Skip to content

fix(report): stop telling users step 22 did not run when its consensus cannot tell - #571

Open
geiresx wants to merge 40 commits into
GeiserX:mainfrom
geiresx:pgp/i411-sv-support-text
Open

geiresx wants to merge 40 commits into
GeiserX:mainfrom
geiresx:pgp/i411-sv-support-text

Conversation

@geiresx

@geiresx geiresx commented Nov 21, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

The problem

Step 22's consensus now leaves an SV's caller support unknown when it cannot tell (#566). That covers an SV_VCF run's sv_vcf rows, a row with no record ID, an ID in two events, and CNVpytor votes with no ID. summary.json then has support: null with the AnnotSV section's consensus set.

Both reports still gave every null the reason "not known (no step 22 consensus)". So a user whose step 22 did run read that it did not, and could rerun it for nothing. The AnnotSV count line read "single caller: 0", which looks like every SV had two callers. The secondary-findings SV rows said "caller support not known (no step 22 consensus)" too.

The fix

  • og-render (annotsv.rs): support_text(x, consensus) takes the section's consensus flag. When it is set, a null support reads "not known (step 22's consensus cannot tell)". Without it, the old text stays.
  • The count line adds the unknown rows when the consensus ran: single caller: 0, not known: 3. With no unknown row it is unchanged. A row with no support key counts as not known too, so a hand-written or older summary still gets its count line.
  • acmg_sf.rs: the SF structural rows read the AnnotSV section's flag (consensus_ran) and give the same reason.
  • bin/render_report.py and bin/live_results.py (the Python live site) change the same existing lines, with no new function or file.
  • docs/05-annotsv.md and CHANGELOG.md say what the reports print.

Only report text changes. No file, key, option or output name changes.

Parity goldens

The pinned Python oracle (tests/parity/oracle.ref, report-render) prints the old reason. So every report-render case that shows a null support with the consensus set now differs from it on purpose. That is 93 items in 50 cases: c-full, c-float-nan, c-float-inf, c-float--inf, all, all-history, the 14 a-* and 9 s-* cases (all from c-full), cb-full, cb-quoted-*, cb-unicode-contig, cb-no-assets, and 15 m-* clinical cases (from cb-full). Each gets its whole report as a golden.

Each golden differs from the oracle's report only by the new text. Undoing the three changes in og's output (the reason, its HTML-escaped form, and ", not known: N") gives the oracle's bytes exactly, for all 93 items. The corpus already reaches the new text, so no new parity case was needed.

Three files outside the package's list were needed:

  • tests/parity/gen/report-corpus.sh pins generated_utc in each collected summary. Without it, a whole-report golden of a collected summary holds the clock and goes stale on the next run. This is the same hunk, byte for byte, as fix(carrier): keep the low-confidence mark and the zygosity on every carrier row #559's, so the two merge cleanly.
  • scripts/ci/check-personal-data.sh allows four lines under tests/parity/golden/report-render/: the made-up lipoprotein(a) genotypes and repeat sizes of the summary-collect corpus, which the new goldens print. The two lipoprotein(a) lines cover every report-render golden, and the two repeat-size lines only the .txt ones, where they occur. The scan failed on them (160 findings) before these lines.
  • tests/parity/README.md said only one report-render case is compared with committed goldens. It now names the cases that show the new reason and the generated_utc pin.

Base: this branch starts from the T13 batch tip (171d5c45, branch pgp/i411-sv-support-label of #566), which holds #566's unknown support and #561's og report render. The PR base is main, so its diff shows those batches until they land.

Merging with #559: both PRs add 38 report-render goldens in 20 cases (all, all-history, cb-full, cb-quoted-*, cb-unicode-contig and 13 m-* clinical cases), and CHANGELOG.md conflicts. When both are in one batch, regenerate those 38 goldens from og on the combined code and keep both changelog entries.

