You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
#660/#662 writes M as a both-same difference. That identity should be checked against the rank pair, not only against collapsed D. In particular: is both-same the same as rank 2? Is both-same × both-same (spiral pairing, 6 configs at axis L=3 k=6; 685360 at axis L=5) rank-1 or rank-2?
Compute
Stream axis L=3 and L=4 (site). For each config record:
Delivered: draft PR #668 (branch issue-665-joint-rank-wrap-l3l4, base main). Notes: notes/issue-665-joint-rank-wrap-20260908.md; integer joints in results/issue665-joint-rank-wrap/axis-L{3,4}.json.
Answer to the ticket question: both-same ≠ rank 2; both-same × both-same is pure rank-1 × rank-1 (spirals) — (1,1): 6 at axis L=3 k=6, (1,1): 1120 at L=4 (k=8..12). both-same splits 6 spiral / 91 cross at L=3 and 1120 / 9045 at L=4. Rank-2 appears only in the D-carrying exclusive-cross cells (0,2)/(2,0). Tripwires pass at both L (Bernstein bit-for-bit, r_b + r_w = 2, PR #653 totals reproduced). Integers only. L=5 not run (Mac boundary; NEED_HUAWEI if wanted). No STATUS edit; ticket left open.
L=3,4 only; Bernstein and r_b+r_w=2 tripwires claimed pass; L=5 not run.
Answer:both-same is not rank-2. At L=3 it is 6 spirals (rank-1) + 91 crosses (rank-2). both-same × both-same is exactly the (1,1) spiral pairing (6 at L=3, 1120 at L=4). Rank-2 lives only in neither×both=(0,2) and both×neither=(2,0).
Activity
LightChainr commentedon Sep 8, 2026
Axis L=3,4 only (
2^9,2^16). L=5 is Huawei if ever. Draft PR against main. Integers only. Do not edit STATUS.LightChainr commentedon Sep 8, 2026
Delivered: draft PR #668 (branch
issue-665-joint-rank-wrap-l3l4, basemain). Notes:notes/issue-665-joint-rank-wrap-20260908.md; integer joints inresults/issue665-joint-rank-wrap/axis-L{3,4}.json.Answer to the ticket question:
both-same≠ rank 2;both-same × both-sameis pure rank-1 × rank-1 (spirals) —(1,1): 6at axis L=3 k=6,(1,1): 1120at L=4 (k=8..12).both-samesplits 6 spiral / 91 cross at L=3 and 1120 / 9045 at L=4. Rank-2 appears only in the D-carrying exclusive-cross cells(0,2)/(2,0). Tripwires pass at both L (Bernstein bit-for-bit,r_b + r_w = 2, PR #653 totals reproduced). Integers only. L=5 not run (Mac boundary; NEED_HUAWEI if wanted). No STATUS edit; ticket left open.LightChainr commentedon Sep 8, 2026
PR landed: #668
Grok check (no merge, leave open):
r_b+r_w=2tripwires claimed pass; L=5 not run.both-sameis not rank-2. At L=3 it is 6 spirals (rank-1) + 91 crosses (rank-2).both-same × both-sameis exactly the(1,1)spiral pairing (6 at L=3, 1120 at L=4). Rank-2 lives only inneither×both=(0,2)andboth×neither=(2,0).both-sameby rank.Ticket stays open. Related comment on #660/#662.