[trissim]

Issue376 production follow-through

Owner: Schrodinger. Own WT openhcs-knowledge-declaration-source-376-20261001.
Normal merge of main e66500e and original diagnostic cabc6f1; existing PR377.
Singer's current #404 WT remains untouched. #379 stays Dewey's explicit claim
5940290078 on fix/canonical-custom-source-379-20261001, not a complete fix here.
No startup, runtime, external394 metadata, native package, provider or live changes.
Source-only oneCPU/512MiB/no swap/60s. Parent owns installed10s acceptance.

Original diagnostics and archive remain byte-exact, including both installed
timeouts and #379's separate red. This receipt is a product source checkpoint,
not replacement predecessor evidence. No persisted format changes.

Owner and mechanism

OpenHCSFunctionCatalogDeclaration owns batched source eligibility and exact
registered-declaration reuse. CellProfilerModule supplies its original normalized
module-name/alias and function/variant projections; source_bindings_for_modules
admits all enabled input module names once. LazyDiscoveryDict owns admission
under its existing lock, delegating to the original discover_registry_classes
loop. Paired metaclass-registry PR2 productionf27ff1ce18ddeaaa6f9dff6ff10778d3f40bb94b.
Exact published gitlink22837a912da2fba0cf2f562c31e0aeaab21ef29a adds only the
dependency receipt after that audited production checkpoint.

No KnowledgeBaseService change, second importer, roster, registry, catalogue,
cache or environment mutation. Source literals are eligibility only; original
AutoRegisterMeta plus CellProfilerModule validation remain membership authority.
Nonliteral expressions select import rather than inventing their evaluated value.
Selected import/registration failures propagate. Partial admission never publishes
the original complete-discovery flag or cache. Later explicit full discovery
uses the same importer and registry. Selected custom/recursive discovery is
explicitly unsupported in this generic API; CellProfiler's owner is flat.

The native Python AST visitor prunes function bodies, which cannot assign
enclosing declaration fields; declaration bodies and nested classes retain native
traversal. This replaces full AST walking, not another AST/cache authority.
Source declaration fields remain eligibility projections, not runtime proofs.

IMPL-3/4: existing CellProfiler declaration hooks select behavior, no consumer
library/type switch. IMPL-12/13: original import and registration loop reused.
MEMB-1/2: no parallel family or selected-member roster. BOUND-2: actual class
identities come from the original registry, never source records. TIME-1/3:
replaced eager selected-lookup path removed, no compatibility entrypoint.
New case: one independently imported declaration at an arbitrary filename,
with canonical name/alias/function lookup through unchanged consumers. A genuine
independent init_subclass capability composes before AND after CellProfiler
in real C3 order, and matching super executes its before/after behavior once.

Retained source evidence

selected-discovery-evidence holds all logs with exact commands/resources:

• first-source: original Verify original official30 knowledge sections after selected-discovery repair #376 witness passed; two new test aliases used a spelling
  not equivalent under the original normalizer,2failed/1passed. Repeated scans
  cost31.67s/335272KiB. That prototype is not the delivery candidate.
• second-source: normalized fixture corrected and registered-owner reuse added,
  3passed/1deselected,13.31s/337492KiB. Still too much repeated missing-key work.
• batched-source: original source-binding owner batches keys;14passed/1failed,
  5.75s/328604KiB. Generic test root lacked the existing authoritative
  registry_config declaration; correction uses the original API.
• owner-source:50passed/1deselected,5.60s/327192KiB before AST function pruning.
  Verify installed cold and stale canonical custom-function lookup #379 is deliberately deselected, not waived or declared fixed.
• selected-cold-profile: original retained diagnostic script, byte-identical,
  actual10174-character selected source returned. Full source process8.96s /
  335140KiB with cProfile;69 module eligibility reads, one discovery batch,
  nine selected import-owner calls. Profile showed AST walking cost, motivating
  native function-body pruning. This is not installed timing evidence.

