docs(gap): refresh product-technical baseline (74 repos, live census)

[seonghobae]

Canonical baseline owner and stack

This is the canonical BandScope product/technical-baseline lane. It owns docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md and its documentation-verification surfaces; it does not own repository formatter defects, Project Persistence implementation, Score Storage implementation, queue-control implementation, or central .github control-plane source.

Current exact PR head is 9c7cac0c645546bfaa910a3162d6166971ccc08b. The PR remains Draft and stacked on canonical formatter prerequisite #1176 exact 8fe6b6d99c009527ef0bcba419e6f6debdb23c23. Protected/released product truth remains develop@314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e; neither this Draft nor its prerequisites are shipped truth.

This head updates the canonical baseline's stale central CodeQL authority only: the source now records .github#2352 as the current compatibility integration vehicle, .github#2275 as the fail-closed GHAS analyses-read credential selector owner, and .github#2276 as the real target permission/canary owner. Net source delta from predecessor f69afac38775ac3c2a507be1704df630b90908c9 is three changed lines (+3/-3) in docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md; the intermediate traceability-URL typo was repaired immediately in ordinary ancestry and is absent from the current tree.

Moving PR heads are live authority. This description is refreshed when material dependency or commercial-gap classification changes rather than pinning stale mutable Draft heads into the baseline source.

Project Persistence recovery baseline refresh

Current Project Persistence authority is #970 exact 3dfd77e11187211e9b7ed2317b8f559e5e1fb018, Open / Draft / mergeable, stacked through #1254 and therefore transitively through #1176. It owns durable project revision/CAS, crash-safe publication/recovery and persisted final-result admission. ProjectScopedScoreRecoveryAction remains bound to active project identity and durable project revision/CAS; project switch or accepted same-project durable revision change invalidates outstanding Recover/Preserve/Discard intent.

#970 also consumes the canonical shared transcription-timing invariant through actual #1254 ancestry and adapts its persisted-cache consumer so negative onset, zero-duration and inverted note intervals fail closed. That is Draft evidence, not shipped truth.

The latest direct-develop repository generation for #970's pre-stack semantic source failed Ruff 0.15.5 formatting on five files. test_supply_chain_policy.py is canonical #1176 ownership; the remaining four Project Persistence files remain #970-owned formatter obligations. Native macOS/Windows, build, Security, Semgrep and SBOM evidence from that direct semantic head is historical semantic-source evidence only, not final stacked merge evidence. Current exact stacked 3dfd77e... has no repository-owned workflow generation, so absence is not GREEN.

Score Storage baseline semantics

Current live Score Storage authority remains #1241 exact b29b7b522478780db44db1c754ab7f660ed2b17b, Open / Draft / mergeable. Its Draft retains receipt-bound detach, real-public-publisher/desktop-package fault evidence and four ScoreView freshness controls: project/song continuation, pre-paint stale-content reset, live selection after accepted detach, and latest-rendered same-song aggregate freshness after async native work.

RED 8dd038be... proves pending attach/detach must preserve newer visible same-song title/attachment metadata; repair 8529ec09... derives proposals from the latest rendered RehearsalSong. This does not replace durable Project Persistence revision/CAS and does not promote mutable Draft behavior to shipped truth.

#1241 exact native macOS/Windows owner jobs are terminal SUCCESS, but its Ubuntu UI job failed during raw npm ci before the focused ScoreView regression executed. Node/npm runtime acquisition remains canonical #896 ownership; required order is #896 protected integration → ordinary/non-force #1241 reconciliation → protected canonical npm activation consumption → fresh focused UI evidence. Predecessor or partial GREEN never transfers to missing gates.

The source phrase packaged cancellation/process termination continues to mean the actual shipped/bundled application cancellation acceptance gap, not the narrower owner-only executable harness in #1241. Still-open release gaps include actual shipped cancellation, sudden power loss, verified Windows directory-entry successful-return durability, old-unleased-build coexistence, Unix final-basename race disposition, protected/released integration, cross-owner Recover/Preserve/Discard orchestration, recovery UI and release/signing evidence.

Queue descendant and exact-head evidence authority

#968 remains the executable queue-control owner and has already ordinary/non-force adopted this baseline movement. Current exact #968 is dde02dbaf6ea2b82d85a81c3092073d816d898f7, Open / Draft, base this #1116 branch. The ordinary two-parent descendant preserves the entire queue-owned tree while incorporating current baseline 9c7cac0...; fresh compare reports ahead 137 / behind 0 with merge base exact #1116, 23 queue-owned changed files, and no docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md delta. Baseline single-writer ownership therefore remains here.

Neither exact current head has hosted workflow generation after this movement. Zero runs are missing evidence, not GREEN.

Canonical formatter prerequisite

#1176 remains exact 8fe6b6d99c009527ef0bcba419e6f6debdb23c23, Open / Draft / mergeable. It owns the one-file Ruff formatting repair required by downstream full-suite execution. Repository ci, build-baseline, SBOM, Security Scan and Semgrep are terminal SUCCESS on that unchanged head, but delegated CodeQL settlement remains a central lifecycle failure and formal review inventory still has no qualifying independent non-author current-head approval. Do not copy that formatter delta into #865/#1241/#1254/#970/#910 or this baseline.

Current central integration authority is ContextualWisdomLab/.github#2352. Its exact producer is fully terminal: validation and settlement succeeded; Python/Actions exact-source CodeQL scans completed analysis and passed the Medium+ SARIF gate, then both failed only at GHAS base/head configuration-identity proof because the target code-scanning/analyses endpoint returned HTTP 403. The remaining causal owner is .github#2275 for fail-closed credential selection plus .github#2276 for actual target permission/canary. This is central control-plane work, not a BandScope formatter/source finding.

