Type: + - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:08 GMT + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0360047 + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CJDP8sGRptHZTBAD; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + Via: + - 1.1 google + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.91 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0360047 + response: + body: + string: '' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Length: + - '0' + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:07 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0360047 + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CKqOuoWYivfCLxAD; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - GCLB=CKqOuoWYivfCLxAD + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.91 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0360047 + response: + body: + string: "\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n + \ \n\n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n\n \n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n \n\n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n Practice-based + initial teacher education in alternative teaching certification programs: + A scoping review protocol | PLOS One\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                      \n
                      \n \n Skip to main + content\n \n\n
                      \n
                      Advertisement
                      \n\n \n
                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n\n \n
                      \n\n
                      \n
                      \n\n\n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n Browse Subject Areas\n
                      ?
                      \n + \
                      \n

                      Click through the PLOS taxonomy + to find articles in your field.

                      \n

                      For more information about + PLOS Subject Areas, click\n here.\n

                      \n + \
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n \n \n + \
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n\n\n\n\n\n
                        \n
                      • \n

                        Loading + metrics

                        \n
                      • \n
                      \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                      \n\n
                      \n + \

                      Open Access

                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Study Protocol

                      \n
                      \n\n\n
                      \n + \
                      \n
                      \n\n\n\n
                      \n + \

                      Practice-based + initial teacher education in alternative teaching certification programs: + A scoping review protocol

                      \n\n
                        \n\n\n\n\n + \ \nGerardo Urra-Barra, + \
                        \n\n + \ \n

                        \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Methodology,\n\n Writing \u2013 original + draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                        \n \n

                        Affiliation\n Facultad de Educaci\xF3n, Universidad + San Sebasti\xE1n, Chile\n

                        \n\n ⨯ \n
                        \n\n\n\n \nGraciela Acevedo , + \
                        \n\n + \ \n

                        \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Methodology,\n\n Writing \u2013 original + draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                        \n

                        + * E-mail: Graciela.acevedo@uss.cl

                        \n + \

                        Affiliation\n Facultad + de Educaci\xF3n, Universidad San Sebasti\xE1n, Chile\n

                        \n \n\n ⨯ \n
                        \n\n\n\n \nErich Leighton-Vallejos,
                        \n\n \n

                        \n Roles\n Conceptualization,\n\n + \ Methodology,\n\n Writing \u2013 original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 + review & editing\n

                        \n \n

                        Affiliation\n + \ Facultad de Educaci\xF3n, Universidad San Sebasti\xE1n, Chile\n

                        \n\n + \ + ⨯ \n
                        \n\n\n\n \nV\xEDctor Ruiz-Gonz\xE1lez, + \
                        \n\n + \ \n

                        \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Methodology,\n\n Writing \u2013 original + draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                        \n \n

                        Affiliation\n Facultad de Educaci\xF3n, Universidad + San Sebasti\xE1n, Chile\n

                        \n\n ⨯ \n
                        \n\n\n\n \nCamila D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez
                        \n\n \n

                        \n Roles\n Conceptualization,\n\n + \ Methodology,\n\n Writing \u2013 original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 + review & editing\n

                        \n \n

                        Affiliation\n + \ Facultad de Educaci\xF3n, Universidad San Sebasti\xE1n, Chile\n

                        \n\n + \ + ⨯ \n
                        \n\n\n
                      \n\n\n
                      \n\n\n
                      \n + \
                      \n
                      \n

                      Practice-based initial teacher education + in alternative teaching certification programs: A scoping review protocol

                      \n\n
                        \n\n
                      • Gerardo + Urra-Barra, \n\n
                      • \n
                      • Graciela Acevedo, \n\n + \
                      • \n
                      • Erich Leighton-Vallejos, \n\n
                      • \n + \
                      • V\xEDctor Ruiz-Gonz\xE1lez, \n\n
                      • \n + \
                      • Camila D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez\n\n
                      • \n\n
                      \n\n\n\n + \
                      \n
                      \n \"PLOS\"\n
                      x
                      \n
                      \n + \
                      \n
                      \n\n \n\n
                      \n + \
                      \n\n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n\n\n\n\n\n
                      \n\n\n
                      \n \n
                      \n
                      \n
                      \n\n\n\n\n
                      \n\n\n\n\n
                      \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                      \n \n\n\n\n

                      Abstract

                      Given the shortage of specialized teachers, Initial + Teacher Education requires alternative teacher preparation routes, such as + Alternative Teaching Certification Programs, that allow the incorporation + of professionals who already possess prior work experience into the educational + system. However, this situation raises new challenges regarding the design + and implementation of the teacher preparation model within these programs. + Consequently, this study aims to map and synthesize the existing evidence + on the characteristics of practice-based teacher education (PBTE) programs, + understood as an approach in which professional learning is constructed through + authentic, situated teaching experiences rather than primarily theoretical + instruction, designed for individuals who already hold technical, bachelor\u2019s, + or professional degrees. The review will be conducted following the JBI (Joanna + Briggs Institute) methodology for scoping reviews, and will be reported in + accordance with PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Data extraction and synthesis will + be structured around the JBI Participants, Concept, and Context (PCC) analytical + framework. Database searches will be conducted in Web of Science (WoS) and + Scopus, including studies published between 2009 and 2025 in English, Spanish, + and Portuguese. The review will specifically examine program duration, mentoring + structures, practicum design, institutional type, teaching strategies, and + reported outcomes. This protocol has been registered in the Open Science Framework + (OSF) and will be publicly available once approved.

                      \n
                      \n\n\n

                      Citation: + Urra-Barra G, Acevedo G, Leighton-Vallejos E, Ruiz-Gonz\xE1lez V, + D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez C (2026) Practice-based initial teacher education in + alternative teaching certification programs: A scoping review protocol. PLoS + One 21(10):\n e0360047.\n \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047

                      Editor: + Rogis Baker, Universiti Pertahanan Nasional Malaysia, MALAYSIA

                      Received: + April 29, 2026; Accepted: September 21, 2026; Published: + October 13, 2026

                      Copyright: \xA9 2026 Urra-Barra + et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution + License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction + in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

                      Data + Availability: No datasets were generated or analysed during the current + study. All relevant data from this study will be made available upon study + completion.

                      Funding: This study was supported by Vicerrector\xEDa + Acad\xE9mica and Centro de Investigaci\xF3n para la Educaci\xF3n Superior + \u2013 Fondo USS-FIN-2026_APC_VRA-013.

                      Competing interests: + The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

                      \n\n\n\n\n\n

                      Introduction

                      Initial + Teacher Education (ITE; in Spanish, Formaci\xF3n Inicial Docente, + FID) is understood as a systematic and structured process aimed at developing + the professional competencies required for teaching across the different levels + of the educational system [1,2].

                      \n

                      At a global level, + the United Nations estimate that approximately 44 million new teachers will + be needed by 2030 in order to respond to the growing educational demand [3]. This shortage poses + concrete demands on teacher preparation systems, which must not only increase + enrollment, but also guarantee training that is both high in quality and relevant + to current teaching practice.

                      \n

                      In this context, alternative teaching certification + programs have emerged as a relevant alternative within the Chilean tertiary + education system. For the purposes of this review, Alternative Teaching Certification + Programs (ATCPs) are defined as initial teacher education pathways designed + for individuals who already hold a prior technical, professional, or academic + qualification, offering an abbreviated or alternative route to a teaching + credential that recognizes prior learning and work experience [4]. These programs connect prior learning experiences + with the completion of a bachelor\u2019s degree in education and a specific + disciplinary teaching certification. The National Accreditation Commission + (CNA; in Spanish: [5] + defines these programs as designed, formalized, and implemented with the purpose + of offering study continuity to individuals who already hold a prior professional + or technical degree or an academic qualification, recognizing work experience + and knowledge acquired within the school system. Notwithstanding, their growth + also raises challenges regarding the program\u2019s quality assurance, particularly + under current regulations, in which accreditation is required to enroll new + students.

                      \n

                      In response to these challenges, it becomes necessary + to reconsider the teacher preparation models offered to pre-service teachers. + Within this scenario, the international approach of Practice-Based Teacher + Education (PBTE) has gained relevance. PBTE argues that professional learning + should be constructed through authentic teaching experiences that integrate + pedagogical theory, disciplinary knowledge, and situated action in the classroom + [6,7]. This approach implies a substantial transformation + in the design of ITE (FID) programs, particularly in relation to mentoring + practices and the articulation between universities and schools. Unlike models + focused primarily on theoretical or didactic preparation, PBTE promotes the + active participation of pre-service teachers in simulated teaching, analysis + of real classroom practices, guided mentorship, and systematic processes of + critical reflection [8,9]. Its implementation + becomes especially relevant in alternative teaching certification programs, + where candidates bring prior educational and/or work experiences that require + pedagogical proposals capable of recognizing and articulating those forms + of knowledge with concrete opportunities for situated and contextualized professional + development. While PBTE is associated with stronger practical readiness and + greater coherence between theory and classroom action, the literature also + identifies persistent tensions regarding the risk of reducing the theoretical + and disciplinary foundations of teacher preparation, the resource demands + of high-quality mentorship, and the variability in how authentic practice + is operationalized across programs and institutional contexts.

                      \n

                      Despite its expansion, + the ways in which this approach is implemented to guide pedagogical processes + in teacher education programs vary significantly across countries, institutions, + and levels of development of teacher preparation systems [10\u201313]. + These experiences illustrate that PBTE is being adopted and adapted through + diverse methodological approaches, without yet converging on shared definitions, + common program structures, or agreed criteria for what constitutes a practice-based + component in teacher preparation. This conceptual and empirical heterogeneity + signals a field that is still under development, for which a scoping review + is the most appropriate first synthesis step rather than a systematic effectiveness + review.

                      \n

                      Given the diversity of frameworks, designs, and + contexts involved, a scoping review was considered the most appropriate methodological + approach. Unlike systematic reviews focused on effectiveness, scoping reviews + allow researchers to explore the range, nature, and characteristics of a broad + body of literature, map emergent categories, and synthesize key concepts [14,15]. This approach is particularly pertinent when the + field of study is under development, as is the case of PBTE, and when a structured + overview of the available knowledge is required.

                      \n

                      For this reason, + the purpose of this scoping review is to map the available literature on PBTE, + identifying its main characteristics in terms of program duration, mentoring + structures, practicum design, and institutional type, as well as pedagogical + strategies and reported outcomes, in the context of alternative teaching certification + programs that enable professionals with prior educational experiences and + certifications to obtain a teaching degree.

                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Research question

                      \n

                      What evidence + does the literature report regarding the design, implementation, and outcomes + of practice-based initial teacher education programs for individuals with + existing degrees, including post-baccalaureate, alternative, and consecutive + routes?

                      \n
                      \n
                      \n\n

                      Methods

                      The proposed + scoping review will be conducted in accordance with the Joanna Briggs Institute + (JBI) methodology for scoping reviews, as outlined in the JBI Manual for Evidence + Synthesis [14], and + following the PRISMA-ScR recommendations [16]. The protocol has been registered in the Open Science + Framework (OSF) under the registration number 10.17605/OSF.IO/UTR6V, + ensuring transparency and traceability throughout the process.

                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Inclusion criteria

                      \n

                      Participants: + Studies involving both teacher candidates and teacher educators participating + in programs explicitly defined by their authors as alternative teaching certification + programs, and that are directed at students or professionals who hold a prior + academic or professional qualification (e.g., bachelor\u2019s degree, tertiary + technical degree, or professional title) will be included. Studies reporting + only on traditional initial teacher education programs (i.e., those involving + teacher candidates without such prior qualifications) will be excluded.

                      \n

                      Concept: + Studies examining initial teacher education programs that implement a practice-based + teacher education (PBTE) approach will be considered. PBTE is characterized + by the structured and systematic integration of authentic teaching experiences + as the core element of teacher professional learning. Such experiences include, + among others, simulated lessons, analysis of real classroom practice, reflective + practice, and guided mentorship provided by experienced educators [6,17]. + For the purposes of this review, a program will be considered PBTE-aligned + if it explicitly incorporates at least one of the three processes described + by Grossman et al. [8]: + representation of practice, decomposition of practice, or approximation to + practice, implemented in a structured and recurring manner within the program + design. No restrictions will be placed regarding the length of the program, + disciplinary area, intended education level, or any other characteristics + of the program or its participants. The language of program implementation + is not a restriction; however, publications reporting on the program must + be written in English, Spanish, or Portuguese, as these are the languages + the research team can assess.

                      \n

                      Context: Studies conducted in practice-based + initial teacher education programs directed at individuals with prior academic + or professional qualifications (post-baccalaureate/alternative/consecutive + routes) and delivered by higher education institutions worldwide will be included.

                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Types of sources

                      \n

                      This + scoping review will consider studies adopting experimental and quasi-experimental + designs. Likewise, analytical observational studies including prospective + and retrospective cohort studies, case-control studies, and analytical cross-sectional + studies will be included. Descriptive observational designs such as case series, + single case reports, and descriptive cross-sectional studies will be considered.

                      \n

                      Additionally, + qualitative studies informed by approaches such as phenomenology, grounded + theory, ethnography, qualitative description, and action research will be + included. Opinion pieces and reflective articles relevant to the object of + study and meeting the inclusion criteria will also be considered. Opinion + and reflective articles are included because PBTE within alternative teaching + certification programs is an emerging area in which much of the available + knowledge is still expressed through expert commentary and practitioner reflection + rather than empirical studies. During data charting, these sources will be + flagged by type and synthesized separately from empirical studies in the narrative + synthesis.

                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Search + strategy

                      \n

                      Systematic database searches will be conducted + in Web of Science Core Collection and Scopus. These two databases were selected + because they offer the broadest interdisciplinary coverage of peer-reviewed + literature in education and social sciences, support advanced Boolean search + logic, and together index the large majority of high-impact journals in teacher + education research [18,19]. The search strings + were structured in three thematic blocks: Block A covers PBTE terminology, + Block B covers initial teacher education, and Block C covers alternative certification + programs. The three blocks are crossed using the AND operator. No language + restriction is applied at the level of program implementation; studies are + limited to those published in English, Spanish, or Portuguese, reflecting + the linguistic competencies of the research team. Studies published between + 2009 and 2025 will be included, as this period corresponds to the emergence + and consolidation of practice-based approaches in teacher education, particularly + with the development of models such as practice-based teacher education and + the consolidation of concepts such as core practices and high-leverage practices + [7,8]. The complete Boolean search strategies for both + databases are presented in Table 1 (Web + of Science) and Table 2 (Scopus).

                      \n
                      \"thumbnail\"
                      Table 1. + Web of Science Core Collection search strategy (TS\u2009=\u2009Topic field).

                      \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047.t001

                      \"thumbnail\"
                      Table 2. + Scopus search strategy (TITLE-ABS-KEY field).

                      \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047.t002

                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Selection + of studies and sources of evidence

                      \n

                      All citations + will be imported into Rayyan, a systematic screening tool, and duplicates + will be removed automatically. Prior to full-scale screening, a pilot test + will be conducted with four articles selected purposively from the initial + search results to represent a range of study designs and geographic contexts. + The pilot aims to confirm inter-rater agreement on the application of the + eligibility criteria and to identify any ambiguity in their wording. An agreement + rate below 75% on the pilot set will trigger a joint discussion between reviewers + and, if necessary, a revision of the inclusion and exclusion criteria before + full screening proceeds. It is acknowledged that four articles constitute + a limited pilot sample given the conceptual complexity of PBTE; the research + team will therefore remain attentive to recurring disagreements during the + early stages of full screening as an informal extension of the pilot phase. + After the pilot, titles and abstracts will be assessed independently by at + least two reviewers. References that meet the inclusion criteria will proceed + to full-text assessment, which will also be conducted independently by two + reviewers. Any discrepancies will be resolved by consensus or by involving + a third reviewer.

                      \n

                      The complete study selection process will be + reported in the final review using a PRISMA-ScR flow diagram for scoping reviews + [20].

                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Data extraction

                      \n

                      Data + will be extracted independently by two or more reviewers using a data extraction + tool specifically designed by the research team for this review. This tool + will include structured fields aligned with the PCC framework (Participants, + Concept, and Context). Furthermore, this tool will also include additional + variables concerning methodological designs, program implementation characteristics, + and the main findings reported in each study. This strategy will ensure a + systematic, rigorous, and coherent data collection process aligned with the + objectives of the scoping review.

                      \n

                      The data + extraction form will be piloted with an initial sample of included studies + to assess its relevance, clarity, and alignment with the review objectives. + Based on the pilot, the research team will refine the form as necessary before + proceeding with full data extraction. Any modifications made to the extraction + tool during the review process will be documented and justified in the final + review to ensure transparency and reproducibility.

                      \n

                      In cases + where relevant information is not available in the full text of a study, corresponding + authors will be contacted to request missing data or necessary clarifications. + If no response is received within two weeks, a reminder will be sent. If the + information remains unavailable after a further two weeks, the missing data + will be coded as not reported. If the search yields fewer studies than anticipated, + the research team will broaden the search terms and extend manual reference + list screening before concluding that the evidence base is genuinely limited. + If a database becomes temporarily inaccessible during the search window, the + search for that database will be repeated when access is restored and the + execution date will be documented in the PRISMA-ScR flow diagram.

                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Data + analysis and presentation

                      \n

                      The results will be presented descriptively and + narratively, organized around the components of the PCC framework and directly + addressing the objectives and central research question of the review. Accordingly, + different formats will be used to enhance the visualization and understanding + of the findings.

                      \n

                      First, the results will be organized into tables + that will map key characteristics of the included studies, such as country + of origin, type of program, participant population, type of institution, methodological + approach, implemented practice-based components, and main findings. These + tables will provide an overview of how practice-based teacher education has + been addressed in programs aimed at individuals with prior technical, academic, + or professional qualifications.

                      \n

                      Second, + graphical representations and thematic maps will be used to identify patterns, + knowledge gaps, and geographical or institutional concentrations within the + available evidence. These visualizations will support the identification of + emerging areas, recurrent practices, and potential gaps in the implementation + of the PBTE approach across specific contexts.

                      \n

                      In addition, + a narrative synthesis will be conducted to interpret the findings in relation + to the PCC framework. Themes will be identified using a primarily deductive + approach structured around the dimensions stated in the research objective, + specifically program duration, mentoring structures, practicum design, and + institutional type, while remaining open to inductively coding patterns that + emerge from the data and do not fit these predefined categories. Two reviewers + will independently group the extracted data into preliminary themes. Discrepancies + in theme labeling or grouping will be resolved by discussion and, where necessary, + by a third reviewer.

                      \n

                      Finally, in accordance with the purposes of a + scoping review, no critical appraisal of methodological quality will be conducted + for the included studies. However, when appropriate, comments will be made + regarding the diversity of designs and methodologies used, with the aim of + informing future systematic or empirical research.

                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Significance

                      \n

                      At the national + level, this review responds directly to the expansion of alternative teaching + certification programs in Chile under accreditation requirements that currently + lack an evidence base on how practice-based components should be designed + and implemented. Mapping international evidence on PBTE can therefore inform + program design and quality assurance criteria in this specific context. At + the global level, given the United Nations projection of approximately 44 + million additional teachers needed by 2030 [3], alternative certification routes are expanding as + a workforce strategy across multiple countries. This review contributes by + synthesizing, for the first time, evidence on how practice-based approaches + have been conceptualized and implemented specifically within this type of + program, supporting future systematic reviews and informing policy decisions + in national systems facing comparable teacher shortage pressures.

                      \n
                      \n\n
                      \n

                      Limitations

                      \n

                      This + protocol presents several anticipated limitations. First, restricting the + systematic database search to Web of Science and Scopus, while justified by + their interdisciplinary coverage and advanced Boolean search capabilities, + means that studies indexed exclusively in discipline-specific or regional + databases may not be captured. Second, the pilot test involves only four articles, + which is a modest sample given the conceptual complexity of PBTE; this is + acknowledged and partially mitigated by the informal extension of the pilot + phase during early full-text screening. Third, the inclusion of opinion and + reflective articles alongside empirical studies introduces heterogeneity in + the strength of evidence synthesized; this is addressed by analyzing and reporting + these source types separately in the narrative synthesis. Fourth, consistent + with standard scoping review methodology, no formal quality appraisal of included + studies will be conducted; the review will therefore map the breadth of available + evidence rather than evaluate its methodological robustness. Fifth, while + the regulatory context of Chilean alternative teaching certification programs + motivates this study, the global scope of the review means that findings will + need to be interpreted in light of each country\u2019s specific institutional + and regulatory conditions.

                      \n
                      \n
                      \n\n\n\n\n\n

                      Acknowledgments

                      \n

                      This + study was supported by Vicerrector\xEDa Acad\xE9mica and Centro de Investigaci\xF3n + para la Educaci\xF3n Superior \u2013 Fondo USS-FIN-2026_APC_VRA-013.

                      \n

                      References

                      1. 1.\n Cornejo + J, Fuentealba R. Pr\xE1cticas reflexivas para la formaci\xF3n profesional + docente: \xBFqu\xE9 las hace eficaces? Santiago: Ediciones Universidad Cat\xF3lica + Silva Henr\xEDquez; 2008.
                        • 2.\n \xC1valos B. La formaci\xF3n de profesores y su + desarrollo profesional. Pr\xE1cticas innovadoras en busca de pol\xEDticas. + In: Cox C, editor. Pol\xEDticas educacionales en el cambio de siglo. La reforma + del sistema escolar de Chile. Santiago: Editorial Universitaria; 2003. p. + 559\u201394.
                          • 3.\n + \ UNESCO, International Task Force on Teachers for + Education 2030. Global report on teachers: addressing teacher shortages and + transforming the profession. Paris: UNESCO; 2024. Available from: https://teachertaskforce.org/sites/default/files/2024-04/2349-23_GlobalReportonTeacher_WEB.pdf +
                            • 4.\n + \ Bast\xEDas-Bast\xEDas LS, Iturra-Herrera C. La formaci\xF3n + inicial docente en Chile: Una revisi\xF3n bibliogr\xE1fica sobre su implementaci\xF3n + y logros. Rev Electr Educare. 2022;26(1):1\u201322.
                            • 5.\n + \ Comisi\xF3n Nacional de Acreditaci\xF3n (CNA). T\xEDtulo + exacto del documento. Falta completarla. Probablemente corresponde a los Criterios + y est\xE1ndares de calidad para la acreditaci\xF3n de carreras y programas + de pedagog\xEDa; confirmen cu\xE1l documento citaron. Santiago: CNA; 2023. +
                              • 6.\n + \ Zeichner K. The turn once again toward practice-based + teacher education. J Teach Educ. 2012;63(5):376\u201382.
                              • 7.\n + \ Ball DL, Forzani FM. The work of teaching and the + challenge for teacher education. J Teach Educ. 2009;60(5):497\u2013511.
                              • 8.\n + \ Grossman P, Compton C, Igra D, Ronfeldt M, Shahan + E, Williamson P. Teaching practice: a cross-professional perspective. Teach + Coll Rec. 2009;111(9):2055\u2013100.
                              • 9.\n + \ Matsumoto-Royo K, Ram\xEDrez-Montoya MS. Core practices + in practice-based teacher education: a systematic literature review of its + teaching and assessment process. Stud Educ Eval. 2021;70:101047.
                              • 10.\n + \ Lim JM, Choi HJ, Hwang H. Supporting preservice + teachers\u2019 reflection with an AI chatbot: The mediating role of cognitive + and emotional engagement. Teach Teach Educ. 2025;137:104447.
                              • 11.\n + \ Flamand L, Vanderlinde R, Tuytens M. Promoting epistemic + agency in teacher education: A learning path for student teachers and teacher + educators. Teach Teach Educ. 2025;138:104456.
                              • 12.\n + \ DeJarnette NK, Hord C. Building teacher candidates\u2019 + interdisciplinary capacity through design challenges. J STEM Educ Res. 2025. + \
                              • 13.\n + \ Waychunas W. Scaffolding novices toward ambitious + social studies teaching: a learning progression for enactment of core practices. + Proceedings of the 2025 AERA Annual Meeting. 2025.
                              • 14.\n + \ Peters MDJ, Godfrey C, McInerney P, Munn Z, Tricco + AC, Khalil H. Chapter 11: Scoping reviews (2020 version). In: Aromataris E, + Munn Z, editors. JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis. JBI; 2020.
                                • 15.\n Arksey H, O\u2019Malley + L. Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol. + 2005;8(1):19\u201332.
                                • 16.\n + \ Tricco AC, Lillie E, Zarin W, O\u2019Brien KK, Colquhoun + H, Levac D, et al. PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist + and Explanation. Ann Intern Med. 2018;169(7):467\u201373. pmid:30178033
                                • 17.\n + \ Ball DL, Sleep L, Boerst TA, Bass H. Combining the + Development of Practice and the Practice of Development in Teacher Education. + Elem Sch J. 2009;109(5):458\u201374.
                                • 18.\n + \ Harzing A-W, Alakangas S. Google Scholar, Scopus + and the Web of Science: a longitudinal and cross-disciplinary comparison. + Scientometrics. 2016;106(2):787\u2013804.
                                • 19.\n + \ Mongeon P, Paul-Hus A. The journal coverage of Web + of Science and Scopus: a comparative analysis. Scientometrics. 2016;106(1):213\u201328. + \
                                • 20.\n + \ Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann + TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for + reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021;372:n71. pmid:33782057
                                \n\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n + \
                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n + \
                                \n \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n \n \n \n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n" + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:07 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Vary: + - Accept-Encoding + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '140079' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml deleted file mode 100644 index bcb9ce4..0000000 --- a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-comp-biol].yaml +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2182 +0,0 @@ -interactions: -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=42868205&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"42868205","objurls":[],"info":"No - LinkOut links available for UID: 42868205"}]}]} - - ' - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Alt-Svc: - - clear - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT - Ncbi-Phid: - - 1D322F91B7495C35000057E45CD6A5AB.1.1.m_1 - Ncbi-Sid: - - 320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 - Oct 2027 12:57:55 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Ratelimit-Limit: - - '10' - X-Ratelimit-Remaining: - - '7' - X-Ua-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-Xss-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-length: - - '176' - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.60 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868205&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: '{"header":{"type":"esummary","version":"0.3"},"result":{"uids":["42868205"],"42868205":{"uid":"42868205","pubdate":"2026 - Oct 13","epubdate":"2026 Oct 13","source":"PLoS Comput Biol","authors":[{"name":"Yin - Q","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""},{"name":"Chen L","authtype":"Author","clusterid":""}],"lastauthor":"Chen - L","title":"Interpretable neural networks prioritize cancer driver genes from - genome-wide dependency landscapes.","sorttitle":"interpretable neural networks - prioritize cancer driver genes from genome wide dependency landscapes","volume":"22","issue":"10","pages":"e1014869","lang":["eng"],"nlmuniqueid":"101238922","issn":"1553-734X","essn":"1553-7358","pubtype":["Journal - Article"],"recordstatus":"PubMed - as supplied by publisher","pubstatus":"10","articleids":[{"idtype":"pubmed","idtypen":1,"value":"42868205"},{"idtype":"doi","idtypen":3,"value":"10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869"},{"idtype":"pii","idtypen":4,"value":"PCOMPBIOL-D-26-01062"}],"history":[{"pubstatus":"received","date":"2026/05/05 - 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"accepted","date":"2026/10/04 00:00"},{"pubstatus":"medline","date":"2026/10/13 - 23:36"},{"pubstatus":"pubmed","date":"2026/10/13 23:36"},{"pubstatus":"entrez","date":"2026/10/13 - 18:14"}],"references":[],"attributes":["Has Abstract"],"pmcrefcount":"","fulljournalname":"PLoS - computational biology","elocationid":"doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869","doctype":"citation","srccontriblist":[],"booktitle":"","medium":"","edition":"","publisherlocation":"","publishername":"","srcdate":"","reportnumber":"","availablefromurl":"","locationlabel":"","doccontriblist":[],"docdate":"","bookname":"","chapter":"","sortpubdate":"2026/10/13 - 00:00","sortfirstauthor":"Yin Q","vernaculartitle":""}}} - - ' - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Alt-Svc: - - clear - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT - Ncbi-Phid: - - 1D3407F95CD407A5000036EFC3CCE88F.1.1.m_1 - Ncbi-Sid: - - 320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=320B2B998C1976CA_2A98SID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 - Oct 2027 12:57:55 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Ratelimit-Limit: - - '10' - X-Ratelimit-Remaining: - - '7' - X-Ua-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-Xss-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-length: - - '1723' - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article/file?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pcbi.1014869&type=manuscript - response: - body: - string: '' - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - max-age=3600 - Content-Length: - - '0' - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT - Location: - - https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869/1/pcbi.1014869.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T063435Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host&X-Goog-Signature=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 - Server: - - Apache - Set-Cookie: - - GCLB=CIfo682BrZK1uQEQAw; path=/; HttpOnly - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000 - - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - status: - code: 302 - message: Found -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/122.0.6261.128 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869/1/pcbi.1014869.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T063435Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-Signature=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&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host - response: - body: - string: "\n\n
                                \n\n\n\nComposition - Vendor\nNewgen KnowledgeWorks (P) Ltd.\n\n\n\n\n\nPLoS Comput Biol\nplos\nploscomp\n\nPLOS - Computational Biology\n\n1553-734X\n1553-7358\n\nPublic Library - of Science\nSan Francisco, CA USA\n\n\n\n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869\nPCOMPBIOL-D-26-01062\n\n\nResearch Article\n\n\nMedicine and health sciencesPharmacologyBehavioral - pharmacologyDrug dependence\nMedicine and health sciencesOncologyCancers - and neoplasms\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsMutation\nMedicine and health sciencesOncologyCancers - and neoplasmsMalignant tumors\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsGene - typesSuppressor genesTumor - suppressor genes\nResearch and analysis methodsDatabase - and informatics methodsBiological databasesMutation - databases\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsMutationMutation - databases\nBiology and life sciencesCell - biologySignal transductionCell - signalingOncogenic signaling\nBiology and life sciencesGeneticsGene - identification and analysisMutation detection\n\nInterpretable - neural networks prioritize cancer driver genes from genome-wide dependency - landscapes\nInterpretable - neural networks for cancer driver genes\n\n\n\nhttps://orcid.org/0009-0004-3643-7981\n\nYin\nQingyang\n\nConceptualization\nData - curation\nFormal - analysis\nInvestigation\nMethodology\nResources\nSoftware\nValidation\nVisualization\nWriting - \u2013 original draft\n\n\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6164-4553\n\nChen\nLiang\n\nConceptualization\nFunding - acquisition\nInvestigation\nMethodology\nProject - administration\nResources\nSupervision\nWriting - \u2013 review & editing\n*\n\n\nDepartment of Quantitative and Computational Biology, - University of - Southern California, Los Angeles, - California, United States of America\n\n\n\nWei\nHang\n\nEditor\n\n\nXidian University, - CHINA\n\n\n

                                The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

                                \n
                                \n* E-mail: liang.chen@usc.edu\n
                                \n13102026\n102026\n22\n10\ne1014869\n\n552026\n4102026\n\n\n2026\nYin, - Chen\n\nThis is an open access article distributed - under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which - permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided - the original author and source are credited.\n\n\n\n

                                Identifying - cancer driver genes and their therapeutic impact remains a core challenge - in computational cancer biology. We introduce xNNDriver and xAEDriver, two - interpretable neural network frameworks that connect cancer mutations with - genome-wide DepMap gene dependencies, pathway activity, and drug-response - patterns. xNNDriver is a supervised pathway-guided model that evaluates whether - a gene\u2019s mutation status is encoded in the genome-wide dependency landscape; - we interpret model fitness as a driver potential score, which quantifies the - strength of this mutation-dependency signal and prioritizes genes with broad - functional footprints. Across 3,008 candidate genes, xNNDriver recovers major - established drivers and highlights literature-supported candidates, while - pathway analyses reveal biologically coherent programs related to metabolism, - growth factor signaling, and immune regulation. To capture combinatorial functional - states, xAEDriver uses an unsupervised autoencoder to learn Driver Variant - Representations (DVRs), latent binary features guided by the frequency distribution - of known driver mutations. DVRs capture cell-line-specific dependency patterns - and expression patterns and are associated with drug sensitivity and pathway - activity. Together, these interpretable deep learning models demonstrate that - gene dependency landscapes encode rich, interpretable signals of oncogenic - function and provide a hypothesis-generating framework for prioritizing drivers, - pathways, and therapeutic vulnerabilities for further experimental validation.

                                \n
                                \n\nAuthor summary\n

                                Cancer is often - driven by genetic changes that give tumor cells a growth advantage, but finding - which changes matter and how they affect cell behavior remains difficult. - In this study, we used large-scale gene-editing data from cancer cell lines - to ask whether the pattern of genes a cell depends on can reveal information - about its cancer-driving alterations. We developed interpretable neural-network - models that connect mutation patterns, cell survival dependencies, and biological - pathways. One model prioritizes genes whose mutation status leaves a clear - functional signature across the cell. A second model summarizes broader, combined - driver-like states in each cell line. These summaries were linked to known - cancer biology, tissue type, and differences in drug response, suggesting - that functional dependency data contain useful clues about cancer mechanisms. - By connecting mutation patterns with functional dependencies and pathway activity, - our approach helps identify candidate cancer drivers and interpretable drug-response - patterns that can guide future experimental studies. Making the models interpretable - allows researchers to move from large screening datasets toward biological - explanations of cancer-driving processes.

                                \n
                                \n\n\nNIH\nR01NS139485\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6164-4553\nChenLiang\n\nNIH\nR01CA301708\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6164-4553\nChenLiang\nThis - work was supported by the National Institutes of Health (R01NS139485 and R01CA301708 - to L.C.). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, - decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nData Availability\nThe - codes are available at https://github.com/qyyin0516/xNNDriver-and-xAEDriver. - All data from the DepMap database were downloaded from https://depmap.org/portal/download/all/ - (version: 23Q2). The COSMIC database can be downloaded at https://cancer.sanger.ac.uk/cosmic/download/cosmic/v102/mutantcensus, - and categories of clinical significance for SNVs can be found at https://www.ensembl.org/info/genome/variation/prediction/predicted_data.html#consequences/. - The ClinVar database can be downloaded at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/, - and categories of clinical significance for SNVs can be found at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/docs/clinsig/. - Reactome pathway annotations and hierarchy can be downloaded at https://reactome.org/download-data. - The list of 3,008 frequently mutated candidate genes can be found at https://github.com/idekerlab/DrugCell.\n\n\nPLOS - Publication Stage\nuncorrected-proof\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n\nIntroduction\n

                                One of - the most critical and challenging areas in cancer biology is the identification - of driver genes and mutations. Cancer driver mutations fuel tumor progression, - unlike neutral passenger mutations [1]. - In recent years, machine learning and deep learning have shown great potential - in bioinformatics, including applications for detecting cancer driver genes - and mutations [2\u20136]. However, current - deep learning models predominantly utilize sequence data and three-dimensional - protein structures to infer driver mutations [1], - while functional genomics, especially gene editing, remains less explored. - Additionally, the interpretability of these black-box models is often limited.

                                \n

                                Conventional - gene perturbation strategies, such as knockout and RNAi-mediated knockdown, - enable researchers to study a gene\u2019s loss-of-function effects on tumor - progression, aiding in identifying cancer-driver genes and mutations [7]. CRISPR-Cas9 has advanced - gene perturbation in terms of precision and scale [8]. The Cancer Dependency Map (DepMap) - at the Broad Institute conducted genome-wide CRISPR-Cas9 knockout screens - across a wide range of cancer cell lines [9,10], providing gene dependency - scores that reflect each gene\u2019s importance for cell proliferation and - survival in a cell-line-specific manner. While DepMap dependency scores provide - valuable insights into the essentiality of genes in cancer cells, they are - not sufficient on their own to conclusively determine whether a gene is a - driver of cancer. Accurate identification of cancer driver genes requires - an integrated analysis of dependency scores with other data types, such as - DNA mutations, pathway involvement, and gene expression.

                                \n

                                We hypothesize - that mutations with driver activity can leave detectable signatures in the - genome-wide dependency landscape, whereas passenger mutations are less likely - to produce coherent dependency shifts. To test the hypothesis, we built a - supervised learning model to predict the mutation status (mutated or not) - of each candidate gene, using the dependency scores of all screened genes - in a cell line. The model\u2019s fitness, expressed as the driver potential - score of this candidate gene, prioritizes genes whose mutation status has - a strong functional footprint in dependency data. We name this model xNNDriver - (explainable Neural Network for Driver - gene identification). Because the labels are derived from existing mutation - annotations, xNNDriver is best viewed as a functional prioritization and interpretation - framework rather than an independent de novo mutation-discovery tool. Additionally, - genome-scale CRISPR knockouts measure gene loss-of-function effects on cancer-cell - fitness. Although well suited to detecting oncogene addiction, these screens - may have limited sensitivity for tumor suppressors that are already inactivated. - However, tumor suppressor alterations can still be reflected in DepMap data - when they reshape the dependencies of other genes across the genome. xNNDriver - is designed to capture these broader mutation-associated dependency patterns, - rather than relying only on the dependency score of the candidate gene itself.

