4444J99 · Oct 12, 2026 · Oct 12, 2026 · Oct 12, 2026 · Oct 12, 2026 · Oct 12, 2026
@@ -115,10 +115,14 @@ acceptance and distribution approvals. An empty register or a summary claiming
 
 ## Current limits and validation boundary
 
-Structured-occurrence reconciliation, generalization, policy adoption, binding
-verification, native enforcement and estate evidence adapters remain unfinished.
-The milestone projection does not implement those adapters or invent evidence
-for them. Recovery consequently retains their unknown or incomplete conditions.
+Structured-occurrence reconciliation is implemented through paired recovery
+inputs and validates pinned occurrence identities, claim associations, evidence,
+authority, independent review and coverage. The adapter does not itself supply
+actual reconciliation receipts or close the structured-occurrence condition.
+Generalization, policy adoption, binding verification, native enforcement and
+estate evidence adapters remain unfinished. The milestone projection does not
+implement those adapters or invent evidence for them. Recovery consequently
+retains their unknown or incomplete conditions.
 
 Regression tests exercise inconsistent gate identities, altered conditions and
 counts, false closure claims, missing publication inputs, legacy-rights

@@ -0,0 +1,136 @@
+# Current reconciliation issuance after cloud replay
+
+Status: staged authorized partial reconciliation; v0.2 acceptance remains open.
+
+## Authorized execution — October 12, 2026
+
+After this runbook was staged in PR #507, the owner directly approved the exact
+current actor pair and 2,174-decision scope at 21:44:17 UTC. The additive grant,
+actual issuance, distinct final-envelope review and successful source-bound
+accounting are retained in `evidence/v02-authorized-reconciliation-20261012/`.
+Accounting now reports **2,174 validated / 59,767 unresolved out of 61,941**, with
+`mapping_complete=false`. No historical grant, receipt or report was overwritten.
+The private final ledger is preserved separately. The original authority finding
+below describes the pre-grant inspection; it is superseded for this exact scope.
+
+The initial recovery attempt failed because the source-only cache lacked
+`candidates.jsonl`. The subsequent
+[recovery integration](../evidence/v02-recovery-integration-20261012/README.md)
+restores five corpus members to their independently recorded A3 hashes and runs
+the actual full reporter with the same issued receipts. It reproduces
+**2,174 validated / 59,767 unresolved / 61,941 total**. The candidate ledger is
+available; the earlier failed attempt remains an unchanged historical record.
+The original complete capsule and rendered-body cache, publication, pilot and
+acceptance requirements remain open. Retained authenticated source files were
+reused without acquisition, and recovery revalidated source provenance.
+
+
+PR #506 preserves completed current source replay at `6c37fe5` and its independent
+review. Reuse those executed results for the same locked archives and unchanged
+input hashes. Do not rerun acquisition merely to address the role-grant gap.
+Fresh verification of final accounting by `ges.claim_reconciliation` still reruns
+claim provenance as part of its existing contract. It can consume the retained
+fresh-pinned source cache without network acquisition. Do not add a flag that trusts
+a saved success report in place of source-bound accounting.
+
+## Authority finding
+
+The preserved `evidence/v02-finish-20261010/owner-authorization.json` names:
+
+| Role | Granted actor |
+|---|---|
+| Reconciler | `codex:01a12707-22ff-7f52-b05b-937b45b7ce0c:/root` |
+| Independent reviewer | `codex:01a12707-22ff-7f52-b05b-937b45b7ce0c:/root/finishline_gates` |
+
+Its scope covers five successor claims, predecessor supersession and unchanged
+carryforward audit, with exact complete claim/catalog/proposal bindings. It forbids
+identity substitution and backdating. These actors are not the current cloud root
+and reviewer. The historical combined policy binds the old universe; the separate
+OpenCode serialized-execution grant names other actual roles and does not grant
+these cloud actors replacement issuance authority. Source-review, continuation,
+publication and mechanical-review permissions do not supply the missing grant.
+No authentic replacement grant was found in the inspected tracked records, PR #506
+conversation or retained preparation records. This finding is bounded to those
+accessible records; it does not assert absence in inaccessible owner conversations.