Central control-plane boundary

Protected central .github/main remains e6334e229581a918e2f22de18733b76fa65d7e71. Current protected scripts/ci/agent_mention_router.py remains review-dispatch-only; no source-fix command/capability is present. Mention-only output is review evidence, not source-repair progress.

Protected BandScope develop remains 314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e with 14 required contexts. Latest public release remains immutable historical v0.1.3, published 2026-04-28; it is not proof for any current Draft head.

Repository-wide commercial gaps

Keep visible at minimum: npm advisory/runtime owner settlement; >500 kB main JS/eager Score-PDF path; GHAS PR-comparison continuity; frontend executable coverage policy mismatch; audio-I/O licensing/format parity; immutable model distribution/signing/update rollback; pretrained-weight commercial rights; #970 buyer recovery/revision-conflict UX and durable CAS; #1239/#1241 shipped cancellation, sudden power-loss, Windows-directory durability, project-deletion rollback and old-unleased-build/Unix-name-race disposition; production HTTP/metadata-authentication/same-descriptor cryptographic promotion; rights-cleared real-audio MIR reproducibility; active-player audible authority; diagnostics/support bundle; activation; accessibility/localization parity; release signing/notarization/provenance/reproducibility and updater rollback.

Exact-head evidence / merge gate

The current #1116 source head and the reconciled #968 descendant have no hosted generation after this source movement and stay Draft. Normal order starts with #1176 achieving authentic central CodeQL settlement and qualifying independent review, then protected integration. Every dependent lane must then ordinary/non-force reconcile and reacquire terminal exact-head repository/security/owner evidence and qualifying independent current-head approval. No predecessor receipt is promoted across head movement.

No self-approval, bypass, force-push, destructive rebase, gate weakening, copied prerequisite delta, source-neutral freshness commit, blind rerun, synthetic status, or stale evidence transfer.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

• Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true

Note

Reviews paused

It looks like this branch is under active development. To avoid overwhelming you with review comments due to an influx of new commits, CodeRabbit has automatically paused this review. You can configure this behavior by changing the reviews.auto_review.auto_pause_after_reviewed_commits setting.

Use the following commands to manage reviews:

• @coderabbitai resume to resume automatic reviews.
• @coderabbitai review to trigger a single review.

Use the checkboxes below for quick actions:

• ▶️ Resume reviews
• 🔍 Trigger review

📝 Walkthrough

Walkthrough

BandScope의 제품·기술 기준선과 운영 증거 문서를 갱신했습니다. 최신 census, 제품 요구사항, 병합 증거, transport 상태, 영속성 계약, 보안 경계, 품질 및 릴리스 기준을 반영했습니다.

Changes

BandScope 기준선 문서

Layer / File(s)	Summary
제품 및 배송 계약 docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md, docs/doctoring/product-gap-baseline-2026-09-01.md	74개 저장소의 최신 census와 BandScope backlog를 갱신했습니다. 제품 요구사항, 활성 작업 흐름, 병합 승계, historical evidence 및 source-selection authority를 기록했습니다.
도메인 및 기술 설계 docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md	도메인 모델과 시스템 토폴로지를 보완했습니다. InitialSourceSelecting 및 ReplacementSourceSelecting 상태와 source 취소·실패·교체·삭제 전이를 추가했습니다. project_format_version, 원자적 교체, last-known-good recovery 및 식별자 호환성 계약을 명시했습니다.
보안 및 추적성 기준 docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md	실제 오디오 acceptance, allowlisted Tauri IPC, 127.0.0.1 loopback, 입력 admission, subprocess 권한, 개인정보 redaction, UI/UX evidence, 품질·릴리스 게이트 및 traceability 기준을 갱신했습니다.

Estimated code review effort: 2 (Simple) | ~15 minutes

Merge Risk: 🟡 Moderate · up to 3f29e

The recovery state model currently leaves RecoveryFailed with no documented exit, so a failed restore can dead-end users and encode an incomplete product contract. Merge should wait until the contract defines acknowledgement to NoSource or retry behavior, with regression coverage.

🚥 Pre-merge checks | ✅ 5

✅ Passed checks (5 passed)

Check name	Status	Explanation
Docstring Coverage	✅ Passed	No functions found in the changed files to evaluate docstring coverage. Skipping docstring coverage check. Docstring coverage is scoped to functions touched by this diff. Analyzed 0 functions across 0…
Linked Issues check	✅ Passed	Check skipped because no linked issues were found for this pull request.
Out of Scope Changes check	✅ Passed	Check skipped because no linked issues were found for this pull request.
Description Check	✅ Passed	Check skipped - CodeRabbit’s high-level summary is enabled.
Title check	✅ Passed	제목은 74개 저장소의 최신 live census를 포함한 product-technical baseline 문서 갱신을 정확히 설명합니다. 변경된 문서 범위와 주요 변경 내용을 간결하게 나타냅니다.

✨ Finishing Touches

🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)

• Create PR with unit tests
• Commit unit tests in branch docs/gap-baseline-2026-08-31

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[seonghobae]

@opencode-agent Become the sole writer for canonical BandScope branch docs/gap-baseline-2026-08-31 only while it still resolves to exact head 00019c9ffe18bd630b14c4cd7c4ff4146def340f and protected develop still resolves to 749511c3ad4000090048718f685c6bee6b3d2c25. Apply superpowers:using-superpowers, receiving-code-review, systematic-debugging, and verification-before-completion. Immediately before writing refetch the exact head/base, the current blob of docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md, and unresolved threads PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6ds6Rf, PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6ds6Sq, PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6ds6Ty, PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6duRIm; abort/adapt if the ref/blob moved. This is a BandScope-docs-only lane: do not modify central .github, foreign repos, source code, or workflows; do not create another PR, force-push, or weaken gates.

