[PM seat] domain:spec @ objectui — 🟢 huangyiirene · session_01DBZ9bntPZ7VKyQNtJeNsgw

[objectstack-fleet]

_{Signed off 2026-10-09T00:32Z on the maintainer's instruction (「当前任务处理完，合并后就下班」), session session_01DBZ9bntPZ7VKyQNtJeNsgw. Successor: run /pm-dispatch 接手 and read this post first. The sign-off brief is comment 6071794717. The previous shift's ledger (9 landings, session_01CPvhwGcirXqBGEdPSb72TZ) is the body revision of 2026-10-06T13:31Z; its sign-off brief is comment 6017431303.}

① Current PM

⏳ vacant.

• Predecessor: huangyiirene (GET /user), session session_01DBZ9bntPZ7VKyQNtJeNsgw, seated 2026-10-08T08:33Z, signed off 2026-10-09T00:32Z. Seat id domain:spec#1. No stay-behind.
• Wake Routine: trig_017DCFxtUByEe5QYmfVVEHui (hourly, bound to that session) is disabled at sign-off. A successor seat gets its own Routine from the maintainer, in the Routines UI.
• Dev sessions: none to archive. Every dev and reviewer this shift ran as an in-process subagent of the seat's session (mode:subagent), and none is running.

② Ledger

Landed this shift: 17. Each was verified on main by content and by git patch-id --stable against the PR's net diff.

card	PR	commit	review
#6152 round 7 (resizableColumns retired on both faces; Part of)	#11955	d73d9877	6057624502 PASS; base merge 6058341570 PASS
#11168 last slice (action:button.undoable delivered and published, ruling B; card closed)	#11954	f0496bdf	6057523337 PASS; base merge 6058301376 PASS
#11389 (metric sub-caption retired at the objectui end, ruling C; card closed)	#11957	d92b2a15	6057862848 FAIL (2 CI reds), then 6058353993 PASS after the patch round and base merge
#11070 round 12 (M3 re-run; sidebar.side declared on both faces; Part of)	#11964	172acc31	6060070007 PASS
#6152 round 8 (17.7.0 object-grid operations and grid / kanban / calendar filter by reference; Part of)	#11969	d7e9e9ab	6060520083 PASS
#6152 round 9 (object-calendar calendar container follows the strict 17.7.0 slot; Part of)	#11980	1473757b	6063323808 PASS
#11943 removable-only half (SortBuilder entry disabled; card closed)	#11981	4f4fc03f	6063497259 PASS
#11978 (the racy hooks-panel test this seat filed; card closed)	#11986	fff07fbb	seat ACCEPT; no review owed (test only)
#11070 round 13 (fields[].scale / currencyConfig; M3 class (ii) reads 0; card closed)	#11972	18d7b489	6062030855 PASS
#11860 grouping in the URL (onGroupingChange, uf__group; card closed)	#11991	75bacf93	6065375611 PASS
#6152 round 10 (ObjectGridSchema.defaultFilters and the gantt / map filter by reference; Part of)	#11993	b13ea3c6	6065656403 PASS
#11863 Q3 (recent packages on the Studio landing; Part of)	#11996	054fd844	6066168690 PASS; base merge 6066636004 PASS
#11880 repeater half (element:repeater reads the node-level dataSource; Part of)	#12002	aaba8655	6068250581 PASS
#6152 round 11 (the list view's four blocks are the 17.7.0 slots by reference, strict; Part of)	#12003	cf62edf6	6068305378 PASS; patch round 6068765914 PASS
#11863 Q1 (the /studio header: AppHeader studio variant; Part of)	#12004	7ebff399	6068640274 FAIL (i18n patch → minor), then 6070090337 PASS
#11880 item 5 (ObjectView hands its grid the whole filter chain in filter; card closed)	#12010	5bc55c0c	seat ACCEPT 6070864975 (Clause-②: no, no review owed)
#6152 round 12 (the options bag is the spec overlay's by reference; ListViewTimelineConfig follows; ListViewGalleryConfig retired; Part of)	#12014	5d77c099	6071509854 PASS

In flight: none.

Queue (domain:spec, open) at sign-off:

• 121 declared-but-unmirrored keys across 16 schema pairs — the lane #6058's new UnmirroredDeclared ledger made visible #6152 (pm:queue): the renderer-side retirement of the readers is left (the alias folds, the defaultView lift, the spreads, the options rungs, the projection collectors' lists). It needs its own census of stored rows first.
• studio landing (/studio): the header holds only the product wordmark — no account menu, breadcrumb or search — and most of the page is blank #11863 (pm:queue): Q2, search on /studio (ruled A after objectui#11912, with C as the fallback). It adds first-load bytes, so it waits for eager-closure room (objectui#11939).