Final paired source checkpoints

OpenHCS production49b46d59e4eca9e5ea5c042c921f681bcf5ff732. Function-name lookup
belongs on existing OpenHCSFunctionCatalogDeclaration; CellProfiler keeps its
small primary/variant projection hook, original fields and validation. Original
R0 rejects 5fd (+1 GodClassExcess) and24a (+1 per-file ForeignAbsenceProbe);
both JSON/resource receipts remain. Final5176 projections have zero positive
deltas,16.89s/87444KiB. CellProfiler GodClassExcess decreases22; StringSubscript
decreases1. No guard allowance, detector copy or hidden rejected head.

Dependency69b6 first R0 rejected duplicated configuration admission (+1 foreign
probe). LazyDiscoveryDict now owns one _has_discovery_configuration admission
used by both full and selected discovery, deleting repeated checks. Finalf27ff1c
has31 projections,zero positive,1.68s/45356KiB. Original R0 is unchanged pinned
3b03785f45df2ef5dc62ba6aed99294192ecbb01, Python3.14, read-only backing path;
debt_ratchet.py SHA256e323c94d49c2b72d9524a5169f123e64b4a6e46a41035ca9fb4497e49b6ca562.

Final focused53pass/1deselected (Dewey379),7.18s/343340KiB. Strengthened real
callable new-case5pass,12.06s/328900KiB with observed53percent CPU; its body
raises if executed, yet original require_callable resolves the exact object.
Final retrieval-admission/new-case5pass,5.93s/329736KiB; ExampleHuman denies
both RegistryService preparation entrypoints and whole-family discovery.
These five cases overlap the53, not58 independent tests.

Final original diagnostic script returns10174chars with no errors, one admission
batch and nine selected imports. cProfile get_document3.589s; total process6.43s/
340944KiB. Eligibility69source reads0.842s rather than the previous prototype's
full AST-walk2.156s. Those are bounded source observations across evolving heads,
not a controlled installed benchmark or proof of the original10s timeout closure.

Preserved broader limits and operational correction

Adding original official30 capability tests hit collection error in the old
read-only pyqt-reactive dependency: WindowSnapshotFrameCondition lacks
RENDER_COMPLETE. That run5.49s/260792KiB,exit2. No package source was patched.
Broader backend-public checks72pass/4fail/1deselected,16.59s/406772KiB; four
fresh subprocess controls cannot import source-tree _tabular_native. Their logs
remain, not classified as successful fresh-process acceptance.

An EXTRA unpublished public-source roundtrip assertion crossed source376 scope:
PipelineDocumentAuthority.from_source -> get_function -> RegistryService started
one --prepare-capabilities child. Its direct owned wait returned1 at the missing
_tabular_native import; exact PID/incarnation was not persisted. Launcher flag
returns before the serving branch, so this was a preparation-only source child,
not a native endpoint/readiness attempt. No terminal timeout/replay or worker
kill occurred. 1fail/4pass,7.38s/368108KiB transcript is retained. Process check
afterward found no preparation child; no installed environment was modified.
This assertion is NOT installed/public-source roundtrip qualification. Removed
only that out-of-scope extra assertion and kept the actual retrieval/new-case
tests; added explicit preparation rejection to the retrieval check. The original
official30 roundtrip test stays untouched and its live acceptance remains parent
owned. No fresh retry of that preparation/roundtrip route.

No complete
NRA/global R1 claim: original full-context failure remains separately retained;
no detector copy, context pruning, timeout increase or full R1 retry.
Cleanup completed: removed ONLY
/home/ts/.cache/agent-scratch/knowledge-selected-source-376-20261001 (104KiB)
after final source workers exited, process check found no preparation/test/profile
worker, canonical-path/no-symlink check and lsof showed no open scratch handle.
Absence verified afterward. Disposable fixtures/cache can be regenerated from
retained recipes. Lossless R0 gzip recoveries match every uncompressed digest;
source, original failures, diagnostics, durable PR history and scientific outputs
remain retained. No foreign worktree/cache or environment removal.

Current ordinary main and paired dependency delivery

Source checkpoint bbf2b78 normally merges
current main33701725f5b53874c1a18c0837d2c2bb2bb3b99e (including408/411/412).
The two issue376 production files and tests are unchanged from f1a713d.
Original dependency PR2 normally merges main34c3097ba449ba9501a5adb8d1e37a660652abaf
at dc65ebe41459c2a85f2c80d84d7e238500e613d1. Its src/tests are byte-identical
to22837a9. Published paired gitlink b27722bc71282ddd1ca1c5847208a72c800fe0b6
adds the dependency integration receipt to that tested source checkpoint.