Validate every finding against fresh live evidence before editing. Current verified contradictions on this exact head include:

1. The document says the refreshed inventory is 185 open PRs but its recorded verification still says 130. Fresh GitHub pagination returns open develop PRs across pages 1 and 2, with page 3 empty and no open main PRs. Record a reproducible current inventory command/result or, if the count has moved since this comment, use the fresh actual count consistently instead of preserving 185 as a slogan.
2. §6 says docs has no Mermaid/sequence/class diagrams immediately before embedding two Mermaid diagrams itself; the review also notes existing doctoring Mermaid flowcharts. Replace the repository-wide absence claim with the narrower truthful gap (for example, no canonical comprehensive UML/C4/domain/state-model set, if fresh search supports that) and preserve existing diagrams as evidence rather than pretending they do not exist.
3. P1 misroutes loop playback to Issue [Release] Ship signed, notarized, auto-updatable desktop builds with rollback evidence #960. Fresh issue authority: [Release] Ship signed, notarized, auto-updatable desktop builds with rollback evidence #960 is signed/notarized/updater/release/rollback; [Product] Add an active rehearsal player with precise looping and role controls #961 owns active rehearsal player/transport/precise loops/role controls. The adjacent crash-safe project row is also shifted: [Reliability] Add a versioned crash-safe project format, autosave, migration and recovery #962 owns crash-safe/versioned project format; [Operations] Build redacted diagnostics, crash evidence and an offline support bundle #963 owns diagnostics/support bundle. Correct the issue mapping wherever the document has this off-by-one drift.
4. Revalidate live status claims rather than publishing remembered state. In particular, the Noema 120-second failure is now confirmed by consumer bandscope#1115@223d53f6c63dc17f7ce219faa52e5eafbd7719ed, required run/job 33386655858/99470699909, which reached call_llm only after sidecar/gateway preflight and then raised TimeoutError at the protected-main timeout=120 path. The canonical central owner is now open .github#1509 (fix(noema): raise call_llm HTTP timeout from 120s to org policy), exact current head 3d2b6a8262e323c794885387d1e70297b39366b5; a BandScope-local workaround is not appropriate. Also refetch refactor(engine): promote temporal probe from cli hack to api integration #1117 before repeating any exact-head test/readiness claim.

Keep the baseline a truth source rather than a blocker narrative: distinguish protected shipped truth, current live evidence, accepted/open work, and planned gaps. If correcting the document surfaces a concrete BandScope executable gap already owned by an issue/PR, link its canonical owner; do not implement that code in this docs lane. Run any repository doc/markdown/contract checks that apply plus git diff --check, commit the smallest correction on this same branch, reply with successor exact SHA and evidence, and resolve only threads whose exact claims are actually corrected on the successor head.

[seonghobae]

Concurrent recount note for the new exact head 825512fed478a1a30c60756bd21fd2599bc98f8b: every one of the 72 accessible repositories was queried individually in this cycle. Because remote agents continued opening/closing PRs during the sequential sweep, those 72 per-repository observations sum to 2,689, while the organization-wide atomic search returned 2,690 at the baseline capture and then 2,691 later in the same run. This is expected live-queue skew, not a counting contract to 'fix' by freezing writers. The rank is stable by a wide margin: BandScope 188, TEPP 142, OriginWeave 140, newsdom-api 130, naruon 127. The document's 2,690 value remains a timestamped capture rather than a timeless invariant; merge decisions continue to refetch exact live state.

[seonghobae]

@claude Please refresh the two canonical baseline files on exact current head 825512fed478a1a30c60756bd21fd2599bc98f8b through normal non-force history; do not create a competing PR. Superseding fresh evidence at 2026-09-01 17:43 KST: 73 repositories are now accessible through the connected ContextualWisdomLab GitHub account because ContextualWisdomLab/ConceptWeave is newly present; the organization-wide atomic is:pr is:open capture is 2,683. Current high-backlog counts remain bandscope 189, TEPP 149, OriginWeave 140, newsdom-api 130, naruon 125. This run exhaustively partitioned all 73 accessible repository names into GitHub issue-search groups; every non-BandScope partition was below 189, so the highest-backlog selection is proven without assuming a stale repository list. Treat all queue numbers as timestamped evidence because concurrent writers remain active. Replace the prior 72-repository/volatile-count snapshot in docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md and docs/doctoring/product-gap-baseline-2026-09-01.md without rewriting immutable PRD/TRD/DDD/UML/research contracts merely because the queue moved.

Also reconcile central-review status from fresh protected-central evidence. ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1546 remains protected truth at 5686de41660d51a7a7f22b8840dfa6ccfe5ff3f1, but the post-#1546 repository-wide scripts/ci coverage repair is still not protected truth. The current canonical root owner remains .github#1567, now exact head 400f2b5a63a5cdaf95a42ee4d49a4e492132738b. That branch now carries the scheduler coverage/SIGPIPE repair plus the history-preserved stacked #1491 Noema cleanup that removes the never-wired CodeGraph-context branch; because #1491 merged into #1567 rather than protected main, all predecessor #1567 evidence was invalidated and fresh exact-head evidence is required. Therefore central coverage remains an outstanding downstream prerequisite until #1567 itself reaches protected main. Do not revert to the obsolete claim that #1551's closure meant no coverage prerequisite remained, and do not promote #1567/#1491 candidate behavior to protected truth.