Closed this shift: #11168, #11389, #11943, #11978, #11070, #11860, #11880.

Filed by this seat this shift: #11978 (landed), #11984 and #11992. #11984: the hide-fields, Group and Row color lists offer an unreadable field, as the objectui#11943 dev measured. Triage graded it domain:ui, p3. #11992: a view-tab switch keeps the previous view's quick-filter selections, as the objectui#11860 dev measured; it is with triage.

Decision box: nothing waits on the maintainer. Five answers the seat gave inside standing rulings are listed for the maintainer to overrule:

1. 6066456661: 121 declared-but-unmirrored keys across 16 schema pairs — the lane #6058's new UnmirroredDeclared ledger made visible #6152 round 11, Q1 → A and Q2 → A.
2. 6067887446: page elements bind data through the node-level dataSource only: the repeater reads it, record_picker and number drop their flat-key fallbacks, the designer writes it (objectui half of objectstack#11509, ruled A-narrow) #11880, precedence A.
3. 6068966481: page elements bind data through the node-level dataSource only: the repeater reads it, record_picker and number drop their flat-key fallbacks, the designer writes it (objectui half of objectstack#11509, ruled A-narrow) #11880 item 5, A + A1.
4. 6070475966: 121 declared-but-unmirrored keys across 16 schema pairs — the lane #6058's new UnmirroredDeclared ledger made visible #6152 round 12, Q1 → A, Q2 → B, Q3 → A. D, taking options off the authoring face, is the maintainer's to reopen (objectui#10380).
5. 6069594612: a claim amendment for two now-false sentences.

Not filed, no carrier: resolveFieldCurrency's first limb reads a field-level currency the spec refuses. No reach was measured.

Acceptance notes carried, not filed (no measured reach:): #11624's details requiredness; #11637's carousel items[].content and reverse-reach residual; #11954's action:button predicates not seeing the RecordContext record; #11957's DashboardGridLayout header never drawing widget.description.

③ Hot-file serial queue

Empty: nothing is in flight in this lane.

④ Notes

• Platform fact (this shift): in a cloud seat container, REST PUT /pulls/N/update-branch writes as the session's linked user, not as objectstack-fleet[bot]. The relay has no op for it. One base merge (feat(components): action:button delivers undoable where a record is in scope, and publishes it (objectui#11168) #11954's 944e5aff) went out that way and is disclosed on objectui#11168. Base merges since then go to the PR's own dev, with git merge and a push.
• Eager-closure budget: main's ceiling is 3,391,484 bytes (objectui#11949). Bundle Analysis does not run in merge_group. objectui#12007 (main red at aa67386a, reverted by objectui#12009) taught that two PRs that each fit alone can cross together, so this lane queued byte-adding PRs one at a time, each measured on the main it would land on. At sign-off, main sits about 0.1 KB under the ceiling. objectui#11939 (the lazy designers, p1 under objectui#11942's ruling B C) is the standing remedy.
• Model quota: R1 and R2 built at default on this seat's account, with no quota refusal. The predecessor's recorded exhaustion (resetting Oct 10, 15:00 UTC) was on another account.
• objectui gates outside a dev's narrowed union: scripts/__tests__/ reads the tree by content (doc-version-claims, check-hand-rolled-comment-mask). Dispatches now name the whole suite.
• Recipe rule, carried: a local Spec Main Shape Gate reproduction needs TURBO_FORCE=true AND a scratch --cache-dir.
• Tool spelling, carried: check-governed-merges.mjs --pr takes objectstack-ai/objectui#N.

[objectstack-fleet]

Round-open marker — seat founded, R1

domain:spec @ objectui, session session_01RJpZ7i6X3hdxouUgKaqiQg, marker written 2026-09-22T16:57Z.

writes via fleet-write relay as objectstack-fleet[bot] · session session_01RJpZ7i6X3hdxouUgKaqiQg · route read 2026-09-22T16:55Z · first write = this post's parent issue #10217, author objectstack-fleet[bot], relay run 35757308315

Preflight — the three checks, before any write

#	check	reading
①	objectstack checkout at main	git pull --ff-only origin main clean; HEAD 16d090ed — ⚠️ equal to the named commit, ⛔ not strictly after it. The substantive condition holds: .github/workflows/fleet-write.yml and all four of scripts/pm/fleet-write/{dispatch,execute,ops,validate}.mjs are present. Recorded as equality rather than reported as 「在之后」.
②	session id	session_01RJpZ7i6X3hdxouUgKaqiQg (from get_session → ccr.id)
③	route	"transport":"dispatch" ✅ exit 0

⭐ The route's own reason independently corroborates a measurement this seat took before the instruction arrived: 「a cloud seat container, whose proxy replaces the Authorization header」. This seat had measured exactly that — a deliberately bogus bearer token still answered 200 and still resolved to a user login, and every /app* path answers 403 "Access to this GitHub API path is not permitted through this proxy". ⇒ the App token can neither be minted in this container nor supplied to it from outside; the relay is the only route to the bot identity. ⛔ The first relay run did not fail at 「Mint the fleet App token」 ⇒ the App installation scope does include objectui.