How it was checked

  • Red first: cargo test -p og-render --test i411_sv_support_text on the code before the fix fails 2 of 5: a_consensus_that_cannot_tell_says_so (the count line had no "not known: 1", the row said "no step 22 consensus") and a_row_without_a_support_key_counts_as_not_known. The three old-text controls pass. After the fix all 5 pass.
  • The live site: before the fix, its clinical-filter table and its findings list gave the old reason for a secondary-findings SV when step 22's consensus ran (3 rows in a probe summary), and after it they give the new one. With no consensus they keep the old reason. tests/test_live_results.py, test_owngenome_live_family.py, test_live_widgets.py and test_collect_summary.py pass. --test clinical (14) and the og-render unit tests (13, including the AnnotSV card test, now with the new text) pass. cargo fmt --check and cargo clippy -p og-render --all-targets -D warnings are clean.
  • scripts/ci/oracle-diff.sh summary-collect report-render report-charts with a local Python oracle: before the goldens, 93 of 1753 items in 399 cases differed (all in report-render); after, all 1753 items agree. summary-collect and report-charts were unchanged throughout.
  • scripts/ci/check-personal-data.sh: failed before the allow lines, passes after.
  • The fork Guard run on the first head (https://github.com/geiresx/OwnGenome/actions/runs/44929907669) went red in unit-tests (0): tests/test_owngenome_live_family.py builds a live-site summary whose SV row has no support key, and the new count line raised on it, so the live site dropped the card. The next commit counts a missing key as not known in both renderers (cargo test a_row_without_a_support_key_counts_as_not_known), and the test passes on that head (https://github.com/geiresx/OwnGenome/actions/runs/44935007176).
  • The full workspace suites run in the fork's Guard and Rust checks.

E2E cases for the batch tip: annotsv-report-section-1-chain (the AnnotSV section and its count line) and report-followups-1-sections.

Bead: sv-01 (#411).

FilterMutectCalls in step 49 ran without a contamination table, so another
person's DNA in the sample, whose alleles sit at a low VAF, could pass as a
small clone. With step 29's common-sites VCF installed, the step and the
Nextflow CHIP_MUTECT2 now run GetPileupSummaries inside the CHIP exons and
CalculateContamination, and pass --contamination-table and
--tumor-segmentation to FilterMutectCalls. New optional parameter
--chip_common_sites; run-all.sh passes it when the VCF and its .tbi are
installed. Without the VCF the log says there is no estimate.

Bead: trait-62
…ntamination table

The fake-docker case runs step 49 without the common-sites VCF, with it, and
with it but no .tbi; renders CHIP_MUTECT2's script block with a fake gatk with
and without --chip_common_sites; and checks that run-all.sh passes the VCF to
the pipeline only with its .tbi.

Bead: trait-62
…e CHIP exons

The CHIP coding exons hold 8 of the 59,295 sites of the common-sites VCF,
too few for CalculateContamination to estimate anything. Contamination is a
property of the sample, so GetPileupSummaries now reads every common site of
the VCF in both the step and CHIP_MUTECT2. The fake-docker case checks the
table first, so main fails it on the --contamination-table check.

Bead: trait-62
…carrier row

The carrier list parsed each hit with the default call floor (GQ 30,
DP 10) and dropped the floor the hits file states, and it wrote no call
quality at all, so a weak call read like a sure one. Each row now has
zygosity, gq, dp and low_confidence, judged against the file's own
##PGP_CALL_FLOOR, as the ClinVar section judges the same hit.

A homozygous or hemizygous P/LP row has no unchanged copy, so it moves
from carriers to a new list, hom_or_hemizygous. Two different
heterozygous hits in one recessive gene get pair and phase from the
haplotype rule of the secondary-findings card (two hits, possible two
hits, or one copy in cis). A pair resting on a low-confidence call, and
a deletion plus a low-confidence call (two_hits), is at most possible.

The schema describes the carrier section; the summary-collect goldens
change only in the carrier section. og-render's hemizygous tests read
the row from its new list.