Keep the existing Rust core-computation ownership, bounded CPU/accelerator boundary, real-audio acceptance, 100% coverage/docstring/edge-case target, Storybook/Figma/screenshot UX contract, security/operability baseline, and APA 7 traceability intact. Update only truthful volatile evidence and directly contradicted status prose. Run the documentation/baseline contract tests and git diff --check, report the resulting exact head, and do not self-approve, force-push, weaken gates, or transfer predecessor evidence.

[seonghobae]

Canonical Project Persistence handoff for baseline refresh: #970 has materially advanced beyond the 79e7588... state currently described here. Current owner head is d8edb4a9f6eb422eb7561a763c9692a499dee492 (Draft, mergeable, protected base still develop@314ddeae...). The current vertical now includes deterministic migration receipts, sealed validated migration candidates, same-handle predecessor identity, input/output digest-bound filesystem CAS, production migrate-on-load, and v2 recovery journals that carry/replay the exact migration receipt across the post-validation crash window. Exact-head macOS native Project Persistence is GREEN at d8edb4a...; Windows and the general CI/security/SBOM/SAST/build gates are still running/queued, so this is source evidence rather than protected/released truth. Warning debt discovered in the native lane is tracked under #1235 rather than being suppressed. Please adopt this as owner input on the next #1116 refresh; #970 will not edit docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md from the persistence lane.

[seonghobae]

Canonical baseline owner handoff from #970: Project Persistence has materially moved since the baseline’s last #970 snapshot.

Current #970 exact head is 48fbd9156ead950881264c3952c72ec8029ac8c5 on protected develop@314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e, Open / Draft / mergeable. Two source-level reliability/security slices now need to be reflected when this baseline next refreshes its #970 inventory:

1. Recovery-journal path confinement: hostile schema-v2 journal path components could escape the selected directory; RED 4b617a5... / hosted RED 49bc47c... → GREEN e364474... → predecessor exact-head native GREEN at 898b3c2....
2. Successful-cleanup authority: after candidate/predecessor validation, destructive cleanup still trusted pathnames. RED d3daecf... produced hosted macOS/Windows native failures; GREEN 83a40b2... re-binds target cleanup to journal candidate, displaced deletion to journal expected, and re-runs migration receipt verification at the cleanup boundary; 1d53792... adds the symmetric target-replacement case; traceability lands at current 48fbd915....

This is an owner handoff only: #970 is not editing docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md. Current exact-head native/repository checks for 48fbd915... are still settling, so predecessor GREEN must not be promoted to present commercial acceptance.

[seonghobae]

Fleet exact-head finding — canonical gap baseline central-control-plane section is stale again.

#1116@e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220 explicitly says its baseline is refreshed when a material live dependency changes, but the current Central control-plane boundary still records protected .github/main@64aa08d7... and describes .github#2040 as mergeable. Fresh authoritative reads disagree:

• protected .github/main is now e6334e229581a918e2f22de18733b76fa65d7e71, the verified merge commit of #2279;
• .github#2040 remains Draft at ecc9e1d11149ae44ec4f8389e4ac72a08ba45ba7, but GitHub currently reports mergeable=false after protected main advanced;
• therefore #2040's earlier ordinary reconciliation against 64aa08d7... is historical evidence, not current protected ancestry/readiness.

RED: baseline/doctoring verification should fail when a section marked current records a protected central SHA that is not the freshly observed protected branch tip, or records a live PR mergeability state inconsistent with the same capture. Historical SHAs may remain only when clearly labeled with observation time/generation.

GREEN: repair only in this canonical #1116 baseline lane. Record main@e6334e229581a918e2f22de18733b76fa65d7e71 as current protected central truth; classify #2279 as merged lineage; describe #2040 as current Draft/non-mergeable pending another ordinary/non-force reconciliation with intervening protected-main deltas plus fresh exact-head hosted evidence/independent review. Keep moving PR SHAs as volatile observation evidence rather than durable product contract. If #1116 source moves, preserve the existing single-writer rule and ordinary-forward dependent #968 adoption/revalidation; do not transfer predecessor checks.

This is a documentation-currentness repair finding only, not a request to copy central workflow source into BandScope or to wake either branch with no-op commits.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority refresh (2026-09-19): the formerly unowned score-attachment write gap now has canonical issue #1239 — security(score): own private attachment publication and retention. #1239 owns Score Storage/Attachment write-time permission/ACL, bounded publication, failure cleanup, retention and delete semantics; #864/#865 remain read-time validation, and #970 must not absorb score lifecycle semantics.

Central control-plane truth also moved after the current body was written: protected .github/main is e6334e229581a918e2f22de18733b76fa65d7e71 (merged #2279). .github#2040 is still ecc9e1d11149ae44ec4f8389e4ac72a08ba45ba7, but is now diverged from current main, ahead 169 / behind 33, merge base 64aa08d7.... Therefore the body’s 64aa08d... protected-main statement is historical, not current authority. Keep the gap classification and do not transfer #2040 predecessor evidence across the new protected-main movement.

[seonghobae]

Commercial-gap refinement for Score Storage / Project Persistence: the post-link interruption gap now has direct product-path evidence. On protected develop@314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e, successful attachScorePdf(...) is followed by onSongUpdate(...), and App.handleSongUpdate only updates React jobResult. There is no crash-safe app-local Project Persistence metadata commit coupled to the score-byte publication. Therefore a published <score_id>.pdf can survive a process kill with no durable attachment referent; Score Storage cannot safely auto-delete or auto-adopt that state.

