[trissim]

Row 8: verdicts

Head: f0900066c38fdc4e94da9e2d71e9ebddb09dca35
Base: fix/parity-family-a at 9243f5845e6468c5c1f85c94fbeb85082edb86a5, including its rebase onto main and both CLI-field/time-boundary corrections.

Superseded by family-A integration in #2101 at e686e0fcd1abd97fa074dd4a44bcfe994485a5c3. Not merged to main or installed.

Integrated result (5984)

Read the retained p301/catalog-verdict-live.json and p301/verdict-family.json: row8 passed all four real current/native accepted/send-back paths. Git object comparison confirms the verdict implementation, its tests and generated plan are byte-identical to this worker head; row8's declaration is retained unchanged (the rows file only adds the independent story comparison). This is integration-owner execution, not an independent rerun by this worker.

#2101 remains draft/held. Its tools ratchet is0; its source check ended in a mypy2.3.0 internal error at rows.py:180, so there is no clean integrated source-check claim. The prior actor-specific and default-reader failures below remain historical observations, not proof of a global store repair.

Implementation and ownership

• Row 8 declares comparison = VerdictComparison.read once; no row verify() forwarder or shared-dispatch change.
• Four independent LifecycleRun copies compare accepted/send-back through the original current judge and native CommsVerdictTool.
• Each copy executes the real pinned Pi SDK edit tool and stores its actual result using SessionManager. The original Edit.unjudged reader must find exactly that fresh call.
• Controlled fresh tool-request envelopes are verification input, not genuine model/provider output. No provider request, fabricated native result, replacement native owner or original-session write.
• VerdictMutation owns the observed deltas; VerdictObservation inherits the existing LifecycleObservation proof behavior. The old parallel case validator and boolean-state DTO were removed.
• Existing native owners retain Goal/strike mutation and committed-history visibility. Consumers use Goals.goal_history, not a second interpretation of internal journal tags.
• The shared LifecycleRun.invoke_command owns process launch/expiry. Node receives the copied project and package.node_environment(...) explicitly; ChildOutcome.successful owns outcome interpretation.
• No config.cli, hhmm, deleted deadline() helper, compatibility reader, extra copier, native pin, checker, baseline or installation change.
• Corrected row 8's declaration/generated prose: current judge already invokes the native verdict owner, not a competing verdicts.jsonl store.

Actual results

Current executable-code artifacts: /home/ts/.cache/agent-scratch/pi-cn-phase2/verdict-main-*; final ratchets: verdict-final-main-*. The final amendment only changes a comment; ast.dump confirms executable AST equality with tested head3255cd338.

• Actual row-8 run fails before creating an order/verdict, in CheckRoot._session -> source.reading -> TypedStore.require_schema: external_transcripts.sqlite3 differs from its declaration. No store was altered and no fallback reader was added. This matches the independently reported integration blocker for row 30.
• Focused/regression batch: 90 passed, 1 failed. Sole failure is withdrawal demanding installed evidence. It was reproduced independently on parent c474d9f95; the retained repair belongs to pi-toad-cancel/P287: gate stale and unplanned commander work; reconcile merged deliveries #2073. It is not a new row-8 regression.
• Final-head separate tools/source ratchets: 0 / 0 against9243f5845; positive deltas, introduced findings and introduced sites are all empty. No checker modification. The earlier comment-word finding was corrected in its owning commit, not suppressed.
• Separately exercised the ordinary configured-commander CLI default (without the explicit pi-cn-phase2 caller). That also fails before selecting/copying a unit: MalformedRecord: Unknown StrikeTodo name: 'missed_first_call_strike' while reading canonical held orders. Evidence: verdict-default-live.err/.exit. This is a distinct read-compatibility blocker, not a passing replacement fixture.
• Ruff and diff checks passed.

Earlier actual copied-bus acceptance, before the main/runtime rebase: head 4cc7691dfe79c20de709151331be65548b892b91, verdict-delivery-live.json, exit 0. All four real SDK-edit/current-or-native verdict journeys passed: accepted had one verdict/Todo revision, zero Goal revisions/history changes/strikes; send-back had one verdict/Todo revision, one Goal revision/committed history record/strike, with matching strike/verdict event and visible canonical feedback. Both kept Goal identity/state and retained the actual native return. This is not acceptance of the current rebased head.

The earlier whole verifier stopped on the existing capacity subprocess's 30-second timeout; no fresh whole-parity count is claimed. Existing Load ownership has the reproducer.

Source evidence

NRA Package/Repository census before and after: verdict-ast-before.txt, verdict-main-ast.txt. Python production/tests/tools/stack roots have zero parse omissions. Row 8 has one comparison declaration and zero verify forwarders. Actual source relationships inspected: original judge -> measured native call -> CommsVerdictTool -> Goals.send_back/SentBackOrderGoalAction; Goal/history and strike consumers remain their canonical owners. The Python AST does not prove dynamic Node import resolution or parse TS/C internals; SDK/tool/session APIs were inspected and the earlier original SDK journey ran successfully.

Remaining acceptance and resource custody

The integration owner has now demonstrated the four-path copied workflow on the integrated head. Remaining family checks and installed acceptance stay with that owner. This worker has not rerun its earlier actor-specific/default-reader failures and makes no claim that all retained histories are repaired. Original data must not be rewritten or bypassed by this comparison. Merger owns fresh installed acceptance; nothing was merged or installed here. No UNKNOWN input/edit was replayed; unrelated P310/P311 and withdrawal implementations remain with their named owners.

Owned prepared-artifact copy: /home/ts/wt/pi-cn-phase2--P297/stack/.pi-native-a0f57a811b47862f, copied unchanged from the existing owned P273 preparation. Retirement after integration is recorded in verdict-integration.md; existing shared native cache and donor are untouched. Test roots and logs are under /home/ts/.cache/agent-scratch/pi-cn-phase2; retire disposable test roots after their processes exit. Preserve P273's dirty handoff and all original sessions, stores and UNKNOWN inputs.

Assumed: controlled SDK input proves the affected tool/storage/Goal path, not provider behavior or installed UI acceptance. First push and draft PR opening met the requested 10/20-minute milestones.

[trissim]

Superseded by #2101 at e686e0f: the verdict implementation, tests and generated plan are byte-identical to f090006, and row8 retains its single comparison declaration. Read the integration-owner artifacts: all four real edit/verdict paths pass. This is copied-workflow acceptance, not main merge or installation. The integrated source check hit a mypy internal error; #2101 remains draft/held. No independent rerun or global retained-store repair is claimed.