                                \n

                                Our - approach successfully identified both well-known driver genes and novel candidates. - To discern the pathways through which these drivers contribute to tumorigenesis, - we incorporated the Reactome pathway hierarchy [11] - into the network architecture, designing each neuron to represent a distinct - biological pathway.

                                \n

                                To simultaneously infer multi-driver functional - states in a cell line, we designed an interpretable autoencoder model that - integrates both dependency scores and gene expression data. This unsupervised - model is named xAEDriver (explainable AutoEncoder - for hidden overall Driver status identification). The latent - layer of xAEDriver, which captures the key features of the input data in a - compressed form, is guided by the mutation distribution of known driver single - nucleotide variants (SNVs). The latent representations are constrained to - resemble the population-level distribution of driver mutations, but they are - not forced to correspond to specific genes or variants. We refer to these - latent representations as Driver Variant Representations - (DVRs). xAEDriver is also interpretable, so it can reveal biological pathways - that offer a deeper understanding of the driver mutation status. Notably, - cell lines stratified by DVRs exhibited distinct drug responses, supporting - the use of dependency-derived driver states to interpret treatment-relevant - vulnerabilities.

                                \n
                                \n\nResults\n\nThe fitness of the supervised xNNDriver quantifies - cancer driver potential from dependency landscapes\n

                                Our supervised - xNNDriver model links genome-wide gene dependency scores to the mutation status - of a candidate driver gene in each cancer cell line. The mutation status of - a true driver gene, but not passenger mutations, influences the impact of - other genes\u2019 knockout on tumor survival (dependency). In other words, - the distinct genome-wide dependency scores can predict the mutation status - of driver genes (high model fitness), but not those of passenger genes (low - model fitness). We define the resulting model fitness as the driver potential - score, a measure of mutation-dependency association and functional prioritization - rather than direct proof of causality. A schematic overview of the workflow - is shown in Fig 1A.

                                \n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g001Supervised xNNDriver model for prioritizing individual - candidate driver genes.

                                (A) Workflow of xNNDriver. - Functional SNVs are aggregated to annotate the gene-level mutation status - for each candidate driver gene. Individual neural network models are trained - using gene dependency scores as input features and candidate gene mutation - status as labels. Data are split into training and test sets, and the model - follows the Reactome pathway hierarchy. Predictions from all layers are integrated - via voting. The model fitness is evaluated using the driver potential score, - where a higher score indicates a stronger mutation-dependency association - and higher priority as a candidate driver. (B) Prediction performance - for the top 15 genes with the highest driver potential scores. Point color - represents the number of cell lines with functional mutations in each candidate - gene. A total of 1,095 cell lines (mutated and non-mutated) are considered - for each model. Gene names are color-coded by driver annotation from DepMap - (purple: driver; black: non-driver). (C) Tissue-level driver - potential scores. The color of each square indicates the driver potential - score within test cell lines from a given tissue, and the number following - the tissue name denotes the count of test cell lines in that tissue.

                                \n
                                \n

                                To construct the training data, we determined - each candidate gene\u2019s mutation status based on the presence of functional - somatic SNVs, as annotated by both the COSMIC [12] - and ClinVar [13] - databases. The model was trained using a biologically informed feedforward - neural network whose architecture mirrors the pathway hierarchy acquired from - the Reactome database. The input layer consists of screened genes with dependency - scores, and the hidden layers represent pathways. The edges between the input - layer and the first hidden layer capture pathway membership for each gene, - while the edges between pathway layers represent the hierarchical relationships - between pathway terms. Each pathway layer is followed by a predictive layer - designed to predict the mutation status of a candidate driver gene. Predictions - from all hidden layers are aggregated using a voting mechanism.

                                \n

                                The - model fitness of xNNDriver reflects the strength of association between a - candidate gene\u2019s mutation status and genome-wide dependency patterns. - A high driver potential score therefore suggests that the gene\u2019s mutation - status is linked to a broad functional dependency signature in cancer cells - and prioritizes it for driver-focused interpretation. Important pathways contributing - to predictions are identified by contrasting the activation values of neural - networks between mutated and non-mutated cell lines. We iteratively apply - the xNNDriver model to all candidate genes (3,008 genes) to prioritize cancer - driver genes and their associated important pathways.

                                \n
                                \n\nxNNDriver - prioritizes established drivers and literature-supported candidate driver - genes\n

                                We applied our supervised model, xNNDriver, to the 15% most - frequently mutated genes in human cancers as determined by the CCLE project - [14], totaling - 3,008 candidate genes. Fig - 1B illustrates the driver potential scores of the 15 highest-scoring - genes, with complete results provided in S1 Table. Among the top 15 genes, ten are - well-established cancer driver genes as documented in DepMap, such as KRAS, - NRAS, BRAF, PIK3CA, TP53, - and so on. This strong concordance supports that the dependency landscape - contains functional information that captures core cancer driver biology.

                                \n

                                The - remaining genes, although not yet recognized as drivers in DepMap, have been - suggested in the literature to possess driver-like functions. For example, - Murakami et al. and Strazisar et al. [15,16] reported that LATS2 - acts as a tumor suppressor essential for regulating the proliferation and/or - survival of malignant mesothelioma cells. EZH2 exhibits a - dual role, functioning as either a tumor suppressor or an oncogene depending - on the cellular context [17]. - Additionally, Sasaki et al. [18] - identified KEAP1 as an inhibitor of NRF2-induced cytoprotection - and proposed it as a potential tumor suppressor. Collectively, these results - demonstrate that xNNDriver can reprioritize known drivers and nominate literature-supported - candidates for further validation.

                                \n

                                To test the robustness of our model, - we redefined mutation status using all somatic SNVs rather than only functional - ones. The top 30 genes under this alternative annotation are shown in S1 Fig, - with complete results in S2 - Table. The recovery of major known drivers (KRAS, - NRAS, BRAF, PIK3CA, TP53) - and consistent identification of EZH2 underscore the robustness - of our approach.

                                \n

                                We next examined tissue-specific driver activity. - For the top 15 genes (Fig - 1B), we recalculated driver potential scores within individual tissue - types. As shown in Fig 1C, - higher tissue-level scores indicate a gene\u2019s stronger driver potential - in that tissue. For instance, BRAF is strongly associated - with thyroid cancers, consistent with the BRAF V600E mutation - being the most common alteration in papillary thyroid carcinoma [19]. Similarly, PIK3CA - mutations frequently drive breast cancers [20]. - This tissue-resolved analysis highlights the context-specific roles of cancer - drivers.

                                \n

                                Furthermore, we evaluated event-level performance for the - 15 highest-ranked genes by comparing held-out cell line\u2013gene predictions - with curated functional SNV labels (S2 Fig). Precision exceeded 90% for several - established drivers, including KRAS, BRAF, - TP53, and HRAS. Predicted-positive pairs - without matching SNVs may represent false positives or alterations not included - in the current labels, such as indels, copy-number alterations, structural - variants, and other non-SNV mechanisms. Recall was approximately 78% for KRAS - and 60% for BRAF. Missed events may reflect passenger or - context-dependent mutations, incomplete dependency signals, or limited model - sensitivity. Thus, xNNDriver identifies catalogued mutation events associated - with detectable functional dependency footprints, although this cell line-gene-level - analysis does not directly determine the functional effect of an individual - variant.

                                \n

                                To assess performance under native class imbalance, we additionally - calculated the area under the precision-recall curve (AUPRC) for the top 15 - xNNDriver genes without upsampling. Established drivers (e.g., KRAS, - TP53, BRAF, NRAS) retained - strong precision-recall performance, whereas several rare or marginal candidates - (e.g., LATS2, ALK, BAP1) - showed low AUPRC despite non-random AUROC (S3 Table). Thus, AUROC-based driver potential - and AUPRC provide complementary information: AUROC reflects overall discrimination, - while AUPRC provides a more conservative estimate of positive-class recovery - in imbalanced mutation settings. Together, these analyses demonstrate both - the benefit of upsampling for detecting mutation-associated dependency signals, - particularly for rare mutations, and the need for further experimental validation - of candidates with limited positive-class precision.

                                \n

                                Baseline machine - learning models, including Logistic Regression, Random Forest, and an unconstrained - Multilayer Perceptron, achieved comparable or sometimes higher AUROC for individual - genes (S4 - Table). These results indicate that genome-wide dependency profiles - contain mutation-associated signals that can be detected by multiple modeling - approaches. xNNDriver showed a positive rank correlation with Logistic Regression, - the strongest baseline model (Spearman \u03C1\u2009=\u20090.49; S4 Table), supporting consistency in dependency-based - gene prioritization. However, the main advantage of xNNDriver is not raw classification - accuracy alone, but its pathway-guided interpretability. By embedding the - Reactome hierarchy directly into the network architecture, xNNDriver links - candidate driver mutations to interpretable pathway-level dependency patterns, - providing biological context that is not directly available from standard - baseline models.

                                \n
                                \n\nSelf-dependency - contributes biologically meaningful signal but does not fully explain top - driver predictions\n

                                To address whether xNNDriver relied primarily - on the candidate gene\u2019s own dependency score, we performed a leave-candidate-dependency-out - analysis for the top 15 genes. In this analysis, the dependency score of the - target candidate gene was removed from the input feature matrix, and model - performance was recalculated (S5 - Table). The strongest established drivers retained substantial predictive - performance after this removal. For example, KRAS changed - from 0.873 to 0.896, NRAS from 0.854 to 0.858, BRAF - from 0.814 to 0.790, PIK3CA from 0.684 to 0.738, and TP53 - from 0.640 to 0.638. These results indicate that, for core drivers, mutation - status is also encoded in dependency patterns across other genes, supporting - the presence of distributed functional footprints.

                                \n

                                At the same time, - several genes showed stronger dependence on the candidate gene\u2019s own - dependency feature. LATS2 decreased from 0.667 to 0.500, - ALK from 0.598 to 0.498, XPO1 from 0.571 - to 0.500, and MYC from 0.556 to 0.500 after self-dependency - removal. We do not interpret this as a model defect, because self-dependency - is itself an experimentally measured functional phenotype and may reflect - direct vulnerability, oncogene addiction, or altered tolerance to gene loss. - Instead, this analysis separates two biologically meaningful components of - the driver potential score: direct self-dependency and distributed network-level - dependency effects.

                                \n
                                \n\nxNNDriver reveals - driver-associated pathway programs from dependency signatures\n

                                Using - the interpretable xNNDriver model, we discovered important pathways associated - with high-scoring candidate driver genes. Fig - 2A shows the top 20 pathways, ranked by their importance measurements - (Dpvalues), - for the 15 genes with the highest driver potential scores. The complete list - of pathways passing the Dp - cutoff (default: 0.1) for these genes is provided in S6 Table. Metabolic pathways ranked prominently, - including \u201Cmetabolism,\u201D \u201Cmetabolism of proteins,\u201D and - \u201Cmetabolism of lipids.\u201D This aligns with Vander Heiden et al. [21], who demonstrated - that altered cellular metabolism can drive tumor progression and inform cancer - prognosis and therapy.

                                \n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g002Analysis of important pathways from xNNDriver.

                                (A) - Top important pathways. The top 20 pathways are ranked by Dp - values, aggregated from models of the 15 highest-scoring driver genes. For - pathways identified in multiple models, the maximumDp - value is reported. (B) Pathway proximity to driver genes. Benjamini-Hochberg - adjusted p-values are from the one-sided Wilcoxon signed-rank test comparing - the shortest path lengths to the corresponding driver gene between identified - and random pathways at the same hierarchy level. The random sampling procedures - were repeated 20 times. Genes are sorted by their driver potential scores. - The number in brackets next to the gene name indicates the number of important - pathways identified from the corresponding gene model. The red dashed line - marks the adjusted p-value cutoff of 0.05. (C) Correlation between - pathway proximity and importance. Pearson correlation coefficients between - relative shortest-path length differences and pathway rankings. The red dashed - line marks the cutoff of 0. (D) Differential pathway expression - variability. Benjamini-Hochberg adjusted p-values from one-sided Wilcoxon - signed-rank tests comparing the expression CV values of all gene members of - an important pathway between cell lines with and without the corresponding - driver gene mutation are shown. The red dashed line marks the adjusted p-value - cutoff of 0.05.

                                \n
                                \n

                                Additionally, - signal transduction pathways, such as \u201Cdiseases of signal transduction - by growth factor receptors and second messengers,\u201D were also highly ranked. - This is consistent with Rho et al. [22], - who highlighted growth factor signaling as a central mechanism in carcinogenesis. - The \u201Csignaling by receptor tyrosine kinases\u201D pathway governs essential - processes in cell growth and survival, with mutations in key members (e.g., - EGFR, HER2, MET) representing - major cancer hallmarks [23,24].

                                \n

                                Interestingly, - several immune-related pathways, such as \u201Csignaling by interleukins,\u201D - \u201Ccytokine signaling in the immune system,\u201D and \u201Cinnate immune - system\u201D, were identified as important pathways associated with the top - 15 driver genes. These pathways are known to regulate inflammation, immune - signaling, and tumor-immune interactions that contribute to cancer initiation - and progression. Aberrant interleukin and cytokine signaling can activate - oncogenic pathways such as JAK/STAT3 and PI3K-AKT, while dysregulation of - innate immune signaling promotes chronic inflammation and immune evasion [25\u201327].

                                \n
                                \n\nDriver-associated - pathways show Reactome proximity and independent expression variability\n

                                To - assess the validity of the identified pathways, we measured their proximity - to corresponding driver genes within the Reactome hierarchy. We calculated - the shortest path length between each important pathway node (Dp\u22650.1) - and its corresponding driver gene, comparing against random pathway nodes - at the same level (20 random samplings). As shown in Fig 2B, important pathway nodes are significantly - closer to their corresponding driver genes than random ones (Benjamini-Hochberg - adjusted p-values\u2009<\u20090.05 for all comparisons, paired Wilcoxon - signed-rank tests).

                                \n

                                We further evaluated the relationship between - pathway importance and hierarchical proximity. Across nearly all drivers, - the relative difference in shortest-path length between important and random - pathways positively correlated with pathway rank (Fig - 2C). Thus, the more important a pathway is, the closer it is to the - driver gene compared to random pathways at the same layer. Notably, genes - with higher driver potential scores exhibit stronger correlations, as shown - in Fig 2C, where genes - are ordered by their scores. Together, these results support the use of Dp - for interpretable pathway prioritization and reinforce the utility of the - driver potential score as a functional association measure.

                                \n

                                To explore - the underlying mechanisms by which the pathways promote tumorigenesis, we - examined pathway expression stochasticity. In our previous study [28], we found that pathways important for - cell type stratification often exhibit differential expression stochasticity, - measured by the coefficient of variation (CV; standard deviation over mean), - rather than differences in mean expression between cell type groups. Here, - for each important pathway, we calculated the expression CV for all genes - within the pathway, comparing cell lines with the corresponding driver gene - mutated versus unmutated, and assessed significance using a Wilcoxon signed-rank - test. As shown in Fig 2D, - of the 357 pathways analyzed (Dp\u22650.1 - across the 15 highest-scoring gene models, S6 Table), 193 display a Benjamini-Hochberg - adjusted p-value below 0.05. These findings emphasize that expression variability - rather than mean differences may characterize driver-associated pathways, - which is an insight often overlooked by traditional gene set enrichment analyses. - Importantly, xNNDriver does not use expression data, so these stochasticity - patterns are independent of model training and reflect intrinsic pathway characteristics.

                                \n
                                \n\nThe unsupervised xAEDriver model learns multiple-driver - functional representations\n

                                The success of xNNDriver suggests that - genome-wide dependency scores for a tumor cell line contain information predictive - of driver-associated functional states. Building on this, and recognizing - that multiple driver mechanisms collectively shape tumorigenesis, we developed - the unsupervised xAEDriver model to infer multiple driver variant representations - (DVRs) that encapsulate cell-line-specific dependency and expression profiles - while being regularized toward the population-level frequency distribution - of known functional driver SNVs (Fig - 3A). xAEDriver integrates gene dependency and expression data using - an autoencoder with a fully connected encoder and a biologically informed - decoder constrained by the Reactome pathway hierarchy. The latent layer captures - lower-dimensional embeddings of the data. Here, to guide xAEDriver in generating - hidden \u201Cdriver mutation\u201D information, we incorporated data from - known functional driver SNVs to steer the autoencoder's training, ensuring - that the lower-dimensional embeddings (referred to as DVRs) have frequency - distributions similar to real driver SNVs (Materials and methods). We then - applied layer-wise relevance propagation (LRP) to identify important pathways - contributing to the reconstruction, enabling us to uncover additional biological - insights related to the latent functional states.

                                \n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g003Unsupervised xAEDriver model to reconstruct driver - variant representations (DVRs).

                                (A) Workflow of xAEDriver. - Gene dependency and expression data are jointly used to train an autoencoder - with a fully connected encoder and a biologically constrained decoder aligned - with the Reactome hierarchy. The encoder produces low-dimensional embeddings - (DVRs) representing cell-line-specific driver states. Known driver SNVs are - incorporated into training using a truncated binomial modeling approach. - (B) Illustration of cancer type matching ratio. As an example, among - three cell lines with mutations of the DVR (value\u2009=\u20091), two match - the reported cancer type (melanoma) for the corresponding (the most similar) - known driver SNV, yielding a matching ratio of 23. - Similarly, for the most similar real driver SNV, the matching ratio is 1 (22). - (C) Comparison of cancer-type matching ratios between DVRs (blue) - and their most similar known driver SNVs (red). The data are sorted in descending - order based on the matching ratios of the DVRs.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nDVRs recapitulate - driver-mutation frequency and represent the overall driver mutation status - of a cancer cell line\n

                                To evaluate the effectiveness of the guided - learning in xAEDriver, we compared the mutation distribution of known driver - SNVs with that of DVRs across all cell lines (S3 Fig). The mutation distribution of DVRs - closely matched that of actual driver mutations, as demonstrated by the Earth - Mover\u2019s Distance (EMD) of 5.4 (on a 0\u20131,000 scale) between their - mutation patterns. EMD, a metric for assessing distribution similarity, represents - the minimum effort required to transform one distribution into another [29]. These results underscore - the effectiveness of the regularization term in mimicking the distribution - of real mutations, guiding xAEDriver to actually learn DVRs in the hidden - layer.

                                \n

                                Next, we examined whether each DVR\u2019s artificial mutation - status (coded as 1 in the artificial representation vector) matched the reported - cancer type of its closest real SNV, determined via Euclidean distance. The - cancer type matching ratio was calculated as illustrated in Fig 3B. After excluding 481 DVRs with non-unique - matched real SNVs, 61 out of 440 DVRs achieved a matching ratio\u2009\u2265\u20090.5 - (Fig 3C), suggesting - that many DVRs capture cancer-type-specific mutation patterns. Among the remaining - 379 DVRs with a matching ratio below 0.5, 263 (or 69%) still had a matching - ratio greater than or equal to that of their corresponding real SNV. This - suggests that the associated real mutations are often observed in a cancer - type different from the one reported. This could be due to several factors: - the driver mutation may drive tumorigenesis in another cellular context or - a different cancer type, or the mutation may emerge during cancer progression - as a compensatory mechanism or an accelerating \u201Csecond hit\u201D.

                                \n
                                \n\nxAEDriver highlights pathways central to tumor progression\n

                                Using - layer-wise relevance propagation (LRP) in xAEDriver, we computed pathway relevance - scores (Rp,c) - for each pathway p - and cell line c, - where higher values indicate greater contribution to the reconstruction of - the autoencoder. Averaging across all cell lines yielded overall pathway importance - (Rp). - Fig 4 shows the top - 20 pathways ranked by Rp - values, with the complete list provided in S7 Table. The top pathways, such as \u201Ccomplement - cascade\u201D (rank 1), \u201CTNFR2 non-canonical NF-kB pathway\u201D (rank - 2), and \u201CHuR (ELAVL1) binds and stabilizes mRNA\u201D (rank 6), have - been previously linked to tumor progression. For example, Rutkowski et al. - [30] highlighted - the role of the complement cascade in driving cancer by promoting key hallmarks - of its progression. Albini et al. [31] - demonstrated that RAF2 inactivating mutations increase alternative - NF-kB pathway activation in mantle cell lymphoma, diffuse large B-cell lymphoma, - and multiple myeloma. Cai et al. [32] - revealed that ELAVL1 is an m6A-binding protein highly expressed - in multiple tumors that regulates RNA stability to promote tumor progression. - These results confirm that xAEDriver effectively uncovers biologically meaningful - pathways central to tumor biology.

                                \n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g004Important pathways identified from xAEDriver.

                                The - top 20 pathways ordered by Rp - values are shown.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nDVRs link multi-driver functional states to drug response\n

                                Having - established that xAEDriver captures meaningful driver variant representations - (DVRs), we next investigated whether these DVRs are associated with functional - outcomes in cancer cells, specifically their ability to reflect tissue-specific - drug sensitivity patterns and provide mechanistic insights into differential - drug responses. To address this, we constructed LASSO regression models to - predict drug sensitivity (AUC) for each drug using the DVR binary matrix across - our panel of cancer cell lines (Materials and methods). DVR-based models significantly - outperformed those trained on an equivalent number of random somatic mutations - in the test set. Twelve DVR models achieved a test-set R2>0.05, - whereas none of the 50 random models met this threshold (complete list in - S8 Table).

                                \n

                                For - each of the twelve DVR-based models passing this performance threshold, we - identified the ten most influential DVRs based on the absolute values of their - LASSO coefficients, comparing them to a control set of ten randomly selected - DVRs. The biological relevance of these top DVRs was evaluated using a tissue - concordance score (Materials and methods), which quantifies the alignment - between each DVR\u2019s mutation distribution across tissues and the tissue - distribution of the most drug-sensitive cell lines (lowest AUC values). These - top DVRs showed significantly higher tissue concordance scores than random - controls, indicating that they capture tissue-specific drug response patterns - (mean p\u2009=\u20090.0015\xB10.0018 - across 10 independent random samplings, paired Wilcoxon signed-rank test, - Fig 5A). These results - demonstrate that DVRs effectively prioritize biologically meaningful, tissue-specific - features associated with drug sensitivity.

                                \n10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.g005DVRs from xAEDriver reveal drug-response patterns - via LASSO regression and distance-based stratification.

                                (A) - Differential tissue concordance of DVRs. The displayed points correspond to - one representative random-control sampling, in which the top 10 DVRs from - LASSO models for twelve LASSO-explainable drugs show significantly higher - tissue concordance scores than random DVRs (p\u2009=\u20090.0005, paired Wilcoxon - signed-rank test). Across 10 independent random-control samplings, this comparison - remained significant (mean p\u2009=\u20090.0015, SD\u2009=\u20090.0018). (B-E) - Differential drug sensitivity. Cell lines stratified by DVR dissimilarity, - DVR-divergent (high dissimilarity) and DVR-convergent (low dissimilarity), - exhibit distinct drug responses. The DVR-convergent group shows significantly - higher sensitivity (lower AUC) to drugs (B) Velban, (C) - ICL1100013, (D) Mirin, and (E) Alecensa (all Benjamini-Hochberg - adjusted p\u2009=\u20090.02, t-tests). (F) Pathway hierarchy - tree for the top 10 important pathways in the DVR-divergent and DVR-convergent - groups. Highlighted pathways illustrate representative differences in Rp - (pathway importance) between groups. Gray nodes denote parent pathways connecting - these top-ranked nodes, while non-relevant child and sibling nodes are omitted - for clarity.

                                \n
                                \n

                                Next, - we stratified cancer cell lines based on their DVR binary matrix using a distance-based - approach (Materials and methods). This analysis divided the cell lines into - a DVR-divergent (high dissimilarity) group (n\u2009=\u200976) and a DVR-convergent - (low dissimilarity) group (n\u2009=\u2009430). Comparison of drug responses - between these two groups identified seven drugs with significantly different - AUC values (Benjamini-Hochberg adjusted p-value\u2009<\u20090.05, t-test). - Fig 5B\u20135E highlight four representative - drugs, including Velban, ICL1100013, Mirin, and Alecensa. Interestingly, all - four drugs were more effective in the larger DVR-convergent group, suggesting - shared vulnerabilities across a broad spectrum of cancer cell lines. The boxplots - for the other three drugs, SN38, Mps-1-IN-1, and Y-39983, are shown in S4 Fig.

                                \n

                                To - further assess the relationship between DVR and drug response, we correlated - the pairwise Euclidean distances between cell lines in the DVR space with - the pairwise Pearson\u2019s correlations of their drug response (AUC) profiles. - This analysis revealed a significant, though modest, negative correlation - (PCC\u2009= \u22120.04, p-value\u2009=\u20095.5\xD710-39), - indicating that cell lines with greater DVR dissimilarity tend to exhibit - less similar drug sensitivity patterns. These results demonstrate that DVR-based - stratification can effectively distinguish cell lines with distinct drug response - profiles.

                                \n

                                To explore the biological mechanisms underlying these differences, - we analyzed pathway relevance within each cell line group. All 680 pathways - were ranked by their average relevance scores across cell lines (S9 Table), revealing group-specific enrichment - among the top pathways (Fig - 5F). For example, the \u201CAdaptive immune system\u201D pathway ranked - 7th in the DVR-convergent group but 654th in the DVR-divergent group, consistent - with higher sensitivity to Velban and ICL1100013 in the DVR-convergent group - (Fig 5B\u20135C). Previous findings show - that local low-dose Velban injection enhances adaptive immunity via dendritic - cell maturation [33], - while ICL1100013 targets NMT1, an enzyme critical for T-cell - receptor signaling and immune function [34,35]. Similarly, the \u201CBase - excision repair\u201D (BER) pathway ranked much higher in the DVR-convergent - group (10th vs. 564th in the DVR-divergent group), consistent with increased - sensitivity to Mirin (an MRE11 inhibitor) and Alecensa (an - ALK inhibitor) (Fig - 5D\u20135E). - These associations are mechanistically coherent: MRE11 plays - key roles in BER and single-strand break repair [36], - while Alecensa resistance, characterized by low SFTPD expression, - has been linked to elevated BER pathway activity [37]. Together, these findings suggest that - enhanced immune and DNA repair pathway activities underlie the heightened - drug sensitivity observed in the DVR-convergent group.

                                \n

                                Overall, these - results demonstrate that DVR-based representations capture biologically and - therapeutically relevant signals, enabling the identification of tissue-specific - patterns, drug sensitivities, and underlying pathway mechanisms in cancer - cell lines.

                                \n
                                \n\nAblation study supports - the importance of frequency-guided regularization\n

                                To assess whether - the truncated binomial distribution penalty provides a useful inductive bias - or instead introduces circularity by injecting known driver mutation statistics - into the latent representation, we performed an ablation study. We trained - a binomial-penalty-ablated xAEDriver model in which the autoencoder was optimized - using only reconstruction loss and L2 weight regularization, while removing - the frequency-guided penalty from the latent layer.

                                \n

                                The binomial penalty - used in xAEDriver is intentionally low-information. It does not encode driver - gene identity, pathway membership, tissue type, drug response, or any one-to-one - correspondence between DVRs and known driver SNVs. Instead, it constrains - only the marginal frequency distribution of DVR presence across cell lines, - encouraging the latent variables to have a sparsity pattern broadly similar - to observed functional driver SNVs. Many different DVR-cell line assignments - could satisfy the same frequency distribution; therefore, the biological and - pharmacological associations of DVRs must still be learned from the dependency - and expression data during autoencoder training.

                                \n

                                Removal of the binomial - penalty substantially reduced downstream performance. The number of drugs - with held-out test-set R\xB2\u2009>\u20090.05 decreased from 12 to 2, and - the maximum test-set R\xB2 declined from approximately 0.34 to 0.08 (S10 Table). - Tissue concordance of the top predictive DVRs also became non-significant, - with the paired Wilcoxon signed-rank test p-value changing from 0.0015 to - 0.5. In addition, DVR-based stratification no longer identified any drugs - with significantly different sensitivity between DVR-divergent and DVR-convergent - cell lines, compared with seven drugs identified by the original model using - Benjamini-Hochberg adjusted p-value\u2009<\u20090.05.

                                \n

                                These results - indicate that the binomial penalty improves the biological coherence and downstream - utility of the learned latent space. Rather than imposing specific biological - annotations, the frequency-guided penalty acts as a weak population-level - prior that discourages degenerate latent representations and helps xAEDriver - recover DVRs that remain informative for drug response, tissue concordance, - and pathway-level interpretation.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nDiscussion\n

                                In this study, we - introduce interpretable functional-genomics frameworks for linking cancer - driver alterations to genome-wide dependency landscapes, pathway programs, - and drug-response structure in cancer cell lines. xNNDriver prioritizes candidate - driver genes by quantifying how strongly their mutation status is reflected - in dependency profiles, while xAEDriver learns multi-driver functional representations - that summarize broader oncogenic states. Together, these models show that - DepMap dependency data encode biologically interpretable signals of driver - activity and treatment-relevant vulnerability.

                                \n

                                xNNDriver reframes - driver identification from a purely mutation-frequency paradigm to a systems-level - functional consequence paradigm. The fact that known drivers score highly - supports the biological signal embedded in dependency landscapes. Furthermore, - the model is applied uniformly to 3,008 candidate genes and identifies both - established and literature-supported but not yet DepMap-annotated candidates. - Importantly, the driver potential score quantifies the functional footprint - of mutations rather than their recurrence alone.

                                \n

                                Given that the dependency - score of the candidate driver gene provides a quantifiable functional signature - of driver activity, it was included as an input feature and could be intrinsically - selected during model training. For example, loss of an oncogene often reduces - cell viability (low dependency score), whereas loss of a tumor suppressor - enhances growth (high dependency score). As shown in S5 Fig, TP53, a tumor suppressor, - exhibits the highest mean dependency score (0.426), while NRAS, - an oncogene, shows a low value (\u22120.654). However, HRAS, - another oncogenic driver, displays a near-neutral score (\u22120.107), underscoring - that single-gene dependency alone provides only partial information about - driver status. Indeed, the self-dependency exclusion experiment showed that - top drivers retained substantial predictive performance after their own dependency - scores were removed, indicating that xNNDriver also captures distributed dependency - signals across other genes. For some candidates, performance decreased after - removal, suggesting a stronger contribution from direct self-dependency. Thus, - we interpret the driver potential score as an integrated mutation-dependency - association measure that can reflect self-dependency, network-level dependency - effects, or both.

                                \n

                                xNNDriver-prioritized pathways frequently exhibited - lower expression CV in driver-mutant cell lines, even when differences in - mean expression were modest. Because these estimates were derived from bulk - RNA-seq across cell lines, they reflect inter-cell-line pathway-state variability - rather than single-cell transcriptional noise. Reduced variability may indicate - driver-induced canalization, in which oncogenic alterations lock downstream - pathways into more stable transcriptional states. In non-mutated contexts, - higher pathway variability may reflect dynamic responses to environmental, - genetic, and regulatory cues, whereas driver mutations may restrict this flexibility - by enforcing a constitutive pathway state. This state-locking provides a plausible - mechanistic link to the dependency footprints captured by xNNDriver, because - tumor cells may become more reliant on the altered pathway or its compensatory - networks and less able to adapt to CRISPR perturbations. Because expression - data were not used to train xNNDriver, the observed decrease in pathway expression - variability provides independent biological support for the functional dependency - footprints identified by the model.

                                \n

                                To model complex combinatorial - functional states, we developed the unsupervised xAEDriver model. While xNNDriver - excels at evaluating individual driver genes, it is not inherently designed - to capture systemic, multi-driver states. In contrast, xAEDriver represents - a conceptual shift from single-driver evaluation to multi-driver functional - state inference by encoding cell-line-specific patterns that mimic the behavior - of real functional driver variants through guided learning.

                                \n

                                DVRs showed - biologically interpretable and drug-associated patterns. Using LASSO regression, - we demonstrated that the DVR-based predictions of drug response also exhibited - strong tissue-type specificity, supporting their biological relevance. Furthermore, - DVR-based stratification of cancer cell lines revealed distinct groups with - significantly different drug sensitivity profiles and pathway activities. - This stratification identified specific vulnerabilities, such as enhanced - response to immune-related or DNA repair-targeting drugs, highlighting the - translational potential of DVRs in predicting therapeutic responses and informing - precision oncology strategies.

                                \n

                                The ablation analysis of xAEDriver - supports the importance of frequency-guided regularization in shaping biologically - interpretable DVRs, but the role of the truncated binomial prior should be - interpreted with caution. This prior does not encode specific driver gene - identities, pathway annotations, tissue labels, drug-response information, - or one-to-one mappings between DVRs and known driver SNVs. Instead, it provides - only a coarse prevalence constraint, encouraging DVRs to follow the broad - sparsity pattern observed for functional driver SNVs while leaving the specific - DVR-cell line assignments to be learned from dependency and expression data. - This design helps balance flexibility and biological structure in the latent - space: it discourages overly dense or degenerate representations optimized - only for reconstruction, while still allowing DVRs to capture novel combinations - of functional states. Thus, we view the binomial penalty as a weak inductive - bias that improves latent-space organization, rather than as evidence that - mutation frequency itself determines driver importance. Future work may explore - alternative priors, including cancer-type-specific or context-adaptive priors, - to better capture rare driver states.

                                \n

                                To enhance interpretability, - both xNNDriver and xAEDriver incorporated biologically informed neural network - architectures guided by the Reactome pathway hierarchy. Rather than acting - merely as a sparsity constraint, this design embeds the hierarchy directly - into the network to aggregate signals across levels, enabling the mechanistic - attribution of driver effects. We do not view the pathway-constrained architecture - alone as proof of a causal mechanism; instead, pathway attributions are supported - by standalone proximity analysis, expression-stochasticity analyses, and consistency - with external literature. In xNNDriver, the identified important pathways - demonstrate hierarchical coherence and expression variability patterns. In - xAEDriver, a biologically constrained decoder preserves pathway structure - while allowing the encoder to learn flexible representations, since fully - constraining both sides proved too restrictive and often produced trivial - DVRs. Ultimately, the pathways identified by both models confirm the biological - robustness of our framework, providing interpretable and biologically grounded - insights beyond conventional pathway enrichment analyses.

                                \n

                                Despite - the utility of DepMap as a comprehensive functional-genomics resource, several - limitations should be acknowledged. Genome-scale CRISPR knockout screens measure - the effect of additional gene loss on cancer-cell fitness. This design is - well suited to detecting direct dependencies on activated oncogenes, but its - interpretation for tumor suppressors is more context-dependent. Some tumor - suppressor alterations can still be captured when they are associated with - direct dependency signals or broader dependency-landscape changes. For example, - TP53 exhibits a high mean dependency score (0.426), is strongly - prioritized by xNNDriver, and remains predictive after TP53\u2019s - own dependency score is removed from the input features (S5 Table). This indicates that tumor suppressor-associated - dependency signals can extend beyond dependency on the candidate gene itself. - However, tumor suppressors that are already functionally inactivated, poorly - represented in relevant tissue contexts, or mainly altered through non-SNV - mechanisms may remain difficult to detect. RB1 illustrates - this limitation: despite its established role in retinoblastoma and other - cancers, it shows no strong eye-specific signal and generally low scores in - Fig 1C. This may reflect - pre-existing RB1 loss, limited tissue representation, and - incomplete capture of non-SNV loss-of-function mechanisms, including indels, - copy-number loss, structural alterations, or epigenetic silencing. Therefore, - low xNNDriver scores should not be interpreted as evidence against the established - roles of canonical tumor suppressors. Future versions of the framework should - integrate multiple alteration types to better capture tumor-suppressor biology.

                                \n

                                Second, - DepMap also identifies pan-essential housekeeping genes whose loss broadly - impairs cell fitness. Such dependencies may contribute to driver-associated - functional footprints but are unlikely to provide a favorable therapeutic - window because of potential on-target, off-tumor toxicity. Therefore, xNNDriver - pathway scores indicate functional associations rather than direct therapeutic - tractability, which requires additional evaluation of tumor selectivity and - normal-tissue tolerance.

                                \n

                                Looking ahead, expanding the models to include - larger and more diverse datasets will improve the detection of both common - and rare driver mutations across different cancer types. This broader scope - will refine our understanding of gene dependencies and mutation synergies, - leading to more accurate prediction of therapeutic vulnerabilities. Ultimately, - the integration of dependency data with mutational and pharmacological information - will advance precision oncology by enabling more personalized and effective - cancer treatment strategies.

                                \n
                                \n\nMaterials - and methods\n\nDatasets\n\nThe - DepMap database.\n

                                We utilized data from the Cancer Dependency Map - (DepMap) projects (23Q2 version). This release contains data from CRISPR-Cas9 - knockout screens across multiple tumor types, as part of Broad\u2019s Achilles - [38] and Sanger\u2019s - SCORE projects [39]. - It also includes genomic and transcriptomic characterizations from the CCLE - project [40].