Round-mutex — four readings, taken before any write

reading	value
① last stand-down brief	none — no seat post for this seat existed; this post is its first
② newest round-open marker after it	none
③ newest non-self Claim: bearing this seat id on the lane's pm:dispatched ∪ pm:queue	none
④ newest CLOSED lane card bearing this seat id	none

Enumeration behind ①/②: all pm:seat in objectui, open+closed, = 4 (#9800, #9771 domain:ui; #5748 domain:devx; #5560 domain:ui) ⇒ none is this seat. ⇒ mutex clear. domain:spec seats 1–5 on objectstack were read, ⛔ not touched — this is the per-repo split, ⛔ not a takeover of any of them.

Charters re-read this round (git-history.mjs touch)

charter	touch
SKILL.md	7e0bfce40
references/core-rules.md	7e0bfce40
references/lanes/spec.md	4d1d9d9f9

⚠️ The newest sibling marker on the lane recorded 37ed9ae04 for the first two ⇒ they moved ⇒ re-read this round by construction, ⛔ not inherited.

check-harness-current: CURRENT — every harness-loaded path on origin/main is in the shared HEAD 16d090ede0. ⛔ No swap owed.

Tier — a re-measurement that reverses the newest sibling reading

origin/main:scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs:12282:export const CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER = 'claude-fable-5-1';

The newest domain:spec marker on the fleet recorded this constant as claude-opus-5 and concluded 「this seat is AT TIER」. That reading was true when taken; commit 372931e (「the contract-review tier is fable — revert the opus constant」, #19684) reverted it. This session is served claude-opus-5 (read from the session record, ⛔ not assumed) ⇒ BELOW TIER.

⇒ ⛔ no in-seat Clause-② review this round; a Clause-②: yes card needs an isolated at-tier subagent. This round therefore takes Clause-②: no work only. ⭐ Same shape the sibling seat itself named as its shift's lesson: a measurement authorises a conclusion only under the condition it was taken in — including that seat's own.

[objectstack-fleet]

⛔ Published correction — two figures in this post were wrong, and the corrected finding is STRONGER

Written 2026-09-22T17:00Z. This corrects the seat post body (§④) and the round-open marker 5780565247, both written by this seat minutes ago.

What was wrong, and the single cause

Both errors came from one flawed instrument: I counted comments with grep -c '"id":', which counts nested ids (comment.id, user.id, …), ⛔ not array members.

published	actual	verdict
「control: #9837 returns 4」	#9837 returns 1	⛔ wrong — 4 was the "id": occurrence count of a single comment
「MCP get_comments under-reports independently — #9837 gave 1 of 4」	MCP returned 1, REST returns 1 — they agree	⛔ withdrawn in full — there is no MCP under-reporting; that was an artefact of the same bad counter

⭐ The control word discipline catches the shape of a zero but ⛔ not a miscounted positive. The re-measure used a JSON-aware count (array length), ⛔ not a grep.

The finding itself — unchanged in direction, and now much better evidenced

The 11 cards still return zero comments, and the control still passes (#9837 returns 1, ⛔ not 0) ⇒ the instrument can see comments ⇒ the zero is a real absence. But the corrected re-measure found the thing the bad counter had hidden:

All 12 cards — the 11 from 2026-09-20 AND the control #9837 — carry a metadata comments counter that exceeds the actual list by EXACTLY 1.

card	meta	actual
#9837 (control)	2	1
#10145 #10084 #10083 #10078 #10074 #10073 #10072 #10071 #10069 #10068 #10066	1 each	0 each

⇒ exactly one comment was deleted from each of twelve cards. GitHub's counter does not decrement on delete, which is why the two readings disagree — the counter is the fossil of the deleted comment.

Named, verified instance. #9837's surviving ruling cites its triage comment by id: 「Facts (this card; triage 5727829764)」.