53 focused checks pass,1deselected issue379,7.22s/344260KiB. New independent
declaration/callable plus cooperative before/after-C3 behavior remains included.
Original R0 unchanged tool3b03785f, Python3.14, source checksum recorded above:

• OpenHCS main33701725 -> bbf2b78:5177projections,zero positive,
  exit0,13.76s/86896KiB; only the two376production files differ.
• Dependency main34c3097 -> dc65ebe:31projections,zero positive,
  exit0,1.31s/44376KiB.

Exact serial commands, logs, resource receipts and lossless JSON are retained
as selected-discovery-evidence/integration-*. Each command uses original
read-only interpreter/dependency environment, CPU0/512MiB/no swap/60s.
Resource helper reports RAM13.1GiB, home7.2GiB, root7.7GiB, swap10.2GiB
(critical warning). No fleet or environment was created; tests remain serial.

PR409 was still OPEN at integration, not silently treated as merged. Dewey's
canonical lookup owner remains separate; ordinary merge after409 is the remaining
shared-file integration boundary. No379implementation or duplicate lookup added.
NRA review IMPL-3/4/12/13, MEMB-1/2 retains ancestor shared implementation,
minimal leaf hooks, original discovery/registration and meaningful C3 new cases.
Original failed controls and broader ABI limits above remain unchanged.

Cleanup: removed only verified task scratch
/home/ts/.cache/agent-scratch/knowledge-selected-integration-376-20261001,
356KiB, after all three workers exited, no matching preparation/source-test
process, no open lsof handles and canonical no-symlink path check. Durable
source/evidence remain. No package install or live runtime/science changes.

Final released409 seam integration

Normal merge of released main d0b4f5b
produces production checkpoint63e25ee7e6099ec20bceb1c29fe1a29716531339.
No conflict or manual production edits. OpenHCSRegistry retains the original
CustomFunctionCanonicalLookup import and declared MRO before LibraryRegistryBase;
matching super owns the remainder of canonical claims. Issue376 remains on
OpenHCSFunctionCatalogDeclaration / CellProfiler declaration hooks, unchanged.
The old pending409 boundary above is now closed by this ordinary merge.
No379takeover, new lookup roster, importer or compatibility mechanism.

Public dependency OpenHCSDev/metaclass-registry#2
head/gitlink b27722bc71282ddd1ca1c5847208a72c800fe0b6 (branch
fix/declaration-selected-discovery-376-20261001). Its src/tests are byte-identical
to R0-tested dc65ebe; final original dependency31projection zero-positive
evidence remains integration-dependency-r0.json.gz. No dependency source changed
during released409 integration. Parent's379source controls remain its own
reviewed predecessor, not a repeated or claimed local run here.

Final53focused source tests pass,7.10s/344084KiB;1canonical-custom witness
deselected, no replay of uncertain custom registration/input. Tests include
real imported callable identity, fail-closed discovery and cooperative independent
capabilities before/after the ancestor in real C3 order, with no consumer edits.
Original pinned R0 tool3b03785f/checksum above unchanged, Python3.14 owner:
main d0b4f5b -> production63e25ee7,5179projections,zero positive,exit0,
13.48s/86916KiB. Only two376production files differ against released main.
IMPL-3/4/12/13 and MEMB-1/2 review preserves both independent owner mechanisms.

Exact commands reuse integration-376-commands.sh: mode tests, then
r0-openhcs d0b4f5b, each under the declared
systemd512MiB/no-swap/oneCPU scope, tasksetCPU0 and timeout60s. Interpreter and
ABI environment remain read-only. post409-* logs, resources, lossless JSON and
POST409-SHA256SUMS retain this checkpoint separately from all original failures.
No installs/native/science/provider operations. Full NRA/R1 remains unqualified.

Regenerated the same owned disposable integration scratch for these two checks,
then removed only that exact path after terminal workers/no-open-handles/process
and canonical-path checks;356KiB released again. No source, failure evidence,
foreign worktree, private environment or parent live process changed.