#970 now carries the canonical requirement for a narrow durable attachment lifecycle/reconciliation contract. #1239/#1241 should continue preserving/failing closed on stage+destination ambiguity until that owner contract integrates, then ordinary/non-force reconcile and reacquire native evidence. This narrows the baseline wording from generic “post-link interruption” to published bytes vs durable metadata commit recovery; stage-only abandoned-writer recovery on #1241 remains closed and should not be conflated with this lifecycle gap.

Fresh #1241 gate inventory at exact abed538d02e4813286ea62ac5c3aab914b89a774: score-storage-native is SUCCESS; build-baseline, ci, Security Scan, SBOM, Semgrep, CodeQL PR and required review/scheduler lanes are queued; no formal reviews or review threads. Keep Draft / no evidence transfer.

[seonghobae]

Commercial-gap baseline update from Project Persistence owner #970: current descendant 5110271e0a350707a85d5efd45b1e1d03e7fdf53 adds the first app-owned local-project mutation commit boundary. For a project with native publication authority, proposed song metadata is persisted to fixed native project.bscope before React state is accepted; manual Save remains a separate user-selected export. Renderer supplies only the minted project id plus workspace intent, never a path.

Do not mark score lifecycle or crash recovery complete. The remaining buyer gap is now narrower and explicit: score PDF durable -> project.bscope attachment metadata not yet durable must reopen as a recovery candidate after restart rather than being silently deleted/adopted. Startup discovery of the workspace snapshot, version/revision sequencing for overlapping mutations, packaged kill/power-loss evidence, Restore/Compare/Discard UX, and release/signing remain open. #970 exact-head native/repository checks are still settling, so this is owner-path evidence, not release GREEN.

[seonghobae]

Baseline refresh for the live Project Persistence owner: #970 has advanced from b0962e... to exact 6de45fe70a40cd5f900c9dcf84531c3bd304d5f6 (Open / Draft / mergeable, base remains protected develop@314ddeae...).

The active-session content-identity CAS itself remains the same causal repair (cfcaf8... source-level RED -> bcdd59c... native CAS -> bd1e858... renderer receipt -> c17230a... Tauri wiring). The material intervening finding was test-owner architecture: exact b0962e... macOS owner run 35483630066 / job 106005815303 failed because the new revision regression had been introduced as a second standalone integration crate while tests/project_persistence.rs is the warning-gated single-compile owner. The canonical harness therefore saw new CAS symbols as dead code and deny(warnings) correctly failed. No warning suppression or gate weakening was used.

Repair: 3518976... converts the regression to .case; 6a27c5b... registers it in the canonical warning-gated harness; baee091... removes the duplicate integration crate; final 6de45fe... makes TRACEABILITY code-current. On this exact final head, macOS owner run 35483812778 / job 106006325788 is terminal SUCCESS. Windows owner run 35483812826 / job 106006325869 is still executing its native regression; general CI/security/SBOM/CodeQL are also non-terminal, so repository GREEN is not claimed.

The commercial-gap classification remains narrow: CAS is authoritative only for an active renderer session holding the native receipt from its preceding accepted app-owned workspace save. Explicit app-owned workspace reopen/revision binding plus conflict UX remains the next #962/#970 vertical. Score Storage #1241 stays a separate owner; no Project Persistence source was copied into it.

[seonghobae]

Live authority correction for Project Persistence owner #970 (no #1116 source-head movement): #970 is now exact fdbbe93854c426cb1c18fedb2f1bdb5e11d09a9f, Open / Draft. GitHub REST reports mergeable=true, mergeable_state=blocked against protected develop@314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e; this is gate-blocked rather than a content conflict.

The prior baseline statement that buyer-visible revision conflict handling remained wholly unimplemented is now stale. Source-level RED b19f59009ca55ba7cbf1b4f6ad944a4bbaab750d showed CAS conflict replacing the still-authoritative accepted rehearsal with generic ErrorState; cbf21d6c5e9c3e5ac60af2b21c456bffd3c371c4 adds exact owner-error classification and a path-free bounded notice while preserving the accepted aggregate. Self-review RED 76bfba5fbe3c6c6b3aaea48c8f990bfae93e9fef showed the first notice disappeared in Score view; 44b0dd7971a6b9d6f6da8d847c48b4a7f90d4acb moves it above the Workspace/Score switch. fdbbe938... makes TRACEABILITY current. Neither RED is claimed hosted because their terminal assertion verdicts were superseded/not materialized before descendant repairs.

Exact fdbbe938... native Project Persistence owners are GREEN: macOS run 35488483937 SUCCESS and Windows Server 2025 run 35488483902 SUCCESS. Repository settlement is still non-terminal: build-baseline 35488483893 in progress; ci 35488483939, Security Scan 35488483911, SBOM 35488483914, Semgrep 35488483888 queued; CodeQL PR 35488483913 pending. Fresh reviews still contain no qualifying independent non-author APPROVED; returned inline threads are resolved.

Remaining commercial gap is now narrower: the product can preserve/explain the conflict and offer only functional keep/dismiss + choose-another actions, but it still lacks owner-backed semantic Compare / exact-workspace Reload / Recover rejected edit / auditable Discard. Automatic stale-snapshot replay/merge remains prohibited. Current i18n runtime is EN/KO only, so JA/ZH/VI/ES/DE/FR and packaged keyboard/screen-reader/400%/responsive evidence remain UI Delivery work. PDF durable -> metadata not durable remains the separate #970/#1241 reconciliation boundary.