GET /repos/objectstack-ai/objectui/issues/comments/5727829764  -> 404 Not Found
GET /repos/objectstack-ai/objectui/issues/comments/5729875984  -> 200   (control: the ruling itself, alive)

⇒ the instrument distinguishes deleted from alive, and the triage measurement underpinning a maintainer-agreed ruling is gone.

What this changes for dispatch — one card separates from the other eleven

• The 11 stay undispatchable. Each says 「the comment governs and this paragraph does not」 and declares itself CONFIRMED by the deleted comment ⇒ no surviving authority, and the body disclaims its own wording. ⛔ Not dispatchable on their own terms.
• finding(plugin-grid): object-grid 的 pagination 与 selection 用相反的规则读「自己在不在」—— 写下对象,一个生效、一个无效 #9837 remains dispatchable. Its deleted comment was the triage one, but the surviving ruling (5729875984, maintainer 「同意」) restates the facts it relied on in its own body ⇒ it is self-contained; the card's authority does ⛔ not depend on the deleted comment.

⇒ the separation is 「does a surviving authority state the facts」, ⛔ not 「how many comments are left」.

⚠️ For the triage seat and the maintainer

Twelve cards in one lane each lost exactly one comment, and the deleted ones are the triage re-measurements — including one a director-seat ruling cites by id. ⛔ This seat does ⛔ not know the cause (deliberate deletion, a retracted bulk write, or platform-side) and ⛔ does not guess. Reported, ⛔ not diagnosed. The evidentiary base of the 2026-09-20 filing batch is gone and needs re-measuring at source before any of those 11 can be dispatched.

[objectstack-fleet]

Stand-down brief — seat released (final write)

Authority, verbatim, maintainer in this seat's session: 「你可以下班了」 · and on the open findings: 「你刚才提的问题总监都接手了，不用再管」.

Stand-down = state flush plus explicit placement of what is in flight. This comment is the seat's last write: the title, the body and #9837's state label were changed in the same relay request, immediately before it. Read at 2026-09-23T03:09Z.

① Landed this shift — 1

card	PR	merge	verified by content
#9837 (ruling batch #162 item 2 · A′)	#10218	62597c5, an ancestor of objectui main	ObjectGrid.tsx:4404-4408 checks showPagination === false before pagination presence, and the changeset @object-ui/plugin-grid: minor is on main

⚠️ Honest note on the instrument: my first dark control, the snippet pagination !== undefined → ? true, still matched on main, because A′ keeps that branch and only puts the explicit off ahead of it. The discriminator is the order of the two checks, ⛔ not the snippet. It was re-read on that basis.

② In flight — 0

• finding(plugin-grid): object-grid 的 pagination 与 selection 用相反的规则读「自己在不在」—— 写下对象,一个生效、一个无效 #9837 was closed by Fixes. pm:dispatched was removed in this request (a closed card carries no pm state label); the assignee stays as the record.
• The dev subagent returned its report (5781323644) and was accepted (5787900889). No other dispatch was made.
• The lane's only other pm:dispatched card, objectui#8068 的过渡背书：58 个 array/object 类 input 仍无 per-block 成员 pin（逐条转 pin，删豁免） #8071, belongs to hotlong — ⛔ not this seat's. Its staleness is among the items handed to the director.

③ Handed to the director — ⛔ nothing here is left to a successor seat

The post-stamped fail-open fallback, the relay's automerge_enable permission, the classifyHttp 403 misclassification, the 12 deleted triage comments, the spec selection.type default seam, and #8071. Source of the handover: the maintainer's words above. ⛔ This seat filed no card and made no pm:retriage write for any of them.

④ This shift's own misses, stated plainly

• No wake Routine was created at seating (the rule is 「入座即建唯一自绑 cron Routine」). The shift ran on maintainer turns only ⇒ there is nothing to delete, and ⛔ no timer points at this session.
• A miscount went onto the board and was corrected publicly (5780598365): grep -c '"id":' counted nested ids, ⛔ not comments.
• A claim draft carried a bare timestamp inside a quoted span. post-stamped refused it (exit 2, zero writes), so the atomic pair was never split.

⑤ Closing readings

• Writes this shift: every one went through the relay as objectstack-fleet[bot] — ⛔ zero direct writes.
• One relay run stopped part-way: run 35810462718 stopped at automerge_enable. The two actions before it landed and were recorded on finding(plugin-grid): object-grid 的 pagination 与 selection 用相反的规则读「自己在不在」—— 写下对象,一个生效、一个无效 #9837 (5787926803); the maintainer then merged by hand.
• Zero suggestions, per the shift-report default. Everything that might have become one is with the director.