                                \n

                                The - primary dataset includes CRISPR-Cas9 essentiality screens for 17,931 genes - across 1,095 cell lines [9,10], resulting in a cell-line-by-screened-gene - matrix. Each entry represents the \u201Cdependency score\u201D of a screened - gene, which was processed from the log-fold change in sgRNA read counts before - and after knockout. A lower dependency score indicates a stronger reduction - in cell viability following gene knockout, implying that the gene is essential - for cell survival. Quality control and normalization were performed by DepMap.

                                \n

                                Somatic - point mutations for the DepMap cell lines were obtained from the same source - [41]. We specifically - filtered for SNVs, resulting in a final set of 1,290,926 mutations for downstream - analysis. Gene expression data (RNA-seq) were also retrieved as transcripts - per million (TPM) for 19,194 genes across 1,450 cell lines, log-transformed - with a pseudo-count of one. A total of 1,019 cell lines had both dependency - score and gene expression data available.

                                \n

                                We also downloaded drug - sensitivity data for the cell lines [42]. - From the raw data, fold-change viability values were calculated using the - R package gdscIC50 [43], - and standard four-parameter monotonic log-logistic dose-response curves were - fitted using the R package dr4pl [44]. - Drug sensitivity was then quantified as the area under the curve (AUC), covering - 320 drugs across 962 cell lines. Among these, 506 cell lines also had dependency - scores and gene expression data available.

                                \n
                                \n\nThe - COSMIC database.\n

                                We obtained mutation data from the Catalogue - of Somatic Mutations in Cancer (COSMIC) Cancer Mutation Census [12], filtering for SNVs. To identify functionally - significant mutations, we retained those annotated as \u201Chigh\u201D or - \u201Cmoderate\u201D impact based on consequence predictions from the Ensembl - Variation database [45].

                                \n
                                \n\nThe ClinVar database.\n

                                ClinVar compiles - relationships between human genetic variants and phenotypic outcomes [13]. Although primarily - focused on germline mutations, it includes somatic variants as well. We downloaded - the ClinVar summary table and filtered for SNVs annotated as: pathogenic, - likely pathogenic, affects, drug response, or confers sensitivity.

                                \n

                                We - merged the filtered COSMIC and ClinVar SNVs, yielding 28,459 clinically significant - variants also documented in DepMap. Among these, 340 were located in known - driver genes with mutations observed in at least one cell line, which we designated - as known driver mutations for model training and validation.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nxNNDriver: Supervised model for identifying driver - genes\n\nTraining and test data.\n

                                Gene - names from the considered datasets were converted to Ensembl IDs using the - DAVID portal [46], - ensuring consistency with the Reactome database. Genes absent from the Reactome - database were excluded. Dependency scores were split into training (75%) and - test (25%) sets, with five-fold cross-validation on the training set for hyperparameter - tuning. Because mutation-positive samples were much fewer than negatives, - we balanced the classes during the training process by random upsampling of - positive samples to achieve a 1:1 ratio.

                                \n
                                \n\nPathway - hierarchy.\n

                                The Reactome database [11] - was used to construct a hierarchical pathway tree using the NetworkX Python - library. Internal nodes represent pathways, and leaves correspond to genes. - To simplify the hierarchy and reduce redundancy, each gene was linked only - to its closest pathway nodes. A hyperparameter l controlled - the number of pathway levels included. Genes or pathways absent from the data - were excluded. The resulting structure was encoded as a binary mask matrix - M, where Mi,j=1denotes - a valid connection. Following our previous work [28], - multi-layer predictive designs were employed to enhance model accuracy.

                                \n
                                \n\nNeural network construction.\n

                                We built a - feedforward neural network based on the mask matrix. The input layer consists - of CRISPR-Cas9 screened genes, with their corresponding dependency scores - as input data. The size of the input layer corresponds to the number of genes - allocated to the lowest level of the pathway hierarchy. For each layer, the - input is denoted as x - and the output as y. - The output of each layer is calculated as: y=f[(MW)x+b], - where f - is the activation function (tanh), M - is the mask matrix, W - is the weight matrix, and b - is the bias vector. Here, MW - is the element-wise multiplication (Hadamard product) of M - and W.

                                \n

                                The - tanh activation function was selected to provide bounded and signed hidden - representations. Because xNNDriver pathway importance is based on activation - differences between mutation-positive and mutation-negative cell lines, bounding - activations to [-1, 1] improves comparability across pathway layers and gene-specific - models. In addition, the sign of tanh activations allows the model to preserve - opposing dependency patterns, rather than truncating negative signals as ReLU - would. Although tanh may saturate in deeper networks, the relatively shallow - Reactome-guided architecture used here reduces this concern.

                                \n

                                Binary - predictions were generated using a sigmoid function: \u03C3(z)=11+e\u2212z. - A cell line was classified as 1 (mutated) if \u03C3>0.5. - Training used the Adam optimizer, cross-entropy loss, and L2 regularization. - Final predictions were aggregated across all predictive layers via majority - voting, and model performance was quantified by the AUC metric on the test - set, referred to as the driver potential score.

                                \n
                                \n\nHyperparameter - tuning.\n

                                We applied stepwise hyperparameter tuning with five-fold - cross-validation on the training set of the model for the candidate gene KRAS - to optimize hyperparameters. Hyperparameters were tuned sequentially in the - following order: the number of levels in the pathway hierarchy tree (l), - L2 regularization hyperparameter, learning rate, batch size, and - number of epochs. The optimal hyperparameter values based on the highest driver - potential score were l - = 3, regularization\u2009=\u20090.0001, learning rate\u2009=\u20090.01, batch - size\u2009=\u2009128, and epochs\u2009=\u2009100.

                                \n
                                \n\nEvent-level - validation.\n

                                Beyond the aggregate driver potential score, we performed - event-level validation to assess whether xNNDriver can correctly identify - individual mutation events in held-out cell lines. For each of the top 15 - candidate driver genes, precision was calculated as the fraction of cell lines - predicted as mutation-positive that indeed harbored the corresponding functional - mutation in DepMap, and recall was calculated as the fraction of truly mutated - cell lines that the model correctly identified. These per-gene metrics were - evaluated on the same held-out test set (~25% of all cell lines) used for - driver potential scoring.

                                \n
                                \n\nBaseline - model comparison.\n

                                To contextualize xNNDriver\u2019s predictive - performance, we benchmarked it against three conventional classifiers: Logistic - Regression, Random Forest, and a standard Multilayer Perceptron without pathway - constraints (all with default hyperparameters). All baseline models were trained - using the same genome-wide dependency score features, mutation-status labels, - and 75/25 training/test split as xNNDriver, but without embedding the Reactome - pathway hierarchy into the model architecture. For the top 15 candidate genes, - we compared the test-set AUROC of each baseline model with the corresponding - xNNDriver driver potential score. To further assess whether xNNDriver produced - gene rankings consistent with a simpler predictive model, we trained Logistic - Regression across candidate genes with valid xNNDriver driver potential scores - greater than 0.5 (433 genes) and calculated the Spearman rank correlation - between Logistic Regression AUROC and xNNDriver driver potential score.

                                \n
                                \n\nIdentification of important pathways in xNNDriver.\n

                                Pathway - importance was measured as the absolute difference in activation values between - cell lines with and without mutation for a given pathway p: - dp=|Ap,0\u2212Ap,1|. - If a pathway appears in the paths of multiple prediction layers (nested subnetworks), - we chose the maximum value of dp - across all paths as the final importance measure, denoted as Dp. - Pathways with a Dp - value greater than a predefined threshold (default: 0.1) were considered important. - If the pathway node was an artificial node introduced to preserve the pathway - tree structure, the original pathway node was retrieved.

                                \n
                                \n\nProximity analysis in the Reactome hierarchy.\n

                                For - each candidate driver gene, we calculated the shortest path length between - its important pathways and the gene within the Reactome tree using NetworkX. - Random pathways from the same hierarchical level served as controls. Statistical - significance was assessed using paired Wilcoxon signed-rank tests. Correlations - between relative path-length differences (the shortest path length for an - important node minus that for a random pathway node, divided by the former) - and Dpranks - (sorted descendingly) were computed using Pearson correlation coefficients - across 20 randomizations.

                                \n
                                \n\nExpression - stochasticity of the pathways.\n

                                Pathway expression variability - was quantified by the coefficient of variation (CV: standard deviation over - mean) of member genes across cell lines with or without the candidate gene - mutation. Differences in CV distributions were tested using the Wilcoxon signed-rank - test. Here, we use the term \u201Cexpression stochasticity\u201D operationally - to describe inter-cell-line variability in pathway expression measured from - bulk RNA-seq, rather than single-cell transcriptional bursting within individual - cells.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nxAEDriver: Unsupervised - model for multi-driver representation learning\n\nTraining - data preparation.\n

                                The model xAEDriver utilized both gene dependency - score and gene expression data as input features. Cell lines present in only - one of the two data sources were excluded. For each gene j - in cell line i, - each feature was normalized within genes: normi,\_\_j=xi,\_\_j\u2212mean(x\xB7,j)max(x\xB7,j)\u2212min(x\xB7,j). - This gene-wise normalization step maps both CRISPR dependency scores and RNA-seq - gene expression data onto a comparable numerical scale. After normalization, - the gene dependency and expression data were merged into a unified matrix - by aligning cell lines.

                                \n
                                \n\nGuided learning - using known driver SNVs.\n

                                Known driver SNV frequencies across cell - lines were modeled using a truncated binomial distribution to exclude both - endpoints. Let X - represent the number of cell lines in which a known driver SNV is present - as the mutated allele. The truncated binomial distribution for X - is:

                                \nP(Xi=k)={@lr(nk)pk(1\u2212p)k1\u2212(1\u2212p)n\u2212pn,k=1,2,\u2026,n\u22121~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0,k=0orn,\n

                                where - n - (= (1,019) is the number of cell lines, and p - is the unknown probability of SNV being present in the population. Note that - for all known driver SNVs, k - is neither 0 nor n. - Parameter p - was estimated via maximum likelihood from the 340 known driver SNVs.

                                \n
                                \n\nAutoencoder construction.\n

                                The autoencoder - consists of a fully connected encoder and a biologically informed decoder. - The encoder and decoder share a symmetric structure in terms of node numbers - at each layer, and both use the tanh activation function. However, in the - decoder, certain neuron connections are masked according to the pathway-gene - mask matrix, while the encoder remains fully connected.

                                \n

                                The pathway-gene - mask matrix was constructed following the approach outlined in the description - for xNNDriver. The key distinction was in how we handled genes that appeared - in both the dependency score and expression datasets. Before integrating dependency - and expression data, each feature was normalized across cell lines by subtracting - its mean and dividing by its range, placing the two modalities on comparable - numerical scales. Then, the pathway was linked to both the \u201Cdependency\u201D - node and the \u201Cexpression\u201D node, and both entries in the mask matrix - were set to one. The binary mask matrix M - specifies only the allowed topology and does not impose equal weights across - modalities. Dependency and expression edges are assigned independently learned - weights during training, allowing the autoencoder to balance modality-specific - information and noise. For genes present in only one dataset, connections - were handled as described before.

                                \n

                                The lower-dimensional representation, - referred to as driver variant representations (DVRs), is produced in the latent - layer, which consists of 1024 neurons. Each DVR is represented by a neuron - in the latent layer with values constrained to 0 or 1, indicating the mutation - presence or absence of the DVR. The sigmoid activation function is used in - the latent layer, ensuring the binary nature of the DVRs (rounded to 0 or - 1). The autoencoder was trained by the Adam optimizer, and the cost function - includes both reconstruction loss (measured as the mean squared error between - the output layer and the input layer) and regularization terms, which include - an L2 regularization term and a binomial distribution penalty.

                                \n

                                Specifically, - the binomial distribution penalty term encourages the DVRs to resemble real - driver SNVs. In each epoch, after obtaining the lower-dimensional representations, - we computed the sum for each DVR neuron across all cell lines and denoted - it as xi. - The binomial distribution penalty term is defined as the negative logarithmic - likelihood across all DVRs (q\u2009=\u20091,024), calculated as:

                                \nbinomial_penalty=\u22121q\u2211i=1qlogP(X=xi).\n

                                If - P(X=xi) - is equal to 0, the training process will be terminated, and the rounded DVRs - from the previous epoch will be used as the final output.

                                \n
                                \n\nHyperparameter tuning.\n

                                Grid search was - used to tune the model\u2019s hyperparameters. For each hyperparameter combination, - we recorded the average loss over five repeats and selected the combination - yielding the lowest loss as the default. The default values for the L2 - regularization hyperparameter and binomial distribution penalty hyperparameters - were set to 0.1 and 0.001, respectively. The default learning rate was 0.01. - The default number of epochs was 1,000. The batch size was fixed at 1,019, - corresponding to the total number of cell lines, as it is required to remain - constant to compute the binomial distribution penalty.

                                \n
                                \n\nMeasuring - pathway importance by layer-wise relevance propagation.\n

                                To assess - the contribution of pathways in generating DVRs, we employed layer-wise relevance - propagation (LRP) with the epsilon rule [47]. - LRP decomposes the prediction by propagating relevance scores backward through - the autoencoder\u2019s layers. For a given cell line c, the - relevance score rj,c - for neuron j is calculated as:

                                \nrj,c=\u2211kaj,cwj,k\u03B5+\u2211iai,cwi,krk,c,\n

                                where - k denotes a neuron in the subsequent layer (closer to the - output), and i iterates over all neurons in the same layer - as j that connect to k. Given the pathway-constrained - hierarchy of our architecture, these connections are sparse, meaning wi,k - is non-zero only for biologically established links. Here, aj,c - and ai,c - represent the forward-pass activation values, wj,k - and wi,k - are the corresponding connection weights, and \u03B5 - is a small positive constant. The relevance scores are propagated from the - output layer to the input layer. We compute normalized relevance scores for - each layer using z-scores, and the pathway importance is quantified by examining - the decoder layer. The final normalized relevance score for pathway j - and cell line c - is denoted as Rj,c.

                                \n
                                \n\nLASSO regression model for DVR-drug association.\n

                                For - each drug, a LASSO regression model was built with DVRs as predictors and - drug AUC values as responses. Data were split into training (80%) and test - (20%) sets. Models were trained using a LASSO regularization parameter (\u03B1) - of 0.001 and a maximum of 2,000 iterations. Predictive models (R\xB2\u2009>\u20090.05) - were analyzed for their top 10 DVRs based on coefficient magnitude. LASSO - models were also built on 50 sets of random mutation controls for comparison.

                                \n

                                To - evaluate the biological relevance of the top DVRs, we calculated a tissue - concordance score for each DVR. For a given drug, we defined two groups of - cell lines: (1) the DVR-positive group, consisting of all cell lines in which - the DVR was present (value\u2009=\u20091), and (2) the drug-sensitive group, - consisting of an equal number of cell lines showing the strongest response - to the drug (i.e., the lowest AUC values). The tissue concordance score was - defined as the degree of overlap in tissue-type composition between these - two groups, normalized by group size. This score reflects the degree of tissue-specific - association between DVR presence and drug response.

                                \n

                                As a control, - for each drug, we randomly selected ten DVRs that were not among the top ten - and repeated the concordance analysis. We then compared the tissue concordance - scores between the top DVRs and the random controls using a paired Wilcoxon - signed-rank test to assess statistical significance.

                                \n

                                The regularization - parameter \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.001 was empirically selected to balance feature - sparsity and model capacity in high-dimensional functional genomics data: - excessively large \u03B1 values force most coefficients to zero, while excessively - small values lead to overfitting. To verify the robustness of this choice, - we retrained the LASSO models across different \u03B1 values and evaluated - the number of predictive models (test R2 - > 0.05) and resulting tissue concordance p-values - (S11 Table). - Extreme settings reduced predictive performance, whereas \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.001 - and \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.0005 both produced 12 predictive drug models and - significant tissue concordance. We therefore retained \u03B1\u2009=\u20090.001 - as the primary setting within a robust effective range.

                                \n
                                \n\nDistance-based DVR stratification for drug sensitivity - patterns.\n

                                We calculated the total Euclidean distance of each cell - line to all others in DVR space and stratified lines into DVR-divergent (large - total distance) and DVR-convergent (small total distance) groups using the - 85th percentile cutoff. The 85th percentile was chosen as a data-driven threshold - that balances signal purity and statistical power, as confirmed by a sensitivity - analysis across adjacent percentiles (75th\u201390th). Drug sensitivity (AUC) - differences were assessed with Welch\u2019s t-test, omitting cell lines lacking - drug data.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nSupporting - information\n\n\n\nPrediction - performance of xNNDriver for the top 30 genes with the highest driver potential - scores using all SNVs.\n

                                All somatic SNVs, no matter whether annotated - as functional or not, are used. Data point color indicates the number of cell - lines with mutations in that gene. Gene name color distinguishes whether a - gene is a known driver or not (purple: driver, black: non-driver), as documented - by DepMap.

                                \n

                                (TIF)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nEvent-level - validation of xNNDriver predictions for the top 15 candidate driver genes.\n

                                Blue - bars indicate precision, defined as the fraction of cell lines predicted as - mutation-positive that carried the corresponding catalogued functional mutation - in DepMap. Green bars indicate recall, defined as the fraction of cell lines - with a catalogued functional mutation that were predicted as mutation-positive - by xNNDriver. Predictions were evaluated on the held-out test set (~275 cell - lines) for each gene.

                                \n

                                (TIF)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nComparison - of mutation frequency distributions between DVRs from xAEDriver and known - functional driver SNVs.\n

                                The histograms display the frequency of - mutation occurrences across cell lines for (A) DVRs and (B) known driver SNVs.

                                \n

                                (TIF)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nDifferential - drug sensitivity for additional significant drugs.\n

                                DVR-divergent - and DVR-convergent cell lines show distinct drug responses for (A) SN38 (Benjamini-Hochberg - adjusted p - = 0.04), (B) Mps-1-IN-1 (adjusted p - = 0.03), and (C) Y-39983 (adjusted p - = 0.02), based on t-tests followed by Benjamini-Hochberg p value adjustments.

                                \n

                                (TIF)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nDistribution - of mean dependency scores of all genes.\n

                                The histogram illustrates - the distribution of mean dependency scores across all cell lines for all genes - in the DepMap gene dependency dataset.

                                \n

                                (TIF)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nComprehensive - results of all xNNDriver models using functional SNVs.\n

                                Each model - corresponds to a frequently mutated candidate gene (3,008 in total). Information - includes the following metrics: driver potential score, the number of cell - lines with mutation presence, the number of cell lines without mutation presence, - and whether the gene is annotated as a driver based on DepMap.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nComprehensive - results of all xNNDriver models using all SNVs.\n

                                Each model corresponds - to a frequently mutated candidate gene (3,008 in total). Information includes - the following metrics: driver potential score, the number of cell lines with - mutation presence, the number of cell lines without mutation presence, and - whether the gene is a driver based on DepMap.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nAUPRC evaluation - of xNNDriver for the top 15 genes.\n

                                Each entry reports the test-set - AUPRC for an xNNDriver model evaluated without upsampling, preserving the - native mutation-class imbalance.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nBaseline - model comparison.\n

                                Prediction performance (driver potential score) - of xNNDriver, Logistic Regression, Random Forest, and an unconstrained Multilayer - Perceptron is shown for the top 15 candidate genes using the same genome-wide - dependency features and mutation-status labels. The table also reports the - broader comparison between xNNDriver and Logistic Regression for the 433 genes - with xNNDriver driver potential score\u2009>\u20090.5.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nSelf-dependency - exclusion analysis for the top 15 genes.\n

                                Each entry reports the - driver potential score after removing the candidate gene\u2019s own dependency - score from the input features.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nImportant - pathways identified from xNNDriver for candidate driver genes.\n

                                This - table includes a comprehensive summary combining results for all 15 genes, - as well as 15 individual sheets detailing results for each gene. The overall - table also provides the adjusted p-values from the Wilcoxon tests on the comparison - of coefficients of variation of pathway expression between cell lines with - and without mutations.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nPathway - importance from xAEDriver.\n

                                This table includes the average Rp - values across all cell lines. Pathways marked with \u201C_copy1\u201D indicate - artificial nodes created to preserve the pathway tree structure.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nTest set - <inline-formula id=\"pcbi.1014869.e073\"><alternatives><graphic id=\"pcbi.1014869.e073g\" - mimetype=\"image\" position=\"anchor\" xlink:href=\"info:doi/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.e073\" - xlink:type=\"simple\"/><mml:math display=\"inline\" id=\"M73\"><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:msup><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi - mathvariant=\"bold-italic\">R</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mn - mathvariant=\"bold\">2</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:msup></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:math></alternatives></inline-formula> - values of LASSO regression models based on DVRs and random somatic mutations.\n

                                Random - control results are averaged over 50 runs.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nAverage - pathway importance (<inline-formula id=\"pcbi.1014869.e074\"><alternatives><graphic - id=\"pcbi.1014869.e074g\" mimetype=\"image\" position=\"anchor\" xlink:href=\"info:doi/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014869.e074\" - xlink:type=\"simple\"/><mml:math display=\"inline\" id=\"M74\"><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi - mathvariant=\"bold-italic\">R</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi - mathvariant=\"bold-italic\">p</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:math></alternatives></inline-formula> - values) and rankings for the DVR-divergent and DVR-convergent groups.\n

                                Reported - metrics include average Rp - and rank for each group.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nDrug-response - prediction using DVRs learned without the binomial penalty.\n

                                Test-set - R\xB2 values are shown for LASSO regression models trained on DVRs from the - binomial-penalty-ablated xAEDriver model.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\nSensitivity - analysis of LASSO regularization parameter (\u03B1).\n

                                The number - of predictive drug models (test-set R2 - > 0.05) and the corresponding tissue-concordance p-values are shown across - a range of \u03B1 values.

                                \n

                                (XLSX)

                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n

                                We - thank Dr. Sika Zheng at the University of California, Riverside, Yingtong - Liu, and all members of the Chen lab for their discussions and suggestions - throughout this study.

                                \n
                                \n\nReferences\nPorta-Pardo - E, Valencia - A, Godzik - A. Understanding oncogenicity - of cancer driver genes and mutations in the cancer genomics era. - FEBS Lett. 2020;594(24):4233\u201346. - doi: 10.1002/1873-3468.13781 32239503\nSong - Q, Li - M, Li - Q, Lu - X, Song - K, Zhang - Z, et al. DeepAlloDriver: - a deep learning-based strategy to predict cancer driver mutations. - Nucleic Acids Res. 2023;51(W1):W129\u201333. - doi: 10.1093/nar/gkad295 37078611\nZeng - Z, Mao - C, Vo - A, Li - X, Nugent - JO, Khan - SA, et al. Deep - learning for cancer type classification and driver gene identification. - BMC Bioinformatics. 2021;22(Suppl - 4):491. doi: 10.1186/s12859-021-04400-4 34689757\nPeng - W, Tang - Q, Dai - W, Chen - T. Improving cancer driver - gene identification using multi-task learning on graph convolutional network. - Brief Bioinform. 2022;23(1):bbab432. - doi: 10.1093/bib/bbab432 34643232\nLiu - Y, Baugh - AG, Roussos - Torres ET, MacLean - AL. Inference of marker genes - of subtle cell state changes via iLR: iterative logistic regression. - Bioinformatics. 2026;42(2):btag051. - doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btag051 - 41627891\nYin - Q, Wang - Y, Guan - J, Ji - G. scIAE: an integrative - autoencoder-based ensemble classification framework for single-cell RNA-seq - data. Brief Bioinform. 2022;23(1):bbab508. - doi: 10.1093/bib/bbab508 34913057\nvan - der Weyden L, Jonkers - J, Adams - DJ. The use of CRISPR/Cas9-based - gene editing strategies to explore cancer gene function in mice. - Curr Opin Genet Dev. 2021;66:57\u201362. - doi: 10.1016/j.gde.2020.12.005 33429291\nChiu - Y-C, Zheng - S, Wang - L-J, Iskra - BS, Rao - MK, Houghton - PJ, et al. Predicting - and characterizing a cancer dependency map of tumors with deep learning. - Sci Adv. 2021;7(34):eabh1275. - doi: 10.1126/sciadv.abh1275 34417181\nDempster - JM, Rossen - J, Kazachkova - M, Pan - J, Kugener - G, Root - DE. Extracting biological - insights from the project achilles genome-scale CRISPR screens in cancer cell - lines. BioRxiv. 2019. doi: - 10.1101/720243\nMeyers - RM, Bryan - JG, McFarland - JM, Weir - BA, Sizemore - AE, Xu - H, et al. Computational - correction of copy number effect improves specificity of CRISPR-Cas9 essentiality - screens in cancer cells. Nat Genet. 2017;49(12):1779\u201384. - doi: 10.1038/ng.3984 29083409\nJoshi-Tope - G, Gillespie - M, Vastrik - I, D\u2019Eustachio - P, Schmidt - E, de - Bono B, et al. Reactome: - a knowledgebase of biological pathways. Nucleic Acids - Res. 2005;33(Database issue):D428-32. - doi: 10.1093/nar/gki072 15608231\nForbes - SA, Bindal - N, Bamford - S, Cole - C, Kok - CY, Beare - D, et al. COSMIC: - mining complete cancer genomes in the Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer. - Nucleic Acids Res. 2011;39(Database - issue):D945-50. doi: 10.1093/nar/gkq929 20952405\nLandrum - MJ, Lee - JM, Riley - GR, Jang - W, Rubinstein - WS, Church - DM, et al. ClinVar: - public archive of relationships among sequence variation and human phenotype. - Nucleic Acids Res. 2014;42(Database - issue):D980-5. doi: 10.1093/nar/gkt1113 24234437\nKuenzi - BM, Park - J, Fong - SH, Sanchez - KS, Lee - J, Kreisberg - JF, et al. Predicting - Drug Response and Synergy Using a Deep Learning Model of Human Cancer Cells. - Cancer Cell. 2020;38(5):672-684.e6. - doi: 10.1016/j.ccell.2020.09.014 33096023\nMurakami - H, Mizuno - T, Taniguchi - T, Fujii - M, Ishiguro - F, Fukui - T, et al. LATS2 - is a tumor suppressor gene of malignant mesothelioma. Cancer - Res. 2011;71(3):873\u201383. - doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-10-2164 21245096\nStrazisar - M, Mlakar - V, Glavac - D. LATS2 tumour specific - mutations and down-regulation of the gene in non-small cell carcinoma. - Lung Cancer. 2009;64(3):257\u201362. - doi: 10.1016/j.lungcan.2008.09.011 19008013\nZimmerman - SM, Lin - PN, Souroullas - GP. Non-canonical functions - of EZH2 in cancer. Front Oncol. 2023;13:1233953. - doi: 10.3389/fonc.2023.1233953 37664059\nSasaki - H, Suzuki - A, Shitara - M, Okuda - K, Hikosaka - Y, Moriyama - S, et al. Keap1 - mutations in lung cancer patients. Oncol Lett. - 2013;6(3):719\u201321. - doi: 10.3892/ol.2013.1427 24137397\nAl-Masri - M, Al-Shobaki - T, Al-Najjar - H, Iskanderian - R, Younis - E, Abdallah - N, et al. BRAF - V600E mutation in papillary thyroid carcinoma: it\u2019s relation to clinical - features and oncologic outcomes in a single cancer centre experience. - Endocr Connect. 2021;10(12):1531\u20137. - doi: 10.1530/EC-21-0410 34734568\nLee - K-H, Hwang - H-J, Noh - HJ, Shin - T-J, Cho - J-Y. Somatic Mutation of - PIK3CA (H1047R) Is a Common Driver Mutation Hotspot in Canine Mammary Tumors - as Well as Human Breast Cancers. Cancers (Basel). - 2019;11(12):2006. - doi: 10.3390/cancers11122006 31842489\nVander - Heiden MG, DeBerardinis - RJ. Understanding the Intersections - between Metabolism and Cancer Biology. Cell. - 2017;168(4):657\u201369. - doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2016.12.039 28187287\nRho - O, Kim - DJ, Kiguchi - K, Digiovanni - J. Growth factor signaling - pathways as targets for prevention of epithelial carcinogenesis. - Mol Carcinog. 2011;50(4):264\u201379. - doi: 10.1002/mc.20665 20648549\nLemmon - MA, Schlessinger - J. Cell signaling by receptor - tyrosine kinases. Cell. 2010;141(7):1117\u201334. - doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2010.06.011 20602996\nYarden - Y, Pines - G. The ERBB network: at last, - cancer therapy meets systems biology. Nat Rev Cancer. - 2012;12(8):553\u201363. - doi: 10.1038/nrc3309 22785351\nGrivennikov - SI, Greten - FR, Karin - M. Immunity, inflammation, - and cancer. Cell. 2010;140(6):883\u201399. - doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2010.01.025 20303878\nMantovani - A, Allavena - P, Sica - A, Balkwill - F. Cancer-related inflammation. - Nature. 2008;454(7203):436\u201344. - doi: 10.1038/nature07205 18650914\nKumari - N, Dwarakanath - BS, Das - A, Bhatt - AN. Role of interleukin-6 - in cancer progression and therapeutic resistance. Tumour - Biol. 2016;37(9):11553\u201372. - doi: 10.1007/s13277-016-5098-7 27260630\nYin - Q, Chen - L. CellTICS: an explainable - neural network for cell-type identification and interpretation based on single-cell - RNA-seq data. Brief Bioinform. 2023;25(1):bbad449. - doi: 10.1093/bib/bbad449 38061196\nRubner Y, Tomasi C, Guibas - LJ. A metric for distributions with applications to image databases. In: Sixth - International Conference on Computer Vision (IEEE Cat. No.98CH36271). 59\u201366. - https://doi.org/10.1109/iccv.1998.710701\nRutkowski - MJ, Sughrue - ME, Kane - AJ, Mills - SA, Parsa - AT. Cancer and the complement - cascade. Mol Cancer Res. 2010;8(11):1453\u201365. - doi: 10.1158/1541-7786.MCR-10-0225 20870736\nAlbini - A, Di - Paola L, Mei - G, Baci - D, Fusco - N, Corso - G, et al. Inflammation - and cancer cell survival: TRAF2 as a key player. Cell - Death Dis. 2025;16(1):292. - doi: 10.1038/s41419-025-07609-w 40229245\nCai - Z, Zhai - X, Xu - J, Hong - T, Yang - K, Min - S, et al. ELAVL1 - regulates PD-L1 mRNA stability to disrupt the infiltration of CD4-positive - T cells in prostate cancer. Neoplasia. 2024;57:101049. - doi: 10.1016/j.neo.2024.101049 39265220\nTanaka - H, Matsushima - H, Nishibu - A, Clausen - BE, Takashima - A. Dual therapeutic efficacy - of vinblastine as a unique chemotherapeutic agent capable of inducing dendritic - cell maturation. Cancer Res. 2009;69(17):6987\u201394. - doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-09-1106 19706755\nLi - Y, Umbach - DM, Krahn - JM, Shats - I, Li - X, Li - L. Predicting tumor response - to drugs based on gene-expression biomarkers of sensitivity learned from cancer - cell lines. BMC Genomics. 2021;22(1):272. - doi: 10.1186/s12864-021-07581-7 33858332\nRampoldi - F, Bonrouhi - M, Boehm - ME, Lehmann - WD, Popovic - ZV, Kaden - S, et al. Immunosuppression - and Aberrant T Cell Development in the Absence of N-Myristoylation. - J Immunol. 2015;195(9):4228\u201343. - doi: 10.4049/jimmunol.1500622 26423150\nAlblihy - A, Ali - R, Algethami - M, Shoqafi - A, Toss - MS, Brownlie - J, et al. Targeting - Mre11 overcomes platinum resistance and induces synthetic lethality in XRCC1 - deficient epithelial ovarian cancers. NPJ Precis Oncol. - 2022;6(1):51. - doi: 10.1038/s41698-022-00298-0 35853939\nLi - Z, Fan - Y, Ma - Y, Meng - N, Li - D, Wang - D, et al. Identification - of Crucial Genes and Signaling Pathways in Alectinib-Resistant Lung Adenocarcinoma - Using Bioinformatic Analysis. Mol Biotechnol. - 2024;66(12):3655\u201373. - doi: 10.1007/s12033-023-00973-y 38142454\nTsherniak - A, Vazquez - F, Montgomery - PG, Weir - BA, Kryukov - G, Cowley - GS, et al. Defining - a Cancer Dependency Map. Cell. 2017;170(3):564-576.e16. - doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2017.06.010 28753430\nBehan - FM, Iorio - F, Picco - G, Gon\xE7alves - E, Beaver - CM, Migliardi - G, et al. Prioritization - of cancer therapeutic targets using CRISPR-Cas9 screens. Nature. - 2019;568(7753):511\u20136. - doi: 10.1038/s41586-019-1103-9 30971826\nBarretina - J, Caponigro - G, Stransky - N, Venkatesan - K, Margolin - AA, Kim - S, et al. The - Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia enables predictive modelling of anticancer drug - sensitivity. Nature. 2012;483(7391):603\u20137. - doi: 10.1038/nature11003 22460905\nGhandi - M, Huang - FW, Jan\xE9-Valbuena - J, Kryukov - GV, Lo - CC, McDonald - ER 3rd, et al. Next-generation - characterization of the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia. Nature. - 2019;569(7757):503\u20138. - doi: 10.1038/s41586-019-1186-3 31068700\nIorio - F, Knijnenburg - TA, Vis - DJ, Bignell - GR, Menden - MP, Schubert - M, et al. A - Landscape of Pharmacogenomic Interactions in Cancer. Cell. - 2016;166(3):740\u201354. - doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2016.06.017 27397505\nVis - DJ, Bombardelli - L, Lightfoot - H, Iorio - F, Garnett - MJ, Wessels - LF. Multilevel models improve - precision and speed of IC50 estimates. Pharmacogenomics. - 2016;17(7):691\u2013700. - doi: 10.2217/pgs.16.15 27180993\nRitz - C, Baty - F, Streibig - JC, Gerhard - D. Dose-Response Analysis - Using R. PLoS One. 2015;10(12):e0146021. - doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0146021\nHarrison - PW, Amode - MR, Austine-Orimoloye - O, Azov - AG, Barba - M, Barnes - I, et al. Ensembl - 2024. Nucleic Acids Res. 2024;52(D1):D891\u20139. - doi: 10.1093/nar/gkac1000\nDennis - G, Sherman - BT, Hosack - DA, Yang - J, Gao - W, Lane - HC. DAVID: Database for Annotation, - Visualization, and Integrated Discovery. Genome Biol. - 2003;4(5):P3.\nBinder A, Montavon G, Lapuschkin S, M\xFCller KR, Samek - W. Layer-wise relevance propagation for neural networks with local renormalization - layers. In: 2016.\n\n
                                \n
                                " - headers: - Accept-Ranges: - - bytes - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - private, max-age=0 - Content-Disposition: - - attachment; filename=journal.pcbi.1014869.xml - Content-Length: - - '184995' - Content-Type: - - application/xml - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT - ETag: - - '"588c4afdf870c42bc95bce71802ac441"' - Expires: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:56 GMT - Last-Modified: - - Tue, 13 Oct 2026 17:45:49 GMT - Server: - - UploadServer - X-GUploader-UploadID: - - AP6rU83EzS1I3zHTG8frXB_JV94Fp09XGDqfbGbw72Bu83UlLJ_hQ5u-kepw82b_T1J0AZKinTs8UYvh46YecA - x-goog-generation: - - '1791913549093855' - x-goog-hash: - - crc32c=LQNGlA== - - md5=WIxK/fhwxCvJW85xgCrEQQ== - x-goog-metageneration: - - '1' - x-goog-storage-class: - - STANDARD - x-goog-stored-content-encoding: - - identity - x-goog-stored-content-length: - - '184995' - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml deleted file mode 100644 index 10c8ec3..0000000 --- a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript[plos-one].yaml +++ /dev/null @@ -1,880 +0,0 @@ -interactions: -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?cmd=prlinks&dbfrom=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: '{"header":{"type":"elink","version":"0.3"},"linksets":[{"dbfrom":"pubmed","idurllist":[{"id":"42868208","objurls":[],"info":"No - LinkOut links available for UID: 42868208"}]}]} - - ' - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Alt-Svc: - - clear - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:54 GMT - Ncbi-Phid: - - 1D3407F95CD407A500002BEFC1B73A6C.1.1.m_1 - Ncbi-Sid: - - A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 - Oct 2027 12:57:54 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Ratelimit-Limit: - - '10' - X-Ratelimit-Remaining: - - '8' - X-Ua-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-Xss-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-length: - - '176' - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like - Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=42868208&retmode=json - response: - body: - string: "{\"header\":{\"type\":\"esummary\",\"version\":\"0.3\"},\"result\":{\"uids\":[\"42868208\"],\"42868208\":{\"uid\":\"42868208\",\"pubdate\":\"2026\",\"epubdate\":\"2026 - Oct 13\",\"source\":\"PLoS One\",\"authors\":[{\"name\":\"Urra-Barra G\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Acevedo - G\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Leighton-Vallejos - E\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"Ruiz-Gonz\xE1lez - V\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"},{\"name\":\"D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez - C\",\"authtype\":\"Author\",\"clusterid\":\"\"}],\"lastauthor\":\"D\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez - C\",\"title\":\"Practice-based initial teacher education in alternative teaching - certification programs: A scoping review protocol.\",\"sorttitle\":\"practice - based initial teacher education in alternative teaching certification programs - a scoping review protocol\",\"volume\":\"21\",\"issue\":\"10\",\"pages\":\"e0360047\",\"lang\":[\"eng\"],\"nlmuniqueid\":\"101285081\",\"issn\":\"\",\"essn\":\"1932-6203\",\"pubtype\":[\"Journal - Article\"],\"recordstatus\":\"PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE\",\"pubstatus\":\"258\",\"articleids\":[{\"idtype\":\"pubmed\",\"idtypen\":1,\"value\":\"42868208\"},{\"idtype\":\"doi\",\"idtypen\":3,\"value\":\"10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\"},{\"idtype\":\"pii\",\"idtypen\":4,\"value\":\"PONE-D-26-12708\"},{\"idtype\":\"pmc\",\"idtypen\":8,\"value\":\"PMC13660980\"},{\"idtype\":\"pmcid\",\"idtypen\":5,\"value\":\"pmc-id: - PMC13660980;\"}],\"history\":[{\"pubstatus\":\"received\",\"date\":\"2026/04/29 - 00:00\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"accepted\",\"date\":\"2026/09/21 00:00\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"medline\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 - 23:37\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"pubmed\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 23:36\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"entrez\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 - 18:14\"},{\"pubstatus\":\"pmc-release\",\"date\":\"2026/10/13 00:00\"}],\"references\":[],\"attributes\":[\"Has - Abstract\"],\"pmcrefcount\":20,\"fulljournalname\":\"PloS one\",\"elocationid\":\"doi: - 10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\",\"doctype\":\"citation\",\"srccontriblist\":[],\"booktitle\":\"\",\"medium\":\"\",\"edition\":\"\",\"publisherlocation\":\"\",\"publishername\":\"\",\"srcdate\":\"\",\"reportnumber\":\"\",\"availablefromurl\":\"\",\"locationlabel\":\"\",\"doccontriblist\":[],\"docdate\":\"\",\"bookname\":\"\",\"chapter\":\"\",\"sortpubdate\":\"2026/10/13 - 00:00\",\"sortfirstauthor\":\"Urra-Barra G\",\"vernaculartitle\":\"\"}}}\n" - headers: - Access-Control-Allow-Origin: - - '*' - Access-Control-Expose-Headers: - - X-RateLimit-Limit,X-RateLimit-Remaining - Alt-Svc: - - clear - Cache-Control: - - private - Content-Security-Policy: - - upgrade-insecure-requests - Content-Type: - - application/json; charset=UTF-8 - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:54 GMT - Ncbi-Phid: - - 1D322F91B7495C35000038E45B96D6E8.1.1.m_1 - Ncbi-Sid: - - A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID - Referrer-Policy: - - origin-when-cross-origin - Server: - - Finatra - Set-Cookie: - - ncbi_sid=A30F269E0869977C_2E6DSID; domain=.nih.gov; path=/; expires=Thu, 14 - Oct 2027 12:57:55 GMT - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload - Transfer-Encoding: - - chunked - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Ratelimit-Limit: - - '10' - X-Ratelimit-Remaining: - - '7' - X-Ua-Compatible: - - IE=Edge - X-Xss-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - content-length: - - '2087' - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0360047&type=manuscript - response: - body: - string: '' - headers: - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - max-age=3600 - Content-Length: - - '0' - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT - Location: - - https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047/1/pone.0360047.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T065306Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host&X-Goog-Signature=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 - Server: - - Apache - Set-Cookie: - - GCLB=CPvL-qzrgcfdexAD; path=/; HttpOnly - Strict-Transport-Security: - - max-age=31536000 - - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains - Via: - - 1.1 google - X-Content-Type-Options: - - nosniff - X-Frame-Options: - - DENY - X-XSS-Protection: - - 1; mode=block - status: - code: 302 - message: Found -- request: - body: null - headers: - Accept: - - '*/*' - Accept-Encoding: - - gzip, deflate - Connection: - - keep-alive - User-Agent: - - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.6312.86 - Safari/537.36 - method: GET - uri: https://storage.googleapis.com/plos-corpus-prod/10.1371/journal.pone.0360047/1/pone.0360047.xml?X-Goog-Algorithm=GOOG4-RSA-SHA256&X-Goog-Credential=wombat-sa%40plos-prod.iam.gserviceaccount.com%2F20261014%2Fauto%2Fstorage%2Fgoog4_request&X-Goog-Date=20261014T065306Z&X-Goog-Expires=86400&X-Goog-Signature=4e17444ef0c430a33abad3ac0210332144f05c9e715bbdadbac1c4fbae7db1254b823054dafdee078e991739d067803b6e20735c2a16f686b3b5f6c8a931f3bb69193d3b66d3eeaa7328686638c6f757b764c824573d52fd7629c8fa99c78df9aec1c8c25dea19865986e7421962b08d900ae2f6d4d282b8f928562a13eeec39d721bcef07b943139ef4e14361b85b1791e29d260bf7ac38b769ca7451482775842aea6e206d772c1edbb6a224f07ca2f5f032bc05f808cdd4faaff80dc024cb8e63714c3fec49218e86d28df11f50ed70dfe3795a3ecb9c3830dd7a85aeb7b6a87da7ab5cc953f96d7905a4f9f40056d462af846bf641cda9a19a41720b8c95&X-Goog-SignedHeaders=host - response: - body: - string: "\n\n
                                \n\n\n\nComposition - Vendor\nNewgen KnowledgeWorks (P) Ltd.\n\n\n\n\n\nPLoS One\nplos\nplosone\n\nPLOS - One\n\n1932-6203\n\nPublic - Library of Science\nSan Francisco, CA USA\n\n\n\n10.1371/journal.pone.0360047\nPONE-D-26-12708\n\n\nStudy Protocol\n\n\nPeople and placesPopulation - groupingsProfessionsTeachers\nResearch and analysis methodsDatabase - and informatics methodsDatabase searching\nBiology and life sciencesNeuroscienceCognitive - scienceCognitive psychologyLearningHuman - learning\nBiology and life sciencesPsychologyCognitive - psychologyLearningHuman - learning\nSocial sciencesPsychologyCognitive - psychologyLearningHuman - learning\nBiology and life sciencesNeuroscienceLearning - and memoryLearningHuman - learning\nResearch and analysis methodsResearch - design\nSocial - sciencesSociologyEducation\nBiology and life sciencesNeuroscienceCognitive - scienceCognitive psychologyLanguage\nBiology and life sciencesPsychologyCognitive - psychologyLanguage\nSocial sciencesPsychologyCognitive - psychologyLanguage\nSocial sciencesPolitical - scienceUnited Nations\nResearch and analysis methodsResearch - assessmentSystematic reviews\n\nPractice-based - initial teacher education in alternative teaching certification programs: - A scoping review protocol\nPractice-based - teacher education in alternative certification programs: Scoping review protoco\n\n\n\n\nUrra-Barra\nGerardo\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting - \u2013 original draft\nWriting - \u2013 review & editing\n\n\nhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-8100-6663\n\nAcevedo\nGraciela\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting - \u2013 original draft\nWriting - \u2013 review & editing\n*\n\n\n\nLeighton-Vallejos\nErich\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting - \u2013 original draft\nWriting - \u2013 review & editing\n\n\n\nRuiz-Gonz\xE1lez\nV\xEDctor\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting - \u2013 original draft\nWriting - \u2013 review & editing\n\n\n\nD\xEDaz-Ib\xE1\xF1ez\nCamila\n\nConceptualization\nMethodology\nWriting - \u2013 original draft\nWriting - \u2013 review & editing\n\n\nFacultad - de Educaci\xF3n, Universidad San Sebasti\xE1n, - Chile\n\n\n\nBaker\nRogis\n\nEditor\n\n\nUniversiti Pertahanan Nasional Malaysia, - MALAYSIA\n\n* E-mail: Graciela.acevedo@uss.cl\n\n