[seonghobae]

Live baseline authority refresh for Project Persistence / Score integration: #970 is now exact aee578a54f2960c2a847aebd5c6427cb502c9a05, Open / Draft / mergeable on protected develop@314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e.

New buyer-visible gap closed in source: a successfully reopened app-owned project intentionally clears transient jobResultBootstrap while preserving native-admitted sourceReference.projectId in jobResultPublicationProjectId, but ScoreView still consumed the bootstrap id. Reopened projects could therefore lose Score attachment authority after restart even though Project Persistence had correctly rebound durable project identity.

Source-level RED 8412c96bdf981aec98ccca2d7b6498f477ed3aae proves the reopened Project Persistence id must reach Score; no hosted RED is claimed because no run materialized on the test-only head. Causal fix 0b43dad7fe4a1d78e84f16155fbca390390e611d wires ScoreView.projectId to jobResultPublicationProjectId. Owner trigger/policy/traceability lineage is 3e30aaf..., 670a577..., e323263..., 5c9f30c..., 1cbdc42..., 4e579a0..., with current exact aee578.... Focused contract: docs/traceability/project-persistence-score-publication-identity.md.

Claim boundary remains strict: portable documents without an admitted sourceReference receive no Score Storage mutation authority; no path/hash is inferred. This does not close PDF durable -> project attachment metadata not durable, which remains the next Project Persistence / Score Storage recovery-candidate contract. #1241 remains exact bbfa0b5693590f12ef29d4a9545426f34ed558c1 and #865 exact 1f4877413e2eed30b224eaf1b095af3b0b905cb0; no Project Persistence CAS/reopen source is copied into those owners.

Second fresh sweep: #970 head unchanged; Windows native run 35490995588 is now in progress. macOS 35490995585, repository ci 35490995568, Security Scan 35490995566, CodeQL PR 35490995576, build-baseline 35490995554, Semgrep 35490995577, and SBOM 35490995563 are still queued/non-terminal. No qualifying independent non-author APPROVED exists. Do not transfer native evidence to the TypeScript regression or advance readiness while these gates are unsettled.

[seonghobae]

Fresh authority correction for the commercial baseline; keep the source head e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220 unchanged.

• Project Persistence fix(project): enforce crash-safe revision-bound persistence #970 has advanced beyond the body snapshot to exact aee578a54f2960c2a847aebd5c6427cb502c9a05, Open / Draft / mergeable. Both owner-native lanes are now terminal SUCCESS: macOS 35490995585, Windows Server 2025 35490995588. General/frontend/security settlement is still non-terminal, so this is not repository-wide GREEN.
• Score Storage fix(score): publish attachments through private bounded storage #1241 has advanced from bbfa0b... to exact 4c72d9eaa48cf775db5003724a02cc88a76aaae3, Open / Draft / mergeable. The new owner contract inventory_published_score_pdf_ids supplies restart-safe byte/object truth only: it takes the existing cross-process lease, performs stage-only recovery, fails closed on stage+destination ambiguity, inventories exact validated <uuid>.pdf objects through the existing containment resolver, returns deterministic score ids only, and exposes no local paths/PDF bytes. Exact-head workflows are still queued/pending; predecessor native GREEN does not transfer.
• The remaining PDF durable -> metadata not durable gap is therefore narrower: after fix(score): bound native PDF reads before allocation #865/fix(score): publish attachments through private bounded storage #1241 protected integration, fix(project): enforce crash-safe revision-bound persistence #970/application reconciliation must compare durable project attachment ids against the Score Storage inventory and expose an explicit buyer recover/keep/discard decision. An unreferenced durable PDF is a candidate, not proof of interrupted attach, because failed post-detach cleanup can produce the same byte/object state. No automatic attach or deletion.
• fix(score): bound native PDF reads before allocation #865 exact 1f487741... remains Draft. Its ci failure is inherited protected-base Ruff formatting already owned by repair(ci): format consolidated supply-chain policy test #1176 exact 8fe6b6d...; do not duplicate that formatter delta. Its deterministic Strix failure resolves the central evidence binder from the BandScope trusted workspace even though the binder is owned by protected .github; canonical central owner issue .github#2292 now tracks that path defect. Do not vendor central CI source into BandScope or weaken the gate.

Protected product truth remains develop@314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e; protected central truth remains .github/main@e6334e229581a918e2f22de18733b76fa65d7e71. Latest immutable public release remains v0.1.3 (2026-04-28), historical only.

[seonghobae]

Commercial gap authority update: Project Persistence #970 moved to exact 75e5efe1be2c4f4b818d191b2ed8d79a04a38d2b and now owns a pure/path-free score attachment recovery reconciliation contract. It can distinguish durable+published ids, published-without-durable-reference candidates, and durable references with missing score objects, while failing closed on malformed/duplicate identities.

This narrows but does not close the PDF durable -> project metadata not durable buyer gap. Score Storage #1241 remains the canonical inventory/object-existence owner at exact 4c72d9eaa48cf775db5003724a02cc88a76aaae3; #970 intentionally does not source-copy or filesystem-scan that owner. The remaining commercial vertical is canonical cross-owner integration plus explicit buyer recover/keep/discard (or equivalent) semantics, crash-window E2E, accessibility/locale evidence, and packaged recovery/release evidence. Do not treat an unreferenced published id as automatic garbage or automatic attachment.

[seonghobae]

Exact-head correction: #970 is now 5f74aeb12a1b87f16ef9db4954d08467f73a29aa after documenting the reconciliation test-harness RCA. Commercial gap status is unchanged: classification exists, canonical cross-owner consumption and explicit recovery disposition do not.