Bead: clin-15
Bead: clin-19
…or not at all

FilterMutectCalls weighs each allele by its population frequency, which
Mutect2 takes from gnomAD's germline resource. On public data (HG002 with
HG005's reads mixed in) the estimate removed 31 of 35 PASS calls with
gnomAD and none without it. The step now warns in that case, and main.nf
warns on the console without --chip_common_sites and with it but without
--chip_germline_resource, since a task's stderr is not shown. The docs say
the estimate needs gnomAD too and give the measurement.

Bead: trait-62
Check the positional binding of the common-sites VCF and index. List the optional VCF in the Nextflow guide.

Bead: trait-62
…s and on the live page

Moving homozygous and hemizygous P/LP rows from `carriers` to
`hom_or_hemizygous` left every consumer reading only `carriers`. The live
page lost its act finding for such a row ("two changed copies", "the only
copy changed"), and a gene left with a homozygous row fell to a plain
ClinVar review finding. Both reports dropped the row from the carrier
block.

The live page (finding rows, the carrier panel and its headline) now
reads both lists. Both report renderers (og-render and render_report.py,
still step 24's) print each such row on its own line in the carrier
block, "two changed copies" or "the only copy changed", "not the pattern
of a carrier", and the block's first line counts it apart from the
carriers. The report-render parity cases whose summary holds such rows
get goldens for the new lines.

The two CFTR pair tests now assert their row count, so they cannot pass
with no row.

Bead: clin-15
Bead: clin-19
…ort goldens

The report-render goldens of the all and all-history cases print the
LPA section of the synthetic corpus summary, whose two risk-allele lines
read as an rsID with a genotype. They are invented test data: allow
those two lines in those goldens only.

Bead: clin-15
…on every run

A collected summary carries the minute og summary collect ran
(generated_utc), and both reports print it. The report-render goldens of
the cases with a row in hom_or_hemizygous therefore failed on the next
day's run. report-corpus.sh now writes one fixed time into every
collected summary (sed on that one line, so a summary that holds NaN or
Infinity on purpose stays as it is), and the goldens are written again
from og run inside the checkout, as CI runs it: the all and all-nf
summaries now read their repeat tables, as on CI. The pinned oracle
matches the old og on every other output (299 of 301; the other 2 are
the committed viral golden), and no new golden is stale.

The all and all-history text goldens also print the corpus's invented
repeat sizes: allow those two lines too.

Bead: clin-15
# Conflicts:
#	CHANGELOG.md
… call

The SF card called two_hits(), so a class 4/5 deletion plus a P/LP call
below step 06's call floor read 'biallelic' there, while the carrier list
of the same report read it as possibly biallelic (low-confidence call).
Two phased hets of which one is a low-confidence call also read
'biallelic' with no mark.

Each counted allele now carries its low_confidence mark. The deletion rule
goes through two_hits_with, and a pair whose proof needs a low-confidence
call reads 'possibly biallelic (low-confidence call)'. A confident
homozygous call or a confident pair stays 'biallelic'.

Bead: clin-19
…zygous rows

The Python server flags a sample whose carrier list holds only homozygous
or hemizygous rows (a man with only a GLA row). og live serve read only
'carriers', so it gave such a sample no attention flag.

Bead: clin-15
The report-render cases now compare whole reports. The 24 cases whose
summary holds a homozygous or hemizygous carrier row get whole-report
goldens; each differs from the oracle only in the carrier block. The
docs and the changelog say what the SF card now does with a pair on a
low-confidence call.

Bead: clin-15, clin-19
…ssense scores written as text

Bead: nf-vcfanno-ops
… a weak call

The two cards capped different pairs when a gene held a low-confidence
call. The carrier list capped a pair whenever any of its hets was weak,
so a confident phased pair beside a weak third het read "possible two
hits (low-confidence call)". The secondary-findings card capped only a
pair whose proof needed the weak call. Commit 6059508 also said a
confident pair stays biallelic beside a low-confidence call. That was
false for a confident deletion pair: the card gave it the low-confidence
word, while the same row's two-hit line said biallelic. And a combined
allele lost its confidence when any one of its calls was weak.