                                The authors have declared that no - competing interests exist.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n13102026\n2026\n21\n10\ne0360047\n\n2942026\n2192026\n\n\n2026\nUrra-Barra - et al\n\nThis is an open access article distributed - under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which - permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided - the original author and source are credited.\n\n\n\n

                                Given - the shortage of specialized teachers, Initial Teacher Education requires alternative - teacher preparation routes, such as Alternative Teaching Certification Programs, - that allow the incorporation of professionals who already possess prior work - experience into the educational system. However, this situation raises new - challenges regarding the design and implementation of the teacher preparation - model within these programs. Consequently, this study aims to map and synthesize - the existing evidence on the characteristics of practice-based teacher education - (PBTE) programs, understood as an approach in which professional learning - is constructed through authentic, situated teaching experiences rather than - primarily theoretical instruction, designed for individuals who already hold - technical, bachelor\u2019s, or professional degrees. The review will be conducted - following the JBI (Joanna Briggs Institute) methodology for scoping reviews, - and will be reported in accordance with PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Data extraction - and synthesis will be structured around the JBI Participants, Concept, and - Context (PCC) analytical framework. Database searches will be conducted in - Web of Science (WoS) and Scopus, including studies published between 2009 - and 2025 in English, Spanish, and Portuguese. The review will specifically - examine program duration, mentoring structures, practicum design, institutional - type, teaching strategies, and reported outcomes. This protocol has been registered - in the Open Science Framework (OSF) and will be publicly available once approved.

                                \n
                                \n\nThis - study was supported by Vicerrector\xEDa Acad\xE9mica and Centro de Investigaci\xF3n - para la Educaci\xF3n Superior \u2013 Fondo USS-FIN-2026_APC_VRA-013.\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nData Availability\nNo - datasets were generated or analysed during the current study. All relevant - data from this study will be made available upon study completion.\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n\nIntroduction\n

                                Initial - Teacher Education (ITE; in Spanish, Formaci\xF3n Inicial Docente, - FID) is understood as a systematic and structured process aimed at developing - the professional competencies required for teaching across the different levels - of the educational system [1,2].

                                \n

                                At a global - level, the United Nations estimate that approximately 44 million new teachers - will be needed by 2030 in order to respond to the growing educational demand - [3]. This shortage - poses concrete demands on teacher preparation systems, which must not only - increase enrollment, but also guarantee training that is both high in quality - and relevant to current teaching practice.

                                \n

                                In this context, alternative - teaching certification programs have emerged as a relevant alternative within - the Chilean tertiary education system. For the purposes of this review, Alternative - Teaching Certification Programs (ATCPs) are defined as initial teacher education - pathways designed for individuals who already hold a prior technical, professional, - or academic qualification, offering an abbreviated or alternative route to - a teaching credential that recognizes prior learning and work experience [4]. These programs connect - prior learning experiences with the completion of a bachelor\u2019s degree - in education and a specific disciplinary teaching certification. The National - Accreditation Commission (CNA; in Spanish: [5] - defines these programs as designed, formalized, and implemented with the purpose - of offering study continuity to individuals who already hold a prior professional - or technical degree or an academic qualification, recognizing work experience - and knowledge acquired within the school system. Notwithstanding, their growth - also raises challenges regarding the program\u2019s quality assurance, particularly - under current regulations, in which accreditation is required to enroll new - students.

                                \n

                                In response to these challenges, it becomes necessary to - reconsider the teacher preparation models offered to pre-service teachers. - Within this scenario, the international approach of Practice-Based Teacher - Education (PBTE) has gained relevance. PBTE argues that professional learning - should be constructed through authentic teaching experiences that integrate - pedagogical theory, disciplinary knowledge, and situated action in the classroom - [6,7]. This approach implies a substantial - transformation in the design of ITE (FID) programs, particularly in relation - to mentoring practices and the articulation between universities and schools. - Unlike models focused primarily on theoretical or didactic preparation, PBTE - promotes the active participation of pre-service teachers in simulated teaching, - analysis of real classroom practices, guided mentorship, and systematic processes - of critical reflection [8,9]. Its implementation - becomes especially relevant in alternative teaching certification programs, - where candidates bring prior educational and/or work experiences that require - pedagogical proposals capable of recognizing and articulating those forms - of knowledge with concrete opportunities for situated and contextualized professional - development. While PBTE is associated with stronger practical readiness and - greater coherence between theory and classroom action, the literature also - identifies persistent tensions regarding the risk of reducing the theoretical - and disciplinary foundations of teacher preparation, the resource demands - of high-quality mentorship, and the variability in how authentic practice - is operationalized across programs and institutional contexts.

                                \n

                                Despite - its expansion, the ways in which this approach is implemented to guide pedagogical - processes in teacher education programs vary significantly across countries, - institutions, and levels of development of teacher preparation systems [10\u201313]. These experiences illustrate that - PBTE is being adopted and adapted through diverse methodological approaches, - without yet converging on shared definitions, common program structures, or - agreed criteria for what constitutes a practice-based component in teacher - preparation. This conceptual and empirical heterogeneity signals a field that - is still under development, for which a scoping review is the most appropriate - first synthesis step rather than a systematic effectiveness review.

                                \n

                                Given - the diversity of frameworks, designs, and contexts involved, a scoping review - was considered the most appropriate methodological approach. Unlike systematic - reviews focused on effectiveness, scoping reviews allow researchers to explore - the range, nature, and characteristics of a broad body of literature, map - emergent categories, and synthesize key concepts [14,15]. - This approach is particularly pertinent when the field of study is under development, - as is the case of PBTE, and when a structured overview of the available knowledge - is required.

                                \n

                                For this reason, the purpose of this scoping review is - to map the available literature on PBTE, identifying its main characteristics - in terms of program duration, mentoring structures, practicum design, and - institutional type, as well as pedagogical strategies and reported outcomes, - in the context of alternative teaching certification programs that enable - professionals with prior educational experiences and certifications to obtain - a teaching degree.

                                \n\nResearch question\n

                                What - evidence does the literature report regarding the design, implementation, - and outcomes of practice-based initial teacher education programs for individuals - with existing degrees, including post-baccalaureate, alternative, and consecutive - routes?

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nMethods\n

                                The - proposed scoping review will be conducted in accordance with the Joanna Briggs - Institute (JBI) methodology for scoping reviews, as outlined in the JBI Manual - for Evidence Synthesis [14], - and following the PRISMA-ScR recommendations [16]. - The protocol has been registered in the Open Science Framework (OSF) under - the registration number 10.17605/OSF.IO/UTR6V, ensuring transparency - and traceability throughout the process.

                                \n\nInclusion - criteria\n

                                Participants: Studies involving both teacher candidates - and teacher educators participating in programs explicitly defined by their - authors as alternative teaching certification programs, and that are directed - at students or professionals who hold a prior academic or professional qualification - (e.g., bachelor\u2019s degree, tertiary technical degree, or professional - title) will be included. Studies reporting only on traditional initial teacher - education programs (i.e., those involving teacher candidates without such - prior qualifications) will be excluded.

                                \n

                                Concept: Studies examining - initial teacher education programs that implement a practice-based teacher - education (PBTE) approach will be considered. PBTE is characterized by the - structured and systematic integration of authentic teaching experiences as - the core element of teacher professional learning. Such experiences include, - among others, simulated lessons, analysis of real classroom practice, reflective - practice, and guided mentorship provided by experienced educators [6,17]. - For the purposes of this review, a program will be considered PBTE-aligned - if it explicitly incorporates at least one of the three processes described - by Grossman et al. [8]: - representation of practice, decomposition of practice, or approximation to - practice, implemented in a structured and recurring manner within the program - design. No restrictions will be placed regarding the length of the program, - disciplinary area, intended education level, or any other characteristics - of the program or its participants. The language of program implementation - is not a restriction; however, publications reporting on the program must - be written in English, Spanish, or Portuguese, as these are the languages - the research team can assess.

                                \n

                                Context: Studies conducted in practice-based - initial teacher education programs directed at individuals with prior academic - or professional qualifications (post-baccalaureate/alternative/consecutive - routes) and delivered by higher education institutions worldwide will be included.

                                \n
                                \n\nTypes of sources\n

                                This scoping review will - consider studies adopting experimental and quasi-experimental designs. Likewise, - analytical observational studies including prospective and retrospective cohort - studies, case-control studies, and analytical cross-sectional studies will - be included. Descriptive observational designs such as case series, single - case reports, and descriptive cross-sectional studies will be considered.

                                \n

                                Additionally, - qualitative studies informed by approaches such as phenomenology, grounded - theory, ethnography, qualitative description, and action research will be - included. Opinion pieces and reflective articles relevant to the object of - study and meeting the inclusion criteria will also be considered. Opinion - and reflective articles are included because PBTE within alternative teaching - certification programs is an emerging area in which much of the available - knowledge is still expressed through expert commentary and practitioner reflection - rather than empirical studies. During data charting, these sources will be - flagged by type and synthesized separately from empirical studies in the narrative - synthesis.

                                \n
                                \n\nSearch strategy\n

                                Systematic - database searches will be conducted in Web of Science Core Collection and - Scopus. These two databases were selected because they offer the broadest - interdisciplinary coverage of peer-reviewed literature in education and social - sciences, support advanced Boolean search logic, and together index the large - majority of high-impact journals in teacher education research [18,19]. - The search strings were structured in three thematic blocks: Block A covers - PBTE terminology, Block B covers initial teacher education, and Block C covers - alternative certification programs. The three blocks are crossed using the - AND operator. No language restriction is applied at the level of program implementation; - studies are limited to those published in English, Spanish, or Portuguese, - reflecting the linguistic competencies of the research team. Studies published - between 2009 and 2025 will be included, as this period corresponds to the - emergence and consolidation of practice-based approaches in teacher education, - particularly with the development of models such as practice-based teacher - education and the consolidation of concepts such as core practices and high-leverage - practices [7,8]. The complete Boolean - search strategies for both databases are presented in Table 1 (Web of Science) and Table 2 (Scopus).

                                \n10.1371/journal.pone.0360047.t001Web of Science Core Collection search strategy (TS\u2009=\u2009Topic - field).\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                #Search query
                                1TS=(\u201Cpractice-based teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cpractice-based - teacher preparation\u201D)
                                2TS=(\u201Ccore practices\u201D OR \u201Chigh-leverage practices\u201D - OR \u201Chigh leverage practices\u201D)
                                3TS=(\u201Cpedagogies of enactment\u201D OR \u201Capproximations - of practice\u201D OR \u201Cdecompositions of practice\u201D)
                                4TS=(practicum OR \u201Cfield experience\u201D - OR \u201Cclinical experience\u201D OR \u201Cmentored teaching\u201D OR \u201Cguided - mentorship\u201D)
                                5#1 - OR #2 OR #3 OR #4 [Block A \u2014 PBTE]
                                6TS=(\u201Cinitial teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cteacher - preparation\u201D OR \u201Cteacher training\u201D OR \u201Cpreservice teacher\u201D - OR \u201Cpre-service teacher\u201D)
                                7TS=(\u201Cstudent teacher\u201D OR \u201Cteacher candidate\u201D - OR \u201Cprospective teacher\u201D OR \u201Cteacher educator\u201D)
                                8#6 OR #7 [Block B \u2014 ITE]
                                9TS=(\u201Calternative certification\u201D - OR \u201Calternative licensure\u201D OR \u201Calternative route\u201D OR \u201Calternative - teacher certification\u201D)
                                10TS=(\u201Cpost-baccalaureate\u201D OR postbaccalaureate OR - \u201Cconsecutive teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cconsecutive route\u201D)
                                11TS=(\u201Ccareer changer\u201D - OR \u201Csecond-career teacher\u201D OR \u201Ctransition-to-teaching\u201D)
                                12#9 OR #10 OR #11 [Block C \u2014 - ATCP]
                                13#5 - AND #8 AND #12 [Final intersection]
                                14#13 AND Publication Years: 2009\u20132025
                                \n
                                \n

                                Source: Prepared by the authors.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n10.1371/journal.pone.0360047.t002Scopus search strategy (TITLE-ABS-KEY field).\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                #Search query
                                1TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cpractice-based teacher education\u201D - OR \u201Cpractice-based teacher preparation\u201D)
                                2TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Ccore practices\u201D - OR \u201Chigh-leverage practices\u201D OR \u201Chigh leverage practices\u201D)
                                3TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cpedagogies of - enactment\u201D OR \u201Capproximations of practice\u201D OR \u201Cdecompositions - of practice\u201D)
                                4TITLE-ABS-KEY(practicum - OR \u201Cfield experience\u201D OR \u201Cclinical experience\u201D OR \u201Cmentored - teaching\u201D OR \u201Cguided mentorship\u201D)
                                5#1 OR #2 OR #3 OR #4 [Block A \u2014 PBTE]
                                6TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cinitial teacher - education\u201D OR \u201Cteacher preparation\u201D OR \u201Cteacher training\u201D - OR \u201Cpreservice teacher\u201D OR \u201Cpre-service teacher\u201D)
                                7TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cstudent teacher\u201D - OR \u201Cteacher candidate\u201D OR \u201Cprospective teacher\u201D OR \u201Cteacher - educator\u201D)
                                8#6 - OR #7 [Block B \u2014 ITE]
                                9TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Calternative certification\u201D OR \u201Calternative - licensure\u201D OR \u201Calternative route\u201D OR \u201Calternative teacher - certification\u201D)
                                10TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Cpost-baccalaureate\u201D - OR postbaccalaureate OR \u201Cconsecutive teacher education\u201D OR \u201Cconsecutive - route\u201D)
                                11TITLE-ABS-KEY(\u201Ccareer - changer\u201D OR \u201Csecond-career teacher\u201D OR \u201Ctransition-to-teaching\u201D)
                                12#9 OR #10 OR #11 [Block C \u2014 - ATCP]
                                13#5 - AND #8 AND #12 [Final intersection]
                                14#13 AND PUBYEAR\u2009>\u20092008 AND PUBYEAR\u2009<\u20092026
                                \n
                                \n

                                Source: Prepared by the authors.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\nSelection of studies and sources of evidence\n

                                All - citations will be imported into Rayyan, a systematic screening tool, and duplicates - will be removed automatically. Prior to full-scale screening, a pilot test - will be conducted with four articles selected purposively from the initial - search results to represent a range of study designs and geographic contexts. - The pilot aims to confirm inter-rater agreement on the application of the - eligibility criteria and to identify any ambiguity in their wording. An agreement - rate below 75% on the pilot set will trigger a joint discussion between reviewers - and, if necessary, a revision of the inclusion and exclusion criteria before - full screening proceeds. It is acknowledged that four articles constitute - a limited pilot sample given the conceptual complexity of PBTE; the research - team will therefore remain attentive to recurring disagreements during the - early stages of full screening as an informal extension of the pilot phase. - After the pilot, titles and abstracts will be assessed independently by at - least two reviewers. References that meet the inclusion criteria will proceed - to full-text assessment, which will also be conducted independently by two - reviewers. Any discrepancies will be resolved by consensus or by involving - a third reviewer.

                                \n

                                The complete study selection process will be reported - in the final review using a PRISMA-ScR flow diagram for scoping reviews [20].

                                \n
                                \n\nData extraction\n

                                Data will be extracted - independently by two or more reviewers using a data extraction tool specifically - designed by the research team for this review. This tool will include structured - fields aligned with the PCC framework (Participants, Concept, and Context). - Furthermore, this tool will also include additional variables concerning methodological - designs, program implementation characteristics, and the main findings reported - in each study. This strategy will ensure a systematic, rigorous, and coherent - data collection process aligned with the objectives of the scoping review.

                                \n

                                The - data extraction form will be piloted with an initial sample of included studies - to assess its relevance, clarity, and alignment with the review objectives. - Based on the pilot, the research team will refine the form as necessary before - proceeding with full data extraction. Any modifications made to the extraction - tool during the review process will be documented and justified in the final - review to ensure transparency and reproducibility.

                                \n

                                In cases where - relevant information is not available in the full text of a study, corresponding - authors will be contacted to request missing data or necessary clarifications. - If no response is received within two weeks, a reminder will be sent. If the - information remains unavailable after a further two weeks, the missing data - will be coded as not reported. If the search yields fewer studies than anticipated, - the research team will broaden the search terms and extend manual reference - list screening before concluding that the evidence base is genuinely limited. - If a database becomes temporarily inaccessible during the search window, the - search for that database will be repeated when access is restored and the - execution date will be documented in the PRISMA-ScR flow diagram.

                                \n
                                \n\nData analysis and presentation\n

                                The results - will be presented descriptively and narratively, organized around the components - of the PCC framework and directly addressing the objectives and central research - question of the review. Accordingly, different formats will be used to enhance - the visualization and understanding of the findings.

                                \n

                                First, the results - will be organized into tables that will map key characteristics of the included - studies, such as country of origin, type of program, participant population, - type of institution, methodological approach, implemented practice-based components, - and main findings. These tables will provide an overview of how practice-based - teacher education has been addressed in programs aimed at individuals with - prior technical, academic, or professional qualifications.

                                \n

                                Second, - graphical representations and thematic maps will be used to identify patterns, - knowledge gaps, and geographical or institutional concentrations within the - available evidence. These visualizations will support the identification of - emerging areas, recurrent practices, and potential gaps in the implementation - of the PBTE approach across specific contexts.

                                \n

                                In addition, a narrative - synthesis will be conducted to interpret the findings in relation to the PCC - framework. Themes will be identified using a primarily deductive approach - structured around the dimensions stated in the research objective, specifically - program duration, mentoring structures, practicum design, and institutional - type, while remaining open to inductively coding patterns that emerge from - the data and do not fit these predefined categories. Two reviewers will independently - group the extracted data into preliminary themes. Discrepancies in theme labeling - or grouping will be resolved by discussion and, where necessary, by a third - reviewer.

                                \n

                                Finally, in accordance with the purposes of a scoping review, - no critical appraisal of methodological quality will be conducted for the - included studies. However, when appropriate, comments will be made regarding - the diversity of designs and methodologies used, with the aim of informing - future systematic or empirical research.

                                \n
                                \n\nSignificance\n

                                At - the national level, this review responds directly to the expansion of alternative - teaching certification programs in Chile under accreditation requirements - that currently lack an evidence base on how practice-based components should - be designed and implemented. Mapping international evidence on PBTE can therefore - inform program design and quality assurance criteria in this specific context. - At the global level, given the United Nations projection of approximately - 44 million additional teachers needed by 2030 [3], - alternative certification routes are expanding as a workforce strategy across - multiple countries. This review contributes by synthesizing, for the first - time, evidence on how practice-based approaches have been conceptualized and - implemented specifically within this type of program, supporting future systematic - reviews and informing policy decisions in national systems facing comparable - teacher shortage pressures.

                                \n
                                \n\nLimitations\n

                                This - protocol presents several anticipated limitations. First, restricting the - systematic database search to Web of Science and Scopus, while justified by - their interdisciplinary coverage and advanced Boolean search capabilities, - means that studies indexed exclusively in discipline-specific or regional - databases may not be captured. Second, the pilot test involves only four articles, - which is a modest sample given the conceptual complexity of PBTE; this is - acknowledged and partially mitigated by the informal extension of the pilot - phase during early full-text screening. Third, the inclusion of opinion and - reflective articles alongside empirical studies introduces heterogeneity in - the strength of evidence synthesized; this is addressed by analyzing and reporting - these source types separately in the narrative synthesis. Fourth, consistent - with standard scoping review methodology, no formal quality appraisal of included - studies will be conducted; the review will therefore map the breadth of available - evidence rather than evaluate its methodological robustness. Fifth, while - the regulatory context of Chilean alternative teaching certification programs - motivates this study, the global scope of the review means that findings will - need to be interpreted in light of each country\u2019s specific institutional - and regulatory conditions.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n

                                This - study was supported by Vicerrector\xEDa Acad\xE9mica and Centro de Investigaci\xF3n - para la Educaci\xF3n Superior \u2013 Fondo USS-FIN-2026_APC_VRA-013.

                                \n
                                \n\nReferences\nCornejo - J, Fuentealba - R. Pr\xE1cticas reflexivas para - la formaci\xF3n profesional docente: \xBFqu\xE9 las hace eficaces? - Santiago: Ediciones Universidad - Cat\xF3lica Silva Henr\xEDquez; 2008.\n\xC1valos - B. La formaci\xF3n de profesores - y su desarrollo profesional. Pr\xE1cticas innovadoras en busca de pol\xEDticas. - In: Cox C, - editor. Pol\xEDticas educacionales en el cambio de siglo. La reforma - del sistema escolar de Chile. Santiago: - Editorial Universitaria; 2003. - p. 559\u201394.\nUNESCO, International Task Force on Teachers - for Education 2030. Global report on teachers: addressing teacher - shortages and transforming the profession. Paris: - UNESCO; 2024. Available from: - https://teachertaskforce.org/sites/default/files/2024-04/2349-23_GlobalReportonTeacher_WEB.pdf\nBast\xEDas-Bast\xEDas - LS, Iturra-Herrera - C. La formaci\xF3n inicial - docente en Chile: Una revisi\xF3n bibliogr\xE1fica sobre su implementaci\xF3n - y logros. Rev Electr Educare. 2022;26(1):1\u201322. - doi: 10.15359/ree.26-1.13\nComisi\xF3n Nacional de Acreditaci\xF3n (CNA). - T\xEDtulo exacto del documento. Falta completarla. Probablemente corresponde - a los Criterios y est\xE1ndares de calidad para la acreditaci\xF3n de carreras - y programas de pedagog\xEDa; confirmen cu\xE1l documento citaron. - Santiago: CNA; - 2023.\nZeichner - K. The turn once again toward - practice-based teacher education. J Teach Educ. - 2012;63(5):376\u201382. - doi: 10.1177/0022487112445789\nBall - DL, Forzani - FM. The work of teaching - and the challenge for teacher education. J Teach Educ. - 2009;60(5):497\u2013511. - doi: 10.1177/0022487109348479\nGrossman - P, Compton - C, Igra - D, Ronfeldt - M, Shahan - E, Williamson - P. Teaching practice: a cross-professional - perspective. Teach Coll Rec. 2009;111(9):2055\u2013100.\nMatsumoto-Royo - K, Ram\xEDrez-Montoya - MS. Core practices in practice-based - teacher education: a systematic literature review of its teaching and assessment - process. Stud Educ Eval. 2021;70:101047. - doi: 10.1016/j.stueduc.2021.101047\nLim - JM, Choi - HJ, Hwang - H. Supporting preservice - teachers\u2019 reflection with an AI chatbot: The mediating role of cognitive - and emotional engagement. Teach Teach Educ. - 2025;137:104447. doi: - 10.1016/j.tate.2023.104447\nFlamand - L, Vanderlinde - R, Tuytens - M. Promoting epistemic agency - in teacher education: A learning path for student teachers and teacher educators. - Teach Teach Educ. 2025;138:104456. - doi: 10.1016/j.tate.2023.104456\nDeJarnette - NK, Hord - C. Building teacher candidates\u2019 - interdisciplinary capacity through design challenges. J - STEM Educ Res. 2025. doi: 10.1007/s41979-024-00157-2\nWaychunas - W. Scaffolding novices toward - ambitious social studies teaching: a learning progression for enactment of - core practices. Proceedings of the 2025 AERA Annual - Meeting. 2025. doi: 10.3102/2197149\nPeters - MDJ, Godfrey - C, McInerney - P, Munn - Z, Tricco - AC, Khalil - H. Chapter 11: Scoping reviews - (2020 version). In: Aromataris - E, Munn - Z, editors. JBI Manual for Evidence - Synthesis. JBI; 2020.\nArksey - H, O\u2019Malley - L. Scoping studies: towards - a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol. - 2005;8(1):19\u201332. - doi: 10.1080/1364557032000119616\nTricco - AC, Lillie - E, Zarin - W, O\u2019Brien - KK, Colquhoun - H, Levac - D, et al. PRISMA - Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist and Explanation. - Ann Intern Med. 2018;169(7):467\u201373. - doi: 10.7326/M18-0850 30178033\nBall - DL, Sleep - L, Boerst - TA, Bass - H. Combining the Development - of Practice and the Practice of Development in Teacher Education. - Elem Sch J. 2009;109(5):458\u201374. - doi: 10.1086/596996\nHarzing - A-W, Alakangas - S. Google Scholar, Scopus - and the Web of Science: a longitudinal and cross-disciplinary comparison. - Scientometrics. 2016;106(2):787\u2013804. - doi: 10.1007/s11192-015-1798-9\nMongeon - P, Paul-Hus - A. The journal coverage of - Web of Science and Scopus: a comparative analysis. Scientometrics. - 2016;106(1):213\u201328. - doi: 10.1007/s11192-015-1765-5\nPage - MJ, McKenzie - JE, Bossuyt - PM, Boutron - I, Hoffmann - TC, Mulrow - CD, et al. The - PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. - BMJ. 2021;372:n71. doi: - 10.1136/bmj.n71 33782057\n\n
                                \n
                                " - headers: - Accept-Ranges: - - bytes - Alt-Svc: - - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 - Cache-Control: - - private, max-age=0 - Content-Disposition: - - attachment; filename=journal.pone.0360047.xml - Content-Length: - - '54783' - Content-Type: - - application/xml - Date: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT - ETag: - - '"2f0d55f8a9c67c6e52306ec0572825b7"' - Expires: - - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 12:57:55 GMT - Last-Modified: - - Tue, 13 Oct 2026 17:48:14 GMT - Server: - - UploadServer - X-GUploader-UploadID: - - AP6rU81xzxa_Qg7j7DKGHokGBW_hXpPJJnOBQIFw0_nRprLhu-9DitMlUxs8imRoHzC_aP3IRF_vHOsFaC-PPA - x-goog-generation: - - '1791913694195892' - x-goog-hash: - - crc32c=LvdmRw== - - md5=Lw1V+KnGfG5SMG7AVygltw== - x-goog-metageneration: - - '1' - x-goog-storage-class: - - STANDARD - x-goog-stored-content-encoding: - - identity - x-goog-stored-content-length: - - '54783' - status: - code: 200 - message: OK -version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml index 8b95a73..c5eec84 100644 --- a/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml +++ b/ace/tests/cassettes/test_ace/test_journal_scraping.yaml @@ -4387,4 +4387,6099 @@ interactions: status: code: 200 message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720 + response: + body: + string: 'Handle Redirect + + https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720' + headers: + CF-RAY: + - a4a7052c1ae467aa-DFW + Connection: + - keep-alive + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=utf-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:41 GMT + Nel: + - '{"report_to":"cf-nel","success_fraction":0.0,"max_age":604800}' + Report-To: + - '{"group":"cf-nel","max_age":604800,"endpoints":[{"url":"https://a.nel.cloudflare.com/report/v4?s=uWL5Vhv7ZfNJyWpXorQJub0wpMAUG5qNyscty1qfoB%2FVJlj9gT%2FoLOSzXy7HeyoXeROF8vOaa9aswrzhM8lu4T2%2F2vCYe1Rnu20wiQaMzXij%2F7ANtK2%2BTdI%3D"}]}' + Server: + - cloudflare + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + alt-svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=86400 + cf-cache-status: + - DYNAMIC + expires: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 14:35:30 GMT + location: + - https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720 + permissions-policy: + - interest-cohort=(),browsing-topics=() + vary: + - Origin + - Accept + status: + code: 302 + message: Found +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720 + response: + body: + string: ' + + + + 301 Moved Permanently + + + +

                                Moved Permanently

                                + +

                                The document has moved here.

                                + +
                                + +
                                Apache Server at dx.plos.org Port 80
                                + + + + ' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Content-Length: + - '338' + Content-Type: + - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:41 GMT + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0300720 + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CIaris6Qld6abxAD; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + Via: + - 1.1 google + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0300720 + response: + body: + string: '' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Length: + - '0' + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:41 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0300720 + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CJ-81IGN8Lfm6gEQAw; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - GCLB=CJ-81IGN8Lfm6gEQAw + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.118 + Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0300720 + response: + body: + string: "\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n + \ \n\n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n\n \n\n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n \n \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n Brain age monotonicity + and functional connectivity differences of healthy subjects | PLOS One\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n \n Skip to main + content\n \n\n
                                \n
                                Advertisement
                                \n\n \n
                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n \n
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n Browse Subject Areas\n
                                ?
                                \n + \
                                \n

                                Click through the PLOS taxonomy + to find articles in your field.