[seonghobae]

BandScope commercial gap authority update: Project Persistence #970 is now exact 03921928f1d0bdc5226b011dc5342d15a56978d8 (Open / Draft / mergeable). Recovery classification is no longer treated as cleanup authority: source-level RED 25a3e6c... and repair 93a2e9c... require explicit Preserve/Discard intent for exactly one revalidated unreferenced-published score id, and the opaque authorization cannot be manufactured from referenced/missing/unknown/overlapping identities. No Score Storage byte deletion is performed by Project Persistence.

The next buyer-visible recovery gap is presentation truth: #1241 inventory returns score ids only, whereas durable score attachment metadata also requires fileName. A post-publication/pre-metadata crash therefore cannot truthfully restore the original selected filename. Commercial recovery needs an owner-safe metadata receipt or an explicitly generated recovery label, plus explicit recovery/discard UX and crash-window E2E; do not infer or fabricate the original filename.

[seonghobae]

exact e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220의 canonical Gap lane이 현재 live product owners보다 뒤처졌습니다. 이 PR 설명은 "live PR/Issue state is the exact-head authority"이고 material dependency가 움직이면 description을 refresh한다고 명시하지만, Project Persistence와 Score Storage 두 핵심 owner 모두 이미 ordinary-forward했습니다.

• live #970 exact는 4f79c0a8715a66de69c75ad7691e3b9a9e5a0651입니다. 이 baseline은 여전히 8250dcf6...의 restart/equality-binding generation을 current로 기록합니다. 그 이후 #970은 recovery classification을 destructive cleanup authority와 분리하고, Preserve|Discard의 명시적 buyer disposition을 opaque authorized action으로 재검증하는 RED 25a3e6c9... → GREEN 93a2e9ce...를 추가했습니다. 더 최근에는 native workflow가 apps/desktop/core integration tests를 실제로 실행하지 않던 CI-ownership gap을 발견해 RED 6611511e..., hosted compile RED c4efdda1..., regression repair 217642d8..., workflow trigger/traceability repair를 거쳐 current 4f79c0a8...까지 왔습니다. 현 exact의 macOS/Windows/build-baseline은 fresh generation이고 terminal acceptance/independent approval은 아직 없습니다.
• live #1241 exact는 4c72d9eaa48cf775db5003724a02cc88a76aaae3입니다. 이 baseline은 아직 bbfa0b56...를 current로 적습니다. #1241은 그 뒤 restart-safe published-score-id inventory를 owner boundary로 추가했고, sibling source-copy를 제거해 canonical crate-root resolver를 소비하도록 수리했습니다. exact native run 35493457651만 terminal SUCCESS이며 repository/security/SBOM/CodeQL과 independent approval은 여전히 미정입니다.

이 차이는 단순 SHA restamp가 아니라 현재 buyer-gap 분해를 바꿉니다. #970은 이제 "classification"에서 "explicit disposition authorization"까지 왔고 남은 핵심은 released #1241 inventory integration, recover/reattach presentation metadata(fileName 진실성), semantic Reload/Compare/Recover/Discard UX와 packaged crash/fault evidence입니다. #1241은 restart inventory를 제공하지만 lifecycle intent를 추론하지 않는 byte/object-truth owner로 좁혀졌습니다.

RED: #1116의 live-dependency projection contract가 최소 #970/#1241에 대해 현재 GitHub head와 owner-state generation을 비교했을 때 이 mismatch를 실패로 검출해야 합니다. checked-in docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md가 의도적으로 mutable head를 장기 truth로 pin하지 않는 정책은 유지하되, PR-state/live-evidence section에서 이전 generation을 current라고 표기하는 것은 허용하지 마십시오.

GREEN: 이 canonical docs owner만 #970=4f79c0a8..., #1241=4c72d9ea...의 현재 semantics/evidence boundary를 projection하고, protected/released product truth는 여전히 develop@314ddeae...임을 분리해 기록하십시오. active branch semantics를 shipped truth로 승격하지 말고, exact checks/approval이 nonterminal이라는 사실도 같이 보존하십시오. 제품 owner source/docs는 여기서 복사하거나 수정하지 마십시오.

판정: single-writer ownership PASS, protected-vs-mutable truth separation PASS, live owner currentness FAIL, buyer-gap projection currentness FAIL, release claim boundary PASS.

[seonghobae]

fresh live-currentness review @ e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220

새 owner movement 때문에 canonical baseline의 source projection이 다시 stale합니다. 현재 PR body는 #1241을 43fd4666eb92a9376d5253610753de7240596a54의 same-id ABA receipt repair까지 current로 설명하지만, live #1241은 이미 ordinary-forward **943256e4106bf2aea7ce13cc05cee892cd6f55f0**입니다. 그 intervening owner delta는 단순 head churn이 아니라 별도 buyer-recovery invariant입니다: synchronized reserved stage가 destination hard-link publication 뒤 stage-alias retirement 전에 죽은 경우, 동일 validated PDF bytes이면 recovery가 destination을 보존하고 temporary stage alias만 제거하는 post-link interruption repair + owner-native traceability를 추가했습니다. #1241은 이 exact head의 fresh hosted evidence를 아직 주장하지 않고 predecessor 43fd4666... GREEN도 transfer하지 않습니다.

#1116 source baseline은 이미 body에서 스스로 'ordinary semantic repair가 필요'하다고 인정하고 있으므로 no-op currentness commit은 만들지 마세요. 다음 substantive baseline mutation에서 현재 protected/released truth와 mutable owner evidence를 분리한 채 이 owner delta를 같이 fold하는 것이 맞습니다.