Both cards now count a gene's hits twice, with every call and with the
confident calls alone:

- A pair the confident calls prove is "two hits" on the list and
  "biallelic" on the card, whatever weak call sits beside it.
- On the card, a confident deletion pair that is biallelic or possibly
  biallelic is used before the low-confidence cap.
- A pair that only a weak call proves gets the low-confidence word.
- Hits of unknown phase are "possible two hits" and "possibly
  biallelic" when two of them are confident. Two confident unphased hets
  plus a weak homozygous call now read "possibly biallelic" on the card,
  as the carrier list already said.
- An allele counts the copies its confident calls give (a count, not a
  flag), so a combined allele that one confident call proves stays firm.
  The carrier list counts a combined allele the same way.

No reported or not-reported decision moves; only `pair` and `phase`
change. A new test runs MUTYH, which is on both lists, through both
cards over 25 shapes of hits and requires the same answer from both.

Bead: clin-19
…port

With step 22's consensus set and an SV whose support is null, both
reports must say the consensus cannot tell, never that it did not run,
in the AnnotSV rows and in the secondary-findings SV rows, and the
AnnotSV count line must count the unknown rows. Without the consensus
the old text stays. Red on the code before the fix: the header lacks
"not known: 1" and the row says "no step 22 consensus".

Bead: sv-01
…ll an SV's support

og summary collect writes an SV's support as null when step 22's
consensus ran but cannot tell (an SV_VCF run's rows, a row with no ID,
an ID in two events, a vote with no readable ID). Both renderers still
said "not known (no step 22 consensus)" for every null, and the AnnotSV
count line read "single caller: 0".

The AnnotSV section's consensus flag now picks the reason in the AnnotSV
rows and the secondary-findings SV rows, and the count line adds
", not known: M" when the consensus ran. bin/render_report.py and
bin/live_results.py change the same lines for the live site.

The pinned Python oracle prints the old reason, so the 50 report-render
cases that show it get whole-report goldens. report-corpus.sh pins each
collected summary's generated_utc so those goldens stay stable (the same
hunk as the carrier-confidence lane).

Bead: sv-01
…der goldens

The whole-report goldens of the c-full, all and a-/s- report-render
cases print the made-up lipoprotein(a) genotypes and repeat sizes of the
summary-collect corpus. The scan read them as personal data. Allow
those four lines under tests/parity/golden/report-render only.

Bead: sv-01
@geiresx
geiresx requested a review from GeiserX as a code owner November 21, 2026 17:24
@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Nov 21, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Important

Review skipped

Too many files!

This PR contains 147 files, which is 47 over the limit of 100.

To get a review, reduce the PR to 100 files or fewer by splitting it into smaller PRs or changing its base branch.

Upgrade to a paid plan to raise the limit.

CodeRabbit couldn't verify your organization's usage billing state, so no usage-priced review was started. Retry after the billing service recovers.

Run configuration

Commits

Reviewing files that changed from the base of the PR and between 9dd5dda and 23eb52a.

Files ignored due to path filters: 4

  • assets/output_contract.tsv is excluded by !**/*.tsv
  • scripts/ci/e2e-case-paths.tsv is excluded by !**/*.tsv
  • scripts/ci/e2e-case-times.tsv is excluded by !**/*.tsv
  • tests/parity/gen/report-corpus.sh is excluded by !**/gen/**
Files selected for processing: 147

