Repository navigation
Allow runtime observation exports with validated compile-artifact reuse #179
Description
Owner: OpenHCS blind-analysis coordinator (this thread).
Public MCP reproducer on installed main-equivalent #177: create source-backed session for one 128x128 synthetic image; inspect compiled artifact plan; submit_compile(wait=False); after compile complete, submit_pipeline_execution with the SAME session/source/config and returned compile artifact, requesting runtime_observation_export_path and scope values. Run b6f27b83-af6c-486d-b5d1-7cc198700ac7 fails before any processing: Compile artifact 'c4eeb807-0fe0-4da4-87db-72ae433f9eb4' does not match execution request.
Source-backed cause: ZMQExecutionRequestPayload.request_signature hashes all config_params including the export-only destination/scope. ZMQAuxiliaryExecutionParams already owns those declarations separately from execution axis/debug inputs. Compiler reuse treats an observation-only request change as a different compiled pipeline; the compile artifact is popped before compatibility validation, so the rejected request consumes it.
Acceptance:
- Derive compilation identity from its typed determining owners, excluding only proven observation-only transport options while preserving source/pipeline/config/axis/debug distinctions.
- Retain the original request/evidence identity where its consumers require the complete submission.
- Do not consume an artifact before compatibility validation succeeds.
- Verify same-source compile -> execute with values/outcomes export through installed public MCP and check actual retained typed output/observation artifacts.
- Reject real source/config/axis differences. No permissive hash bypass or transport-key mirror roster.
This is separate from #145/#157, which preserve already-produced output paths after worker cleanup. Persistent requests/source/failed receipts are under /home/ts/wt/openhcs-live-point-evidence-20260929/native-pipeline-reopening-20260929. Fresh-compile execution is a separate diagnostic path, not proof of reused-compile acceptance. Frozen H002 is unchanged.
Activity
trissim commentedon Sep 29, 2026
Merged PR #184 is installed and live-verified in the owned Python3.12 MCP environment. Actual public MCP journey: compile bafd5d02 -> changed pipeline rejected as incompatible -> original pipeline successfully reused the SAME artifact with values export (d460519b), proving rejected reuse did not consume it. Separate outcome-scope compile/reuse also completed (129a01e2). Native readers validated A01 coverage, five value records, six existing observed files for each scope; MCP inventories each returned seven result files. Full accepted/failed envelopes, declarations, native export summaries and a checked 26-file SHA manifest are preserved at /home/ts/wt/openhcs-live-point-evidence-20260929/compile-observation-identity-20260929. This is runtime workflow validation only; the unchanged synthetic detector remains rejected and frozen H002 remains unchanged.