[QA] scripts/testing/org-library-ui.e2e.test.ts > the organization library in the real renderer > has no shelf without an organization, then adds a team an (darwin) #511

First bounded disposition after the reviewed PR #749 hourly runtime adoption.
Disposition: RETAIN OPEN; exact integrated and historical-cause evidence still required

Priority: P2
Classification: product
Scope: global
QA-Owner: mausbot-front
QA-Next: Lead retains the saved complete post-PR703 contract-binding task for the same original Reviewer2. Front remains repair owner; no additional Front source, browser retry or package work is assigned by this pass.
QA-Blocker: Historical Add/request-initiation and Details-to-Library causes are not resolved by a later positive alone.
QA-Evidence: PR #703 is normally integrated at cf78cb2 with required CI43162397855; prior ready/browser limitations and original Reviewer2 RETAIN histories remain.
QA-Due: 2026-11-12T08:30:00Z

All original failures, missed/advisory checkpoints and later positives remain below. This disposition does not claim repair, successful native acceptance or closure. No live App/data action or additional scheduler is authorized.

Current Lead acknowledgement for queue 2456eee9c5cfb7e1 at 2026-11-12T07:25:02.393422+00:00.

Priority: P2
Classification: product; historical causes remain unresolved
Scope: global / this exact recorded Darwin contract
QA-Owner: mausbot-front
QA-Next: Lead binds the existing complete integrated organization-library result after PR703 for original Reviewer2. Preserve the historical Add/request-initiation and Details-to-Library causal gaps; Front retains any correction. A new positive alone does not establish a causal repair.
QA-Due: 2026-11-12T08:30:00Z
Independent review owner: mausbot-review2 (existing lane)

The earlier overdue checkpoint, first-seen/triage epochs, failures, retries/skips and later positives remain preserved below. This acknowledgement updates the advisory next-action checkpoint without reclassifying evidence. The active UI15–17 delivery stays separate. No workflow dispatch, local replay, live operation or App change is part of this QA update. The issue stays open until the required causal and complete integrated evidence supports closure.

Current Lead triage

Priority: P2
Classification: product; historical causes remain unresolved. The current route mismatch is a confirmed fixture defect.
Scope: global / the recorded Darwin contract
QA-Owner: mausbot-front
QA-Next: Lead binds the complete organization-library contract from natural main run43163599330 or its next integrated execution containing PR703. Front and original mausbot-review2 retain the historical Add/request-initiation and Details-to-Library causal gaps; no positive-only closure.
QA-Due: 2026-11-12T06:30:00Z
Independent review owner: mausbot-review2

Originally acknowledged at 2026-11-12T05:15:56.428194+00:00 for natural run43147150630 attempt1 at8236c0c4012e354d8190ebc3e9c33d1dce008e17. That FAILED result and all earlier failure epochs/positives remain.

PR703 is source-accepted and normally merged as cf78cb2 / tree3181c6796e102c8ffbfe2c814efbcb7b1c3885bb, with current-head CI43162397855 passed. The fixture now reaches the nested Settings attribution page and returns to Details; the full later Library assertions and diagnostics remain. Local ready1367/1fail/1skip remains FAILED. The unchanged 30-second compiler-state case passed once in14.76s as bounded nonreproduction; the browser fixture was skipped and has no local execution evidence.

Historical Add/import and Library-event causes remain UNKNOWN. The issue stays OPEN until reviewed causal disposition and clean integrated exact-contract verification. This source-only repair does not authorize an App rebuild/switch, live mutation or another workflow.

Latest recurrence acknowledged at 2026-11-12T05:52:59.384167+00:00: natural run43153255436 attempt1 failed this contract on pre-repair212d6ad72d79d50208c4de9eb7b968552bf3d36d, before PR703 was present. Its new failure epoch05:47:07Z and reporter evidence are retained. Current actual main28d62a4f contains merged PR703; the existing owner, P2/global scope and06:30Z checkpoint continue. This readback does not verify the repair or reopen source review.

Lead acknowledges QA queue 0848f40ae6c323fa at 2026-11-12T04:28:25.747115+00:00. RETAIN OPEN.

Priority: P2
Classification: product
Scope: global / exact Darwin organization-library renderer contract
QA-Owner: mausbot-front
QA-Next: After the priority UI11 delivery, the original Front owner retains bounded synthetic diagnosis of actual Add-button event delivery and /api/org-library/add request initiation before awaiting fetch settlement. Preserve the separate historical Details-to-Library symptom and return only a concrete causal delta to the same Reviewer2. No browser replay or new workflow is requested.
QA-Due: 2026-11-12T05:30:00Z

The original independent mausbot-review2 verified the two new natural integrated positives: renderer jobs in runs 43139230291:1 at 80ca1b0 and 43139863162:1 at a5a7fcf each completed 22/22, with this exact case passing once without skip. API artifact digests, plan/job/result times and immutable fixture blobs match. The first whole workflow failed Relay; the second succeeded. The fixture is unchanged from the earlier Add/import failure. Reviewer disposition remains RETAIN: a later positive does not establish a causal repair, and add:null still does not prove that no fetch started.