  • .github/workflows/e2e.yml
  • CHANGELOG.md
  • bin/live_results.py
  • bin/owngenome_live.py
  • bin/render_report.py
  • docs/05-annotsv.md
  • docs/25-prs.md
  • docs/49-chip.md
  • docs/nextflow.md
  • docs/parameters.md
  • docs/results/secondary-findings.md
  • docs/testing.md
  • main.nf
  • modules/local/chip/main.nf
  • modules/local/vcfanno/main.nf
  • nextflow.config
  • nextflow_schema.json
  • rust/crates/og-live/src/state.rs
  • rust/crates/og-render/src/sections/acmg_sf.rs
  • rust/crates/og-render/src/sections/annotsv.rs
  • rust/crates/og-render/src/sections/carrier.rs
  • rust/crates/og-render/tests/clinical.rs
  • rust/crates/og-render/tests/i411_sv_support_text.rs
  • rust/crates/og-summary/src/collect/acmg.rs
  • rust/crates/og-summary/src/collect/carrier.rs
  • rust/crates/og-summary/src/collect/two_hits.rs
  • rust/crates/og-summary/tests/i411_carrier_confidence.rs
  • scripts/49-chip.sh
  • scripts/ci/check-personal-data.sh
  • scripts/run-all.sh
  • tests/e2e/i411-nf-vcfanno-ops-1-score-tiers.sh
  • tests/fake-docker/i411-chip-contamination.sh
  • tests/parity/README.md
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-escape/a-escape.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-escape/a-escape.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-failed/a-failed.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-failed/a-failed.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-full/a-full.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-full/a-full.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-missing/a-missing.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-missing/a-missing.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-no-painting/a-no-painting.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-no-painting/a-no-painting.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-numbers/a-numbers.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-painting/a-painting.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-painting/a-painting.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-partial/a-partial.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-partial/a-partial.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-prs-raw/a-prs-raw.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-prs-raw/a-prs-raw.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-prs-sex/a-prs-sex.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-prs-sex/a-prs-sex.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-since/a-since.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-since/a-since.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-stale/a-stale.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-stale/a-stale.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-unreadable/a-unreadable.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-unreadable/a-unreadable.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-y-calls/a-y-calls.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/a-y-calls/a-y-calls.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/all-history/all-history.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/all-nf/all-nf.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/all-nf/all-nf.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/all/all.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/c-float--inf/c-float--inf.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/c-float-inf/c-float-inf.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/c-float-nan/c-float-nan.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/c-full/c-full.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-full/cb-full.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-full/cb-full.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-nf/cb-nf.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-nf/cb-nf.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-nfbad/cb-nfbad.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-nfbad/cb-nfbad.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-no-assets/cb-no-assets.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-no-assets/cb-no-assets.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-notbi/cb-notbi.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-notbi/cb-notbi.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-dosage/cb-quoted-dosage.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-dosage/cb-quoted-dosage.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-interval/cb-quoted-interval.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-interval/cb-quoted-interval.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-smn/cb-quoted-smn.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-smn/cb-quoted-smn.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-unicode-contig/cb-unicode-contig.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-unicode-contig/cb-unicode-contig.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-escape/m-clinical-escape.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-escape/m-clinical-escape.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-failed/m-clinical-failed.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-failed/m-clinical-failed.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-stale/m-clinical-stale.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-stale/m-clinical-stale.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-unreadable/m-clinical-unreadable.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-unreadable/m-clinical-unreadable.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-freq-note/m-clinvar-freq-note.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-freq-note/m-clinvar-freq-note.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-many/m-clinvar-many.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-many/m-clinvar-many.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-none/m-clinvar-none.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-none/m-clinvar-none.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple-empty/m-couple-empty.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple-empty/m-couple-empty.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple/m-couple.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple/m-couple.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-none/m-cpsr-none.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-none/m-cpsr-none.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-noown/m-cpsr-noown.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-noown/m-cpsr-noown.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-sf-notes/m-sf-notes.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-sf-notes/m-sf-notes.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-since-clinical/m-since-clinical.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-since-clinical/m-since-clinical.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-phase/m-slivar-phase.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-phase/m-slivar-phase.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-unphased/m-slivar-unphased.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-unphased/m-slivar-unphased.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-consumer-reasons/s-consumer-reasons.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-consumer-reasons/s-consumer-reasons.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-consumer-stale/s-consumer-stale.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-consumer-stale/s-consumer-stale.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-chrx/s-sexloss-chrx.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-chrx/s-sexloss-chrx.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-detected/s-sexloss-detected.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-detected/s-sexloss-detected.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-failed/s-sexloss-failed.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-failed/s-sexloss-failed.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-gain-stale/s-sexloss-gain-stale.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-gain-stale/s-sexloss-gain-stale.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-not-estimated/s-sexloss-not-estimated.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-not-estimated/s-sexloss-not-estimated.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-odd/s-sexloss-odd.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sexloss-odd/s-sexloss-odd.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sv-stale/s-sv-stale.html
  • tests/parity/golden/report-render/s-sv-stale/s-sv-stale.txt
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/all-history/all-history.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/all-nf/all-nf.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/all/all.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-full/cb-full.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-nf/cb-nf.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-nfbad/cb-nfbad.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-notbi/cb-notbi.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-quoted-dosage/cb-quoted-dosage.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-quoted-interval/cb-quoted-interval.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-quoted-smn/cb-quoted-smn.json
  • tests/parity/golden/summary-collect/cb-unicode-contig/cb-unicode-contig.json
  • tests/schema/summary.schema.json
  • tests/test_vcfanno_toml.sh

