Repository navigation
Commander native in Core: remaining phases (2, 3 rest, 4-9) #1495
Description
Tracks the commander-native plan (commander scripts -> Core tools) phase by phase. Each phase gets a commander order (Core todo) when dispatched; this issue lists what is on main.
| Phase | State on main (8a9062d) |
|---|---|
| 0 retained-store conversion | done (#1412) |
| 1 one owner for orders | done (#1409); P554 done (#1612, fa26fc8): judge verdicts live only on Todo.verdicts; copied-root judge ok passed; leftovers: edits.jsonl, rules.jsonl (rules.py:21), growth_seen.json (growth_watch.py:12), fleet-board/fleet-narrative markdown (cli_commands.py:1391) still written by scripts |
| 2 design reconciled with what shipped | ordered 18:06 inside P83's slice series (cn-p7), after PlanIdle |
| 3 record plane | partly: PlainText, OrderText and StrikeTodo in todos.py (#1414). Missing: Verdict on the order, StrikeLimit + fire, delivery states (merged to main / other branch / not merged), strike voiding (P47 in progress) |
4 review queue (comms_order_work, comms_unjudged) |
done: comms_unjudged merged (PR1654, 41e4ec7): unjudged edits come from native turns keyed by tool call id; edits.jsonl deleted |
| 5 order and fleet stories | not started |
| 6 commander page in Toad | not started |
7 control plane (heartbeat, StandingRule, CommanderLoad, growth, UnitStorage, send guard on Core) |
in progress: P83 StandingRule + PlanIdle (cn-p7, fire 18:31); next the six rotate.py rules, then UnitStorage. Order progress and stall alarm: P73 (ci-1370); P582 (core-commander-2, due 21:20): DETACHED and REQUEST STALLED become StandingRule members, IdleUnits reads native turns |
| 8 cutover | blocked on 4-7 and the parity gate |
| 9 skill uses only Core tools | blocked on 8 |
Dependencies: 2 <- 1; 3 <- 0; 4 <- 3; 5 <- 4; 6 <- 5 (alarms fill with 7); 7 <- 3; 8 <- 4,5,6,7 + parity gate; 9 <- 8.
Why it stalled: after phases 0, 1 and part of 3 merged on 2026-10-18 the commander put every unit on decoder cleanup orders and never dispatched phase 2 or 4-9; the plan lived outside Core, so no open item showed the gap.
🤖 Generated with Claude Code
Activity
trissim commentedon Oct 18, 2026
Root cause of the stall and its fix is P48 (owner requests become commander-thread goals; every order names one; rotation alarms on a request with no open order). Until P48 lands, this issue tracks the phases.
Merge pull request #1612 from OpenHCSDev/fix/p554-judge-todo-verdicts
Merge pull request #1618 from OpenHCSDev/cn-p4/P107-verdict-kinds
Merge pull request #1628 from OpenHCSDev/cn-p4/P116-edit-records
Merge pull request #1631 from OpenHCSDev/cn-p4/P118-comms-load
Merge pull request #1654 from OpenHCSDev/fix/p577-native-unjudged
Merge pull request #1661 from OpenHCSDev/fix/p582-standing-rotation
trissim commentedon Oct 19, 2026
Owners as of 2026-10-19 13:45 local (every unit is a gpt-6.1-sol Pi thread on ts-gaming, own checkout ~/wt/--P1):
Phase 4 is done (#1654). Live overlaps to merge around: #1912 (P701), #1756 (P202).
🤖 Generated with Claude Code
trissim commentedon Oct 19, 2026
Unfinished automatic firing is preserved at branch checkpoint/cn-phase3-fire-1495 (86fcf24), separate from P254 ratchet repair on #1935. Not accepted, merged or installed.