+
+The concrete proposed replacement pair is:
+
+| Role requested, not granted | Actual current actor |
+|---|---|
+| Reconciler | `chatgpt-cloud:20261012:2aefcbff59bd:/root` |
+| Independent receipt reviewer | `chatgpt-cloud:20261012:2aefcbff59bd:/root/envelope_review` |
+
+The latter is currently a read-only software reviewer. Code review alone is not
+receipt review, and neither task is an independent human approver. A direct owner
+decision must name the pair and exact package before either actor issues or reviews
+receipt envelopes. Preserve the authentic decision reference and actual recording
+time in a new record; do not edit the historical grant or imply broader authority.
+
+## Exact requested package
+
+| Binding | SHA-256 |
+|---|---|
+| Reviewed nonissued draft bytes | `a8b9065b0a5a43e950451683badcbeaa335cc344bbce78940dac4420fb6d7185` |
+| Canonical draft | `010aa6e9003301d96825cb1f34b317bafb401783e9f7462c40ac1c7d05bbb8e6` |
+| Current claim universe | `4c9c65b1c59f656d0a8bc423ee84c26e835754f7fca02ac4cc8df8e27f5bd20b` |
+| Catalog | `125555b58ee9cfc66af0fb335429911005f1f9ad1da555ea4f0acd51602ec24c` |
+| Proposals | `e16b506ada35741ea1d61f93bcf11b846893b643eb6e25eaed4a6edb70cf59d4` |
+
+Scope: 2,164 unchanged carried decisions plus five predecessor SUPERSEDED exclusions
+and five successor SPECIALIZE decisions. Preserve all subjects and substantive
+fields. Keep `accepted_policy=false` and `adopted_obligation=null`. Permitted envelope
+changes are schema, actual reconciler/reviewer identities and actual issuance/review
+timestamps only; the reviewed draft already binds the current universe.
+
+The fresh retained-draft check reconstructs every current subject from hash-checked
+metadata and all 655 claim documents, verifies all 2,174 dispositions structurally,
+and compares 19,476 carried fields. It reuses the ten-disposition semantic review
+recorded in #506; it does not claim a new semantic adjudication or source replay.
+The private draft remains private. Its recorded hash is the review anchor.
+
+## Sequence after genuine owner grant
+
+1. Authenticate the decision and record a separately named current-role policy with
+   all three bindings. The CLI cannot establish identity or approval authenticity.
+2. The granted reconciler authenticates the pinned draft, inspects its decision
+   package, and issues a separate final ledger with actual current issuance times.
+   Preserve the original draft, historical receipts, policies and execution reports.
+3. The distinct granted reviewer compares every final envelope with the exact draft
+   and policy and records actual final review evidence and times after issuance.
+   Do not reuse the October 12 earlier draft-review timestamps. Keep final review
+   evidence separate from both prior semantic review and this software review.
+4. Use the read-only comparator, with the actual private paths:
+
+   ```sh
+   python -m ges.reconciliation_envelopes \
+     --draft PRIVATE_DRAFT.json \
+     --draft-sha256 a8b9065b0a5a43e950451683badcbeaa335cc344bbce78940dac4420fb6d7185 \
+     --receipts ISSUED_RECEIPTS.json --policy AUTHORIZED_POLICY.json
+   ```
+
+   It compares exact membership and every substantive field and checks role strings
+   against the supplied policy and ordered nonfuture timestamps. Its output is
+   expressly mechanical comparison, with no authorization or accounting credit.
+   It neither writes envelopes nor proves that declared actors actually acted.
+5. Run `ges.claim_reconciliation` using retained authenticated artifact metadata,
+   fresh-pinned sources, current reviews/catalog/proposals, and the same issued
+   receipts/policy pair. Capture actual output, exit, times, code/input/output hashes.
+   Pass that same pair into `ges.recovery`; missing other gate inputs remain unknown.
+
+Only successful actual accounting can establish the conditional 2,174 validated /
+59,767 unresolved out of 61,941. A discrepancy is a finding to investigate, not a
+reason to alter evidence to match arithmetic. Reconciliation remains partial.
+
+## Integration and remaining acceptance
+
+This narrow verification addition is a dependent draft after #506, retaining
+#496 -> #497 -> #503 -> #506 and their review/merge boundaries. It changes no historical
+receipt or owner grant. Final merged-main verification and owner acceptance remain
+required; green branch tests constitute staged evidence.
+
+Original A3 capsule restoration, historical rendered-body authentication,
+source-to-claim omission completeness, remaining adapters and six-source synthesis,
+full public disposable pilot evidence, exact-use publication clearance, human
+code/security review, distribution approval and owner acceptance remain separate.
