Research repository for Lean-assisted verification of results on spaces of compatible metrics.
The joint preprint by Yoshito Ishiki and Tomoki Uda, Borelness of Moduli Spaces of Metrics Implies Separability, is available as arXiv:2608.19618v2, posted on 2026-11-03. The earlier v1 remains available as a versioned reference.
The formalisation's statement gate is the manuscript source received on
2026-11-03, which is reference-only and lives outside this repository.
The public v2 and that received archive are distinct source references;
the matching date alone does not establish that their contents are identical.
The repository verifies the received source theorem by theorem:
notes/borel-manuscript-20261103-audit.md is the mathematical source of truth
(statements, verdicts, verified repairs, external-theorem dependencies, and
the label-level Lean correspondence) for that source;
notes/borel-manuscript-20260827-audit.md is the frozen record of the
previous received source (2026-08-27) and holds the exact external
statements; notes/borel-preprint-audit.md is the frozen arXiv v1 record and
carries the per-declaration Lean package; and the
Lean development under lean/IshikiConj51/Ext/
(namespace IshikiExt) formalises the audited statements. The audit notes
record, per theorem, exactly what is formalised and modulo which explicit
external theorems — including where a Lean statement deliberately differs
from the printed one (a density-free parameter set, audited proof-route
repairs, or statements stronger than the preprint's that imply them). The
published Met/BMet/CPM ambient hypotheses are preserved exactly, never
replaced by proxies. Two families of results are covered:
- Archimedean chain (v1 numbering: Proposition 2.1, Lemmas 3.1–3.2, Theorems 3.3–3.5
and 3.8, Corollaries 3.6–3.7 and 3.9): the discrete non-Borelness
obstruction for
Met(Z)/BMet(Z)inCPM(Z), its component and complete-metric refinements, and the transfer "moduli space Borel ⇒ base space separable". Ishiki's isometric-extensor theorem (E1, arXiv:2407.03030) and Koshino's theorem (E3) enter the Lean statements only as explicit hypotheses, never as axioms. - Non-Archimedean/ultrametric chain (v1 numbering: Proposition 2.2, Lemmas 3.10–3.11,
Theorems 3.12–3.14 and 3.16, Corollaries 3.15 and 3.17): the same
programme for
R-valued ultrametrics, with theUCPM/𝒰𝒟^Rambient built from scratch. Ishiki's factorization theorem (E2, Colloq. Math. 2023) enters as an explicit hypothesis bundle.
Where the audit found a printed proof with a repairable gap, the Lean
development formalises the audited repair rather than the printed route; the
audit note records every such deviation next to the theorem it concerns.
Terminology for both tracks is fixed in notes/terminology.md.
This repository originally proved and formalised Conjecture 5.1 from Ishiki, An isometric extensor of metrics, arXiv:2407.03030:
For a discrete space
Dof cardinalityℵ₁,Met(D)— the metrics compatible with the discrete topology, with the supremum-metric topology — is not completely metrizable.
That result passed the project's independent mathematical audit and has a sorry-free Lean 4 formalisation. It is retained as an archival verified core rather than the active research target.
Archival artifacts:
report/report-ja.md— self-contained Japanese proof report;lean/IshikiConj51/Conj51/— Lean formalisation of the Conjecture 5.1 proof;notes/proof-audit.md— historical proof and formalisation audit record;paper/— the earlier single-author manuscript workspace.
Do not rewrite those artifacts to match the newer joint preprint unless a dedicated issue explicitly requires a provenance-preserving change.
An earlier draft attempted a stronger analytic/coanalytic theorem package.
That track is closed and must not be treated as a source of truth: the Borel
statement replaces it, and §5 of notes/borel-manuscript-20261103-audit.md
records the claims that must not be reinstated — in particular, the draft's
"not coanalytic" half is not a ZFC theorem. The pointclass-free metric coding
that work produced remains reusable IshikiExt infrastructure.