                                \n

                                For more information about + PLOS Subject Areas, click\n here.\n

                                \n + \
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n \n \n + \
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n
                                  \n
                                • \n

                                  Loading + metrics

                                  \n
                                • \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n
                                \n + \

                                Open Access

                                \n

                                Peer-reviewed

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Research Article

                                \n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n + \
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n
                                \n + \

                                Brain age + monotonicity and functional connectivity differences of healthy subjects

                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n + \

                                Brain age monotonicity + and functional connectivity differences of healthy subjects

                                \n\n
                                  \n\n
                                • Siamak + K. Sorooshyari\n\n
                                • \n\n
                                \n\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n \"PLOS\"\n
                                x
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n \n\n
                                \n + \
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n \n
                                \n + \
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n \n\n\n\n

                                Abstract

                                Alterations in the brain\u2019s connectivity + or the interactions among brain regions have been studied with the aid of + resting state (rs)fMRI data attained from large numbers of healthy subjects + of various demographics. This has been instrumental in providing insight into + how a phenotype as fundamental as age affects the brain. Although machine + learning (ML) techniques have already been deployed in such studies, novel + questions are investigated in this work. We study whether young brains develop + properties that progressively resemble those of aged brains, and if the aging + dynamics of older brains provide information about the aging trajectory in + young subjects. The degree of a prospective monotonic relationship will be + quantified, and hypotheses of brain aging trajectories will be tested via + ML. Furthermore, the degree of functional connectivity across the age spectrum + of three datasets will be compared at a population level and across sexes. + The findings scrutinize similarities and differences among the male and female + subjects at greater detail than previously performed.

                                \n
                                \n\n\n

                                Citation: + Sorooshyari SK (2024) Brain age monotonicity and functional connectivity + differences of healthy subjects. PLoS ONE 19(5):\n e0300720.\n \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720

                                Editor: + Farzin Hajebrahimi, New Jersey Institute of Technology, UNITED STATES

                                Received: + November 27, 2023; Accepted: March 4, 2024; Published: + May 30, 2024

                                Copyright: \xA9 2024 Siamak + K. Sorooshyari. This is an open access article distributed under the terms + of the Creative Commons + Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and + reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

                                Data + Availability: The data underlying the results presented in the study + are available from 1000FCP (http://fcon_1000.projects.nitrc.org), + camCAN (https://www.cam-can.org/index.php?content=dataset), + and SRPBS (https://bicr-resource.atr.jp/srpbsopen). + The 1000FCP and camCAN datasets were further processed to arrive at the correlations + that were used as features in the analysis. The processing is outlined in + the Materials and Methods of the manuscript, and the processed correlations. + The code for the data processing and ML analysis, as well as the processed + data are available from the Github repository (https://github.com/sorooshyari/PLOS_ONE_2004).

                                Funding: + The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.

                                Competing + interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests + exist.

                                \n\n\n\n\n\n

                                Introduction

                                An understanding + of the changes that occur to a brain is fundamental to human neuroscience. + While variability in person-to-person brain aging is expected due to genetics, + environment, and life events, there are also changes that are more salient. + Resting-state fMRI can be collected relatively quickly and easily from subjects + of different ages, demographics, and possible pathologies. Atypical brain + aging is often reflective of or a precursor to developmental disorders. Furthermore, + abnormal trajectories in brain age have been implicated in Parkinson\u2019s + disease (PD) [1], Alzheimer\u2019s + disease (AD) [2], as + well as several other neural pathologies [3] and even mortality [4]. Utilizing fMRI data to investigate brain aging dynamics + entails examining alterations in measures of functional connectivity (FC). + Typically, patterns of correlated activity between regions of interest (ROIs) + are compared between conditions to assess whether there are changes. In the + case of aging, differences between connectivity maps are quantified and used + to predict age with the purpose of identifying if and how brain signals change + over time. Due to its importance, age prediction from brain activity has been + undertaken across sizable datasets.

                                \n

                                Subsequent to + correlational studies and graph-theoretic approaches, machine learning (ML) + has been used to discover structure by performing either regression or classification. + There exists a growing number of works that use ML to answer questions pertaining + to brain aging. In [5] + support vector regression (SVR) was used to estimate brain age. Three groups + of subjects were considered with the ages of a subject lying in between 6 + and 35 years. The considered age range was limited in comparison to more recent + works as well as the data considered in this work. The work considered 12,720 + FC features per subject and pare to 200 for the analysis. LASSO regression + was used in [6] to + predict brain age by considering over 14,000 healthy participants from the + UK Biobank. Interestingly, that work found that resting and task-based fMRI + are relatively uninformative in comparison to several variants of MRI, i.e. + T1-weighted MRI, T2-FLAIR,T2*, and diffusion-MRI, at chronological age prediction. + A review on the use of ML techniques for rsfMRI analysis is provided in [7]. We shall highlight + several of the more recent and particularly relevant works below.

                                \n

                                The + deviation of a person\u2019s brain age from biological age may also be affected + by sex as there is no reason to assume that the prospective changes are uniform + among males and females. Works are increasingly incorporating sex as either + a predictor or a response variable when evaluating brain age. A recent study + [8] considered over + 4,000 subjects across a wide age spectrum from five different sites. Ridge + regression was used, and brain age prediction performance was quantified via + the mean absolute error (MAE) and correlation between the predicted and actual + ages. The work quantified the effects of a multiscale study by considering + various numbers of functional networks in the predictive analysis. In [9] the authors consider + over 9,000 different pipelines consisting of hyperparameter values across + a large (over 14,000) number of subjects from the Human Connectome Project + (HCP) and UK Biobank. Correlation-based measures of functional connectivity + were computed and used as inputs for several classifiers including variants + of deep learning (DL). It was noted that the regularized regression method + elastic net performs comparably with DL schemes for age prediction.

                                \n

                                We + use an ML pipeline to study whether brain aging is a progressive phenomenon + that can be characterized by a monotonic relationship. Recordings of different + age groups will be used in a training procedure with the resulting machine + asked to classify subjects from age groups that the machine has not previously + encountered. The findings will reveal a prospective similarity or difference + among the connectivity of brains from a test set to those that are younger + or older. Several hypotheses will be presented and tested. Namely, what degree + of monotonicity exists in the changes experienced by brains during aging? + How consistent are the findings across datasets? Does the aging trajectory + of young brains provide insight into the aging trajectory of older brains? + Conversely, are alterations in older subjects informative of brain activity + earlier in life? To the best of our knowledge, such analysis has not been + previously undertaken in imaging studies that assess FC.

                                \n

                                The dedifferentiation + theory of aging was presented to reflect evidence of brain activity that is + localized to specific regions in young adults becoming less localized with + aging [10]. While there + exist advancements to and affirmations of the dedifferentiation theory of + aging [11, 12], we scrutinize the variability in the FC that appears + at the various age groups by computing the number of significant connections + across the brains of subjects to evaluate how they are altered by aging. The + study shall be undertaken separately for male and female subjects as well + to assess sex differences. The analysis constitutes novel findings and quantifies + the modularity with the inclusion of anticorrelations. The majority of FC + fMRI works restrict attention to positive connections and do not differentiate + by sex.

                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Materials and + methods

                                \n
                                \n

                                Subjects, imaging acquisition, and ROI definition

                                \n

                                Three + different datasets were considered. Table 1 + contains a comparative listing of the number of subjects per age group in + each dataset. The age groups have been selected on (approximately) a decade + basis. A subject division by sex is also provided and will be necessary for + the assessment of FC differences among males and females during aging. The + first dataset consists of participants from the International Neuroimaging + Data-sharing Initiative (INDI), 1000 Functional Connectomes\u2019 Project + (1000FCP) [13, 14]. The cohort contains N = 887 individuals from 17 + centers with the requirement that a center provide a minimum of 10 participants + with full brain anatomical and functional coverage. The ages of the subjects + spanned 21\u201385 years, and 514 were female. All subjects were at rest and + not performing any task during recording. Some subjects had their eyes open + while some had their eyes closed, and each recording consisted of signals + collected for 42 ROIs. Our analysis is based upon preprocessed data of ROIs + obtained from a previous study. We provide an overview of the most relevant + section from the methods of [11]. + Seed-based analysis was performed as previously described [15, 16] + to identify seven networks. The following seed regions were used to delineate + the networks: left posterior cingulate cortex, right frontoinsula, right intraparietal + sulcus, right superior parietal cortex, left auditory cortex, right visual + cortex, and left motor cortex. Each seed was defined as a 6 mm radius sphere + centered on previously published foci. Correlation maps were produced by extracting + the time course from each of the above seeds. Then, the Pearson correlation + coefficient (PCC) between the time course and the time course of each voxel + across the whole brain was computed to create the voxel-wise connectivity + maps. The maps from a young age group (N = 458, 21\u201330 years) were used + to identify peak coordinates of additional ROIs representing each network. + All regions were defined as 6 mm radius spheres around the peak coordinate. + Information regarding the participants, number of time points collected for + each recording, and the rsfMRI acquisition and epidemiological parameters + of the different centers are detailed in Table + 2 as well as Tables 1 and 2 + of [11].

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 1. + An itemization of the number of subjects per age group associated with rsfMRI + data via the 1000FCP (N = 887), NKI-RS recording center of 1000FCP (N = 307), + SRPBS (N = 709), and camCAN (N = 652) datasets.

                                The number of subjects per age group are bifurcated + by sex via the convention (male, female). *The 1000FCP subjects in Group #1 + were, more precisely, in the 21\u201330 range.

                                \n

                                \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.t001

                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 2. + (Top) Recording center demographics for the N = 887 subjects from the 1000FCP + that were used in the analysis.

                                Additional + details such as the number of slices, voxel size, and subject handedness can + be found in Table 1 of [11]. (Middle) Recording center demographics for the + N = 709 subjects from SRPBS, with additional information available in Table + 5 of [17]. (Bottom) + Information on the N = 652 subjects from the camCAN dataset that consisted + of a single recording center. Further details about the subjects and study + can be found in [18, + 19].

                                \n

                                \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.t002

                                The + rsfMRI data from N = 709 subjects (286 female) spanning ages 18\u201379 years + in the Japanese Strategic Research Program for the Promotion of Brain Science + (SRPBS) project [17] + was also used. Healthy control (HC) data was taken from five sites in Japan: + Osaka, Showa, Kyoto, and Hiroshima Universities as well as the Advanced Telecommunications + Research Institute (ATR). Each recording consisted of signals collected at + 140 ROIs of a HC. The voxel sizes were generally not the same across the five + sites, however, the values were similar by being between 3 mm x 3 mm x 3 mm + and 4 mm x 4 mm x 4 mm (please see Table 5 of [17]). A scanning time of 10 minutes was used, and the + subjects had their eyes open and fixated on a point during the recording. + The 9730 unique PCC values were provided as part of the dataset, thus no additional + processing was required to attain the features. The acquisition and imaging + parameters for SRPBS are shown in Table 2 + and in more detail via Table 5 and 9 of [17].

                                \n

                                Lastly, we used rsfMRI data that was collected + at one recording center as part of the Cambridge Centre for Aging and Neuroscience + (CamCAN) study [18, + 19]. A single testing + center provided N = 652 subjects (330 female) spanning ages 18\u201388 years. + The subjects had their eyes closed during the recordings and followed the + instruction to not think of any one thing in particular. A voxel size of 3 + mm x 3 mm x 4.44 mm was used with an acquisition time of 8 minutes and 40 + seconds. The acquisition and imaging parameters are further detailed in Table 2 of [19]. To compute the FC from ROI recordings, the Craddock + unsmooth parcellation was used to attain 840 ROIs. The mean intensity across + voxels was used. Although the parcellation provided 840 ROIs, we considered + 808 across each subject as 32 had missing values for some of the subjects. + The PCC values were computed by correlating the time courses of the ROIs.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Preprocessing + and head motion correction

                                \n

                                With the 1000FCP dataset, the functional images + were preprocessed in [11] + using the FSL software (FMRIB Software Library v. 5.0.1, Oxford, UK) and SPM + software (Statistical Parametric Mapping software package, Wellcome Department + of Imaging Neuroscience, London, UK) following conventional methods originally + described in [16, 20]. The following steps + were preformed: 1) slice-timing correction; 2) rigid-body motion correction; + 3) registration to the MNI152 space; 4) regression of nuisance variables including + ventricles, white matter (WM), and global average signal 5) temporal bandpass + filtering (0.01\u20130.08 Hz). The preprocessing included rigid body correction + for motion within and across runs, normalization to the standard echo-planar + imaging (EPI) template of the Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI), and compensation + for slice-dependent time shifts. Several key acquisition parameters are shown + in Table 2 with additional information + such as the number of slices, voxel size, and subject handedness available + in Table 1 of [11]. The preprocessed functional data (in atlas space) + were temporally filtered to remove constant offsets and linear trends over + each run while retaining frequencies below 0.08 Hz. Data were spatially smoothed + using a 4 mm full-width half-maximum (FWHM) Gaussian blur. Sources of spurious + or regionally non-specific variance were removed by regression of nuisance + variables. This included six parameters obtained by rigid body head motion + correction, the signal averaged over the whole brain (global signal), the + signal averaged over the lateral ventricles, and the signal averaged over + a region centered in the deep cerebral WM. Temporally shifted versions of + these waveforms were removed by inclusion of the first temporal derivatives + (computed by backward differences) in the linear model. The analysis used + via [11] to account + for head motion is summarized as follows. The parameters were calculated for + each participant as proposed by [22]. + Framewise displacement (FD), which represents head displacement from volume + to volume, was computed as the sum of the first derivative of the six rigid-body + motion parameters estimated during standard volume realignment. Delta variation + signal (DVARS), which represents the change in BOLD signal intensity from + one frame to the next, was computed as the root mean square average of the + first derivative of fMRI signals across the entire brain. A standardized version + of DVARS was applied according to [21]. + Volumes with FD value over 0.5\u2009mm or DVARS value over 1.5 IQRs above + the 75th percentile were removed with one prior and two subsequent volumes. + Sixteen individuals from several centers were excluded due to excessive head + motion during rsfMRI acquisition according to the described movement parameters + criteria [22].

                                \n

                                The + preprocessing of the SRPBS rsfMRI data are detailed in [17]. This was primarily done using SPM8 implemented + in MATLAB (R2016b; Mathworks, Natick, MA). The first 10 seconds of data were + discarded to allow for T1 equilibration. Preprocessing steps included slice-timing + correction, realignment, co-registration, segmentation of T1-weighted structural + images, normalization to MNI space, and spatial smoothing with an isotropic + Gaussian kernel of 6 mm FWHM. The ROIs were delineated according to 140 regions + defined by the Brainvisa Sulci Atlas and three subregions of the cerebellum + (the left and right cerebellum, and the vermis). The BOLD signal time courses + were extracted from the ROIs, and a bandpass filter (0.008\u20130.1 Hz) was + applied to the time courses before a regression procedure. Filtered time courses + were linearly regressed on temporal fluctuations of the WM, the cerebrospinal + fluid (CSF), and the entire brain, as well as six head motion parameters. + Fluctuation in each tissue class was determined from the average time course + of the voxels within a mask created by segmentation of the T1 image. Extracted + time courses were then bandpass filtered (0.008\u20130.1 Hz) before linear + regression, as was done for regional time courses. Then, for each individual, + a matrix of 9,730 connections between the 140 ROIs was calculated by evaluating + PCCs of BOLD signal time courses. The flagged frames in the previous procedure + were discarded. After calculating the FD, volumes with FD > 0.5 mm were + removed. Further details and information about the procedure to calculate + the matrix are outlined in [17, + 21].

                                \n

                                The camCAN + preprocessing of the rsfMRI data was performed and is detailed in [19]. The procedure is summarized as follows. Co-registered + T1 and T2 images were used in a multi-channel segmentation (SPM12 Segment, + based on \u201CNew Segment\u201D in SPM8 [23]) routine in order to extract probabilistic maps + of six tissue classes: gray matter (GM), WM, CSF, bone, soft tissue, and residual + noise. Images from each subject were coregistered to the subject\u2019s T1-weighted + image using a rigid-body (6-df) linear transformation. Normalization parameters + from the diffeomorphic anatomical registration through exponentiated lie algebra + (DARTEL) procedure [24] + were applied. The native-space GM and WM images for all participants who passed + quality-control checks were submitted to diffeomorphic registration to create + group template images. The group template was then normalized to the MNI template + via an affine transformation. Then combined normalization parameters were + applied to each individual participant\u2019s GM and WM images. Individual + normalized GM and WM images were smoothed (8 mm FWHM Gaussian kernel). Data + from each recording was unwarped to compensate for magnetic field inhomogeneities, + then realigned to correct for motion, and slice-time corrected. The EPI data + were co-registered to the T1 image, and the normalization parameters were + applied to warp functional images into MNI space. The mean regional time-courses + were then extracted using the template method.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Computed + features and description of ML pipeline

                                \n

                                To measure + FC, PCC values were evaluated between the time courses for all pairs of ROIs + of a participant. Each recording consisted of signals collected for 42, 140, + and 808 ROIs for subjects in the 1000FCP, SRPBS, and camCAN datasets, respectively. + A simple calculation shows that we have 861, 9730, and 326,028 unique PCC + values to be used as features. The features from each participant were used + either as training or test data in the ML analysis. We form two sets A and + B, consisting of a younger age group and an older age group for the scenarios + considered in Fig 1. Let N1 + denote the number of subjects in the young group and N2 the number + in the aged group. The following steps are taken.

                                \n

                                Step + 1) Let m = min{N1, N2}.

                                \n

                                Step 2) Train a machine on the m data points from + the smaller set, and m randomly selected points from the larger set. This + is done to ensure balance of data for an age range. The feature vectors will + consist of the PCC values for a subject. The labels correspond to whether + the subject is from the aged or young group.

                                \n

                                Step + 3) Use the k = max{N1, N2}\u2212m + left-out recordings from the larger set as validation data. The trained machine + is to predict whether the k residual recordings are young or aged and an accuracy + rate (AR) will be attained.

                                \n

                                Step 4) Test + on the subjects not included in sets A and B, but rather in interval i: i + = 1, 2, or 3 for the Fig 1 scenario that + is being considered.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 1. + Three scenarios for assessing whether brain aging is a progressive phenomenon.

                                In + each case a machine is trained on a young and aged cohort and asked to classify + CPs of subjects with ages that it has not previously encountered. For each + scenario an illustration contains possible hypotheses (H) for the trajectory + of the predicted brain ages in the respective interval. A) In interval 1 it + is expected that the percentage of brains classified as aged follow a monotonically + increasing trajectory among the chronological age range with the y-intercept + being less than 50%. B) The study of interval 2 investigates whether the CP + of young brains provide information about the CP of aged brains. C) Interval + 3 is intended to investigate whether CP differences among aged brains can + be used to infer aging dynamics of younger brains.

                                \n

                                \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g001

                                The + above steps are depicted in the pipeline of Fig + 2 where the schematic is iterated once with the performance on the k residue + data points from the larger set viewed as validation accuracy. The trained + machine is then presented with the left-out data from the new category. The + ML technique used was a support vector machine (SVM) with a linear kernel + and a binary classifier. The techniques were implemented in R via the packages + e1071 and kernlab.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 2. + An ML pipeline to evaluate whether brains age in a monotonic fashion.

                                The + sets A and B refer to the young and aged groups of the different scenarios + that are considered when testing on subjects of interval 1, 2, and 3. An SVM + is trained on 2m data points, asked to classify k residue data points from + either the aged or young group, and classify the age phenotype of the subjects + in interval 1, 2, or 3.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g002

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Methodology to assess monotonicity of brain + differences with age

                                \n

                                It is natural to assume that a brain will possess + characteristics that are more similar to brains close to its age than those + of increasingly disparate age groups. A test of this notion is to present + a trained machine with recordings across a spectrum of ages that it has not + previously seen. The three scenarios in Fig + 1 are considered with the ML pipeline in Fig + 2. This will encompass training a machine on connectivity patterns (CPs) + from an equal number of subjects from a young and an aged cohort in each scenario. + The trained machines\u2019 decisions will scrutinize whether brains\u2013whose + age the machine has not previously encountered\u2013have a CP that is more + similar to an older or a younger cohort. The cartoons accompanying each of + the scenarios in Fig 1 denote possible + trajectories that we hypothesize for the left-out recordings that will be + classified by the respective machine. Interval 1 is the most conspicuous since + it is expected that as chronological age increases, brains exhibit properties + that become increasingly similar to an extrema group of aged brains in a monotonic + fashion. It is also expected that the youngest brains in the interval exhibit + CPs that are close to the extrema of young subjects (i.e., an intercept < + 50%). The described relation is referred to as hypothesis 1 (H1) in Fig + 1A.

                                \n

                                The prospective hypotheses are less conspicuous + for interval 2. It is conceivable that older subjects exhibit CPs that follow + an increasing trajectory away from younger brains that have been bifurcated + into a younger (i.e., aged) and youngest (i.e., young) groups. This possibility + is reflected by the two increasing lines labeled H1 and H2 in Fig + 1B. The difference in the intercept of the two lines reflects the notion + that the youngest brains in interval 2 can be classified as being closer in + CP to brains in the aged group that are the most proximal to them in years + (H1), or alternatively as relatively young (H2) if the CPs in the unseen data + are classified on a relative rather than absolute basis. Lastly, it is conceivable + that the recordings exhibit CPs that do not deviate very much from the aged + (yet relatively younger) brains in which case a horizontal line with an intercept + greater than 50% would be noted (H3). The investigation of interval 2 probes + at whether CPs of young brains provide information on the dynamics noted in + older subjects.

                                \n

                                Interval 3 in Fig + 1C represents a somewhat inverted version of the study for interval 2. + It investigates whether older brains provide insight into the connectivity + changes that occur among younger brains. A hypothesis shown by the strictly + increasing line (H1) entails young brains exhibiting properties reminiscent + of the youngest brains in an otherwise aged cohort, and the CP of the young + brains gradually resembling that of the most aged brains as chronological + age is increased. It is also conceivable that the gradual resemblance to the + most aged brains does not occur, but rather the trained machine associates + the brains in interval 3 as resembling the young cohort as the chronological + age of the subjects approaches that of the subjects in the more proximal young + cohort. This scenario is depicted via the inverted U-shaped trajectory (H2). + Lastly, it may be that the CPs of subjects remain similar to the younger group + as shown by the trajectory of a horizontal line with an intercept below 50% + (H3). The investigation of interval 3 probes at whether aged brains provide + information on the dynamics of connectivity earlier in life.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Quantification + of FC changes with age and sex

                                \n

                                The pairwise + PCC values were used as the features for the ML analysis and to assess the + connectivity among brain regions. For each subject the number of connections + that exceeded the threshold |\u03C1 = 0.6| were totaled and referred to as + the FC for the subject. The value of 0.6 has been motivated in works such + as [19, 25]. For completeness, thresholds of |\u03C1 = 0.45| + and |\u03C1 = 0.7| are also considered in the analysis to assess the robustness + of the findings. The evaluation with different FC thresholds is to account + for the possibility of low SNR in the recordings. Typically, signals in a + stable or high SNR regime would provide similar trends when a correlation + threshold is uniformly adjusted. Importantly, we consider the positive and + negative (i.e. anticorrelation) CC values separately when assessing the change + in connectivity with aging for the three datasets. In testing for the statistical + significance of an effect, the youngest age group is taken as a reference + and a two-sample t-test is conducted among the positive, negative, and total + connections in the subjects. A p-value of 0.05 is used as the threshold for + statistical significance when evaluating the change in FC between the youngest + age group and the older subjects. The change is assessed separately among + male and female subjects with the objective of determining whether age-modulated + FC is sex specific. As done with the entire population, the youngest age group + is considered the reference for assessing FC changes, and a two-sample t-test + is used to test for statistical significance (i.e. p < 0.05). The standard + deviations (s.d.) of the number of functional connections are also computed + to study the inter-subject variability in connectivity during aging.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Consideration of recording center and subject + arousal effects

                                \n

                                The 1000FCP dataset consists of recordings from + 17 centers, and thus warrants scrutiny of potential site effects. The NKI-Rockland + (NKI-RS) center contains approximately 34% of the subjects in the 1000FCP. + This number is significant when considering the next largest participant pool + (i.e. Beijing) contributes approximately 13%. NKI-RS also contains the largest + spread of subjects\u2019 chronological ages (Table + 1). The monotonicity and change in FC analysis shall be repeated with + only subjects from the NKI-RS center. A comparison of the findings for 1000FCP + and its constituent NKI-RS will show whether the same trends are noted for + both cases or if site effects may be affecting the findings. Furthermore, + unlike SRPBS and camCAN, the 1000FCP contains a mixture of recordings where + subjects had their eyes open and closed (Table + 2). A difference in arousal level can affect FC strength and bias connectivity + patterns. The monotonicity and change in FC analyses are conducted separately + on 1000FCP recordings where subjects had their eyes open (N = 543). The reason + for not additionally conducting an analysis on subjects with eyes closed is + because of their relatively low number (N = 197), and lack of representation + across the spectrum of ages in the 1000FCP dataset (Table + 2).

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Results

                                \n
                                \n

                                Monotonic changes in functional connectivity occur + over an intermediate age interval

                                \n

                                In considering + the 1000FCP data, the scenario in Fig 1A + encompassed a machine trained on features from 78 brains, 39 that comprise + the 71+ age group and 39 of which have been randomly selected from the 21\u201330 + group. The remaining 809 brains shall be considered as test data. Naturally, + it is expected that the 419 remaining recordings from the 21\u201330 age group + be classified as young. In evaluating the accuracy on the test data, excellent + performance is seen for the left-out young brains in the 21\u201330 age group + via an AR of 0.84 across 419 subjects. The accuracy vindicated the machine\u2019s + integrity to continue the monotonicity study and evaluate decisions on recordings + in interval 1. The decisions made by the machine on the 390 brains of ages + 31\u201370 years are shown in Fig 3. We + have considered the number of brains at each age that were classified as old + to arrive at percentages for the ages encompassed in interval 1. The bar plot + illustrates the number of brains at an age that have been classified as young + or aged. The accompanying line plot represents the percentage of subjects + that were classified as aged after the application of a 5-year sliding window + for smoothing. Although the increase is not monotonic, an increasing trend + is noted in the percentage. The absence of complete monotonicity is due to + cross-subject variability as variance inherently exists among all facets of + recordings from different people. Furthermore, there is the limitation that + the number of samples at each age in Fig 3 + was not very large (min sample size = 3, max sample size = 19). Such confounding + factors are natural and expected to provide uncertainty to the findings. This + is noted by the moderate Spearman correlation value of 0.7 between the subjects\u2019 + ages and the percentage of subjects classified as aged. To test for a trend, + a linear regression with intercept \u03B20 and slope \u03B21 + was fit to the results. As previously mentioned, a positive trend and a low + intercept are expected for the brains in interval 1. The intercept \u03B20 + = 31.58 is rather low indicating that the classification of the youngest brains + in interval 1 are indeed skewed towards the young group. A slope of \u03B21 + = 0.952 demonstrates a positive association between the increase in age and + CPs resembling the older phenotype. The results justify H1 as holding for + interval 1 of Fig 1A.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 3. + The results of the brain age monotonicity analysis for interval 1.

                                The + histograms show the number of subjects classified as young and aged at every + considered age. A 5-year sliding window was applied and a linear regression + was fit to the results with intercept \u03B20 and slope \u03B21. + A machine was trained on the youngest and oldest groups and presented with + test data of intermediate-aged subjects. For 1000FCP we have \u03B20 + = 31.58, \u03B21 = 0.952. The Spearman correlation of 0.7 computed + among the percentages of subjects classified as aged and the ages indicates + a moderate degree of monotonicity between the two quantities. With SRPBS, + \u03B20 = 7.285, \u03B21 = 2.696, and a Spearman correlation + of 0.948 demonstrates a high degree of monotonicity between the two quantities. + A consideration of camCAN leads to \u03B20 = 0 and \u03B21 + = 2.234. The Spearman correlation of 0.986 signifies monotonicity between + the two quantities. For NKI-RS subjects we note \u03B20 = 39.74, + \u03B21 = 0.877, and the Spearman correlation of 0.608 reflects + monotonicity.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g003

                                For + the SRPBS subjects, a machine is trained on 72 subjects randomly selected + from the 18\u201330 age group and the 72 in the 61+ group. The test set consists + of 565 subjects, 255 of which are residual from the 18\u201330 year old (y.o.) + range. The machine classified 247 of the residual recordings as young leading + to AR = 0.968 and vindicating the machine efficacy. The histograms in Fig + 3 illustrate the number of subjects assigned as young and aged at every + considered age. To test for a trend, a linear regression was applied to the + results in interval 1. The low intercept (\u03B20 = 7.285) and + the positive slope (\u03B21 = 2.696) were expected while a Spearman + correlation of 0.948 indicates a high degree of monotonicity in the brains + classified as having an aged profile with increasing biological age. The hypothesis + H1 in Fig 1A is validated. Similarly, for + the camCAN dataset a machine was trained on 45 randomly selected subjects + from the 18\u201330 age group and the 45 subjects 81+ y.o. Of the 34 remaining + subjects in the younger group 33 were classified as young leading to AR = + 0.9705. A linear fit to the percentage of subjects classified as aged in Fig 3 yields the intercept \u03B20 + = 0 and slope \u03B21 = 2.234. The Spearman correlation of 0.986 + computed among the percentages of subjects classified as aged and their chronological + ages indicates monotonicity between the two quantities. The analysis supports + H1 as the brain aging dynamics of intermediate aged subjects when extrema + groups are used as the references. The NKI-RS analysis entailed a machine + trained on features from 32 recordings of subjects in the 71+ age group and + 32 randomly selected from the 21\u201330 age group. The remaining 33 recordings + from the young group (21\u201330 y.o.) were classified by the trained machine + at an AR of 0.696. The decisions on the residual 210 brains spanning 31\u201370 + years are shown in Fig 3. An increasing + trend (\u03B21 = 0.877), relatively low intercept (\u03B20 + = 39.74), and a formidable Spearman correlation value of 0.608 are noted. + The results also support hypothesis H1 as an explanation for brain aging dynamics + in interval 1.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Young + brain functional connectivity is not indicative of alterations in older subjects

                                \n

                                Considering + the 1000FCP subjects, the ML pipeline is applied with the partition in Fig 1B to probe whether there is a monotonic + relationship. A machine is trained on 170 brains, 85 of which have been randomly + selected from the 21\u201330 age group, and 85 that comprise the 31\u201340 + age group. The remaining 717 subjects in the dataset are used to investigate + whether brains are perceived as young or aged by the machine. The 373 remaining + brains from the 21\u201330 age group are expected to be classified as young, + however, the decisions are not obvious for the 344 brains that constitute + interval 2. The AR noted is 0.646 for the held-out brains in the young group. + It is expected that the AR levels for Fig 1B + be lower than those reported for Fig 1A\u2013this + is attributed to the difficulty in distinguishing among brains that are closer + in age. We consider the decisions made by the trained machine on the 344 elder + brains (41\u201371+ y.o.) of interval 2. In Fig + 4 the percentage of brains classified as aged does not show a monotonically + increasing relationship (Spearman correlation = -0.243). The point 77+ on + the abscissa is considered as the final age because of the relatively few + samples available above this age\u2013the point is comprised of 14 subjects + ranging from 77 to 85 y.o. When fit with a linear regression, the intercept + \u03B20 = 71.4 is rather high indicating that the youngest brains + in interval 2 appear more similar to the proximal brains in the aged group + rather than the relatively young group that was used during training. The + slope of \u03B21 = -0.147 does not support an increasing trend + for the 41+ y.o. subjects of interval 2. The Spearman correlation of -0.243 + between chronological age and the percentage of brains classified as aged + indicates that the change in CP dynamics of the younger brains is not conserved + among the progressively older brains. We conclude that hypothesis H3 in Fig 1B is the most representative trajectory + for interval 2.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 4. + The results of the brain age monotonicity analysis for interval 2.

                                The + histograms show the number of subjects classified as young and aged at every + considered age. A 5-year sliding window was applied and a linear regression + was fit to the results with intercept \u03B20 and slope \u03B21. + A machine was trained on the two youngest groups of subjects and then asked + to classify older recordings. For 1000FCP we attain \u03B20 = 71.4 + and \u03B21 = -0.147 indicating little change in the classification + of increasingly older brains as aged. Furthermore, a Spearman correlation + of -0.243 reflects a non-monotonic relationship. With the SRPBS subjects \u03B20 + = 82.159 and \u03B21 = 0.1 suggest little change in the classification + of increasingly older brains as aged. The Spearman correlation of 0.149 reflects + a non-monotonic relationship among the ages and the percentage classified + as aged. For camCAN we attain \u03B20 = 77.48, \u03B21 + = 0.329 demonstrating little change in the classification of increasingly + older brains as aged. The Spearman correlation of 0.74 reflects a moderately + monotonic relationship among the subjects\u2019 ages and the percentage classified + as aged. The consideration of NKI-RS subjects of interval 2 leads to \u03B20 + = 65.48, \u03B21 = 0.453, and a Spearman correlation of 0.417. + This indicates an increasing relationship but little monotonicity.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g004

                                Applying + the analysis to the SRPBS dataset involved a machine trained on 126 subjects + randomly selected from the 18\u201330 age group and 126 comprising the 31\u201340 + group. The test set consisted of the remaining 457 subjects. Of the 201 residual + subjects from the 18\u201330 y.o. group, 146 were classified as young leading + to AR = 0.726. In interval 2 we attain intercept and slope values of \u03B20 + = 82.159, \u03B21 = 0.1 indicating little change in the appearance + of increasingly older brains from the more proximal aged group. A Spearman + correlation of 0.149 in Fig 4 denotes negligible + monotonicity in the percentage of subjects classified as aged with an increasing + number of years. The findings support hypothesis H3 that studying the aging + trajectory in younger brains (i.e. 18\u201340 y.o.) provides little information + about their aging trajectories in later years. Analysis with the camCAN subjects + considered the training data comprised of 79 subjects from the 18\u201330 + as well as the 31\u201340 age groups, and testing done on the 493 residual + subjects. The 26 subjects from the older group were classified as aged at + an AR of 0.653 by the trained machine. After computing the percentages of + 468 subjects deemed as old at each age in the 41+ range, the linear fit provided + \u03B20 = 77.48 and \u03B21 = 0.329. This indicates + little increase in the classification of the older subjects with the increase + in their chronological ages. The Spearman correlation of 0.74 between the + percentage of brains classified as aged and the chronological age reflects + a moderately monotonic relationship. The findings signify H1 as the most expressive + of the hypotheses for the trajectory in interval 2. NKI-RS subjects in the + age group 21\u201330 and 31\u201340 were used to train an SVM for the interval + 2 analysis. Following the selection of 27 random recordings from the younger + group, the 38 left out recordings were classified at a below-chance level + of AR = 0.473. By computing the percentages of the 215 subjects that were + 41+ y.o. and classified as aged, a linear fit provided \u03B20 + = 65.48 and \u03B21 = 0.453 (Fig + 4). While the slope indicates an increasing trend, a Spearman correlation + of 0.417 between the percentage of brains classified as aged and the subjects\u2019 + ages in interval 2 reflects the absence of a monotonic relationship. The analysis + signifies H3 as the most representative hypothesis for the NKI-RS trajectory + in interval 2.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Connectivity + patterns of older subjects reflects aging dynamics in young brains

                                \n

                                Through + the scenario depicted in Fig 1C we explore + if older brains exhibit CPs that can be used to differentiate among younger + brains, and whether the differentiation occurs in a monotonic fashion with + age. We hypothesize the trained machine to provide a low intercept when investigating + a trend in the percentage of brains classified as aged. However, it is not + obvious if a monotonic increase or a positive association will be seen. For + the 1000FCP dataset an SVM is trained on 78 brains; 39 randomly selected from + the 61\u201370 age group and 39 from the 71+ age group. The residual subjects + from the 61\u201370 age group are expected to be classified as young, and + an AR of 0.714 was noted on the 28 held-out brains from this group. The decisions + made by the trained machine on the 781 younger brains (ages 21\u201360 years) + are shown in Fig 5. The intercept of \u03B20 + = 24.2 is somewhat high since the ideal intercept would be near zero. This + demonstrates that the relatively young brains that were used to train the + machine are not very representative of the FC changes in the youngest subjects + of the study. The slope in Fig 5 is \u03B21 + = 0.58 indicating a marginal but increasing trend in the percentage of brains + classified as aged across interval 3. A Spearman correlation of 0.795 is noted + among the subjects\u2019 ages and the percentage of brains classified as aged. + We conclude that H1 is the best hypothesis for interval 3. This indicates + that the difference in CP among aged brains is reflective of FC dynamics earlier + in life.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 5. + The results of the brain age monotonicity analysis for interval 3.