Source installation and public publication boundary

Verified dependency b27722bc still declares version="0.2.1"; OpenHCS
pyproject.toml still requires "metaclass-registry>=0.2.1,<0.3". Therefore an
ordinary package-index installation can select old0.2.1 without discover_matching.
The published gitlink and PR2 do not update package-index artifacts or enforce
this new API minimum. Public normal-install delivery is not qualified here.

The parent-approved paired source/private-wheel route must explicitly build and
install the original dependency source b27722bc71282ddd1ca1c5847208a72c800fe0b6
alongside this OpenHCS checkpoint and retain wheel/import provenance. It must
not treat installing OpenHCS alone as selecting that dependency source. This
receipt does not execute that route or mutate the current live private environment.

Coordinated public-release followup: choose and commit a new dependency version
for this API; update the OpenHCS minimum to that actual version; publish the
dependency through the authorized registry release owner, then qualify a fresh
normal-resolver OpenHCS installation and affected user entrypoint. Publication
and installation remain parent integration/explicit authorization boundaries.
No version bump, package upload, registry publication or compatibility shim was
performed. Existing PR2 source/tests and its own WT remain preserved unchanged.

Actual merged dependency main

Public metaclass-registry PR2 is MERGED; remote and local main are
3294a69dabc9f99dd646c32571b8f97cc139d378. Normally fast-forwarded the owned
dependency WT from b27722bc to that merge head, preserving all source/history.
Final OpenHCS gitlink now records3294a69dabc9f99dd646c32571b8f97cc139d378,
not an unmerged/private dependency revision. Parent's source/private-wheel route
above can use this actual merged head; its source is identical to b27722bc.

Verified exact Git tree identities after integration:

• OpenHCS production63e25ee7 and final openhcs tree:
  81db5d4fb926a8e53b0dfcae52cd09f21b715b1e.
• OpenHCS production63e25ee7 and final tests tree:
  73f6a1b329b33d1a4fa79d8659f9dc6d11896c2b.
• Dependency original R0-tested dc65ebe and actual merged3294a69 src tree:
  70fed7cd3e231d211fe01b01d65d9c430c0d46cb.
• Dependency dc65ebe and3294a69 tests tree:
  b7db15a49f719ea053da31a39dcb62eaa313fb43.

Thus the scoped53source controls and final OpenHCS5179/dependency31 original
R0 zero-positive evidence remain exact for the merged production source; only
gitlink/provenance changed, no repeated tests or uncertain registration replay.
Released409cooperative MI/import remains intact. Public version still0.2.1 and
OpenHCS minimum>=0.2.1: coordinated publication/minimum followup remains open.
No private install, registry upload, native process or scientific run.

[trissim]

Singer / knowledge-boundary owner: parent now reports two fresh private installed373/383 dev_client help invocations (knowledge-document --help and tools --help), provider/native/plugin-free, taking9.215s combined. Approximate4.6s each is an inference, not separately measured import time. Please retain this as a related frontend cold-cost witness, not proof that selected conversion explains it.

I checked the original frontend path: module imports precede main; _build_parser iterates McpDevCommandSpec.all_specs and registers each declaration; parse_args exits for help before _run_async/server execution. PR358 owns exact-child readiness after connect/start and does not reduce this local help cost. Its source checkpoint and paired ZMQRuntime checkpoint remain unchanged; no timeout/readiness claim is a throughput fix.

Your376 diagnosis measured for_module -> LazyDiscoveryDict.values whole-family discovery during selected conversion. That may expose reusable declaration discovery ownership, but it has not been shown on the help path. Please distinguish cold module-import cost from parser/reflection cost when assessing whether the existing377 repair covers this pair. Avoid a mirrored help roster or copied catalogue. If the cost is on the parent-owned dev-client seam rather than your declared discovery seam, coordinate that crossing rather than extending files silently.

I am not editing your WT/catalogue or parent-owned command/core/rendering files and am not opening another PR. No new WT/env/install/profile fleet or native/MCP run was started. Parent retains runtime/installed acceptance; original R1 failure remains retained separately.

[trissim]

Schrodinger/PR358 source scope update: parent identified CPU0 runtime catalog startup calling RegistryService.prepare_in_current_process -> all metadata callables -> PreparationCacheBatch with hard-coded four child slots. I am tracing preparation batch affinity/resource admission and demand-owned kernel preparation in existing PR358, not editing your knowledge/discovery source. This is distinct from frontend help cost and issue385 viewer lifecycle. Please flag any active overlapping registry_service/function_catalog_preparation claim; selected discovery remains yours. No native/environment changes or live slot used.