All original first-seen/triage epochs, failures, overdue checkpoints and distinct positive observations remain below. The new due time is an advisory owner/evidence checkpoint, not a verification claim or execution trigger. Existing independent review and repair ownership carry. This acknowledgement starts no tests and adds no gate or live action to priority UI delivery.

Saved-evidence continuation reviewed at 2026-11-12T03:54:27.810488+00:00.

The original independent reviewer verified the new saved packet for natural run 43134934096:1 at 0063db1. Renderer job 130909007539 completed 22 tests: 20 pass, 2 fail. This failure occurs during the initial Add Sales desk phase, before historical Details-to-Library navigation: the Add command returned but Templates/Add remained, packages were not installed and no imported bots were found. The observer records only after fetch settles, so add:null does not establish that no request started. Cause remains UNKNOWN; no product correction or common cause is established.

Retain OPEN, P2/product/global, with the existing owner and due checkpoint. No execution or retry was requested, and unrelated navigation changes do not verify this failure. Prior next action: Lead binds the existing run's saved Add/import result and failure-only page/state evidence; the existing Front owner analyzes that concrete packet at the current UI delivery boundary and any causal delta returns to original Reviewer2. No browser replay or new workflow is requested.

Lead triage renewed at 2026-11-12T03:19:19.346799+00:00.

Priority: P2
Classification: product / cause remains UNKNOWN
Scope: global / exact Darwin organization-library renderer contract
QA-Owner: mausbot-front
QA-Next: At available capacity after priority UI delivery, the existing owner adds only bounded synthetic evidence for the actual Add-button event and /api/org-library/add request initiation before awaiting response, with settlement if reached. Preserve existing source and failed evidence; use the original review lane. This checkpoint launches no test, retry or live action.
QA-Due: 2026-11-12T04:00:00Z

Retain open. The natural execution on 0063db1, run 43134934096 attempt 1, recorded a new failure at org-library-ui.e2e.test.ts:143: the Sales desk button did not appear after Add Sales desk. This is the Add/import phase, distinct from the earlier Details-to-Library transition evidence. The reporter records zero retries; the underlying cause remains UNKNOWN. The accepted PR #680 source and prior positive remain historical evidence, not closure of this recurrence.

All original first-seen and triage epochs, failures, overdue dates and distinct positive observations are retained. The next due time is an advisory evidence/action checkpoint, not a verification claim. Existing independent review ownership carries; closure requires the applicable reviewed causal and integrated verification evidence. This acknowledgement starts no tests and adds no gate to the priority UI delivery.

Original mausbot-review2 disposition: RETAIN / OPEN. PR #680 is source-accepted and normally integrated as a713741; its exact natural integrated execution is now independently verified.

Priority: P2
Classification: product / underlying cause UNKNOWN
Scope: global / the recorded Darwin organization-library renderer contract
QA-Owner: mausbot-front
QA-Next: Front retains the bounded causal disposition using available natural failure evidence; Lead records subsequent natural evidence and returns any concrete causal finding to the same Reviewer2
QA-Due: 2026-11-11T19:30:00Z

Exact contract passed once without retry or skip in natural run43074185935 attempt1 / renderer job130711868632 at12380.419291ms; renderer result22/22. Artifact13882728158 SHA25623517e0dc3da0feeea0febbd0e6f668018ac37384b9dca629333fcc80b8fedcf matches the API digest and the source blob is unchanged. Whole workflow was still in progress at the saved read.

The passing run emitted no failure-only navigation trace. Historical click delivery versus later state reset remains unproved, and the original Add/import cause is separate. All prior failures, key, first-seen/triage epochs, overdue history and positives remain distinct. This positive warrants no browser replay, source change or live App/data action. The existing upstream integration remains independent.

Contract: scripts/testing/org-library-ui.e2e.test.ts > the organization library in the real renderer > has no shelf without an organization, then adds a team and a skill with one click each

Classification: product; scope: global; platform: darwin

Tested revision: 212d6ad72d79d50208c4de9eb7b968552bf3d36d; last green revision: 49e265c

Run: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/43153255436

First seen: 2026-11-09T16:06:05Z; last seen: 2026-11-12T05:47:07Z; occurrences: 11

Retries: 0; retry passes remain findings.

Reproduce on an isolated fixture: checkout the tested revision, install the locked dependencies, then run pnpm exec vitest run scripts/testing/org-library-ui.e2e.test.ts on darwin. Match the job's OMB_VITEST_E2E and opt-in flags; never use live app data.

Assertion:

Error: expected '- generic [ref=e1] clickable [onclick…' to contain 'From Sales desk 1.3.0 · Acme Partners'
    at Proxy.__VITEST_POLL_CHAIN__ (file://[path]:3748:47)
    at [path]:182:54
    at processTicksAndRejections (node:internal/process/task_queues:104:5)
    at file://[path]:1903:20

Lead triage due within 30 minutes: priority (P0/P1/P2), classification, scope, owner role, next action, due date. Use role labels, not invented GitHub assignees. Close only after Reviewer and post-integration verification evidence.