                                The + histograms show the number of subjects classified as young and aged at every + considered age. A 5-year sliding window was applied and a linear regression + was fit to the results with intercept \u03B20 and slope \u03B21. + A machine was trained on the two oldest age groups and received younger subject + recordings as test data. With the 1000FCP dataset, the values \u03B20 + = 24.2, \u03B21 = 0.58, and the Spearman correlation of 0.795 indicate + a gradual increase and moderate monotonicity. For SRPBS, \u03B20 + = 3.11, \u03B21 = 0.788, and the Spearman correlation of 0.853 + demonstrates monotonicity in the number of subjects classified as aged with + increasing age. With camCAN, the values \u03B20 = 32.52, \u03B21 + = -0.205, and the Spearman correlation of -0.448 indicate a gradual decrease + and small degree of monotonicity. The NKI-RS subjects of interval 3 provide + \u03B20 = 45.12 and \u03B21 = -0.176 to reflect a gradually + decreasing relationship. The Spearman correlation of -0.161 indicates an absence + of monotonicity.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g005

                                Applying + the ML pipeline to the SRPBS dataset, a machine is trained on 69 subjects + in the 51\u201360 age group and 69 subjects randomly selected from the 61+ + group. The testing was performed on the remaining 571 subjects. Of the 3 remaining + subjects from the 61+ y.o. group, 2 were correctly classified as aged (AR + = 0.667). By applying the ML pipeline of Fig + 2 to this scenario, we attain the results in Fig + 5 for interval 3. A linear fit provides a low intercept (\u03B20 + = 3.11) and a positive slope of \u03B21 = 0.788. The Spearman correlation + of 0.853 signifies that differences among aged brains (i.e. 61+ y.o.) provide + a high degree of information about the aging trajectory of younger brains. + The quantified results indicate that hypothesis H1 is the most explanatory + of the three hypotheses for interval 3. The study with the camCAN subjects + involved training on 45 young (71\u201380 y.o.) and 45 aged (81+ y.o.) subjects + and subsequently testing on the 561 residual recordings. The 72 residue subjects + in the 71\u201380 group were classified accurately as young via AR = 0.666. + For the remaining 489 recordings that comprise interval 3, the linear fit + provides \u03B20 = 32.52 and \u03B21 = -0.205. The Spearman + correlation of -0.448 reflects a small degree of monotonicity in the number + of subjects classified as aged when the reference was taken to be the aging + dynamics of older brains. The scenario H3 is the endorsed hypothesis as the + properties of the two chronologically oldest groups do not markedly differentiate + between the ages of the recordings from the younger subjects. The ML analysis + for the NKI-RS subjects involved training on 32 young (61\u201370 y.o.) and + 32 aged (71+ y.o.) recordings. The 13 residual subjects in the 61\u201370 + group were classified as young via AR = 0.692. The decisions made by the machine + on the 230 younger subjects comprising interval 3 yield \u03B20 + = 45.12 and \u03B21 = -0.176 when fit with a linear model (Fig + 5). A Spearman correlation of -0.161 does not reflect monotonicity and + H3 is recognized as the most supported hypothesis.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Functional + connectivity changes are categorical with aging

                                \n

                                In light + of the ML analysis providing predictions from measures of FC, we pursue a + quantitative evaluation of the FC and how it varies across the age spectrum. + For the 1000FCP dataset, Fig 6A shows the + mean and standard deviation (s.d.) of the FC for subjects across the seven + decades. A significant decrease in mean FC in noted among the 51\u201360, + 71\u201380, and 81+ groups (p < 0.05). The positive FC values that showed + a significant decrease coincided with the total FC except for the 31\u201340 + age group. Although less apparent, the presence of anticorrelations was not + negligible, and the decrease in the negative FC values was significant for + the 81+ group. The alteration in FC with aging was also prevalent for the + SRPBS subjects, however the direction of the change was different as there + is an increase in FC with age (Fig 6B). + The increase accelerated among the 51\u201360 and 71+ groups and, aside for + the positive correlations in the 61\u201370 y.o. group, is seen for positive, + negative, and total connectivity measures. The change in the number of negative + connections is not insignificant and follows an increasing trend that coincides + with the conventionally considered (i.e. positive) correlations. The camCAN + subjects show a decrease in FC that is steady but significant with increasing + age (Fig 6C). Interestingly, while being + negligible in value in comparison to the number of positive correlations, + the anticorrelations show an opposite trajectory by increasing with aging. + For the NKI-RS dataset, Fig 6D shows the + mean of the FC for subjects. A significant decrease in mean FC is noted among + the 81+ y.o. group and for the positive FC values of the 71\u201380 y.o. group + (p < 0.05).

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 6. +

                                A + study of the change in FC for subjects across decades from the A) 1000FCP, + B) SRPBS, C) camCAN, and D) the NKI-RS recording center. The mean FC was computed + by averaging across subjects the number of times that the Pearson CCs from + the connectivity matrix exceeded a threshold of |\u03C1| = 0.6. The bifurcation + of the FC in positive and negative (i.e. anticorrelations) directions is also + shown. Two-sample t-tests are used to assess the significance of the change + in FC with the youngest age group taken as the reference. A p-value of 0.05 + is the threshold for statistical significance in the pairwise comparisons + between positive, negative, and total FC values. The s.d. of the number of + functional connections is illustrated to study the inter-subject variability + across the age spectrum.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g006

                                We + examine the inter-subject variability in FC with aging. In the case of 1000FCP, + there is an increase in variability among middle age to elder (61\u201370) + subjects, and a reduction in FC variability for the two oldest decades (Fig 6A). It is intriguing that the increase + in FC consistency for the oldest subjects is precipitous and present among + the positive and negative correlations. Similarly, the peak inter-subject + FC variability occurs in middle age for the SRPBS subjects (51\u201360 y.o.) + with decreasing variance for older and younger age groups (Fig + 6B). The youngest subjects (18\u201330 y.o.) exhibit the most consistency. + The variance in the inter-subject FC for the camCAN subjects shows a steady + decrease along the decades. There is a bimodal division as the older subjects + (61+ y.o.) have a more consistent CP than the younger subjects (Fig + 6C). It is interesting that the datasets provide very different results + on the variability in inter-subject FC across the broad age spectrum. While + the 1000FCP and camCAN subjects show the least variability in the oldest age + groups, the SRPBS subjects show the lowest variability for the youngest subjects. + Furthermore, the 1000FCP and SRPBS subjects show the highest variability for + middle-age (61\u201370 and 51\u201360, respectively), while the youngest decade + (18\u201330 y.o.) camCAN subjects exhibited the largest inter-subject FC variability. + In the case of the NKI-RS subjects there is an increase in variability among + middle age to elder (61\u201370 y.o.) subjects, and a reduction in FC variability + for the two oldest decades (Fig 6D). The + trend is very similar to the aggregate 1000FCP scenario since the increase + in FC consistency is precipitous for the oldest subjects and exists for positive + and negative correlations. In summary, the change in the total FC is categorical + with aging across the populations of subjects. The inter-subject variance, + however, follows an inverted U-shaped trajectory in two datasets, and a bimodal + trajectory showing a decrease in variability with aging in the third case.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Brain aging dynamics are similar among + sexes, but accentuated in males

                                \n

                                In considering + the 1000FCP subjects, the results in Fig 7 + indicate that a decrease in FC with increasing age is more pronounced in males. + Specifically, the two middle-age groups of males (41\u201350, 51\u201360) + exhibited a significant decrease in their positive FC measures (p < 0.05) + while only the 51\u201360 y.o. group of females showed a similar decline. + The significant decrease in FC is noted in the total FC of males for the two + oldest groups. A similar decrease is noted in females of 81 years and older. + Interestingly, the oldest females witness a greater reduction in FC than the + male subjects. For the SRPBS dataset there is an increase in FC with aging + for both males and females, although the increase is only significant for + the male subjects. Specifically, the increase in all three classes of correlations + are significant for the male subjects in the 41\u201350 and 51\u201360 y.o. + range, while only the negative correlations are significant for the female + subjects of the same age groups (Fig 8). + Perhaps more importantly, the males show their largest number of negative + and total connections in the oldest age group. The subjects in the camCAN + cohort exhibit a similar trend with the progressive change in FC being more + prominent in males. While a significant decrease in total FC is noted in the + 71\u201380 and 81+ age groups for both sexes, the change starts earlier in + males via the 61\u201370 y.o. group (Fig 9). + The earlier alteration to FC in males is also noted among their anticorrelations + across the age spectrum. The change in FC for the NKI-RS subjects is similar + to that seen for the aggregate 1000FCP dataset (Fig + 10). The decrease in connectivity is only significant for the oldest age + group of male and female subjects. The change is more pronounced in males + because the total and positive FC values are statistically significant, while + only the positive FC values are significant for females.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 7. + An assessment of the differences in FC between male and female subjects in + the three datasets.

                                The + mean and s.d. of the number of connections are plotted separately for the + male and female subjects from the 1000FCP dataset. The mean FC was computed + by averaging across subjects the number of times the Pearson CCs from the + connectivity matrix exceeded a threshold of |\u03C1| = 0.6. The division of + the FC in positive and negative (i.e. anticorrelation) directions is also + shown. Two-sample t-tests are used to assess the significance of the change + in FC with the youngest age group taken as the reference. A p-value of 0.05 + is the threshold for statistical significance in the pairwise comparisons + between positive, negative, and total FC values. The s.d. of the number of + FCs is shown to study the inter-subject variability for each sex and age group.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g007

                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 8. + Assessment of the differences in FC between male and female subjects in the + three datasets.

                                The + mean and s.d. of the number of connections are plotted separately for the + male and female subjects from the SRPBS dataset. The mean FC was computed + by averaging across subjects the number of times the Pearson CCs from the + connectivity matrix exceeded a threshold of |\u03C1| = 0.6. The division of + the FC in positive and negative (i.e. anticorrelation) directions is also + shown. Two-sample t-tests are used to assess the significance of the change + in FC with the youngest age group taken as the reference. A p-value of 0.05 + is the threshold for statistical significance in the pairwise comparisons + between positive, negative, and total FC values. The s.d. of the number of + FCs is shown to study the inter-subject variability for each sex and age group.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g008

                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 9. + Assessment of the differences in FC between male and female subjects in the + three datasets.

                                The + mean and s.d. of the number of connections are plotted separately for the + male and female subjects from camCAN. The mean FC was computed by averaging + across subjects the number of times the Pearson CCs from the connectivity + matrix exceeded a threshold of |\u03C1| = 0.6. The division of the FC in positive + and negative (i.e. anticorrelation) directions is also shown. Two-sample t-tests + are used to assess the significance of the change in FC with the youngest + age group taken as the reference. A p-value of 0.05 is the threshold for statistical + significance in the pairwise comparisons between positive, negative, and total + FC values. The s.d. of the number of FCs is shown to study the inter-subject + variability for each sex and age group.

                                \n

                                \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g009

                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 10. + Assessment of the differences in FC between male and female subjects in the + three datasets.

                                The + mean and s.d. of the number of connections are plotted separately for the + male and female subjects from the NKI-RS recording center. The mean FC was + computed by averaging across subjects the number of times the Pearson CCs + from the connectivity matrix exceeded a threshold of |\u03C1| = 0.6. The division + of the FC in positive and negative (i.e. anticorrelation) directions is also + shown. Two-sample t-tests are used to assess the significance of the change + in FC with the youngest age group taken as the reference. A p-value of 0.05 + is the threshold for statistical significance in the pairwise comparisons + between positive, negative, and total FC values. The s.d. of the number of + FCs is shown to study the inter-subject variability for each sex and age group.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.g010

                                We + examine the inter-subject variability in FC with aging separately among the + sexes. A rising and precipitous fall in variability is noted among both sexes + for the 1000FCP subjects (Fig 7). However, + the peak variability occurs at the different junctures of 51\u201360 for males + and 61\u201370 for females when considering the total FC. A similar inverted + U-shape trend is noted with the SRPBS data (Fig + 8) but with the peak variance in inter-subject FC at the 61\u201370 age + group in males while the peak variability for females occurred during the + 51\u201360 interval. In Fig 9, the camCAN + results for the female subjects showed a similar spike in inter-subject variability + during middle age since the 41\u201350 and 51\u201360 year-old females had + the least consistency. The males show a variation in FC that is incongruous + to what we have noted thus far. Namely, they showed the greatest variance + in the young (18\u201330 and 31\u201340) and a relatively constant variance + in the latter decades. The NKI-RS male and female subjects show a rising and + precipitous falling in FC variability with aging (Fig + 10). The trends are similar to that for the aggregate 1000FCP since the + peak variabilities occur at 51\u201360 for males and 61\u201370 for females. + In both sexes the lowest variability is seen for the oldest age group.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Discussion

                                In + the course of healthy human aging, one may expect a monotonic relationship + with young brains having properties that are increasingly similar to aged + brains. The application of ML pipelines can aid in the discovery of fundamental + facets of brain aging including the role of sex. While our use of SVM was + motivated by prior works [5, + 26], the questions + and classification-based methodology are novel. The three intervals studied + in Fig 1 investigate questions pertaining + to the dynamics of brain aging among healthy subjects. A strong degree of + monotonicity was noted when considering the two extrema age groups as references + (interval 1 of Fig 1A). This was consistent + among three datasets that contained subjects of diverse demographics. A discrepancy + from a Spearman correlation value of one\u2013i.e., a completely monotonic + relationship\u2013points towards several practical considerations. For instance, + the study is prone to inter-subject variability since participants of the + same age may have very different genetic traits, environmental factors, and + life histories while participants in a different age group may be more similar + to each other with respect to the aforementioned factors.

                                \n

                                The analysis + that accommodated a new question of whether the CPs of young brains contain + structure that is conserved among progressively older brains (interval 2 of + Fig 1B) provides a less categorical answer. + While the majority of brains were classified as more similar to the aged group, + there was little indication of monotonicity in the classifiers\u2019 decisions + across the age spectrum. The difference in CP among younger brains was not + indicative of nor resonated to the CP changes of the older brains. Conversely, + it is interesting that information can be gained about the connectivity of + young brains through the CPs of strictly older brains (i.e. interval 3 of + Fig 1C). In two of the datasets a linear + fit showed that the CP associated with old subjects (61+ y.o.) are informative + of relative changes in much younger subjects. Table + 3 contains the prominent hypotheses among the possible brain aging trajectories + in each interval for the datasets. The ML parameters as well as the results + attained via the post-processing are also listed. To the best of our knowledge, + this work presents the first evaluation of monotonicity in brain aging and + its quantification via ML. The analysis has gone beyond the paradigm of brain + age prediction from fMRI signals or changes in brain connectivity to probe + whether differences in CPs of young brains are reflective of the differences + in later life. Interestingly, the complementary question of whether the difference + in CPs of aged brains are informative of the changes seen by younger subjects + provided a different answer. For each of the three intervals in the monotonicity + study, a 5-year sliding window was applied for smoothing. This was done prior + to fitting a linear regression to the percentage of subjects that were classified + as aged across the spectrum. The analysis was also performed without the sliding + window (S1 Fig) and we did not witness + a change in the conclusions. It is noteworthy that the Spearman CC values + were smaller in magnitude without the sliding window. This is expected because + not smoothing may obfuscate or hide trends if the data at a single age contains + outliers or when fewer, non-representative subjects exist at an age. The interval + 1 subjects in Figs 3\u20135 + that deviate from a monotonic relationship deserve further discussion. This + is explained by the limitation in the number of subjects as well as the empirical + nature of the collected data. Despite a smoothing operation having been applied, + the percentage of subjects classified as aged was computed for every year + in the interval. This temporal resolution further contributed to specific + ages consisting of a fewer number of subjects and the likelihood of a non-representative + CP affecting the results at a particular age. Another factor follows from + the choice of the monotonicity measure. Although a commonly used metric, the + Spearman CC is a measure of linear monotonicity. Conversely, the BOLD signal + as well as the aging process are nonlinear processes at both the micro- and + macroscale. As increased data, analysis, and results come forth, it will perhaps + be possible to thoroughly assess the suitability of nonlinear measures of + monotonicity for explaining brain aging dynamics.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 3. + The comparative parameters and results of the monotonicity study conducted + with the three datasets.

                                The + intercept (\u03B20) and slope (\u03B21) attained via + a linear fit to the percentage of subjects classified as aged in intervals + 1, 2, and 3 are included. The Spearman CC and fitted parameters were used + to determine the prominent hypothesis among the possible brain aging trajectories.

                                \n

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.t003

                                While + quantitative ML analysis of how brain connectivity dynamics are modulated + by aging is important, it is also necessary to be cognizant of the features + that are input to the predictive algorithm. The Pearson CC has been used as + a measure of the degree and direction of the relationship\u2013i.e. connectivity\u2013among + pairs of ROIs. This measure and its transformations are prevalent in rsfMRI + works that investigate the effects of aging on CPs. Drawing upon several recent + studies, in [27] task-evoked + and rsfMRI were collected from subjects spanning 20 to 93 years. The connectivity + comparisons concluded that large-scale brain organization was maintained during + aging, but parcellation differences existed among age groups and increased + with larger differences in age. Conversely, the resting and task fMRI data + analyzed in [28] led + the authors to conclude that FC was lower in older adults. Correlational analysis + in [29] also noted + that aging led to a decrease in strong FC across the brain. The decrease in + modularity was quantified by more uniform activity patterns among the ROIs + of the older subjects. The more diffuse and fewer strongly correlated functional + connections with older age has been referred to as functional dedifferentiation + [30\u201332]. We also note a definitive change in FC with increasing + age that is more significant in the latter decades of the subjects. Two of + the datasets show the strength of the connections to decrease (supporting + functional dedifferentiation) while contrary results were noted with the SRPBS + cohort. The general decrease in the mean number of significant CC values with + increasing age is consistent with several prior reports of the modularity + in functional networks decreasing with aging [11, 29, + 33, 34]. A recent work found mostly weakened connectivity + with aging among subjects, but an increase in several cases [8]. The authors attribute the increases to the within + network FC of several prominent systems such as the visual and somatomotor. + In [35] a four-year + longitudinal analysis of N = 16 elderly subjects (69+ y.o. at the start of + the study) was undertaken. The results revealed a decrease in FC in two of + the three considered brain networks. Such findings are interesting in accommodating + the non-unanimous results noted here when considering three distinct datasets.

                                \n

                                The + BOLD fMRI signal has been processed to quantify FC in assessing a large scale + of phenotypes studied in resting and task-based studies. Surprisingly, much + less attention has been given to its inter-subject variability. In this work + the variability in FC was studied by computing the s.d. at various decades. + An inverted U-shape was noted in quantifying the variability in two of the + three datasets where the middle-aged-to-elder subjects\u2014i.e. 51\u201360 + y.o.\u2014showed the highest variability. The findings point toward brain + aging being a complex process where alterations in cohorts do not simply increase, + decrease, or remain constant across the decades of life. The peak in variability + during middle age presents intriguing possibilities as far as peoples\u2019 + lifestyle, occupation, and perhaps their personality being the most different + during that juncture. Interestingly, the peak occurred at different junctures + within the middle-to-elder range for male and female subjects.

                                \n

                                Another largely + neglected facet of connectivity-based fMRI analysis is the consideration of + anticorrelations. While we note that the relative change of significant anticorrelations + during aging generally follow what was seen for the positive correlations, + there were discrepancies. Perhaps more importantly, including the negative + correlations in a tally of the connectivity changes does lead to altered or + new findings. With the 1000FCP subjects, if one was to restrict attention + to the canonical positive connections, then a significant decrease in connectivity + would be seen between the two earliest decades of the considered ages. However, + incorporating the anticorrelations into the total indicates that the change + is not significant. Additionally, for the 1000FCP data, the loss of FC in + the male subjects for the 81+ y.o. group was not deemed significant when accounting + for only the positive correlations (or the anticorrelations)\u2013yet, the + aggregate account shows statistical significance. A similar result occurred + for the oldest group of male SRPBS subjects. Namely, counting the standard + (positive) correlations showed no significant alteration in the number of + functional connections, whereas the inclusion of anticorrelations indicated + that the FC of 71+ y.o. males is modulated in comparison to the reference + young group. This reveals that when assessing FC, an aggregate connectivity + measure should be considered rather than solely positive correlations.

                                \n

                                Human + and animal studies are increasingly becoming cognizant of the differences + between the sexes and performing separate analyses. Thus, the attainment of + trajectories of healthy brain aging in males and females is important. Repeating + the per-decade FC analysis for male and female subjects provided several findings. + First, the changes in connectivity with aging were similar between males and + females in the three datasets. Second, the modulation in the dynamics were + more pronounced (i.e. statistically significant) for males. Such a result + would be important to take into account when assessing deviations from a baseline + in a male versus a female. Perhaps most importantly, the results reveal that + the modulation in FC with age is not as prominent when male and female subjects + are considered separately rather than together. This accentuates the prudence + of separate sex analyses in age-related studies across a population. The inter-subject + variability in FC among the sexes also yielded interesting results. Although + the peak variabilities occurred at different junctures in the age spectrum + between males and females, they occurred in the middle-to-elder range. This + result, however, did not hold in one dataset where the youngest group of males + exhibited the largest variance. Such discrepancy highlights the general difficulty + in attaining consensus across datasets in light of the brain being a nonlinear + stochastic system while aging is a complex process. It also warrants the requirement + of further scrutiny via additional datasets, methodologies, and computation.

                                \n

                                The + datasets considered in this work share similarities as well as differences. + The 1000FCP subjects spanned 17 centers necessitating an investigation of + site effects. The monotonicity and change in FC analyses were repeated on + subjects from the NKI-RS center to investigate if the trends noted with all + subjects coincide with those seen for the largest constituent center. Interval + 1 results on the presence and degree of monotonicity coincided with those + attained for 1000FCP. The interval 2 findings also agreed on the absence of + a monotonic relationship. Contrarily, the interval 3 conclusions were different + because the NKI-RS analysis did not reflect a monotonic relationship. Aside + from possible site effects, such deviation may be due to the single-site dataset + providing a fewer number of subjects in the ML training set as well as in + the test set. The change in FC analysis conducted on the NKI-RS subjects provided + results that were very similar to the aggregate results. In the constituent + and the 1000FCP, there was an increase in variability among middle age to + elder subjects, and a reduction in FC variability for the two oldest decades. + The trends noted for the positive and negative correlations also coincided. + Furthermore, the sex differences in FC that were observed in the NKI-RS subjects + agreed with those of the collective dataset. In summary, the results are suggestive + of site effects not being prominent in the results presented for the 1000FCP + recordings. Nevertheless, the use of harmonization techniques [36, 37] + is a future avenue for further assessing to what degree the presented results + may be affected.

                                \n

                                The SRPBS and camCAN studies maintained a constant + protocol with respect to all subjects having their eyes open and closed, respectively, + during the recordings. This was not the case with the 1000FCP dataset (S1 Table). It is not unusual for rsfMRI investigations + to consider a mixture of subjects of different arousal states [11, 38]. + Nevertheless, we consider the monotonicity and quantification of FC separately + for the 1000FCP recordings where subjects had their eyes open. The conclusions + of the monotonicity analysis when subjects had their eyes open (N = 543) generally + agreed with those attained with the aggregated subjects (S2 + Fig). The hypotheses derived from interval 1 and interval 2 agree between + the two studies. However, the interval 3 results indicate the absence of a + monotonic relationship between the chronological age and the percentage of + subjects classified as aged when considering only subjects with eyes open + during recordings (S2C Fig). The findings + pertaining to the change in FC across decades were consistent when considering + all 1000FCP subjects and separately studying the subjects with eyes open (S2D Fig).

                                \n

                                The study of + FC alterations with aging was repeated with thresholds of |\u03C1 = 0.45| + and |\u03C1 = 0.7| for declaring connections (S3 + and S4 Figs). Scrutiny with lower and higher + thresholds aims to expurgate spurious relationships that would arise with + noise-dominated signals (i.e. low SNR recordings). With the decreased value + of |\u03C1 = 0.45|, the per-dataset trends in the mean and variability of + the number of FCs across the age spectrum matched what was reported in Fig 6. There were naturally a larger number + of FCs per age group with the lower threshold. Similarly, although a higher + threshold lowered the number of FCs in every age group, the trends in the + mean and variability were consistent to those observed in Fig + 6. The results are reassuring by reproducing the findings despite less + stringent as well as more conservative threshold values from what we initially + considered. Nevertheless, more detailed analysis of the FC dependency during + aging on the SNR and threshold values is an avenue of future research. There + is an additional caveat of the number of ROIs not being constant among the + considered datasets. However, it is not uncommon in fMRI studies that examine + multiple datasets to assess BOLD differences with different ROI numbers and + selection schemes [39\u201341]. For instance, the + authors of [42] compared + age prediction results with 419 ROIs from HCP subjects and 55 ROIs from UK + Biobank subjects. Despite the ML pipeline ensuring that the same number of + young and aged subjects are used to train an SVM, there is an unequal number + of subjects considered across the age groups in the datasets. This is a consequence + of the subject imbalance between ages that exists in neuroimaging studies + where age is a predictive variable and spans a broad range. Rather than being + a hinderance, this is standard among related works [8, 43]. + The number of data points across the subjects at different recording centers + was also not constant. This is consistent with related works such as [11, 44]. + A recent work evaluated brain age prediction accuracy for varying number of + time points and observed improvements with the number of time points [45]. However, the increases were reported as being relatively + small. Lastly, it should be noted that more sophisticated and computationally + demanding algorithmic techniques such as DL may provide more accurate prediction + results and reveal FC properties in any one of the considered datasets. However, + the techniques may also overfit a different dataset to provide marginal predictive + capability and obscure FC characteristics by not generalizing. An SVM classifier + was considered in this work due to its simplicity, general robustness, and + interpretability. A comparative study with more advanced methods is a future + avenue of investigation.

                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Supporting + information

                                S1 + Fig. Brain age monotonicity without application of a sliding window.

                                The results of the brain age + monotonicity study for intervals 1, 2, and 3 without application of a 5-year + sliding window. To test for a trend, a linear regression was fit to the data + with the intercept \u03B20 and slope \u03B21. A) For + 1000FCP subjects, in interval 1 we have \u03B20 = 31.49, \u03B21 + = 0.971. The Spearman correlation of 0.549 computed among the percentages + of subjects classified as aged and the ages indicates a moderate degree of + monotonicity between the two quantities. In interval 2 we attain \u03B20 + = 70.94, \u03B21 = -0.108 indicating little change in the classification + of increasingly older brains as aged. The Spearman correlation of -0.053 reflects + a non-monotonic relationship among the ages and the percentage of subjects + classified as aged. For interval 3, the values \u03B20 = 24.33, + \u03B21 = 0.568, and the Spearman correlation of 0.404 signifies + a gradual increase and small degree of monotonicity. B) When considering the + SRPBS subjects, in interval 1 we have \u03B20 = 6.647, \u03B21 + = 2.749. The Spearman correlation of 0.818 computed among the percentages + of subjects classified as aged and the ages demonstrates monotonicity between + the two quantities. In interval 2 we attain \u03B20 = 82.49, \u03B21 + = 0.054 indicating little change in the classification of increasingly older + brains as aged. The Spearman correlation of 0.108 reflects a non-monotonic + relationship among the subjects\u2019 ages and the percentage labeled as aged. + For interval 3, the values \u03B20 = 3.48, \u03B21 = + 0.748, and the Spearman correlation of 0.544 indicates an increase and moderate + degree of monotonicity. C) For the camCAN dataset, in interval 1 we have \u03B20 + = 0, \u03B21 = 2.254. The Spearman correlation of 0.9027 computed + among the percentages of subjects classified as aged and the subject ages + signifies a high degree of monotonicity between the two quantities. In interval + 2 we attain \u03B20 = 76.42, \u03B21 = 0.3706 demonstrating + little change in the classification of increasingly older brains as aged. + The Spearman correlation of 0.386 reflects a non-monotonic relationship. For + interval 3, the values \u03B20 = 32.301, \u03B21 = -0.1968, + and the Spearman correlation of -0.118 indicate a gradual decrease and non-monotonicity + in the number of subjects classified as aged with increasing biological age. + D) With the NKI-RS subjects, in interval 1 we have \u03B20 = 39.71, + \u03B21 = 0.858. The Spearman correlation of 0.396 demonstrates + small to no monotonicity between the percentages of subjects classified as + aged and the ages. In interval 2 we attain \u03B20 = 64.78, \u03B21 + = 0.496 which indicates a gradual increase in the classification of increasingly + older brains as aged. The Spearman correlation of 0.371 reflects an absence + of monotonicity among the subjects\u2019 ages and the percentage labeled as + aged. For interval 3, the values \u03B20 = 45.75, \u03B21 + = -0.206, and the Spearman correlation of -0.112 indicates a non-monotonic + but decreasing relationship.

                                \n

                                https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.s001

                                (TIFF)

                                \n

                                S2 + Fig. Findings for subjects with eyes open during the rsfMRI recordings.

                                The results of the brain age + monotonicity and change in FC studies for subjects in the 1000FCP dataset + that had eyes open during rsfMRI recording. For the monotonicity study, the + histograms show the number of subjects classified as young and aged at every + considered age. A 5-year sliding window was applied and a linear regression + fit to the results with the intercept \u03B20 and slope \u03B21. + A) The analysis consists of a machine trained on the youngest and oldest groups + and presented with test data of intermediate-aged subjects. In interval 1 + we have \u03B20 = 22.71, \u03B21 = 1.34. The Spearman + correlation of 0.661 computed among the percentages of subjects classified + as aged and the ages indicates a moderate degree of monotonicity. B) A machine + was trained on the two youngest groups of subjects and then provided with + recordings from subjects 41+ y.o. (interval 2). The values \u03B20 + = 54.2, \u03B21 = 0.76, and a Spearman correlation of 0.325 indicate + an absence of monotonicity. C) A machine was trained on subjects from the + two oldest age groups prior to being presented with the task of classifying + younger subjects (21\u201360 y.o.) in interval 3. The linear fit values \u03B20 + = 34.32, \u03B21 = 0.25, and Spearman correlation of 0.047 signify + a non-monotonic relationship between chronological age and the percentage + of subjects classified as aged. D) The change in FC analysis consisted of + the mean FC computed by averaging across subjects the number of times that + the Pearson CCs from the connectivity matrix exceeded |\u03C1| = + 0.6. The s.d. of the number of functional connections is shown to study the + inter-subject variability across the age spectrum.

                                \n

                                https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.s002

                                (TIFF)

                                \n

                                S3 + Fig. Analysis of FC changes with threshold |\u03C1| = 0.45.

                                A study of the change in FC + for subjects across decades from the A) 1000FCP, B) SRPBS, and C) camCAN datasets. + A threshold |\u03C1| = 0.45 was used to determine if the Pearson + CCs from the connectivity matrix constituted a FC. The mean FC was computed + by averaging the FC values across the subjects in each age group. A bifurcation + of the FC to positive and negative (i.e. anticorrelations) directions is also + shown. Two-sample t-tests were used to assess the significance of the change + in FC with the youngest age group taken as the reference. A p-value of 0.05 + is the threshold for statistical significance in the pairwise comparisons + of positive, negative, and total FC values. The s.d. of the number of functional + connections is illustrated to study the inter-subject variability across the + age spectrum.

                                \n

                                https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.s003

                                (TIFF)

                                \n

                                S4 + Fig. Analysis of FC changes with threshold |\u03C1| = 0.7.

                                A study of the change in FC + for subjects across decades from the A) 1000FCP, B) SRPBS, and C) camCAN datasets. + A threshold |\u03C1| = 0.7 was used to determine if the Pearson CCs + from the connectivity matrix constituted a FC. The mean FC was computed by + averaging the FC values across the subjects in each age group. A bifurcation + of the FC to positive and negative (i.e. anticorrelations) directions is also + shown. Two-sample t-tests were used to assess the significance of the change + in FC with the youngest age group taken as the reference. A p-value of 0.05 + is the threshold for statistical significance in the pairwise comparisons + of positive, negative, and total FC values. The s.d. of the number of functional + connections is illustrated to study the inter-subject variability across the + age spectrum.

                                \n

                                https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.s004

                                (TIFF)

                                \n

                                S1 + Table. 1000FCP subjects with eyes open or closed.

                                A listing of the subjects from the 1000FCP with eyes open + (N = 543) or closed (N = 197) during the rsfMRI recording.

                                \n

                                https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0300720.s005

                                (TIFF)

                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n

                                Acknowledgments

                                \n

                                The + author acknowledges Itamar Kahn and Noam Bosak for providing the 1000FCP data, + material and methods, as well as feedback on the manuscript. I also thank + Daniela Kaufer and Jack Gallant for valuable discussions.