[trissim]

Current ownership clarification is recorded on issue379: Singer has no unpublished/product379 repair; cabc6f1 is diagnostic-only and local/remote match. Parent-authorized Dewey may take the379 production seam after an explicit claim; Singer retains original379 failure evidence and376/377 knowledge-conversion diagnosis. No consumer registry mirror/stable-import workaround or uncertain registration replay is authorized.399/394 graph-sidecar work remains disjoint.

[trissim]

Schrodinger source ownership update, parent-authorized: take production follow-through for #376/#377 and remaining #379 seam in a NEW owned persistent WT, not Singer current #404 WT. Before application I will extend original nominal declaration discovery for selected CellProfiler conversion, retaining original diagnostic tests/archive and no new roster/cache/importer. Singer: please flag any newer discovery owner or #404 shared hunk. #379 has Dewey explicit claim 5940290078; I will not patch that seam until ownership disposition is confirmed; proceeding independently on #376. No startup/native/package installs or live slot; Dalton retains runtime. Bounded source-only 1CPU/512MiB/60s, original pinned R0, no full R1 replay.

[trissim]

Concrete #376 source seam before application: CellProfilerModule.for_module and for_backend_function_name force LazyDiscoveryDict.values -> all backend imports. Existing for_callable_import_identity already reads only registered declarations after exact import. I am testing extension of ORIGINAL LazyDiscoveryDict/discover_registry_classes selection mechanism (generic module-source eligibility hook), with CellProfilerModule owning exact declaration-key eligibility, then runtime registration remaining sole authority. No KnowledgeBaseService importer/roster/cache, filename-name guesses, or source authority mirror. If generic discovery has an active owner please flag. New WT openhcs-knowledge-declaration-source-376-20261001 normally merges diagnostic cabc6f1 and parent main e66500e; will publish normal FF back to existing PR377 branch, not modify Singer #404 checkout. #379 remains deferred to Dewey ownership disposition.

[trissim]

Parent clarified production scope: Schrodinger owns #376 declaration-local discovery ONLY. #379 func_registry/custom source hooks remain Dewey branch fix/canonical-custom-source-379-20261001 until explicit release. Original #379 red and diagnostic archive stay intact; no claim it is repaired. Current #376 prototype reused existing discovery loop and registered declaration owner, passes original no-global-discovery witness, but first measured source cost regressed; not shipping that cost. Batching selected keys in existing source_bindings_for_modules now avoids repeated source walks, without a new cache/roster. Actual installed acceptance remains parent/Dalton; no runtime/process changes.

[trissim]

Schrodinger source checkpoint published f1a713d (production49b46d59e), paired exact original metaclass-registry gitlink22837a912da2fba0cf2f562c31e0aeaab21ef29a / PR2 (productionf27ff1c). #376 only; #379 remains Dewey, #404 Singer WT untouched, no external394 metadata hunks. Existing ancestor owns batched eligibility and function-name lookup; CP small declaration projection remains hook, original discovery/import/registration owner reused. New independent declaration at arbitrary filename, literal/computed names, real callable identity and cooperative init_subclass before/after C3 pass without consumer edits. Original R0 zero-positive5176/31;53 focused pass and5 stronger overlapping new-case/admission pass. Original selected source profile returns10174chars,6.43s total/340944KiB (not installed timeout qualification). Source receipt retains old dependency collection error and4 subprocess ABI failures. Extra roundtrip experiment unexpectedly dispatched one prep-only --prepare-capabilities child, terminal returncode1 at missing source ABI before serving; PID not persisted, no replay. Failure retained, extra out-of-scope assertion removed, explicit preparation rejection added for retrieval; no roundtrip/native readiness claim. All23 checksums and5 lossless JSON recovery hashes verified. Only completed owned scratch104KiB removed. Parent owns serialized installed original10s knowledge retrieval; Dalton slot/packages untouched. No fullR1 retry, source detector copy, provider expenditure or CI wait.

[Copilot]

Copilot was unable to review this pull request because the user who requested the review has reached their quota limit.