You can disable this status message by setting the reviews.review_status to false in the CodeRabbit configuration file.

  • Autofix · Keep fixing CodeRabbit findings and required CI, and resolving merge conflicts

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

Share

@geiresx

geiresx commented Nov 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

@coderabbitai review

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Nov 21, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Action not completed

Review rate limited.

Note: CodeRabbit is an incremental review system and does not re-review already reviewed commits. This command is applicable only when automatic reviews are paused.

…t the 9 GB GATK one

GATK_IMAGE is pulled lazily, so the shard that ran this case pulled about
9 GB to bgzip five small tables. The bcftools image is cached and ships
bgzip and tabix.
The new count line read each row's support with d["support"] (Python)
and at("support") (og-render). A live-site summary whose rows have no
support key then raised, and the live site dropped the structural card:
tests/test_owngenome_live_family.py counted 0 flagged cards where it
expects 1. Both now count a missing key as not known, the same as null.

Bead: sv-01
Two confident hets of unknown phase beside a weak het in trans with one
of them read "possible two hits (low-confidence call)" on the carrier
list but "possibly biallelic" on the secondary-findings card. The card
checked two confident copies of unknown phase before the low cap; the
list capped first. The list now takes the same step in the same order.

A combined allele that is confident only through a folded part kept the
GT and phase set of its own weak call, so both cards could call a pair
biallelic that the confident calls do not prove. Each allele is now
counted with the GT and phase set of the confident call that makes it
confident, on both cards. On the card's deletion path a weak combined
allele with a confident part is no longer marked low when the
confident calls give its copies, and it pairs with the deletion by
that confident call's phase.

New shapes in the agreement test: R1, R1b, R1c (the list now says
possible two hits), R2 and R3d (the card now says possibly biallelic,
with its two-hit line), R3 (both now say possibly), and R6 and R7,
which keep the low word on both cards.

Bead: clin-19
The docs and the changelog said a gene on both lists gets the same
answer. That holds for a recessive gene the SF card counts by two
copies, and only at the gene level: on the carrier list the answer is
the best of `pair`, the `two_hits` verdict and the homozygous rows, and
`pair` counts heterozygous hits only. Say so, and name the new rule for
two confident copies of unknown phase.

Bead: clin-19
… reason too

bin/live_results.py called sf_rows without the AnnotSV consensus in the
clinical-filter table and in the findings list, so those rows still said
"no step 22 consensus" after step 22 ran, next to AnnotSV rows that said
it cannot tell. Both now pass the consensus, as the AnnotSV rows do.
The parity README names the new golden cases and the generated_utc pin,
and the two repeat-size allow lines cover only the text goldens.

Bead: sv-01
A HIGH-impact record of the clinical VCF for the same variant made a weak
call count as confident on the secondary-findings card, because the card
read only step 06's low_confidence mark. With the record's phase set it
proved a pair biallelic from a weak phase alone, and beside a deletion it
cleared the low-confidence word. The card now also treats a call whose
HIGH-impact record has weak_call as low confidence.