                                \n

                                References

                                1. 1.\n Kim + J., et al., \u201CAbnormal intrinsic brain functional network dynamics in + Parkinson\u2019s disease,\u201D Brain, 2017. pmid:29053835
                                2. 2.\n + \ Habes M., et al., \u201CThe Brain Chart of Aging: + Machine-learning analytics reveals links between brain aging, white matter + disease, amyloid burden, and cognition in the iSTAGING consortium of 10,216 + harmonized MR scans,\u201D Alzheimer\u2019s & Dementia, 2021. pmid:32920988 +
                                3. 3.\n + \ Mattson M. and Arumugam T., \"Hallmarks of brain + aging: adaptive and pathological modification by metabolic states,\" Cell + Metabolism, 2018. pmid:29874566
                                4. 4.\n + \ Cole J., et al., \u201CAbnormal intrinsic brain + functional network dynamics in Parkinson\u2019s disease,\u201D Molecular Psychiatry, + 2018.
                                5. 5.\n + \ Dosenbach N., et al., \u201CPrediction of individual + brain maturity using fMRI,\u201D Science, 2010. pmid:20829489
                                6. 6.\n + \ Cole J., \u201CMulti-modality neuroimaging brain-age + in UK Biobank: relationship to biomedical, lifestyle and cognitive factors,\u201D + Neurobiology of Aging, 2020.
                                7. 7.\n + \ Khosla M., Jamison K., Ngo G., Kuceyeski A., and + Sabuncu M., \u201CMachine learning in resting-state fMRI analysis,\u201D Magnetic + Resonance Imaging, 2019. pmid:31173849
                                8. 8.\n + \ Zhou Z., et al., \u201CMultiscale functional connectivity + patterns of the aging brain learned from harmonized rsfMRI data of the multi-cohort + iSTAGING study,\u201D NeuroImage, 2023. pmid:36731813
                                9. 9.\n + \ Pervaiz U., Vidaurre D., Woolrich M., and Smith + S., \u201COptimising network modelling methods for fMRI,\u201D NeuroImage, + 2020. pmid:32062083
                                10. 10.\n + \ Fair D., et al., \u201CFunctional brain networks + develop from a \u201Clocal to distributed\u201D organization,\u201D PLoS Computational + Biology, 2009.
                                11. 11.\n + \ Siman-Tov T., et al., \u201CEarly age-related functional + connectivity decline in high-order cognitive networks,\u201D Frontiers in + Aging Neuroscience, 2017. pmid:28119599
                                12. 12.\n + \ Abdulrahman H., et al., \u201CDopamine and memory + dedifferentiation in aging,\u201D NeuroImage, 2017. pmid:25800211
                                13. 13.\n + \ Mennes M., Biswal B., Castellanos F., and Milham + M., \u201CMaking data sharing work: the FCP/INDI experience,\u201D NeuroImage, + 2013. pmid:23123682
                                14. 14.\n + \ Nooner K., et al., \u201CThe NKI-Rockland sample: + a model for accelerating the pace of discovery science in psychiatry,\u201D + Frontiers in Neuroscience, 2012.
                                15. 15.\n + \ Van Dijk K., et al., \u201CIntrinsic functional + connectivity as a tool for human connectomics: theory, properties, and optimization,\u201D + Journal of Neurophysiology, 2010. pmid:19889849
                                16. 16.\n + \ Kahn I., et al., \u201CDistinct cortical anatomy + linked to subregions of the medial temporal lobe revealed by intrinsic functional + connectivity,\u201D Journal of Neurophysiology, 2008. pmid:18385483
                                17. 17.\n + \ Tanaka S., et al., \u201CA multi-site, multi-disorder + resting-state magnetic resonance image database,\u201D Scientific Data, 2021. + \ pmid:34462444
                                18. 18.\n + \ Shafto M., et al., \u201CThe Cambridge Centre for + Ageing and Neuroscience (Cam-CAN) study protocol: a cross-sectional, lifespan, + multidisciplinary examination of healthy cognitive ageing,\u201D BMC Neurology, + 2014. pmid:25412575
                                19. 19.\n + \ Taylor J., et al., \u201CThe Cambridge Centre for + Ageing and Neuroscience (Cam-CAN) data repository: Structural and functional + MRI, MEG, and cognitive data from a cross-sectional adult lifespan sample,\u201D + NeuroImage, 2017. pmid:26375206
                                20. 20.\n + \ Kahn I. and Shohamy D., \u201CIntrinsic connectivity + between the hippocampus, nucleus accumbens, and ventral tegmental area in + humans,\u201D Hippocampus, 2013. pmid:23129267
                                21. 21.\n + \ Yahata N., et al., \u201CA small number of abnormal + brain connections predicts adult autism spectrum disorder,\u201D Nature Communication, + 2016. pmid:27075704
                                22. 22.\n + \ Power J., et al., \u201CMethods to detect, characterize, + and remove motion artifact in resting state fMRI,\u201D NeuroImage, 2014. + \ pmid:23994314
                                23. 23.\n + \ Ashburner J. and Friston K., \u201CUnified segmentation,\u201D + NeuroImage, 2005. pmid:15955494
                                24. 24.\n + \ Ashburner J., \u201CA fast diffeomorphic image registration + algorithm,\u201D NeuroImage, 2007. pmid:17761438
                                25. 25.\n + \ Tomasi D. and Volkow N., \u201CFunctional connectivity + density mapping,\u201D PNAS, 2010. pmid:20457896
                                26. 26.\n + \ Vergun S., et al., \u201CCharacterizing functional + connectivity differences in aging adults using machine learning on resting + state fMRI data,\u201D Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, 2013. pmid:23630491 +
                                27. 27.\n + \ Han L., et al., \u201CFunctional parcellation of + the cerebral cortex across the human adult lifespan,\u201D Cerebral Cortex, + 2018. pmid:30307480
                                28. 28.\n + \ Hughes C. et al., \u201CAging relates to a disproportionately + weaker functional architecture of brain networks during rest and task states,\u201D + NeuroImage, 2020. pmid:31926282
                                29. 29.\n + \ Song J., et al., \"Age-related reorganizational + changes in modularity and functional connectivity of human brain networks,\" + Brain Connectivity, 2014. pmid:25183440
                                30. 30.\n + \ Malagurski B., et al., \u201CFunctional dedifferentiation + of associative resting state networks in older adults\u2013a longitudinal + study,\u201D NeuroImage, 2020. pmid:32105885
                                31. 31.\n + \ Damoiseaux J., \u201CEffects of aging on functional + and structural brain connectivity,\u201D Neuroimage, 2017. pmid:28159687 +
                                32. 32.\n + \ Geerligs L., et al., \"A brain-wide study of age-related + changes in functional connectivity,\" Cerebral Cortex, 2015. pmid:24532319 +
                                33. 33.\n + \ Li X., et al., \u201CAge-related changes in brain + structural covariance network,\u201D Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2013. +
                                34. 34.\n + \ Hrybouski S., et al., \u201CInvestigating the effects + of healthy cognitive aging on brain functional connectivity using 4.7 T resting-state + functional magnetic resonance imaging,\u201D Brain Structure and Function, + 2021.
                                35. 35.\n + \ Oschmann M., et al., \u201CA longitudinal study + of changes in resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging functional + connectivity networks during healthy aging,\u201D Brain Connectivity, 2020. + \ pmid:32623915
                                36. 36.\n + \ Yu M., et al., \u201CStatistical harmonization corrects + site effects in functional connectivity measurements from multi-site fMRI + data,\u201D Human Brain Mapping, 2018. pmid:29962049
                                37. 37.\n + \ Pomponio R., et al., \u201CHarmonization of large + MRI datasets for the analysis of brain imaging patterns throughout the lifespan,\u201D + NeuroImage, 2020. pmid:31821869
                                38. 38.\n + \ Raut R., et al., \u201COrganization of propagated + intrinsic brain activity in individual humans,\u201D Cerebral Cortex, 2020. + \ pmid:31504262
                                39. 39.\n + \ Geerligs L., et al., \u201CState and trait components + of functional connectivity: individual differences vary with mental state,\u201D + Journal of Neuroscience, 2015. pmid:26468196
                                40. 40.\n + \ Dadi K., et al., \u201CBenchmarking functional connectome-based + predictive models for resting-state fMRI,\u201D NeuroImage, 2019. pmid:30836146 +
                                41. 41.\n + \ Ahrends C., et al., \u201CData and model considerations + for estimating time-varying functional connectivity in fMRI,\u201D NeuroImage, + 2022. pmid:35217207
                                42. 42.\n + \ He T., et al., \u201CDeep neural networks and kernel + regression achieve comparable accuracies for functional connectivity prediction + of behavior and demographics,\u201D NeuroImage, 2020. pmid:31610298
                                43. 43.\n + \ Kim E., et al., \u201CConnectome-based predictive + models using resting-state fMRI for studying brain aging,\u201D Experimental + Brain Research, 2022. pmid:35922524
                                44. 44.\n + \ Haak K., Marquand A., and Beckmann C., \u201CConnectopic + mapping with resting-state fMRI,\u201D NeuroImage, 2018. pmid:28666880
                                45. 45.\n + \ Guan S., Jiang R., Meng C., and Biswal B., \u201CBrain + age prediction across the human lifespan using multimodal MRI data,\u201D + GeroScience, 2024. pmid:37733220
                                \n\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n + \
                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n + \
                                \n \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n \n \n \n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n" + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:41 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Vary: + - Accept-Encoding + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '261664' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.78 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969 + response: + body: + string: 'Handle Redirect + + https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969' + headers: + CF-RAY: + - a4a70532e8df6bc5-DFW + Connection: + - keep-alive + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=utf-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:42 GMT + Nel: + - '{"report_to":"cf-nel","success_fraction":0.0,"max_age":604800}' + Report-To: + - '{"group":"cf-nel","max_age":604800,"endpoints":[{"url":"https://a.nel.cloudflare.com/report/v4?s=j%2BgbxXOQ2FySw3jv8ksuWEkwjnwBVLYYck%2BqRxEulrsXeJ4hwTNCzdjKwQp0MRkoXxC%2B5ulBBeb%2FkpvZ%2B1XEpt52gsfwmWX1QC8QSMeIG%2FH9H5F7ffLqJ04%3D"}]}' + Server: + - cloudflare + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + alt-svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=86400 + cf-cache-status: + - DYNAMIC + expires: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 14:25:55 GMT + location: + - https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969 + permissions-policy: + - interest-cohort=(),browsing-topics=() + vary: + - Origin + - Accept + status: + code: 302 + message: Found +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.78 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969 + response: + body: + string: ' + + + + 301 Moved Permanently + + + +

                                Moved Permanently

                                + +

                                The document has moved here.

                                + +
                                + +
                                Apache Server at dx.plos.org Port 80
                                + + + + ' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000 + Content-Length: + - '338' + Content-Type: + - text/html; charset=iso-8859-1 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:42 GMT + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0303969 + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CJqKpvaP-q6UXBAD; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + Via: + - 1.1 google + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.78 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/doi?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0303969 + response: + body: + string: '' + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Length: + - '0' + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:42 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Location: + - https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0303969 + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Set-Cookie: + - GCLB=CP-CyZjd_cCMchAD; path=/; HttpOnly + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + status: + code: 301 + message: Moved Permanently +- request: + body: null + headers: + Accept: + - '*/*' + Accept-Encoding: + - gzip, deflate + Connection: + - keep-alive + Cookie: + - GCLB=CP-CyZjd_cCMchAD + User-Agent: + - Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like + Gecko) Chrome/124.0.6367.78 Safari/537.36 + method: GET + uri: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0303969 + response: + body: + string: "\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n + \ \n\n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n \n\n \n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n \n + \ \n\n \n\n \n\n \n\n \n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n + \ \n\n\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n + \ \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n Insights into + the effects of Friedreich ataxia on the left ventricle using T1 mapping and + late gadolinium enhancement | PLOS One\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n \n Skip to main + content\n \n\n
                                \n
                                Advertisement
                                \n\n \n
                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n \n
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n Browse Subject Areas\n
                                ?
                                \n + \
                                \n

                                Click through the PLOS taxonomy + to find articles in your field.

                                \n

                                For more information about + PLOS Subject Areas, click\n here.\n

                                \n + \
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n \n \n + \
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n
                                  \n
                                • \n

                                  Loading + metrics

                                  \n
                                • \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n
                                \n + \

                                Open Access

                                \n

                                Peer-reviewed

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Research Article

                                \n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n + \
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n
                                \n + \

                                Insights into + the effects of Friedreich ataxia on the left ventricle using T1 mapping and + late gadolinium enhancement

                                \n\n
                                  \n\n\n\n\n + \ \nRoger E. Peverill ,
                                  \n\n \n

                                  \n + \ Roles\n Conceptualization,\n\n Data + curation,\n\n Formal analysis,\n\n Funding acquisition,\n\n Investigation,\n\n + \ Methodology,\n\n Project administration,\n\n Resources,\n\n Software,\n\n + \ Supervision,\n\n Validation,\n\n Visualization,\n\n Writing \u2013 + original draft,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                                  \n

                                  + * E-mail: roger.peverill@monash.edu

                                  \n + \

                                  Affiliation\n Monash + Cardiovascular Research Centre, MonashHeart and Department of Medicine (School + of Clinical Sciences at Monash Health), Monash University and Monash Health, + Clayton, Victoria, Australia\n

                                  \n \n\n ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n\n \nKimberly Y. Lin, + \
                                  \n\n + \ \n

                                  \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Data curation,\n\n Formal analysis,\n\n Funding + acquisition,\n\n Investigation,\n\n Methodology,\n\n Project administration,\n\n + \ Resources,\n\n Software,\n\n Supervision,\n\n Validation,\n\n + \ Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                                  \n \n

                                  Affiliation\n Division of Cardiology, Children\u2019s + Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States of America\n + \

                                  \n\n + ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n\n \nMark A. Fogel, + \
                                  \n\n + \ \n

                                  \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Data curation,\n\n Formal analysis,\n\n Funding + acquisition,\n\n Investigation,\n\n Methodology,\n\n Project administration,\n\n + \ Resources,\n\n Software,\n\n Supervision,\n\n Validation,\n\n + \ Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                                  \n \n

                                  Affiliation\n Division of Cardiology, Children\u2019s + Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States of America\n + \

                                  \n\n + ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n\n \nMichael M. H. + Cheung,
                                  \n\n + \ \n

                                  \n Roles\n + \ Data curation,\n\n Formal analysis,\n\n Funding acquisition,\n\n + \ Investigation,\n\n Methodology,\n\n Project administration,\n\n + \ Resources,\n\n Software,\n\n Supervision,\n\n Validation,\n\n + \ Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                                  \n \n

                                  Affiliations\n Department of Cardiology, Royal Children\u2019s + Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia, \n Department of Paediatrics, + University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria, Australia, \n Heart Research + Group, Murdoch Children\u2019s Research Institute, Parkville, Victoria, Australia\n + \

                                  \n\n + ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n\n \nW. Stuart Moir, + \
                                  \n\n + \ \n

                                  \n Roles\n + \ Data curation,\n\n Formal analysis,\n\n Investigation,\n\n Methodology,\n\n + \ Resources,\n\n Software,\n\n Supervision,\n\n Validation,\n\n + \ Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                                  \n \n

                                  Affiliation\n Monash Cardiovascular Research Centre, + MonashHeart and Department of Medicine (School of Clinical Sciences at Monash + Health), Monash University and Monash Health, Clayton, Victoria, Australia\n + \

                                  \n\n + ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n\n \nLouise A. Corben, + \
                                  \n\n + \ \n

                                  \n Roles\n + \ Data curation,\n\n Investigation,\n\n Project administration,\n\n + \ Resources,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                                  \n \n

                                  Affiliation\n Bruce Lefroy Centre for Genetic Health + Research, Murdoch Children\u2019s Research Institute, Parkville, Victoria, + Australia\n

                                  \n\n ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n\n \nGlenn Cahoon, + \
                                  \n\n + \ \n

                                  \n Roles\n + \ Methodology,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n

                                  \n \n

                                  Affiliation\n Department + of Cardiology, Royal Children\u2019s Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia\n + \

                                  \n\n + ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n\n \nMartin B. Delatycki + \
                                  \n\n + \ \n

                                  \n Roles\n + \ Conceptualization,\n\n Funding acquisition,\n\n Project administration,\n\n + \ Resources,\n\n Supervision,\n\n Writing \u2013 review & editing\n + \

                                  \n \n

                                  Affiliations\n + \ Bruce Lefroy Centre for Genetic Health Research, Murdoch Children\u2019s + Research Institute, Parkville, Victoria, Australia, \n Victorian Clinical + Genetics Services, Parkville, Victoria, Australia\n

                                  \n\n ⨯ \n
                                  \n\n\n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n + \

                                Insights into the effects + of Friedreich ataxia on the left ventricle using T1 mapping and late gadolinium + enhancement

                                \n\n
                                  \n\n + \
                                • Roger E. Peverill, \n\n
                                • \n
                                • Kimberly + Y. Lin, \n\n
                                • \n
                                • Mark A. Fogel, \n\n + \
                                • \n
                                • Michael M. H. Cheung, \n\n
                                • \n + \
                                • W. Stuart Moir, \n\n
                                • \n
                                • Louise + A. Corben, \n\n
                                • \n
                                • Glenn Cahoon, \n\n + \
                                • \n
                                • Martin B. Delatycki\n\n
                                • \n\n
                                \n\n\n\n + \
                                \n
                                \n \"PLOS\"\n
                                x
                                \n
                                \n + \
                                \n
                                \n\n \n\n
                                \n + \
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n
                                \n \n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n \n\n\n\n

                                Abstract

                                \n
                                \n

                                Background

                                \n

                                The + left ventricular (LV) changes which occur in Friedreich ataxia (FRDA) are + incompletely understood.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Methods

                                \n

                                Cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) imaging was + performed using a 1.5T scanner in subjects with FRDA who are homozygous for + an expansion of an intron 1 GAA repeat in the FXN gene. Standard + measurements were performed of LV mass (LVM), LV end-diastolic volume (LVEDV) + and LV ejection fraction (LVEF). Native T1 relaxation time and the extracellular + volume fraction (ECV) were utilised as markers of left ventricular (LV) diffuse + myocardial fibrosis and late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) was utilised as + a marker of LV replacement fibrosis. FRDA genetic severity was assessed using + the shorter FXN GAA repeat length (GAA1).

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Results

                                \n

                                There + were 93 subjects with FRDA (63 adults, 30 children, 54% males), 9 of whom + had a reduced LVEF (<55%). A LVEDV below the normal range was present in + 39%, a LVM above the normal range in 22%, and an increased LVM/LVEDV ratio + in 89% subjects. In adults with a normal LVEF, there was an independent positive + correlation of LVM with GAA1, and a negative correlation with age, but no + similar relationships were seen in children. GAA1 was positively correlated + with native T1 time in both adults and children, and with ECV in adults, all + these associations independent of LVM and LVEDV. LGE was present in 21% of + subjects, including both adults and children, and subjects with and without + a reduced LVEF. None of GAA1, LVM or LVEDV were predictors of LGE.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Conclusion

                                \n

                                An + association between diffuse interstitial LV myocardial fibrosis and genetic + severity in FRDA was present independently of FRDA-related LV structural changes. + Localised replacement fibrosis was found in a minority of subjects with FRDA + and was not associated with LV structural change or FRDA genetic severity + in subjects with a normal LVEF.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n\n

                                Citation: Peverill RE, Lin KY, Fogel + MA, Cheung MMH, Moir WS, Corben LA, et al. (2024) Insights into the effects + of Friedreich ataxia on the left ventricle using T1 mapping and late gadolinium + enhancement. PLoS ONE 19(5):\n e0303969.\n \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969

                                Editor: + Vineeta Ojha, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, INDIA

                                Received: + October 23, 2022; Accepted: May 4, 2024; Published: + May 30, 2024

                                Copyright: \xA9 2024 Peverill + et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution + License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction + in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

                                Data + Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its + Supporting information files.

                                Funding: + This study was funded by the Friedreich Ataxia Research Alliance + (FARA) Bronya J Keats International Research Collaboration Award (curefa.org). + The funders had an advisory role in study design and data collection, but + no role in data analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.

                                Competing + interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests + exist.

                                Abbreviations:\n AOS,\n age + at onset of symptoms; BSA,\n body surface area; CMR,\n cardiac + magnetic resonance; ECV,\n left ventricular myocardial extracellular + volume fraction; FRDA,\n Friedreich ataxia; GAA1,\n number + of GAA repeats in the smaller allele of the FXN gene; LGE,\n late + gadolinium enhancement; LV,\n left ventricular; LVEDV,\n left + ventricular end-diastolic volume; LVEDVI,\n left ventricular end-diastolic + volume indexed to body surface area; LVEF,\n left ventricular ejection + fraction; LVESV,\n left ventricular end-systolic volume; LVM,\n + \ left ventricular mass; LVMI,\n left ventricular mass + indexed to body surface area; SDur,\n symptom duration; SV,\n stroke + volume

                                \n\n\n\n\n\n

                                Introduction

                                Friedreich ataxia + (FRDA) is an autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disease caused by pathogenic + variants in the FXN gene which encodes for the mitochondrial protein + frataxin [1]. Cardiac + disease is a frequent accompaniment of FRDA, can lead to arrhythmias and cardiac + failure, and is the most common cause of death [2\u20134]. + A proportion of subjects with FRDA develop a reduced LV ejection fraction + (LVEF) [5\u20137], and post mortem histology of the heart in FRDA has + shown extensive interstitial fibrosis, focal degeneration of muscle fibres + and active muscle necrosis [8]. + An increase in LV wall thickness and a reduction in LV chamber size are more + common than, and likely precede and predispose to, a subsequent reduction + of LVEF in FRDA [5\u20137, 9\u201315]. + However, there is little information about the histological changes in the + LV myocardium during the early stages of the disease process.

                                \n

                                A better understanding + of the changes which occur in the myocardium in FRDA prior to a reduction + in LVEF is important for future attempts to modify or prevent cardiac disease + progression. Cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) not only provides a gold standard + assessment for LV volumes and LV mass (LVM), but with the use of intravenous + gadolinium and late imaging to detect late gadolinium enhancement (LGE), it + also provides a non-invasive technique for the visualisation of localised + replacement myocardial fibrosis [16]. + Furthermore, sensitive quantitative information about more generalised changes + in the LV myocardium can be obtained using T1 mapping techniques [17]. Both native T1 relaxation time and calculated myocardial + extracellular volume fraction (ECV) have been shown to increase in the presence + of diffuse myocardial fibrosis [17\u201321]. However, there has + only been limited investigation in FRDA into the presence of LGE [6, 22\u201324] or diffuse myocardial + fibrosis [24].

                                \n

                                Approximately + 96% of FRDA is due to homozygosity for a GAA expansion in intron 1 of FXN, + with the other 4% being compound heterozygous for a GAA expansion and a different + FXN pathogenic variant. In the homozygous group, the number of GAA + repeats in the shorter allele of the FXN gene (GAA1) is inversely + related to cellular levels of frataxin [25, + 26], and there has + therefore been interest in the ability of GAA1 to explain cardiac disease + severity in FRDA. GAA1 has been reported to be a predictor of cardiac death + [3, 4], of progression to a reduced LVEF [7], and has also been associated with increased LV wall + thickness [4, 9, 10, + 12, 15, 27], + relative wall thickness (RWT) [22], + LV mass (LVM) [10, + 15, 28] and LVM index (LVMI) [9, 29] + and a smaller LV end-diastolic diameter (LVEDD) [4, 15] + and LV end-diastolic volume (LVEDV) [14, + 15]. The aims of the + present study using CMR with gadolinium injection in adults and children with + FRDA homozygous for GAA repeat expansions, were to quantify LV volumes, LVM, + native T1 time and ECV, to determine the presence and extent of LGE, and to + investigate the relationship of these LV variables with GAA1, age at onset + of symptoms (AOS), symptom duration (SDur), age and the age group (i.e. children + versus adults).

                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Materials and + methods

                                \n
                                \n

                                Subjects

                                \n

                                Children + and adults homozygous for a GAA expansion in intron 1 of FXN and + aged between 10 and 50 years were recruited through clinical research programs + (including the Collaborative Clinical Research Network in FA (CCRN-FA) and + from the Friedreich Ataxia clinics at Monash Health, Melbourne, Victoria, + Australia and the Children\u2019s Hospital of Philadelphia, PA, USA. Prior + to undergoing CMR all individuals had their renal function evaluated and estimated + glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) calculated to confirm the absence of renal + dysfunction and thus the safety of gadolinium administration. Individuals + with known ischemic heart disease, hypertension, more than mild valvular disease, + a persistent atrial arrhythmia or contraindications to CMR or gadolinium injection + were excluded from the study. Approval for this study was provided by the + Human Research Ethics Committee of the Royal Children\u2019s Hospital, Melbourne, + Victoria, Australia and the Institutional Review Board of the Children\u2019s + Hospital of Philadelphia, PA, USA. All participants in the study, or their + parents/guardians if the participant was aged under 18 years, provided written + informed consent as per the Declaration of Helsinki.

                                \n

                                Height and + weight were measured, and body surface area (BSA) and body mass index were + calculated, using standard formulae. AOS was defined as the time when an individual + or their parents first noted neurological or non-neurological symptoms of + FRDA, and SDur was defined as the time between AOS and the time of CMR testing. + GAA repeat size in the smaller (GAA1) and larger (GAA2) alleles of the FXN + gene were determined using a single in-house method at the Melbourne site + and from different commercial laboratories at the Philadelphia site. Clinical + severity of neurological disease was evaluated to provide a neurological profile + of the cohort by performance of the neurological component of the Friedreich + Ataxia Rating Scale (nFARS) within one month of the CMR study (available in + 81 subjects, score out of 125). A blood sample was drawn on the same day as + the CMR study for measurement of haematocrit (Hct).

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Cardiac magnetic resonance + protocol

                                \n

                                CMR studies were performed using similar protocols + on 1.5T magnetic resonance imaging units (Magnetom Avanto in Philadelphia + and Magnetom Aera in Melbourne; Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen, Germany). + Breath-held images were acquired in expiration, and a 4-lead vector-electrocardiogram + was recorded for gating purposes. Following standard localising images, true + fast imaging with steady-state precession (TrueFISP) cine images were acquired + in the 4-chamber, 2-chamber, and 3-chamber views and used to plan short axis + imaging. End-expiration basal, mid-cavity, and apical short axis native T1 + images were collected using the optimised parameter set of a Modified Look-Locker + Inversion recovery (MOLLI) research sequence provided by Siemens with an acquisition + rest/schema of 5(3)3 designed for long T1 values in native scans.

                                \n

                                An + IV injection of gadobutrol (Gadovist 1.0, Bayer AG, Berlin, Germany) at a + dose of 0.2 mmol/kg body weight was administered to all subjects and immediately + following contrast injection, TrueFISP cine functional imaging was obtained + in contiguous 7.0 mm slices in the short axis. At 10 minutes post contrast + administration a TI scout sequence was used to determine optimal inversion + time (average TI = 300 ms) for the late gadolinium enhanced (LGE) images, + 8 mm single slice mid ventricle, TR/TE: 23.67/1.1 ms, flip angle 30\xB0, 340 + mm FOV, and generated using 20 ms increments from 80 to 500 ms. LGE images + were collected using a free breathing phase sensitive inversion recovery (PSIR) + technique, as well as single slice, breath held, PSIR with whole ventricular + coverage in the short axis. Factors for the two sequences were adjusted to + allow direct comparison, typically TR 700 ms, FOV 340 x 280 mm, flip angle + 45\xB0, matrix = 256 x 192, TI = 300 ms, voxel size 1.3 x 1.3 x 8.0 mm.

                                \n

                                Post + contrast T1 mapping sequences were acquired at approximately 15 minutes post + contrast injection using an optimised parameter set for MOLLI using the same + slice thickness and positions as the native T1 images. TR/TE = 360/112 ms, + flip angle = 35\xB0, TI = 260 ms, FOV = 360 x 306 mm, matrix = 256 x 168, + interpolated voxel size = 1.4 x 1.4 x 8.0 mm, GRAPPA = 2 with 36 reference + lines. An acquisition/rest schema of 4(1)3(1)2 was employed to account for + short TI values post contrast.

                                \n

                                Standard + measurements of CMR volumes, LVM and LVEF, and analysis of T1 maps, were performed + at each site using cvi42 v5.3.2 (Circle Cardiovascular Imaging Inc, Calgary, + AB, Canada). Papillary muscles were included in the myocardial mass and excluded + from LV volumes. The presence of abnormalities of LV end-diastolic volume + (LVEDV) and LVM were determined using sex and BSA based criteria specific + for children or adults as appropriate, with papillary muscles excluded from + LVEDV and included in LVM, and 2 standard deviations (SD) from the mean representing + the upper and lower limits of the normal range [30]. Left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) was defined + as a LVM > 2 SD above the mean. A LVEF of <55% was defined as reduced. + The LVM volume ratio (LVMVR) was calculated as the ratio of LVM/LVEDV and + used as a marker of concentric LV geometry, with an upper limit of the normal + range of 0.9 in males and 0.8 in females [30]. For myocardial T1 analysis, manual epicardial and + endocardial contours were drawn on the MOLLI mid ventricular short axis slice + and segmented according to the American Heart Association (AHA) 16 segment + model.

                                \n

                                Reported T1 based measurements were an average + of results from all the basal and mid LV segments as has been previously described + [31]. Extracellular + volume fraction (ECV) was calculated using the mean segmental pixel value + from the MOLLI ECV maps using the formula: ECV = (\u0394[1/T1myo]/\u0394[1/T1blood])*[1-Hct]). + A \"synthetic ECV\" was also calculated using a calculated haematocrit utilising + the equation: synthetic haematocrit = 831.6 * (1 / T1blood)\u20140.151 + [32]. Native T1 times + and ECV in individual FRDA subjects could not be classed into normal or abnormal + in this study because of the lack of an adequate comparison group. This is + because native T1 times and ECV are not only recognised to be machine and + protocol dependent, but also because they are sex- and probably also age-dependent + in adults [33\u201336]. Normal T1 values + therefore require large numbers of subjects of different ages and of both + sexes, but these were not available for either adults or children for this + study. To determine inter-rater reliability of T1 times in CMR studies, 19 + randomly chosen scans had T1 measurements repeated at the alternative site, + with the study images sent to the alternative site, and the second measurer + blinded to the previous measurements.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Statistical analysis

                                \n

                                Results + are expressed as mean \xB1 standard deviation or median [range] if not normally + distributed. Statistical analysis has been performed using Systat V13 (Systat + Software, Chicago, IL, USA). Some of the analyses have been confined to subjects + with a normal LVEF because the number of subjects with a reduced LVEF was + small, and also because the main focus of this study was on the early myocardial + changes which occur in FRDA. Children and adults were compared but also analysed + separately because of previous evidence that there may be differences in the + relationship of GAA1 with LV structural features based on age group [15]. Univariate linear regression analysis was performed + to assess the relationships of CMR variables with selected demographic and + FRDA-specific variables of interest based on previous findings about the cardiac + effects of FRDA. In particular, BSA, sex, age, age group (child v adult), + AOS, SDur and GAA1 were considered in analyses of LV volumes and LVM, and + sex [33\u201338], age [33\u201336], age group, heart + rate [34, 38], AOS, SDur and GAA1 were considered in analyses + of T1 mapping variables. The relationship of GAA2 with the above independent + variables was also investigated but it was not a predictor of any of the variables + and has not been reported in any of the analyses. Categoric variables were + included in multivariate models as dummy variables for sex (male = 1, female + = 0), age group (adults = 1, children = 0) and study site (Philadelphia = + 1, Melbourne = 0). SDur was not normally distributed and was log transformed + prior to inclusion in linear regression models. Log SDur was positively correlated + with age (r = 0.48, p<0.001) and GAA1 was negatively correlated with AOS + (r = -0.58, p<0.001), and therefore these relationships were considered + when constructing multivariate models. Independent variables were removed + during the multivariate modelling process if the p value was >0.10, but + the final models only show independent variables with a p<0.05. Scatter + plots and residuals were reviewed to determine if there were outliers, and + if identified, the possibility of exclusion of the outlier from the analysis + was considered.

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Results

                                There + were 96 subjects with FRDA who underwent CMR imaging, but of these, satisfactory + LV volume and mass measurements were not possible in 3 subjects, 2 because + of an irregular heart rate during image acquisition, and one because they + were found to have been dehydrated at the time of the study. The demographics + of the remaining 93 subjects, comprising 63 adults and 30 children, are shown + in Table 1. There were three subjects with + diabetes, all of whom were adults. The numbers for Melbourne and Philadelphia + are shown separately and demonstrate some variations in subject demography + between the two sites.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 1. + Demography of study subjects at each study site.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t001

                                \n
                                \n

                                Left + ventricular mass and volumes

                                \n

                                Of the 93 subjects there were 20 (22%) with LVH, + this comprising 10/30 (33%) of the children and 10/63 (16%) of the adults. + There were 36 subjects (39%) with a small LVEDV, and this comprised 30% of + the children and 42% of the adults. There were only 3 subjects who met the + criteria for a LVEDV above the normal range, all of whom were adults. There + were 9 subjects with a LVEF <55% (6 adults, 3 children), of whom 2 also + had LV dilatation and 3 also had an increased LVM. The results of indexed + LV volumes, LVMI, LVMVR and LVEF in subjects with a LVEF \u226555% (n = 84) + are shown in Table 2, with male and female + subjects shown separately. In a comparison of adult subjects with a normal + LVEF, LVMI, LVEDVI and LVESVI were all higher in males than females, whereas + LVEF was higher in females. LVMVR was greater than the upper limit of the + sex-specific normal range in 75/84 (89%) subjects, was higher in children + than adults (1.47\xB10.33 v 1.24\xB10.38 g/mL, p<0.01), but was similar + in adult males and females (p = 0.79).

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 2. + Left ventricular indexed volumes and mass in males and females with a normal + LVEF.

                                \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t002

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Predictors of LVEDV in subjects with a normal LVEF

                                \n

                                In + subjects with a LVEF \u226555% (n = 84), LVEDV was positively correlated with + BSA (r = 0.76, p<0.001) and was higher in males (p<0.001), but male + sex was only a borderline significant predictor of LVEDV after adjusting for + BSA (p = 0.053). After adjustment for BSA and sex, LVEDV was not different + between children and adults (p = 0.70). In adults (n = 57) after adjusting + for BSA and sex, AOS was a borderline positive correlate of LVEDV (p = 0.056), + but there were no contributions to the model of LVDEV from GAA1 (p = 0.39), + log SDur (p = 0.66) or age (p = 0.80). In a multivariate model of LVEDV, BSA + and AOS, but not sex, were independent predictors of LVEDV, with an earlier + AOS associated with a smaller LVEDV (Table + 3). In children (n = 27) BSA was a positive correlate of LVEDV (r = 0.73, + p<0.001), and after adjusting for BSA there was no independent contribution + from sex to the model (p = 0.80). After including BSA in multivariate models + of LVEDV in children there were no contributions from AOS (p = 0.17), GAA1 + (p = 0.12) or age (p = 0.15), but there was a borderline significant contribution + from log SDur (p = 0.05), with longer disease duration associated with a smaller + LVEDV.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 3. + Multivariate model of LVEDV in adult subjects with a normal LVEF.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t003

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Predictors of LVM in subjects with a normal LVEF

                                \n

                                In + subjects with a LVEF \u226555% (n = 84), LVM was positively correlated with + BSA (p<0.001), larger in males (p<0.001), and both BSA and sex were + independent predictors of LVM (p<0.001 for both). After adjustment for + BSA and sex, LVM was not different between children and adults (p = 0.11). + In adults (n = 57) after including BSA and sex in the model, there were additional + contributions from GAA1 (\u03B2 = 0.36), AOS (\u03B2 = -0.35) and age (\u03B2 + = -0.39), but not from log SDur (p = 0.57). The model which included GAA1 + (Table 4) explained a similar amount of + the variance of LVM to the model which contained AOS (Table + 5). Neither GAA1 nor AOS remained significant predictors in the model + of LVM when both independent variables were included together (p = 0.056 & + p = 0.062, respectively). Older age was an independent predictor of a lower + LVM in a model which included BSA, sex and GAA1 (Table + 4), whereas neither AOS nor age remained significant when age was added + to the combination of BSA, sex and AOS (p = 0.067 & p = 0.054, respectively). + GAA1 accounted for 10% and age accounted for an additional 5% of the variance + in LVM in adults. All the predictors of LVM in Table + 4 remained significant after excluding diabetic subjects from the analysis. + In children (n = 27) LVM was positively correlated with BSA (r = 0.54), and + male sex was a borderline significant predictor of a larger LVM (p = 0.066) + after adjusting for BSA. There were no significant contributions to the model + of LVM in children which included BSA and sex from any of GAA1 (p = 0.86), + AOS (p = 0.97), log SDur (p = 0.79) or age (p = 0.20).

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 4. + Multivariate model of LVM including GAA1 in adult subjects with a normal LVEF.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t004

                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 5. + Multivariate model of LVM including AOS in adult subjects with a normal LVEF.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t005

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                T1 relaxation + times

                                \n

                                T1 relaxation times pre and post gadolinium contrast, + the partition coefficient, and the ECV calculated using both the measured + Hct and the calculated Hct, in the total group, and subjects with normal and + reduced LVEF, are shown in Table 6. Post + contrast T1 imaging was not performed, and thus ECV was also not available, + in one of the subjects with a reduced LVEF. In the 87 subjects in whom both + methods for ECV calculation could be performed, the synthetic ECV using the + calculated Hct gave a slightly higher result (0.286\xB10.050 v 0.277\xB10.051, + p<0.001), but there was a close correlation between the two methods (r + = 0.97, p<0.001). Because it was available in all subjects the synthetic + ECV results have been used in all the modelling of ECV. Univariate p values + for comparison of normal LVEF with the reduced LVEF group are not provided + in Table 6 because there were a number + of potential confounding factors including sex and study site (see below).

                                \n

                                In + univariate analyses of the whole group, native T1 time was not different between + the study sites (p = 0.70), but it was higher in women than men (p<0.001) + and positively correlated with heart rate (r = 0.30, p = 0.003). After adjusting + for sex and heart rate, there was no difference in native T1 time between + subjects with a reduced versus a normal LVEF (p = 0.17). Post contrast T1 + time and ECV were both higher at the Philadelphia than the Melbourne site + (p<0.002 for both). After adjusting for study site, post contrast T1 time + was higher in men (p = 0.047), but not correlated with heart rate (p = 0.30) + and not different between those with a normal versus reduced LVEF (p = 0.47). + After adjusting for study site, ECV was not correlated with heart rate (p + = 0.15), there was a trend for it to be higher in females (p = 0.094), and + it was higher in subjects with a reduced LVEF (p = 0.001).

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Predictors of native T1 relaxation time in + subjects with a normal LVEF

                                \n

                                In subjects with a normal LVEF (n = 84), after + adjusting for sex, heart rate was a positive correlate of native T1 time (\u03B2 + = 0.21, p = 0.029) and children had a higher native T1 time than adults (p + = 0.02), but when included together in a model of native T1 time, neither + heart rate (p = 0.09) nor age group (p = 0.061) remained significant predictors. + In adults with a normal LVEF (n = 57), after adjusting for sex, GAA1 was an + independent positive correlate of native T1 time (\u03B2 = 0.21, p = 0.013), + whereas there were no contributions from any of heart rate (p = 0.30), AOS + (p = 0.57), log SDur (p = 0.35), age (p = 0.37), LVMI (p = 0.063) or LVEDVI + (p = 0.34). The multivariate model of native T1 time including sex and GAA1 + is shown in Table 7. GAA1 accounted for + 7% of the variance in native T1 time. There was one outlier with a native + T1 time of 861 ms (>3 SD below the group mean), but there was no significant + change in the findings when this outlier was excluded from the regression + analyses. GAA1 remained a predictor of native T1 time after exclusion of diabetic + subjects from the analysis (p = 0.025).

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 7. + Multivariate model of native T1 time in adult subjects with a normal LVEF.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t007

                                In + children with a normal LVEF, native T1 time was not higher in females (p = + 0.10), GAA1 was a positive correlate of native T1 time (r = 0.45, p = 0.02), + but there were no correlations of native T1 time with any of heart rate (p + = 0.77), AOS (p = 0.75), log SDur (p = 0.79), age (p = 0.10), LVMI (p = 0.89) + or LVEDVI (p = 0.88). GAA1 accounted for 17% of the variance in native T1 + time in children.

                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Predictors + of post contrast T1 relaxation time in subjects with a normal LVEF

                                \n

                                In + subjects with a normal LVEF (n = 84), after adjusting for study site, male + sex was a borderline predictor (p = 0.085) of a higher post contrast T1 time, + but there was no difference in post contrast T1 time between children and + adults (p = 0.19). When only adult subjects were analysed, however, both study + site and sex were independent predictors of post contrast T1 time (Table + 8). After adjusting for study site and sex, in adults there were no independent + contributions to the prediction of post contrast T1 time from GAA1 (p = 0.16), + AOS (p = 0.59), log SDur (p = 0.70), heart rate (p = 0.18), age (p = 0.21), + LVMI (p = 0.067) or LVEDVI (p = 0.056). There were no significant predictors + of post contrast T1 time in children (p>0.10 for all).

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 8. + Multivariate model of post contrast T1 time in adult subjects with a normal + LVEF.