[objectstack-fleet]

Round-open marker: R1 of this shift

domain:spec @ objectui · session session_01877XiBYSaRCk2CU7cMSg3S · 2026-09-23T23:49Z

Round mutex. ① Newest stand-down brief: 5788305956 (the predecessor, session_01RJpZ7i6X3hdxouUgKaqiQg). ② No round-open marker after it. ③ Lane pm:dispatched ∪ pm:queue shows no Claim: newer than the brief: the newest card updated_at in the lane is 2026-09-22T03:51Z, which is before the brief. ④ Nothing on the lane has closed since then. The brief is the release marker, so the seat is taken directly.

Charter touches (git-history.mjs touch, objectstack origin/main fdeeea0): SKILL.md 0bc46c6d1, references/lanes/spec.md f151ef2c9, references/execution-duties.md f151ef2c9. All three were read this fire. check-harness-current: CURRENT.

Round outcome: 0 dispatched. The reasons are on the body (§②): the batch is held on deleted evidence, #9849 is waiting on pm:retriage, and the North-Star gate is closed for the remaining p2/p3 hygiene and tooling cards. The Routine re-checks every hour. It stays silent if nothing has changed.

[objectstack-fleet]

Seat-post body corrected at 2026-09-24T01:48Z. Session session_01877XiBYSaRCk2CU7cMSg3S found the body out of date during an hourly check. Triage rerouted #9849 to domain:ui, and #9747 was closed as a duplicate. The P0/P1 counts were re-read, and the North-Star gate is still closed. The lane still has 0 dispatchable cards and 0 in flight.

[objectstack-fleet]

Seat-post body corrected at 2026-09-24T03:48Z. The hourly check found #8346 closed not_planned, so it is off the gated candidate list. Nothing else changed: the North-Star gate is still closed (objectstack 4 P0 / 29 P1, objectui 0 P0 / 7 P1). The lane still has 0 dispatchable cards and 0 in flight.

[objectstack-fleet]

Seat-post body updated at 2026-09-24T05:50Z. On the maintainer's instruction, this seat re-measured the 2026-09-20 batch at source, one comment on each of the 11 cards. The ledger in §② now classifies them. No card was claimed or dispatched in this act.

[objectstack-fleet]

Round-open marker: R1 of this shift · 2026-09-27T01:26Z

domain:spec @ objectui · session session_014fWVhLzhxR8qrFsJ5o8TYW · account os-tesla. Summoned by the maintainer (/pm-dispatch spec@objectui).

Round mutex (four readings, taken before any write):

reading	value
① last stand-down	this post's body revision at 2026-09-25T04:25Z (「Unseated」, predecessor session_01877XiBYSaRCk2CU7cMSg3S, Routine disabled)
② round-open marker after it	none
③ newest non-self Claim: bearing domain:spec#1 on the lane's pm:dispatched ∪ pm:queue, or a branch push after ①	none. #7469's claim 5827036862 is domain:ui#5 (another seat; released at 5827639834), and its branch sits at BASE. claude/issue-7759-* last moved 2026-09-09.
④ newest CLOSED lane card bearing this seat id	#10289, predecessor's session (before ①)

⇒ The stand-down is the newest event, so the seat is taken directly.

Charters re-read this fire (git-history.mjs touch, objectstack origin/main 16c5a33): SKILL.md 7b068877c · references/execution-duties.md 7a13e0562 · references/lanes/spec.md f151ef2c9 · references/seat-lifecycle.md f151ef2c9 · references/landing-operations.md 4502bfb59 · references/cross-repo-coordination.md 3f3c0f765. check-harness-current: CURRENT.

Tier. CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER = 'claude-fable-5-1', and this seat is below it. Every contract review therefore runs as an isolated at-tier subagent.

This round's batch (3), by the take order. Contract face first, then priority:p2, then Bug and card age:

• finding(types): the 「record id is a string」 rule has THREE unruled survivors — CommentSearchResult.recordId and RecordSubscription.recordId (both REQUIRED, published) plus DataSourceMutationEvent.id #10078 (p2): the inherited record-id ruling (see its claim);
• finding(types,plugin-kanban): ColumnWidthConfig / ColumnWidthConfigSchema are published with zero readers and no schema key that references them (objectui#8522 removed the last reader) #10582 (p3 bug): retire ColumnWidthConfig;
• finding(types,plugin-charts): ObjectChartSchema.xAxisField / yAxisFields / aggregation are declared on the object-chart node, but ObjectChart reads none of them; a node written with them draws no category axis #10608 (p3 bug): retire the three inert ObjectChartSchema keys.

Serial behind them: #10611 after #10078 (views.ts), and #10584 after #10608 (ObjectChartSchema block). #7469 (p3 enhancement, ruling C) is next in line.