+Private pilot support remains unverified. No reconciliation grant approves those
+milestones, policy adoption, native rollout, estate rollout or a release.
@@ -105,13 +105,44 @@ closed. Calculated `PROVEN` evidence is not the governed designation `Verified`;
 the merged-main, review and owner-acceptance requirements in `GOVERNANCE.md`
 remain in force.
 
-## Current admitted implementation checkpoint
-
-The [v0.2 continuation package](../evidence/v02-finish-20261010/README.md) records
-five new consumed successor claims, independently reviewed semantic dispositions,
-complete metadata input digests and scoped owner authority. Raw records grew by
-five; no replacement envelopes or new validated-accounting closure are claimed.
-Heavy host admission denied authenticated full replay and the prescribed full
-verification commands. The approved JSON representation amendment is implemented,
-but its two exact-expression rights decisions remain HOLD. The complete release
-candidate, six-source closure and human acceptance remain pending.
+## Current staged checkpoint — October 12, 2026
+
+The [cloud source replay in PR #506](../evidence/v02-cloud-replay-20261012/README.md)
+authenticated all six locked sources and replayed provenance for 61,941 claims in
+655 documents. Its independent audit and retained input hashes are recorded with
+the execution. The earlier native host admission denials remain historical
+observations; the completed cloud replay uses its own execution evidence.
+
+The [authorized reconciliation in PR #507](../evidence/v02-authorized-reconciliation-20261012/README.md)
+records the owner's exact current-role grant, actual issuance of 2,174 receipts,
+distinct final-envelope review and successful source-bound accounting. The result
+is **2,174 validated dispositions and 59,767 unresolved claims out of 61,941**,
+with `mapping_complete=false`. Historical grants, receipts and the original
+nonissued draft are preserved. Agent review does not supply human approval or
+extend the recorded grant to adoption, publication, merge or release acceptance.
+
+The subsequent [recovery integration](../evidence/v02-recovery-integration-20261012/README.md)
+recovers the candidate and historical page ledgers, reconstructs the dependency
+ledger and historical summary, and restores the structured requirements. All five
+match independently recorded A3 byte hashes. With the preserved October 7 artifact
+metadata and authenticated October 12 source files, the actual reporter now
+succeeds and carries the authorized 2,174-receipt accounting into its gates and
+milestones. The earlier failed attempt remains preserved; missing candidates are
+no longer the current blocker. A required-input preflight now identifies missing
+corpus/source files before expensive processing, preserving the existing trusted
+Darwin path-alias policy.
+
+The report contains 3,590 valid artifact disposition receipts out of 13,657;
+10,067 artifacts remain without such receipts. It retains 150,903 candidate
+blocks, 605 structured occurrences, 18,019 published page applications and the
+original 14 unresolved source mappings. No new structured-occurrence certification,
+control adoption or semantic-omission certification is claimed. The frozen summary
+retains its historical 31 catalog-referenced artifacts; the current catalog's
+reference count is independently 35.
+
+Complete original capsule and historical rendered-body authentication, omission completeness, remaining
+generalization/adoption/binding/native adapters, six-source synthesis and the full
+public pilot matrix remain open. The approved JSON representation amendment is
+implemented, but its two exact-expression rights decisions remain HOLD. The final
+release candidate, publication clearance, human review, governed integration,
+merged-main verification and owner acceptance remain pending.
@@ -0,0 +1,85 @@
+# Authorized partial current reconciliation — October 12, 2026
+
+**Staged.** The owner directly approved the exact current actor pair and reviewed
+2,174-decision package. Actual issuance occurred at 21:44:56.198907 UTC; the distinct
+granted reviewer completed final-envelope comparison and recorded review time
+21:46:06.610245 UTC. No historical authorization, ledger or report was overwritten.
+
+The actual `ges.claim_reconciliation` command exited 0 in 10.997 seconds. It reused
+the retained source cache and artifact metadata from PR #506, authenticated their
+hash continuity and current repository input closure, and revalidated source-claim
+provenance under the existing contract. No source acquisition was run by this
+accounting command. The result is partial:
+
+| Measure | Actual result |
+|---|---:|
+| Known claims | 61,941 |
+| Validated dispositions | 2,174 |
+| Unresolved claims | 59,767 |
+| MAP | 382 |
+| SPECIALIZE | 57 |
+| CONFLICT | 3 |
+| REFERENCE | 1,721 |
+| EXCLUDED_WITH_REASON | 11 |
+
+`mapping_complete=false`. Rights clearance, adoption, omission completeness and
+semantic truth certification remain false. This result is current accounting under
+issued, independently reviewed envelopes, rather than conditional arithmetic.