                                \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t008

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Predictors of extracellular volume + fraction in subjects with a normal LVEF

                                \n

                                In subjects + with a normal LVEF (n = 84), ECV was higher at the Philadelphia site (p = + 0.002), and after adjustment for study site, it was higher in children than + adults (p = 0.013), but not different between males and females (p = 0.11). + In contrast, in separate analysis of adults with a normal LVEF (n = 57) after + adjustment for study site, female sex was associated with a higher ECV (p + = 0.006). In adults after adjustment for study site and sex, ECV was positively + correlated with GAA1 (\u03B2 = 0.30, p = 0.022), there was a positive correlation + with log SDur (\u03B2 = 0.365, p = 0.009), but only a borderline significant + contribution from AOS (p = 0.069), and no contributions from heart rate (p + = 0.25), age (p = 0.21), LVMI (p = 0.53) or LVEDVI (p = 0.89). A multivariate + model of ECV in which there were independent contributions from study site, + sex, GAA1 and log SDur is shown in Table 9. + GAA1 accounted for 7% of the variance of ECV and log SDur accounted for an + additional 7% of the variance in ECV. When diabetics were excluded from the + analysis, log SDur remained a significant predictor of ECV (p = 0.038), but + GAA1 was no longer significant (p = 0.066). In children there were no significant + predictors of ECV from study site, GAA1, AOS, log SDur, age, LVMI and LVEDVI + (p>0.10 for all).

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 9. + Multivariate model of ECV in adult subjects with a normal LVEF.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t009

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Reproducibility + of T1 measurements

                                \n

                                There were 19 randomly selected CMR studies (8 + from Melbourne and 11 from Philadelphia, with gadolinium administered in 18), + for which T1 measurements were performed independently by the investigators + at both sites. The results of the two measurements are shown in Table + 10. There were close correlations of T1 relaxation times for native myocardium + and blood (r = 0.96\u20130.97, n = 19) and for post contrast myocardium and + blood (r = 0.96\u20130.97, n = 18). There were no significant differences + in the repeated measurements for any of these variables.

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Table 10. + Blinded remeasurements of T1 relaxation times.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.t010

                                \n\n
                                \n

                                Late + gadolinium enhancement

                                \n

                                LGE was present in 19 of the 92 (21%) subjects + who had a contrast injection. One of these 19 only had LGE at an insertion + point. The number of segments involved in the other 18 subjects ranged from + 2\u201314 (median of 3). Examples of LGE in two of these subjects are shown + in Figs 1 and 2. + The most common site for LGE was mid myocardium, but there were also segments + with a subepicardial LGE location. There was only one subject in whom there + was evidence of transmural LGE, this being a subject with a reduced LVEF and + LGE in 14 segments. The walls most frequently involved in the 18 subjects + were the anterolateral and inferolateral walls. Only two subjects had LGE + in the septum. LGE was present in 20% of children and 21% of adults. In subjects + with a LVEF \u226555%, there were 14/83 (17%) with LGE and in subjects with + a LVEF<55% there were 5/9 (56%) with LGE. If more than 4 segments had LGE + there was always a reduced LVEF. In logistic regression analysis of all subjects, + a reduced LVEF was a predictor of LGE presence (p = 0.014), and there were + no additional contributions to the prediction of LGE by sex, age group, GAA1, + AOS, log SDur, age, LVEDVI or LVMI (p>0.10 for all). Similarly, in subjects + with a normal LVEF, none of sex, age group, GAA1, AOS, log SDur, age, LVEDVI + or LVMI were predictors of the presence of LGE (p>0.10 for all).

                                \n
                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 1. + A cardiac magnetic resonance image showing a short-axis section of the left + ventricle, with the red arrows showing mid myocardial late gadolinium enhancement + in the basal segment of the inferolateral wall.

                                \n + \ https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.g001

                                \"thumbnail\"
                                Fig 2. + A cardiac magnetic resonance image showing a short-axis section of the left + ventricle, with the red arrows on the left showing mid myocardial late gadolinium + enhancement in the septal wall and the red arrows to the right of and underneath + the ventricle showing epicardial late gadolinium enhancement in the anterolateral + and inferolateral walls.

                                \n https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.g002

                                The + 74 subjects without LGE were also investigated for an association of reduced + LVEF with native T1 time and ECV. A reduced LVEF was not a predictor of native + T1 time after adjustment for sex, heart rate and age group (p>0.50). However, + a reduced LVEF remained a predictor of an increased ECV after adjustment for + study site, age, sex and age group p = 0.04). In adult subjects with a preserved + LVEF (n = 48) and without LGE, after adjustment for sex, GAA1 was still an + independent predictor of native T1 time (\u03B2 = 0.33, p = 0.014) and after + adjustment for study site and log SDur, GAA1 was still an independent predictor + of ECV (\u03B2 = 0.35, p = 0.009).

                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Discussion

                                Standard + CMR measurements of LVM and LVEDV, in conjunction with T1 mapping techniques + and LGE, were utilised in this study to quantify LV structure and ultrastructure + in subjects with FRDA who were homozygous for GAA expansions in the FXN + gene. The relationships of FRDA genetic severity (GAA1) with macroscopic LV + structure (LVM and LVEDV) and LV ultrastructure (native T1 time, ECV and LGE) + were also investigated. Positive correlations of GAA1 with native T1 relaxation + time and ECV in FRDA subjects with a normal LVEF suggest an association between + the degree of frataxin deficiency and the percentage of diffuse interstitial + LV myocardial fibrous tissue. That these positive correlations were independent + of changes in LVM and LVEDV suggests that T1 mapping techniques provide information + about the LV myocardium which is at least partly independent of the recognised + LV macroscopic structural changes of FRDA. The marker of myocardial replacement + fibrosis, LGE, was found in only 21% of subjects with FRDA and there was substantial + individual variation in the number of LV segments involved. LGE was more frequent + in subjects with a reduced LVEF, but in subjects with a normal LVEF LGE was + not associated with GAA1, LVEDVI or LVMI. The absence of predictors of LGE + suggests that there is a different, and possibly idiosyncratic, mechanism + underlying the development of replacement fibrosis compared to diffuse fibrosis + in the early stages of cardiac disease in FRDA.

                                \n

                                In multivariate + models of LVEDV and LVM, BSA was the most important predictor of both variables, + and male sex was an independent predictor of a larger LVM in adults. The contribution + of male sex independently of BSA to a higher LVM is consistent with what is + found in healthy subjects and also with previous CMR and echocardiographic + findings in subjects with FRDA and a normal LVEF [11, 15]. + The findings of the current study again highlight the importance of taking + both body size and sex into account when categorising LV mass in FRDA, something + which has not been performed in some previous studies [4\u20136]. + The finding of an inverse relationship of LVM with age in the present cross-sectional + study is consistent with a previous echocardiographic study [15] and two CMR studies in FRDA [11, 24]. + This observation is at present unexplained and could represent a genuine reduction + in LVM during disease progression [29], + survivor bias, or a combination of both processes. In the present study, in + the absence of age in the model of LVM, log SDur was not a predictor of LVM, + this finding not supporting the hypothesis of a decrease in LVM during disease + progression in FRDA.

                                \n

                                In the present study LVM was increased above + the normal sex, age-group and BSA adjusted ranges in 34% of children and 16% + of adults. Meyer et al performed CMR in 41 adults with FRDA, 3 of whom had + a LVEF <50%, and reported an increase in LVMI in 29% of subjects [11]. While this frequency seems substantially higher + in comparison to the adults in the present study, the threshold for increased + LVMI used by Meyer et al was lower, sex differences were not taken into consideration, + and the LVM method used was different to the present study as it included + papillary muscles in the LV volume rather than in the LVM. Rajagopalan et + al also reported an increase in LVMI in FRDA compared to control subjects + in a CMR study which included adults and children with a normal LVEF. However, + the percentage of subjects with a LVMI above the normal range was not reported + in this study, nor was there differentiation made between the LVMI in males + and females [28]. An + increase in LVMI based on echocardiography in subjects with a LVEF >50%, + this study including some subjects from the current study at an earlier time + point, also found higher percentages of age group and sex-adjusted LVMI compared + to the present study (47% of children and 24% of adults) [15]. However, differences in the categorization of LVMI + by CMR and echocardiographic studies is likely to reflect, at least in part, + differences in both accuracy and reproducibility of the two techniques [39].

                                \n

                                More common than + an increase in LVM in the present study was the presence of an age-group, + sex and BSA adjusted LVEDV less than the lower limit of the normal range, + this being found in 39% of subjects (42% of adults and 30% of children). Thus, + a low LVEDV was more common in adults than children, whereas a high LVM was + more common in children than adults. Rajogapalan et al also reported a lower + LVEDV using CMR in FRDA compared to control subjects, but did not adjust for + age group, sex or BSA in their study [28]. + Our finding is consistent with echocardiographic studies which have reported + that the left ventricle is smaller in adults with FRDA and a normal LVEF when + compared to age and sex-matched control subjects [13, 14]. + The current study therefore provides additional evidence that the increases + in wall thickness and LVM in FRDA are associated with a negative LV cavity + remodelling process, as has also been reported in the sarcomeric hypertrophic + cardiomyopathies [40]. + With the combination of an increased LVMI and reduced LVEDVI in our cohort, + an increase in LVMVR was inevitable, and in subjects with a LVEF \u226555%, + the LVMVR was higher than the normal range in 89% of subjects in this study. + Not predictable given the different patterns of increased LVMI and decreased + LVEDVI in adults and children, was that the LVMVR in FRDA was higher in children + than adults.

                                \n

                                To the best of our knowledge this is the largest + study of LGE in FRDA, it may be the only study to assess the incidence in + LGE in a group including both adults and children, and it is also the only + study to investigate the predictors of the presence of LGE in FRDA. LGE was + only present in 21% of the subjects in the current study (age range 10\u201349 + years, SDur range up to 36 years), and in contrast to the LVEDVI and LVMI + differences between adults and children, this percentage was similar in adults + and children. LGE was more common in subjects with a reduced LVEF, but it + was not present in all subjects with a reduced LVEF. LGE location was mostly + in the mid myocardium but there was also subepicardial involvement, whereas + transmural LGE involvement was rare. The percentage of subjects with LGE in + previous studies in FRDA has been variable, and both higher and lower percentages + than those of the current study have been reported. Raman et al reported LGE + in 58% of 26 adult subjects with a normal LVEF (age range 18\u201357 years, + SDur not reported) [22]. + Weidemann et al reported LGE in 66% of 32 subjects (age 33\xB113 years, number + of children and SDur not reported), 25% of whom had a LVEF <55% [6]. All those with a reduced LVEF were positive for + LGE, whereas 13/25 (52%) with a normal LVEF had LGE. That children with FRDA + can develop LGE was also previously reported in 3 children with a normal LVEF + by Mavrogeni et al [23]. + Takazaki et al reported only 15% LGE positivity in 27 subjects with a normal + LVEF (age 28\xB110 years, number of children not reported, SDur = 13\xB18 + years) [24]. We can + provide no explanation for the substantial variation in LGE positivity in + the different studies, particularly given the absence of important details + about the age groups of the subjects and the SDur for some of the cohorts. + On the other hand, our finding that the mid myocardium was the most common + site for LGE is consistent with the findings of both Raman et al [22] and Weidemann et al [6].

                                \n

                                GAA1 is known to be inversely associated with + frataxin levels [25, + 26] and with the AOS + [15], and to be positively + associated with the severity of FRDA cardiac involvement [4, 41]. + In the present study, a larger GAA1 was associated with a larger LVM in adults + independently of both sex and body size. Positive correlations of GAA1 with + LVMI have been reported in some [9], + but not other [12, + 15], echocardiographic + studies, and have not been reported in previous CMR studies [11, 28]. + The discrepancies between studies regarding the relationship of GAA1 with + LVM could be because the correlation of GAA1 with LVM is relatively weak, + that the studies have been small, and/or that LVMI is less accurately calculated + with echocardiography compared to CMR [42]. + Although LVEDV was smaller than the normal range in 39% of subjects in the + current study, GAA1 was not a predictor of a lower LVEDV. A weak negative + correlation of GAA1 with LVEDV has been reported previously in one echocardiographic + study [15].

                                \n

                                We + also examined the relationship of AOS with LV variables in this study, although + issues related to collinearity needed to be considered given the expected + and observed inverse correlation of GAA1 with AOS (r = -0.60). In adults, + LVM was positively correlated with GAA1 and negatively correlated with AOS, + but these associations were not independent. In contrast, in adults, LVEDV + was positively correlated with AOS despite not being correlated with GAA1, + suggesting that the small contribution of AOS to the prediction of LVEDV was + independent of GAA1. The role of SDur was also investigated in this study, + but a longer SDur was only found to be an independent predictor of a smaller + LVEDV in children and a larger ECV in adults.

                                \n

                                After adjustment + for study site, the ECV was higher in subjects with a reduced LVEF compared + to those with a normal LVEF, and in the group of subjects with a normal LVEF, + it was higher in children than adults. A recent study reported on ECV in FRDA + subjects using a 3.0T machine [25], + finding it to be 0.36\xB10.05 in 27 subjects with FRDA and a normal LVEF who + were of age 28\xB110 years, this being substantially higher than the value + of 0.25\xB10.02 in the 10 control subjects in that study. In contrast, in + the current study using a 1.5T machine the ECV in subjects with a normal LVEF + was only 0.271\xB10.045 at the Philadelphia site and 0.242\xB10.030 at the + Melbourne site. One possible explanation for the much higher average ECV in + the Takazaki et al study compared to the present study is that it has been + reported that the native T1 time is longer when assessed by a 3T compared + to a 1.5T machine [38]. + Moreover, the type of acquisition sequence has been shown to affect both native + T1 time and ECV [37]. + In addition, the comparison with control subjects in the study of Takazaki + et al was confounded by the small size of the control group (n = 10), with + the imaging performed at a separate site and on a different machine, and the + adequacy of age and sex matching uncertain.

                                \n

                                The independent + positive associations of GAA1 with both native T1 time and ECV in the present + study provide evidence supporting a causal relationship between the severity + of frataxin deficiency and an increased ratio of interstitial fibrous/cardiomyocyte + volume in FRDA. However, there were no control subjects in the present study + and there is only limited data in the literature about normal sex and age + values for native T1 and post contrast T1 times and ECV based on the methodology + used in the present study. Our study can therefore provide no definitive evidence + that native T1 time and ECV are increased in FRDA, or how common abnormalities + in native T1 time and ECV might be in FRDA. That sex and age based normal + values are essential for this purpose is supported by studies in healthy subjects + in which males have a lower native T1 time and ECV than females [33\u201338] + and where there is at least a trend, possibly modified by sex, to a lower + native T1 time with older age [33\u201336]. In the present study + the native T1 time was lower in males, and the ECV was lower in adult males + with a normal LVEF, suggesting that similar to healthy subjects, in FRDA there + are not only sex effects on LVMI but also sex effects on the myocardium at + the ultrastructural level.

                                \n

                                There is the potential for clinical and ongoing + research roles for T1 mapping in FRDA given that both the native T1 time and + ECV can provide information about the LV myocardium prior to a reduction of + LVEF, and that this information is at least partly independent of the FRDA-associated + LV structural changes. However, the nature, timing and speed of the progression + of changes in T1 mapping variables in FRDA are unknown, and reproducibility + and robustness of T1 mapping techniques for serial testing are uncertain. + In the present study there were differences in post contrast T1 time and ECV + based on the study site even though the machines, protocols and analysis software + were similar at the two sites, and the explanation for this difference remains + uncertain. On the other hand, native T1 time did not appear to be influenced + by the study site, and this simpler technique provides the additional advantages + for the subject in that it does not require gadolinium injection and there + is also less scanning time required.

                                \n

                                There are a + number of limitations of this study. The number of children in the study was + fewer than the number of adults and this resulted in lower statistical power + to detect effects of FRDA on CMR variables in children. All studies in FRDA + are at least partly confounded by recruitment being limited to subjects who + have presented with symptoms and also by the absence of those subjects who + have had disease progression and died as a result of the disease. For a CMR + study in FRDA there is the additional limitation that some subjects were ineligible + because of the presence of spinal rods inserted for the treatment of FRDA-associated + scoliosis. An appropriate control group for T1 mapping would have enabled + determination of the frequency of T1 mapping variable abnormalities in FRDA. + However, this was not feasible as it would have required substantial numbers + at both sites to adequately match the age range and sex mix of the FRDA subjects. + Moreover, it would be difficult to justify the use of intravenous gadolinium + injection in normal children, or indeed to even be able to recruit healthy + children for such a study. A further limitation was that the methods for GAA + estimation differed and there is therefore a possibility of systematic differences + in GAA repeat lengths between the different assays. However, this possibility + is more likely to lead to false negative than false positive findings. Moreover, + adjustment for potential differences in techniques between the 2 institutions + has been addressed in part in the regression analyses in which GAA repeat + length was tested an independent variable by the inclusion of the institution + as a dummy variable. Although there were differences in the prediction of + ECV and post GAD T1 time based on institution there were no differences based + on institution in the prediction of native T1 time. This suggests that the + institutional differences could have been related to the post GAD data but + does not support an independent contribution from differences in GAA estimation. + Lastly, there is uncertainty regarding the mechanistic significance of some + of the regression analysis findings due to collinearity between GAA1 and AOS + and also between age and SDur. That there were independent effects of age + from SDur and vice versa was suggested by the evidence that age, but not SDur, + was an independent predictor for LVM in adult subjects with a normal LVEF + and that SDur, but not age, was an independent predictor of ECV in adult subjects + with a normal LVEF.

                                \n

                                In conclusion, there is an association between + diffuse interstitial LV myocardial fibrosis and genetic severity in FRDA, + with this effect being independent of the FRDA-associated LV changes in LVEDVI + and LVMI. Localised replacement fibrosis was found in a minority of subjects + with FRDA, this minority including both children and adults, and subjects + with and without a reduction of LVEF. In contrast to T1 mapping variables, + LGE in subjects with a normal LVEF was not associated with genetic severity, + and was also not associated with LVM or LVEDV, consistent with the development + of LGE in FRDA having an idiosyncratic element. There is the potential for + roles of both T1 mapping and LGE in the assessment and monitoring of the cardiomyopathy + of FRDA, but information will be required about their prognostic significance, + and more data will also be required regarding the reproducibility of T1 mapping + variables.

                                \n
                                \n\n

                                Supporting + information

                                S1 + File. Anthropomorphic and cardiac magnetic resonance data in subjects + with Friedreich ataxia.

                                https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303969.s001

                                (XLSX)

                                \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n

                                Acknowledgments

                                \n

                                We + would like to thank all subjects who generously volunteered their time to + participate in this study. In addition, we would like to thank Ms Genevieve + Tai from the Murdoch Children\u2019s Research Institute who provided laboratory + and research support and Michael Kean and the staff of the Royal Children\u2019s + Hospital MRI department for their expertise and support of this study.

                                \n

                                References

                                1. 1.\n Delatycki + MB, Corben LA. Clinical features of Friedreich ataxia. J Child Neurol. 2012;27(9):1133\u20137. + \ pmid:22752493
                                2. 2.\n + \ Hewer RL. Study of fatal cases of Friedreich\u2019s + ataxia. British Medical Journal. 1968;3(5619):649\u201352. pmid:5673214
                                3. 3.\n + \ Tsou AY, Paulsen EK, Lagedrost SJ, Perlman SL, Mathews + KD, Wilmot GR, et al. Mortality in Friedreich ataxia. J Neurol Sci. 2011;307(1\u20132):46\u20139. + \ pmid:21652007
                                4. 4.\n + \ Pousset F, Legrand L, Monin ML, Ewenczyk C, Charles + P, Komajda M, et al. A 22-Year Follow-up Study of Long-term Cardiac Outcome + and Predictors of Survival in Friedreich Ataxia. JAMA Neurol. 2015:1\u20138. + \ pmid:26414159
                                5. 5.\n + \ Weidemann F, Rummey C, Bijnens B, Stork S, Jasaityte + R, Dhooge J, et al. The heart in Friedreich ataxia: Definition of cardiomyopathy, + disease severity, and correlation with neurological symptoms. Circulation. + 2012;125:1626\u201334. pmid:22379112
                                6. 6.\n + \ Weidemann F, Liu D, Hu K, Florescu C, Niemann M, + Herrmann S, et al. The cardiomyopathy in Friedreich\u2019s ataxia\u2014New + biomarker for staging cardiac involvement. Int J Cardiol. 2015;194:50\u20137. + \ pmid:26005806
                                7. 7.\n + \ Legrand L, Diallo A, Monin ML, Ewenczyk C, Charles + P, Isnard R, et al. Predictors of left ventricular dysfunction in Friedreich\u2019s + Ataxia in a 16-year observational study. Am J Cardiovasc Drugs. 2020;20(2):209\u201316. + \ pmid:31650522
                                8. 8.\n + \ Hewer R. The heart in Friedreich\u2019s ataxia. + Br Heart J. 1969;31(1):5\u201314. pmid:5774037
                                9. 9.\n + \ Isnard R, Kalotka H, Durr A, Cossee M, Schmitt M, + Pousset F, et al. Correlation between left ventricular hypertrophy and GAA + trinucleotide repeat length in Friedreichs ataxia. Circulation. 1997;95(9):2247\u20139. + \ pmid:9142000
                                10. 10.\n + \ Dutka DP, Donnelly JE, Nihoyannopoulos P, Oakley + CM, Nunez DJ. Marked variation in the cardiomyopathy associated with Friedreich\u2019s + ataxia. Heart (British Cardiac Society). 1999;81(2):141\u20137. pmid:9922348 +
                                11. 11.\n + \ Meyer C, Schmid G, Gorlitz S, Ernst M, Wilkens C, + Wilhelms I, et al. Cardiomyopathy in Friedreich\u2019s ataxia-assessment by + cardiac MRI. Mov Disord. 2007;22(11):1615\u201322. pmid:17546670
                                12. 12.\n + \ Regner SR, Lagedrost SJ, Plappert T, Paulsen EK, + Friedman LS, Snyder ML, et al. Analysis of echocardiograms in a large heterogeneous + cohort of patients with Friedreich ataxia. Am J Cardiol. 2012;109(3):401\u20135. + \ pmid:22078220
                                13. 13.\n + \ Mottram PM, Delatycki MB, Donelan L, Gelman JS, + Corben L, Peverill RE. Early changes in left ventricular long-axis function + in Friedreich ataxia: relation with the FXN gene mutation and cardiac structural + change. J Am Soc Echocardiogr. 2011;24(7):782\u20139. pmid:21570254
                                14. 14.\n + \ Dedobbeleer C, Rai M, Donal E, Pandolfo M, Unger + P. Normal left ventricular ejection fraction and mass but subclinical myocardial + dysfunction in patients with Friedreich\u2019s ataxia. Eur Heart J Cardiovasc + Imaging. 2012;13(4):346\u201352. pmid:22127629
                                15. 15.\n + \ Peverill RE, Romanelli G, Donelan L, Hassam R, Corben + LA, Delatycki MB. Left ventricular structural and functional changes in Friedreich + ataxia\u2014Relationship with body size, sex, age and genetic severity. PLoS + ONE. 2019;14(11):e0225147. pmid:31721791
                                16. 16.\n + \ Mewton N, Liu CY, Croisille P, Bluemke D, Lima JA. + Assessment of myocardial fibrosis with cardiovascular magnetic resonance. + J Am Coll Cardiol. 2011;57(8):891\u2013903. pmid:21329834
                                17. 17.\n + \ White SK, Sado DM, Flett AS, Moon JC. Characterising + the myocardial interstitial space: the clinical relevance of non-invasive + imaging. Heart. 2012;98(10):773\u20139. pmid:22422587
                                18. 18.\n + \ Flett AS, Hayward MP, Ashworth MT, Hansen MS, Taylor + AM, Elliott PM, et al. Equilibrium contrast cardiovascular magnetic resonance + for the measurement of diffuse myocardial fibrosis: preliminary validation + in humans. Circulation. 2010;122(2):138\u201344. pmid:20585010
                                19. 19.\n + \ Iles L, Pfluger H, Phrommintikul A, Cherayath J, + Aksit P, Gupta SN, et al. Evaluation of diffuse myocardial fibrosis in heart + failure with cardiac magnetic resonance contrast-enhanced T1 mapping. J Am + Coll Cardiol. 2008;52(19):1574\u201380. pmid:19007595
                                20. 20.\n + \ Jerosch-Herold M, Sheridan DC, Kushner JD, Nauman + D, Burgess D, Dutton D, et al. Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging of myocardial + contrast uptake and blood flow in patients affected with idiopathic or familial + dilated cardiomyopathy. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. 2008;295(3):H1234\u2013H42. + \ pmid:18660445
                                21. 21.\n + \ Ugander M, Oki AJ, Hsu LY, Kellman P, Greiser A, + Aletras AH, et al. Extracellular volume imaging by magnetic resonance imaging + provides insights into overt and sub-clinical myocardial pathology. Eur Heart + J. 2012;33(10):1268\u201378. pmid:22279111
                                22. 22.\n + \ Raman SV, Phatak K, Hoyle JC, Pennell ML, McCarthy + B, Tran T, et al. Impaired myocardial perfusion reserve and fibrosis in Friedreich + ataxia: a mitochondrial cardiomyopathy with metabolic syndrome. Eur Heart + J. 2011;32(5):561\u20137. pmid:21156720
                                23. 23.\n + \ Mavrogeni S, Giannakopoulou A, Katsalouli M, Pons + RM, Papavasiliou A, Kolovou G, et al. Friedreich\u2019s ataxia: Case series + and the additive value of cardiovascular magnetic resonance. J Neuromuscul + Dis. 2020;7(1):61\u20137. pmid:31796683
                                24. 24.\n + \ Takazaki KAG, Quinaglia T, Venancio TD, Martinez + ARM, Shah RV, Neilan TG, et al. Pre-clinical left ventricular myocardial remodeling + in patients with Friedreich\u2019s ataxia: A cardiac MRI study. PLoS ONE. + 2021;16(3):e0246633. pmid:33770103
                                25. 25.\n + \ Campuzano V, Montermini L, Lutz Y, Cova L, Hindelang + C, Jiralerspong S, et al. Frataxin is reduced in Friedreich ataxia patients + and is associated with mitochondrial membranes. Hum Mol Genet. 1997;6(11):1771\u201380. + \ pmid:9302253
                                26. 26.\n + \ Deutsch EC, Santani AB, Perlman SL, Farmer JM, Stolle + CA, Marusich MF, et al. A rapid, noninvasive immunoassay for frataxin: utility + in assessment of Friedreich ataxia. Mol Genet Metab. 2010;101(2\u20133):238\u201345. + \ pmid:20675166
                                27. 27.\n + \ Bit-Avragim N, Perrot A, Schols L, Hardt C, Kreuz + FR, Zuhlke C, et al. The GAA repeat expansion in intron 1 of the frataxin + gene is related to the severity of cardiac manifestation in patients with + Friedreich\u2019s ataxia. J Mol Med. 2001;78(11):626\u201332. pmid:11269509 +
                                28. 28.\n + \ Rajagopalan B, Francis JM, Cooke F, Korlipara LV, + Blamire AM, Schapira AH, et al. Analysis of the factors influencing the cardiac + phenotype in Friedreich\u2019s ataxia. Mov Disord. 2010;25(7):846\u201352. + \ pmid:20461801
                                29. 29.\n + \ Ribai P, Pousset F, Tanguy ML, Rivaud-Pechoux S, + Le B, Gasparini F, et al. Neurological, cardiological, and oculomotor progression + in 104 patients with Friedreich ataxia during long-term follow-up. Arch Neurol. + 2007;64(4):558\u201364. pmid:17420319
                                30. 30.\n + \ Kawel-Boehm N, Hetzel SJ, Ambale-Venkatesh B, Captur + G, Francois CJ, Jerosch-Herold M, et al. Reference ranges (\"normal values\") + for cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) in adults and children: 2020 update. + J Cardiovasc Magn Reson. 2020;22(1):87. pmid:33308262
                                31. 31.\n + \ Treibel TA, Fridman Y, Bering P, Sayeed A, Maanja + M, Frojdh F, et al. Extracellular Volume Associates With Outcomes More Strongly + Than Native or Post-Contrast Myocardial T1. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging. 2020;13(1 + Pt 1):44\u201354.
                                32. 32.\n + \ Treibel TA, Fontana M, Maestrini V, Castelletti + S, Rosmini S, Simpson J, et al. Automatic Measurement of the Myocardial Interstitium: + Synthetic Extracellular Volume Quantification Without Hematocrit Sampling. + JACC Cardiovasc Imaging. 2016;9(1):54\u201363. pmid:26762875
                                33. 33.\n + \ Liu CY, Liu YC, Wu C, Armstrong A, Volpe GJ, Van + der Geest RJ, et al. Evaluation of age-related interstitial myocardial fibrosis + with cardiac magnetic resonance contrast-enhanced T1 mapping: MESA (Multi-Ethnic + Study of Atherosclerosis). J Am Coll Cardiol. 2013;62(14):1280\u20137. pmid:23871886 +
                                34. 34.\n + \ Piechnik SK, Ferreira VM, Lewandowski AJ, Ntusi + NA, Banerjee R, Holloway C, et al. Normal variation of magnetic resonance + T1 relaxation times in the human population at 1.5 T using ShMOLLI. J Cardiovasc + Magn Reson. 2013;15:13. pmid:23331520
                                35. 35.\n + \ Rauhalammi SM, Mangion K, Barrientos PH, Carrick + DJ, Clerfond G, McClure J, et al. Native myocardial longitudinal (T1) relaxation + time: Regional, age, and sex associations in the healthy adult heart. J Magn + Reson Imaging. 2016;44(3):541\u20138. pmid:26946323
                                36. 36.\n + \ Roy C, Slimani A, de Meester C, Amzulescu M, Pasquet + A, Vancraeynest D, et al. Age and sex corrected normal reference values of + T1, T2 T2* and ECV in healthy subjects at 3T CMR. J Cardiovasc Magn Reson. + 2017;19(1):72.
                                37. 37.\n + \ Rosmini S, Bulluck H, Captur G, Treibel TA, Abdel-Gadir + A, Bhuva AN, et al. Myocardial native T1 and extracellular volume with healthy + ageing and gender. Eur Heart J Cardiovasc Imaging. 2018;19(6):615\u201321. + \ pmid:29617988
                                38. 38.\n + \ Granitz M, Motloch LJ, Granitz C, Meissnitzer M, + Hitzl W, Hergan K, et al. Comparison of native myocardial T1 and T2 mapping + at 1.5T and 3T in healthy volunteers: Reference values and clinical implications. + Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2019;131(7\u20138):143\u201355.
                                39. 39.\n + \ Myerson SG, Bellenger NG, Pennell DJ. Assessment + of left ventricular mass by cardiovascular magnetic resonance. Hypertension. + 2002;39(3):750\u20135. pmid:11897757
                                40. 40.\n + \ Haland TF, Hasselberg NE, Almaas VM, Dejgaard LA, + Saberniak J, Leren IS, et al. The systolic paradox in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. + Open Heart. 2017;4(1):e000571. pmid:28674623
                                41. 41.\n + \ Peverill RE, Donelan L, Corben LA, Delatycki MB. + Differences in the determinants of right ventricular and regional left ventricular + long-axis dysfunction in Friedreich ataxia. PLoS ONE. 2018;13(12):e0209410. + \ pmid:30596685
                                42. 42.\n + \ Bellenger NG, Davies LC, Francis JM, Coats AJ, Pennell + DJ. Reduction in sample size for studies of remodeling in heart failure by + the use of cardiovascular magnetic resonance. J Cardiovasc Magn Reson. 2000;2(4):271\u20138. + \ pmid:11545126
                                \n\n\n\n
                                \n
                                \n\n + \
                                \n
                                \n\n
                                \n
                                \n
                                \n\n + \
                                \n \n
                                \n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n \n \n \n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n
                                \n\n\n" + headers: + Alt-Svc: + - h3=":443"; ma=2592000,h3-29=":443"; ma=2592000 + Cache-Control: + - no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate + Content-Language: + - en-US + Content-Type: + - text/html;charset=UTF-8 + Date: + - Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:44:43 GMT + Expires: + - '0' + Pragma: + - no-cache + Server: + - Apache + Strict-Transport-Security: + - max-age=31536000 + - max-age=31536000 ; includeSubDomains + Transfer-Encoding: + - chunked + Vary: + - Accept-Encoding + Via: + - 1.1 google + X-Content-Type-Options: + - nosniff + X-Frame-Options: + - DENY + X-XSS-Protection: + - 1; mode=block + content-length: + - '240901' + status: + code: 200 + message: OK version: 1 diff --git a/ace/tests/conftest.py b/ace/tests/conftest.py index e84a1f6..8ac1b15 100644 --- a/ace/tests/conftest.py +++ b/ace/tests/conftest.py @@ -20,6 +20,23 @@ def _scrub_api_keys(response): return response +# The URI of every request a cassette was asked for, served or refused. A +# refused request raises inside the code under test, where a broad except can +# swallow it, so play_counts alone can't show that it was never made. +_ATTEMPTED_URLS = [] + + +def _record_attempt(request): + _ATTEMPTED_URLS.append(request.uri) + return request + + +@pytest.fixture +def attempted_urls(): + _ATTEMPTED_URLS.clear() + return _ATTEMPTED_URLS + + @pytest.fixture(scope="module") def vcr_config(): # Cassettes recorded with PUBMED_API_KEY set must not store the key, and @@ -29,4 +46,5 @@ def vcr_config(): "filter_query_parameters": ["api_key"], "decode_compressed_response": True, "before_record_response": _scrub_api_keys, + "before_record_request": _record_attempt, } diff --git a/ace/tests/test_ace.py b/ace/tests/test_ace.py index ddebd36..ae4777e 100644 --- a/ace/tests/test_ace.py +++ b/ace/tests/test_ace.py @@ -192,7 +192,7 @@ def test_database_processing_stream(db, test_data_path): @pytest.mark.vcr(record_mode="once") -def test_journal_scraping(test_data_path, source_manager): +def test_journal_scraping(test_data_path, source_manager, attempted_urls): scrape_path = join(test_data_path, 'scrape_test') # Start clean: index_pmids makes the scraper skip anything already on disk, # so articles left behind by an earlier failed run would send it past the @@ -220,6 +220,7 @@ def test_journal_scraping(test_data_path, source_manager): shutil.rmtree(scrape_path, ignore_errors=True) assert len(names) == 2 + assert not [url for url in attempted_urls if 'pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov' in url] # Each file must be the PLoS NLM XML. Neither article had a LinkOut record # when this was recorded, so both are addressed by their esummary DOI. for name, doc in zip(names, docs): @@ -762,9 +763,6 @@ def test_a_table_readability_drops_is_appended(source_manager): PMCID_LOOKUP_400_CASSETTE = join(CASSETTES, 'test_pmcid_lookup_failure_is_logged_without_the_api_key.yaml') NO_LINKOUT_CASSETTE = join(CASSETTES, 'test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_nothing_for_other_journals[book-chapter].yaml') ESUMMARY = 'https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id={}&retmode=json' -# Cassette URIs keep the query as the api_key filter re-encoded it, so the -# slash in a DOI reads %2F. -PLOS_MANUSCRIPT = 'https://journals.plos.org/{}/article/file?id=10.1371%2F{}&type=manuscript' def _played_urls(cassette): @@ -800,11 +798,13 @@ def test_get_html_by_pmid_opens_the_provider_url_from_the_keyed_lookup(vcr, tmp_ @pytest.mark.vcr(record_mode="once") -@pytest.mark.parametrize('pmid, manuscript_url', [ - ('42868208', PLOS_MANUSCRIPT.format('plosone', 'journal.pone.0360047')), - ('42868205', PLOS_MANUSCRIPT.format('ploscompbiol', 'journal.pcbi.1014869')), -], ids=['plos-one', 'plos-comp-biol']) -def test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript(vcr, tmp_path, pmid, manuscript_url): +@pytest.mark.parametrize('pmid, doi, article_page', [ + ('42868208', '10.1371/journal.pone.0360047', 'https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id='), + # Not in PLOS_JOURNAL_SITES. + ('42868163', '10.1371/journal.pmen.0000749', 'https://journals.plos.org/mentalhealth/article?id='), +], ids=['plos-one', 'plos-mental-health']) +def test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_article_by_doi( + vcr, tmp_path, attempted_urls, pmid, doi, article_page): # Freshly indexed PLoS articles have no LinkOut record yet. The journal # passed in is a placeholder, so PubMed's esummary has to say it is PLoS. scraper = scrape.Scraper(str(tmp_path)) @@ -813,16 +813,20 @@ def test_get_html_by_pmid_without_linkout_opens_the_plos_manuscript(vcr, tmp_pat played = _played_urls(vcr) assert vcr.all_played - assert played[:3] == [ELINK_PRLINKS.format(pmid), ESUMMARY.format(pmid), manuscript_url] + assert set(attempted_urls) == set(played) + assert played[:3] == [ELINK_PRLINKS.format(pmid), ESUMMARY.format(pmid), f'https://doi.org/{doi}'] + assert played[-1].startswith(article_page) assert not [url for url in played if 'pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov' in url] - assert '' in caplog.text assert FAKE_API_KEY not in caplog.text