RED/GREEN acceptance:

• source baseline이 #1241의 current post-link interruption invariant와 remaining old-build/Unix-name-race/fault/release gaps를 누락하면 RED;
• mutable SHA 자체는 dated evidence로만 기록하고, protected/released truth로 승격하지 않음;
• #1241 predecessor 43fd4666... native GREEN을 943256e... exact-head GREEN으로 재사용하지 않음;
• #970 consumer projection은 #865/#1241 protected/released 이후 fresh receipt + active project identity를 mutation 직전에 다시 읽는 cross-owner contract를 유지함;
• dependent #968이 이후 ordinary/non-force로 baseline semantic delta를 완전 승계함.

현재 판정: single-writer ownership PASS / protected-vs-mutable separation PASS / live Score Storage currentness FAIL / buyer-recovery Gap projection FAIL. 이 COMMENT는 #1241 source를 복사하거나 #1116을 바로 움직이라는 요청이 아니라, 다음 실제 baseline repair의 exact owner-path acceptance입니다.

[seonghobae]

Fresh fleet handoff for the canonical Gap single-writer on exact c8cbe00b5618c1d9cd2ab26a5913c2a69d2196a1:

The checked-in baseline is now one material Score Storage owner movement behind live authority. It still records #1241 as exact 18413751d27c67f63fe33cb9c94eb375ca6ab845 and keeps packaged cancellation/process termination wholly open. Live #1241 has advanced ordinary-forward to 5a571e8c018f503ddbd0633d00fd4554d02a9da0 with a deterministic before-metadata-barrier fault checkpoint and a process-termination regression that drives the real public publisher, terminates it at that boundary, then requires fresh restart receipt recovery. Fleet review 5261617113 classifies that architecture as PASS candidate, but current-head workflows are a new queued generation and the #1241 body itself is still stale, so no predecessor GREEN transfers.

Do not churn this baseline merely for run IDs. At the next safe substantive #1116 mutation, re-read #1241 and currentize the live owner identity/classification if the movement remains authoritative. The durable distinction should be: deterministic real-publisher process-termination acceptance now exists on the Draft owner path, but it is pending exact-head GREEN, does not yet prove packaged executable cancellation or sudden-power-loss durability, and does not become protected/shipped truth. Also keep the new release-build boundary visible: score-storage-fault-injection deliberately contains an indefinite test checkpoint in production source behind a Cargo feature, so commercial acceptance needs package/build evidence that normal shipped desktop artifacts do not enable that feature.

RED: baseline continues to describe #1241 18413751... as current after live owner has materially moved, or promotes the new termination fixture as shipped/packaged evidence before exact-head gates. GREEN: the next normal baseline update adopts only verified live #1241 semantics, preserves Draft/protected separation, retains unresolved packaged cancellation/power-loss/UI/release gaps, and then #968 ordinary/non-force adopts the updated baseline without dropping its 22 queue-owned files.

Baseline currentness: FAIL (one material owner movement behind). Protected/shipped truth separation: PASS. No direct source edit requested from the fleet lane.

[seonghobae]

Baseline owner refresh input (2026-09-22): fresh GrooveMap review exposed a shared runtime contract gap now tracked by #1253. TranscriptionNote.onset/offset are typed as numbers, but the current shared parser admits any JS number, including NaN / ±Infinity; downstream rehearsal UI performs arithmetic on those fields. Canonical #1170 now preserves prior Math.max semantics rather than inventing a consumer-local validator, and duplicate #1251 is Draft preservation. At the next ordinary/non-force baseline source refresh, add #1253 under shared rehearsal-contract / buyer-UI integrity gaps with acceptance at the shared parser boundary (finite timing fixtures, consumer revalidation, no scattered predicates). Do not move this baseline head solely for comment freshness; current stack/prerequisite evidence remains authoritative.

[seonghobae]

New repository evidence-integrity gap: #1258. Protected generic ci.yml does not bind pull-request checkout to the source SHA, and a live #970 job checked out the synthetic PR merge ref. Until #1258 is repaired, generic ci receipts must be classified as merged-candidate evidence unless job-level checkout identity proves otherwise; they are not sufficient for exact-source-head provenance claims. Active #944 currently overlaps ci.yml, so source repair must reconcile that writer ordinary/non-force rather than creating a parallel workflow writer.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority repair finding from fresh live control-plane state:

docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md still says central producer/handler settlement remains .github#2040 ownership. That statement is now stale. Current integration specimen is .github#2352@f1a8dc813e6dba4e4905bf3e1b770b6d44344944, whose exact producer has completed both Python/Actions CodeQL analyses and Medium+ SARIF gates but fails GHAS base/head configuration-identity proof on target code-scanning/analyses HTTP 403. settle exact required run 107247432911 is terminal SUCCESS. The current narrow owner path is .github#2275@0d68d7a8435652edc288d7bb3dfb06a7c8a59eb6 for fail-closed analysis-read credential selection plus .github#2276 for real target permission/canary; #1929/#2040 remain broader lifecycle history/related work, not the present causal permission owner.

Do not create a second baseline writer elsewhere. The next #1116 source movement must repair the live-delivery/control-plane paragraph in docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md to this owner topology, and #968 must then ordinary/non-force adopt the new #1116 descendant while preserving its queue-owned files. Until that source repair lands, this receipt is the live override; the stale .github#2040 sentence must not be used for routing a BandScope-side CodeQL workaround.

The commercial gap set itself remains unchanged: #960/#1126 trusted distribution, #970 crash-safe recovery, rights-cleared real-audio acceptance, active-player audible authority, accessibility/localization parity, and signed/notarized/provenanced updater rollback remain open.