+
+## Evidence
+
+- `owner-authorization.json`: authentic direct owner decision and exact scoped actors.
+- `claim-reconciliation-policy.json`: separately named current binding, preserving old policy.
+- `issuance.json`: actual reconciler action and private pending-ledger digest. Its
+  `independent_review_complete=false` describes that earlier issuance moment.
+- `independent-envelope-review.json`: actual distinct final review and final-ledger digest.
+- `envelope-comparison.json`: mechanical exact-draft comparison; no standalone identity proof.
+- `review-final-envelopes.py`: retained actual independent comparison/review script.
+- `current-accounting.json`: exact stdout of successful source-bound accounting.
+- `accounting-execution.json`: actual command, code revision, times, input/output hashes.
+- `run-accounting.py`: retained actual bounded accounting driver.
+- `recovery-integration-attempt.json` and stderr: actual failed full recovery attempt.
+- `independent-accounting-review.json`: distinct review of actual accounting and continuity.
+
+The final private ledger SHA-256 is
+`b4147bf94b13d18188b7acc775c1f7508f1653f2737bcecc7f27920afe58b73f`;
+its canonical receipt digest is
+`9085ac042ae2b951aa582b390faf36e78380d8108199de1c4073e84557a17e8f`.
+The exact final ledger, pending ledger and original nonissued draft are preserved
+separately in a private custody package. They are not exposed in this public tranche.
+Source bodies remain in retained private storage; public metadata is not a substitute
+for preserving or authenticating the full original capsule.
+
+## Remaining integration and acceptance
+
+Passing the same final receipt/policy pair to `ges.recovery` failed with exit 1 because
+the fresh-pinned source replay cache has no frozen corpus `candidates.jsonl`. No
+recovery report was produced. Restore the authenticated full frozen corpus and
+rendered-body inputs through their authorized custody route, then rerun recovery
+with this exact pair. Do not create empty stand-in corpus files or relabel a fresh
+corpus as the original historical cache.
+
+The original capsule, historical rendered-body authentication, omission completeness,
+remaining adapters and six-source synthesis, full public disposable pilot evidence,
+exact-use publication clearance, human review, governed merge, merged-main checks,
+distribution authority and owner acceptance remain open. Private pilot support remains
+unverified. This grant grants none of those separate permissions.
+
+The integration remains on draft PR #507, after #496 -> #497 -> #503 -> #506.
+The repository's "Verified" definition requires merged-main and organization
+acceptance. This tranche closes only the specific current-role/issuance/accounting
+dependency for these partial reconciliation receipts; it does not close v0.2.
+
+New-head Toolkit validation succeeded on commit 4bb4b5799f9cbbdf5204965f8dd564360e9df5d4 (https://github.com/4444J99/github-engineering-standards/actions/runs/38313579565).
+
+Source acquisition and coverage succeeded on head a6a163ee29f81a3cf6371c931f2eef87364dce32 (https://github.com/4444J99/github-engineering-standards/actions/runs/38313328290).
+
+Source acquisition and coverage succeeded on current head 4bb4b5799f9cbbdf5204965f8dd564360e9df5d4 (https://github.com/4444J99/github-engineering-standards/actions/runs/38313514024).
+
+Toolkit validation succeeded on current head a817e512d298a9f50a0ce395e7bc11c6d05ab23d (https://github.com/4444J99/github-engineering-standards/actions/runs/38313809675).
+
+Toolkit validation succeeded on current head 580c2d9f1c661ba4c8467bca9e3498005c385faf (https://github.com/4444J99/github-engineering-standards/actions/runs/38313982195).
+
+Toolkit validation succeeded on current head 8f86f145731d4774908f5fe0f5b6665b75906290 (https://github.com/4444J99/github-engineering-standards/actions/runs/38314133627).
+
+Source acquisition and coverage succeeded on head 580c2d9f1c661ba4c8467bca9e3498005c385faf (https://github.com/4444J99/github-engineering-standards/actions/runs/38313982481).