| Path | Role |
|---|---|
lean/IshikiConj51/Ext/ |
Lean formalisation of the public-preprint track (IshikiExt) |
lean/IshikiConj51/Conj51/ |
archival Lean proof of Conjecture 5.1 |
report/report-ja.md |
archival Japanese Conjecture 5.1 proof |
notes/ |
mathematical audit, terminology, and literature references |
paper/ |
archival earlier manuscript workspace |
Module map for lean/IshikiConj51/Ext/ (v1 theorem numbers are retained for
orientation; labels are the stable identifiers, and the correspondence column
uses the labels of the 2026-11-03 received source):
| Modules | Content | Received-source correspondence |
|---|---|---|
BddPMet, BoundedCoding |
bounded pseudometric ambient; the star-metric coding and its exact pullback identity | lem:metric-coding, lem:closed-parameter-embedding, thm:bounded-discrete-nonborel → BddPMet, BoundedCoding; received-source pullback repairs are already reflected in the existing route |
Borel, CPM, Relabel |
discrete non-Borel obstruction (Theorem 3.3) in the bounded and unbounded ambients; arbitrary-carrier relabelling | thm:bounded-discrete-nonborel, cor:discrete-metric-nonborel → Borel, CPM, Relabel; v1 coverage retained, with the received-source pullback and relative-Borel repairs already reflected in the route |
Amalgam, Component |
one-point amalgamation; component non-Borelness (Theorem 3.4) | lem:one-point-amalgamation, thm:metric-component-nonborel → Amalgam, Component; strengthened to ` |
Completeness, CompleteMetric |
complete-metric branch (Theorem 3.8, Corollary 3.9) | thm:complete-metric-nonborel, cor:complete-metric-borel-separability → Completeness, CompleteMetric; received-source complete-amalgam repair is already reflected in this route |
GeneralSpace, GeneralSeparability |
general-space Borel/separability transfer (Theorem 3.5), E1 as explicit hypothesis | thm:borel-separability → GeneralSpace, GeneralSeparability; received-source BMet transfer and pullback repairs are already reflected in the existing route. cor:nonseparable-metric-nonborel → GeneralComponent (E1, E1c) |
CompleteMetrizability |
Alexandrov–Lavrentiev for a metrizable ambient; Corollaries 3.6 and 3.7 | thm:complete-metrizability-g-delta, cor:metric-space-complete-separability → CompleteMetrizability, GDeltaCompletelyMetrizable; cor:bounded-metric-complete-sigma-compact's five-way form → FiveWay (E1, E3, E5, E6) |
UltraPMet, CantorUltra, UltraCoding, UltraComponent |
discrete ultrametric core (Proposition 2.2, Lemmas 3.10–3.11, Theorems 3.12–3.13) | prop:dense-aleph1-nonborel-cantor, lem:ultrametric-coding, lem:closed-ultrametric-parameter-embedding, thm:discrete-ultrametric-nonborel, thm:ultrametric-component-nonborel → UltraPMet, CantorUltra, UltraCoding, UltraComponent; Cantor witness strengthened to bi-density (#109, PR #116) |
UltraGeneral, UltraTransfer |
ultrametric transfer (Theorem 3.14, Corollary 3.15), E2 as explicit hypothesis | thm:ultrametric-borel-separability, cor:ultrametric-space-complete-separability → UltraGeneral, UltraTransfer; the v1 ambient-transfer repair remains reflected here as an alternative route. cor:nonseparable-ultrametric-nonborel and the E2c-route forms of both theorems → UltraComponentGeneral (E2c as the explicit hypothesis hEx); lem:ultrametric-extensor-preserving-component → UltraNetExtensor, which proves hEx and gives the extensor-hypothesis-free forms of 4.6–4.8 |
UltraComplete, UltraCompleteTransfer |
complete-ultrametric branch (Theorem 3.16, Corollary 3.17) | thm:complete-ultrametric-nonborel, cor:complete-ultrametric-borel-separability → UltraComplete, UltraCompleteTransfer, UltraPublished (E2(N1); both the Borel and the completely-metrizable claim) |
GitHub Issues and Pull Requests are the sole work queue and
execution-evidence record; repository documents carry only durable
mathematical, architectural and reference content. Mathematical statement
changes are gated by the corresponding audit note and land through focused,
independently reviewed PRs. Accepted Lean results are sorry-free, introduce
no custom axioms, and include an explained #print axioms check recorded in
the PR review trail.
Install elan and Git, then run from a checkout of this repository:
cd lean
lake exe cache get # fetch mathlib oleans; never cold-build mathlib
flock /tmp/lean-build.lock lake buildlean/lean-toolchain pins Lean 4.35.0, and lean/lake-manifest.json
pins mathlib and its transitive dependencies. Keep the manifest when
reproducing a build; lake update changes the dependency resolution and is
not part of this procedure. Allow at least 2 GiB of free memory and do not
run concurrent builds in a shared environment. The flock command above
is for Linux; on other systems, run lake build with equivalent exclusive
access to the checkout.
The default target imports the archival and public-preprint modules through
lean/IshikiConj51.lean. A successful build checks those Lean declarations;
it does not establish source fidelity or discharge external theorems that
remain explicit hypotheses. The audit notes describe those boundaries.
Independent #print axioms checks of accepted declarations use an
untracked scratch file and are recorded with the corresponding PR.
For the mathematical notes' PDF build, dependencies and missing-glyph
checks, see notes/README.md. No CI is configured;
validation is local/manual, with execution evidence in Issues and PRs.
lean/scripts/check-comparator.sh runs an optional, manual Comparator pilot
for one IshikiExt result against a frozen reference
(notes/comparator-pilot-contract.md); it is not part of the build above.
For the mathematical results, cite:
Yoshito Ishiki and Tomoki Uda, Borelness of Moduli Spaces of Metrics Implies Separability, arXiv:2608.19618v2 (2026). DOI: 10.48550/arXiv.2608.19618.
The DOI identifies the e-print; the versioned arXiv link identifies v2. For a result about this Lean development, also identify the repository commit and the relevant declaration or module. CITATION.cff provides machine-readable citation metadata. The earlier single-author paper and Conjecture 5.1 materials remain archival artifacts, not the source of the joint preprint's attribution.
The repository's existing license is Apache-2.0. The externally hosted joint preprint v2 is distributed under CC BY 4.0, as recorded on its arXiv page. A citation or link does not change either license. The reference-only received manuscript archives are not included in this repository.