The carrier list paired a weak combined allele with a deletion by the weak
row's own GT and phase set, while the card used its confident part. The
list now pairs it the same way: by the first confident row of the same
allele with as many copies.

The card dropped the phase of a combined allele whose confident call gives
fewer copies than the weak one, although that phase came from the
confident call. Every small allele now counts with the copies, GT and phase
set of its confident call.

The agreement test gains eight shapes (H1, H2, H3p, H5, X4, X4b, X9b,
X10); each fails on the previous head.

Part of GeiserX#411 (clin-19).
A HIGH-impact record is weak on a skewed allele balance too, not only below
the clinical call floor. Such a call is now low confidence on the
secondary-findings card and confident on the carrier list, even when both
files state the same floor. The changelog and the results page said the
two lists agree whenever the floors match; they now name this case.

Part of GeiserX#411 (clin-19).
…balance

The docs said a HIGH-impact call weak on allele balance is low confidence
on the card only. It never lowers a hit whose ClinVar row is confident, so
that split does not exist. The real one is the HIGH-impact call of a part
of a combined allele, which makes the allele confident on the card while
the list marks it low confidence.

Bead: clin-19
…part

The carrier list rescued a weak part by its confident combined allele in
every case. The card counts a part through its combined allele only when
that allele is unphased and the part is its first part present, so a
phased combined allele inside a deletion made its weak part just outside
it read biallelic on the list. The SF card's deletion pair on a weak
HIGH-impact call also blamed the call floor; it now names both kinds of
low-confidence call.

Bead: clin-19
…t text

Main now prints the SV caller support as main's code words it ("caller
support not known (no step 22 consensus)" and the like), so the 38 report
goldens this PR adds no longer matched og. Each file is og's own output
from the merged tree; oracle-diff summary-collect report-render agrees on
all 1097 items, and no summary-collect golden moved.

Bead: clin-19
# Conflicts:
#	CHANGELOG.md
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/all-history/all-history.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/all/all.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-full/cb-full.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-full/cb-full.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-dosage/cb-quoted-dosage.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-dosage/cb-quoted-dosage.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-interval/cb-quoted-interval.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-interval/cb-quoted-interval.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-smn/cb-quoted-smn.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-quoted-smn/cb-quoted-smn.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-unicode-contig/cb-unicode-contig.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/cb-unicode-contig/cb-unicode-contig.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-escape/m-clinical-escape.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-escape/m-clinical-escape.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-stale/m-clinical-stale.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinical-stale/m-clinical-stale.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-freq-note/m-clinvar-freq-note.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-freq-note/m-clinvar-freq-note.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-many/m-clinvar-many.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-many/m-clinvar-many.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-none/m-clinvar-none.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-clinvar-none/m-clinvar-none.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple-empty/m-couple-empty.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple-empty/m-couple-empty.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple/m-couple.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-couple/m-couple.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-none/m-cpsr-none.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-none/m-cpsr-none.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-noown/m-cpsr-noown.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-cpsr-noown/m-cpsr-noown.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-sf-notes/m-sf-notes.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-sf-notes/m-sf-notes.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-since-clinical/m-since-clinical.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-since-clinical/m-since-clinical.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-phase/m-slivar-phase.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-phase/m-slivar-phase.txt
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-unphased/m-slivar-unphased.html
#	tests/parity/golden/report-render/m-slivar-unphased/m-slivar-unphased.txt
…t traced

A traced run skips the panel measure (measure_on in its file, GeiserX#572), so its
shard should not be planned around 2900 seconds of work that never runs.
…eiserX#571

GeiserX#559 (carrier confidence) and GeiserX#571 (SV support reason) each added the same
38 report-render goldens, each written by its own og. On the merged tree og
prints both changes, so the 38 files are og's output on this tip: every line
of each comes from one of the two sides, and oracle-diff now agrees on all
1097 summary-collect and report-render items (38 differed before).

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants