Repository navigation
Lark feedback tracer: received and answered reactions from canonical facts #1040
Description
Parent
What to build
The integrated Lark PersonaBot adds a receipt reaction after durable Inbox Admission and a completion reaction only when the corresponding answer is known accepted for sending.
Acceptance criteria
- Use the checked Provider reaction capability and canonical source/admission/outbound correspondence, not standalone chat or prompt instructions.
- Verify the concrete reaction-write permission and actual platform reactions through the integrated path.
- No receipt on mere SDK receipt without Admission, and no ✅ for silent turns, delegation, waits, unrelated output or uncertain/failed sends.
- Parallel sources, replay and reconnect do not exchange or duplicate another source’s indicators.
- Feedback failure or unavailable reaction capability cannot authorize, discard or block work; Web exposes truthful capability/status where needed.
- Demonstrate both reactions, silence and failure with real messages and retain tutorial images.
- Test through checked Provider and authenticated management/owning service boundaries; keep existing canonical persistence and no parallel content/decision authority.
- Retain real sanitized screenshots/step evidence and maintain the affected English/Chinese tutorial section; UI changes include matched baseline/changed light/dark evidence and no private secrets.
- Provide the exact-version runnable review path and focused behavioral coverage; pause for Human QA before expansion, without automatic merge/deployment.
Blocked by
None (can start immediately).
Completion evidence — 2026-10-09
The original source-bound feedback tracer is complete through merged implementation #1207 / Provider #16 and merged QA evidence #1236. This records implementation acceptance, not a released/deployed Provider candidate.
| Acceptance | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Checked capability, canonical ownership and management boundaries | ADR-0149, owning-service/checked Provider tests and exact source/Admission/Outbox facts in #1236. No parallel content/decision authority. |
| Concrete permission and real reactions/silence/failure | R1 retained the real permission-denial observation without rewriting unknown history; known-denial classification has regression coverage. R2 DM originals rendered GLANCE/DONE and silence GLANCE only. R3 group original rendering is now evidenced by the Human-supplied unique-marker capture. |
| No false receipt/completion; parallel sources, replay and reconnect | Integrated feedback tests cover no-Admission group traffic, parallel accepted/silent/failed/unknown replies, pending replies and separately source-linked output. Replay/restart attempts are deduplicated. Real R3 mute/reconnect and R4 live Host restart/fresh reply supplement the tests. Delegation/wait/lifecycle completion cannot substitute for the canonical accepted source reply. |
| Failure isolation and truthful Web state | Real permission failure did not prevent source replies; focused tests cover rejected/pending/unavailable feedback and the timeout concurrency bound. Authenticated Web shows the selected identity’s truthful attempt states, with matching light/dark captures. |
| Sanitized bilingual tutorials and runnable exact-version review | #1236 contains source/digest provenance, runbook, restoration and Human production-reply confirmation. Human accepted the available visual evidence: Web captures are explicitly post-merge themes, not pre-feature before/after; missing historical baseline is not misrepresented. Each production-app window and merge had specific Human authorization. |
| Focused coverage and checks | Integrated feedback tests, focused Provider/identity coverage in #1207, and full CI on final evidence head passed. Standards review: 0 findings; Spec review: 0 blocking findings within the evidence PR scope. |
Separate follow-ups and release boundary
- Lark QA follow-up: correlate one in-window blocked DM with checked receiver rejection #1250: exact in-window blocked-message arrival/rejection evidence; the R4 minute-only match remains unqualified.
- Web diagnosis: reproduce session-maybe adapter failure and preserve first-error evidence #1251: reproduce/diagnose the earlier Web assembly failure; its first saved occurrence predates R3 cutover, with no verified feedback/Provider cause.
- IM identities and messaging: provider coordination #48 retains Provider qualification coordination and the runbook’s unexercised broader platform cases before any pin promotion decision. The published pin is unchanged; no publication or deployment is implied.
Earlier comments kept #1040 open for these broader items. The closure assessment now separates them from the original completed tracer instead of treating them as implemented acceptance failures. Closing #1040 resolves its native dependency for #1045/#1161; it does not mark either sibling implemented or authorize expansion without their own scope/QA.
Activity
DoodleBears commentedon Oct 8, 2026
Agent work claim
codex/local/01a11bd6-6350-7013-b7ae-79b7405f2fa6(not a DSH Session)codex/1040-lark-feedbackPreflight: #1040 OPEN, no existing comments/claims or associated open PR, no native blocking dependencies; latest origin/main
be804da7. Read #1031/#1104 and #1022 handoff. No production receiver interruption, secret copying, other-session messaging, provider publication/pin promotion, merge or deployment authorized.Merge main into Lark feedback candidate and preserve both ledger entries
docs: verify merged feedback candidate and fresh native model reply
docs: link candidate QA runbook from generated Lark guides
37 remaining items
docs: correct Lark QA failure timeline and blocked test time
docs: correlate R3 group source with official delivery log
DoodleBears commentedon Oct 8, 2026
Agent work claim — R4 bounded live qualification
codex/local/01a11bd6-6350-7013-b7ae-79b7405f2fa6(not a DSH Session)codex/1040-qualificationReuse the approved existing app and reviewed Provider candidate; no added permissions, publication, or Provider pin promotion. Human sends three marker messages from the working Lark client because the web messenger remains unavailable. The agent restores production and obtains production Lark/Discord reply confirmation. R3's blocked marker was sent at 03:59 JST, after its cutoff, so it is not valid block evidence.
docs(lark): qualify live Host restart and record bounded block evidence
DoodleBears commentedon Oct 8, 2026
Agent work outcome — R4 live restart and bounded block observation
codex/local/01a11bd6-6350-7013-b7ae-79b7405f2fa6(not a DSH Session)The freshly approved window armed at 04:52:50.784 JST, with an unchanged 05:00:50.784 local cutoff and independent 05:01:50.784 server fallback. The exact reviewed paired sources and all 400 Provider runtime files were verified; no pin, permission or deployment changed.