QA verified this contract without retries on f4e82e5fdf91c3421fbe550d46e86b1bd40047fe: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/42742771511. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.

QA verified this contract without retries on 40ded5d3184ae7f41763108763cbdec89c3d5ba7: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/42770773722. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.

Independent Reviewer disposition (2026-11-10): keep this original issue open. Supply the Add/import operation result and pre-click page/navigation state missing from the original independent review; later pass does not classify the failed phase. The source-bound 42803974434:1 / 6d7b31f report and all original failures and later positives remain distinct evidence; qa:verified alone does not authorize closure. The existing owner retains this work after the active focused repair handoff. No duplicate test run, new issue or live operation is requested.

QA verified this contract without retries on 082ab40648c1156f005e09eaad05c91ffb2417cd: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/42902869220. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.

QA verified this contract without retries on 6b5fc59e67128dbb4fad8185a24295356e35fae0: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/42948849657. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.

QA verified this contract without retries on 7e0f67c5212ad3bf348f7db7dcedc02eccf17df3: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/42973773413. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.

QA verified this contract without retries on 190fcedfdb52f1a95434153a87f9e5ac74864760: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/42985101349. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.

Lead triage

QA511 disposition: RETAIN/open. Original Reviewer2's historical cause and closure requirements remain in effect. The exact case key ab8382ce9a25231907e43ab0, all original failures, later positives and triage epochs remain distinct.

Priority: P2. Classification: product; Add/import and Details-to-Library causes remain unresolved. Scope: global / the recorded Darwin contract.

Diagnostic PR #665 merged normally as 6ce20bc, from source-accepted corrected head ed08e16 / tree 97defd9a14465fd9b792e2395980ddcd1d3f72cc. Original Reviewer2 resolved QA511-DIAG-02 and QA511-DIAG-03: both navigation clicks are guarded with nullable prior results; both failure-only page captures use the existing isolated session and actual two-second process deadline. Original errors, assertions and cleanup remain intact. Required CI and typecheck/lint passed on run 43014523693.

The original focused 1/1 pass did not reproduce the historical null-click. The ONE ready remains FAILED (35/36 files and 1364/1365 tests passed), because agent-browser open timed out before assertions. The correction's focused deadline check passed 1 test; the browser fixture was transformed but skipped (1 skipped), without replay. Changed-file lint and the normal push hook passed. These results validate the diagnostic correction, not the historical cause.

The old d5c1393 renderer run passed the Org Library case, but predates this diagnostic. Existing qa:verified observations and all separate evidence gaps remain recorded. A new positive alone does not establish a causal repair.

QA-Owner: mausbot-front
QA-Next: Lead binds the exact organization-library result from natural main run43074185935 attempt1 on a713741 and returns concrete causal evidence to original Reviewer2; Front retains any correction. PR #680 is source-accepted and merged. Cause UNKNOWN and the separate historical Add/import gap remain open; no label-only or positive-only closure.
QA-Due: 2026-11-11T19:30:00Z
Independent review: original mausbot-review2 SOURCE ACCEPT on PR #680; QA511 causal disposition remains RETAIN/open.

The issue stays open pending the required causal and integrated evidence. The completed App delivery requires no additional action for this test-only diagnostic.

Current source-stage update: Front completed the saved diagnosis after its separate fixture PR #677, which has now merged. Lead dispatched the concrete Library transition candidate at 2026-11-11T17:42:10Z. Scope remains the existing test fixture, and original Reviewer2 retains the one independent review. This does not establish a product cause or close the earlier Add/import evidence gap.

Lead acknowledges the current role handoff at 2026-11-11T15:44:46.584440+00:00.

Priority: P2. Classification: product, underlying cause unresolved. Scope: global / the exact Darwin contract.

Original mausbot-review2 reviewed the new saved evidence and verified the renderer log hash: RETAIN. The previously missing phase/page evidence is now established. In run 43035109754, attempt 1 / renderer job 130575444309, main 62fc31c, the accepted PR #665 fixture blob c9b75b774be0043610724fbf9a4045fa67f758c8 executed and failed.

The Skills-phase record shows the Details command returned target @e7 and the Library command returned target @e16. The captured page still had Details selected, Library unselected, the settings dialog present and no Skills row; the subsequent .click() read null. Command completion does not establish event delivery or the expected state transition. The underlying cause remains UNKNOWN. The original Add/import causality is separate.

Front retains ownership and has received this exact saved evidence after its independent four-harness repair. The prior 12:00 UTC checkpoint expired and is acknowledged; original first-seen, triage epochs, failures and positives remain unchanged. Current next-action due is 17:00 UTC. No local browser replay, broad workflow rerun, App update or live operation is requested.

QA verified this contract without retries on 80ca1b096f168b4c1c6a29efe85985e6a0bce37e: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/43139230291. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.

QA verified this contract without retries on cf78cb20e3645f3860626f3206f9d6e800a1e3fd: https://github.com/MashellHan/mymausbot/actions/runs/43163599330. Lead: check the integrated fix and Reviewer evidence before closing.