The real same-Profile Host restart is now qualified: BEFORE and fresh AFTER sources each committed exactly one Admission, the exact matching accepted reply and accepted receipt/answer attempts. The retained identity and all historical feedback matched across the restart; the new owned Host was registered with the original guard before enabling IM. Web reload reached the actual composer with no new post-reload console errors.
The Human reported sending BLOCKED at 04:56 JST, inside the window, with no reply or reaction. Canonical inspection found no matching source, no new Outbox and unchanged feedback. Official Event Log Search showed one successful receive event at 04:56:44.857 in that minute, but exposes no message ID/body; exact blocked-marker delivery is still independently unproven and the case is not fully qualified.
QA identity/account/temporary credentials were removed, the restarted Host stopped, and production was verified running at 04:57:55.239 JST. The independent timer and local guard were stopped after recovery. The Human confirmed both production Lark and Discord replied.
Correction to the R3 outcome: the first saved Web scope failure was 03:48:24.290 JST, before R3 armed at 03:50:18.602, so the earlier attribution to an in-window Provider hot lifecycle was unsupported. Ten isolated reload/mode-switch cycles did not reproduce it; its trigger/root cause remains unverified. The Human also confirmed R3 BLOCKED was sent at 03:59 JST, after cutoff/recovery; it cannot qualify that case. The R3 group event has a separate exact-ID official SUCCESS record; neither that row nor the Human-reported Glance/Done appearance replaces a source-specific group reaction image.
Remaining: exact blocked-source arrival correlation, source-specific group reaction rendering, the earlier Web failure's trigger and unexercised acceptance cases. Keep #1040 open and #1045/#1161 dependencies in place. No additional receiver window is active or authorized by this outcome.
DoodleBears commentedon Oct 8, 2026
Agent work claim — Human group capture and evidence merge
codex/local/01a11bd6-6350-7013-b7ae-79b7405f2fa6(not a DSH Session)BH1040-R3-GROUP, review the documentation/evidence-only PR docs: record guarded Lark feedback qualification #1236, and merge it if review and required checks pass, as the Human requested. No new receiver window or runtime deployment.codex/1040-qualificationPreserve historical window records and add a dated capture follow-up. Extract only the original QA message/reactions and its matching reply without regenerating pixels; omit unrelated group notices and personal names. Exact blocked-marker correlation, the earlier Web failure trigger and unexercised cases remain outside this documentation merge.
docs(lark): add Human-supplied group reaction rendering evidence
docs(lark): record guarded feedback QA and group reaction evidence (#…
DoodleBears commentedon Oct 8, 2026
Agent work outcome — group visual evidence and authorized documentation merge
codex/local/01a11bd6-6350-7013-b7ae-79b7405f2fa6(not a DSH Session)The Human supplied the original
BH1040-R3-GROUPscreenshot and explicitly authorized merge after adding it and checking the PR. The unique marker, 03:51 time, real mention, two DeepSeekBot-attributed reaction chips and matching reply correlate with the retained R3 source and accepted GLANCE/DONE attempts. Group original-message rendering now has visual evidence. Two sanitized lossless crops were verified pixel-for-pixel, with original/crop hashes retained in the public provenance record. The no-capture observations from the earlier window remain historical and are explicitly superseded by this later follow-up.Standards review: 0 findings. Spec review: 0 blocking findings. Full CI passed for reviewed head
b087042a8700b7b9921e4751b20f4bf8b0cc344a(verify); all embedded evidence images rendered on GitHub. No runtime code, app permission or Provider pin changed.The earlier R4 window remains closed, QA stopped and temporary account/credentials removed; the Human confirmed normal production Lark and Discord replies. No new production cutover occurred for this capture update or merge.
Keep #1040 open for exact blocked-marker arrival correlation, the earlier Web failure trigger and unexercised acceptance cases; preserve #1045/#1161 dependencies. This documentation merge does not publish/deploy the candidate or promote its Provider pin.
DoodleBears commentedon Oct 9, 2026
Completion assessment — original tracer scope
Task:
codex/local/01a11bd6-6350-7013-b7ae-79b7405f2fa6. State: completed for #1040’s original source-bound feedback tracer. The Human asked whether the issue can close; rechecking the original acceptance against merged implementation, focused coverage, real platform evidence and approved visual exceptions supports closure. The body now links the evidence for all nine acceptance items.Correction of prior coordination scope: keeping this tracer open for every broader QA item and an unverified pre-cutover Web failure was overly broad. The remaining facts are preserved without declaring them passed: #1250 tracks exact blocked-marker arrival/rejection; #1251 tracks Web assembly diagnosis. #48 retains unexercised broader platform qualification and the unchanged Provider pin/release boundary.
Implementation #1207 / Provider #16 and evidence #1236 are merged; full CI passed, with Human-reviewed group rendering and production restoration. Closing resolves #1040’s native dependency for #1045/#1161, without implementing either sibling or authorizing deployment, permission changes or another production receiver window.